Discussion Locked

President Obama is doing a grave disservice by. . . . . .

0 helpful
416 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

.....his continued rhetoric on how bad the economy is and on how long it will take for recovery (years, not months).

.....claiming that our economy is in the worst shape since the great depression.

The former will only serve to prolong the lagging economy, and, in essence, help this self-fulfilling prophecy become reality. The latter is simply a blatant lie, not even close to being true.

The prophecy of gloom and doom is alive and well. Instilling financial fear in people is not only doing them a grave disservice, but it will actually keep people and businesses from fully participating in the economy, thereby contributing to its further slide and making recovery more difficult.

Their solutions of more government spending, more government debt, and more control over business and people will only serve to make people more dependent, less free, and less prosperous. Look at how far down the United States has fallen on the [i]Index of Economic Freedom[/i] over the years. Our national goal should be a return to the top of that list; and we should let that goal drive the policy decisions.

Less government, not more; more personal responsibility, not less; more economic freedom, not less; these are the only long-term solutions out of the financial mess that's been growing since the failed policies of Franklin Roosevelt's New Deal drove the first nail into the coffin of economic freedom. People are most free when they're most economically free. This growing financial dependence on government only tightens the shackles of economic slavery.

President Obama ran on a policy position of [i]change and hope[/i]. However, the prophets of doom and gloom in the Democratic Party will never change; all of their policy positions are based on instilling fear and uncertainty. There's no change taking place, only more of the same: more government spending; more government debt; more government control. And where's the [i]hope[/i] in such things?

I avoid negative people in the workplace like the plague. They're a cancer on an entire organization.

I avoid negative people in life. They're a real drag, and they only try to find others to share in their self-inflicted misery.

Let's take it to the next level.

I abhor negative people in government. They don't govern, but rather become demagogues and prophets of doom and gloom. They don't lead, but rather pander. They don't take or preach responsibility, but rather prefer to place blame, make excuses, and advance class envy. They don't encourage excellence, but rather convince so many into becoming victims - self-inflicted victims.

Rhetoric has trumped reality. Fear has trumped [i]hope[/i]. And in the quest to gain even more political power, the notion that [i]nothing changes[/i] has trumped [i]change[/i].

416 replies

by dhcdbd

What led to the depression that FDR's "New Deal" came from. Was that also the result of Government interference in the market, or was that unrestrained capitalism, or something else entirely. Please don't feed us WW1.

by maxwell edison

.....what did the New Deal really achieve?

Regardless of the indoctrination school children receive (including ones from my own generation), the programs of the New Deal didn't (financially) solve a darn thing. What was it that ultimately led that era of America out of the depression - the one that lasted throughout the entire twelve years of FDR's administration (with the possible exception of the last two)?

As to your question, what caused the Great Depression? Heck, economists even today can't agree on all the reasons. However, your simplistic reason ([i]unrestrained capitalism[/i]) is far from the correct one.

Edit:

By the way, as people so often do, don't mistake [i]less government[/i] to mean [i]no government[/i].

by dhcdbd

>"what did the New Deal really achieve?"

The Tennessee Valley Authority, new hydro electric dams, roads, etc.

>"What was it that ultimately led that era of America out of the depression..."

WWII and the building of America's manufacturing base that resulted from the war effort.

>"As to your question, what caused the Great Depression? Heck, economists even today can't agree on all the reasons."

Try the stock market crumbling combined with the dust bowl. This was an era of unrestrained capitalism which the downfall of the stock market was the beginning. The primary means of income to that point had been agriculture. When the dust bowl occurred it destroyed the primary means of sustenance for a large segment of the population. When the dust bowel occurred the stock market was largely recovering, but was again destroyed. Heck, grade school stuff.

Liken the crumbling housing market to the dust bowel, the sustenance is destroyed but from another direction; the stock market speaks for itself. What led to the housing burst that is also present in the stock market? Could it be two things that are related? Unrestrained greed (capitalism) and unrestrained greed by the banks and mortgagors selling assets for unrealistic prices? This unrestrained venture marketing could be the cause of both - meaning those who venture to make money at all costs.

Around the time that the depression occurred the Reserve board was created to attempt to control the venture risks of banks. This in turn was controlled by the fox in the hen house, the banking industry. Therefore a lack of oversite. Industry has proven time and again that it is unable to police itself. One possible solution is to require all venturists to put up 40 - 50% of the costs and show sufficient resources to cover a 100% loss. No can do, then no can invest.

I firmly believe in the words of, I believe Thomas Jefferson:" the government that governs the least, governs the best." Without that little thought, what do we have? One example that comes to mind is the F.D.I.C. seizing Washington Mutual and selling it to J.P. Morgan for 1/10 the value of the assets. However, there are some things that government can do better than individuals.

by nicknielsen

As I remember my History of Economics, the bursting of the stock market bubble in 1929, the Smoot-Hawley tariffs and the economic repercussions thereof, and an extremely tight money policy from the Federal Reserve combined with other non-economic factors (e.g. the Dust Bowl) to create the perfect economic storm.

My personal take on the whole bailout thing is that if the President and Congress want to stimulate the economy and have to do more than just give us back our money, do the following:
* Refund the net tax paid for every individual who files a 2008 tax return with net taxable income under the 2008 median; use all returns filed by April 15 to set that median. No money to anybody above the median and no money to people who didn't pay net tax.
* Take what's left of the TARP fund (a few hundred billion?) and allocate it to the individual states for infrastructure improvement: highways, bridges, etc.
* Prosecute for fraud the corporate executives who used bailout funds to take trips, issue bonuses or obtain perks. Their companies can't be that bad off if they've got enough money to waste on that stuff.

Actually, giving money to people who care so little about the businesses they are running that the first thing they think of with cash in hand is bonuses or perks is flat stupid. Of course, I don't think anybody on TR has ever accused the US Congress of even marginal intelligence.

by michael jay

It could never happen, what with the IQ being what it is for the government as a whole, or is that a hole?

Makes one think, I think.

by dhcdbd

I am not familiar with or do not remember the Smoot-Hawley tariffs. Please give me your takes; in the meantime I will look it up.

While you have some good points, I believe that you are overlooking an important item. That being that just because people have money available does not mean that they will spend it, nor does it mean that they will spend it in a fashion that will benefit the U.S.

by michael jay

Positive words and actions provide forward and positive prospects.

Negative words and actions foster negative results.

At my advanced age I am so glad to finally learn this simple axiom.

by maxwell edison

But you are correct in classifying your reasons for the Great Depression and your list of New Deal programs as [i]Grade School stuff[/i], because that's the indoctrination I mentioned - in its simplistic best. It all goes well beyond simplistic [i]Grade School stuff[/i].

I also often repeat Jefferson's maxim, [i]"the government that governs the least, governs the best."[/i]

But still, what point are you trying to make? Your message, on one hand, seems like an attempt to justify big government, but on the other hand, it espouses less government (in Jefferson's words).

by dhcdbd

1) You are needlessly attacking a policy that is not yet in effect.

2) Incorrectly placing blame.

3) Justifying the status quo.

4) Failing to look at the root causes.

5) Failing to look at solutions that may work.

6) The new one: using propaganda.

While the victors do write the history, there is always some element of the truth that survives and is difficult to hide.

In the case of the economy, my position is that Obama is caving to the financial industry and there [U]MAY[/U] be no change. I am certainly not seeing anything that indicates a rebuilding of a manufacturing base. I also see no real effort to control capital ventures. The two issues that are most closely related in history. I also see the current war effort as unwinable and foolish.

If you wish to continue, please start a new sub thread.

I do not necessarily disagree with you, but I do think differently. If you are willing to continue, I am willing.

by maxwell edison

The reply to your message deserves much more than a fleeting comment. Stay tuned, and I'll reply tomorrow in a new thread.

I welcome honest and genuine dialogue.

by nicknielsen

It was passed in 1930 and raised import tariffs to unprecedented levels "to protect the American worker." The resulting retaliatory tariffs and reductions in trade were significant contributor to the worldwide economic travails of the 1930s.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smoot_hawley

And you're right about the money and spending it the way we expect. Consider the CEOs of AIG, Merrill Lynch, Goldman Sachs, and many others who awarded themselves taxpayer-provided bonuses for running their companies into the ground.

by dhcdbd

and a few others.

This one in particular is informative:
http://eh.net/encyclopedia/article/obrien.hawley-smoot.tariff

What is enlightening in both is the point that they bring out that the tariff was raised only about 2.5 percent and that losses due to tariffs are short lived because the market rapidly adjusts.

Another point is that that in depth this act had nothing to do with bringing about the depression, but rather was a consequence of it.

A very interesting point that supports my hypothesis of capitalistic greed is that the Smoot-Hawley tariffs were initially a special interest duty that applied to agriculture and was subsequently hijacked by business to many things.

How does this tie in with your position?

by nicknielsen

I'm simply repeating what I remember from a college economics course 35 years ago. The only other thing I remember from that class is that economics is not a scholarly pursuit in which I cared to further indulge.

by thechas

Max,

I do understand the power of positive thinking and the benefits of showing the positive side of any situation.

However, there comes a time when you need to admit that the short term outlook is not rosy and that we will go through some tough times to get to the point where the situation starts to improve.

While there are many reasons that John McCain lost the Presidential election, part of why the voters wanted change was precisely because the positive spin the GWB and John McCain tried to put on what was going on with the economy was in drastic conflict to what the voters were seeing around them.

The US economy is at a point where no level of positive talk or spin will get people out there spending because they have nothing to spend.

I do not know anyone who is waiting for word that the economy is improving before they spend money. The people I know are not buying things because they don't have any money to spend. There are a few that are waiting to see how low the housing market goes before they invest in a new home. Just are there are some who have pulled their investments from the stock market wait to see where the bottom is.

If there is no money to spend and no credit available, you can say things are great all that you want and nothing will change.

There is a fine line between optimism and delusion.

Now, people will respond to a positive message if the world they see around them supports that positive outlook.

I don't think that even the news media could get away with stating that the economy is past the bottom and starting to improve without some real evidence that there are new jobs and new opportunities. I think at least 3 times now there have been pronouncements about the market hitting bottom, only to see the market fall further a few days later.

That said, I do agree to the point that the stimulus package is not going to fix the economy.

Nor, will any level of tax cuts fix the US economy either.

The first step toward fixing the economic mess we are in is to balance the Federal Budget. Like it or not, that will never be accomplished with just spending cuts. In order to balance the budget and start paying off the national debt, there will need to be a general tax increase.

Once the government stops borrowing money, there will be a flood of capital available for investment that will spark true economic growth.

Personal spending is not the answer to the US economy. Having money available for investment in new ideas and technologies is the only way we are going to grow the US economy and create new jobs.

Chas

by jdclyde

Will resolve your last statement?

[i]"Having money available for investment in new ideas and technologies is the only way we are going to grow the US economy and create new jobs."[/i]

Will higher taxes make more investment capital available?

Will higher government spending on "free" healthcare?

Or is government the solution, and will be providing this investment capital?

I know from looking at this proposed "stimulus" package, half of it has nothing to do with stimulus. Are we going in the right or wrong direction?

I admit to being preoccupied the last few days, what, in your opinion, has Obama been going Right? [i](if I want to hear what he is doing wrong, there are plenty of venues for that..... )[/i]

Thanks.

by thechas

Correct, I see nothing in the present stimulus package that is going to help the overall economy.

As the US economy no longer has a significant base in manufactured goods, increasing consumer spending is not going to build up the overall economy.

Further, even more than the 2008 stimulus checks, any direct money to individuals will go toward day to day expenses or paying down bills.

The best way that the US Federal Government can free up the investment capital required to fund new business is to stop borrowing money. To do so will require a combination of spending cuts and higher taxes.

Once the budget is balanced, Congress should not even consider lowering tax rates until at least half of the national debt is paid off. Well, we could entertain tax cuts that equal half of any spending reductions.

As to health care, that is a whole different topic. Any program where the government picks up more of the cost of health care will require new taxes or spending cuts in other areas.

Chas

by jdclyde

because he knows he has zero hope of rising to what he claimed during the election.

If he can lower the expectations, his cult will stand with him longer, not questioning why neither his hope nor his change is making peoples lives better.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

subscribing to the notion that it's somehow the job of government to better my life. I figure it's the job of government to stay out of my way and let me better my life.

by michael jay

thinking with your own mind, that is just not right. You need government to spoon feed you from cradle to grave.

Not..

by dhcdbd

I noticed was that after the elections, after his (Obama's) briefings began, he began to back down or away from previous positions.

by ontheropes

I even heard one local politician say, the day after his election, that his policies would work if there was enough money to implement them. Hell, MY policies would work if there was enough money to implement them.

by w2ktechman

is allowed. As long as one comes to the same conclusion as the 'powers at be' want.
However, if your thought goes astray from what is wanted -- watch out, or the govt may need to use a bigger spoon

by boxfiddler Hot topic

the LSD that was a four way Windowpane, will give me a rubber room, keep me high and fed and warm, they can have me.

:D :D :D

by dhcdbd

enough Purple Microdot or Orange Barrel will outdo Windowpane. 25 for those that could get it was better; pure Sandoz.

When you got a little out there those Red Devils brought you back in a hurry.

by jdclyde

as long as it is in favor of their conclusions.

Tolerance does not go both ways, these days.

by cupcake

You have demonstrated a constant attack of the President since the day after the elections. Okay, I think everyone gets that you're a Republican, and unhappy that the Republican party has been ousted from the helm in Washington.

What's the point? If you can accuse the President of "doing a grave disservice by his continued rhetoric", what do you suppose you can be accused of?

And you know what? I abhor negative people too. Especially those who cloak their negativity in a very badly veiled guise of being informative.

Oh, and before I get it from your wingman, don't bother. Don't care to hear more of the same from him either.

[Edited for misspelling]

by michael jay

attacking the President, just stating the facts as he sees them.

Curious point, who is his wing man?

by maxwell edison

Cupcake has this distorted belief that I'm a tried and true Republican (versus a person with a firm set of principled beliefs), and that jdclyde is my [i]wing man[/i], although we all know jd is his own man and speaks for himself. In short, she attacks the person instead of debating the position.

by santeewelding

Person and position are not separable. One can animate the other. In the original, I can get the blade of a knife between them, just.

Try again, Cupcake.

by maxwell edison

You said, [i]"You have demonstrated a constant attack of the President since the day after the elections."[/i]

Constant attack? Are you serious? I've NEVER attacked President Obama. Please prove your assertion.

You said, [i]"Okay, I think everyone gets that you're a Republican, and unhappy that the Republican party has been ousted from the helm in Washington."[/i]

Actually, I'm a philosophical Libertarian, closer to the Thomas Jefferson and James Madison train of thought. Democrats, in my estimation, are Socialists in sheep's clothing, while Republicans are no more than Baby Democrats. (Do a TR search for [i]Baby Democrats[/i] and you'll see many such references.)

You said, [i]"What's the point? If you can accuse the President of "doing a grave disservice by his continued rhetoric", what do you suppose you can be accused of?"[/i]

Feel free to accuse me of speaking my mind. I care greatly about this country, and I'm concerned about the disastrous direction it has taken.

You said, [i]"And you know what? I abhor negative people too. Especially those who cloak their negativity in a very badly veiled guise of being informative."[/i]

What? Care to make some sense?

You said, [i]"Oh, and before I get it from your wingman, don't bother. Don't care to hear more of the same from him either."[/i]

jdclyde deserves enormous credit for speaking his mind, regardless of the personal attacks levied against him by the likes of you. Your constant attacks on the person, and evasiveness of debating the issues speaks volumes about you.

I've invited you on more than one occasion to debate the issues, but you insist on attacking the person. The invitation stands, but your message in this instance proves your motives as I described.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

by the time I got to it. Cubes were disappearing. Blotter and 4-way panes were it. Mostly panes.

etu

by michael jay

I missed all those interesting pictures, perhaps a better person for it?

Perhaps those things I have never seen I was not meant to see.

by dhcdbd

Actually I hope he does much to eliminate unemployment benefits by doing enough that those in need of such can find good jobs and wont need it. Don't expect it though.

by jdclyde

As I just got laid off Friday. :(

I haven't seen anything yet that will actually create jobs for people like me though.

Everything looks more like a backdoor solution to push the social issues programs instead, and intentionally mislabel it as "stimulus".

by Member 25348569

Did you have any warning? Other than the basic state of the economy, that is.

Anyway, good luck and I hope you get something new quickly.

Neil

by w2ktechman

I shall hope that you do find something quickly.
Hmmm, maybe sell the boys to slavery through the black market?? :0 :0 :0 ok, just kidding.

by santeewelding

Is over. Time for finest hours, every one of them, from here on in.

One of your first priorities will be to keep this channel open. That, so you may advise at least me in my own distress. In which connection I find attitude paramount. In which further connection, I have found yours over the years most helpful.

by maxwell edison

And it's come-a-knocking, jd.

Sure, I know there are those who call such an outlook overly optimistic - or even [i]Pollyanna[/i] - but opportunity is there, jd.

In a weird kinda' way, almost like a balance in the universe (okay, don't laugh), whenever something bad happens to a person, an opportunity of equal or greater good presents itself. It's a principle I first read about from a guy name Napoleon Hill. And looking back at those times in my life, including a couple of lay-offs, I can't disagree.

The doom and dread folks love to criticize such an outlook, and they're almost always right in predicting misery for themselves. But the ones who do believe there's opportunity behind every obstacle are also usually right.

You'll come out of this better and stronger, jd, and a lot of good will come from it. You're just that kinda' guy.

by old-fart-iv

Hang in there JD.
The economy is affecting lots of my friends and I did't figure it would be any better is other parts of the nation.

I've been through a few lay-off in the last 10 years and it is a difficult time for you and those who depend upon your paycheck. I found that furthering my education and networking with those I've worked with helped me to find my next opportunity -- it was the key to me finding my last 2 positions.

I know my job is secure only to the point where the next budget decision will be made -- kind of scary, but it is the new reality.

JR

by av .

I hope they gave you a decent severance package after 19 years employment. At least the government has extended unemployment benefits to something like 39 weeks. There are also healthcare options as well.

Supposedly, jobs will be created in IT associated with the expansion of broadband access and with the power grid. I sure hope so.

Maybe you should look to the government sector. It looks like they'll be replacing some of their outdated computer systems as part of the stimulus package.

The last time I was laid off was in '94 and in hindsight, it was the best thing that ever happened to me even though I didn't think so at the time. Sure, I cried after losing my job, but actually ended up finding a much better job. Hope thats true for you too.

AV

by jamesrl

I've been there, I got through, I'm sure you will as well.

I will help you with your resume. Send me what you've got and I will review it. I can point out some resources to look at.

Feel free to ask me about job search techniques, although there are lots of experts here.

My first advice is to relax for a week. Settle down, get over the shock, and think about what your ideal job would look like. After the "trauma" of the layoff, you aren't ready to interview just yet, you are probably still a little shell shocked. But you should take all the time you need to think through what you'd like to do, and that will form the basis of your plan, so take all the time you need.

Going back to resit those courses is a good idea, even if you didn't have an interest in pursuing that field. Getting into a pattern, will take your mind off the joblessness, keep your spirits up, keep you communicating. The worst thing you can do is to retreat into your shell.

This is the time to re-establish your network. I spent time going to lunch with old friends and work colleagues. This is not to put the arm on them to help you. This is simply to let them know you are looking, and what you are looking for, so that if they hear of an opportunity, they let you know.

I won't bore you with everything at once.

Feel free to peer mail me.

James

by michael jay

discussions to much, I love to follow them, and see where they go.

Thanks for the clarification.

by jdclyde

seems to be almost 1/4 of the "stimulus" package.

new taxes/spending cuts to pay for that will not stimulate anything that I can see.

looking at this package so far, justifies to me my "fears" of Obama getting elected.

not real impressed yet.
\
I am hoping this will change, for OUR sake.

by jdclyde

Thanks Neil.

I have been afraid the whole company might go under for a year now. the layoffs started a year ago, and went deeper than I had ever seen down to a skeleton crew. A week ago, people with 20 years with the company got it.

If it went deep enough to take me, it is a crap shoot of getting called back or not having a company to get called back to.

the ex is NOT pleased because I told her for the first time in 3 years of having the boys, I am going to file for child support. She offered me $200 a month if I wouldn't file. That barely covers their school lunches.

The college I got my BA from allows alumni to resit any if their classes for free, so I think right off the bat I am going to get back in some of the cisco classes for a brush up while I am looking for something new.

going back in about an hour to finish cleaning out my office. had to much crap there to fit it all in my little saturn so I just grabbed my tools and electronics on friday. got my moms van and a bunch of boxes for the rest. I always bought my own books, and have a few book shelves full to grab as well as some odds and ends.

besides, there will only be one person in another end of the building, so this will be a lot easier on everyone to do it, rather than wait for monday. for me, as well as them. :(

first time in 19 years I have been without a job.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

But I like to choose whether or not to wear my rose-colored glasses. I don't want them shoved in my face for me.

by maxwell edison

I like to choose whether or not to wear my doom-colored glasses. I don't want them shoved in my face for me, but I can't listen to a politician or reporter without having just that done - day after day after day after.............

by tonythetiger

[i]just because people have money available does not mean that they will spend it, nor does it mean that they will spend it in a fashion that will benefit the U.S.[/i]

because some spent money that WASN'T THEIRS, And somehow I don't think allowing some people to spend even more money that ISN'T THEIRS, is going to solve any problems. All you're doing is postponing natural law... "the strong and smart will survive, and the weak and stupid will perish".

The amazing and ironic part of all of this is that the side of the aisle that traditionally supports this kind of interference is the same side that claims to support the preservation of nature. Go figure!

by dhcdbd

The fact that most will use it to pay down bills rather than buy goods. Of those that buy goods, many will buy foreign goods rather than American goods (if such exist any longer), or buy out of area goods, rather than purchase something that will do their local or national economy any good at all. Many may just bank the money.

To infer that I support interference would be incorrect. I support letting all the business' that made the mistakes lie in their own mud. Most bank depositors are protected because they have less than 100,000 in any account. The banks, investors, etc. that are at the base of this problem would be at the food line and homeless shelters. The manufactures such as Ford and the like would either be out of business or straighten out; if they went out of business someone or something would soon fill their boots. But the industry hand outs would stop.

Do I support taking care of those that can not take care of themselves. Certainly. One day you may find yourself in that heap because of car or other accident or job loss.

I digress some. People originally banded together forming tribes to protect themselves from the strong whom would take advantage of them. The strong seeking to survive managed to infiltrate those bands and become leaders. The people became tired of the leaders doing to them what they had banded together to prevent. They rose up and killed the leaders. The story of revolutions throughout time. When does survival become EOL?

by tonythetiger

[i]The fact that most will use it to pay down bills rather than buy goods. Of those that buy goods, many will buy foreign goods rather than American goods (if such exist any longer), or buy out of area goods, rather than purchase something that will do their local or national economy any good at all. Many may just bank the money.[/i]

IF it was theirs to do it with.

[i]
To infer that I support interference would be incorrect.[/i]

Didn't intend to infer... only relating an observation.

[i]The people became tired of the leaders doing to them what they had banded together to prevent.[/i]

Yep. Many of the things being done to us today we went to war over someone else doing to their citizens... hypocrisy at best...

by jdclyde

Thanks Max.

I loved my job, but hated the hour drive each way. It was "safe" to stay there, though, instead of go out and start over after almost 11 years.

First step, take advantage of the "safety net" and get everything started for the unenjoyment benefits.

Then get my name in the job bank (as required for the unenjoyment)

next step will be to the college I got my BA from. They have an alum benefit where I can resit any classes free, so will do that for a refresher. Get my CCNA/CCNP certs.

Looking for work the whole time.

I have 9 cisco routers (2500's, 2600's) and a few cisco switches, as well as several laptops, pc's and servers. Will be putting my lab together at home. Should keep me busy.

Hoping to find something closer to home. Because I pay over $5000 a year in travel expenses, I could easily take that much of a pay cut and never miss it if I get something close. Ideal would be within walking or biking distance. B-)

by jdclyde

so far so good, but I don't think it will really set in until tomorrow after I drop my boys off at school, and for the first time in 19 years, don't have a job to go to.

by jdclyde

the 19 was non stop going directly from one job to the next, as a step up.

They are hoping to call me back in a few months. If I don't get the call, that will mean there isn't a company to go back to.

I will not be sitting around waiting, nor feeling sorry for myself.

Will be reaching out to friends as needed, and already getting people checking in with me to make sure I am holding on. B-)

Friends make life worth living.

by jdclyde

but don't have any plans of leaving the state.

I work so I can spend time with friends and family, not to have a fancy house. Things would have to get worse than this for me to leave the state.

With any luck, the "brain drain" of many of the Michigan workbase moving away will have made a shortage of people in my field. hopehopehope.

Thanks.

by jdclyde

we all just do what we can, right?

I always remind myself that the measure of a person is how they handle the bad times, not the good. I hope to measure up.

by jdclyde

This will be a good change for me. Was getting lazy where I was.

Besides, all the eye candy has long since been laid off...... ;\

by jdclyde

Will be working on it.

I just figure this next week, will be out hitting the streets, so probably won't get much time to come out and play.

Got benefits to apply for to make sure my boys have food and health care.

And yeah, my ex is PISSED because I am going to go for child support. "You are a selfish man" was her reply to the email when I gave her the heads up about it..... :D

by jdclyde

Will have to make a run back there in about a week. Because I have a lot of research and school data on my pc, they let me bring it home to copy everything off. pretty sweet.

Still feel up for lunch? B-)

by maxwell edison

....you will emerge stronger and better, I have no doubt. You're smart, well spoken, grounded in principle - especially when it comes to your boys (which is, after all, the most important thing) - and, if I were to guess, you will make things happen. The cream rises to the top, and that's exactly where you'll end up.

By the way, your divorce thread was one of TR's most popular (didn't it hit well over 1,000?), and it helped you think-out that particular obstacle in your life. My guess is that if you start an [i]I was laid-off[/i] thread, not only could it help you navigate yourself through this, but it will undoubtedly help many others as well.

P.S. Don't tell anyone, but I think that I, too, might be on the verge of a lay-off. The bad news is that it might not happen. (Yes, feel free to read into that.)

by maxwell edison

.....you may not have a job to go to, but you DO have an exciting new future to pursue.

No limits, jd. No limits.

by dhcdbd

>"Yep. Many of the things being done to us today we went to war over someone else doing to their citizens... hypocrisy at best..."

Each person has a duty, in order, to family, self, nation. To do for another before doing for self violates this order. The individuals we went to war to protect had the onus of the duty to do for themselves - first. The reality is that we went to war for oil using a fabricated reason. Now we have a bill for a war that we can not afford.

I am not against war; I believe that conflict is inevitable. I do believe that you pick the events that you choose to war over. If the Taliban would have been that much of a problem, their bones should still be glowing in the dark. They would have never been a problem again.

Afghanistan, from appearances, war was begun not to liberate the people but rather to put an oil pipeline in that the Taliban would not allow. The drug trade, he!! it is bigger now than before the operations began. The U.S.S.R. fought over there for seven years and could not win. Do you really think we can. Other countries are willing to supply the weapons they need to sustain war and we trained them.

To this day I still think that Iraq was begun to sooth Dad's black eye.

Stop all the hand outs to every government in the world and all the corporations in any country, stop the bogus wars, remove all troops from every country in the world excluding those on embassy duty. Watch what happens. If someone bothers us, nuke them as a first option, conventional war afterwards if anything is left that needs mop up.

Oh, I forgot to add: get the U.S. off the Military/industrial and the Industrial/prison complex. Make people responsible for their own actions.

by road-dog

Talking down the economy is a time tested election ploy. Every 4 years the economy is painted as the worst in 50 years, etc.

This is different. The expectations of the messiah were left so open ended that they must be re-calibrated now. The way to do so while justifying grandiose increases in spending is to paint the picture as bleakly as possible. Then ANY measure is justified to a populace that has an incredibly low threshold of pain.

We as Americans are getting exactly what we clamor for. Not a leader but a "savior". We have become a shadow of the tough "can do" America of our grandparent's time.

The change we need is to get back to the solid self-reliance of our forefathers. This way is a disaster in the making....

by dhcdbd

Pardon the above tirade. It was asked for, and I will not apologize; some people are so bent about belittling others or mis-stating what they say to spin as propaganda for their good...

One of the points, I hope came about in that tirade is that we need to do for ourselves. If we can not, then we, as a nation, are doomed. It may take a while, but nonetheless.

How can we do for ourselves. While not really practical at this time, I feel that even though I buy foreign for whatever reason (primarily either lack of American production or poor American quality), we should buy from companies that produce over here. We need to first concern ourselves with our own dirt box and people. While import/export does in fact produce jobs, it produces fewer jobs than are outsourced. You can not consume without some medium of exchange and you can not exchange without some medium of production.

One of the primary reasons the Vietnamese rose from poor immigrant status to middle and lower upper class in ten years was because they first spent money in their own circle (communities), with other Vietnamese, then bought from outsiders. This theory of microeconomics has a trickle up effect and supports the entire group, both directly and indirectly. In short, they relied on themselves first and one others only when they had to.

by road-dog

I couldn't agree more. We need to work on our own house first. Unfortunately we are the world's largest consumer but never seem to use that to enforce fair trade. It is time for Americans to put their money where their mouth is as relates to the checkout line.

Our pursuit of a bigger better lifestyle has caused us to enrich nations that now have a dangerous amount of our debt. If China were to "dump" debt and cause the world to see that we as Americans cannot pay, we will be in deep doggie doo. After all, the whole system is built on confidence. If that confidence is shaken, we will go from a position of power to being at the mercy of our creditors. Imagine China militarily taking Taiwan back and threatening to dump debt and hammer the dollar. We would almost certainly capitulate and abandon an ally.

Superpowers stay superpowers only as long as they can project power.

by jdclyde

And last I heard, still was second largest of all time.

Starting something new on this had crossed my mind, because I know I am not the only one getting hit by this.

Will wait and see how tomorrow goes first.

B-)

Good luck with YOUR layoff, either way... ;\

by jdclyde

between someone that is intolerant about something, and someone that preaches tolerance, but is not tolerant themselves about different view points.

Hypocrites, that is what they are.

by jck

Some of your statements I see some sense in, if put into terms of definitive actions by the Obama administration that warranted such negative reebuttment.

However:

- Your proposal that Obama's "gloom and doom" is what will keep the economy down I think is a bit judgemental and foreshadowing. I think the prudent thing to do would be to see if Obama's realism and honest statements give American confidence in his honesty rather than the fluff and over-optimistic statements of the previous administration.

- Considering the policies of the previous administration, as well as the previous president's constant statements of the economy and American people being "well" and "strong", I would think that America would enjoy someone who took a tactful, reasonable, logical, factual and direct approach to presenting the American people with what was really happening, rather than a "pep talk" and wishful thinking.

- Your statement that:
[i]The latter is simply a blatant lie, not even close to being true.[/i]
in reference to:
[i].....claiming that our economy is in the worst shape since the great depression.[/i]
is simply inaccurate.

Facts:
Stock market:
Great Depression- Fell 80% from its highs in a year (1929-1930).
Today - Market has fallen by almost 50% from 14,164 (Oct 2007) to 7,552 (Nov 2008)...the worst since the great depression.

Unemployment:
Great Depression- Before the market crash in 1929 (when there were no stop gaps in place to keep it from crashing), unemployment stood at about 3%. It rose to 8% the following year.
Today- in 2007 when the housing market and economy began it's big downturn, national unemployment was already at about 4.5%. Current estimates as of December 2008 show it at about 7% and climbing.

Economics:
Great Depression- The government didn't pour $1T+ into the economy within 24 months to slow the bleeding. Only an major act to help farmers was passed within the first 2 years.
Today- The government has committed $700B to banks, $100Bs more to automakers, and another est. $800B to other endeavors to stop things from happening like they did in the Great Depression.

Then, your statement of:

[i]Less government, not more; more personal responsibility, not less; more economic freedom, not less; these are the only long-term solutions out of the financial mess that's been growing since the failed policies of Franklin Roosevelt's New Deal drove the first nail into the coffin of economic freedom. People are most free when they're most economically free. This growing financial dependence on government only tightens the shackles of economic slavery.[/i]

You propose that Roosevelt's "New Deal" drove a "nail into the coffin" of economic freedom. I might agree with this, in the fact that economic freedom was dead and needed to be buried. This is because all the freedoms exercised by families like the Morgans and DuPonts had, in concert with worsening farm conditions during the dust bowl, driven this country into a recession; much as has happened today (less a dust bowl, and in place a massive trade surplus).

Roosevelt's actions in the 2-3 years following his election (along with those of a Congress taken over by Democrats) fueled a recovery in this nation.

Facts:
1929-30 rise in unemployment:5.5% to 8.7
1929-30 GNP drops 9.4%

1930-31 rise in unemployment:7.2% to 15.9
1930-31 GNP drops 8.5%

1931-32 rise in unemployment:7.7% to 23.6
1931-32 GNP drops 13.4%

Roosevelt inaugurated Jan 1933:

1932-33 rise in unemployment:1.3% to 24.9
1932-33 GNP drops 2.1%

1933-34 [b]fall[/b] in unemployment:3.2% to 21.7
1933-34 GNP [b]gains[/b] 7.7%

1934-35 [b]fall[/b] in unemployment:1.6% to 20.1
1934-35 GNP [b]gains[/b] 8.1%

1935-36 [b]fall[/b] in unemployment:3.2% to 16.9
1935-36 GNP [b]gains[/b] 14.1%

You can't argue with facts: Roosevelt's policies that you claim cripple and kill economic freedom...brought back the economy to be free and brought it back to life.

You seem to fixate on the concept that Obama wants to control business. I think that this is true, in respect to the financial lending that is going on to banks, automakers, etc. He has seen the lack of constraints already put upon them, and how they have crassly paid billions in bonuses from these monies even though they claimed to be broke and in dire straits. Obama has showed his dismay with this, and vowed to the American people that he won't stand for it any longer.

I think that Obama has taken a new direction. He speaks directly to issues, and doesn't dance around them or make vague positives that he can alter his meaning on later. He gives the truth, and wants America to take a realistic approach to where we are, were we are headed, and what we need to do and change to make sure that direction is a positive one.

You call it doom and gloom.

I call it realism.

The day Obama announces "America is strong" in the middle of recession, or that it is "Mission Accomplished" when our military task is not yet done...then I will begin to think the man is just more of what happened in the previous administration.

Until then, I will let him have his opportunity to guide the country on a new path from the previous 8 years and see where it takes us.

It really can't be any worse, in my opinion.

I'd encourage you to be more positive and give the man more than 10 days in office to make a difference.

by maxwell edison

1930 - 8 percent
1931 - 16 percent
1932 - 24 percent
1933 - 25 percent
1934 - 22 percent
1935 - 20 percent
1936 - 17 percent
1937 - 14 percent
1938 - 19 percent
1939 - 17 percent
1940 - 14 percent
1941 - 10 percent
1942 - 5 percent

(Of course, it was the War Economy that lifted people into the employment ranks.)

Sure, you could argue that Roosevelt's New Deal programs prevented the unemployment rate from going even higher, but that's pure speculation. There's absolutely no way to know. It's not speculation, however, to suggest those New Deal programs failed to keep it at 8 percent. That's a lot of years of failure for a guy to get so much credit.

Add the abysmal New Deal failure to the fact that it set the stage for exponential growth in government with even more and more socialist-type programs, and it's easy to see why libertarians point to 1932 as the beginning of the end of America as it was intended to be.

And you didn't represent my words exactly as intended.

I did not say that [i]Obama's "gloom and doom" is what will keep the economy down[/i].

I said that it, [i]"will only serve to prolong the lagging economy, and, in essence, help this self-fulfilling prophecy become reality."[/i]

You implied that I said it was the only factor, while I clearly implied it was only one of the factors.

(Kinda' like the constant [i]less government[/i] means [i]no government[/i] thing.

Edit:

(Not necessarily to your message, jck.)

I might also add, the Great Depression was not a uniquely American occurrence. It was world-wide, and to point the finger of blame to things only American is not accurate. Heck, the United States wasn't even the world's economic leader during the first half of the 20th century like it became after the war.

I'd never argue for unbridled and unrestricted capitalism. And like any system, it grows and evolves over time, and we should fix its missteps. But more and more government control over the system is not the only answer, and I would argue that it's the wrong answer.

I find it ironic how people on the left quoted Benjamin Franklin when arguing against national security measures to track down terrorists, but they don't use the same quote when it comes to capitalism and financial security - the very thing to which the quote was probably referring.

(I paraphrase)

[i]Those who give up essential liberty in exchange for more security will get or deserve neither.[/i]

by jck

[i](Of course, it was the War Economy that lifted people into the employment ranks.)[/i]

Yes, in that last push. However, war-oriented industrialization was not in full swing until 1942. 9 years previous, Roosevelt had begun to bring things back into place. His programs in an 8 year timeframe reduced unemployment by 60 percent.

Can you offer proof contrary to the number that you and I both have posted?

Probably not.

[i]Sure, you could argue that Roosevelt's New Deal programs prevented the unemployment rate from going even higher, but that's pure speculation.[/i]

Speculation? It seems that with the changing of presidents and a new direction, the economy turned around for years following that and the transition of Congress to Democratic control.

You would argue it had little or nothing to do with it?

I would say the statistics showed that the change in administration and their programs made the economy turn around.

Can you show proof otherwise?

[i] It's not speculation, however, to suggest those New Deal programs failed to keep it at 8 percent. That's a lot of years of failure for a guy to get so much credit.[/i]

True. However, how could someone implement programs to make the economic downslide stop immediately? It's not possible, and that's a very utopian ideal to think could ever exist in reality of economic trends and financial
markets.

Do you have some miraculous way of making that happen? If so, I bet you could be the first trillionaire in history and I'd like to invest in things centered around your programs. I'd like to get rich quick too.

[i]And you didn't represent my words exactly as intended. [/i]

Perhaps I didn't. However, your words tend to shine the light on his direction as what will do no good. You tend to say how real numbers and facts from the past don't show anything but speculation. But in reality, they show what happened once programs were set in place and their effect during the course of the Great Depression.

On the other hand, you can only [b]purely speculate[/b] on what "will only serve" and "become" in the future, because you can't say for sure and have no statistics, facts, or proof of what it will do. Yours is purely a guess, while what I have presented is fact.

As well, let's show the complete trends of the economy, not just unemployment:

Tax Federal GNP Unemp.
Year Receipts Spending Growth Rate
-------------------------------------------------
1929 -- -- -- 3.2%
1930 4.2% 3.4% - 9.4% 8.7
1931 3.7 4.3 - 8.5 15.9
1932 2.9 7.0 -13.4 23.6
1933 3.5 8.1 - 2.1 24.9
1934 4.9 10.8 + 7.7 21.7
1935 5.3 9.3 + 8.1 20.1
1936 5.1 10.6 +14.1 16.9
1937 6.2 8.7 + 5.0 14.3
1938 7.7 7.8 - 4.5 19.0
1939 7.2 10.4 + 7.9 17.2
1940 6.9 9.9
1941 7.7 12.1
1942 10.3 24.8
1943 13.7 44.8
1944 21.7 45.3
1945 21.3 43.7

source:http://www.huppi.com/kangaroo/Timeline.htm

Simply put, Roosevelt and the Congress enacted things from 1933-1940 which spurred economic growth, dropped unemployment, and brought the GNP back to a decent (although not totally recovered) level.

Perhaps WWII was the "nail in the coffin" of The Great Depression, but it was not what miraculously corrected everything when it "...lifted people into the employment ranks." 7 years of statistics show that government did good before the USA being involved in WWII.

In fact, pre-war unemployment dropped the year previous to the USA entering WWII almost as much as our first year in it...and that is going by your own numbers.

Hence, I stand to believe I will (unlike yourself) give Obama a chance to prove himself rather than be a nay-sayer of events not yet to happen and outcomes not yet to be seen.

I think you should point at the real failures of administrations, such as Bush's, which have done little (if any) good for the American people.

And, perhaps you can take a positive stand about a new president who speaks to the American people in clear, honest, direct, logical, and sensible ways.

The previous 8 years of believing in big business to do right has corroded our economy.

Perhaps the time is now to have an administration and Congress who will put their faith back into the American people rather than the American business sector.

(edited because the editor isn't WYSIWYG...and blank space removal means I have to HTML the damned thing)

by maxwell edison

On the [i]Mission Accomplished[/i] banner.

Please tell us the FULL and TRUE story of the events behind that banner, and the words President Bush said while standing in front of it. What did those spoken words mean? Who's idea was it to put up that banner, and for what reason?

I strongly doubt if you'll accept my challenge, because it won't suit your purpose of continually misrepresenting all things Bush. But perhaps someone else will.

by jck

Or, spin? I'm sure you'll find a reason to excuse it for happening, since you tend to always put Bush in a positive light...even though he's more liberal than any Democrat.

Fact is:

The Bush administration [b]knew and participated in the making of[/b] that banner (research Scott McClellan, then White House Spokesman's own statements) and in particular his statement that said they (the White house) arranged for it to be made for the Department of the Navy and to be flown on the vessel during Bush's speech.

If the Bush administration had misgivings about the message that would be communicated from that banner, they would not have allowed it. They f***ed up. Plain and simple.

Bush himself even said during the speech that:

[i]"In the Battle of Iraq, the United States and our allies have prevailed."[/i]

Funny. I don't see US troops leaving there after prevailing and having accomplished their goal of liberating the Iraqi people and, as Bush himself said, "...bringing order to parts of that country that remain dangerous."

I still see reports about insurgent attacks all over Iraq daily, and including in parts of Baghdad which was supposedly secured for the most part long ago.

Neither liberation of the Iraqi people nor muting of insurgent violence has been suppressed for any duration.

The agreement for the White House to participate in the making of and the allowance of that banner to be flown during Bush's speech was, along with other decisions, simply a bad move.

It is yet another example of the incompetence of his administration and staff to take the proper steps to communicate a clear and proper message to the American people.

Can you provide evidence to the contrary that:

- The White House arranged the making of that banner for the Dept. of the Navy?

- The White House knew it was to be flown on the USS Abraham Lincoln during Bush's speech?

- That Bush stated in his speech that the US military had "prevailed"?

Do you not believe is was a blunder? A bad move? A stupid PR exercise?

If I were to go and give a full account of all the information I have read about that whole timeline, I'd have to make this post a whole series of documentaries.

And, I don't have time for that. I have work to do.

by jck

just for the FULL and TRUE story of what Bush thought of the situation upon his departure from the White House:

[i][u]In November 2008, Bush indicated that he regretted the use of the banner, stating in a CNN interview, "To some, it said, well, 'Bush thinks the war in Iraq is over,' when I didn't think that. It conveyed the wrong message."

In January 2009, Bush said that "Clearly, putting 'Mission Accomplished' on an aircraft carrier was a mistake".[/u][/i]

- Wikipedia

Bush admitted...it was a bad move...communicated the wrong message...and was a mistake...by HIS staff and administration.

At least he's admitting he's wrong about having done it.

You could admit he was wrong now too.

by jmgarvin

I'm a moderate (independent if you will), but it's been said by the Bush administration that:
A) The sign was a mistake
B) The sign was something the participated in getting up there
C) The speech sent the wrong message

Iraq is a mess, and will continue to be so. We're losing Afghanistan because of the effort we're dumping into Iraq. Hell, we've even had to hire mercenaries to help fight our wars...that's just pitiful.

by tonythetiger

[i]Unfortunately we are the world's largest consumer but never seem to use that to enforce fair trade.[/i]

is defining 'fair'. I know WE think that fair is what WE do, and that anything done differently by someone else is inherently UNFAIR, but is it?

Personally I think we've created most of our own problems. We have put roadblocks in the way of our businesses that businesses in other countries don't have, giving them an advantage... and somehow I don't think the answer is going to be forcing them to do things our way...

by tonythetiger

of the effects of the New Deal can be shown by comparing changes in conditions in the US to changes in conditions world-wide. I will attempt this comparison when I have some more time.

by jck

From my reading, the only country that I gathered had a higher unemployment rate at that time was Germany.

I would like to see the information you pull...and as to whether or not American steps to improve economic conditions, and the improvements that happened thereafter, actually were followed by economic improvement abroad as well.

by maxwell edison

President Bush said, [i]"Major combat operations in Iraq have ended. In the battle of Iraq, the United States and our allies have prevailed. And now our coalition is engaged in securing and reconstructing that country..... We have difficult work to do in Iraq. We are bringing order to parts of that country that remain dangerous. Our mission continues..... The War on Terror continues, yet it is not endless. We do not know the day of final victory, but we have seen the turning of the tide."[/i]

Well, major combat operations - as defined by the military - did end. [i]Major combat operations[/i] is defined as fighter engaging fighter; tank engaging tank; army engaging army. The next step was, as President Bush said, [i]engaged in securing and reconstructing that country. Major combat operations[/i] were over, while [i]engaging in securing and reconstructing that country[/i] had just begun.

The decision to put up that [i]Mission Accomplished[/i] banner was because of a request made by the personnel on the USS Abraham Lincoln, not by President Bush, personally, and not by anyone in his administration. These sailors were on their way home after being deployed off the coast of Iraq. Their families and loved ones would be waiting at the port to greet them. The sailors would be lined up around the ship in their Navy Whites. The crew was not only proud to have [i][b]Accomplished[/i][/b] their [i][b]Mission[/i][/b], but to actually have the President of the United States land on their ship.

Did the president showboat by landing on the carrier? Sure, you could make that argument. But people like their presidents to showboat, and presidents do it all the time. But people also love to criticize such things if the president in question happens to be one of the opposing party.

The banner was much ado about nothing, or it should have been. However, the political opposition in the Democratic Party (including those in the media) decided to make hay out of it in their on-going attempts to discredit a president they absolutely loathed, and they painted it in the most negative light they possibly could. Heck, they could have painted it in a positive light just as easily - something they would have done for Clinton, or Obama, or Kennedy, or FDR.

It was political smear, pure and simple. To suggest otherwise is only engaging in the political smear yourself.

Was it a mistake, as President Bush said during his last days in office? Sure it was. He should have foreseen how his political enemies could have used the whole thing against him. My biggest criticism of President Bush is that he left so many political smears against him go unanswered. He should have fought back as vigorously as he was being attacked.

by jdclyde

People that pre-hated Bush didn't listen to it.

The only thing that was done was to look for things to pick apart.

If there would have been support for the efforts instead of every chance to talk about how our military is bombing women and children, or terrorizing them in their homes, would the enemy been embolden to continue?

by jdclyde

[i]"troops leaving there after prevailing"[/i]

One objective was finished.

He was ill-advised to start a second objective, that was a result of the first, correct?

Once at that point, should Bush have pulled out and left the power vacuum? In a savage region where people rule by fear and perversion of religion?

===============================

You have said Bush is more liberal than any Democrat. Are you saying now that liberal is bad?

===============================

Do you really think insurgents coming from other countries to attack the new Iraqi government is Bush's fault? Remember, the Iraqi government and civilians have been the main targets of the insurgents, not the US military.