I get the same results from pinging the 2 sites you mentioned (Yahoo pings AOL does not). I just got my DSL line installed, and put in a Linksys router (Very cheap, and has passed many security tests so far, and a truly Plug and Play configuration.) While going through the router manual (Yea, so I am that kind of Geek) they state that the router can block WAN requests which blocks the ping utility. Apparently this is becoming more and more common, especially with D.O.S. attacks and the like.
So, it is not your firewall that is causing this
FYI:
Ping times out to www.aol.com but gives the 205.188.146.23 IP adderss.
Tracert www.aol.com hops 14 times before getting the message that the destination hosts in unreachable.
Long live Ping!
Hope this sheds some light.
Beef