Discussion Locked

Open Letter to President Bush Part 1

0 helpful
21 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

June 12, 2002

Dear President Bush:

I am writing to you to convey my deep concerns over the state of the American Information Technology worker of which I am one. I have two primary concerns:

1. Continuation of the American Competitiveness Workforce Act of 1998, that increased the number of immigrant worker visas to 195,000.

Mr. President, American Information Technology workers had to study hard and continue to study hard to keep their skills up to par with the rapidly changing pace of technology. Most of us have, in the name of company loyalty, worked long stressful hours in order to make production dates. And what do we get in return? Businesses and even State governments (Ohio and Indiana to name two) firing their American workers and hiring H1B visa holders who will work for a fraction of what their American counterpart was earning. The sponsors of these visas claim they cannot find the workers with the right skill set but this simply cannot be true in these numbers. American Information Technology workers find themselves unemployed in unprecedented numbers.

In January 2001, when the company I worked for closed its doors in Phoenix Arizona, I watched while more than twenty hard-working American citizenslost their jobs whilst H1B workers, many with the same skill set, remained employed in Scottsdale (they were placed under the Glendale California branch). Mr. President, I lost my entire 401K savings as a result of losing my job. It took me several months to find another position in Tucson and I lost 1/3 of my salary ($80,000 down to $50,000). I had to use my retirement savings to pay bills so that I could afford to work. I could not even afford to purchase health insurance for my wife through my new employer. I assure you that I am not the only American Information Technology worker who has found himself or herself in such a position.

21 replies

by talkingwall

Now I am hearing that many of my friends, people I care deeply about, are facing the same situation at Sallie Mae (formerly USA Group) in Fishers Indiana. I don't want them or any other hard working American Information Technology worker to have togo through what my family went through last year.

2. The incredibly rapid erosion of jobs and opportunities for this workforce as corporations, in an effort to reduce expenditure, move jobs to large offshore development centers in India, China, The Philippines, and Taiwan.

Regarding the flight of IT jobs offshore, there are many, many "entrepreneurs" who basically act as middle men to secure contracts from American businesses at service rates so low, no American worker can compete. These "entrepreneurs" then contract with offshore facilities to complete the work using workers who earn about $5.00 per hour. This is scandalous! How can we allow this to go on?

Mr. President, let me assure you, I am certainly not a racist or a xenophobe. In fact, my wife Ann is English and holds a green card. When I was a project leader at USA Group (now Sallie Mae) in Indianapolis, I had five Indian nationals on my team of twenty and I very much enjoyed learning about their culture, it wasenlightening. However, this is supposed to be the land of opportunity, but opportunity for whom? There simply must be some limits to what American business should be permitted to do in the name of free enterprise, capitalism, and free trade. In the name of almighty profit, we have lost our way and our integrity and sacrifice our fellow citizens to the god Mammon.

by talkingwall

I just finished reading your April 30, 2002 speech in San Jose California on Compassionate Conservatism. Your points, particularly on job creation are well made. I hear you. But do the people responsible for deciding who gets to work hear you? They are acting counter-productively to your call. I think curbing the abuses of H1B immigrant visas, lowering the number of visas issued back to 65,000 and some rules of conduct for moving work offshore would go a very long way toward answering your call for job creation. Please hear this plea and act from principle.

Sincerely and respectfully yours,

Mark A. Taylor

cc: Vice President Richard Cheney
US Senator Tom Daschle
US Senator Jim Kyl
US Senator John McCaine
US Department of Labor,Undersecretary for Policy
US Congressman Jim Kolbe

by nettek

I indeed hope that your letter was truly sent to those you stated.

Additionally, lets make sure that readers know the facts:
1. The Act you discuss had to be approved by the House and Senate.
2. It was Slick Willy (a.k.a., Bill Clinton) who signed the Act.
3. Section 412 of the Act has provisions stating that no company shall displace a U.S. worker of equal or better qualifications within 90 days prior to hiring, or 90 days after the hiring of, an H1B immigrant (although if you ask me, it should be at least a year).
4. Section 412 also states that a company MUST hire a U.S. worker over an H1B immigrant of equal or lesser qualifications should both apply for the same job (This is where it gets sticky. If they offer you 40k, and you want 80k, then it looks like you turned down the job.)

Be aware that if you are certain a company has violated #'s 3 and 4, you can contact the Attorney General and file a complaint.

by tape lady

Did you receive any response? Did you send this to USA Today/Larry King/ what's his name Ross- whatever that's going deaf! You are so much on target!

by road-dog

H1-B is a luxury that this nation cannot afford. If steel tariffs can be implemented to protect American steel companies, a tariff should be placed on H1-B labor. US firms should not be allowed to bring in cheap labor and undercut American workers.

My opinion is based purely on economics. The hiring of offshore labor hurts American workers hard hit by economic circumstance and acts to the detriment of companies who DO put Americans first.

We most certainly cannot address the lack of opportunities in other countries by recreating the problem here...

by http://stobie.home.sprynet.com/work/

The problem is bigger than this, many organizations view employees as commodities to be exchanged out to save a buck and not as valuable resources. They fall for the HR view that any two technical employees are equal if they can fill the same position.

by talkingwall

Yes, I agree. I used to hate the term "resources". However, let's attack the elephant one piece at a time. Non-immigrant workers and offshore is first up. It's time for the public to get informed and time for American IT to pull its collective heads out of the sand and start making some noise to our elected officials. It's time for our elected officials to put their actions where there words are. Stop talking about American job creation and start defending the damn jobs we have. Act NOW!Write your elected officials.

Mark

Mark

by a4u

I seem to remember these same arguments regarding auto worker jobs in what is now the "Rust Belt". Those areas of the country have never recovered. The same can happen to technology workers.
Keep Americans Working. Was the slogan then and shouldbe now.

by talkingwall

I have just purchased this domain. It will serve as a clearing house for the real facts about H1B and Offshore and provide links to get in touch with folks who can make a difference. I will announce the site when it's up and running. IN the meantime, write your congressman over and over again.

go to this link, type in your state and zip and then the text of your message.

http://www.house.gov/writerep/

by ghstinshll

Keep up the good work! I'm not sure that I saw it, but include a link to that "write your rep" site on there...

by javafox

I couldn't agree more on most points you make. However, please note that for the government to continue to interfere, such as telling businesses where they can do business is simply wrong. That is asking the government to legislate morality. The companies in this country ought to be appreciative enough, and I might add smart enough to know better than to take everyhting off-shore or hire those with H1Bs over americans. Likely as not, they and this country will learn the hard way. Nevertheless, stop and consider this... the steel industry fell victim, the textile industry too, and this country survived. My point is simply this, that those in power see this, not us as individuals. Therefore, their thinking will be, the country will survive this trend as well. Sure, I figure to lose my position where I work in IT while those from off-shore with H1B's continue to work here. Probably only a matter of time. Sure, write your congressman, I think we should, but that is another matter as to whether they really listen or not. What I'm saying is, in a nutshell, we see the small picture, our lives, the gang at the top do not. Don't kid yourselves. I agree, write, do what you can. I would be all for turning this thing around. But each companyacts on it's own best interest. We are not it's best interest, we are as employees a necessary evil. Best of luck to us all.

by djent

The only meaningful communication with a politition is VIA the ballot box, everything else is meaningless static unless you are a monied special interest.

by ahunter6

Since when did IT workers get to start sounding like norma rae? WE, all of US, ME included, as AMERICANS are a greedy group of wankers. Has it occured to you that the reason foreign workers get away with working so cheap is that LIFE is cheap over there? They can make 5 dollars an hour because lunch is thirty-five cents! We make more money that ANYBODY. So you can whine all you want about a 30k pay cut. Your still making 15k more than ME. I personally think IT is the best type of job in the universe and I'm not about to give it up or the money it brings in. Only in America can we be so far elevated and still whine we aren't high enough. Maybe if we got out of the SUVs and skipped a meal occasionally we would realize how good we have it.

by ahunter6

I've been homeless. It sucks. I've been unemployed. It sucks. When there was indeed a shortage of qualified IT people it was necessary to bring in the H1B people. There is no need for it now. That is correct. No argument there. But we all know that corporations exist for the single purpose of making money. Why are we surprised and hurt when they find a way to do that and then go for it?

My father was laid off more times than I can remember. And it hurt the entire family everytime. I wouldn't EVER want to see that happen to my kids. But it is a fundamental fact of the American way of life that we want MORE. And we don't care how we get it. So why are people demanding that government step in and regulate the greed of companies? If George Bush suddenly told us " My Fellow Americans, you must take immediate pay cuts to bring our country in line with the rest of the world.", we'd have another revolution! Just think for a minute the next time you negotiate a price for your new Ford explorer-you're trying to get the most stuff for the least price. Power steering=innovative app. Where is the critical difference in getting free AC in the car for the same price and Hiring Mr. Patel to bang out some code. There is none. It becomes personal and suddenly the government has to do SOMETHING. Wrong. Wrong wrong wrong.

by jamil_lababidi

i dont quite see where you're coming from, dude.. i think you should stop and look at what's happening to the IT industry - i'm sure you know how it feels to lose your job, as you've been homeless and unemployed.. now what you need to look at, is why you've ended up there.. it's because of the insane increase of H1B visa holders - from 65k to 195k.. it's because of american corporations taking the quicker and easier dollar, which is hurting honest, hard working americans.. yea, corporationsare trying to get the most money out of their time, but there's a line..

by jamil_lababidi

the line is:

we did have a shortage of IT professionals, so we let foreign workers come in on H1B visas to help out.. now that we have an abundant force of IT professionals, some of those foreign workers need to be declined and the number of available H1B visas lowered.. it's not all about the money, it's about having a job.. i hear you when you say that people shouldn't be whining about wanting more money, but i think you should listen to the people who are complaining about not having a job at all!! about people being cut off a companies pay roll for some H1B visa to do their same job for a fraction of the cost..

by jamil_lababidi

thats why there's homeless people out there.. thats why there's unemployed people out there.. much like you used to know, but we can stop that.. we can stop people just like yourself, from losing their jobs to foreign workers.. i agree that there should be a total percentage of foreign workers allowed, not just the IT industry, but every industry.. thus providing more opportunity for the hard working american..

now that i've ranted, i hope you see some light from my views.. it's not about the money, it's about the principle.. dont f*ck us honest americans for a few extra dollars!!!!

by danarothrock

http://www.informationweek.com/story/IWK20020201S0017

Legislators Voice Concerns About H-1B Visas Feb. 4, 2002

By Diane Rezendes Khirallah

When Congress voted a year and a half ago on a bill sponsored by Sen. Orrin Hatch, R-Utah, to increase the number of H-1B visa workers allowed into this country, the IT job market was very different than it is today. The dot-com boom was in full swing, and there seemed to be a severe shortage of technology talent. That helps explain why the Senate voted nearly unanimously--96 to 1--to approve the bill.

Some members of Congress, however, are still unhappy at how the bill was slipped through the House of Representatives late at night, with little debate. Reps. Eva Clayton, D-N.C., and Thomas Tancredo, R-Colo., are two who objected to the process. They say the bill was sent to the House late on the same day it passed the Senate and not all members of the House knew a vote was coming. As they recall, the proposed legislation was presented three hours after legislators were told they could go home for the day. It was passed by a voice vote.

by generalist

Actually, the H1Bs are not just on the IT side of things. But that appears to be where the biggest demand has been.

This discussion is closed to new replies.