Discussion Locked

Real Value of IT Work?

0 helpful
281 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

281 replies

by dawuf

Your skill sets are needed in the public sector such as working for the State Agencies, Government and Charitable organizations. The hardest choice you will make is personal economy. These jobs generally pay a lot less than what you make in the private sector, but you would be making them more efficient at serving the public. Thus you would be contributing to the public good. Of course, teaching and some healthcare jobs (not all, nurses actually make a lot more then they used to) would also affect your bottom line as well. At least if you work in IT, you can keep your skill sets up should you choose to go back and work in the private sector. This choice becomes much harder when you have a family to consider as they will have to come along for the ride on your journey of self-discovery. Hard choice.

Good Luck!

by randy_fox

I'd like to add apoteon's response a very recent undertaking that has helped me feel better about the value I've added not just to my company but to society at large (I've also wrestled with some of the same issues that packratt has so this thread really hits home).

We've all heard about the Tsunami and the devastation it has caused in Southeast Asia. One of the individuals in our company is from Sri Lanka and decided to go back and do what he could to help his homeland. Before he left he launched an email campaign to gather support. Through this campaign, he raised enough to purchase:
? Milk Powder for infants
? Medicine - mostly antibiotics
? Water purification pumps
? Approximately 300,000 water purification tablets
? Toys and clothing (much of which was donated by U.S. children for the children in Sri Lanka).

Where do I fit into the picture? I've spent most of my years here building and supporting the email infrastructure. That infrastructure is what allowed his campaign to start. Without my years if blood, sweat, and tears, he wouldn't have been able to do what was needed, when it was needed. He didn't have to worry about the email network but was able to focus on the real crisis and what he could do help. My efferts went in long before there was a crisis but the effects will stay around for a long, long time.

You have to be pretty thick-skinned sometimes in this job but sometimes, if you look hard enough with an open mind, we are having a positive impact on society.

by apotheon

Indeed, that's so. Often, your greatest contributions are things you never see coming before they get here.

I tend to think of anything that supports a free and open Internet "culture" as a Good Thing. I appreciate the effort you, and hundreds or thousands like you, have put into directly supporting the infrastructure for that.

by jwhitaker

If you're still young enough you might look into retraining. I'm not myself, and I feel like the money I've spent keeping up is wasted income. (no real payback) Meanwhile, I bet there are non-profits in your area that need your skills. Volunteer groups are always short on that end. Overall though, unless you can go full time, you have to seperate your work life from your public life. You still have to make a living and you have to be willing to sacrifice to do other things as well.

IT is the same in this area, a lot of guys/gals have had to move on to other ways of earning a living. A lot of new service companies cropped up and then died in the last few years, started by out of work IT people trying to use their hard earned skills. I can't think of any that prospered. I may have to move on myself even if it means living on peanuts a few years to do so.

by jjlov

Of course it is a worthy job. The problem is in the eye of the beholder (that mythical/dnd monster), known as management. This country could not run itself without what we bring to the table.

Current management philosophy says cut costs as the best way to maximize profits. They pour billions into advertising, marketing, give more away as sales incentives, rather than spend a penny on infrastructure, its support, or product development (there are notable exceptions).

As to eliminating other's jobs. My take from 25 years in the business is that we create more jobs than we eliminate (usually performed by the same people) and permit them to be performed in an easier, safer manner, all while increasing the productivity of those we work for - if they use us properly.

The problem is is that management is largely uneducated as to IT and how to use it well. Likewise, (outside the tech market) the CTO is usually the step-child of the board and not a equal member, and is usally a bit out of date with regard to technology. The sure sign of this is parade of consultants brought in to do 'studies' and 'position papers'. A parade of salesmen is a different thing entirely.

Sure signs of good management - implementation of a single infrastructure platform, sane procurement policies, staff work hours, and staffing levels.

Signs of bad management - more than two infrastructure platforms being supported; staff working averaging over 45 hrs/week/person; outsourced, off-site only IT support; low morale; integrated VOIP, wireless and networking backbone (because of bandwidth requirements, security, and failover issues) and missed/lost vacation by staff.

by arjee63

It's tough to find employment that has a larger meaning in today's world. It can be much more fulfilling when you are able to support users who are doing something you believe in - but it's tough to pick and choose jobs that meet all your needs. I left a job that was very fulfilling, doing QA for software written for non-profits. Unfortunately, the pay was so low that I finally left in order to better support my family. My income is better now, but I've lost that feeling that I'm truly contributing to something worthwhile, except someone's bottom line.

The best advice I could give is keep honing and expanding your skills, and look for opportunities within smaller organizations where you have a chance to stand out and truly make a difference. If you can find an organization whose purpose you believe in, then all the better.

by buschman_007

You have to look at this in a glass is half full type situation. I work in IT and while my 9-5 contribution to mankind might not be staggering, I volunteer my time on the weekends to my Animal rescue (www.magsr.org). That is an extremely fulfilling activity. I take a portion of the money I make in IT and donate it to the rescue. I have asked my boss to sell things, like old printer cartridges and other things that we as a company no longer need. Those sales go to the rescue. Other workers in my office do similar things for their churches, fund raisers, and charities.

I buy and sell more than any other person in my office. Being in IT is an advantage to me because of the cash flow that I deal with and the assets that are in my posession. Ask your boss if you can use your job to help others for whatever organization you feel strongly about.

Don't worry about what your job does for mankind, worry about what you do. If your job can aid in that passion, great! If not, it shouldn't hold you back from doing something wonderful for someone or something else.

Good luck with your quest,
Mike

by unclerob

You ask a really good question, what kind of difference do we make in this world with the type of career path that we've chosen. Unless you're involved in some sort of revolutionary new system that would improve worldwide communications or children's education, medical technology, etc, etc. it's hard to see the value in what IT does. Managing a network, deploying new pc's, rebuilding or repairing old pc's, educating users on how to perform a certain task on their pc, etc. doesn't carry the same weight that a humanitarian focus effort would and for all intents and purposes it shouldn't. If you're in IT, you are just another cog in the corporate machine, helping the rich get richer - I don't know of too many system admins, network admins, or PC Lan Technicians who are millionaires (none actually). I work for a company that has several offices & distribution centres across North America and all IT decisions are made from one office in the U.S. and I had a friend that worked there for several years, and let me tell you something, this guy was a brainiac, uber geek, whatever the term du jour is. He was a cisco genius, knew ms networking inside out (nt3.51, nt4, win2k, linux,etc.) he was responsible for our company's entire conversion from our existing novell 4.x network architecture to a MS NT4.0 and later Win2k network, several hundred servers and 5000+ users later, he did it all, even stuff he didn't know about, he would just pick up a book or two and say "yeah we can do that, no problem". Whatever they wanted and asked for he gave it to them, whenever any of us other site admins had issues or problems, we'd just ring him up on the phone, tell him what's going on and we'd be fixed that day either by him doing what needed to be done or educating us on how to fix the problems ourselves. On top of all of that, he's a Super nice guy, very funny, has a wife & family with 3 kids, and on top of that the guy is a super genius, and a bit of a geek (for fun he has his own server rack in his basement rec room, running several servers of his own just because he could doing whatever task he meant them for and making sure he was always on the "bleeding edge" as he called it of IT. One day, he just experienced a revelation that for all the hard work he had done and all the money he had saved for this company and other companies he had worked for, something was missing in his life. He made very good money for the work he'd done (not a millionaire but he's a very good provider for his family) but that wasn't enough for him, he realized that for all of his talents, what kind of difference had he made on a more humane scale and he didn't think he had done anything or given enough of himself, I still don't know what caused him to change, call it religion or spirituality or something else. He just quit one day. He went to school to become a nurse and he hasn't looked back at all. I don't talk with him as much as we used to but we still email each other occasionally, he still messes around a little bit with computers, IT and what's new but he doesn't give it the same focus or the amount of time he used to. He recently wrote me back after I asked him how things were going with his new job and if he missed his old work and he wrote back "I am completely out of the Computer biz. I get to sit back and bitch like everyone else now when the computers don't work. Its great! Seriously, I am really enjoying the LPN work and RN schooling, it is something different everyday and some days you can look back and see that you actually made a difference in someones life which is something that never happened before." No more ugly overtime, all nighters, weekends, etc. The work he does is worthwhile and he does make a difference. I envy him because of his new found morality and the courage it took to make such a huge change in his life. Of course he has a good support system in his family which probably made this change possible.

In the end you ask a good question and if I have to answer honestly, for all my hardwork, too much overtime, weekends, and all the time I miss from my family, it's really hard to justify IT has having alot of social worth. It's just a corporate cost center. Who knows, maybe IT outsourcing may be a blessing in disguise as it may force alot (I know not all) of IT workers into taking up a new career path into something you would never have seen yourself doing with more social & humanitarian value than most IT jobs currently have. Alot of people may disagree but my opinion is given freely and I don't expect anyone to adopt my view on this, just don't bash me on this one, as it feels pretty good to share a success story.

by james.chau

Like the Novell CNE and MCSE Networking, thousands of network administrators are replaced by very powerful and sophisticated networking software built upon artificial intelligence and neural network technologies. There are now little needs of CNE, MCSE or Cisco administrators. I had never fallen to this sort of vendor driven money making schemes called certification. It is a huge mistake to equate IT with just one component such as network administration. Current IT capabilities allow predictive business behaviour such as Walmart merchandises being able to create its own customer instead of being planned through analyzing historical sales statistics, through the use of mySAP CRM.
The current state of IT staleness is caused by the decision of IT vendors to make user friendly and commodity like tools and techniques in the ignorance that IT does have a very high need to innovate scientifically and engineering wise, when is the world going to have a true commercially available alternate energy source ? transportation means ? buildings ? entertainment ? political control systems ? at the rate IT is crawling human beings will NEVER be able to advance as a civilization, but perhaps we will have a lot of very happy nurses.

by unclerob

The kind of systems you make reference to cost alot of money and don't maintain themselves, there will always be a need for systems admin personnel to implement these solutions, maintain them, take care of users, educate users, repair/maintain/install new equipment, etc. etc. etc. Nothing runs by itself, any man-made systems will always require man-made assistance to continue functioning, - we're nowhere near utopia yet. We may get there someday, probably not in our lifetimes and when we do get there and no one needs IT folk anymore, heaven forbid something breaks and needs to be repaired or replaced because none of the people enjoying utopia at that time will have ever had the need to become educated in working with anything that's IT related. CRM products are only as good as their users and I don't think CRM is driving business to Walmart, if you ever heard Sam Walton speak (I'm sure you know he is since you mentioned Walmart), Walmart works because of the simple fact that people work more now than ever in the past (utopia ain't comin' anytime soon), make less money than they ever have and need to stretch their spending dollar as much as possible, people don't have huge families anymore, money is tighter for most families than ever before so Walmarts do well because people prefer/need to spend less for the goods that they need. CRM has nothing to do with it, Walmart was a success many years ago before anyone ever coined the term CRM, before computers were even involved in business tasks such as inventory, cost management, payroll, accounting, etc. Most folks in the know will tell you that CRM is really a solution looking for a problem, if IBM (who tries to peddle their CRM solution) can't make CRM work I don't know what other business could.

Don't knock nurses, it's a time-honored profession. Heaven help us if your AI machine replaces them too. Hope there are plenty of IT consultants around when that happens, hopefully they can propose a solution to take care of that problem when it happens.

Too bad you didn't read the original post and reply to it as the poster had requested, replying to my post and making little of an important topic doesn't help anyone least of all the post's originator.

by gentlerf

What kind of rewarding are you looking for? Teaching certainly is one method when you desire to pass on the benefits of your lifetime of learning. I view things this way, if can touch in a positive way a single life, that should be reward enough. Because you cannot change the world like flipping a light switch, this does not mean one cannot begin a process of change. One area to begin a process of change is in teaching math or science. I have a son who is going to be an electrical engineer. While I didn't precisely teach him where to go, I did encourage him to find his own way and offer what help I could to get there. You could do a similar approach with those you propose to teach.

by retaf

There are times in the past when I felt the same way when I was in a different career. However, I am now working in a local school system as a middle school technology assistant. The joy I get seeing the students grow, both in their knowledge and learning how to use computers, makes it all worth while. I stepped into this position about four years ago when the technology at this middle school was going down hill. Although, I was supposed to be helping in other areas around the school, I took it upon myself to get the technology program back on its feet and stop relying on the district's tech support as the previous technology assistant was about a year behind in all aspects from software upgrades to equipment repair. Now the only time I see tech support is when I am stumped and call them to get another eye on the problem. I know I still have much to learn in IT, and I could make more money working for someone else, but working for the school system has big rewards by watching the students grow in all aspects, not just technology. Granted there are times when I see the district tech support trying to work on a shoe string budget in our poor district, but it could give you some pride in your work knowing you can do things you are not expected to do, because you want to make things better. Do not give up on yourself or your career, try different areas in IT. Good Luck!

by oppvill

It's not the IT field that is intrinsically evil, it's
how the skills are put to use. You won't get
rich working for a non-profit organization, but
at least you "do no harm." I am the sole
person in charge of IT at an agency providing
services to individuals with disabilities. I'm in
a rural area, underpaid, and spread thin; I
don't directly affect the people we serve, just
support others who do. However...I've always
derived some satisfaction from knowing that,
ultimately, I am helping the greater good in my
own backyard, rather than lining the pockets of
a rich corporate owner. We've considered
hiring an IT professional to be part of the
team, but despair of ever finding someone
with good skills who will work for less than the
going rate in for-profit sectors (and less
prestige). There are lots of non-profits like us
in the same boat. Hopefully there are more
people out there like you who want a deeper
meaning behind their technical skills. At the
very least, you can volunteer your services.
We have tech volunteers who support a
computer lab for our clients; help our re-sale
shop post items on eBay; refurbish donated
equipment; and we could find many more
similar tasks, if we had enough qualified and
interested volunteers . It's not rocket science
-- just simple ways someone with strong
computer skills could help others in need and
feel good at the same time. Maybe that's
more valuable than being tops in your field.
Good luck in changing the world.

by gentlerf

Volunteering any skill you have is always a positive thing even when it (the skill) isn't directly IT related. I currently am volunteering to take care of the library in the senior/disabled/low income housing where I now live after being homeless for almost a year. I am refurbing older computers as well for those folks here who either don't have one or the one they have has gone south. And yes, I do teach when asked.

by rfdemond

Sometimes you need to look beyond the job itself as a source of fulfillment of your soul and look at what it enables you to do for others outside the work itself. For example, being in IT certainly pays more than a number of other professions that may have more of a feeling of self satisfaction and contribution to soceity. Use that to help others and contribute to the world. Also, as others have suggested, use your skills to volunteer to help others less fortunate, working with a charity to help train inner city children develop basic IT skills is certainly a noble and rewarding use of your skills. Lastly, don't be afraid to become a mentor to others at work. Personally, that is where I gained my sense of well being when in the Corporate world, I always had a few minorty or female employees that I provided career direction, sponsorship, basic life mentoring etc and I always found that to be extremely rewarding. I've been self employed now for 10 years, however, a number of the people I mentored over the years still keep in touch with me on a regular basis and it is extremely rewarding to see these people develop in their careers and in their personal lives and to know that I helped enable them to improve their lives and in turn helped them to help others as well. There are many ways in life to achieve the kind of self satisfaction and inner peace that you appear to be seeking, don't make the mistake of assuming that you can only achieve this through the work that you do, don't let your employment define you as a person, let your inner person show through by the way in which you use the gifts given to you and the resources at your disposal. I hope that this is useful to you...

by answerman

Check this out people. This is a job advertisment I found from a fairly reputable job site. I contacted the company with a nasty email, although I don't usually do that.... But since we're talking about the value of IT, and whether that's a beneficial career path, I thought I'd share......

HERE IS THE ADVERTISMENT FOR THE JOB:

Desired Skills and Qualifications:

2-3 years of significant Call Center support experience preferred
Ability to work weekends and evenings
Strong hardware knowledge
Strong understanding of network concepts and troubleshooting including TCPIP, VPN, dedicated and dial-up Internet connectivity, LAN/WAN?
Strong familiarity with Windows NT 4.0 and Windows 2000.
DOS ?batch file creation skills.
Knowledgeable of PCAnywhere and VNC
ISQL abilities and understanding of Windows registry
Excellent customer service skills
Proven commitment to quality

Position Summary:

Resolve escalated customer technical issues utilizing hardware and software expertise.
Provide advanced troubleshooting of escalated support calls through remote support utilities.
Thoroughly document support calls following established procedures and guidelines.
Provide direct support to Level 1 staff members by accepting and resolving escalated issues.
Assist in providing technical documentation and information to Call Center department.
24x7x52 on-call availability via pager.

Description:
Leading developer of point of service retail store management software and business intelligence systems for loss prevention, customer solutions and e-commerce integration.

And the price tag for all this knowledge?

$25,000 per year......

I was so "moved" by this outpouring of reward someone "unfortunate" enough to have to take this job, that I sent this response to the company:

25,000 a year? 24x7x52 on-call availability via pager?

You people are out of your minds! No wonder the computer industry is sinking into the crapper. That combined with outsourcing to non-english or part-english speaking people (especially on American made products, which REALLY makes me happy).... The entire country is going to suffer for your immediate gain.....It will effect you too someday!! Have some pride in your country, your product, and your people.

Wonderful stuff. $12 and hour. That's why I spent big bucks for school, so I can make ALMOST as much as an Assistant Manager at McDonalds........ geeeeeez.

by buschman_007

The poster's original post is a little devisive. I think what he really is getting at is, "If IT's job is to make a business more efficient and if business is destroying mankind, then we IT are making that death more efficient, therefore we are morally bankrupt". Correct me if I'm wrong, but it's what I'm gathering from reading packratt's responces to other people.

Your whole ideal is based around the assumption that Business is detrimental to mankind. That's worth discussing, but sort of out of the scope of this question.

I think Lolek hit it on the head. On a humanitarian scale your global value depends on the company you are making more efficient. What do they stand for.

We all took aptitude tests as children and no one was told they are destined to be a garbage man. But the fact remains that there are still garbage men out there. It's wonderful to have ideals. But Ideals don't put a roof over your head and food on the table. I'm not saying this justifies any means to achieve that end. But trying to achieve moral self actualizion shouldn't be either. There needs to be a mix.

Sometimes you have to push your morals to the side, but you should never lose sight of them. I work for a software company that develops telecom software for the AT&T, Global Crossing, and Verizon's of the world. Is my company helpiung or hurting mankind? I'm sure you could find exampoles to support both. The majors carriers have crushed small businesses which makes them seem evil. But without their infrastructure how would you make that 911 call to save someone grandmother from dying? It's all in how you look at it.

Mike

by admin17

Other than insinuating that IT workers are uneducated, I agree with you. There's a lot of work to be done whether in IT or in CEx level management.

by gentlerf

You have hit the nail squarely on the head. IT is an area where we do affect the internal "customers" of the overall company. The tool room in a manufactory doesn't produce a product, but they do allow the machinists, etc., to do theirs in as an effective manner as possible. I for one build cabinetry as a sideline or to meet someone else's needs. Just for myself, a handsaw and miter-box are sufficient tools. To do it commercially, I would need a shop with table saw, power miter saw, drill press and various jigs to make it a production center.

by johnr

I went through a similar career crises about 10 years ago. I like the challenge of solving problems that IT offers, but there was no other "greater good" satisfaction working on projects that I struggled to "beleive in." I was considering switching careers completely but through some luck and a little persistance found that I could work for organizations that do good work and need strong IT support. During a carrer search I stopped focusing on the traditional IT shops in my area and started searching for jobs with companies that did good work and just happened to need IT professionals (non profits, some governemtn agencies, etc.). In the past years I've been able to support initiatives including blood-banking, HIV/AIDS education and prevention in the US and abroad and Vaccine safety, to name a few. My pay has probably lagged those that chased opportunities with start-ups, telecom, etc. but I feel that no matter how bad the day has been, in the end I know I've been able to contribute to something bigger.

Hang in there, find your passion and follow it. I used to think that was a hollow assertion, but now I'm a beleiver.

by bbarnes3

I am currently 55 and have been in and out of IT since 1980 and what I can tell you is this; Computers are an integral part of today's workplace. People (the workers) must use computers to accomplish their tasks, and anyone who helps them do that has value. Whether you support hardware or software, or write software, or develop hardware, or train the end user, or build or maintain stable networks, you're an important link in that IT chain.

I current support the students, staff, and faculty of a university. Everytime I help the light to go on in someone's brain, it's been a good day. I do lots of other IT stuff, but it's that light going on that makes my day.

by rnmpleasant

First, most of us got involved with IT for one of 2 reasons. Either we enjoyed making machines and code do our bidding and solving the problems put in front of us or we enjoyed making a nice wage and being in ?demand?. Truth be told, many IT employees didn?t start out in IT but found their marketing or philosophy degrees just didn?t give them many opportunities. At this point, it should have happened that they asked ?What should I do with my life and how much value do I want to contribute?? but they instead probably asked ?How do I get jobs that pay well??
Also, not many people actually journey down the road of asking what kinds of differences they wish to make in the world else we would have more teachers and volunteers.
Having said all of that, I do understand your perspective and it is probably just a fact of normal growth and maturity that you are asking this. So, now that you are asking, you can only decide if you are not making the difference you wish in the world and take the appropriate steps to make any changes you see as necessary.
In the world of IT, you are seeing what many never dreamed possible but is the same cycle as any other industry. When unionized wages ( and the costs of running a mill in the US) became too high to make profitable products in the steel industry, massive layoffs, bankruptcies, and off shore competition took over. Now, American Steel products are back but in a controlled manner on a smaller scale than before. I wonder if any steel workers asked about the true value of their occupation (that seemed to be easily replaced by foreign workers).
The same issue is underway for IT. While the growth years were great, many of us got fat off the easy wages and unfounded reverence for our abilities. Not to say that we haven?t earned respect but most corporations don?t have a great understanding of what we truly can do and just accepted that we were the wiz kids that would drive profits up.
Seeing that it is not that easy, many US corporations have jumped to the conclusion that if they must invest in IT, as a ?cost center?, then they should look to outsource for the cheapest costs. History shows this will change too because cheapest is not the same as best.
As for you, maybe the issue is really that you are working in IT but for the wrong people. NASA, SETI and others seek to use technology for discovery. There are many other endeavors such as using technology to overcome handicaps, increase learning and such, all of which seem to be self evident in the value they bring. Quite possibly there is some area in your own backyard that you may see as an opportunity to use your skills for 'the greater good'. Most of these do not appeal to the masses because they do not command highest wages but are worthwhile and most likely enjoyable. Maybe you should look into switching where you work.

by unclerob

Your reply kinda hurt, I don't think the original poster was looking for that kind of response and he was asking some decent questions. I wouldn't call it liberal crap either, just an opinion given freely asking for some input from others in this line of work. You will say that your opinion was given freely too but there is a difference, he didn't attack anyone with his original post he just asked some serious questions. I believe most people got into IT for the same reasons as you specified but I think it's foolish to think everyone can hold on to & maintain that original feeling.

I don't think he ever said he was jealous or rich people, he's just observant of the situation around him and I would wager that the same issues hold true in alot of different companies & organizations.

Alot of the companies were working for are fortune 500 businesses, probably been around for decades or more and developed into the businesses they are today and as such probably didn't have to go through that mess of red tape you mentioned. As much as we've gone forward, it's probably harder today than any other time to start a successful business. Don't stick up for rich people, they have lawyers for that kind of stuff and their lives are padded enough so they don't require any additional defense. Another point to take into account is that it isn't hard to question your work if you've ever been in the position of working for what you thought was a strong & vibrant company but turned out to be a cash cow for rich people who think they can rape a company and an industry dry (see Enron, Tyco, Worldcom, etc.) Do you know everything that your employer does, how honest are they, is it possibly that your company could be next? In such an age where companies fold faster than a deck of playing cards, it's easy to question your work & your worth and your role in helping your employer possibly perform a similar feat.

You probably don't know about aspects of his personal nature like time, drive or education so you shouldn't comment on those things either.

As for privacy and security, it's 2005 and it's sad to say that we have none of those things on this connected planet we live in and it would be foolish to think you or other IT Pro's can accomplish things like that. Information technology is such that our goal is provide the tools that provide access to information to ourselves, our peers, our employers, other businesses, the world, etc. In such an environment where the transfer of information is a constant you will never achieve total privacy & security. If Microsoft can't do it what makes you think other "IT Pro's" can. Whatever measures are in place to protect privacy & security, there will always be countermeasures to circumvent any protection available - that's the flipside of human nature, on one side there are those that that try to help others, on the other side there are those that take advantage of others. Don't fault anyone for questioning their current position and what they're doing and where they fit in.

As for the trees, it's winter right now, once the snow melts, I may actually look for a tree to hug. You may want to try it yourself, I hear it's quite "liberating" and maybe you need a hug.

...That's my 0.02 cents.

by admin17

Unless you're working for a small company, in which the scale of a layoff would be greatly reduced, efficiency gains to not go straight to the CEO's pocket. The CEO is, by and large, a salaried worker like the rest of us (albeit with a few extra perks for being in his position). The CEO's job is to increase the profitability of the ORGANIZATION at which he is employed on behalf of the owners (shareholders). Those increased profits go to help fund the salaries of you and your fellow employees.

by sixaxis

Without people to build and maintain the plethora technologies that exist today, there would be an unspeakable loss world wide. Can you imagine where Stephen Hawkings would be right now, without Text to speech software and all the other technologies he has available to him? He would be parked in a corner of some institution, incommunicado and wasting, probably considered retarded and useless.
These technologies that we work on every day have given countless souls new ways to communicate, learn and teach.
When I was in the Air Force, I was a nuclear weapons tech on the B-1 and B-52 platforms, and I often thought what a strange situation I was in that if I performed my job as well as I could, and made sure everything under my control functioned perfectly, someday a massive group of people might be vaporized. I was able to weigh that notion against what could happen if I did not perform my duties to the best of my abilities, and I soon lost any sense of guilt on the matter.
You need to love what you do, and accept that you are part of a larger construct that may move in directions that you find less than palatable. But that does not have to degrade your personal fulfillment of having done your personal and moral best with the task at hand.
I often told people back then that I hated my work, but I loved my job. I still work in aviation, and I keep medevac helicopters up and running. A job I would not have discovered had I not first entered the field by way of keeping weapons of mass destruction functioning.
Its all a big give and take.

by tired-tech

lso workin an enviroment where we lok like we are automating ourselves out of a job. Our OS in more stable, the apps are better, etc.
So now we don't need as many folks to do the work. Those of us who have been here for a while (when the boom was going) are the really seeing this and feel a little frustration because we can't figure out why.. we did our job !!!
amybe a little too well (if that is possible)
I have also used my "career" in IT to further my music interest ( playing on the weekends and such) and just like the entertainment arena when cost sutting starts where do you look ? the "extras" as we are known. companies that are trying to get us outsourced for less money because there are more of us ...!!

butI digress the value of IT you only see it when it doesn't work and you need it fixed,.... yesterday

peace

by rascal1981

Reading through this topic and your posts has left me thinking that maybe you need to consider a more charitable line or work; The truth is that business is business and you do end up looking out for number 1, whether that is you directly or lining your CEO's pockets with cost reduction in head count in order to get that bigger bonus. Seeing a value in this is easy enough; more money = better lifestyle for you and your family and means you are doing a better job (most of the time) which means your end users are benefiting from your work as well.

While you may not be changing the world, tell me what job is? I mean do you really think giving that $5 to the bell ringer in front of your grocery store is saving someone's life in a 3rd world country?? While this may seem harsh it is the unavoidable truth of any job in business. Your productivity does lead to layoffs, cutbacks, reduction, etc... and more money for you (for the most part in the form of bonuses, raises, etc...) and if you feel guilty about that or are looking for deeper satisfaction you will have to look a little further outside of IT and business in general to find it.

Does this sound cold? Most likely but I am a surrealist person who believes the truth; yes what I do may put someone out of business but in this fast paced world, who wouldn't/doesn't do the same? And if it benefits me/my family why shouldn't I?

by gentlerf

In that vein, I would think many of the Protestant denominations could use the benefits of your skills and not just voluntarily either. My local Episcopal Diocese has offered me a position to assist local parishes to become more efficient through technology.

by gentlerf

A bit wordy but makes sense. Another way would be that when a company insists on viewing people as numbers and not names, time to pull the plug.

by frank_gonzalez

Hi, Not too long ago, I worked on a government contract that had to do with developing database applications that would help the government entity I was working for 'catch the bad guys'. I felt I had a true supporting role in helping our guys out in the field. I think maybe sometimes since we lose sight ( as well as those in other departments) of just how important our jobs are. Currently, I work for a small company (back in the private sector). The work I'm doing now is developing applications for the chamber of commerce...helping them draw more businesses into the area. My company is a smaller company and the way I look at it...my sense of purpose is to help contribute, in any way I can, to the livelihood that keeps our company alive and breathing. I do alot of volunteer work in my community that has to do with using my skills. All in all it really depends on one's perspective. Search for balance, and if you're still not happy then move on...life's too short.

by gary_joanne

I agree with most of what you've said aaron and appreciate the feedback, but facing the reality of what exists, creates positive change. Sure, I've got some hands on experience, I program, I maintained a LAN network for over 1-year, run my own ecommerce site, design Web pages, do technical support out of my home and maintain a small income at home, but lets look at the facts. You can say leave politics out of it, but clearly you must have been one to vote for Bush. That's okay and some of what he does is good. I'm not a Democrate of Republican, I'm for the person who does the best for our country and I don't really care who that is as long as it's our best interest as Americans who is gaining. Clearly things need to be done. Instead of rewarding people for outsourcing, tax them so that it makes more common sense to keep the business(workers) here employed. I've got friends who were/are programmers making decent money, yet now, they outsource the programming for low prices. I go to help people be repairing their equipment and at times, I've had to call my customers tech support for their broken down equipment and I sit on the phone for hours and when I do get someone on the phone, it's someone in India who I have no idea what he/she is saying. As with most of my customers, I get the response, (I've had it with them! Every time I call them, I can't understand them!). That seems to be the overall concensus in that area. Reality is, I'm somewhat thankful for that because it's been keeping me into some sort of income on the side. It doesn't matter who's in office, who does what, but I will say that changes need to happen for positive change to affect the IT world. Businesses are scared to invest in the IT departments because they don't know whether they will go broke tomorrow. In other words, tight with their money. Now, tell me I'm wrong? And, before IT, I was a manager for over 15-years and in charge of hiring and firing, I never brought in a persons views other than what they felt they had to offer on the job.

by steve v

To answer your point on "IT being worthwhile", I think you have to look at the company that you work for in order to "SEE" value in your work. If you work for some financial conglomerate who's only interest is making money so that the investors and upper tier management remains happy. I would see this as not as rewarding as, let's say working for a hospital where patient records and important medical data is stored on the network. in these 2 examples there is a true difference between life and death if data loss and communication failure was to occur.
ON your other point of IT being a cost center; this is the nagover effect from the DOT COM era of IT. Business owners and corporate management realized the error that was made by throwing large amount of money into unproven technology and idea, and it bit them in the butt. Now they do not want to repeat that process.

Now on your last point of wanting to accomplish some social value. You would have to find some sort of project that is related to working with your community and fulfilling any type of need related to the IT industry.

IT is not about social harmony. It is about one's and zero's harmony. We are a behind the scenes industry that no one pays attention to until something breaks. We are there to make sure that everything runs smoothly so that their jobs easier. We are here to make sure that the data that is created and saved is there for tomorrow nad the next day. We keep companies going so that everone that comes through the doors in the morninf still have a job to go to, so they can feed their families, pay the rent, and stay alive.

by worm farmer

I'd like to add to this message and say Ditto. I get more satisfaction knowing that I am respected for WHO I am, rather than WHAT I am. Smarts, IQ, College Education...sure that matters for WHAT a person is, but in order for anybody to realize that you are out there to change the world, you must take a look at the world from inside yourself. Respect others and they will respect you.
I know a hundreds of people who were laid off during the "Bad Economy" 2001-2003, many of my IT friends were out of work for months. They were smart, had years of IT, or software developing experience. Those who succeded at obtaining work during that period were not always the "Bosses friend of a friend" but were those who know how to treat and respect others.

---------

There are 2 rules for success in life:
1- Don't tell anyone everything you know.

by cg it

many many IT people lamate about the lack of a hot job market, promotion opportunities, in the information technology field. Well, its no different than any other field like engineering, medicine, nursing, banking, blah blah, yadda yadda. If the "hot market" becomes engineering, "everyone" becomes an engineer, when there is a down turn, engineers moan and groan about the state of the industry, then become real estate agents. Happens all the time in the aerospace field. IT is no different. Those in the IT field that actually "like" it [like the nerds] will stay and find a home someone happily doing their thing. Those that only got into IT for the $$ will move on to the next "hot field".

If those thinking of a career in IT do so because of the $$ and not because it's their personal interest, get into real estate or medicine and become a doctor. They make gobs of $$.

by minjb

It's nothing personal, just business. Lining the executives pockets with extra cash, improving efficieny, and overall improving the bottom line, that's business. Corporations make sure you are compensated, (most times not well enough in IT), for working the business. Wanting to make an impact in the world, even if the world is your community, that's personal. Personal aspirations incur a cost for a business. To give something and without an expectation of an ROI is contrary to good business.

Don't let business requirements interfere with your personal aspirations. I too am pondering whether I should leave corporate IT for teaching. I have been considering teaching math and or english to those in underserved high schools of New York City. It is a sad thing to see students full of energy and excitement going off to college only to have their excitement crushed because before they can start taking classes, they are placed in a remedial program to get them up to speed.

Provide excellent IT service and maybe someone will remember your labor. Provide an excellent teaching and you are guaranteed to never be forgotten. Do what you can for who you can. Most of all do all you can for your family. They are the ones who are going to remember you the most.

by rebjava

Packratt,

The simple fact remains that technology and business are permanently married. And as much as managers and executives hate to admit it, the costs of IT are the costs of doing business. Unfortuneately, IT professionals (and we are professionals) are like any other business supply. For example, a business needs paper to operate, and you can bet the company is going to doggedly search to find the cheapest multiuse paper that will meet their needs. Even when they've found their paper, they're going to continue to look for a better deal. That's the nature of the profit driven beast. Don't take it personally.

However, do continually update and expand your skills. Do this for yourself and not for your employer. If you lack job satisfaction, look for an IT gig revolving around the medical or educational fields or perhaps even something in the .gov domain. You'll be doing something worthwhile for somebody in any of these fields. I did it and I'm much happier now. Good luck to you.

by frustrated_user

Well, first the gripes as a user & then some tips which could make you IT guys better loved, respected & valued by end users but not by your super rich bosses/owners who just want more profits.
........I've been using IT since 1996. I thought I should become PC literate at age 47 for my daughter's sake (school use etc...). Well......... it's been & continues to be a VERY frustrating experience! Constant upgrading, crashes, lost data on re-installs (XP lets you encrypt with no warning to back up the certificate.....nice one guys!!!!!!!!!) software bloat rendering the PC useless without upgrading memory/cpu/disks/etc), software claims that don't stack up when you try them or maybe do just once but not next time you try, constant re-configuring req. as bits of programs fail (XP is better but still too many problems). I build my PCs & in the last 8 years seem to be constantly chasing the dream of a PC I can set up & just USE! Fat chance! I now realise that 'windows' means never pausing with what you have for an instant. Suddenly that hardware you bought just 2 years ago won't work with XP, new drivers req., search around, install, re-configure, test, OK! Then something else happens......software you don't use very often.....launch the program...crash.....won't work at all on XP! Damn! Too much changed now, have to buy new software to do that job, yet more expense! Get the picture? See now why we all see you as a reluctantly necessary cost/evil/nuisance/profit generator (for yourself & others - not us!). All us end users want is a PC that runs our programs & continues to do so stably. If you perfected the operating systems/software we have & didn't dump it, half tested upon us, then move onto the next, bigger, more expensive, resource hungry version & try to flog that, we would be much happier. If you ever thought about the end users you would not bloat the programs with all the bells & whistles. You would cut it down to the basics so it could still run on, say, win 95 with a P100, 64 mb ram & a 5 gb disk. Just think how it would FLY on a fast PC!! By all means offer the full program at great cost to those that want it but stop this enforced upgrading - it's alienating end users.
As for enriching the human race - no, I don't think you've contributed much in that field. Society is worse now as people sit in their rooms, alone, surfing, searching, downloading, trying to use their PCs instead of interacting. PCs waste resources as 'old' ones (2 years old!!!!) are not recycled & this must surely be one of the ultimate IT failures? We now have dramatic increases in internet pornography & paedophilia plus an amazing increase in paper consumption as everything STILL has to be kept on paper as PC storage is so unreliable.........I can well understand the questioning of IT as a career & whether it is really worthwhile. I personally wish we could turn back the clock & not have the PC.

by crake

Sounds like your post is directed at Microsoft - not IT as a profession.

Besides - let's suppose your computer actually did run perfectly. How exactly would you use it to enrich the human race?

You gave an excellent example in explaining that your daughter uses her computer for school.

So do I. The volume and quality of resources available to us are vastly improved over that time in the past you seem to pine for. The price for accessing this endless wealth of data is that the end-user needs to be able to distinguish between what is credible and what is B.S.

More examples of enriching the human race?

Do you realize the same technology that accommodates convenient online banking is also used to set up charity funds for - say - tsunami victims? Cancer patients? Families who have lost loved ones?

Of course - you couldn't know that the new cancer-fighting drug, Tarceva, is a part of my daily fight against Stage IV Rencal Cell Carcinoma and that I wouldn't have known about it without the Internet (at least not until it became FDA approved several years from now - if even then - and if I were still alive).

Now, onto your diatribe regarding crashing PCs, bloated software, porno, et al.

**If there were no demand, there would be no supply.** End of story.

In effect, most of your gripes should be directed at - well - yourself and the end-user community. Microsoft (or whoever) spits out these "upgrades" and "improvements" because R&D tells them that's what their customers want.

Ask any company and they will tell you that their first priority is to generate profit and grow. Business 101.

As an IT professional, I handle all facets of managing that crappy software you bought - including security, SPAM prevention, antivirus, Wi-Fi configurations, disaster recovery, etc.

But I didn't code the stuff, and I don't sell it.
(I'm more of a Linux guy anyhow.)

As far as "people sitting in their rooms, alone, surfing, searching, downloading, trying to use their PCs instead of interacting;" I can only say it sounds like you are describing (projecting?) your personal experience.

I spend each day on the computer - it is part of my job. I also personally interact with hundreds of people every week. That is another part of my job. I also enjoy a highly social recreational life - even with cancer.

I believe a person's experience with technology is much like the rest of life - it's what you make of it.

by darkar

I read many years ago, I think it was in a Tom Peters book, about the differences between Americans and Europeans view of their lives. In America if you ask a person what they are, they will normally give you their job title, i.e. IT person, banker, nurse, or what ever. In Europe if you ask a banker what he is, he may answer a mountain climber, a painter, a sailor, or what ever it is, he views himself as. His job is just the way he makes his living. If you want to ?make a difference?, do your job to support yourself and any family you may have and then go make your difference, be a social worker, help build a house for someone, help in your community. Don?t tie your job, hopefully something you?re good at and enjoy, to who you are or what you do.

by bw3

At times during my 25 year IT career I've had similar thoughts. I think some of the problem is being someone who likes to help people but being on the back end I don't see constant reminders of how users benefit. And without good management and leaders IT is quite often left out of the rewards and recognition that companies realize. I consider myself fortunate however because most of the time I feel I add value to my company and its customers. I have also chosen to work for non-profit organizations in education and healthcare. Two areas I feel add great value and service to our communities. And there's pro's and con's to everything and one of the con's with my choices have been lower salaries. It has been worth it though. Each year I speak at a local university to IT students about IT careers. The most important advice I give them is to read an article by Po Bronson titled "What Should I Do With My Life? The real meaning of success - and how to find it". I found it to be an excellent article and you can find it at http://www.fastcompany.com/online/66/mylife.html
Hang in there and keep looking, I'm sure there's a place out there for you.

by steverd

I would agree about splitting your time. I've been in various engineering, systems developement, and management positions over the last 25 years. Although I enjoy my work, it sometimes left me hollow. I eventually realized that fulfillment came from areas other than work - family and spiritual areas.

I strive to do the best that I can in my career. I do it because it is a means to an end. It makes other things possile which are important - supporting my family, church, etc. This is where my heart is.

If you enjoy your career, don't try to get too much out of it. Use it as a means to an end and find fulfillment elsewhere. If you don't like your career, it's never too late to work towards a change.

by pstorli

Would you say a career in television is worthless? That actors have no purpose? Well, ITs global reach is even greater than television and movies. I have written several programs that affect thousands of people, if not millions. My software makes what they are trying to do easier. We, as programmers, can affect the world in a way that no other technology can. We can and are having an impact on the world. It is how we use technology that determines if it is good or bad, not the technology itself.

by barbmac

Teaching IT is a great career. As you rightly point out, education should not just be about passing exams and learning a trade or 'job skills'. Many students hate school, and it is soul destroying to do something you hate for years. Generally, students love IT. Whether they eventually work in the industry or not, in IT classes they master skills that will be of use in virtually any working environment while having lots of fun, improving their own confidence and self respect. That is a job worth doing.

by phelms

Doing things more efficiently means more than ease. In some cases it means being able to do something that would have otherwise been impossible, such as controlling massive amounts of air traffic.

by joia

Packratt,

There are some very thoughtful replies in this thread, and I've enjoyed reading them. What occurs to me is that it may not be the *profession* you are in that is the problem, it may be the industry!

It's clear that the people in the healthcare IT field feel like they add value to people's lives...both healthcare workers and patients. Maybe you should think about shifting your career to a different industry, where the work you do and the people you serve would provide the personal satisfaction and sense of pride and self-worth you seem to be seeking.

by networks

...comes to mind! Earl Nightengale once quoted on a 'self development' tape series..."you are paid in direct portion for your ability to do the work, the demand for what you do, and the difficulty in replacing you..."

For example, a janitor can be easily taught the cleaning skills. While the demand for a janitor may seem high [ assuming there were only a few ], there would exist little difficulty in replacing them, when compared to a 'brain surgen', who after many years of consentrated and competitive training and education, might receive several hundreds of thousands of dollars, for what he or she does, compared to the janitor at say 30 or 40k.

Therefore, worth could be combined with level of service to others, through sacrifices for the benefit of others.

I am too, a veteran of IT. Approximately 18 years devoted to this field, including teaching at several colleges and one institute of technology. I too am considering updating my credentials again. I am looking at Forensic Computer Crime and/or Security based certificates as a new venture to pursue going forward. I am 48 now, and with still a young family to raise, I must look at upgrading my skills, because I too feel a little stale with the IT/IS career.

Our organization has global reach, but much of the infrastructure building is complete and fairly recent. As a Network Analyst, little more than maintaining the flock for most of the forseeable future.

So, expand your horizons Packratt, because it should trigger a new joy to serve others, in what ever capacity you can achieve!

All the best!!!

by raazeez

I'd like to believe that we are IT professionals due to our belief in the technology and in those it serves. I've asked myself this question, because this has been an issue for me for some time now.

It wasn't until I crossed over to the business side of technology that my purpose as a technology professional became clear. You see, as an IT professional, I could only see the technology. I knew it was good for the company, the employees and the clients these systems served. However, because information technology is OUR business, we tend to lose perspective on OUR purpose. Our purpose for being IS TO SERVE THE BUSINESS, NOT JUST THE TECHNOLOGY. Therefore, we must do more than serve the technology...WE MUST SERVE THE BUSINESS!

As IT professionals, we must be willing to round out our profession with good, solid business sense. We must find ways to present the business case for technology. We can do this in a number of ways; cost comparisons, analysis, and savings must be done and presented to the business. Savings analysis and reports should be performed, as well, in order to prove our worth to the Company.

Ours is an intangible world. One that is rooted in controlling the flow of information. Turn off the computer and all you have is a commodity. Turn on the computer and you have a transport for commerce. Operating systems, service packs, virus protection, virtual private networks, e-mail clients and browsers only exist when the computer system is on!! Although technology's importance is realized everyday, we must commit ourselves to the quantification and qualification of technology's presence for the business and thusly for ourselves.

We can prove to our children that we did _____, because we make businesses GO! The trick is to turn the intangible into the tangible.

I believe the IT field offers more of a career path today and in the future, because the technology era is still in its infancy. We are becoming more than IT professionals, we are becoming IT practitioners, not unlike our legal, medical, and dental counterparts.

The answer to the Real Value of IT Work? question may lie in OUR rediscovery and redefinition of the field of IT.

by dohnotgood

I have had two diiferent job paths. The first was public health were i practiced epidemiology. I loved it but was tired of grant work which was the majority of work in my city. So I went into web development and eventaully database administration in the Distance Learning field with nothing to do with public health and I started to feel just like you. I worked long hours on skeleton crews to make things happen. But I still felt empty. So i stared to look for IT related jobs in the Public Health sector. It took me a year and a half and I was able to and did move within State to take a jobe where I am assiting in the development of a state wide web based disease surveillance system and loving it. I get to practice Epidemiology while keeping my hands wet with data modeling and messaging infrastructures.

by seanpol

I would like to have had the social impact of Ghandu, MLK, Lincoln, Malcom X, or even my drill instructor.
The meaning and purpose of life's worth is in you and is not defined by what you kill and drag home to feed your young.
Do well and be happy in your work, then if you need more sustenance, do volunteer work , or raise a family if you really want to have all of the life challenges and smiles you want.
Being a good dad is tough, being a good geek pales in comparison.
I gave up my job with IBM, for a number of reasons
among them I found a maintenance job that paid more, and let me work with my hands, and be around
kids.
As the saying goes "Life is where you find it"
My neighbor was having a hard time with a break job, I dragged out my compressor and helped him with the hard part, just becaause I could.
I do volunteer tech support, on line for Five Star, and have learned patience dealing with end users who just do the weirdest things, and are spectacularly clueless.
So enjoy your work, make lots of money and learn to share your happiness.
Seanpol

by lister of smeg

I am an IT Consultant and my clients are mainly organisations trying to make money. But with the knowledge, resources and time that this career provides me, I am able to help some very worthy charities for free. I can't tell you how much the charity sector needs the help of IT Consultants - the majority of small charities are an IT nightmare, with no means of repairing or fixing their problems. The most infuriating part for me is usually how minor the problems are and how much difference I could have made if I had been there earlier! Instead of lining the pockets of the few, you can help the people who help the many. I get my clients to donate their old equipment to the charities that need it the most. This is a double edged sword as the charities are able to help my clients by safely disposing or reusing the old equipment and the client often comes round to the idea of offering their skills to help the charity. This part of my job is by far the most rewarding - and it gives me the sense of self worth I think you are looking for.

by reflecting on history

Greetings,
You?ve made a significant statement when you link the question to: what might I tell my children. It seems to me the underlying questions is: Is there a direct relationship between IT (what I do for a living) and what is happening in the world. The focus here is ?direct relationship?.

As a college professor, adjunct, in a multi-disciplinary school, University of Phoenix: Seattle, this question constantly occurs because I work with students who are considering IT as a career and because I work with students employed in IT who are leaving the profession. These students want to know if they are making the world better than it was when they started working in IT. They seek to offer something of themselves as they try to engage problems related to food, shelter, hunger, etc. The recent Tsunami has helped focus this question for many people. The answer to this question is both yes and no.

IT will never have a direct link to anything that is occurring in the world. However, it does enable efforts to change the world, sometimes for the better, sometimes not. I was trained, doctoral level, as a theologian and so these questions and comments are important to me as we all struggle to help make the world a better and safer place. Still IT can never be linked to a substantial change in quality of life. It can however be linked to changes in life. It is the use of IT and the benefits derived from IT that will make the difference, if and only if, there is a concerted effort to distribute the benefits across the entire population rather than on the up side of the digital divide.

A major concern for many of us is the lack of the IT benefit across the population, particularly in second and third world countries. Because IT, science, and engineering workers earn substantially more than non-IT workers they are in a position to help change their environment. Yet this is not so much their possibilities but the purview of the business community and its willingness to redistribute income outside of the direct arena.

As an individual, you make possible the existence of a better world. For example you speed up the tracking and movement of medical supplies, the use of technology in schools, or the distribution of food. You may not directly distribute any of these, but without your help it might not happen. You can also lobby your company to offer training for those who are interested but not skilled or provide resources to schools. You may not change the world because you work in IT, but the world may be better because you work in IT.

by ttoe

I have been thinking about the same issues over the last few years. Friends have been laid off because of/in spite of the efficiencies that my team has created. Wages haven't gone up, although benefits have been cut. The somber mood at this company sounds to be about par for the course right now.

However, I've realized that my skills and opportunities can be put to use anyway. Rather than quitting my job and dedicating my time overseas to the problems, I've found that there are plenty of things to do. It helps me sleep at night, although I will always wish I could do more. I've become a Big Brother (www.bbbsa.org), and I will be volunteering one night a week at a local shelter. Of course, there are plenty of opportunities available, wherever you are.

If that's not enough, you can always do your best to donate money to a charity doing good work. I like AmeriCares (www.americares.org) and Results (www.results.org) but with recent events, there are plenty all over the news.

Oh yeah, voting the correct way always helps too... ;-)

Don't give up trying to improve the world around you. I can assure you, if there were more people who cared about this like you do, hunger and poverty would no longer exist.

Good luck!

by momtojustin

I agree that you can use the money you make in IT to fund what you want to do. In my case, my husband and I are using it to help fund our dream of adopting a special needs boy.

There are still orphanages in the US and so many children out there who need loving care. You need not be a foster or an adoptive parent. You can also just visit a kid who has no visitors at all or volunteer to help out in some other way.

If you are in Massachusetts, you can check out:

http://www.stvincentshome.org/
http://www.thehome.org/site/content/index.asp

Best of luck,
Renee

by momtojustin

If you believe it to be so ominous? To me, IT is like the TV industry. It can be used for ill or good.

Renee

by colinfromthecrypt

You can always turn the TV off. Just try to buy food without a computer in the shop, bank, service provider. Then again maybe there are still places in the world that use cash (for now).

by vanight

I too have have been reflecting much the same as you. For my self I simply had to realize that my true lifes purpose is not going to be found in my job. Now, I totally understand the lack of satisfaction in having "few" people outside of IT understand the value of what we do. My Dad is a builder and when he builds a house it absolutely puts me in AWE. Even someone that digs a ditch has the satisfaction of seeing the ditch when its done at the end of the day.

I have been reading a book called "The Purpose Driven Life" by Rick Warren. Be forewarned it is based in Christian principal, but regardless, it has been on the NY times best seller list for a long time and sold millions of copies. I will just say it helped me immensely and leave it at that.

Do you have an other hobbies you can do on the side to give you the satisfaction you desire? Music, Art, etc...

The issue here is an industry problem in my book. I strongly feel that there needs to be a change of accounting practice in order to truly change the attitude. On the other hand, I have been blessed to be working in a NOC that is a key profit producing center. Much of the problem is also in the way IT people have been slowly changed into viewing themselves. We need become agressive in showing the value and profit we can bring a company by being inovative and leveraging our skills and knowledge of software and hardware. Bottom line though, I sympathize with you as I have often reflected in the same way. Good luck in your self discovery and may you find the purpose your looking for.

David

by tomsutor

It seems back in the day before I got into IT whenever I would go to a place like CompUSA, the people always "talked down" to me like I was intrusive for asking IT questions about computers. When I started my home repair, I noticed the same attitude from competition IT people. Always being aloof and they are not to be questioned. Had IT been more caring and not so self satisfied with their knowledge, they might still be at the top of their profession. As it is, the high schools now teach IT as a trade and that will lower the price people will pay for IT. Also, now that IT has to give customer support to keep their job, only the best of both will get the high paying jobs.

by pm0020256

I've sept the majority of my adult working life in IT, and oh have I become so disenchanted with the whole thing. I've seen a ocean of inept senior management who just don't understand and in most case don't want to understand.

I used to think that IT is a true enabler, but your right it your speculation that the beancounters see it as overhead and senior management see it as a drain on the bottom line.

I also have that horrible feeling that I'v spent almost 20 years doing something of no value. I guess I'm lucky in one respect that I also hold a Facilities Managerment role, and do get a good deal of satisfaction from it, and if the truth where know I'd dump the IT Managers role in the blink of an eye.

by kdeva

For example, consider all the software that goes into medical equipments. Also, my first job in US was as a development tech lead for a Positive Train Separation System, software that is installed in locomotives and with the help of the servers installed in control rooms several thousand miles away and using GPs, will help in identifying any train that is moving on the same track ahead and then help in applying brakes when it is reaching its safe braking distance(in other words - getting "too close" to the other train). I felt proud that the software I was developing and helping others to develop was going to be deployed in all locomotives run by Union Pacific and might actually help in averting accidents thereby saving people's lives and property.

Now, just imagine if all our automobiles are equipped with similar software then it might prevent several accidents. In this process if a few CEOs pocket some money that should not be a big concern, right?

Also, consider the latest havoc that affected a dozen countries in the form of tsunami. Only if those countries had a tsunami warning system, then at least part of those loss to human lives could have been saved. If scientits can come up with probes that can detect such earthquakes and related tidal waves, then our internet and IT can play a major role in conveying those signals right from those probes to be broadcast to all the concerned nations.

So actually IT does make life on earth much better. And we as IT professionals do make a difference. Just dont get worried about the current lay-offs. As economy picks up further and more innovations spring up there will be retraining and reorientation of work force. I am not saying that there will be 100% reutilization, but a major number of people who were laid off will be rehired.

by cheaps

If you are looking for an absolute answer, I don't think you will succeed. One of the few people who resolved the thorny question you ask was St. Francis. But to do so, he had to withdraw from the world. If you remain in the world, you will have to compromise. So, although I think your question is certainly valid and respectable, I suggest you ponder the fact that there are other saints besides Francis. Even saints could be dirtied by the world of compromise, they just keep going.

Many of the responses add up to the simple recognition that the world, and the world of IT, are complex and defy sorting out. You must be young and still trying to do so. Consider other saints!

by the unknown it guy

I have been in the IT field for 20 years and worked for 3 different companies and every one of them has been the same. The feeling I have gotten every time is that IT is "a necessary evil".

by emlesz

I am an old timer (35 years) in the industry. Your problems will not change, you will just learn to manage them better. One of my Technology hero's Carl Sagan said:

Could there be some conceivable selective advantage in our evolutionary make-up? Our science and high technology have given us the ability to effect our long-term future as never before. Aren't these models of unflinching commitment to the truth more necessary to our survival than ever? The themes of the permanent revolution of science and the never-ending struggle to create and preserve a democratic society are interwoven throughout every one of these heroes of science.

IT is the new revolution, eclipsing the Industrial Revolution, so take heart and realise that your job is truly worth while.

by photontx

The big picture that we are discussing here is not being brought to light. Every business in the US is now impacted by technology, and if you are contributing member to the infrastructure of a company that is meeting public or government demands then you are an asset that is helping support the infrastructure of society.

For example, for the last 5 years I have worked for a two-way paging company, engineering, implementing, and maintaining their paging and database systems, whose services are utilized by physicians, surgeons, police, and emergency personnel. Those individuals depend on the robust, reliable, and advanced technological paging engines to help other people. Without my IT skills, and the IT skills of others these services wouldn't exist, and therefore more people would not be helped or possibly would die. I'd say that's just one direct example of how IT contributes, supports, and accelerates the rescue of mankind.

It all depends on your perspective of the big picture, and whether or not you're looking at it from 5 thousand or 30 thousand feet. Look at every business from a systemic standpoint and try to understand how improving the efficiency of any industry helps society. I think you'll find it's a quantifiable and qualitative value that simply needs a different perspective.

by dkucharski1

you wrote:
"I think it's more a question of, in the real scheme of things, what could I offer to people in need that they could use? My skills will not house a homeless person, they will not feed someone who needs food, they will not heal someone who is ill, etc... My skills serve no real purpose in the scheme of things, it seems artificial."
Search out those organizations that DO THOSE THINGS and offer yourself up as a VALUABLE ASSET to them at a BARGAIN PRICE so they can use their funding to contribute the services they provide in a more efficient manner. If a charitable organization is enriched by your contribution, then that charity they provide can be looked upon as a very satisfying, if not impressive part of your compensation. It seems that while the corporate elite have forgotten how to share the wealth, there are many others that still can and do. SEEK them out! With all of the disaster relief being generated right now I know that there are charitable organizations that NEED good people willing to use their talents to help spread the wealth. Good Luck In the QUEST! it is a noble aspiration!!

by gambi

Hey packrat - keep your chin up. I think of similar things and the one thing that keeps me going is that I am helping others to achieve this goal.

I think that dkucharski1 and AcesKaraoke@msn.com hit the nail on the head for me - I may not be able to find a cure for cancer or any significant thing like that, but sure as jolly I can give those people the IT support that they can not do without in this era.

So my name wont be on the list of people who discovered the cure for HIV or on the list of doctors etc who helped with any disaster relief or anything else (I suppose) but those people could not achieve those heights without people like you and me. As sad as it seems...

We have more contribution that what alot of people think.

Hold your head high because of IT.

by gometrics

Has automobiles improved our lives? How many carriage makers when out of business, passenger train lines, and how about all these crazy interstate roads and traffic? What about the airplane? Are we better off zipping all over the place, it certainly put the big ocean liners out of business.

Innovations cause people to lose jobs but usually creates more jobs than are lost otherwise our U.S. economy would not be the strongest model in the world. Consider yourself an innovation enabler. This is all heading somewhere but only God knows where and can tell you if you are in the right place in this adventure called life. If you take all the innovation away you will probably live something like a quaker...not what I'm called to. I'm sure you do your best considering you reflect about these things. That says you care about people...not just the $. Cheers...

by womble

Rascal
I acknowedge the point that business is a a process of making money for shareholders or business owners, but all of us are limited by the sets of values we develop as to what we will do to achieve that profit. By taking the extreme view that alls fair in love and business, we ignore the limits that our society puts on us.
We have seen, by both legislation and education, that most major corporations have been putting in place limits on what they will do to accomplish their corporate goals. Things like bribes and Cartels used to be SOP, but are now avoided minimised or hidden.
IT work has changed from an art to a trade, and as a result it can be used or abused the same as any other trade. If one wishes to use it to suck up all the money you can, then best of luck dealing with the various legal agencies that will be chasing one. If however one makes a decision to stick to one's ethical guns, then this is a lot easier to sleep with.

by james.chau

Objectively I think you are painting an almost holy picture of IT while forgetting that IT is itself becoming one of the principle driving forces of our global economies, albeit an often misguided force. Let's take a brief ride into the IT past and progress into the present with a little conclusion.
The ENIAC costed millions doing just a few calculations, the real IT value at that time was to prove that machines could do...well, just a few calculations, therefore the cost was considered justified. The IBM System/360 costed millions also, but it did a lot more calculations and has the ability to perform input and output with humans. Unix costed less doing the same things a little differently. Apple and PC do them for a lot less money even though they do a lot less work. As you see, here the real IT value had been largely vendor-oriented, namely writing software to enable the manufacturers to sell more hardware. Microsoft has changed that a little bit, namely to partner with manufacturers so that higher hardware demand would also drive higher software sales also. By 2005 the profit in IT has become razor thin, hardware or software, the push for open source and standards is a strong contribution to non-profit paradigm and it is having a financially detrimental effect on the whole IT universe, how can you derive lifeblood profits in a non-profit paradigm ?
The business world cannot understand this paradigm since it cannot fathom why would this be happening, and the IT world cannot get out of its own peril since it has matured into adulthood where it has to generate its own livelihood. From my point of view, it is time for the IT world to take over the business world (like Bill Gates' initiative a few years ago when he tried to get into banking). The basic question is this, why are we IT professionals so naive as to give away our hard earned skills and labor to help the business world make billions while we are perfectly capable of defining and executing our own business enterprises from the IT deliverables that are being virtually given away for free ? This way, the profit IT generates would make the IT field a lot more attractive and rewarding while enabling the world to become technically more advanced and better, thus freeing the IT people from the realm of slavery-like status of cost center and in general a nuisance to the business people who have recently stopped contributing their share to making the world a better place for all.

by cppwhite

Dear Packratt, in reply to your question of whether you make a differnce in the world of I.T., i am become recently diabled, and if it were not for the programs and games and information that so many people like yourself create, then i would not now have a window to the rest of the world,,,i can understand and relate to your feelings of low self esteem, shit happens bro,,,from another perspective,what would you be doing if you were not an it pro?would you be a manual worker also lining the pockets of some company or boss??
I feel I must share with you that I have only had this pc for 18 months and am totally self taught in troubleshooting and running this thing, i have no idea of how to write a program or even write my own web page, but itis very rewarding to me to be able boot up and surf the net,,,it was once written "in reading lies knowledge,and in knowledge lies wisdom",,,
Consider what all the kids would be doing if it were not for people like yourself, I dont agree with spending every moment in front of the pc or ps2 or xbox, that is not good for anyones sanity,,,suggestion,,try writing some game programs that do not shoot or harm another being, suggestion 2, take a sabatical and get out into the real world where you can make a difference in so many different ways,,,and not necessarily to do with money,,,there are many people who need "hands on" help,,,take it easy packratt

by ansed

It?s funny to see this topic when I was just thinking the same thing not to long ago. Most companies look at us a some necessary evil and then end users think we are some how responsible for the major changes in the industry instead of realizing that the fact of the matter is that we are the ones who have to try to keep up with the changes in order to be able to help them.

I realized also that alot don't see us for the work that we do. Alot of people get very defensive in our presence and don't view us as trying to help them, they view as some how trying to blame them.

As much as I love computers, I don?t think I make that big of a difference to the world and if I do you would never guess it from the people I work with. But having said that, my company offers great benefits so I will work there until I get my degree in Justice and then hopefully can make my mark on the world doing something that will hopefully make a difference in the lives of other.

by ives

Excellent statement 'packratt', and excellent response 'apotheon'.

"Do people exist to serve the social construct called capitalism or does that construct exist to serve the needs of the people?"

This is the very same question for many of the present religions, societies or institutions that transcend more than one generation. Are more children born to serve the institution for its own self-propagation, or does the institution survive because it nourishes multiple generations of an individual?

There is actually a new field of study that is focused on the term 'emergence'. In fact, you might both be interested in two books that deal with these very issues (I highly recommend them, but also realize the slim chances them actually being read):

Emergence: the connected lives of ants, brains, cities and software (Steven Johnson).
http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0684868768/

Interface Culture : How New Technology Transforms the Way We Create and Communicate
http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0465036805/ref=pd_sxp_elt_l1/102-7428557-7167352

I certainly agree with apotheon as to how and why things are they way they are (market driven = profit driven) and also believe this drive on a company level leads to disconcerting trends on a macro level.

"Do the least harm", "Technology itself is neutral. Implementation determines its worth."

Two issues often cited for evidence of harm are quality of life for the average IT worker and the fear of being so efficient that you put other people out of work (come to think of it, I believe Kurt Vonnegut wrote of the latter in "Player Piano", 1952). We can dismiss some of the fear of putting people out of work because this is a function of evolution and competition, contracting and consulting have emerged as a business model to address this which I believe is becoming more popular for many fields.

As for the quality of life, I think the issue is more with how the IT field has evolved as a profession and perhaps regressed in many ways compared to other professions. Perhaps this is largely due to the high concentration of younger professionals in the IT field who have less experience and may not yet have families of their own, who have been willing to make sacrifices that most professionals in other fields simply wouldn't. IT mostly pays well, but there are certainly costs in always being on-call or spending personal time to keep pace with the ever-changing field of IT.

Simply put, high pay vs. quality of life behind a desk. I think people really need to stand up for themselves and expect more from their employers. Hard times with a surplus of workers (in the U.S. and a couple routers away in India) always makes this difficult.

The costs of being an IT professional would often detract from most peoples' notion of 'quality of life'. This too is an issue on a macro scale within the US economy however. Workers in many fields in the US receive less vacation time than any other industrialized nation and work perhaps more than many (except for Japan and off-shore workers perhaps). This is often addressed in the policies of many European governments to ensure higher quality of life (France, Spain, Scandinavia and the Netherlands for example).

I believe our lawmakers could certainly do more to encourage responsible use of labor, but keep in mind this is a relatively new field. The early stages of the industrial revolution looked much the same. As workers were overworked laws and the construct of contractors or labor unions formed to help strike a balance.

So, does IT really help anyone?

Think about the contributions to society that IT has enabled. The net at large has created an excellent global community for sharing ideas, uninhibited by politics (although China has a long way to go with their censorship of the net). Better communication can also often help people overcome prejudices. The information era has also brought about a field where men and women are both paid and respected equally (for the most part, and certainly more so than almost any other field).

IT has and always will be a phenomenal enabler for almost any field, just as plumbing and water was an essential prerequisite to any of the first major 'cities'. As with any technology there are always the inventors, implementers and the maintenance crew of those systems. There can be great personal and social reward in the first two, but often little in the latter. Perhaps you seek one of the first two, but in a way that has a direct impact on people?

It all comes back to how it is shaped as an evolutionary force, one with an ongoing positive effect or a lasting detrimental drain on society. IT will continue to improve communication and enable unforeseeable advances for the human race.

Identifying the issues is always the easy part, I am curious if anyone has suggestions for solutions? I personally would like to see reforms in policies that protect people from the discrepancy between a 40-hour salary and a 60+ hour work-week (frequently weekends and holidays too). If people choose to work above and beyond, they should be paid accordingly.

Perhaps an IT union is overdue?
Excellent statement 'packratt', and excellent response 'apotheon'.

"Do people exist to serve the social construct called capitalism or does that construct exist to serve the needs of the people?"

This is the very same question for many of the present religions, societies or institutions that transcend more than one generation. Are more children born to serve the institution for its own self-propagation, or does the institution survive because it nourishes multiple generations of an individual?

There is actually a new field of study that is focused on the term 'emergence'. In fact, you might both be interested in two books that deal with these very issues (I highly recommend them, but also realize the slim chances them actually being read):

Emergence: the connected lives of ants, brains, cities and software (Steven Johnson).
http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0684868768/

Interface Culture : How New Technology Transforms the Way We Create and Communicate
http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0465036805/ref=pd_sxp_elt_l1/102-7428557-7167352

I certainly agree with apotheon as to how and why things are they way they are (market driven = profit driven) and also believe this drive on a company level leads to disconcerting trends on a macro level.

"Do the least harm", "Technology itself is neutral. Implementation determines its worth."

Two issues often cited for evidence of harm are quality of life for the average IT worker and the fear of being so efficient that you put other people out of work (come to think of it, I believe Kurt Vonnegut wrote of the latter in "Player Piano", 1952). We can dismiss some of the fear of putting people out of work because this is a function of evolution and competition, contracting and consulting have emerged as a business model to address this which I believe is becoming more popular for many fields.

As for the quality of life, I think the issue is more with how the IT field has evolved as a profession and perhaps regressed in many ways compared to other professions. Perhaps this is largely due to the high concentration of younger professionals in the IT field who have less experience and may not yet have families of their own, who have been willing to make sacrifices that most professionals in other fields simply wouldn't. IT mostly pays well, but there are certainly costs in always being on-call or spending personal time to keep pace with the ever-changing field of IT.

Simply put, high pay vs. quality of life behind a desk. I think people really need to stand up for themselves and expect more from their employers. Hard times with a surplus of workers (in the U.S. and a couple routers away in India) always makes this difficult.

The costs of being an IT professional would often detract from most peoples' notion of 'quality of life'. This too is an issue on a macro scale within the US economy however. Workers in many fields in the US receive less vacation time than any other industrialized nation and work perhaps more than many (except for Japan and off-shore workers perhaps). This is often addressed in the policies of many European governments to ensure higher quality of life (France, Spain, Scandinavia and the Netherlands for example).

I believe our lawmakers could certainly do more to encourage responsible use of labor, but keep in mind this is a relatively new field. The early stages of the industrial revolution looked much the same. As workers were overworked laws and the construct of contractors or labor unions formed to help strike a balance.

So, does IT really help anyone?

Think about the contributions to society that IT has enabled. The net at large has created an excellent global community for sharing ideas, uninhibited by politics (although China has a long way to go with their censorship of the net). Better communication can also often help people overcome prejudices. The information era has also brought about a field where men and women are both paid and respected equally (for the most part, and certainly more so than almost any other field).

IT has and always will be a phenomenal enabler for almost any field, just as plumbing and water was an essential prerequisite to any of the first major 'cities'. As with any technology there are always the inventors, implementers and the maintenance crew of those systems. There can be great personal and social reward in the first two, but often little in the latter. Perhaps you seek one of the first two, but in a way that has a direct impact on people?

It all comes back to how it is shaped as an evolutionary force, one with an ongoing positive effect or a lasting detrimental drain on society. IT will continue to improve communication and enable unforeseeable advances for the human race.

Identifying the issues is always the easy part, I am curious if anyone has suggestions for solutions? I personally would like to see reforms in policies that protect people from the discrepancy between a 40-hour salary and a 60+ hour work-week (frequently weekends and holidays too). If people choose to work above and beyond, they should be paid accordingly.

Perhaps an IT union is overdue?
Excellent statement 'packratt', and excellent response 'apotheon'.

"Do people exist to serve the social construct called capitalism or does that construct exist to serve the needs of the people?"

This is the very same question for many of the present religions, societies or institutions that transcend more than one generation. Are more children born to serve the institution for its own self-propagation, or does the institution survive because it nourishes multiple generations of an individual?

There is actually a new field of study that is focused on the term 'emergence'. In fact, you might both be interested in two books that deal with these very issues (I highly recommend them, but also realize the slim chances them actually being read):

Emergence: the connected lives of ants, brains, cities and software (Steven Johnson).
http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0684868768/

Interface Culture : How New Technology Transforms the Way We Create and Communicate
http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0465036805/ref=pd_sxp_elt_l1/102-7428557-7167352

I certainly agree with apotheon as to how and why things are they way they are (market driven = profit driven) and also believe this drive on a company level leads to disconcerting trends on a macro level.

"Do the least harm", "Technology itself is neutral. Implementation determines its worth."

Two issues often cited for evidence of harm are quality of life for the average IT worker and the fear of being so efficient that you put other people out of work (come to think of it, I believe Kurt Vonnegut wrote of the latter in "Player Piano", 1952). We can dismiss some of the fear of putting people out of work because this is a function of evolution and competition, contracting and consulting have emerged as a business model to address this which I believe is becoming more popular for many fields.

As for the quality of life, I think the issue is more with how the IT field has evolved as a profession and perhaps regressed in many ways compared to other professions. Perhaps this is largely due to the high concentration of younger professionals in the IT field who have less experience and may not yet have families of their own, who have been willing to make sacrifices that most professionals in other fields simply wouldn't. IT mostly pays well, but there are certainly costs in always being on-call or spending personal time to keep pace with the ever-changing field of IT.

Simply put, high pay vs. quality of life behind a desk. I think people really need to stand up for themselves and expect more from their employers. Hard times with a surplus of workers (in the U.S. and a couple routers away in India) always makes this difficult.

The costs of being an IT professional would often detract from most peoples' notion of 'quality of life'. This too is an issue on a macro scale within the US economy however. Workers in many fields in the US receive less vacation time than any other industrialized nation and work perhaps more than many (except for Japan and off-shore workers perhaps). This is often addressed in the policies of many European governments to ensure higher quality of life (France, Spain, Scandinavia and the Netherlands for example).

I believe our lawmakers could certainly do more to encourage responsible use of labor, but keep in mind this is a relatively new field. The early stages of the industrial revolution looked much the same. As workers were overworked laws and the construct of contractors or labor unions formed to help strike a balance.

So, does IT really help anyone?

Think about the contributions to society that IT has enabled. The net at large has created an excellent global community for sharing ideas, uninhibited by politics (although China has a long way to go with their censorship of the net). Better communication can also often help people overcome prejudices. The information era has also brought about a field where men and women are both paid and respected equally (for the most part, and certainly more so than almost any other field).

IT has and always will be a phenomenal enabler for almost any field, just as plumbing and water was an essential prerequisite to any of the first major 'cities'. As with any technology there are always the inventors, implementers and the maintenance crew of those systems. There can be great personal and social reward in the first two, but often little in the latter. Perhaps you seek one of the first two, but in a way that has a direct impact on people?

It all comes back to how it is shaped as an evolutionary force, one with an ongoing positive effect or a lasting detrimental drain on society. IT will continue to improve communication and enable unforeseeable advances for the human race.

Identifying the issues is always the easy part, I am curious if anyone has suggestions for solutions? I personally would like to see reforms in policies that protect people from the discrepancy between a 40-hour salary and a 60+ hour work-week (frequently weekends and holidays too). If people choose to work above and beyond, they should be paid accordingly.

Perhaps an IT union is overdue?

by jarnett

It sounds to me your problem is not what you do but who you do it for. If you don't feel appreciated in what you do then find another employer.
If you truly don't like what you do and want to help mankind then find a job with a charity.
Believe me there are many worse jobs than IT. They ususally pay less and sometimes have worse hours. I do field installation work. I install high tech security and surveilence equipment in factories and computer centers. The hours are long (12 hour days on average). I worked 60 hours the week between Christmas and New Years.
The pay is poor until you get 15 or 20 years in.
Thankfully I have my 20.
I don't much care for my Corp., but I love the work, I like most of the customers, and my coworkers are a good group.
In short I count myself fortunate.
What you have to decide is; deal with it, or move on.

by Former member

What a bunch of crock! Except for the term surrealist (one who pairs unmatched fantasy images together to represent unconscious dreams).
So many people here are defining materialistic needs; void of purpose and direction.
IT began its downward spiral when the newer members decided it was all about money. Someday, a giant IT tsunami will sweep them all away to a deserted island along with one Commodore C-64 and let them face their own uselessness.
Twenty years ago, IT had a "team" air to it. By helping each other, you helped the field evolve. Today, you need to get your head above the sea of career parasites first then set out to find the personal touch you are destined to contribute.
Let me tell you what happened this week... one of my customers found out she had a blockage in her heart. It was late at night and she needed someone to talk to. She saw that I was logged into Yahoo Messenger. So, we began to talk. I had been working for 18 hours but I listened to her. For 2 hours, I listened. I never once thought it an inconvenience. I certainly did NOT consider charging for my time. She turned to me because she knew that I cared about my customers. She knew when I worked on her computer that I took the time to listen to her and to explain things in her terms. She knew that I did my job because I enjoy it even though there are corporations out there that would pay much more.
The corporations and rapists currently dragging IT through a maze of self-righteous glut will eventually tire and discard the scraps. Among the remains will be a smarter, stronger seed that the upcoming generation will hopefully put to better use.

by dmichalski

No matter what field you take up, it is only a tool; a means to an end. You provide the direction. If IT doesn't seem to have the global effect that you are looking for, perhaps the issue isn't the career, but something in yourself. You could set up web sites to collect food, clothes, money, or other goods to help the needy, homeless, or tsunami victims (your choice). If that isn't your expertise, you could look at what your business does for humanity, and then how you help them accomplish that task. Whether it's provide the world with a better mouse trap for a cheaper price, minimize networking costs that will enable expansion (and jobs) to other regions, or as simple as keeping all the machines running smoothly so that some child will get his toy, game , computer, or what have you in time for the holidays.
Personally, I teach and that is how I am fulfilled (and fulfill others). To see people that are transitioning from working a dead-end job to learning a career that is not going to die any time soon is a good feeling. Worse case scenario, you could have your job in IT and spend your free time making a difference.

by barry_sage

While reading Packrats post I was trying to formulate a meaningful reply. Then I read Aces and realised that the perfect reply was already there, and worded so well. I have moved through IT roles in several industries trying to find more meaning for my contribution. The reality is that most of your colleagues, including the CEO carry the same concerns, and make their contributions to the betterment of society in their own subtle ways, through social programmes, donation, empathy, kindness and political pressure.

by jennyn

There are many people and organizations doing fantastic work to improve the world on many levels. They all need to type stuff, send emails, manage finances, use databases, have websites. Some have networks, mail servers, SQL servers... any private sector skills you have, have a place with organizations doing good. And you get to see the outcome of your work directly as the people you support make it happen. Even though I've moved back & forth between commercial & nonprofit sector, the later is my home. Because of the emphasis on mission rather than profit, I find there's actually more focus on good practice than in the commercial sector. Work can be rewarding (even if the pay might be crap)

Here are some resources/groups if you want to move into the charity/nonprofit sector:

* Nonprofit_Tech_Jobs@yahoogroups.com
(list that advertises nonprofit tech jobs mainly in US)
* www.idealist.org
(has nonprofit tech jobs and more)
* NPO-Techies@topica.com
(General list for nonprofit technicians)
* http://npogroups.org/lists/info/interider (internation eRiders list - eRiders serve multiple nonprofits on a model known as Circuit Riding)
* Information_Systems_Forum@yahoogroups.com
(general nonprofit tech group)
* www.eriders.net
(website for eRiding movement)
* www.techsoup.org
(nonprofit technology resource site - including the administration of SW donation programs by Microsoft/Macromedia/Intuit/Symantec etc etc etc)
* http://blog.deborah.elizabeth.finn.com/blog
(she's a tech networker who pulls together info from the lists and other resources)

by packratt

Thank you for that wealth of information, I've looked into a few of the links and will go through them in more detail as I am able.

It's interesting that my family and I have had to rely on the help of others very recently and that at the same time I'm trying to find ways that we can help others despite our situation.

Hopefully information such as this will enable me to help my family and others at the same time.

Thank you again.

by afarooqi78

Ever tried hitting a nail with a hammer into the wooden wall? Its similar Like Finance & Other departments acting as a Hammer to hit the business process nail get into a competitors wooden wall, IT remains the direction and position of hand driving the whole thing.

No wonder shrunked job market and technology has supplemented to de-value IT persons, but IT work needs a lot more projection to the company. You need to market your success among the other fellow company men. This will greatly help to avoid IT being seen as just a "Cost Centre" in views of people.

by adam.barylko

Western world society as it is currently structured only discourages any pursuit of career within this field. This is partly the result of globalisation and asymmetry of power by large multinationals and even smaller companies and unequal values throughout the world. (For your information I also see some benefits in globalisation). From another perspective if one views education as an investment then its return is quite poor. This field has very little benefits from those in other fields. For example builders can earn double my salary and reap benefits such as cheap materials and can avoid tax (not legal but I'm being realistic) quite easily for their own personal benefits on top of the already available benefits as subcontractors. I also know of technicians and electricians earning more than engineers and computing professionals. I know of A grade electrians earning considerable amounts money more than a lot of engineers (including electrical engineers). It is amazing that electrical engineers cannot even legally wire their own home despite their training which is another joke in the educational systems of this country (I can also say this about the Chief Electrical Inspector where despite fulfillment of a basic course I was not even awarded a simple connect/disconnect license even though I fully completed all requirements). (ie. your knowledge is not recognised, I can say more on this topic as my belief is that if you have proven yourself and fulfil the requirements of a course then any application for a qualification in which all requirements having been met should be acknowledged and the qualification should be given.) After knowing this then why would you bother in IT.
The double standards within society allows for such situations to arise. The dual tax system in this country (Australia) treats companys(subcontractors) as individuals from a legalistic point of view but taxes the companies less than individuals making a slightly above average income. Further more under company law the company can make claims against such expenditures as fuel and maintenance when filling tax returns whereas individuals cannot claim full travel expenses (travel to work and back) against their taxes despite the greater tax paid. So not only are companies able to pay lower taxes they can reduce their tax by claiming other expenses. So earning slightly more from the average wage earner but less than electricians and technicians why would you bother in this field. The amount of adaptation of knowledge and continual learning, lack of training when you ask for it, etc makes it less worth while. Society as it is structured also rewards a small portion of people for insignificant achievements. This is seen with sporting professionals, movie personalities which earn incomes several factors above that which a reasonable person would expect to earn over a single lifetime. I cannot see how realistically a person can be paid 10 times a reasonable income earners retirement benefit in less than a year and just the amount equal to the retirement benefit of an average income earner within the period of a year. Looking at this perspective I'd rather try my luck at playing with a deformed metalic stick also known as a golf club and ball as it can be seen that the earnings can be quite high for a few hours of training everyday compared reading tonnes of technical material and not getting paid for it or even a chance to use this knowledge. To give you an example, I learned a lot about communications system design however if I tried to start a business in this field and combine it with my computing knowledge I may have to invest huge amounts of money compared to my earnings in order to develope high tech electronic equipment. This financial risk is too great as my earnings are quite poor and recover of assets if the enterprise is undertaken fails. Anyway I have heaps to say but don't care if anyone really listens. I now am attempting to persue a more rewarding career (not only financial if you think that was the only thing I was concerned about) not necessarily in this field. I also discourage anyone from persuing careers in science or technology especially in the electronic, communications, computing (all main area such as software development, systems administration, systems analysis). I would advise people to consider other fields where there are greater rewards where you don't have to grovel for pennys, and beg for minuscule amounts for training and software from the bean counters.
I could also make further comments from my observations of modern western culture (some points positive others quite negative which I believe cause many problems in society today).
Anyway that's all that I will say for now and I'd like to hear any arguments for or against maybe this is a spark to start a new war. I wonder when the thought police will come and get me!

by apotheon

Business is absolutely not destroying mankind, by any stretch. Business is a cog in the greater machinery of a market economy (or hybrid economy with some market characteristics). It's necessary for the equitable self-regulation of production of wealth. It is both means and motivation for wealth production, without which we'd all be living in gutters if anyone had bothered to build the gutters in the first place.

What's screwing the pooch is interference with natural market forces. By inserting artificial controls, the self-correcting aspect of market forces is thrown out of whack and bad things start to happen, such as unequitable wealth distribution and reduced wealth production. In other words, it's not "business" that's to blame, but such phenomena as corporate law, business subsidies, protectionist policies, governmentally enforced union regulations, and so on. It is, in short, dictatorial influence that destroys the balance of market forces, which would otherwise tend toward a most-efficient means of advancing quality of life across the board.

by packratt

Never implied that business was inherently evil, don't think that many would.

However, many libertarians who share such opinions as your's that markets unleashed will benefit mankind as if some magical force called "free market" will force them to tend to forget that there were many periods and ages when corporations and businesses had not the tethers of which you speak. Those eras included times when slavery was legal, brought us the joys of the sweathshop and abusive child labor practices, and the wonders of yellow journalism and robber-barrons.

Some, (including some here), would argue that the Dickensian days of indebted servitude child-labor sweatshops, frequent factory maimings, and slave labor seem like a worthy goal to work backwards towards, but the argument as to whether such untethered business practices are beneficial to humanity is another subject worthy of it's own thread I think.

by apotheon

Your words: "there were many periods and ages when corporations and businesses had not the tethers of which you speak"

The very existence of corporations is a result of government interference in the operation of market forces. Corporations are a result of corporate law (that set of laws that creates and regulates business activity involving legal "entities" known as "corporations"). Corporations are not, in any way, synonymous with "business".

You speak of legal slavery, abusive child labor practices, and robber-barons (yellow journalism has in no way been reduced by government interference in anything, ever, and we still have a lot of that, so it doesn't really seem relevant). These are three practices that should be addressed by criminal law. A "free market", sans such terms as "laissez-faire", is not a market economy wherein people are allowed to act as they wish without consequences: it is a market economy wherein the only legal encroachment is in the protection of individual rights [b]without[/b] such "protection" constituting violation of individual rights. Anything that requires the adjective "abusive", is described accurately as "slavery", or protects "robbers" of any stripe is antithetical to a free market. There is a [b]tremendous[/b] difference between a libertarian/minarchist free market economy and an anarcho-capitalist laissez-faire economy.

Don't confuse the term "free market" with a mandate for anarcho-capitalism. While there is some merit to much of what my anarcho-capitalist friends have to say, there are great big problems with that approach to a market economy that allow for routine, institutionalized violation of individual rights. That's why I'm a minarchist, and not an anarchist.

by llauren

You could always do what i did, get a job on the United Nations Development Programme (www.undp.org). Initially, i applied for a job in Bhutan, declined an offer for Ethiopia and ended up here in Timor-Leste (that's East Timor for the rest of you :)

Technically, i do pretty much what i did before, except that my main role is that of an "Advisor". The idea is that the two local IT guys of my department can do "my" job when i'm gone.

The pay certainly isn't spectacular but the people are; both the local people and the others in the UN crew doing other development stuff are dedicated, friendly and approachable. It's a very nice setting and i do feel that what i do can make a difference for the people and the country here.

Oh, and there's a very cute advisor in another office who also digs Linux ;)

~rL

by packratt

Thank you for the information... Seems as though it's a worthy effort you've embarked upon.

I did have a question though. Does working in such programs provide one with enough resources to bring one's family along and provide for their wellbeing? Or are such endevours only advisable to the single or the parents of well off or dual income families?

Thank you again for your input.

by enmichael

Take a look at the Telecommunications Industry especially in Nigeria, the whole industry is driven by IT; without IT the industry is dead. They all need our services to ensure that their network work very well. We are a very important integral part of the society, and we add so much value to life. No IT, no communication. cheers guys!!!

by packratt

Before I begin I wish to thank everyone who has participated so far for their contributions and for their willingness to at least think about such things as this. Even if I may disagree with you I appreciate and applaud your willingness to air your beliefs.

So far there seems to be four camps of answers to my question.

1. Working any job is in and of itself socially beneficial no matter what that job is and whence forth those efforts go and that business is and of itself a good thing.

2. IT Work is beneficial because of the good works it enables or at least makes more efficient, even though it also enables such things as the degredation of humans through mass pornography, SPAM, vulnerabilities to harm through malicious coding, unchecked invasions of privacy, etc...

3. It does not matter if working in the IT field causes more harm or not. What matters is what you do on your own time so long as the company grants you such a thing as "your own time".

4. Working in IT can be good or bad depending on where one's efforts in that field are applied. (i.e. working for a non-profit instead of a for-profit org).

Camp 1 does not present a strong enough case for me to consider really as their's is a faith based declaration. (i.e. trust me, IF corporations had no rules to control them they would benefit mankind even though historical or even present evidence contradicts me.)

Camp 2 worries me a bit as it requires a bit of rationalization to make it palatable. (i.e. The suffering of those who are laid off by use of technology and those who are made to suffer in other ways are not important when compared to the good technology does for those who can afford to benefit from it).

Camp 3 seems reasonable enough but then again, and it's a self admitted simplification, let's apply another analogy and say that you work in the IT field as a web developer for pornographers but justify it by saying that you give a portion of your income to the poor. Do the end results of your income justify the means of obtaining said income? (another analogy perhaps, let's say your efforts result in the layoffs of a hundred people, but you give a thousand dollars to charity a year... Was the end result beneficial or harmful overall?)

Camp 4 provides a potential personal avenue out of the moral/ethical quagmire I proposed. Yet it does still leave the fact that for every one person who can afford such a sacrifice of working for a non-profit, there are others who may be willing but cannot afford to work without benefits nor a wage that would enable one to raise a family well... What of them? (i.e. should a person consider sacrificing the health and welfare of a child, who is by nature innocent and dependent on that adult, in order to be a moral agent within society?)

Thank you all again for your input.

by oxyjen

Some people in IT should have done an arts degree and worked with humans for change. Others find passion in a computer. Then there are some in the middle who should maybe read Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance and learn about man's extension of self into machines. I think it's refreshing that the originator of this post has a higher self looking for purpose and understand his frustrations. However, IT workers are generally cogs within cogs within cogs. Working for huge corporations is a fast track to disallusionment and not a healthy environment for a spiritual seeker. In the corporate world IT people are Aldus Huxley's beta model humans (Brave New World) who fix corporate machines. It is not job satisfaction sought by Packratt as much as it is the age old question of finding purpose in life beyond work, death, and taxes. If you find it let me know.

by munezrhep

Greetings!

I also feel the same way towards work. But I never generalize what I feel to IT. I'm still in my early twenties. Little experience.

I suggest you to write about what you think. And maybe you'll be famous.Who knows.

Best regards.

by mitb67

None or very few through IT. As long as - you put it - it will only be a mere discussion about cost/ profit centers. Don't get me wrong, I have nothing against earning decent money. There's only an issue about this "decent" word. There is a thin line between completely different consequences of automation and IT involvment in the social aspects of our modern civilizations whenever one looks at it only from a business perspective. I personally have seen very (stress that) few IT projects that had a significant social impact in terms of social improvement. The majority just keep increasing the gaps. And this is not only the case of the industry we are nowadays working within. I have a medical background and, for the last ten - business - years (at least), I've witnessed a profound degradation of the healthcare act in terms of availability, quality and, above all, compassion towards a suffering fellow. Phrases like "making a difference", "bridging the digital divide", "healthcare availability", "education for all" are only fumes that emanate from our big brothers' politically correct Neo-cortex.

by mill3502

For the most part IT has lost it luster to me and as you pointed out I to began to ask what am I doing that changes things. And for a while I really thought about returning to school and changing my entire life. But challenges can still be a part of the IT world and instead of returning to school and sitting behind the desk I decided to return to school and be in front of the desk. I am still pursuing my current IT position but I am also teaching part-time at a local community college. It has given me new focus and the ability to face the duldrums of my current position. So I say find that outlet that lets you be creative and gives you a feeling of returning something to society. You will feel a lot better for it and you will not feel like you threw away your life.

by jim asbille

What is the purpose and value of IT? Unless these questions can be answered than nothing else about this issue is meaningful. Does IT exist for the benefit of staff? To a certain extent yes but then why are people laid off when efficiencies are gained? Does IT exist for the benefit of IT staff? Some think so except then IT staff lose jobs and have reduced pay. The reality is that IT exists for the benefit of the Enterprise and for the fulfillment of the corporate mission. The inability of so many IT departments to get this has generated tremendous ill-will towards IT departments. It is also why when efficiencies are gained people get laid off. If the enterprise values efficiencies and lower personnel costs then staff lose jobs. IT professionals need to be more cognizant of the values and mission that their organizations hold. Instead of creating efficiencies that reduce personnel we should create efficiencies that allow the redeployment of resources to accomplish the corporate vision.

by james.chau

Jobs are gained or lost through economic and political conditions, environmental elements, government and fiscal policies, supply and demands, competition, and innovation. Tariffs, an increase of oil prices or the borrowing cost such as interest rates, tsunami, have far more impact on economy and employment than any IT related issues. The declines of empires were not due to efficiencies gained or lost through the deployment of resources, but the mis-management of resources due to lack of good decisions, control, and the availability of good information. Is a good society one which has 100% employment ? stability is not achieved through preservation of the status quo, cost and revenues are subject to many uncontrollable conditions. IT only provides information, not solutions, it is the will of a society which has the desire and capabilities to grow and to compete responsibly that can sustain itself infrastructurally and politically.

by mitchlr

AcesKaraoke (what a pseudonym!) nails it, for better or worse.
If you want meaning, use your IT job to fund whatever it is you do for it. At work you're just a mechanism to produce code, administer or support systems. Indispensible where you are and as likely as not smarter than the person you work for, you are unlikely to be promoted where you can threaten some idiot bean counter's stock options.
Thank the Lord that you have a job that's at least mildly diverting and if you're lucky one in which you don't have to deal with "professional" managers too much.
Look elsewhere for meaning and significance -- your church, synagogue, tutoring, mentoring, making music, writing, or raising your kids (which ought to be first on the list) are where you ought to find your meaning.

For perspective, think about what you would like to be the epitath on your tombstone:

Here lies ITguy, RIP.
He pounded code so Giganticorp could sell widgets more efficiently.

You want that as a legacy? Thanks but no thanks. For right now, I do IT to fund my retirement account and feed my kids, but at some time (when I'm able to sock a bit more in savings or get the mortgage paid down) I'll get the courage to jump ship and take a more meaningful career at half or a third of the pay.

Oh, yeah. If you want meaning, try this: live well below your financial means. Fancy stuff costs losts of money and doesn't add squat to ultimate significance, although it keeps you chained to the IT desk. Live simply, finance your house on a 15 year note, pay it off early, and you will buy yourself more freedom than fancy clothes and cars will ever mean.
With a paid off mortgage, you might be able to take that more meaningful work at a third of what you're making now, and still be able to sock some away for retirement.

All the best to you!

by wadeowen

My IT job is extremely rewarding. I manage a group of technical professionals that develop and maintain a system that manages Child and Elder Abuse and Neglect Cases. The things we do affect people's lives every day!!! Maybe the problem is not IT. Perhaps you should consider working for the government sector. The pay is not as good, but I never wonder why I'm coming to work.

by tonythetiger

Computers play a large part in most people's lives nowadays. Including cargo loading scheduling, etc. So making sure those computers and their programs are working correctly certainly will help people. Making sure food, medicine, building supplies, etc. are delivered where and when it is needed, for example.

Another example is using your skills to make someone else's task easier, allowing them to get that task done sooner so thay can devote more of their time to helping people.

by packratt

Again, I think our discussion here is branching too far away from the original topic, yet I think you are describing a plutocratic system of governance when describing a system involving "free markets" and pure privatization of services.

Under such a system as you describe, individual rights may be protected, as you suggest, but one wonders what those "rights" would include? Do they include the right to an education or would this be considered a privilage only reserved for those who could afford to purchase that service? What of those who did not earn enough to garner shelter, food, medical services, or sanitation? Wage and working condition controls, is it considered a right to work in a safe environment or is this a privilage as well? What about governance of the commons, would it be a violation of my rights if your pollution destroyed my health or the land I live on?

I suppose it's a question again of why humans exist. Do we exist, live and die, to serve the interest of business or did we invent such concepts to serve humanity? To which you answered that this question is unimportant to you. Unfortunately, I feel it is important to the topic at hand.

by net-engr

Many have written to say they feel their only contribution is to streamline businesses that operate for profit. While I may feel this way about my day job, I volunteered to maintain the IT systems of a local non-profit. Very rewarding!

I used to (before moving) volunteer with the local Red Cross chapter. I was their only IT support for several years. I helped them purchase, install, maintain, and upgrade all of their IT resources.

Why is this different than corporate IT? For one example, in aftermath of the hurricanes that hit the Carolinas a few years ago, many stopped by the Red Cross office to donate money. I don't remember how much was donated, but copies of the checks, many for $10 or less -- all someone could spare -- filled several 3 inch binders, five to a page. I was able to get a computer working at the front desk that ran their bookeeping software. This allowed donations to be entered directly into their books. I probably saved the woman who was the accountant/office manager/computer person a few hundred hours of re-keying donations that would have been captured on paper. Those were hours she could spend at home with her kids.

Your skills are valuable not just to for-profit corporations. The next time you wonder how you can "make a difference in the world" only knowing IT, think about the relief agencies that are helping tsunami survivors. Think about the web sites that have been set up to provide information and capture donations. Think about the laptops that being used daily to record survivor information and reunite families...

I encourage you to volunteer your time, putting your IT skills to work for those organizations that ARE making a difference in the world. Or go to work for them! While they often don't pay anything near corporate IT, many non-profit groups are desperately seeking people with computer skills. After all, computers are as much a part of their daily activities as most for-profit corporations. The next time you upgrade and donate your older equipment, think about who will try to make it work.

by ross.elkins

Perspective is everything! I've had 10 odd jobs since 11/02. This teaches you quickly how personally rewarding a job in IT is compared to some crap jobs and employers out there.
I started out in 1981 and felt like I was a pioneer in the info revolution. Maybe many of you felt that way and now are left with the comparative boredom of bizness computing. Its hard to live and work with that after soaring like an eagle. It's much harder to be up against the financial wall and forced to try physical labor, more menial work or the same skilled IT work for 1/3 pay. My last job 2 years ago as the IT mgr for a small ISD was a shot at doing more interesting and scientific work then biz computing and look where it got me! I have steered my children away from IT and I just hope I can finish out my career in the great opportunity I started in over 20 years ago.