Discussion Locked

Person in dorm hall displaying personal information

0 helpful
79 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Ok so the other day I was browsing through shared folders on my university's network looking for music when I came to a shared .pdf document on someone's computer that showed all their personal information (Name, DOB, Social Security Number, residence ect...) I don't have any kind of superuser access to the network so this document is availiable to anyone to see and access. How do I tell this person that they are sharing files they shouldn't be? I don't want them to think that I hacked into their computer because I didn't and I would never exploit someone's personal information.
Thanks for any ideas,
Ac

79 replies

by marileev9

It sounds like their machine may be completely networked when it shouldn't or they forgot to disable their connection to the network.

Having ALL that personal information on a PDF or word doc is bad, bad, bad.

I'd tell them in person right away. Maybe they have a new machine and don't really know all the bells & whistles on it. Also tell your Campus network administrator.

How old is the document? This'll determine how many other people might be able to see their folder with this PDF. Also they should run a credit check.

All sorts of things can go amuck http://www.essentialsecurity.com/news.htm?id=44

by nicknielsen

I've saved the link so I can provide it to some friends who don't understand my convoluted explanations.

Edit: 1st one today!

by nicknielsen

Do not pass Go!, do not collect...

To emphasize your point, print the document, making sure to print it locally and be there when it comes off the printer! Hand them the printout. If he/she quibbles, take them to your PC and show them the document.

Marilee has already provided all the reasons you need to do this.

by techexec2

The truth will set you free. Just tell them. If this file is openly visible on the university's network, why are you concerned about being accused of hacking?

Tip: If you don't want to be thought of as a hacker, don't choose "acracker" as your alias on TR! :^0

by old guy

TE2, The other day I made a comment to you about having changed. The more I thought about it I think I was mistaking you for someone else. I think the other person may have used Techmail or something like that. Sorry to confuse the two of you.

by tig2

Old Guy, I think that you WERE thinking of TechMail. And TechMail, to his credit, has contributed very positively after a rocky start.

TechExec is one of the good ones too... but you know that. He may get his duckie back...

Sorry to pipe up- saw the note yesterday and thought that you might have the two of them mixed.

by techexec2

No problem, Old Guy.

Looks like you and Mae have something in common! :^0 :^0 :^0

P.S. If you don't get this let me know and I'll explain.

by tig2

And let them know. If the doc is shared, you may want to help the person out by showing them how to remove the share.

You may also want to alert the Network Admin. It may be that the school should send an advisory to students letting them know to be careful of their personal data.

Good catch!

by techexec2

This is utter nonsense by a bunch of (very) grown adults. Tigger started a nonsense thread (1) over the weekend for some fun. The objective was to get "revenge" on JDCYLDE for calling MAECUF an "old woman". I also got into this and called Mae "senile" at one point in a related thread (2) (there was a good reason for this).

So, that is what you and Mae have in common (this "old" "senility" thing). Strictly a joke of course! :-)

REFERENCES

(1) Lighthearted fun (fantastic utter nonsense)
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=201010&start=0

(2) Here's where Mae is "senile" and it really heats up for me
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=201011&messageID=2095365

by old guy

I've worked hard to get this old and I'll have you know, umm, who are you again? Oh, yeah, TE2--see nothing wrong with my, uh, my uh, oh, mind! I'll tell you like I tell my son, you keep talking like this and you won't get any older!!!

Just a word of advice...you can call me old but I would definitly run and hide if you said that about Mae. She skeers me, ya know. :_|

:^0 :^0

by maecuff

I'm not scary. Not at all. How many times do I have to say this? I'm NICE, dammit!!

by now left tr

Sorry but I doubt that a user has created a PDF containing all their personal information, created a share, put the PDF here and then joined a Domain or Workgroup (not in that order perhaps). The share hand gives the game away on Windows; the user would need to create the doc in word and then Adobe the PDF. Highly unlikely!

Sound much like a Honey Trap or a Project (what if)!!!!!!

by nicknielsen

Reference list created in OpenOffice, default "Save As" is pdf, default location at the time the student's network share.

And you would not [u]believe[/u] the number of times I have been asked "How can I tell if something on my computer is shared?"

by tgaudet

You never know...... the person may not be familiar with computers, sharing and networks. I know dozens of people like that that work on computers everyday. They have no idea what they are doing past "click this icon to start working".

by old guy

after TE2's comment below I don't know if I want to mix the two..."thought that you might have the two of them mixed" mixing them up was bad enough. Mixing them together would be insufferable! :^0 .

by tig2

A case of mistaken identity is all. Figured it out and decided that both of you (you and TechExec2) are nice guys.

:)

by why me worry?

Whomever decided to use Social Security numbers as student IDs' in colleges instead of some random numbers is a complete dumbass and should have his/her identity stolen. What's even worst is when social security numbers and grades are posted on some bulletin board in a hallway, only to find out who it belongs to because they will run their finger over it when checking grades. It's an ID thief's paradise because it is right there to be taken advantage of. Unfortenately, some people, like this fellow with the pdf file, will end up learning the hard way when his/her credit is destroyed because some ID thief decided to go on a shopping spree. I'd tell the person immediately, but don't do it in such a way that you condescend or insult them. Some people will quickly learn and teach others about security, which is what we IT guys all want..

by marileev9

WhyMeWorry?, your point completely jives with the Gov. release CNET published yesterday http://news.com.com/U.S.+urged+to+keep+lid+on+Social+Security+numbers/2100-7348_3-6117423.html

The U.S. Government is encouraging agencies to move away from using SS#s too. Guess the word needs to trickle down to Universities too http://www.iwantmyess.com/?p=68

Here are some notable Univ. ID thefts:

*March 2006 UC Berkeley personal information on 98,000 graduate students and applicants stolen

*2001 to 2003 Deborah Jenkin (an employee) of University of Hawaii took 150,000 IDs from the school's system

*April 2006, 1,400 Univ. of South Carolina students IDs were mistakenly emailed to classmates

by storch

I always was extremely uncomfortable about my school using my SS# as ID. I should have insisted that they assign me a random number instead.

I went to a new (local) movie rental business and they wanted me to fill out a customer card that included my SS#. I refused and they refused to rent movies to me. Needless to say I never returned. What's scary is that all the other customers were "compliant". I am hoping that the general public is starting to learn about identity theft and act accordingly. But I wonder. It still seems like folks are way too willing to give out all their personal info to almost anyone who asks. I felt like standing outside the door of the rental store to warn people off. But I am a quiet, introverted person and I certainly didn't want the store to call the cops on me.

by too old for it

You might as well post your info on a billboard at the corner of Walk and Don't Walk as give it to some of these people.

by acracker

I told them about their sharing problem and they were happy I did. They took that file off the network so it cannot be found by anyone. They had no idea they were sharing it and to prevent this from happening with other students I will alert the admin to this problem. Thanks for the help!
-Ac

by why me worry?

And Microsoft is harping about their secure computing initiative?

That File & Printer sharing service should be removed by MS as a default setting when TCP/IP is installed

Also, disable Netbios over TCP on the laptop to prevent your machine from being found by the computer browser service

by tony hopkinson

You can't install MSDE without it enabled for instance. Gives you a fatal error and rolls back the entire installation.
If you find one stupid interdependancy in MS stuff there's bound to be ten more.

by marileev9

Terrrrriffic - your schools computing department might also want to do a seminar on ID theft too. This was just one person on the network. I went to the University of Washington & 15,000+ incoming freshmen each year green to the world of networking there are bound to be mulitple oopses like this.

Just some basic user education that students could benefit from.

by tig2

Marilee, I read most of what you post- I agree, security is not taken seiously enough by many people.

I would be interested in your thoughts regarding unsecured WiFi "hot-spots"; a discussion begun by WhyMeWorry in this thread. I will go fetch a link...

Edit to add link: http://tinyurl.com/jfm3s

by marileev9

I'm no angel when I was at school I used to catch hot spots more frequently on my Mac - using the "poor college student" excuse.

There are also WiFi enable spots free in the City of Seattle, like at the Seattle Center and if you're in Spokane, WA nearly the entire city is wired for wireless.

Again, I think this is one of those education issues. Why shouldn't I take all my tech toys as seriously as another? If you don't secure your WiFi, you're just leaving the door open for someone to steal what you pay for. Though now that I'm a desk-monkey, at home I try and not have my laptop anywhere else by my desk workstation it stays plugged-in.

It's getting so cheap now to connect, why steal? http://www.techknowbizzle.com/2006/07/tullys-coffee-shop-to-offer-free.html

by why me worry?

I recall going to a clothing store to get a garment and the sales clerk had asked me for my social security number. Usually, they ask for a home phone number, which I also don't give out because I have it unlisted for a reason, but a social security number? I looked at her like she was on drugs and the pissed off look on my face told her not to ask me any more dumb questions. I asked to speak to a manager and he told me that it's a new "policy" for keeping track of their customers. I flat out told him that he was full of crap and that there are better ways of tracking customers than by using such sensitive information. Nevertheless, I told them that they will be on the news that day to get them to change their policy, and they did. Unfortunately, the only way to get to some people is to threaten them with negative publicity, but if it must be done, so be it.

by jellimonsta

That is absolutely crazy. I can only imagine how many people actually divulged that information before you raised concern.
Sometimes I am flat out horrified at the level of intelligence in this world! :p

by dogknees

While you seem not to be accessing his PC for malicious purposes, you have still hacked in. So, telling him you haven't isn't going to wash.

by nicknielsen

How does "browsing through shared folders on my university's network" constitute hacking in?

Is there a new definition of hacking?

by dogknees

If I happen to leave a share open on a network it isn't an invitation to check it out.

If you happen to leave you house unlocked do you consider it appropriate for me to wander in abd grab what I like? Or would you think it more appropriate to call you and let you know I saw your door open?

When you browse folders, you can usually see that it's a share on a particular computer, if it isn't one you've been invited to use, you don't even look at it. If of course you consider yourself a computer professional.

As we're often reminded, this is a site for Computer Professionals, so obviously the writer is one.

Regards

by old guy

Whatever you say, ma'am. Oh, please don't hit me no mo'. I won't do it again. I promise. I'm soooooryyyyy ma'am. (I just know how you like that statement--hehe) :p

:^0

by lamczyknic3000

notify a network admin and tell them about the situation then inform the person of whom the information belongs to and tell them to get in contact with the networking IT department in order to solve the issue.

by troyw

Not everyone who might have access to the network might be so ethical, I know if I was the one accidentally sharing information that was best not shared, I'd prefer someone let me know sooner rather then later, so I could do something about it. In this sort of case, it's better to access it, determine that the user might not know it's being shared and inform them, then having someone less ethical access it and abuse that information.

If it wasn't for the original person who started this thread finding the accidentally shared information, then someone else might have found it and abused it. I think they did the right thing, because no malice was involved.

Going by your logic, "hackers" who patch a system to make it more secure are bad, because they shouldn't have been accessing a system in the first place, and should have left it wide open to attack for someone else to abuse. I'd much rather there were people out there who didn't share that opinion.

by nicknielsen

Partial definition from the American Heritage Dictionary (my emphasis):

share, v. intr.

1. To have a share or part: shared in the profits.
[b]2. To allow someone to use or enjoy something that one possesses:[/b] Being in daycare taught the child to share.
3. To use or enjoy something jointly or in turns: There is only one computer, so we will have to share.

Your analogy is defective. An [u]unprotected[/u] file or PC is the equivalent of an unlocked house; it does not announce itself on the street, you must check the door. If you happen to leave a share open on the network, you have essentially posted an "Open House" sign. Computer professionals may not browse that share, but I can guarantee you that the majority of people using the network are NOT computer professionals.

As for your assertion that a computer professional would not browse a share he has not been invited to join, that, too, is partially in error. If I am on a public network, no, I will most likely not browse am open share. However, as the computer professional responsible for network security, I will want to know why files from an individual PC are shared when mapped shares already exist on the network server.

[i]...this is a site for Computer Professionals, so obviously the writer is one.[/i]

I read from the sarcasm in this statement that you believe that the writer was wrong to browse a shared file he had not explicitly been invited to view. Was he then also wrong to take the steps to prevent a possible identity theft? I don't get it.

Edit: spelig

by dogknees

(However, as the computer professional responsible for network security, I will want to know why files from an individual PC are shared when mapped shares already exist on the network server.)

Which is fine. But, you don't need to look at the files or their content to do this. If you see a share where there shouldn't be one, you notify the owner. You don't need to look at the content to do this.

There's a difference between realising there is a share where one should not exist, and looking at the content.

If I notice that the payroll department has shared their documents folder, I'ding them and let them know. I would then offer to assist them in securing the data. Opening and reading the files would not be the appropriate thing to do, and isn't required in order to do my job.

Regards

by michael.tindall

email it to them, from an anonymous hotmail account (you have 3 of 4 of them, right?), with a brief explanation, signed "a concerned friend"

by vtassone

I worked at a college IT dept. a number of years ago under contract. One of the students came in one day and said her computer wouldn't boot. I checked it out for her and found that the "windows " folder had been renamed "winblows". This was win98 and she had the whole drive shared.

by tachyon

You could use their credit card to buy them a nice book on security.

Seriously though, how anyone that stupid got to University is beyond me. Must be due to "No idiot left behind".

Slip a note under the door. People that stupid usually take offense to it being pointed out. Do it in person and they're likely to accuse you of hacking etc.
Save the hassle, make it anonymous.
Something like.

"Dear moron, you have all your personal information shared on the public University network. Fix it before someone less honest than me steals your identity"

Besides, it might be a honeypot or other trap and you'll walk into it and spend your days being accused of all kinds of crap by whatever jackboot thugs set it up.

Tachyon

by tachyon

Judging by your whiney little post, you must be the moron he was talking about.
See, I told you morons get touchy if poeople confront them on their stupidity.
Not to mention my reply was completely relevant to the original post, and it's title. Get a sense of humour or shut up
Go back to clicking on pop-ups and claiming money from Nigeria and leave I.T. forums to the smart kids.

by marileev9

Thanks NickNielsen. We have to remember the context of the situation. This could be information from a college freshman & it's their first time using a network.

But even an 18 or 19 year old should understand that people can be unscrupulous and their ignorance can cause them years of headaches down the road when they have to deal with their bad credit because of this exposed data http://www.essentialsecurity.com/news.htm?id=44

by action13

I am a Canadian that worked in the US for a few years. I was also asked for my SSN at a movie rental place. I was surprised at how many places "required" your SSN and it seemed, in fact, a bit scary. To this day (I left the US in 2000), I have an easier time recalling my SSN than my SIN (canadian equivalent). In Canada, I can't recall ever being asked for my SIN except on a job application.

by tig2

Nick had a valid point.

And he has been around the IT block for more years than I will admit to for him.

Perhaps politeness is in order?

by old guy

you weren't confronting me and so far today I haven't done anything that even you would think was stupid. However, your reply to Nick is very typical of a pompous, self indulgent, egotistical, small minded person. Now I hope you're not like that. I'm just stating your reply was typical of someone like that. If you can't be congenial in a forum then maybe you shouldn't "waste" your time here. It doesn't hurt to at least be civil.

by old guy

No, your first response was not relevant to the original post. Your sarcastic acidity was again indicative of a small-minded egotistical little man who appears to think everyone is stupid but themselves. As someone else pointed out here there is a big difference between doing something stupid and being ignorant of how to do something. There are myriads of college students who are extremely smart and talented who haven't a clue about pc security because they've never been shown or learned how to take care of it. That's why we are here in IT admin/management/help desk, etc. to show and instruct people how to apply security. Your original post shows none of that. First rule of thumb: you do not know everything. Second rule: learn how to communicate with people. Third rule: Speak to others how you would want them to speak to you.

I hope you will learn better communication skills. Good luck.

by techexec2

Tachyon, I completely agree with Nick, Tigger, and Old Guy here.

I enjoy a good joke and your first one was pretty funny ([i]"use their credit card to buy them a nice book on security"[/i]). Clever. Light-hearted. But, I think you were way over the line after that. It's just not funny to tear someone to shreds for your own selfish amusement. Not one bit.

Your attack on Nick for calling you on it was completely un-called for.

You are putting a lot of energy into being offensive. You could do a lot of good with that energy. Think about it.

by kiltie

Forgive me Lord, for I am a cynic....

acracker said

"How do I tell this person that they are sharing files they shouldn't be? I don't want them to think that I hacked into their computer because I didn't and I would never exploit someone's personal information."

His profile says

acracker
Job role: Student
Location: East Lansing, MI
Member since: August 2006
I have no professional experience. Everything I know about computers I taught myself. I fix computers for my friends/family and I will be learning how to program soon.

and he posted in the thread What's So Good About Linux"

http://tinyurl.com/o2q8j

I'm not 10 but... (184 of 200)
Could you teach me to write a virus to kill an entire windows network? My friends have lan parties and I'd like to play a little prank on them. Oh yeah, this is kinda off topic, but how do you get a picture for your icon?

-------------------

Maybe I do him an injustice, but with a member ID like that, combined with what he is posting I smell a Troll.
If I am wrong, I sincerely apologise, but surely you can see why my thoughts lead this way?

EDIT: To add emphasis (I am a bit rusty with HTML) and to point out that it just doesn't add up, why would someone so caring (first part) want to write a virus to kill a network (second part)?
yeah, yeah, I know.....those student days......

but.....

I am still a cynic, it is a healthy attitude to have ;-)

by tig2

He never asked how to exploit the information, simply asked how to proceed.

From another post, he let the other student know what he found and the student cleared the matter.

I agree that the "kill an entire windows network" thing doesn't look good. The offshoot "how do you get a pic for your icon" must have been answered.

Hard to say. He was appropriately responsive in this thread. He aseked for opinions, received them, reported back what he did about the problem.

I would say that he is guilty of being young.

by techexec2

[i]"I would say that he is guilty of being young."[/i]

I was convicted of that and sentenced to life without possibility of parole.

P.S. Agree with you about acracker.

by kiltie

@acracker, if you are reading this

I apologise if I misunderstood you, however maybe you can see why?

Tip: pick a less provocative ID and stop asking about how to write viruses.

All life is a learning experience.

by ontheropes

with some wild oats thrown in.

Unless of course acracker is a female in which case... I don't know. I can't figure out too much of anything when it comes to women. I don't even try to anymore.

by kiltie

Ty for the link, seen it before, but it is incomplete and is unclear whether these are beta things, ideas actually implemented, or a wish list. Besides, although it states "the system does not allow HTML tags", some are allowed.
The fact that most of the posts are a year or two old doesn't help, it makes the topic look like something someone had a great idea about, but then forgot all about it

(a really cool feature would be to allow the inclusion of images in posts - be great for screenshots when trying to illustrate problems or answers)

A Question:

Why is it so hard to find anything about TR in TR? It all seems buried, hidden or links don't work.

I asked a question once about a simple profile editing problem, I got an automated reply saying to expect a response in 24 hours..... that was over 2 weeks ago.

maybe once they have finished revamping the site....

-----------

Re my post

I understood that it may have simply been inexperience, or youth, hence my disclaimer, but the clues made me suspicious and I wanted to post about it, as it seemed nobody had noticed the discrepencies.

.
.
.
and lastly.....

I was young once...... but I grew out of it ;-)

EDITED: typo spotted

by nicknielsen

after the fine defense (thanks much, everybody! :x ), but I just have to...

Smart kids? Aahh, I understand. Punks.

by ontheropes

You're a moron? I never got the memo. :_|

Nobody ever tells me anything anymore.

Me pout now.

by ontheropes

Pilsner

Brewed in Mendocino County Californ[b]i[/b]a

A solid 17/20. B-)

Hoorahhh!

Edit: Have you ever noticed how HTML and beer make for interesting posts?

by techexec2

I think you were a good detective. I didn't notice the discrepancies. I thought your post was fine. Anyone who is not too sensitive should not overreact to your post.

Of course, sometimes people misunderstand and overreact at the slightest provocation, like here:

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-11183-0.html?forumID=5&threadID=199706&messageID=2099914

If we all go around trying to be completely PC at all times, TR would become much less fun and much less useful. I think it is reasonable to expect people to be flexible and not overreact too quickly...a lesson learned on me also.

-----

The formtting tags in that page have worked well for me so far. I first started typing in actual HTML to add some formatting. This caused problems. I had to also add paragraph tags too to keep the text from running all together and that was more work than I wanted to do. I don't want to type a whole web page with each post! :^0

-----

[i]"Why is it so hard to find anything about TR in TR? It all seems buried, hidden or links don't work."[/i]

I think they are having a hard time. Too few website programmers perhaps. I usually find things on TR via Google like this:

site:com.com these are the words i want to find

by tig2

Finding things at TR is about to become much easier. See https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=96&threadID=199949&start=0
for a discussion about the new Search capabilities.

I believe that the plan is to launch the new and improved TR this Fall. I had asked Jay some time back if there was a launch date and was told that they are much more interested in making it right than managing to a date. I think that is a good plan.

Check out the discussion and the link to the beta!

Edited because NeverBusted made me!

by techexec2

Thanks, Tigger. I'll check it out.

P.S. This constant blaming of NeverBusted for your own edits has got to stop! Admitting...you have a problem...is the first step...to recovery! :-)

Edited in order to offer psych advice...

by tig2

It IS NeverBusted'd fault! Or is it Nick's fault. I'm pretty sure it isn't Onbliss' fault- he only gets blamed once a month.

It's one of them though! They all said so!

by techexec2

[i]"It's one of them though! They all said so!"[/i]

My Dear Tigger,

They took blame because you were not yet ready to accept it. Sometimes we need to wait until our friends are ready in order to avoid pushing them over the edge. :^0

P.S. You should turn this around on me. It's all my fault. All of you are putting on this charade to avoid pushing ME over the edge. And, you're concerned I might try something like T.O. did. Not a fan of his antics, but I hope he lives through and grows from this.

T.O. attempted suicide
http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2006/football/nfl/09/27/owens.report/index.html?cnn=yes

edited because of NICK'S FRIGGEN' TELEPATHIC SUGGESTIONS! STOP IT! (and to correct spelling)

by tig2

Nick, I KNEW it was your fault! Sorry NeverBusted, I thought it was YOU for a minute.

TechExec, you are too busy being a supportive flaming whatereitwas to be the one to blame.

But it's all your FAULT!

I did catch the piece on TO earlier. Shame...

This discussion is closed to new replies.