That is the question you need to understand that some Recovery Tools are better then others and there are many of them.
With Davory I have a lot of Partial Files Recovered which do exactly the same thing you need to go through individual recovered files and delete what is incomplete.
Of course if you wrote the recovered Files to the same drive that they came off you could very easily have overwritten the existing Files and only recovered the File Headers.
With any Data Recovery you [b]Never[/b] write Data to the Drive that you are recovering from. So what exactly is it you have done here? We need to know so we can help you if it's at all possible here. ;)
Col