Discussion Locked

Pelosi and her choice for leadership roles

0 helpful
34 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Ok, the Democrats won the election and I have no issue with this. With the winning of this election come certain perks. Leadership roles. Nancy Pelosi has been chosen as the leader of the house, and is now filling various leadership positions.

Now, wasn't one of the things that the Democrats ran on was cleaning up Washington? Get the corrupt Republicans out of office? And yes, I agree there was too many corrupt Republicans. But, look at this lady's choice to fill two major leadership positions:

[url]http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/15026624/[/url]

[b]Majority leader: John Murtha of Pennsylvania[/b]
[i]Yet Murtha could prove to be a problematic candidate because of his penchant for trading votes for pork projects and his ties to the Abscam bribery sting in 1980, the only lawmaker involved who wasn?t charged.[/i] Ok, he wasn't charged. Agreed. But....
[i]FBI agents pretending to represent an Arab sheik wanting to reside in the United States and seeking investment opportunities offered bribes to several lawmakers. [b]When offered $50,000, Murtha was recorded as saying, [u]?I?m not interested ... at this point.?[/u][/b] A grand jury declined to indict Murtha, and the House ethics committee issued no findings against him[/i]
Sorry, not interested at this point does not give me a lot of confidence in his honesty.

[url]http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/15741999/[/url]
Next choice Of Ms. Pelosi that I have issue with.
[b]Head the House Select Committee on Intelligence[/b]Rep. Alcee Hastings
[i]Hastings is also one of fewer than a dozen federal judges in U.S. history to be removed from office by the Senate in an impeachment trial. He was a federal judge appointed in 1979 by President Carter.

In 1989 the Democratic-majority House impeached him and the Democratic-majority Senate tried him on charges of conspiring to extract a bribe from two drug dealers in exchange for reducing their sentences. The Senate voted to remove him from the bench.[/i] The democrats themselves impeached and removed this person from office. FOR TAKING A FREAKEN BRIBE, and she wants this person to be the head of the inteligence committie?

Look, who cares what party would be making these choices. These are bad choices. They send completely the wrong message when Americans are fed up with corruption. And yes, the republicans caused this. But this lady is showing no, none, completely nada common sence in her choices.

By the way, I think the Republicans are doing the same stupid thing with their choice of Lott for minority leadership. His racist remarks speak volumes.

Dan

[b]Edited because{/b] I had the wrong replubican listed. It's lott who they want, not Delay as I had previously posted.

34 replies

by maxwell edison

Enlighten us, please. I'm pretty well informed, but I don't know what racist remarks of Lott's you're referring to. What did he say and when did he say it?

By the way, your message speaks volumes as to the merits of voting party over person -- regardless of your party of preference. And to those who claim to have no party of preference, they are also saying, by default, that they have no preference as to which party rules the House or the Senate. It's gotta' be one or the other; and if you don't vote party, you have no say in the matter (at least no "direct" say).

by danlm

It was at the birthday party of a southern politician on something like his 9?th birthday. This politician had advocated segregation. Watch me be wrong on this, and have Delay mixed up with Lott. But, during the birthday party the comment was that we would not be having these problems today if we would have followed the birthday persons policies. Let me look this up, and Ill post it for you. Unfortionally, I'm at work and between things.

And with regards to what I just posted. I wanted to go independent along time ago because I didn't like either party, but I found that to help someone in the primaries. At least where I lived at the time, I needed to be registered with a major party. I ended up being registered Democrat for that reason.

Dan

by maxwell edison

...because Trent Lott made no such "racist remarks", but the Democrats and the press made them out to be.

At a birthday party for Strom Thurmond, Trent Lott, in a good-humored way to say nice things to a colleague, said something to the effect that the country would be better-off had Thurmond won the presidential election of 1948. It was an off-the-cuff comment, and one that was totally meaningless except to make an old man at the end of his career feel good. The "racist" connection is because Strom Thurmond was a segregationist in 1948 -- just like Robert Byrd, another U.S. Senator (except one of the Democrat flavor), was a card-carrying member of the KKK.

Things like this show the disingenuous nature of the Democrats trying to demonize Republicans -- and how the main-stream press is an accomplice. What would they do if Robert Byrd was a Republican, and why don't they do it to him as a Democrat?

But for anyone to call Lott's comments "racist", it shows they're either misinformed, silly, or partisan. Which one were you? Or do you REALLY think those comments were "racist"?

by danlm

[i]WASHINGTON (CNN) -- Incoming Senate Majority Leader Trent Lott issued a written apology Monday evening over his comment that the United States would have avoided "all these problems" if then-segregationist Strom Thurmond had been elected president in 1948. [/i]

And here is the link to a story about it: [url]http://archives.cnn.com/2002/ALLPOLITICS/12/09/lott.comment/[/url]

That is what I was talking about Maxx.

Dan

by jamesrl

I think the subtle part of this is that Thurmond broke away in 1948 to form his own party specifically to campaign on the issue of segregation. And I expect to someone like Lott to know that. So either Lott was racist or he was stupid not to understand how his remarks could and would be understood.

I'd actually look at more of Lott's history before I called him a racist, since in my opinion there are two ways to interpret his remarks. Are there people I would call racist based on one comment - depends on the comment. I don't need to study much on David Duke to know what he is. We had a native leader in Canada who was tried for hate crimes for suggesting Hitler - I could tell by the clarity of his speech that he was racist.

George Wallace was certainly a racist at one point in his career, but became a better man.

I know Byrd has certainly sincerely apoligised and recognized the error of his ways.

Even Strom Thurmond softened his stance over the course of time.

So would I judge Lott based on one questionable comment? I would dig further.

James

by maxwell edison

Agree with me or not, I believe that anyone who doesn't consider the context of Lott's comment is looking for something that just isn't there. At worst, the only thing Lott could be criticized for is not thinking about how other people might be able to construe and twist a comment before he says it. It was a totally innocent attempt to say something nice about -- and to -- an old man. No more, no less. It was not a window into Lott's view on race.

I will say this, however, Lott was a spineless coward for apologizing to the idiots who were race-baiting him in the first place. (Gee, guess what they really WANTED you to do, Trent -- you IDIOT! You played right into their hands -- AS USUAL!)

It was yet another case where the accuser(s) should have been called to task for being disingenuous, political opportunists looking for yet another excuse to demonize someone for nothing. I would have told them that they should be ashamed of themselves for suggesting such a ludicrous and insulting thing, and I would demand an apology from the idiot Democrats who levied such a stupid accusation in the first place. If there's one thing the Republicans in Congress need it's a friggin' spine. (I would never make it in Washington! Too outspoken!)

Trent Lott may have proved he's an idiot, but not that he's a racist.

You and Dan are both way off on this one. (But neither of you will say something like, "Gee, I never looked at it that way. Maybe you're right." That kind of thing just doesn't happen around here.)

by jamesrl

We agree substantively, but you chose to throw me in the same bucket as Dan. I said I wouldn't judge on one statement. I would give him the benefit of the doubt, but I would look further.

You know you are right, you wouldn't make it in Washington. You can be outspoken, but if you are outspoken all the time, you lose credibility.

James

by danlm

Joking or otherwise.

I know you may disagree, but that's ok. Shoot Max, you've seen enough of my posts to know that I do appreciate alot of the Republican policies. But those remarks were totally inappropriate. Jest or otherwise.

I have met too many people of different ethnic/racial backgrounds that I have a lot of respect for to appreciate that remark in any way.

Dan

by danlm

Max, I do agree with what you said. But it's a simple matter that I personally do not like racial comments like that. I consider them offensive. Has nothing to do with my politics, has everything to do what I personally find offensive.

Dan

by maxwell edison

Geesh, how many times does that have to be repeated before it sinks in?

Repeat after me, there were no racial comments.....

there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....
there were no racial comments.....

And people actually believe that the main-stream press can't create an issue and create the appearance of truth from an absolute lie.

Believe what you want, dude.

by maxwell edison

...that you were giving Lott the benefit of the doubt. And the way I read it, you didn't even suggest it.

You did start by saying you were on the fence, but the whole discussion started by someone who claimed that Lott made a racist remark. Unless you question my "reporting" of the incident, or unless you can't do a two second search for the full text and context, one can CLEARLY see that there was nothing racist about it. If you're "on the fence", you just lack the gumption to just call em' like you see em'.

Was that ONE REMARK a racist one or not? It's a pretty simply question to me? And it's the only one on the table.

And it seems to me that one's "credibility" will lie (or should lie) in the consistency of his comments, not how well he plays the political game. Too many people, in my opinion, are afraid to just speak their minds. It would be a refreshing change, if you ask me.

by jamesrl

"I'd actually look at more of Lott's history before I called him a racist, since in my opinion there are two ways to interpret his remarks"

"So would I judge Lott based on one questionable comment? I would dig further."

Read those statements from that post. Is that the benefit of the doubt or not? If you don't see it plainly, then I am at a loss on how to explain it to you.

As to consistency and outspokenness, I see it a little differently. I think you can be entirely consistent on an issue, say abortion, but chose not to emphasize it until the issue arises. Why? Because within the term of any politician there is only so many days and so much time to devote to change. And you should focus on winning the battles you can instead of tilting at windmills. Thats not being afraid to be outspoken - thats choosing to be not outspoken on every topic all the time.

It may not be right, it may not be fair, but those who happen to be outspoken on everything are seen as ideologues. And I know as well as you the appropriate Barry Goldwater quote. But I would remind you he never became president. And also to be fair, I see it the same way for the right and the left. I am just as opposed to the Dems acting that way, as I would be to a right winger.

I heard a project manager today from a business that I respect tell me they tried to work on 6 projects at once last year, and none of them completed. He decided to focus on one and fast track it to make it happen and he is getting results. Thats similar to how I see the "outspokenness".

Am I a political pragmatist? Yes. That doesn't mean I am afraid to speak my mind , I sometimes chose not to. I often don't reply to some of your posts because I know I won't change your mind or you change mind. I am entirely consistent, but not always outspoken. You may think that a political game. You and I would disagree.

James

by maxwell edison

First, Lott's comments. (Context: The 100th birthday party of a tired old man who was retiring from the Senate)

"I want to say this about my state: When Strom Thurmond ran for president, we voted for him. We're proud of it. And if the rest of the country had followed our lead, we wouldn't have had all these problems over all these years, either."

-- The idiot, Trent Lott

Is that stupid? Absolutely it's stupid. Is it racist? Only if you're a partisan or a race-baiter -- or both (which is usually the case).

However, how about this one? Is this racist?

"You think The Republican National Committee could get this many people of color in a single room? Only if they had the hotel staff in here."

-- Guess who? (You probably never heard this reported in the main-stream press. I wonder why?)

How about this editorial cartoon?

[i][b]Sent to inner-city racial re-education camp[/b] You're not white, stupid ..... Now hand over your hair straightener ..... I was Bush's beard! His house nigga[/i]

http://www.gocomics.com/rallcom/2004/07/05/

Where was the main-stream outrage at this?

Or how about this?

http://www.makethemaccountable.org/archives/041118/racist_treatment.htm

Or can Harry Belafonte be considered a racist when he called former Secretary of State Colin Powell a [i]"plantation slave"[/i], or Condeleeza Rice [i]"Aunt Jemima -- the old one who wore a scarf instead of pearls"[/i], or Justice Clarence Thomas an [i]"Uncle Tom"[/i]?

The problem with throwing around the "racist charge" so incorrectly, is that it waters down REAL racism. And in the case of Trent Lott, it's 100 percent politics of personal destruction, and 0 percent racism.

by maxwell edison

I would call giving a person the benefit of the doubt when one considers that person innocent until proven guilty. The tone of your message, as well as the content, seems to judge him guilty until your research might show him to be innocent. I believe there's a big difference.

You said you can take the comment two ways. Well, which do you choose to take it? My way -- being nice to a tired old man -- or Dan's way -- flaming racism? (Okay, I took some editorial liberty with the "flaming" part.)

by jamesrl

Was that I would NOT judge him based on that one statement alone.

LET ME SPELL IT OUT. I would require more evidence before considering him a racist. I thought thats what I said. Could I be more clear?

James

by maxwell edison

You said, [i]"Was that I would NOT judge him based on that one statement alone. LET ME SPELL IT OUT. I would require more evidence before considering him a racist. I thought that's what I said. Could I be more clear?"[/i]

That's pretty clear to me. You need "more evidence" before you call him a racist. I, on the other hand, won't even consider the possibility that he's a racist unless you can provide some evidence.

I'm too used to these "false charges" being levied against people, and it's up to them to prove otherwise. It's a disingenuous ploy used by the left-wing in America, and it makes me sick. And when people buy into it, it actually makes me question their intelligence.

By the way, when did you stop beating your wife? Go ahead, prove that you never did in the first place. In the meantime, I'll give you "the benefit of the doubt". Yea, right. The damage has already been done.

My point, James, is that the charge should NEVER HAVE BEEN SUGGESTED IN THE FIRST PLACE!

Can't I be more clear? Don't you see the distinction? No, of course you don't.

P.S. James, you come across as though you want to be "open minded" and "above it all". (Excuse me while I gag.) Take a stand, man! When you see crap being spewed, call it crap!

by maxwell edison

...really piss me off. And maybe James is right, he IS pissing me off -- because he's (apparently) one of them. I can't stand Trent Lott, but I would never call him a racist without cause.

As a side-note, people like Jesse Jackson are the racists of today.

by danlm

Max, I watched the clip of the birthday party.

I considered them racial because he was saying (jest or not) that we wouldn't have had the issues we have today if we followed old what's his faces polices. I watched the clip, I considered them racial.

My opinion was from watching him say the words, not reading about what words he said.

Dan

[i]Edited because[/i] I can't beleive I have to defend feeling a person was offensive in remarks he made. Who gives a sh*t what party he is from. No sh*t. And as far as the rest of the remarks you posted, they are as bad or worse. Again, wgaf who said it. It's offensive.

by danlm

I don't care what party the person is from.

He offended me.

I don't care if he is white, black, freaken hispantic, or cuban.

He offended me.

I don't care who says crap like that.

It's offensive.

Do i have to clarify any further?

Talk about pissing people off Max. Your putting words in my mouth. It's simple as that. You are reading WHAT you want to, and not looking at anything else I am saying.

And Max, no chit. Just because you don't find it offensive doesn't mean it isn't. Who made you flippen god to tell people how to feel about subjects such as that. I considered it racist. Don't like it, tough chit. I considered your examples as racist too.

Christ, the whole post was about the gd fkn crooks being put in power positions by both parties. I didn't call Lott a crook, just a fkn racist with his remarks. Or down right stupid for saying them, which again shows his LACK OF judgment in either case.

Dan

by maxwell edison

No, that distinction should go to the people who levied the "racist" charge in the first place, because if you saw Lott's comments isolated from any such a silly charge, you wouldn't have been offended in the least. The "racist" charge would have never crossed your mind.

by tonythetiger

who exactly is offending you? Is it the person who made the comment (were you actually there?)? or is it the people who played it over and over again, adding their own interpretation and context to it, [b]knowing damned good and well[/b] it would be seen as inflamatory?

by maxwell edison

Why am I going on about this with such vigor? Because I detest racism and I detest racists. I know about it all too well by growing up in a mid-western city right smack-dab in the middle of the race riots of 1968. I've seen it; I've experienced it; and I know what the hell it is! (And they come in all colors, by the way.)

And to play the "racist card" for pure political expediency (which is what this Lott episode really is) is not only disingenuous and dishonest, but it waters down what it really is and what it really means to be a "racist".

My guess is that you and I might have a different definition of the word "racist". In my estimation, it's one of the worst forms of human behavior. And to me, applying it so nonchalantly when and where it's not deserved is disgusting -- perhaps MORE disgusting than racism itself.

by danlm

My definition comes from my brother being the only white person(director) in an all black center.

When my mother ended up having almhizer. Everyone, well most everyone who my brother had contact with in this job came and helped my family. Not because he asked them, but because they were just good people. I've never forgotten that and that has shaped how I feel about a lot of things.

But your right Max about this being put into my head. If I would have seen that conversation on TV with no mention of the reference racism. I probably would not have thought what I do.

Dan

by maxwell edison

....how the "news" can actually change or form people's minds on things. It's equally amazing how many people can't see the obvious bias in the news. This Trent Lott flap is only one example.

They (Democrats and the main-stream media) hammered home a message so relentlessly and for so long, that people are calling Trent Lott a racist because of something as innocent as being nice to a tired and dying old man. All the while, all those other examples of REAL bigotry and REAL racism barely receive mention. We sure hear all about the Muslims being "offended" by an editorial cartoon (one that's pretty damn true, by the way), but they (the press) apparently give a free pass to the extremely offensive cartoons depicting Condoleezza Rice in a demeaning and racist manner. And where is the main-stream media hammering home Howard Dean's obvious racial stereotype, and where are the demands for an apology appearing? Trent Lott made the front page of the New York Times for a manufactured story, but Howard Dean didn't for a real one. Why is that?

I've maintained for years the obvious bias in the main-stream press and its obvious preference for all things left-wing, and its obvious distaste for all things right-wing. This Trent Lott flap proves my point. A case where a guy was just being nice to a tired and dying old man was turned into a "racist" by Democrats and their accomplices in the main-stream press. Anyone who can't see it is living in a fog. And anyone who is fooled by it deserves "the link".

by tonythetiger

I agree with the bias, but I don't think it is because the press is liberal per se, they just want their business to boom, and of course, everybody knows that bad news sells, so it stands to reason that the best chance for them to have more bad news (thus more business) is to support the liberals!

by jamesrl

The press has an interest in driving up viewership/subscribers etc. The more media consumers they have, the more they can charge for advertising.

Thus the media has fewer inhibitions about what they publish and how close they are to the truth.

Are there publications with a left leaning? Yes. Are there right wing leaning media? Yes. Is tha majority one or the other?

I would suggest that during the Clinton era, they were all over the Lewinski story, Whitewater and many other stories not because they were right wing, but because it would sell.

James

by maxwell edison

...the usual and overused "bad news sells" notion. "Bad news", per se, could just as easily been generated from raking Howard Dean over the coals for his blatant and objectionable racial stereotyping, just as it was obviously generated by raking Trent Lott over the same coals -- and only because he was being nice to a sad, pathetic, dying, old man. Geesh, instead of getting a "Being Nice Merit Badge", he was accused of being racist! How stupid -- and politically biased -- is that? (By the way, there really isn't a Being Nice Merit Badge.)

Moreover, where was the "bad news" about Harry Reid, (D) Nevada, and his pocketing millions of dollars in questionable real estate deals? Where was the "bad news" about John Murtha (D) Pennsylvania, and his involvement in influence peddling? They sure focused on Tom DeLay (R) Texas, but similar charges -- and perhaps more substantiated charges -- concerning Murtha were never discussed in the main-stream press. John Murtha is one of the most corrupt politicians in Washington! Not only has Murtha's corruption been ignored, but he's been put on a pedestal as a friggin' war hero! Why is that?

What's not reported is oftentimes just as revealing -- or MORE revealing -- than what is reported.

And James, you are correct in your observations about Bill Clinton with the Whitewater and the Monica Lewenski stories, as it was certainly in the news day after day. But in most of the "main-stream" press, it was reported with more emphasis on the "Republican witch hunt" that was taking place than the seriousness of the charges. And speaking of what was NOT reported, does the name Juanita Broderick mean anything to you? She was actually the "smoking gun" that not only would have forced Democrats in the Senate to vote in favor of removing President Clinton from office, but could have possibly landed him in jail. (On second thought, Al Gore would have surely pardoned him.)

By the way, James, I think Tony was writing with his tongue firmly planted in his cheek when he said [i]"bad news sells ..... so ..... the best chance for them to have more bad news is to support the liberals."[/i]

by av .

But honestly, I think he is too polarizing a figure to be House Majority Leader and the public is tired of leaders like that. John Murtha would overshadow the Democratic Congress with his views on Iraq.

Everyone wants to get out of Iraq, but that isn't the only problem we face as a nation. I don't think John Murtha is dishonest, despite what he did, but I don't think he is openminded and receptive either.

Honestly, I don't know enough about Steny Hoyer, the newly elected House Majority Leader to even have an opinion on him. Alcee Hastings? Not a good choice at all after reading your article.

In the end, Speaker Pelosi didn't get what she wanted. Thats a good thing. I'm not sure what happened with Alcee Hastings.

I think the bottom line is that whether its a Republican or Democrat, our government is full of ethically-challenged politicians.

Just a word about Trent Lott and his remarks about Strom Thurmond. I think he was just paying tribute to a very old man at his 100th birthday party and he should never have been asked to step down because of it. I don't think Trent Lott meant any of his comments to be racial in any way. It was very overblown and unfair.

I think Nancy Pelosi seems committed to making it all work regardless of the fact that she didn't get her way. We'll see, won't we?

by draack

With all due respect, AmericanVoter, you may not "think John Murtha's dishonest, no matter what he did", but just because he didn't take the bribe in the Abscam incident doesn't mean he's innocent. If you've heard any of the tape, he didn't remove the possibility of taking the money at a later date. In fact, the only reason he wasn't prosecuted that decided to turn state's evidence in order to avoid prosecution.

That said, no, it appears he didn't take the money ... but a person who's put himself *so* close to crossing the ethical line on multiple occasions has questionable ethics to start with ... and a reasonable person could make the reasonable deduction that he's probably crossed it a time or two without getting caught.

Someone who puts her trust in people with such ethics problems (including the first federal judge to be impeached ... *with* an affirmative vote for said impeachment by Ms. Pelosi herself) is not someone whose judgement I'd trust as being the best for our country. I think it's safe to figure that the best interest that she's out for is her own.

She "fights" for the rights of migrant and union workers but refuses to employ migrant or union workers in her vineyard, not to mention the rest of her businesses.

I think it's prudent to recognize that Ms. Pelosi does what she does purely for political gain, and that's that.

by tonythetiger

...so it stands to reason that the best chance for them to have [b]more[/b] bad news (thus more business) is to support the [b]liberals![/b]

by delbertpgh

Strom got good and fed up in 1948 with Harry Truman integrating the Army, and other things in the name of civil rights, and ran for President in the cause of states' rights. "States' rights" was the supposed entitlement of Southern law to systematically separate whites and blacks, in the name of preserving a traditional and dignified way of life. Traditions, of course, were protected at the expense of blacks. We today call that a racist policy.

Trent said at Strom's testimonial that if more people had voted for him, we wouldn't have had a lot of these problems. I don't know what problems he was referring to; the most obvious would be riots and school busing and demonstrations, and all the other mess that happened as this nation sloughed off the remains of slavery.

A decent man could regret some things about history, or say edgy things to be kind to an old man, but the way Trent put it, it sounded like he wasn't so sure that the retreat from segregation was worth the costs. Trent's a smart fellow. Maybe he knew how it would sound, and figured that it would make him more popular with parts of the Republican base.

Or, maybe he just didn't realize or didn't care what it implied, in which case he was just stupid.

This discussion is closed to new replies.