Discussion Locked

Spyware/adware What is the government doig?

0 helpful
12 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

What is our government doing here in the US to prosecute those that develop and deploy malicious code?

Anyone know?

12 replies

by jaqui

why not check the laws as written?
legal ibraries are a good place to start.
and a lawyer is a good source of info on legal questions.

just keep in mind that the us is not changing laws to include computer software, or inet, it is trying to apply laws never meant for the medium first, then changing or creating new laws. makes the us backwards from the rest of the world when it comes to laws around computers.

by thechas

The US Congress did talk about a bill to limit ad-ware.
As I recall, it got nowhere.

While ad-ware and spy-ware are problematic, for the most part, the person who's computer has this class of mal-ware on it opted in to the web site or software that placed the ad-ware on their PC.

Ad-ware and Spy-ware are not written with the malicious intent of a virus. They are written at the behest of companies to either improve their revenue stream from their web site, or to increase profits from software sales.

As such, the current administration would have little interest in limiting this form of commercial speech.

I get very little mal-ware on my PCs.
Most of it comes with "free-ware" that I have downloaded.

My advise, read the EULA and privacy statements for software and web sites.
In most cases, you will find that when you click on install, or sign up for membership on some web sites, you have agreed to allow whatever mal-ware the company chooses to install on your PC.

The other source of mal-ware is the peer-to-peer file sharing networks.
Again, you have agreed to the terms of membership which includes having mal-ware installed on your PC.

If mal-ware is a problem on a company network, you need to monitor and limit the web sites your users access.

Chas

by tony hopkinson

They'll just do it from outside the country. I read somewhere that 70% of the worlds spam, comes from kit in the US.

I think we are talking gold pens and international agreements here.

by maxwell edison

.
Gee, you have a problem and you automatically turn to "government" to solve it? And then some people blame the "current administration" for the problem. Hello! The "current administration", or any administration, cannot write laws.

On one hand the "current administration" is criticized for what some people perceive as squelching "freedom of speech". On the other hand, the "current administration" is criticized for NOT squelching what some people may call "freedom of speech". I guess it depends on what some people may or may not want to allow.

Bottom line: Quit relying on "government" to wipe the bottom of every problem that arises. Figure out a way to deal with it.

However, there already ARE laws against the practice of deploying malicious code. Free enterprise will either have to figure out a way to deal with it, or lose even more of their own freedoms if they expect the government to baby-sit every computer user.

by thechas

My first thought on Ad-Ware and Spy-Ware was that most of the time, the user has authorized the installation of the mal-ware. As such, the user is responsible for the problems with their PC and needs to pay attention to what they do.

Thinking about this, we don't allow a number of malicious practices for brick and mortar businesses, why should we allow malicious code to be incorporated into web sites and software?

If you go with commercial solutions for protecting your PC from all forms of mal-ware, you now need to spend at least $100 (US) for anti-virus, anti-spy-ware, and a firewall.
Many of these programs require constant updates and annual subscriptions to maintain them.
Why should the consumer bear the cost of stopping mal-ware directly?

As an example, I have a mentally challenged relative. Among other issues, he is VERY gullible.

However, he is an accomplished chess player.

Where he lives, chess clubs and tournaments are all on-line, or only communicate via email.

We set him up with a PC so he could go on line and access chess games.
Within 2 months, his PC was so bound up with mal-ware that he could no longer even connect.
I spent 3 hours Christmas day clearing up what I could manually.
I recognized most of the mal-ware as items from pop-up and banner ads. He must have clicked on the ads and felt it critical to allow them to install their code.

When I talked things over with him, his primary comment was why would anyone try to trick somebody like that!

As to training him for what to watch out for, if I am lucky, I get over to his place 4 or 5 times a year. Since these are family gatherings, there is little time for one on one activity.
No one in his household is computer savvy.

I can also see him as easy prey for phishing schemes.

Individual responsibility can only protect so many of us form mal-ware.
Do we deny those who are not wise enough to avoid mal-ware the right to use the Internet?

At a minimum, any additional software that a web site or application wants to install should be required to as openly inform the user of what the impact is as a loan form does.
Further, users MUST be allowed to not install the mal-ware while still installing the desired application.

Chas

by maxwell edison

.
As you probably know, while some people are automatically inclined to seek a "government solution" to a problem, I am much more prone to seek a "private or individual solution". However, as we will probably both agree, there are indeed times when one or the other is obviously preferable. (And being obvious to one, and not obvious to the other, is what makes the discussions "interesting".)

After I posted my message, which I will admit was posted in haste, I continued to think about it and considered that, perhaps, a government solution may indeed be necessary. (I still wouldn't streeeeeeetch it so far as to "blame" any "current administration", however.) Just as our highways have speed limits and other various "rules of the road", I suppose the Information Super Highway could use a few as well. But I sure wouldn't want an Information Super-Highway Patrol monitoring the Information Freeways, either.

I'll post some more after I think about it for a while.

by thechas

Max,

Don't get me wrong, I do not blame the Bush administration for the growth of mal-ware, nor for government inaction.

My point re the current administration is that we are not apt to see any laws proposed by the Bush administration that would in any way restrict business activities.

Now, should mal-ware begin to have the same impact on business productivity that SPAM has had, we might see action proposed.

I find it very sad that our IT department has started including SpyBot on new PCs.

Chas

by thechas

Max,

How about a required standard of conduct for web sites and software producers coupled with a NGO that has the ability to shut down web sites and force software recalls.

That way, the onus is on users to report sites and companies for misconduct. Sort of like how we enforce standards of decency here at TR.

Chas

by garion11

and arrest 14 year olds that are making this stuff? Tell the users to NOT download stupid crap from the Internet, NOT to click OK on POPUPs, use Firefox, install Zonealarm, stop going to Porn sites on company time, run Adware regularly, delete temp files, cache and history.

Sigh...I hate snow.

by thechas

Many commercial software packages install ad-ware to increase their revenue streams.
Broderbund, Intuit, Real are but a few that track your usage.

While viri writers are often foreign based, many of the worst ad-ware and spy-ware code comes from good old US companies looking to make extra profits from unsuspecting consumers.

Chas

by tony hopkinson

One of the places we need goverment action I'm sorry to say. Regulatory body or some such, fines etc. Hardly perfect but while 'reputable businesses' allow themselves such tactics, law is a waste of time.

by the admiral

The government takes everything like it is business as usual until there is a tanamount number of complaints.

The government never in history except for the first 4 years of GWB has been active in preventing things, but has been reactive at every level. Sept 11 = Patriot Act; Pearl Harbor = World War II; Poor Retirement Planning = Social Security; Black Monday = SEC; just to name a few.

Until we send stacks of mail to our legislators stating how bad the situation is, there will be zero that can be done to fix the problem other than create software to take care of the problems.

Does this make it right and just? No. There are going to be people who are not going to be able to recover from the large numbers of abuses of the systm in that their identity will be stolen. It will take them 10 years on average to fix the problem, 3 years after it falls off their credit report.

What can be done? Place a block on Credit Reporting Agencies so that credit requests have to be physically signed for. Two, ensure that any information is audited on a quarterly basis and positive confirmation is done at least that number of times. Three, Credit reporting companies not place items on credit reports that are in dispute (even the "Second secret" one that they send to the companies asking for credit info. Fourth, when a police report has been filed, All items on a credit report now have to be physically confirmed and verified from the prior two years, and until it is verified, they are removed.

That is how you save the consumers from Spyware/adaware. Then you take them suckers to court, find them guilty, and lock them up in the nastiest of Jails.

This discussion is closed to new replies.