Scientists finally agree that humans contribute to global warming
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Software
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by tonythetiger
is that some humans aren't satisfied with the life cards they've been dealt and think that everybody else in the world is responsible to make them happy!
Your "scientists" changed their mind four times about the past hurricane season, and they claimed this winter was going to be much warmer than normal then three days later changed their mind on that! Apparently THEY don't understand as much as they think they do, so I don't see how you can expect the whole world to make life-altering decisions based on their claims.
I know, with all of their the changing guesses, one of them will eventually be right and they'll say "see, we told you so", and you'll look up at them in awe!
In the meantime, we had a new record low temperature this morning.
by deepsand
Time and time again you exhibit, not merely a lack of understanding of science, but an outright distain for it, as though sentiment born of ignorance will somehow show you the truth.
Time to wake up, man, and acquire some knowledge, rather than coasting by on beliefs.
[b]Study the sciences.[/b]
by absolutely
... not to local nor daily ones.
[i]In the meantime, we had a new record low temperature this morning.[/i]
In other words, to the extent that the name "global warming" is even an accurate shorthand for the [i]hypothesis[/i] of climate change resulting from increasing concentrations of greenhouse gases, it refers to "warming" of an as-yet-unnamed thermal quantity measured over wide spatial and temporal ranges.
Note: I treat "global warming" here as merely a hypothesis, but, Tony, you are arguing against a straw man when you implicitly assert that daily low temps contradict the "global warming" hypothesis.
by absolutely
[i]Your "scientists" changed their mind four times about the past hurricane season, and they claimed this winter was going to be much warmer than normal then three days later changed their mind on that! Apparently THEY don't understand as much as they think they do, so I don't see how you can expect the whole world to make life-altering decisions based on their claims.[/i]
I don't watch or listen to the paparazzi any more. What did they say, and why did you believe it was "scientific"?
by jardinier
[i]Until you get rid of your "I know how the world should be run, and the world will comply!" attitude[/i]
Are you referring to my personal attitude, or to the attitude of people in general who accept the possibility/probability that humans contribute to global warming?
If you are referring to my personal attitude then yes, I definitely think governments should look at ways of reducing greenhouse gas emissions.
As I have now said twice, it was one of about five key issues in the recent Australian election and obviously a lot of the GP (general population) thought it was important enough to cause, along with other key issues, a five per cent swing against the Howard government.
Did you actually READ the initial post in this discussion which is about a general agreement among scientists worldwide that humans DO contribute to global warming?
But then perhaps you are merely a patriotic American who believes that the USA has a god-given right to be one of the biggest producers of greenhouse gases.
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
[i]Are you referring to my personal attitude, or to the attitude of people in general who accept the possibility/probability that humans contribute to global warming?[/i]
the attitude that some have that they few have the right to dictate to the world.
And I object to your use of the word "accept" because it pre-supposes that what is "accepted" is proven right.
[i]But then perhaps you are merely a patriotic American who believes that the USA has a god-given right to be one of the biggest producers of greenhouse gases."[/i]
The collectivists have gotten to you. The USA is made up of over 300 million individuals, some who produce more waste than others (I really am on the low side of consumption and waste... just my reasons are different than most "greenies"). If you think I am, as an individual, doing something wrong ... something that you can prove harms you, then by all means come to my house and make me stop it. But you have no right, nobody does, to punish me for what [b]someone else[/b] is doing wrong! It's called liberty, and just because you don't have the balls to stand up for yours does not mean you have the right to take it away from others.
by jardinier
[i]"and just because you don't have the balls to stand up for yours does not mean you have the right to take it away from others."[/i]
I used my "liberty" to vote for the political party which takes global warming seriously.
What do use your "liberty" for?
by tonythetiger
by deepsand
Liberty brings a responsibility to do no harm.
And, if it is not subordinate to the the good of the whole, then there shall ultimately be none left standing for its exercise.
by tonythetiger
... is that you prove it. If you are going to insist on curtailing my liberties, you better have absolute proof that I am harming someone.
The only other way is by the use of force, which will be responded to in kind.
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
by deepsand
with the result that you mis-interpret the data as being supportive of your unfounded beliefs.
To repeat, [b]study the sciences[/b], and acquire an understanding of the [b]physical principles[/b] here involved. Then and only then will you be able to properly address the data.
by tonythetiger
So anyone who doesn't come to the same conclusion as you do lacks the necessary knowledge????
[i]properly address the data[/i]
What would have been the proper way to address the data that scientists had gathered by the seventies? (Remember, they thought a new ice age was imminent. Aren't you glad we didn't act on that?)
by jdclyde
Repeatedly, I have asked for you or any other supporter of this mindset to show ANY facts that show HOW MUCH of an influence humans have. Neither you, nor anyone else have stepped up EVER so show this. When pushed for it, you back down to the "well, it MIGHT be true" BS.
So much of facts.
Science means the theory has to be proven true, not that they can form an concensis [i](ideas out of their asses)[/i] that others must disprove.
Get off your throne and answer the question or back off your case.
Two questions.
WHAT PERCENTAGE OF GW ARE HUMANS RESPONSIBLE FOR?
WHAT IMPACT WILL INDIVIDUAL EFFORTS HAVE ON GLOBAL GW?
And the warmest year in the last 50 years was over five years ago? hmmmmm...
by jdclyde
If we contribute 1%, we have still contributed.
How much is contributed and what can be done about it are where the debates come in.
by deepsand
by jdclyde
because there are so many factors.
Even you can understand that if the sun is hotter than ever, it will heat the Earth up with no help from us.
Thats ok, you can continue to pretend you are above such things to keep from having to come up with any answers, we still see you for who and what you are.
by tonythetiger
by deepsand
To assume as you would is to also assume that one knows all possible causes, which is, of course, impossible.
The scientist makes no such presumption, but merely allows that previously observed causes [b]might[/b] be responsible for a currently observed action. Science is not merely about explaining what has happened, but what is happening now.
Hence my statement that past is not prologue.
by deepsand
Such occurs given the presence of 3 elements.
1) Two bodies in close proximity;
2) One of which is strongly radiative relative to the other; and,
3) The non-radiating, or lesser radiative, body is enclosed in a filter that is not equally transmissive at all wave lengths.
In this case, those elements are the Sun, the Earth, and Earth's atmosphere, respectively.
Man's alteration of the chemical composition of the atmosphere alters the inflow and outflow of short and long wavelength radiation unequally, yielding an increasingly larger imbalance between the two, with the result that 1) an increasing larger portion of the long wavelength (Infrared, or IR) radiation is unable to be re-radiated into space, and, 2) said IR causes snow & ice to melt, resulting in less short wavelength radiation being reflected into space, but absorbed instead.
It's all perfectly natural.
by deepsand
by deepsand
on numerous occasions.
For starters, see, in this Discussion, https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=244956&messageID=2382746 .
Then, do your own independent research of radiative forcing, etal..
So far all you've done is to parrot the claims of the uninformed & uneducated.
by deepsand
by deepsand
by jardinier
by deepsand
be advised that that claim has been laid to rest.
In fact, said influx has been [b]in decline for over 20 years[/b]!
See, among others, http://environment.newscientist.com/article/dn12234-suns-activity-rules-out-link-to-global-warming.html
[b]Study the [u]Science[/u][/b].
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
[i]That sounds like an allusion to Welfare recipients.[/i]
It's not. It's an allusion to people who want to better themselves.
[i] You are not a new incarnation of Maxwell Edison by any chance, are you?[/i]
I am honored, but no :)
by deepsand
does not serve to render them null and void them.
The world is full of those who are unable and/or unwilling to be convinced of that which does not please them.
by deepsand
scientific data if their opinions re. such are to be given credence is not merely a reasonable one, but an essential one.
If you feel it to be elitist, such owes to not understanding science.
BTW, to claim that there was the general expectation among the scientific community of an "imminent" ice age is to exaggerate.
by deepsand
Lacking the necessary scientific training for a full understanding of the issue, and disliking the the consequences of the conclusions of those who do, you prefer instead to cling to hope born of the claims of those who offer you a future more to your liking.
You would do well to consider the consequences if your beliefs prove to be wrong but are those followed.
In the mean time, what "natural" cause(s) do you offer as explanation of global warming?
by jardinier
In one way you are quite unlike Maxwell because you are polite to me -- a skill which Maxwell never acquired over a period of five years.
However you are like Maxwell in your thinking. He was the archetypal ostrich. Even now he probably believes George W. Bush was, is and always will be right. Maxwell was also responsible for the many threads about human-caused global warming because it was one of his "pet peeves."
You may not care what happens to the earth in your lifetime. Do you have children? Do you have grandchildren or expect to have grandchildren? It is the heritage that you may leave to them that you should consider now.
I don't know why you would feel honored to be mistaken for him, but each to his own I guess.
by deepsand
and let us not forget those started by the likes of Mr. Miami - GW would probably come in 2nd.
EL itself topped 3300 posts; the most recent related thread, "The Last Word on the Evolution vs. Intelligent Design Debate," which lasted over 9 months, weighs in at 2663 posts!
by deepsand
to look at those members who took which side in the discussions involving Science, such as Global Warming and Evolution, and those which centered on issues re. the use of Government forces, both Civilian & Military, in matters of both Geo-Politics and Domestic Security.
In general, one sees that those who most favored strong Governmental actions are those who also have the greatest lack of Scientific knowledge and understanding.
In fact, one might say that the "right wing" is also "right brained."
by tonythetiger
[i]The world is full of those who are unable and/or unwilling to be convinced of that which does not please them.[/i]
"They failed to be indoctrinated".
by tonythetiger
[i]You would do well to consider the consequences if your beliefs[/i]
I have never stated a "belief". I have never said the scientists were wrong (of course, I never said they were wrong in the seventies either, but that didn't stop them.
"In the mean time, what "natural" cause(s) do you offer as explanation of global warming?"
I would offer "the same thing that caused all the previous episodes".
by tonythetiger
[i]However you are like Maxwell in your thinking. He was the archetypal ostrich. Even now he probably believes George W. Bush was, is and always will be right.[/i]
Without going into too much detail, here are a couple of things you'd never hear from Bush or Max:
The Patriot Act was and is a disaster.
The illegal immigration "problem" isn't one.
Both major parties in this country favor a government that is far too intrusive into citizens' lives (albeit in different ways). Both want to "help us" using methods that are far too expensive and end up hurting more people than they help. In essence, both have forgotten just who the hell they're supposed to be working for.
by deepsand
Bear in mind that facts are [b]not[/b] dependent on public opinion, but exist in their own right.
It was once the popular notion that the Earth was flat, that the Earth was the center of the Universe, etc..
Your persistent attempts to recast issues of scientific fact into ones of policy, rights, etal. serve to neither alter the facts nor engender an informed decision re. pertinent policy.
by deepsand
a single cause.
If you're going to claim that the present cause is the same as a past one, you will need to both identify the specific physical mechanisms involved [b]and[/b] provide a cogent scientific argument, based on currently available data, to support that claim.
As for the actual present cause, it has already been detailed for you here, in prior discussions; also, reading references were provided for your gaining an understanding of the underlying physical processes involved.
For you to now ask for an explanation of the present global warming, under pretext of such not yet having been forthcoming, is disingenuous.
by deepsand
Did you have but one, increased solar radiation?
If so, then it seems that you are forfeit.
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
[i]If you're going to claim that the present cause is the same as a past one, you will need to both identify the specific physical mechanisms involved and provide a cogent scientific argument, based on currently available data, to support that claim.[/i]
No, I do not. The earth has been in existence for billions of years and, in the past million or so that we know of, has went through several warming and cooling cycles. All prior cycles have been of natural causes.
It is you who are claiming that this one particular cycle has different (unnatural?) causes. It is as if you expect me to accept that apples fell from trees for a different reason today than they did a thousand years ago and a thousand years before that. The burden of proof is entirely upon you, no matter how you try to wriggle out of it.
[i]For you to now ask for an explanation of the present global warming, under pretext of such not yet having been forthcoming, is disingenuous.[/i]
All that's been offered are the speculations of those with the political motive of controlling other's lives ... that and WATBs (Whiny-assed-titty-babies) who are throwing tantrums because everyone in the world isn't bowing down to kiss their ass.
by absolutely
by deepsand
By your mention of U.S. negotiators, I assume that you are referring to the happenings at the recent Bali summit.
But, did this not happen [b]nearly a month after[/b] the opening post here?
by absolutely
I missed the date of the OP, my mistake.
The most recent news was the US change of position at Bali. I hadn't noticed how long ago jardinier started this thread. I recently noticed it for the first time, and assumed ... and the rest was me making an ass of myself!
by absolutely
by absolutely
TonyTheTiger: [i]I would offer "the same thing that caused all the previous episodes".[/i]
I offer no further comment on the subject of [u]government-mandated "solutions" to global warming[/u] than that curtailment of rights is not the proper first measure to pursue in response to any problem, yet is consistently the first measure pursued when it comes to global warming. You cannot secure liberty by destroying it, nor can you gain "a bit of security" by the same means.
Global warming is a fascinating, complex scientific topic, so I reserve the right to comment on it freely, at my discretion.
Probably not on the Internet.
by absolutely
[i]The tree huggers will argue for harsher and more restrictive energy generation to the point that it will not be produced.
Wind farms, not in any place that MAY affect natural wild life. Oh my, an owl will die. Oh my, it ruin my scenic view of the pretty mountains.
Wave farms, not in any place that MAY affect sea life. They don't care if it much more efficient and cost effective in specific area's.
Solar, you are placing these solar arrays in places that will adversely affect both plant and wild life. They don't care if it's the best place collection arrays.
Let's look at hybrid vehicles. I am sure they will find ways of placing restrictions on the distribution system so that these vehicles will not become feasible. You want this to work, you make it so that the common person will be able to afford and use it. Their restrictive policy will stop both of these achievements.
Tree huggers are after 1 thing only. Not more efficient and environmental friendly energy use. They are after the destruction of any and all established industrial nations.[/i]
I think you're right; and unless somebody else solves the problem with technology, they'll make it worse with legislation.
by absolutely
by absolutely
The rapid movement of electrons known as electricity has the side effect of causing minute movements of the protons, ie vibrations of the conductor lattice, ie thermal energy, which in turn impedes the movement of subsequent electrons. The accumulation of this dynamic to the quantity that electricians measure as "resistance" is near-instantaneous, but slow enough compared to the human retina, optic nerve and brain to observe in older circuits as brief dimming or flickering of ambient lighting, when new, high-current appliances are activated.
What's that? Not the kind of resistance you meant? Oh, [u]that[/u] kind of resistance!
[u]That[/u] kind of resistance is futile.
jdclyde: [i]First, the poster children that push this global agenda are bigger offenders than the mindless masses they are preaching to.[/i]
It will be interesting to see what, if anything, is done about solar power in California in the near future, and if so, by whom.
by jdclyde
is why they are also not taking full advantage of tideale generators and wind farms.
The econuts often put the breaks on the wind farms, and go completely rabid if you even talk about a nuke plant.
Currently NBC is running a lot of coverage and push for these technologies, as well as LED's replacing all lightbulbs. Of course, being owned by GE and them making a bundle off of the hype of GW would never come into play on this, right?
Follow the money.
by absolutely
I intended to just show examples of you generalizing about people instead of discussing climate in quantified terms, but taking the intended excerpts in sequence gave a much funnier statement about econuts.
jdclyde: [i]Currently NBC is running a lot of coverage and push for these technologies, as well as LED's replacing all lightbulbs. Of course, being owned by GE and them making a bundle off of the hype of GW would never come into play on this, right?[/i]
The fact that "news" programs are used as advertising platforms is the reason I don't utilize the paparazzi sources. Still, media bias does not disprove the claims of LEDs' efficiency. I like more lumens per BTU in my lighting.
[i]Follow the money.[/i]
Show me the money!
by tonythetiger
Are LEDs really more efficient per lumen when you consider the costs of mining and manufacture? What good is it if it keeps electric companies from putting a proverbial ton of carbon into the atmosphere if the mining and manufacturing puts in a proverbial two tons?
There's also something else to consider, at least in winter, at least in some places. The "waste heat" put off by incandescents can somewhat offset fuel used for heating.
Or you could simply buy them because you like the quality of the light output ... and if they lower your bills, well, that's just gravy.
by absolutely
by absolutely
by absolutely
You're going to have to present data as if you're maxwell edison, then; in other words, to dazzle with brilliance, because your "baffle with bullshi+" method tends not to retain interest quite to the 1000 post range.
[i]Why is it that so many people cannot accept that humans MAY contribute to global warming, and proceed with appropriate measures to reduce human-generated greenhouse gases.[/i]
I'm talking about that kind of straw man argument, against "so many people," whose activities, positions and beliefs you can conveniently assign, to your rhetorical advantage, rather than confronting any of your actual opponents' actual words.
[i]I really don't care if this is just a symbolic gesture.[/i]
No, I really never would have supposed that you did.
[i]We take global warming seriously.
May the children, grandchildren, greatgrandchildren and many further generations of the global warming ostriches/skeptics/cynics suffer direly for the ego-based pig-headedness of their parents of today.[/i]
Nice one, Mr. Hearst! Appealing to the progeny and to hatred of the vaguely-defined "others" in one sentence, ostensibly in pursuit of an agenda grounded in [u]science[/u], is far more damning revelation of your methods and motives than I could have dared to request of Zwarte Pete!
[edited: repeatedly, for grammar, spelling, and sentence structure. 12-17-2007 19:18:00]
by jdclyde
Science is facts that can be recreated and proved or disproved.
Just because a group of people sit around agreeing with each other, it does not make it a fact.
How does the consensus of scientist explain the global warming of Mars?
We look at the current groups leading in GW, and all you have to do is follow the money.
Buying carbon credits solves ANY issue how?
And Gores talk about a carbon tax on the US?
by absolutely
[i]Not like those honest caring types in the oil, coal, power generation and transport industries.[/i]
They care enough, for what you pay.
Yes or no: Can you say the same about those to whom you pay your taxes? Do they get us "there," as consistently "on time"? LOL, end of discussion.
by tonythetiger
[i]But, Tony, that is not scientific.[/i]
The earth was going through these cycles before science existed.
[i]To assume as you would is to also assume that one knows all possible causes,[/i]
No it doesn't. It only assumes that humans were not the cause of previous cycles.
(sorry, didn't see this one before)
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
"Just because a group of people sit around agreeing with each other, it does not make it a fact."
No, consensus is [b]more important[/b] ... so much so that if one of the fellows disagrees, he is no longer considered one of the fellows ... he is shunned ... cast out ... a heretic.
It's looking more like a religious cult every day :)
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
by absolutely
by absolutely
TonyTheTiger: [i]What good is it if it keeps electric companies from putting a proverbial ton of carbon into the atmosphere if the mining and manufacturing puts in a proverbial two tons?[/i]
absolutely: Is that the case? If so, where are your data? So far, you have not provided quantified, scientific support sufficient to conclude that LEDs are twice as bad as incandescent, although your question suggests that, by treating it as the "given" part of the challenge "What good is it if...".
TonyTheTiger: [i]There's also something else to consider, at least in winter, at least in some places. The "waste heat" put off by incandescents can somewhat offset fuel used for heating.[/i]
absolutely: That is worth considering. Have you? Is that "somewhat" offset meant to support your one ton for two tons conjecture? If so, the support is anecdotal for a claim that is quantified. Again, your method is not scientific.
by jdclyde
how much does your bill have to be lowered to off-set the extra expense of the purchase?
I was pricing up LED Christmas lights last week. A strand with 50 LED's was $18.99. I usually have around 700 lights on my tree, and that is only because I have been cutting back. I was averaging about 1400 for a few years....
It would take a LONG time to make up the difference.
Same for all the hype of they hybrid car. Many don't end up getting much better (if any better) mileage than the non-hybrid models, yet you have to waste a few thousand more to purchase the hybrid.
When we hear talk about carbon taxes, it is time to be nervous, and I am already hearing AlGore talking about it.
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
by absolutely
I'm beginning to search noaa.gov for hurricane data, and so far, I have not found any four articles that fit the description of flip-flopping four times. I have noticed that they made one prediction which, I learned recently, is impressively accurate, with only 13/365 remaining days left to be recorded.
NOAA predicts 2007 will make top 10 warmest years since record-keeping began in 1895:
http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/oa/climate/research/2007/ann/us-summary.html
(1/10 odds of being right by pure chance -- try staking your career on that every year!)
Currently in fifth place going into the home stretch:
http://www.cnn.com/2007/US/weather/12/13/warm.weather.ap/
I found also that "The 2007 Atlantic hurricane season brought fewer hurricanes than was originally expected and the total number of named storms was below the recent average, yet above the 1950-2000 average," but I have not yet found any specific, previous predictions which this report contradicts. I'd need three predictions, each contrary to the previous one, and the third contrary to this report, to substantiate your claim.
http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/oa/climate/research/2007/hurricanes07.html
I'm trying, Tony, but I have not yet been able to find those reversals. Anyway, I don't believe it's necessary to disprove, de-bunk or dispute global warming science to favor solving this, like any problem, with technology and informed personal choice to the fullest possible extent, before [u]beginning[/u] to consider reducing people's rights.
by absolutely
by tonythetiger
But I know there [b]were[/b] four different times they reduced their estimate during the season.
http://www.noaanews.noaa.gov/stories2007/s2864.htm
http://www.noaanews.noaa.gov/stories2007/s2905.htm
I cannot currently explain why I can't find all four.
by absolutely
by jdclyde
Is not uncommon. Yet another problem with using the web for referencing, because it is always changing and often not leaving behind a permanent record.
Kind of like trying to find ANY reference on the MicroSoft web site that says NT stands for New Technology. After the "Built on NT Technology" fiasco, they pulled ALL references.
You CAN still find it in old NT reference books though.
by tonythetiger
on things outside one's control (I went through that recently with my supervisor who was evaluating me on the average number of problems I fixed per day. I had no control over how many people called with problems, nor could I control whether the problem was an easy one in the office next-door, or a complex one in the office 60 miles away, which were all counted equally).
I saw four different reports, each showing fewer expected tropical storms/hurricanes/major hurricanes than the one before. That there's even one revision illustrates the original point I was trying to make ... that they don't know as much as they think they do. If they can't get a few months right, it would be sheer lunacy to base major economic changes on what they say will happen in decades!
by tonythetiger
[i]Removal of old or incorrect data
Is not uncommon. Yet another problem with using the web for referencing, because it is always changing and often not leaving behind a permanent record.[/i]
Not that I'm accusing, but it also is handy for history revisionists :)
by absolutely
[i]I saw four different reports, each showing fewer expected tropical storms/hurricanes/major hurricanes than the one before. That there's even one revision illustrates the original point I was trying to make ... that they don't know as much as they think they do. If they can't get a few months right, it would be sheer lunacy to base major economic changes on what they say will happen in decades![/i]
Now, if their error regarding something as complex and changeable as the weather implies that we should disbelieve them, what do we conclude from your claim that there were four such articles, which you have now [u]revised down[/u] to two? I see a direct parallel, with the important difference that you screwed up a much easier computation.
:D
by absolutely
You two have been expressing disbelief in global warming long enough to have archived some pages that make predictions related to the weather, in case they're history-revised off the .gov or .edu sites that the .orgs cite the most. Have you done so?
I'll check those noaa.gov sites you posted soon, but in the meantime, you have evidence of 2, not 4 contrary statements, assuming I'll agree that one contradicts the other in any important way, and you've also made an error.
If you can make unsubstantiated claims, why can't the greenies?
by tonythetiger
[i]You two have been expressing disbelief in global warming[/i]
Where have I EVER expressed such disbelief? I do not disbelieve that the earth is warming. I express disbelief that it is the end of civilization, or anything other than a natural cycle. I express disbelief that man has or can significantly affect this cycle one way or the other. And I express the most disgust that I can muster at the knowledge that there are those who would use this issue to "frighten the natives" into giving up their property or liberties (or in the case of the natives not-so-easily frightened, taking those things away by force).
by tonythetiger
[i]Now, if their error regarding something as complex and changeable as the weather implies that we should disbelieve them, what do we conclude from your claim that there were four such articles, which you have now [u]revised down[/u] to two?[/i]
... that you wrote that. My take on you has always been that you don't "conclude" anything until all of the ascertainable facts have been assessed (a trait I admire and aspire to).
To "conclude" is to stop thinking, and anyone who claims that (genuine) scientists have "concluded" anything is probably not someone I'd place a lot of faith in.
(oops. hit submit too soon)
also, I did not "revise down" my claim. I am simply unable to substantiate it at this time.
[i]I see a direct parallel, with the important difference that you screwed up a much easier computation.[/i]
Please explain.
by tonythetiger
[i]If you can make unsubstantiated claims, why can't the greenies?[/i]
They can, and do. Talk is cheap. The difference is that I am not using my speech to deprive them of property and liberty :)
by deepsand
At an abritrary time within another arbitrary 24 hour period, at an arbitrary geo-spatial location, at an arbitrary celestial position?
Rubbish.
by deepsand
from the trend as being indicative of the trend itself. In fact, the two are very much different things.
It is quite easy to construct a waveform which both has a [u]continuing[/u] upward or downward [u]trend[/u], [b]and[/b] still continues to produce [b]both[/b] [u]new highs and lows[/u]!
In fact, as weather systems are thermally driven, an increase in energy, i.e. heat, will perforce induce increased volatility.
by deepsand
By way of example:
A) All Blue Jays are Birds.
B) All Cardinals are Birds.
C) All Crows are Birds.
D) All Doves are Birds.
Is it therefore true that all Birds are either Blue Jays, Cardinals, Crows or Dove? No, it is not.
If I today see a Bird, might it not be one other than a Blue Jay, Cardinal, Crow or Dove? Yes, it might.
If I was not able to identify the Bird that I just saw, can I assume that it must have been any of the above named Birds? No, I cannot.
Likewise, if you claim that a present cause is the same as a past one, and there were multiple past causes, and therefore are multiple possible current causes, you must [b]prove[/b] which [b]specific cause[/b] is now in play.
Stop trying to weasel out from under your claim. Absent proof, yours is naught but an un-substantiated conjecture.
Additionally, as previously explained, radiative forcing [u]is[/u] a natural process.
It's time for you to stop being a WATB, and start using your left brain.
by deepsand
by tonythetiger
[i]Is it therefore true that all Birds are either Blue Jays, Cardinals, Crows or Dove? No, it is not.[/i]
in your example, you you cannot prove that without producing an example of a bird not of one of he aforementioned types.
by deepsand
To say that you "only assume[s] that humans were not the cause of previous cycles" has no bearing on what the present cause(s) is(are).
The very fact that human activities, and our effects on our surrounds, during the present and the near past are so vastly different means that the current physical system is quite different from that of the past, and that all new variables must be taken into account.
by tonythetiger
by deepsand
If you claim that there are no other kind of Birds, then the burden of proof lies with you to prove such. As you cannot prove a negative, your only hope is to be able to proof that it is not possible to not be one of the named Birds and still be a Bird.
Absent such a proof, you have fallen into the fallacy of mistaking the absence of the observation of any other kind of Bird for proof that none exist.
[u]Absence[/u] of Proof [b]is not[/b] [u]Proof[/u] of Absence.
by deepsand
each perfectly balanced.
Can you predict the results in the short term, with any more than mere chance results? No.
Yet, in the long term, you can make quite accurate predictions for both.
Alternatively, consider a large tub of water, into which you continually add more, sometimes slowly pouring in a small stream at the very surface, while at others dumping in an entire bucket full from a great height.
While you cannot accurately predict what the water height will be at any particular point in the tub at a given moment, you can most assuredly predict that, with the passage of time, it will continue to rise.
As I previously noted, constructing mathematical functions which produce seeming contradictions between the short term volatility and the long term trend is child's play.
by deepsand
A [u]logical[/u] conclusion is based on the facts at hand, and makes no pretense that it applies to anything more than those facts.
Neither does it claim that those facts represent the totality of all possible relevant facts, or that they are immutable for all time.
Just as people alter their subjective opinions when and where appropriate, depending on those factors which are relevant to such opinions, so to does science re-evaluate prior conclusions when presented with new and relevant data.
To fault Science for its past errors, to hold it to the impossible standard of Infallibility, is to condemn the very nature of humankind.
by tonythetiger
When you stop trying to convince people that it's a scientific issue and admit that it's a purely political one. Naturally, you won't, because your agenda depends on obfuscation. The primary tool used to maintain that obfuscation is your continued insistence that for you to be wrong, you must be proven wrong. That is a bastardization of the scientific method if I ever saw one... it is actually more like a religious argument.
The fact is that the earth has been doing what it's been doing for billions of years and if you want to claim that something different is going on, the burden is entirely upon you to prove that you're right. I don't have to re-prove that the apple fell today because of gravity in order to assert that it did, but if you want to assert that it fell for a new reason, you must prove it!
by tonythetiger
by seanferd
by deepsand
One need not know everything about everything that happened in the past in order to determine what is happening now!
This is merely a variation on the Absence of Proof as Proof of Absence fallacy.
Besides, if you don't know what the past causes were, how can you claim that the same are now in play? You're grasping at straws.
by deepsand
As one trained in the Sciences, following a self-initiated exploration of such begun in childhood, to state otherwise would be knowingly deny that which I know to be true.
And, until you recognize the difference, that Science is not about opinions, but about facts, for so long as you place opinions before facts, for so long as you refuse to study Science, you are doomed to being forever lost in matters of its realm; you will remain hostage to the puppet masters and spin meisters who would convince you that black is white, and white black, and that both derive from your own free will.
Pay no attention to that man behind the curtain.
"[i]You can't learn what you don't want to know.[/i]"
Sort by Trending