Discussion Locked

TAX DAY, and 47 percent of all adult Americans pay NO Federal Income Taxes

0 helpful
220 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I wonder if such a thing happens in other industrialized countries? (Great Britain, Canada, Australia, France, Germany, Japan, et al?)

I wonder what will happen when the percentage of those paying NO Federal Income Taxes surpasses 50 percent?

I wonder what will happen when our national debt equals - or exceeds - our GDP (Gross Domestic Product)?

I wonder what will happen when the 20-somethings, 30-somethings, and 40-somethings realize their future is saddled with a huge unsecured debt?

I wonder what will happen when the 20-somethings, 30-somethings, and 40-somethings realize they've been saddled with huge unfunded entitlement obligations to others?

I wonder what will happen when .....

But what the hell? Many of those 20-somethings, 30-somethings, and 40-somethings actually voted for it! To them: Have fun sleeping in the bed you made.

This madness is simply not sustainable.

The [i]progressives[/i] have been able to trump reality by playing the [i]compassion[/i] card. But in the end, they will be proven to be the Jokers - unfortunately, it will come at the expense of the rest of the deck.

Yes, I wrote a pretty big check today. And not only am I not thanked for it, but I'm actually ridiculed. Maybe they want my heart as well?

As hard as I try, and as hard as I work, funding my own retirement remains that elusive butterfly. Other people just won't allow me to do it. And the check I wrote today proves it - maybe when I'm 80 or when pigs fly.

Maybe I should chuck the effort and become a ward of the state. Maybe I'll just do what's necessary so I can become a tax receiver instead of a tax payer. Maybe I'm on the wrong band-wagon. Yea, that's it; I'm on the wrong band-wagon.

Happy tax day!

220 replies

by tig2

We managed to pay our taxes about a month and a half ago. We are also trying to pre-pay 2011 taxes now. We are living on our retirement savings today because there isn't a hell of a lot of choice. SSDI- that he paid into for over 35 years- doesn't cover much.

The system sucks mightily. I don't know anyone that would dispute that. And I get that you are frustrated. Join the club.

Forgive me, but I don't see the value in kvetching about it.

by maxwell edison

You could consider me among the [i]unemployed[/i]. I haven't had a full-time job in over a year.

However, I don't dare collect unemployment compensation from the government. I won't do it; it's a matter of principle. I want nothing from this government - except, of course, to be guaranteed protection of my civil liberties (dream on!).

Instead, I get by the best I can. I do what I need to do. And I know what it's like tapping into retirement savings - like I had to do today to pay my taxes so that other people might collect their unemployment benefits.

What's wrong with this !@#$%^& picture?

And those who collect those unemployment benefits call me selfish!

by tig2

He was unemployed for nearly a year before the diagnosis and we didn't file for SSDI until several months after that.

I have some pretty ugly doctor's bills- even after the insurance has done their minimal thing. Hell, we pay over $3600 a month for ONE of his scrips. We will do that for the rest of his life.

[b]I'm[/b] not the enemy. You may not approve of how we are fighting our way through but at least we are fighting and not laying about whining about how we aren't being given a fighting chance. YOU aren't paying his medical bills, WE ARE.

We PAID our taxes. Maybe we didn't pay as much as some would like. Tough.

We collect the SSDI that he paid into for over 35 years.

Why in hell are you going after me?

by oz_media

You paid into a system designed to assist you when you were unemplyed and yet chose not to accept the benefits which you paid for. Therefore those that pay into teh system and choose to accept such benefits they have paid for owe you no apology.

It is like paying for medical insurance and then letting yourself die because you are too proud to use the insurance. That's nobody's problem but your own.

by maxwell edison

We've ALL paid into it - some for MORE than 35 years.

However, it's all gone; it's all spent; it's nothing but a bunch of IOUs in a file cabinet in West Virginia.

Current - and future - tax payers are actually the ones paying for it.

It begs the question, who's going to pay for them?

by tig2

As would he. We PAID ours. We didn't need to start forum discussions about it either.

Just my opinion but you are starting the wrong fight with the wrong person.

I am sorry you think that we should have seen this coming, stored millions of dollars and never touched anything that we had paid into.

I'm equally sorry you think so little of me.

I know, I know. We were so unforgivably stupid we even bought insurance thinking we were being responsible and yet completely screwing up your version of utopia that doesn't include such things.

Whatever.

Personally, I am grateful that we HAVE that insurance. And I don't feel a moments guilt that he collects SSDI. Just a thought here- I am not his marital partner. I will not collect survivor benefits. I will likely have to take time off work so that I can attend his funeral. Happy now?

by maxwell edison

And more concerned about my son and other people's sons and daughters - into whose lap this whole mess will ultimately fall.

I give it ten years. It'll make the Great Depression look like a walk on the beach.

by oz_media

The UK is STARTING to pull out of it this year, by half of the proposed growth anyway. Canada, having a better banking system didnt quite see the negative repercussions other nations did, but suffers all teh same because now that your dollar is worth less than ours, we pay mroe for gas at the pump because there is less revenue from you, just as power bills have gone up, lumber is more expensive etc. But alas, it is not the end of my world just yet, I have more to give.

I certainly feel for you, poor old Americans are so hard done by in your communist society.

by tonythetiger

[i]The UK is STARTING to pull out of it this year,[/i]

they'll blow more smoke up our asses and re-arrange their mirrors... but the hardest is yet to come.

by maxwell edison

.... to these questions - the ones I initially asked:

I wonder if such a thing happens in other industrialized countries? (Great Britain, Canada, Australia, France, Germany, Japan, et al?)

I wonder what will happen when the percentage of those paying NO Federal Income Taxes surpasses 50 percent?

I wonder what will happen when our national debt equals - or exceeds - our GDP (Gross Domestic Product)?

I wonder what will happen when the 20-somethings, 30-somethings, and 40-somethings realize their future is saddled with a huge unsecured debt?

I wonder what will happen when the 20-somethings, 30-somethings, and 40-somethings realize they've been saddled with huge unfunded entitlement obligations to others?

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=329288&messageID=3277852&tag=content;leftCol

by maxwell edison

..... is still a tax.

How many such [i]chameleons[/i] do we see every day? User fees, access fees, look at them listed in your phone bill fees, registration fees, surcharges, hospitatility fees, etc........ and tolls.

Build a toll booth. If they don't pay, they walk.

by santeewelding

I got my hands all over you, palpating for the least of your ailment.

Dear God: Would that I could do more.

I am more than sure that Max is of like mind.

by maxwell edison

..... I can only ask that you take a second look. Did I really say what you thought I said? I won't attempt to answer for you.

by maxwell edison

..... the truck that hit the curve ball out of left field into foul territory that hit me up side of the head with a 2x4 when I wasn't looking. Or something like that.

P.S. But something inside is telling me to just let it go.

by santeewelding

Hit, System Restore.

(I just had to, among other things, like pulling the plug on my router, checking connectivity, etc., after a slew of problems interfered with me being here...ain't nobody remoting into my setup, is there?)

Tig is loved; you are loved; and I love me.

by maxwell edison

We made our bed, and we now have to sleep in it.

Some of us, however, have been rallying for years - even decades - against the way it was being made - and we're the one's getting short-sheeted. Actually, we're all getting short-sheeted.

by oz_media

I've said for years that your country could not sustain itself beased purely on eth lifestyle Americans feel they derserve to live by/ I don't know how many times I have pointed out how personal gluttony will not be sustained forever. You can blame it on whatever you choose, and YES, all governments are so currupt in that way, you are not alone, just catching up and seeing reality first hand. Recessions happen and it takes teh actions of the people to change that, not just the government. I've said before that there's nothing you can do by winging about government, all you can do is learn to live for less and make the most out of it one day at a time. Government's are screwed globally, no matter hwo's in power, and yours is no different, it's just that the people like to pretend you are above the realities others have learned to face.

by excorpguy

This blog got me thinking of Social Security deductions that I have paid my entire working life. I am currently 46 years old.

Originally when Social Security was started, it was only supposed to be a supplemental income in retirement. Also, at the time life spans were only within a year or two of when one started getting the benefits.

Fast forward to today and many people have not saved enough money during their lives to support their retirement years. Many rely entirely on their Social Security checks for their existence.

The simple fact is that Congress has spent the Social Security fund over the years. More people have been added to the roles without ever having worked and added to the existing fund with SSI and death benefits.

Do I believe that I will receive ANY Social Security benefits after years of payroll deductions? It is simple math that the number or people draining the fund dry vs. those paying into it say NO.

I expect very soon that age cutoffs will be enacted that those of a certain age will continue to be benefits. Those that fall under the magic number will be SOL.

Add to this VAT and a National Sales Tax to bleed everyone with a few more years of this Ponzi scheme.

My 2 cents...

by maxwell edison

..... is that people (like you) see it as a personal attack on them. Rest assured, it's not.

I'm not attacking you or anyone like you. I'm rallying against an overall system that is not only unfair, but it's destructive and has put us on the road to financial disaster.

The train wreck is not only likely, but it's imminent. What happens then?

And what should I tell my son when he wonders why his generation is being handed a mess like this? Be thankful you don't have any kids who ask you the same question.

P.S. And people like me - who have also been paying into the same system for more than 35 years - have been warning others about the looming disaster that awaits. But not enough people would listen. They were too busy either playing or folding to the compassion card.

P.P.S. How could you possibly think that starting this discussion was intended to be a personal attack against you? I've supported you and your causes for years.

by maxwell edison

..... did I personally target you? Please be specific.

And if I posted something that's factually wrong, please point that out.

Moreover, how could you possibly think that starting this discussion was intended to be a personal attack against you? I've supported you and your causes for years.

by charliespencer

"The progressives have been able to trump reality by playing the compassion card."

Plenty of blame to go around across the political spectrum. Progressives didn't go to war in the Middle East with no plan to pay for it other than running up the debt.

by maxwell edison

And look at a breakdown of the federal budget. How much is spent, and where does it go?

P.S. And try to just answer the five questions. Even if you want to blame Bush and the war in the middle-east, the questions are still worthy of being asked - and answered.

P.P.S. I'm actually rethinking my position on the middle-east. Maybe simply isolating the whole lot of them the best we can is the better approach.

by maxwell edison

.... by making a factual statement:

[i](It's) TAX DAY, and 47 percent of all adult Americans pay NO Federal Income Taxes[/i]

and by asking five questions:

[i]I wonder if such a thing happens in other industrialized countries? (Great Britain, Canada, Australia, France, Germany, Japan, et al?)

I wonder what will happen when the percentage of those paying NO Federal Income Taxes surpasses 50 percent?

I wonder what will happen when our national debt equals - or exceeds - our GDP (Gross Domestic Product)?

I wonder what will happen when the 20-somethings, 30-somethings, and 40-somethings realize their future is saddled with a huge unsecured debt?

I wonder what will happen when the 20-somethings, 30-somethings, and 40-somethings realize they've been saddled with huge unfunded entitlement obligations to others?[/i]

You didn't answer any of the questions, but rather took offense to them being asked. What, in my original message (or subsequent ones), was targeting you? I have to wonder why you even posted what you did?

Heck, I wish at least one person would try to answer the five questions in an objective manner?

by notsochiguy

...your/our money is going to reform people and put them on the path of righteousness:

http://www.cnn.com/video/#/video/us/2010/04/15/am.zarrella.scamming.irs.cnn

In the article I read on this yesterday, the part that slayed me was that the IRS was given mountains of evidence from police/department of corrections sources, and pretty much only had to take it to a DA for prosecution. Instead, it was stated that they needed to start their own investigation from scratch.

So, not only was the money flying out the door for the scam, but double the fact-finding efforts = double the taxpayers' money it takes to stop these felons.

Unreal.

The Joker had it right in 'The Dark Knight'; the government may as well put it in a pile and burn it. The heat from the fire would provide more tangible value than what we're getting now.

by jfuller05

Perhaps lunatic is an understatement when it comes to the Joker, but you understand what I mean. :)

by jamesrl

According to the Calgary Herald, 30% of Canadians pay no Federal Tax (though when you look at taxes, there are many other taxes that everyone pays.

http://communities.canada.com/calgaryherald/blogs/hannaford/archive/2009/04/17/30-per-cent-of-canadians-pay-no-tax-at-all.aspx

Regarding Taxes:
http://www.fraserinstitute.org/Commerce.Web/product_files/CanadianConsumerTaxIndex2007.pdf

On National Debt to GDP ratio by country:
Canada (62.3%)is similar to the US(60.8 %), better than some worse than others. Japan makes us all look good (170.4%). But I have to say, Canada's trend over the past while has been going down (running surpluses yearly) until the recession.

James

by maxwell edison

I ask this not because I doubt you, but because they do not match up with the information in the following article:

http://www.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNews/story/CTVNews/20071108/tax_rich_071108?s_name=&no_ads=

[i]....Canadians with an income of $13,523 -- the lowest 10 per cent of family earnings -- were paying 30.7 per cent in federal and provincial taxes....[/i]

By contrast, any American family of four with a household income of $50,000 per year or less, pays NO federal income tax - ZERO.

Those with an annual household income of less than $50,000, not only pay NO federal income taxes, but it's very likely they'll get a gift of cash from those who do pay taxes.

by jamesrl

You assume the two statements are incompatible or inconsistent.

The Calgary Herald article claims 30% of Canadians pay no income tax. Their article is based on a study from the right wing think tank, the Fraser Institute (who I don't always agree with, but who I respect).

The CTV story is based on a study by a left wing think tank. They claim the higher income earners have benefited from tax cuts which started in the mid 90s more than lower or middle income. It shows the top 5% pay less tax on a proportional (percentage of income basis) than poor. But when you look at the study directly (just look at the charts) you see the bottom 10% pay little federal and provincial tax, but proportionately more "other" taxes. The "total" taxes for the bottom 10 is about 25%, the top 1% 30%(the middle class pay more as a percentage).

Certainly I know a large number of people who are adults who do not earn enough income
to file, my wife is one. She has health issues which precludes her holding a steady job, but according to standards she does not qualify for any kind of government support. So much for living in socialist canukistan.

I also know a number of women who raise kids instead of working, or take only part time jobs. The income threshold for filing a tax return in Canada is around $8500 for a single person. They would be part of the 30% that don't pay taxes. I honestly don't think it would equal 30% if that was the only group involved.

Rough calculation for Ontario is that about 7% are on welfare, thats up as some people laid off in the recession use up their employment insurance benefits go onto welfare. If you are unemployed for a full year you'd probably get any taxes paid on employment insurance refunded. We also have seniors on limited incomes, and single mothers on welfare.So while 30% doesn't seem outlandish, I couldn't find a good breakdown. But that doesn't mean all of those people are living off government funding.

BTW I paid income taxes on the employment insurance income I got from the government when I was laid off in 2002.

James

by jck

[i]Yes, I wrote a pretty big check today. And not only am I not thanked for it, but I'm actually ridiculed. Maybe they want my heart as well?

As hard as I try, and as hard as I work, funding my own retirement remains that elusive butterfly. Other people just won't allow me to do it. And the check I wrote today proves it - maybe when I'm 80 or when pigs fly.

Maybe I should chuck the effort and become a ward of the state. Maybe I'll just do what's necessary so I can become a tax receiver instead of a tax payer. Maybe I'm on the wrong band-wagon. Yea, that's it; I'm on the wrong band-wagon.

Happy tax day! [/i]

Just a simple question, Max.

Do you claim all your exemptions during the year?

As your investments earn dividends, do you actively pay tax on them throughout the year?

If you're writing out a "big" check every tax year, I tend to think it's because you have deferred paying taxes until the latest time possible, rather than at the point you are paid.

I claim zero exemptions, plus pay in $10 each pay period extra.

Each year, I get a 4-figure tax refund. About 2/3 of that is due to home mortgage interest write-off.

Something is wrong if you're writing a big check, because if you pay taxes on all your income at the time that you earn it within the tax tables the IRS publishes...you should have little or no tax burden to pay.

And if you have any exemptions/write-offs, you should end up getting somewhat of a refund.

I'm no tax advisor, but I'd bet there's something else there.

Anyways. Sorry you had to pay.

I got my refund in February, and paid off some debt. :)

Happy tax day :^0

by jck

folks like Roman Abromovich and others who are foreign nationals using the "non-domicile" exemption and avoiding some GBP 2B of taxes.

Pity really. That's monies I'm sure your nation could use well to help the sick or improve motorways.

by ic-it

Those that did not pay really aren't making much in the way of income.
That includes head of households working two or more jobs.
I too had to write a fairly large check, for that I am happy.
It means that i am still earning and providing for my family. I will increase my withholdings this year just enough to avoid the penalties. It is my money and I am not giving them a free ride.

To suggest this financial mess is the result of the progressives, come on, you are smarter than that.

by maxwell edison

.... so I read your message.

But alas, I discovered that you did not answer my questions at all. Your misleading message title said [i]answers[/i], but there were none. There were only questions for me. I'll make a deal with you. You answer my questions first, and then I'll answer yours.

by oz_media

If you pay for insurance, you are only right to collect that insurance. Just like OAP, Medical Insurance, motor vehicle insurance. If you feel you are more of a man by not collecting what you have paid for, that's your 'choice', and YOUR choice is exactly what it is. You can't then go and complain that you made such a choice and see no benefit from it.

by jck

See, you put out that you are paying out taxes.

However, you do not supply the method or arrangements you have to pay them out during the year...and imply that you are paying out more than the IRS mandated schedule.

Hence, no one can definitively say why your tax bill is a burden on you or not.

It would be like you asking an accountant to do the taxes for your wages without giving them your check stubs, W-2, etc.

Why are you paying high taxes on your submission?

For all I know, it could be because you're being penalized for delinquency.

Hence, this is the answer to your question:

No one can solve your problem, unless given the full breadth of terms by which you paid during the year.

But if you want answers to your diatribe, then here some direct ones are:

[i]I wonder if such a thing happens in other industrialized countries? (Great Britain, Canada, Australia, France, Germany, Japan, et al?)[/i]

Yes. Lower income folks in other countries are exempted from tax, as well as wealthy people who use loopholes to get income exemptions.

[i]I wonder what will happen when the percentage of those paying NO Federal Income Taxes surpasses 50 percent?[/i]

Many things can happen. That all depends on what the Congress passes into law.

[i]I wonder what will happen when our national debt equals - or exceeds - our GDP (Gross Domestic Product)?[/i]

Again, many things can happen.

Maybe China will invade?

[i]I wonder what will happen when the 20-somethings, 30-somethings, and 40-somethings realize their future is saddled with a huge unsecured debt?[/i]

I'm a 40-something. I can only speak for myself.

A lot of the fiscal conservatives complained about Clinton, but he at least balanced a budget. He made departments tighten their belts and make things work without killing off departments and offices that did provide needed service.

Then when those fiscal conservatives got their candidate in office, he skyrocketed the debt with no positive result other than increasing dividends on a select group of stocks (finance and oil).

So what is this 40-something going to do? I'll give someone besides the status quo politicians a chance to do something constructive, rather than let party politics dictate our country's direction.

[i]I wonder what will happen when the 20-somethings, 30-somethings, and 40-somethings realize they've been saddled with huge unfunded entitlement obligations to others?[/i]

It didn't just start. Been going on for decades.

And since it's been going on for years, why did you and your generation not do something about it so things would be better?

[i]But what the hell? Many of those 20-somethings, 30-somethings, and 40-somethings actually voted for it! To them: Have fun sleeping in the bed you made.[/i]

Hm. Let's see.

The country is in a mess from 8 years of "conservative" direction, yet it's the total fault of a president who hasn't been in office even half his term?

Your hypothesis is faulted for that, and the fact that *all* of these problems you claim are what the younger folks "voted for"...have all existed for decades.

[i]The progressives have been able to trump reality by playing the compassion card. But in the end, they will be proven to be the Jokers - unfortunately, it will come at the expense of the rest of the deck.[/i]

I'm surprised you didn't sneak a Clinton/"poker" joke in there too.

As for the "compassion card", the "conservatives" played that as well. Bush was always making empassioned speeches about "helping the people of Iraq". Well, over $700B spent over there and what do we have?

Nothing.

Iraqi independence has not taken place.
Iraqi military is still not stable.
Iraqi economic conditions have barely improved.
Iraqi infrastructure is still a mess.
Iraqi borders are still insecure.

So, we've spent $720B in Iraq and benefitted how?

At least Obama's healthcare plan gets people medical attention which means people are more able to work, and it is designed to reduce wasteful spending in government healthcare systems.

Is there wrong with more able-bodied workers and lower amounts of wasteful government spending?

[i]Yes, I wrote a pretty big check today. And not only am I not thanked for it, but I'm actually ridiculed. Maybe they want my heart as well?[/i]

No, paying your taxes will do just fine. Keep your heart.

BTW, no one gets thanked by the IRS. Stop whining.

[i]As hard as I try, and as hard as I work, funding my own retirement remains that elusive butterfly. Other people just won't allow me to do it. And the check I wrote today proves it - maybe when I'm 80 or when pigs fly.[/i]

Who is stopping you? You have no retirement investments?

As much as you act like you make, you should be able to. I'm just a piddly computer programmer, and I have a tidy sum put away less than 10 years after having to cash in because of post-9/11 circumstances.

Rather than a tax advisor, it sounds like you could use a financial advisor if your financial future is so bleak.

[i]Maybe I should chuck the effort and become a ward of the state. Maybe I'll just do what's necessary so I can become a tax receiver instead of a tax payer. Maybe I'm on the wrong band-wagon. Yea, that's it; I'm on the wrong band-wagon.[/i]

Perhaps you should.

Then, you can eat bland food and not get to choose what you eat.

And, you will have to watch whatever channels they have on the TV in the home you are put into.

Plus, you won't get to decide what games you wish to play as the home will decide your recreational activities.

There you go. Choose to be a ward, and you lose your choices in life.

BTW, I'm pondering going back to school and staying on the financial assistance program as long as I can. $50k in loans per year + $15k grants? Tax free?

I could live like a king and bolster my retirements easily.

I wonder if I can stretch out getting a degree in kennel cleaning for 8 years. :^0

by oz_media

I don't see or keep my tax returns, for another year anyway, but then I'll have that extra few grand each year, no GSt rebate of course, people who earn more money and buy more goods (thus paying more GST) don't get get such quarterly rebates. Mind you the GST rebate isn't even enough to fill my gas tank once. But it was 19 degrees and stunningly beatiful today, went and hung out at the marine with a friend and had salmon fihss and chips, yummy. Glad I can afford to pay taxes and enjoy when I'm not working though.

by jck

I think the case is concerning Max:

He takes as many exemptions as he can during the year, and maybe makes extra earnings for which he doesn't pay at a rate that would cover the tax obligation.

Then when April 15 comes and he didn't pay in enough during the year, he has to write a fat check.

He sees that as paying "too much" when it is, in reality, what everyone else is paying too.

Hell. I paid 5 figures in taxes this past year. Between 25 and 30 percent of my income to the US government. Plus 7.65 percent FICA/Medicare.

Does it bother me? Yeah. I get no free anything in this country. While I think people unable to provide for themselves should get help, there has to be a determination to differentiate between [b]unable[/b] and [b][u]unwilling[/b][/u].

The US Government is REALLY bad at that. They need to find those who can work (and as I have said repeatedly before) and make the Jamestown, Virginia precident apply:

If you're able to work and you don't...and your family won't provide for you...then you will starve...

Starvation is a huge motivator to work.

And oh yeah. Someone tries to steal from you rather than work and earn their meals...allow the victim to shoot the criminal.

by jamesrl

Since the 60s when many rich people left Britain because of tax issues, including more than a few rock stars.

Take a good listen to the Beatles "Taxman", it isn't just a pop song. The Beatles were subject like a few other very rich Britains to a super tax of 95%. So when whey sing 1 for you, 19 for me, they were not exagerating at all.

Taxman:
Let me tell you how it will be,
There?s one for you, nineteen for me,
?Cause I?m the Taxman,
Yeah, I?m the Taxman.
Should five per cent appear too small,
Be thankful I don?t take it all.
?Cos I?m the Taxman,
Yeah, I?m the Taxman.

(If you drive a car ), I?ll tax the street,
(If you try to sit ), I?ll tax your seat,
(If you get too cold ), I?ll tax the heat,
(If you take a walk ), I?ll tax your feet.
Taxman.

?Cause I?m the Taxman,
Yeah, I?m the Taxman.
Don?t ask me what I want it for
(Taxman! Mister Wilson!)
If you don?t want to pay some more
(Taxman! Mister Heath!),
?Cause I?m the Taxman,
Yeah, I?m the Taxman.

Now my advice for those who die, (Taxman!)
Declare the pennies on your eyes, (Taxman!)
?Cause I?m the Taxman,
Yeah, I?m the Taxman.
And you?re working for no-one but me,
(Taxman).

by jamesrl

We don't have many toll roads, one in Ontario. It was built by the government then privatised, sold to a foreign company.

If you don't pay your tolls, you can't renew your plates. Drive with out of date plates, pay another fine, and so on.

James

by maxwell edison

In today's talk, if Person-A wants to keep what he earns so that he can decide what to do with it himself, he's called [i]selfish[/i].

By contrast, if Person-B wants to take those earnings from Person-A - either for himself or for the presumed benefit of others - he's called [i]compassionate[/i]

What's wrong with this picture?

by oz_media

Someone that doesn't want to pay taxes, that lives in a nation like all others that collects such taxes, is either delusional or overly hopeful.

I don't want to pay taxes either, but guess what, we all do if we earn a living and want to enjoy our freedoms. If we didn't pay taxes, you would end up being paid about half of what you do now. NET income is what you should focus living on, that's what you really earn, forget calculating gross figures.

by maxwell edison

People are either afraid to admit they're riding on a gravy train, or they're afraid of being criticized for not wanting to fund it.

by oz_media

Please, interview 10,000 people collecting EI or welfare and let me know how many live a comfortable life riding the gravy train. THen let me know how many have no hope of furthering their education due to costs and retraining limitations, how many USED to pay a lot of money in taxes and wish they could again, how many are living with people they can't stand because they simply cannot afforf to live alone, how many couldn't afford to buy the kids new shoes, pens and pencils for school, how many couldn't afford to help their mother with her health issues before she passed away, how many can't afford to feed themselves after they spent their entire welfare check feeding and keeping a roof over their kids heads (if they are fortunate enough).

Man, you sure do find some bizarre issues to feel sorry for yourself about. Are you feeling a little less fortunate due to your work status over the last year? I truly do hope things turn around for you, I've been there and AM there now. I have the skills to find SOME work but I am not working full time either, but I don't blame that on anyone, it's just that the most of the world has fallen on hard times, I am not alone.

I know a lot of people a lot worse off than me, I choose to think myself lucky that I can still enjoy my life, instead of feeling sorry for myself and blaming my current financial staus on others who are even less fortunate than me.

by oz_media

Maybe people are just tired of you blaming your current shortfalls on those less fortunate than yourself.

by sleepin'dawg

C'mon Max, I warned everyone here many times over that the best reason for keeping a low profile financially speaking was to avoid as much and as many taxes as possible and keep what little is left of our privacy and freedoms.
Take note; I said [b][i][u]AVOID[/b][/i][/u] not evade.
Well the chickens have finally come home to roost and none of them look to be too healthy or, for that matter, edible. I tried to give some investment advice but was pretty much ridiculed for my efforts.
People keep asking me how I've made out during the recent financial boondoggles, which, by the way, are still going on, witness Goldman-Sachs. I reply, "Anyone can make money in a bull market but it takes a really good investor to make money in a bear market as well." So far I'm doing just fine financially, thank-you very much. Now if I could just get my bones to knit properly I could really get to work on some of the opportunities I see comming up.

[b][i]Dawg[/b][/i] ]:)

by santeewelding

Have you made provisions against the pissed have-nots eyeing you as a have, no matter how much you have?

by sleepin'dawg

I may be on the limp for a bit but I'll never be a victim. I've always maintained that if you look and behave like a victim you'll end up being one.
I follow the old boy scout motto, "Be Prepared".

[b][i]Dawg[/b][/i] ]:)

by sleepin'dawg

Or all the offshore tax havens and they probably never will, even if they could.

[b][i]Dawg[/b][/i] ]:)

by oz_media

Seriously, Max. Once I manage to stop the flow of tears and catch my breath, I'll say a prayer for you. It really upsets me that the government doesn't send me a thank you letter either, but it is heartwarming to know that they need my money so badly that they wouldn't forget to take it each year and merely give me a safe, democratic nation with all the freedoms to enjoy the life I have made for myself. 30% of Canadians don't have such obligations as me, kinda makes me feel fuzzy inside.

I have to admit that it's also a privilege being the only Canadian that pays taxes, I know how it feels to be so alone in suffering from an extorted income, however it makes me feel so unique and important. I know that IF I ever get the fortune of retirement, I will also live on limited income and they will take a piece of taht too, and what do I get? Freedom? Peace? Safety? Health? A home? Weekends doing what I choose to do? Pshaw!

The fact that I have a home, a warm bed, food in the fridge and friends that I can enjoy my free time with means nothing in the grand scheme of things, I too am hard done by, I pay taxes (well in fact my income is simply stolen from me and given to others without so much as a thank you), but that's okay.

I'm the one who has it rough, not those who are disabled and unable to work, not those who's parents were drunks and crackheads so they were too screwed up to finish their education and get a good job, not those who didn't even have parents and were raised in foster homes and living with the resulting mental issues, it is ME that is hard done by. MY life is not fair and for that, I will shed these tears for those poor souls who are so desperately downtrodden, like us, and hope to hell that those that go without are bloody grateful for my sacrifice.

'kin whiny little clown.

by oz_media

Then less than half of yoru nation will be paying income tax. And perhaps you won't be able to bomb Baghdad, or next week's target without considering costs, maybe some of those people who are wrongly incarcerated at your personal expense will have to be released, MAYBE just maybe, you will have to be mroe resourceful (sorry, just a maybe don't want to scare anyone here), MAYBE you;ll have to pay a little more for yoru resources and take less from other nations, oh fiddlesticks, it's all Obama's fault. If Bush was still in power your could waste the trillions you choose to on idiotic means and then pretend it was all okay again while your government slips further into debt.

It's amazing how one man can screw up your nation in a mere year and a few months. Especially after teh repiblican party did such a great job of strengthening yoru economy and saving money for the prior 8 years. Oh, how stable your country was and how screwed up it is now, and they would have gotten away with it if it wasn't for them meddling democrats!

by thechas

Max,

I agree that the 47% projection from the Tax Policy Center is troubling. At least until you start looking behind the numbers.

Start with the Tax Policy Center report that is quoted as a source by many news stories.

http://www.taxpolicycenter.org/publications/url.cfm?ID=1001289

The first thing to note is that the 47% that will owe no federal income tax in 2009 is based on a computer model.

The more significant item to note is that the vast majority of those that will owe no income tax are families earning less than $40,000 in 2009.

I came across one statement in an article that said without the stimulus credits, the number of tax payers who would owe no income tax will drop to 38%

Still, what is missing in Tax Policy Center Report and all the news stories is that the main factor behind the 47% number is the loss of income for large numbers of families in this recession.

Another fact that was skipped, is that all of those tax payers in the 47% still paid their social security and Medicare taxes. So even if they ended up getting full refund of Federal Income Tax, they still contributed to the funding of the government.

One final thought on this. If you look at the details of the so called "fair tax", the prebate for low income families would amount to about the same percentage of people with no Federal tax burden.

Chas

by oz_media

The figrue includes, people who work full time and pay income taxes, sales taxes etc. but have enough deductions that they are not required to pay taxes on federal tax day.

Some of them even get a 'rebate' that MAY actually exceed what they pay in taxes.

Single mothers who work full time, get to write off babysitting/extended child care costs and more.

Low income, full time workers, often the family's sole breadwinner, also get great write offs.

Senoir citizens, I don't know how they get by pn what they get given in social security, are also exepmt.

So really, with these working people making up a great portion of the 'non-federal tax payers', they do pay their share of taxes and usually pay very little federal tax anyway, additional exepmtions and the stimulus plan have reduced that further, but the change has hardly tipped the scales that much further than before.

by oz_media

America was founded on the greatest constitution ever written by mankind. If people only still rode horses and carried muskets, life in America would be perfect. If more men wore knickers and women stayed at home raising children while their slaves tended the fields, life in America would be perfect.

Damn progress screwed everything up for them.

by jck

Poor corporation paying so much there.

Kinda like Bill Gates. You donate enough money to your charity that your daddy runs for you as a not-for-profit, you get to write off most of your taxes.

Maybe I can donate enough of my pay to a charity my parents run, that gives them extra income, and I can declare bankruptcy and owe no money. :^0

by oz_media

Wouldn't exactly give THEM more money though (unless illegally), being on the sucking end of the teet would help in that case.

by tonythetiger

[i]Someone tries to steal from you rather than work and earn their meals...allow the victim to shoot the criminal. [/i]

... he doesn't kill the criminal, but disables him for life?

by oz_media

I would believe the sky was falling too. In fact I'd have probably sucked on the tailpipe long ago, if I saw the world the way you do.

by jck

to give the victim another bullet to finish the job and clean up the gene pool, than to have to pay $40k-65k imprisoning a free-radical human...or worse yet...the $300k a year giving them care if they are a vegetable.

Or, there is another option:

Let their family take care of them. If the family doesn't want to, then nature will take care of that easy.

Either way, things would be dealt with.

by jck

If ya can find someone willing to feed, take care of, bathe, buy expensive medical supplies for a vegetable guy who got that way from being shot in the head while robbing someone?

Well, let them take care of him.

Otherwise, I don't think it's society's responsibility to take care of persons whose maladay came in the course of violating the law.

Otherwise, why don't I just go ram my car into a crowd of people then plunge into a tree and get brain damaged so my parents can claim medicaid and medicare for me and live in my house free as welfare will pay for it all?

Sorry. I can't see maintaining the physical well-being of a criminal. Makes no sense.

by jck

Because, the organization can pay them whatever salary...then disburse the rest to creditors and/or beneficiaries.

Gates' Sr. makes a dumpload overseeing the administration of the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation.

I just need to find a way to pay my parents really well for signing checks. :^0

by oz_media

From what I understand, in this case only the Canadian law on the matter, wage must be deemed 'fair and reasonable'. If the organization handles millions snd administrative duties would notmally pay six figures, then that is deemed fair and reasonable wage. YOu can't simply have a charity that handles 200,000 a year, have little to no responsibilty and take home 60,000/yr.

Reasonable wage is measured against what a person working for a for profit company and conducting the same duties with the same volume of revenue would earn. So if Bill Gates himself turned MS into a non-profit organization, he'd still take home a tidy sum, though of course less than he earns today, due to the gross revenue losses.

by tonythetiger

[i]I can't see maintaining the physical well-being of a criminal. Makes no sense.[/i]

for child abuse and neglect perpetrators...

by santeewelding

I assure you, Max, when it comes to [b]jck[/b] and grapefruit.

The man is far-seeing.

____

Wayward bracket.

by maxwell edison

[i]Iraqi independence has not taken place.
Iraqi military is still not stable.
Iraqi economic conditions have barely improved.
Iraqi infrastructure is still a mess.
Iraqi borders are still insecure.
[/i]

Your god, Barack Obama, promised, that if he were elected, all troops would be out of Iraq in one year.

He lied.

I predicted that it was a lie.

You're an idiot. So is Obama.

by maxwell edison

Why do you want to force me to say it?

P.S. Just drop it. Nothing will change my opinion of jck. You're only making me elaborate.

by santeewelding

Consignment of me to hell?

Face it: you're malleable.

Mark of intelligence, in some cases; indecision and rubber legs, in other cases.

by maxwell edison

..... consign you to hell.

I consign that jck isn't worth my time - something he's proven (just look at his mesages).

You confuse the two.

If you want to defend jck, then be prepared to defend - and agree with - what he says. (And spare me the right to say it crap, because I have the same right to reply in disagreement.)