Discussion Locked

President Obama says chance for healthcare overhaul is slipping away

0 helpful
324 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post

324 replies

by oz_media

Why not read what he said instead of assuming?

"when I had COBRA [b]from my last insured job[/b] I was paying over $600 a month just for health...no dental or vision or life or disability...for 1 person."

An 'insured job', to me, would probably be the same as an employer providing insurance options.

I could be wrong though, as I am sure you will point out anyway.

Now even $250.00 is insanely steep compared ot what you COULD be paying.

My "insurance" when my son was under my care was a little under $50.00 a month, and my employer provided dental, extended medical (which in included eye care also, as well as compensation for extended time off work).

The employer paid less than $70 for that extended coverage, which all employees received after 3 months (6 for dental).

SO the total cost per person, for standard medical, extended medical, eyecare, dental was under $140.00 month. The bulk of which was attributed to the private coverage that my employer paid in full.

When you are covered in such a way, your family members/dependents are covered also, whether I have one kid or three.

Face it, yuor medical system is in disrepair, needs an overhaul something fierce. If Obama's plan isn't the paradigm of perfect medical plans, that'll change in due time, the fact is though, SOMETHING has to be done now or it wlll never get done down the road.

Planting seeds and all that.

by delbertpgh

Canada spends about half what America does on health care. We spend $6714 per person (2006); in Canada the same year it was approx $3700. That's more like $300 per month, a long way from the insurance premiums you pay.

While Canadian health care is far cheaper, and Canadians seem to be more satisfied and secure than Americans with their plan, you can in no way say you're paying only $700 a year. You pay a much larger bundle in taxes to support your health.

You just pay, in the end, a lot less than we do.

by jck

Hm...let's see.

I go out and work a full-time job.

I work part-time on the side to supplement that, because cost of living is up.

I have 2 elderly parents I have to help take care of that live 3 hours from me, so then it means I have to make sure I do all my domestic responsibilities during week nights so that weekends are usually spent taking care of them.

The people who have the hardest time on welfare are those in rural America where you have to drive miles and miles to get services and what not.

The people in urban areas on public assistance have it WAY easier, because everything is located around them and within close proximity and they have access to public transportation.

And it is degrading? Yeah right. If it was such a negative social and personal stigma to live with, no one would go on it that had any kind of personal pride.

I was unemployed for a while. I couldn't take it being on the dole. I went out and got a job making $7 an hour (less than the unemployment pay) because I couldn't stand sitting on my a$$.

Sorry, Oz. But, welfare is not some tasking, belittling, major effort in life to have or deal with in any sense.

And besides, I have been called a lot worse things than "welfare baby" or "scammer" or "lazy a$$" in my life.

And to be totally honest: If I could find medical doctors who'd certify me disabled and help me get Social Security disability and that beefy $2200+ a month I could draw til I die...I would do it in a heartbeat now.

Cause, then I could go do cash-only, tax-free, under-the-table jobs fixing PCs and make another $200-400 a month and live like a king.

So...yay for free rides. I might just catch the gravy train, if I can. 30 years of working is enough for me.

by jck

pays $.28 extra every paycheck to have a supplemental plan where he can choose any dentist to go to for treatment.

For me to have that, I would have to pay an additional $10+ a paycheck to be able to get the same level benefit from out-of-network doctors as those already in-network.

Scary. Where do I sign up to pay an extra $1000 a year again for social healthcare, since I'm already paying it and not getting that option?

Oh well...it doesn't matter...hopefully I'll not need insurance much longer.

C'MON LOTTO TICKET!!! :^0

by jck

[i]If you actually had some values, you would debate someone on the issues discussed instead of stomping up and down like a spoiled child, screaming that everyone is lying, just because you don't agree with them.

I will leave you two to your love fest.[/i]

I hear the pitter-pattering of the stomping off of another pair. :^0

Actually, Oz...he's right...it's not your values that keep you from placing judgement in blanket statements.

It's a lack of narcissistic piety.

by oz_media

Maybe in the USA it's a cakewalk and people respect others on welfare and they are all able and simply unwillign to work.

Fortunately that covers a VERY small percentage of our own welfare recipients. It takes a lot of runnign around, even when in the city and things are within 20kms of each other, UI forms to get stamped saying yuo are not eligible, doctors to see if you are claiming temporary/short term disability, job search reports to be handed in, traiing classes to attend and you get a whopping $53,00 a month for it, which for thse that really do need and qualify for welfare are unable to live on or even pay teh rent with. I have yet to meet a single person, livign on welfare that would say so in company, it is the most degrading system of funding known to Canadians, unless of course it's just a scam on top of your other job.

In Toronto they get a bit more as the rent is higher, they also pay more for utilities, food, etc. how effective is a system of support for the needy if it doesn't even help cover the most basic of needs, such as housing. That' swhy myself and millions of other Canadians always support a rise in welfare payments, though many scam it, thos ein need to not get the help they need to get on their feet again. Most people on welfare are forced ino other acts for money now, whether prostitution, selling drugs, theft and fencing etc. It's a damn hard rut to avoid and an almost impossible one to escape once you are there. Fun huh, fishing and enjoying the sun?

The AVERAGE price for a 1 bedroom in the Lower Mainland is $868.00/mo, a 1 bedroom in Vancouver averages $1100.00/mo. So if you are a welfare recipent, you have to move into skid row just to make the rent, and than face high crime ratesm unsafe streets, daily breakin's of your 'room' etc.

Sounds like fun, right?

As for $2,200/mo plus anpother $200-$400 for side work, how can a person revert to living with that low of an income if you are used to working in a decent paying field for years? I couldn't even get by with that as spending money for the month (including gas and related 'luxury' expenses).

When I am in the US, nothing is really that much cheaper than up here anymore, I simply don' tknow how Americans live on such tight budgets yet are such heavy consumers of whatever they are told is a good deal, and still make ends meet.

I don't know how much a welfare recipient gets there but it must be a lot more than here if people are so happy collecting it.

Does everyone there owe a lifetime of money in loans or something?

by oz_media

To be clear, I have said several times that is a cost for subsidized medical. The subsidy being the taxation part of our system. Bottom line though, even if the did away with all medical tomorrow, my taxes would remain the same, I am not going to start paying less, government's do not do that. At best, they may make it APPEAR as if it was given back, by offering some form of rebate but that would pale in comparison to the amount taken in taxes and paid into medical support to begin with.

Like they did with hydro, we had paid a surplus so everyone got $100.00 credit.

My friend pays over that each month for his hydro (hydro is what we refer to our power as because it is hydro-electric power which used to be provided by the provincial crown corporation BC HYdro).

I have it easy, my 2 bedroom apartment costs (get this!) $17 DOLLARS every TWO months. that's right, eight dollars and fifty cents per month (sshhhhhh!). ;) the "Lord of the Land" pays for heat & hot water and I pay for electrical, it's still pretty damn cheap though ,don't you think?
So when I was rebated $100.00 lets just say I had abotu a year without paying for hydro.

Anyway, back on track...I understand our taxes are used to support the medical system, again though that wouldn't change if it wasn't used that way, they just allocate it to something else.

This is also why I often debate the tax issue with Americans, it seems so many Americans feel that if they dropped services, they would have more money, but government's don't think nor operate that way, they would just reallocate it to something else. It may be something you favour and support but millions of others don't, it may be something else you feel is a waste of tax money but others like.

The bottom line is, we all pay taxes and that's never going to change. For MY tax dollars I get medical coverage, how about you? More funding to help save your souls from evil Saddam's cronies just in case they do have WMD's and MIGHT be plotting against you?

I have health coverage and very few enemies that I need protection from. (I'd say none but I am sure SOMEONE doesn't like Canada and as I don't know who it is, hopefully I can be protected from them) I know which side of the border I'd rather be on anyway.

I'll side with health care and safety assurance, over fear, sickness and arms.

by jamesrl

..is not part of government paid for healthcare in Canada, unless its for somethign like facial reconstruction or if a dental issue becomes a medical issue requiring hospitalization (absess).

That .28 cents your friend pays is like a fractional co-pay. I happen to know what my employer pays for me, they actually publish an annual statement, and its much more than that. The insurance company for my dental/drugs etc is a private company. There are caps and limits and so on, just like US plans. Having worked for a government agency at one point, I know how good the benefits were, and only wish I had that level of benefits now.

James

by jdclyde

then step up and lets here it.

If all you can do is attack the messenger (like usual) then you have nothing to add to the conversation the adults are having. If you don't wish to be sent back to the kids table, grow up.

by jdclyde

being stimulated that has effected me.

My old just is still not there because of the housing slump, and that isn't changing soon.

Sure, there are a lot of new programs offered now, but even working 25 hours a week with a family of three and no benefits, I still make to much for us to qualify for anything.

by nicknielsen

COBRA is actually an acronym for Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consolidated_Omnibus_Budget_Reconciliation_Act_of_1985

When people lose their jobs, they are given the option of continuing with the insurance from their previous employer (for up to 18 months, I believe). However, because the individual is no longer employed, he must pick up the entire monthly cost that he was previously sharing with the employer.

THAT is where jck's $700/month came from.

by oz_media

Thanks for that, i'll stick to the COBRA acrconym I think.

That's still a bundle and a bit simply for medical coverage though, no matter how you slice it.

by jck

And after 18 months, that carrier is obligated to take you on as a full-time member.

Then you can choose from their other policies.

by oz_media

it's just one, known to be biased, opinion from a news article, however you pose it as proof and not merely a reporter's sensational opinion.

by jck

Here's a site that is an organization of physicians who are for a nation healthcare program.

http://www.pnhp.org/facts/single_payer_resources.php

Hope that sheds some light on what actual medical people think of having a system, rather than a lot of news outlet BS and politicians spouting spin.

NOTE: Their "About" info -
[i][b]Physicians for a National Health Program is a single issue organization advocating a universal, comprehensive single-payer national health program. PNHP has more than 16,000 members and chapters across the United States.

Since 1987, we've advocated for reform in the U.S. health care system. We educate physicians and other health professionals about the benefits of a single-payer system--including fewer administrative costs and affording health insurance for the 46 million Americans who have none.

Our members and physician activists work toward a single-payer national health program in their communities. PNHP performs ground breaking research on the health crisis and the need for fundamental reform, coordinates speakers and forums, participates in town hall meetings and debates, contributes scholarly articles to peer-reviewed medical journals, and appears regularly on national television and news programs advocating for a single-payer system.

PNHP is the only national physician organization in the United States dedicated exclusively to implementing a single-payer national health program. [/b][/i]

by jck

a) Most Americans owe money. It's the American way. Spend your ass off, give your kids ownership of stuff 5 years or more before your death (to avoid estate tax), then die and leave nothing but bills and stuff.

b) Here in the USA if you get on welfare, you get the following:

1) A check for $xxxx depending on number of dependents, etc.

2) Free medical from city/county/state health depts.

3) Housing assistance from HUD (e.g.- Section 8) that makes your rent/lease payment sometimes $0.

4) Food vouchers

5) Free meals for any and all dependent children in their schools

6) Federal school grants to get a free education

7) Assistance from utility companies to help keep them in power/water

etc etc etc.

So basically someone on welfare who gets a place to live where the landlord accepts the HUD payment as full rent payment has $0 rent cost and usually reduce cost utilities.

That's how they afford Cadillacs and Lincolns and what not. They get things free from the system, then take their welfare check and buy expensive stuff.

Hell, the lady I bought my house from was on public assistance programs. How'd she do it?

She had a husband, but they never legally married. But, they co-habitated. So, he worked and made money to support the household.

She worked as a sub teacher, but never made more than a few thousand per year. Since they had 2 sons, she qualified for all that since she was never legally married to him.

Being "welfare" people, they had gotten the money/assistance to build that home, as well as later some kind of money a department gave them so they could buy a $14k grand piano for their son who was a classically trained pianist so he could practice and go on tours with various organizations.

Now...how is that fair to any of us who work our butts off and have less and less, and she can scam the system and get a $14k grand piano, a cheap house, and drive a Volvo?

Yeah...the USA welfare system has a lot of scammers...but, I won't go on welfare.

I'll get disability if anything, since I've paid in over 20 years into it.

by jck

He was claiming what a good father he was compared to other fathers on the show.

The other fathers said they read to their kids every night, take them out to play every day when they get home, go on vacations to places their children want to go.

They asked the Republican "How many nights a week do you go right home and spend time with your kids?"

He says "About 3, but that doesn't mean I'm not as good a father."

And then one of his co-workers said "Yeah, 3 is about right. Any more than that, and it would interfere with his golf times."

Such piety to think that having your children do without spending time with you so you can indulge personal wants...is good parenting. :^0

by jck

was through my employer.

COBRA allows you to pick up the premium that your employer negotiated with your insurance.

I couldn't get insurance anywhere else, so I had to pay it...or else I was SOL on insurance.

If you had family of four coverage in recent years costing you $250 a month, it was probably the difference in premium between a single coverage policy and the cost of your family policy.

That's what all my jobs in the past few years have done: you pay the difference if you're not single.

by jck

When Obama signed off, he did say that "things are going to get worse before they get better".

Of course, you'll ignore that part to spin things the way you want them to look.

And as for nothing to show for it? We, the American people, own parts of GM and Chrysler...car companies in YOUR state.

You didn't see hotel and resort owners in Florida getting billions in bailout money.

Stop whining and go apply at GM...or better yet, go buy a Michigan-made American car.

by tomshotcash

I liked the disucssion from the nurse above, which I agree with exactly. HOW are we going to manage it, both financially and legally (legally meaning the red tape of how the various procedures will be handled)

This discussion is closed to new replies.