A similar thing is happening to me and others that i know some discs don't boot properly. in my case and with others i know also (note: they have differnt name brade drives).
I have noticed with newer disks recently purchased or attained have problems being recognized by my 440n, my older ones that have always booted, still boot fine. So it could only really be one of the following reasons:
1. Drive Gone bad (works fine with older disks though)
2. More modern program disks made differently and drive can't always recognize them properly. (I say "not always" because some of these new ones eventually after multiple tries load up) Maybe TDK needs to give better driver updates to keep it current with current disk making techniques.
3. There is a virtually undetectable macro virus/bug out there causing this to happen since I've seen this problem spread out among different brand name drives (most have been older drives though)
through my experience with this problem and now coupled with yours and your efforts to resolve the problem eventually getting a new drive which I assume is working fine now makes me lean toward reason #2 maybe #3 but if it is 3 then the bug only affects older units I'd bet though it's 2 after all why should companies such as tdk give us proper support for our old working units when they can prosper on selling us new ones? :(