Discussion Locked

The debate is not over - Scientists meet to dispute global warming theory

0 helpful
136 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

[i]NEW YORK CITY - The A-list of manmade climate-change skeptics is meeting in New York City for the 2009 International Conference on Climate Change.

The Conference is definitely international in scope. Opening the conference is Vaclav Klaus, president of the Czech Republic and the European Union. When it comes to manmade global warming, Klaus calls that a myth. He is also an outspoken critic of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, and says the panel is one-sided and has a political agenda.

Featured at the conference will be more than 70 scientists who do not subscribe to the notion that so-called global warming is driven by manmade emissions of carbon dioxide, one of those being Harrison "Jack" Schmitt -- one of the last astronauts to walk on the moon.

The Conference is being hosted by The Heartland Institute. Dan Miller is the director of public relations at Heartland.

"What we are trying to accomplish with this conference is to present to the politicians and to the public that the debate is not over about global warming or climate change; that there is plenty of room for disagreement; and that sound science shows that the earth is not warming," says Miller.

"For much of the latter part of the 20th century there's been a mild warming as we come out of an ice age -- but the planet today is much cooler than it was a thousand years ago."

Besides the 70+ scientists at this conference, more than 650 scientists worldwide have expressed skepticism over manmade climate change.[/i]

http://www.onenewsnow.com/Culture/Default.aspx?id=439146

http://www.onenewsnow.com/Culture/Default.aspx?id=440562

136 replies

by oz_media

It has been ongoing for many decade now. 30 years ago it was global cooling, then global warming and now the more accurate 'climate change'.

From what I can see, this meeting is not to really discuss the theory of global warming, but is more focused towards the theories behind the CAUSE of global warming, or more specifically 'is it man made or not?'.

As the group seems to be mainly comprised of scientists and advocates against man made global warming, I don't see what possible positive outcome there could be other than they prove to themselves that GW was not created by man. Which is only rarely contested by GW advocates anyway.

Most GW advocates already agree that global warming is not man made, however they see mankind's emissions as contibuting to the speed of the transition.

Most GW naysayers argue that man didn't cuase GW. Which has not been contested by the advocates either.

The debate will be perpetual until the two sides realize they are not opposing or supporting the same argument.

One side says man didn't create it, but it is a subject that needs to be addressed as man's emissions are contributing to the natural effects or GW.

The other side says man did not create it because GW is a natural phenomenon.

Some will say its all crap because its snowing outside.

Some feel Nostradamus had it pegged as the indication of major change to mankind due in 2012.

You also continue to bring it up in an effort to dispell myths or solidify your own beliefs on a regular basis.

But one thing that remains constant, no matter what side is speaking, those 'for' it say that man's emissions MAY contribute to this natural phenomenon. Those against it say that man is not responsible for global warming, completely ignoring the first assertion and answering a question only they have raised.

Once they can agree on what they are debating, they MAY be able to find some answers.

I think between the press and yourself, the global warming 'debate' will continue for eternity, however long or short, hot or cold that may be.

by jdclyde

Here, we are told repeatedly that the debate is over.

Here, there are wingnuts comparing GW deniers to holocaust deniers, and have even talked about making legislation to silence the "deniers".

Because of these fringe groups taking over media and politics in the US, it is VERY important for REAL science to finally get a say.

Other nations that see it as just important to not poison the Earth without the anti-corporation, anti-business, anti-progress politics don't have as much of a need to combat the insane rhetoric.

Cap-and-trade is a scam that will steal from one and give to another based upon arbitrary standards.

by oz_media

I know it is a media frnzy down there but i would expect that most people can s ethrough it, just as they should be able to see through political BS. What is it with people that believe whatever they hear or believe it pourely based on an source they are afraid to question? That's not freedom by any stretch of the imagination, JD.

I see the same problem with this issue as with any presidential race, lack of middle, reasonable ground.

It is always extremes to one side or another and very little common, realistic ground.

Without claiming superiority, I see Canada as mainly left-centred, on such issues with the government's opinion being the least trusted/credible source for ANY information we are fed.

People will heed David Suzuki's words long before even listening to what the government thinks. the same goes in the UK, where John Cleese has more credibility and devoted listeners than Paul Martin.

You are right in that it is political in teh US, it is here too but we ignore the political part and just do our own part(sure they tax us for it, but nobody pays any attention to that crap up here anyway).

In Canada the people gurdgingly accept the government because it is noted that 'at least it isn't as bad as the US government', but rarely trust or rely on it.

The government does its thing, the people do their thing, the two are very rarely related.

So its up to us, and that's why i am always on abotu personal changes and personal responsiblity, being more resourceful etc. If that solves teh great GW swindle, so be it, if not at least we saved resources and were more environmentally friendly, for ourselves, our children and the amazing wildlife that we share the planet with.

Nobody loses regardless of the outcome, but perhaps we just MIGHT win in the long run too.

Why does it NEED to be forced upon us?
Why do they NEED proof for us to be less wasteful?
Why do we need ot be pushed into responsible actions to make our world a better place to live in?
How much money do people have to save before they realize its not so hard to do?

Personal responsiblity or lack thereof is always an issue in the USA it seems.

by half9

Look back through the last 2000 years at the changes in the world temps and you will find that there have been warm spells and cool spells.
In England around the 12-13 century it was warm, At that time they built a lot of the castles, churches, and other major constructions.
History also shows that in the 15-16 century, the River Thames froze over.That was a cool period.
I have read that most of the CO2 gas is held in the Oceans, lakes ect. When the water gets warmer ,I>E less dense, it releases this gas, and the one eyed jump on the warming bandwagon. this process does not happen overnight. It has been proved that it takes 8oo years to do a cycle, as the water cools again it locks in the CO2 again.
SO really if the global warming is caused by man it is a load of rubbish,
If the time frame is correct, there was only a few people around compared to today and they did not have the technology to produce the so-called greenhouse gases in todays amounts.
So in summery it seems to me some scientific person made a comment about this and it was picked up by the treehuggers,and then the governments thought, [We can make money out of this] and it snowballed.
The whole recycle industry is based on this and it does not matter that it takes a lot more "carbon footprint' to process this. It has the people brainwashed to think they are doing the right thing, and someone is laughing all the way to the bank.
If there was a real problem the governments would have got in behind alternative fuel systems, with the same enthusiasm that they jumped on the warming exercise. They moan about the carbon but they pussyfoot along the fuel track as they are making too much money from the taxes, and they rely on the money to keep the country afloat.
So it is a joke and nothing will change as it boils down to the $$$$

by oz_media

Well you are coming from a VERY old viewpoint and one that is only part of the problem we have been discussing.

As for recycling, it is true tha SOME items, such as plastics do create a large carbon footprint when recycled, in fact with the fleet of collection trucks, recycling costs etc. it does not become mroe cost effective either.

However, recylcing things like newpaper and colourd flyers has a great return on investment.

Penn & Teller did a Bullsh1t episode on recycling, they pretended to be form a recycling board and had a tes on one street where they had over 16 bins for different items to be separated into. MOST of the street's tennants were happy to separate theitems by bin, even rdiculous ones like half eaten vegetables in one bin and whole vegetables in another.

That's not realistic or what anyone here is looking at though.

We all know the Earth warms and cools naturally, the question is how much do our emissions effect that natural cycle.

Do we increase the speed of such effects or not?

There are some very simple facts behind reducing our own emissions though, burnign fossil fuels creates carbon MONoxide (CO) as well as Co2. CO is lethal to humans, we cannto breathe it. This is a reason you get a headache if walkign around a bust city all day, why policemen, streetworkers and city crews get sick and often suffer prolonged effects of CO poisoning, called caboxyhemoglobin. This is proven scientific FACT, not theory or scare tactics, fact. that's why CO detectors have become common place in most homes now too, especially motorhomes, cottages that have wood stoves etc.

So given that our emissions are poisonous to us, reducign our emissions, keepign your cxar tuned etc. Using less heat, using less electricty, recylcing known cost saving items etc. are not inconveniences but just reponsible living.

How does keeping your car tuned up become an incomvenience? Keeping the heat off when your not home, or wearing a sweater in the evening instead of jacking the thermostat a few more degrees an inconvenience?
how is placing newspaper in it's own bag/bin for recycling an inconvenience?

How lazy have we become in this disposable consumer society that we forget to at least be somewhat responsible for our own resources and waste?

Why is that hard to accept?

Whay is it an issue for some people?

We will be long gone before the planet is harmed, it's seen much worse than us.

by Member 25348569

Read what it is, work out what it means and then - please - stop posting crap...

:)

Your one-eyed (un)friendly neighbourhood Global Warming zealot has spoken.

by road-dog

Since the GW community seems bent on managing the world's economy and lifestyle for reasons based upon consensus rather than evidence, it is valuable to point out that such consensus does not exist.

by maxwell edison

[i]Hansen told a Kansas wind and renewable energy conference last month global warming inevitably will bring about droughts, melting ice caps, rising sea levels and mass extinctions.

Hansen has claimed those who question his conclusions "are guilty of crimes against humanity and nature."

But Roy Spencer, U.S. science team leader for NASA's collection of satellite temperature data and principal research scientist at the University of Alabama at Huntsville's Earth System Science Center, says the climate system is not as sensitive to increasing concentrations of carbon dioxide as computer models suggest.

This would mean "that we have little to worry about in the way of man-made global warming and associated climate change," Spencer said in testimony to the U.S. Senate Environment and Public Works Committee this summer. "And, as we will see, it would also mean that the warming we have experienced in the last 100 years is mostly natural. Of course, if climate change is natural then it is largely out of our control, and is likely to end - if it has not ended already, since satellite-measured global temperatures have not warmed for at least seven years now."

Spencer is author of the book, "Climate Confusion." He says mankind will one day look back at the global warming scare "as a gigantic false alarm."[/i]

http://www.worldnetdaily.com/index.php?fa=PAGE.view&pageId=77869

by the scummy one

the mass exctinctions were -- politicians, shlt for brains board members (but only the truly shlt for brains)
and anyone else who isnt 'scummy friendly' :D

by larryd4

Funny this should come up. I was watching a show on one of the Discovery channels last night and it was centered around an issue with this map.
http://www.world-mysteries.com/sar_1.htm

Basically this map that was created in 1513, is an almost perfect depiction of the physical, Antarctic coastline, minus the 1 mile thick giant sheets of ice.

So the show itself was asking how did they accurately depict the physical coastline with all that ice and snow covering it!

Only a two possibilities..

Aliens
or
There was no ice sheets then..

Global warming or just the earth and its natural process?

by oz_media

LOL, you do realize how silly that sounds. right?

The Earth's natural process of cooling and warming [i]is[/i] GLOBAL WARMING or GLOBAL COOLING, whichever stroke it is on.

MAN CAUSED global warming is not the subject GW activists argue, its just rusty old verbage used by those opposed to the whole concept who argue MAN CAUSED it (or didn't).

No matter how many activists or scientists say that its not CREATED by man but may be EXPEDITED by man, the naysayers are always blind and deaf to their conclusions, retorting with 'man didn't CAUSE global warming'.
Yeah, most everyone knows that and doesn't argue it, find a new/relevant argument.

There are not too many people allowed in civilised society that actually believe man CAUSED global warming, so let's let that old chant of the skeptical be silenced, its a non-argument that 'you people' keep trying to prove wrong for some reason.

People who are raising alarm over global warming pretty much unanimously agree that man did not CAUSE global warming but that our emissions are likely to increase the speed at which natural global warming takes effect.

Understand it now? Very few actually believe we CAUSED global warming.

Undertstanding that our atmosphere is a collection of many gases and that the planet warms and cools naturally as a result in changes to that atmosphere is not such a stretch, its more of a fact of global history(usually wiping out anything that exists except cockroaches when it does).

Even you agree with that.

So how is it so absolutely unfathomable that our own emissions into that chaging 'atmosphere' could contribute to that change?

Pee in the pool enough times and you're swimming in pee. I suppose those chemical changes could be natural too, over a much longer time frame though.

Some gases break down into relatively harmless gases at alititude, others don't break down until VERY high in the atmosphere, and others, such as CO, stay closer to the ground (heavier than and mixes with air) and pollute our streets and give us headaches and other sicknesses when out in traffic or busy city streets, again just common facts.

So what part of harmful gases being emitted into the atmosphere, potentially changing the delicate balance of gases that protect us, do you not get?

There are 5 year old children that grasp such simple concepts, but for some it seems it is easier to create a baseless argument and then use it repeatedly to dispel anyone's beliefs that we may be contributing to global warming.

A group dof scientists getting together to prove that man did not cause global warming is an incredible waste of everyone's time and money. We already know what they are trying to dispel.

And why wouldn't a similar number of scientists and NASA staff who had an oppsing opinion be taken seriously then? Scientists around teh worl dhave said that we contribute to global warming, NASA has seen the changes from outerspace and also have collected evidence that our emissions exist in oru atmosphere.

That all means nothing though when you can create an argument all by yourself and then dispel it.

I am off to prove the world is round now, so all those who keep saying its flat can get their facts straight.

by maxwell edison

I also challenge that assertion. It was neither caused nor expedited by human activity.

[i]Scientists around the world have said that we contribute to global warming...[/i]

And just as many - if not more - say we have not and/or if we have, it's insignificant and much ado about nothing.

by maxwell edison

A recent BBC sponsored poll found that 66% of the British population believe that global warming is a result of human activity.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/pressoffice/pressreleases/stories/2007/03_march/27/climate.shtml

If this is the definition: [i].....is a result of.....[/i]

What's the word? [i]Caused[/i], perhaps?

From the article:

[i]In other words, if I randomly draw 1,200 people in the UK, call them and ask whether they believe global warming is caused by human activity, I can then make an inference on what the entire population of the United Kingdom believes (sorry for the simplicity to all the statisticians out there). [/i]

by Member 25348569

The majority of modern cartographers - those, at least, who have no desire to write a von Danikan style book or get themselves on the telly - generally consider the "Antarctica" claims of the Piri Reis Map to be somewhere between "bollocks" and "absolute bollocks".

However, please don't let fact get in the way of a good Discovery Channel program! I mean, it's nearly as authoritative as Wiki!

:)

by maxwell edison

I didn't do anything to [i]prove it[/i] within my self-imposed 90 day deadline. Therefore, you either won the bet, OR I win the bet based on what you, yourself, really think?

by tony hopkinson

They live in the moon which we never landed on you know, all you have to do is draw line through the pyramids, and it points to the star they came from as encoded in the Bible.

by w2ktechman

this is evidence of their existence now.
you uncovered the secret :0
How could Scummy have let this happen :0

Well, at least you didnt uncover Atlantis yet (but Google Earth is close :0 )

Oops, we already found the Atlantians though, they settled in the State of Georgia

oh btw -- that was a good read though :D

by oz_media

"And just as many - if not more -"

How about , Sicentists also oppose that concept?

Just as many? "How do you know?" "if not more?" How do you know? That's not a counter argument itself.

For all you or I know it could be 12 million for and 1000 against, or vice versa.

Unless you have some stats, which I don't expect you to look for, the comment is simply MANY vs MANY I suppose.

Or in other words, a divided opinion.

So with something as possibly as important as this, is it not a smarter practice amongst mankind to err on the side of caution or will we just use the old, hindsight is 20/20 cliche and shrug it off if we begin to perish one day?
"Well you were right I guess, we are all going to die by Tuesday." ( I know its extreme, sorry but it reminds me of a bad relationship, where I predicted the outcome 6 years prior to it going to sh1t but was told I was nuts to think that.)

"Well I guess you were right all along."
Doesn't help 6 years later.

The point is, debate takes time and time is apparently the factor here.

You know very well that I don't run to the hills screaming 'we're all doomed' over this stuff; but I am aware enough not to be flippant about it either.

There are grey areas that I see, which you will most likely not see as you prefer to apply one rule to an entire field regardless of variances.

The government imposing carbon taxes, I hate the idea, absolutely abhor it, but that doesn't make me dispel GW as a concept itself.

Private citizens making the necessary moves to become more energy efficient, to be less wasteful of resources and to keep cars in proper running condition is one step I see benefitting us regardless of whether or not we are doomed.

Either way, becoming more resourceful is something we can all benefit from in the short and possibly long term.

While people are learning to be more resourceful and aware of their pollutions, the manufacturing sector will have to fall into suit too. Consumers drive markets, a cleaner consumer results in a cleaner marketplacet too. This means more focus towards energy efficient vehicles and less simple lip service paid at car shows, offering 'green prototypes' we'll never seen in production.

They can build better gasoline powered cars already, they do it all over the world, except here because people want land yachts and large trucks for city living.

Its only recently, now that a lot of European car shows are being aired here with 550HP 'super cars', that people are starting to accept being seen in a smaller car with smaller engine. But it is a good start in the right direction, at least a change in mindset that a younger generation is adopting.

Manufacturers can also seek better ways to power cars, which we have seen in very small part but nothing realistic enough to see broad change.

Segue>

Unfortunately, there are hundreds of back yard manufacturer's out there developing cars but withotu resources to stay in business. Its a joke in Europe now, back yard car builders have designed and built protos of some of the best vehicles on the road today, but they just get bought by BMW, Ford, Ferrari etc. If they pose any threat to the gasoline/oil industry the car never sees the light of day and the designer is long gone broke. There are literally thousands of car designers and builders in the UK alone, but they quickly disappear as the big players eat them up one by one before they get into production. Europeans can buy some great one-offs dirt cheap this way.

Back on point>

So as this is all a natural and progressive way to be more responsible with limted accessible energy. In the same sense, it keeps the GW activists happy and, should they actually be right, we have made measures to at least begin protecting our environments too.

My question to you is, what harm is there in such a practice?

by maxwell edison

That is ALL this is about - it's a desire for more tax and control in search of a crisis to justify it.

It's not about saving the planet, or any other such claim. Tax and control - that's all it's about.

by tony hopkinson

If it wasn't global warming, it would be something else.

Our real problem was outlined, over a 200 years ago, by Malthus. Larger population, same size planet = less for everyone. Solution, have the plebs use less so the elite can have more...

For an example, you need look no further than Al Gore, this is a rich f*cker who flies around the planet, telling people to save resources...

On the opposite side of the political divide 'Dick' Cheney, saying we'll provide cheap flights to Gore and make a killing.

Personally I'd have both of them do something a bit more useful, like decompose.

by oz_media

But if you look there are positive reasons for us to do better as a race, f**k the government, they are crooked losers in every country, but I am more interested on how bad I screw with the world and how we can do better than we do.

Everything these days boils down to resources, oil, war, lumber, fish, grains, power, you name it, we use and overuse it.

So by playing lip service to GW zealots and iniring GW naysayers,while just getting on with our lives and being more responsible, we can reduce the strain, cost an ferocity in obtaining such resources.

by tony hopkinson

If 66% of them didn't believe in it, you'd be making that extrapolation.

Think about this way, there's a lot of publicised data from the poles pointing to warming, believing we are a factor for change, means we can have an impact. Anything else means just sitting down and crossing 'our' fingers.....

I'm surprised the figures are that high, my impression was there a small number of definitlies, and mass of shrugs. There again I'm from the Nort East of England...

by oz_media

If I had posted that poll result to support my views, it would have been laughed off of TR as completely unreliable and unscientific BS.

by tony hopkinson

How can anyone possibly say man is having no impact on our climate, or that he is.
As far as I'm concerned any 'scientist' who turns up at a convention for or against, is merely demonstrating their belief, not their evidence or their conclusions.

How can you have a debate when only one point of view is put forward anyway?

Rational people would get more out of visiting TR and looking for your threads...

by tony hopkinson

The ones which definitley don't warm the planet, or the ones which will definitley stop it.

Why is there a change in policy, based on bad science is a good question, justifying the current policy based on bad science is far from a good answer though.

by oz_media

As I just said to Max, screw the government, they just don't matter to me or my day to day life, ignoremthem and they are simply not there and yuo can get on with your life, I don't bleed my politics.

But you hit on a key that I am focused on, resources. More people=fewer resources=higher costs= war.

So how about kicking several problems at once.

BE MORE RESOURCEFUL AND REPONSIBLE IN OUR USE OF OUR NATURAL RESOURCES.

More food, lower cost.
more gas, (or different energy source) nlower cost.
More power, lower cost.
More lumber,lower costs to build homes etc., happy tree huggers.
More fish, lower cost, safer on ocean, happier whale huggers due to reduced ocean traffic.

If we are simply more responsible as a whole, we will reduce the impacts on environment and reduce the cost of resources.

Screw the government, I'm in it for me and we all win this way.

There is absolutely no excuse and no reason to be wasteful or gluttonous, none at all.

by oz_media

first of all you are showing an interpretation, the actual question(s)asked were not given.

I am sure many people here would agree to the questions,
[i]"Are you aware of climate change?"[/i] if so,
"Do you think human activity is a significant cause?"

But those same people will also acknowledge that GW is a natural phenomenon too and that we are simply contributing to it.

The question does not differentiate, it does not say [i]"Do you think man CAUSED global warming or that man increased the natural phenomenon?"[/i]

Either way, for you to post not even the original poll or questions but an editor's rewording/summary of such is a ridiculous attempt at PROOF.

I have yet to meet a single person who thinks man CAUSED global warming, its a given that we didn't as there are widely known FACTS proving otherwise. Your interpretation is grasping at straws to prove nothing at all.

From WIKI
STATEMENT: "Human activity is a significant cause of climate change."
PERVENTAGE AGREED: 79%
Year: 2007 "

Now do you REALLY think that those 79% of people surveyed think we were the cause of climate change? It doesn't say that at all, in fact the surveys this was derived from were from several nations polls with different questions asked. The author then reworded it, saying "significant cause" however that was obviously not the initial question.

To top it all off, since when did YOU start believing polls? I thought that was your most laughable source of such statistics.

Funny how you change when it suits your agenda.

How stupid do you really think people are compared to yourself? You know exactly how that wording is ignored by most.

by maxwell edison

.....totally change the point, evade the point, and fail to admit that you made an outrageous - and false - comment when called on it.

Oz: [i] "There are not too many people allowed in civilised society that actually believe man CAUSED global warming......[/i]"

It seems that 66 percent of Brits (give or take) and 62 percent of Canadians (give or take) prove Oz's comment wrong.

(Not to mention the nonsensical wording: [i]"..... not too many people allowed"[/i]..... Huh?)

by oz_media

My post was entirely focused on the interpretation and understanding of the term itself.

And no, it is not my job to be more clear when no matter how it is worded you read with a blind eye and only see what you want to see.

by jdclyde

How much is "significant"?

We hear the reports of wanting to cut X% of emissions by a certain year.

Why that number?
How was it determined?
How will that cut be achieved?
What will the cost of the attempted cuts be, regardless of if they are hit or not?
What will be the effects IF the cut is achieved?

All valid questions that MUST be asked, but never are, if they are based upon science instead of politics.

by oz_media

Liek David Suzuki, a brilliant and fascinating scientist that has made his name in Canada for decades now, now handing off the torch to his daughter as he just turned 70.

He has the 1-tonne challenge on his website. Simple things everyone can do at home and in their day to day lives that will hopefully se ethem reducing wasted resources and reducing personal emissions by 1-tonne per year.

I've done it, thousands have done it.

But why 1-tonne?

It is a benchmark, not a specific target.

If we all reduced our emissions by 1 tonne each year (it really is effortless to reduce your overall emissions and does not impose in any way), that would equate to over 330 MILLION tonnes of saved emissions. 33) MILLION of anything has to have positive impact.

the point is that the government does very little and can't be expected to do much more on their own accord, it just won't happen.

But if PEOPLE are more responsible personally, that's 330 million tonnes a year in saved emisisons, not to mention tha reduction in resource waste, that number is very significant indeed.

I find Americans, yes I am being specific, don't care about anything except their own personal liberties.

So much so that they will not openly accept a challenge to be personally responsible. "If it aint forced upon me by the government it aint gonna happen" seems to be the general concensus.

However, if the government tries to move in tha direction, all of a sudden the alarm bells ring and Americans start whining about personal liberties and freedoms being taken away and that they should be allowed to be personally responsible, not realizing that they chose NOT to do so in the past and that's why it is now being forced on them.

Americans are either the most hypocritical society on the planet or they ar simply too blind to see that they apply double standards to everything in order to have it suit their own desires.
Sorry, but that's really how it seems to others, pure ignorance.

So perhaps if you are not willing to be responsible, just like any oter irresponsible child, people need to be mandated, forced and pushed into compliance. It's not amatter of teh governmen tsaying everyone must wear blue hats on Thrusdays, or you must be Christian or you must be of a certain ethnicity, this is a global effort to reduce emissions, which benefits us all regardless of GW.

I just don't see how so many popele can be so pig headed and ignorant that they sit on their hands and hum so as to ignore reality. In fact it is those ignorant losers who I wish we could just thin out of society and cull the herd a bit, no more ignorant, idiots allowed.

by oz_media

I find it interesting that Canadians #1 concern is the environment. We get more of it to see and enjoy, therefore we care more about it.

[i]20 per cent of respondents said the environment, followed by 14 per cent who said health care, 13 per cent who said the economy and 10 per cent who said they were concerned about social issues or poverty. Only seven per cent said they were concerned about governance issues, followed by five per cent who said they were concerned about the war in Afghanistan and four per cent who said they were concerned about jobs and unemployment.[/i]

And the least important were government, war and employment.

I think that says a whole lot about quality of life and the sense of freedoms in Canada.

It seems more Canadians are concerned about living, than being politically focused. Well, plus we have a better employment rate, resulting in more recreation, resulting in more people happy with their country and completely ignoring the government.

I'd take that over bleeding politics, that's not freedom it is mind numbing, time consuming, worrying, infatuation.

With such a national mindset, how can so many Americans say Canadians are jealous of Americaa? Our wants and benefits are completely different. Canadians wouldn't make good political fodder in the US, CNN would be out of business pretty quick. .

This also explains my own views very well, "let's be more resourceful and save our own lands. If that results in reduced GW and happy politicians, so be it."

It's as if people opposed to GW are making a case to excusing their gluttonny and a reason to continue as is, without any responsibility.

Good find, I wish I had dug that one up myself long ago.

by road-dog

Inertia is justified in this instance. "Bad" science does not provide a clear justification to leave the current state.

I commute using the same route to work every day using a route that is optimal for me. I divert only due to construction or traffic problems. I will not take a different route unless a source I trust as being knowledgable on the traffic indicates otherwise.

I don't feel the need to "justify" my current route to work at all. If somebody wants me to take a different route to work, they need to articulate their case.

The current policy requires no justification. To begin with the assumption that it requires justification seriously misplaces the burden of proof.

by tony hopkinson

just don't tell me you chose the route based on the sky being safely held up by your mate Atlas....

Bad science is bad science, whether you are using it to justify change or staying the same.

You want to attack the Global warmers for drawing invalid conclusions based on their evidence, that's fine.

Drawing invalid but contradictory conclusions off your own evidence, isn't science it's belief and politics.

My prediction is that they are all going to be wrong.

by road-dog

I'm not attacking anyone. I am going about my business and people are saying that I (me and the rest of the industrialized world) need to alter lifestyle because of some looming disaster.

When the Jehovah's Witnesses come to my door telling me about their faith, I am not attacking them when I tell them that I don't believe their theology. They endeavor to convince me from my current position, thus the onus is upon them to provide compelling arguments for their position.

The people who believe that MMGW is a big steaming pile of feces aren't telling the world that they MUST get a bigger carbon footprint. We aren't telling anyone to do anything. Thus the onus isn't upon us to justify anything.

The burden of proof falls upon those asking concessions of others.

by oz_media

I've reread it several times ot try and find what you are picking at but it seems plain and simple to me. You commented and I spoke specifically of your comment.

To reiterate it, you feel that someone responding positively to the open question is an indicator that people actually think MAN CAUSED global warming. WHich is pure crap, science and common fact shows otherwise and MOST people know it.

The question was focused on whether people think man is responsible for global warming, in which case most people will say yes, knowing very well that we didn't cause it but that our own emissions are adetrimental to the natural process.

I haven't met too many people stupid enough to think otherwise, I'm sure there are a few but the skewed POLL which you posted certainly isn't an example.

And to see you hang onto a 'kin POLL as if it was your last hope for breath is ridiculous.

The results ar einterpreted as poorly as the question was, plain and simple.

If you were to ask TWO questions, people's opinions woul dbe vastly different.

1) Do you think man actually CAUSED global warming to begin with?

2) Do you feel it is a natural phenomenon that we are adding to?

I promise you the results would be vastly different if the questions were posed properly. But if you want to hang on to such crap as if it has any relevance or meaning, go ahead, I'll just earmark that for the next time you shoot down polls as a farce.

by tony hopkinson

,but Max's pet boffins.

Though I could chnage my mind after that lot.

Yes they are telling the world to get a bigger carbon footprint, how else are they continue to make a tidy profit, better still an even tidier one.

I've made it quite clear I don't believe either group, unlike them I'm not dependant on a vested interest's financial backing...

What would constitute proof either way, I mean we've got people walking about who still think the earth is flat, worse still we've got a pile of people in power because of that sort of belief.

Even if sea level went up by a metre, you could still argue that it wasn't human caused. We aren't capable of proving it.

If sea level does go up by a metre, then we get into the something has to be done phase. At that point, if the GWers are right we are f'ked.

Why is being green a concession?
What if you could work from home, find local employment, get a relocation grant, have reliable fast efficient 'public' transport.

What if the concession is reducing your energy bills, generating further employment, eating locally grown fresh produce in season?

Being paid for recyclable waste.

Being able to buy things that don't conk out two days after the warranty expires.

Making those who pollute pay for clean up.

I'm seeing plusses here not minusses....

by maxwell edison

Regardless of the issue, all things should be considered, and no one factor should trump all else.

The MMGW/CC believers are advancing their radical political agenda as though their environmental card trumps all others. Well it doesn't.

What might be the major factors? Here's my top three: the environment, cost and affect on the economy - both personal and business, and infringement on personal freedom and liberty.

In my opinion, the last one is - or should be - the strongest trump card of them all. Especially considering the environmental argument is based on very questionable and non-provable [i]what if[/i] predictions - and ones that aren't even predicted to happen until after we're all dead and gone (or pretty close). Moreover, the drastic [i]dooms-day[/i] predictions are even questioned among the environmental ranks, and should simply be dismissed as nonsense.

The MMGW/CC believers are making the claims, all I ask is that they come up with a win-win-win solution - all three of the aforementioned factors being the winners, and none being the loser. And it's their charge to do it, not mine.

However, all things considered, even if human activity does have an effect on the Earth's temperature and/or climate patterns, it's slight, at best, and adaptation is a better choice than prevention.

Mankind's short-term inclination might be for safety to trump liberty, but in the long-term, mankind's yearning to live free will always trump everything else.

What legacy would I prefer to leave? A better environment with less (or no) liberty and freedom? Or greater liberty and freedom, but with an environmental challenge facing them? If those are the two options from which to choose, and considering all things, if it were me, I'd choose the latter.

Mankind has always adapted to a changing environment, and we (they) always will. And it can be done best by those who live free.

by maxwell edison

.....to almost everyone else reading these threads - at least in my opinion. Of course, I can't read their minds, but if I were to guess.......

by road-dog

All but one thing you ask for is a concession:

"What if you could work from home, find local employment, get a relocation grant, have reliable fast efficient 'public' transport."
Paid for by whom?
------------------------------------
"What if the concession is reducing your energy bills, generating further employment, eating locally grown fresh produce in season?"
Are you going to tell businesses how/where to do business or do you propose that government (paid for by taxpayers like me) to do it in typical wasteful and incompetent government fashion?
--------------------------------------------
"Being paid for recyclable waste."
By whom? Recycling is a net loss right now
-----------------------------------------
"Being able to buy things that don't conk out two days after the warranty expires."

Non-sequitur but already managed by the free market. Hyundais used to suck, now they have 100,000 mike warranties. The free market at work.
------------------------------
"Making those who pollute pay for clean up."

About the only suggestion you make that is not a concession is pollution cleanup. Once again, this is already dealt with.

Where you see plusses, I see the erosion of private property and individual rights.

The radical environmental movement isn't about environmentalism at all. It's green on the outside, red on the inside. It's about getting fools to give up sovereignity to solve an invented problem.....

by tony hopkinson

They are indeed putting forth their political agenda, both sides are.

As are we, though to a lesser extent.

To be quite honest I see the GW debate as a polarisation, and that only benefits both extremes. I fail to see why your quest for personal happiness, and mine for communal are so diametrically opposed. I see all too well why the extremes wish us to see it so....

What we have to remember, given we both have a profound distrust of government, and the desire to govern more and more, is that to both the 'left' and 'right' of the professional political class, we are the loony other. They'd put us both in the same box, and nail the lid down if they considered us a real threat to the pork barrel politics they really believe in.

by tony hopkinson

Who will pay for it?.

Us, obviously, The people who are paying for it now.

Who pays for health care costs from pollution and stress.
Us

Who pays for overseas food and overseas aid?
Us

Who pays to sell arms to people to shoot at us?
Us

Who is paying for the sub prime fiasco?
Us

Who pays for commuting?
Us

Who pays for advertising?
Us

Who pays for currency speculation
Us

Who pays for shorting?
Us

Who pays for the government
Us

If you are going to come up with balance sheet, put all the items on there. As we should know all too well, leaving things off it isn't a solution.

by delbertpgh

It's a conservative think tank. When a political organization hosts a purportedly scientific convention to put forward controversial views, its scientific impartiality is necessarily suspect.

The Heartland Institute campaigns about global warming science, against tobacco taxes and regulation, and voices a number of other conservative tropes. It used to take contributions from energy companies, but says it no longer does. It has refused to publish its donors for the last few years.

by maxwell edison

.....the Democratic Party.

However, the scientists who appeared at that forum were, after all, scientists, were they not?

Typical ploy. If one can't debate the issue or message, one attacks and discredits the person (or institution).

Besides, as I've said all too many times, the whole issue has been hijacked by any number of political causes, including the Democratic Party and just about any other [i]environmental group[/i] you can name - environmental groups that are really a political agenda disguised as an environmental concern.

If you're suggesting that we keep ALL debate, agendas, conclusions, solutions, etc. about MMGW/CC out of politics, I'm with you 100 percent. Let's EVERYBODY keep it out of politics. (Or are you suggesting a double standard?)

by jdclyde

is rule one in politics these days, and global cooling/warming/shirts is just another political agenda.

Try to discredit the scientists rather than disprove their work.

They MUST be evil, they got money from companies! Right?

by oz_media

Most people, especially in phone or door to door interviews don't read into baited questions such as that, and yes it is a baited question as it leads one to a conclusion that is buried in the question with only one word being relevant to your cause and the rest of the question being irrelevant.

If you wwant to really find out whether people understand the difference between 'man caused' and 'man has increased' the effects, you need to ask those two very specific questions.

And as for you claiming I have not answered the question, which I have three times now and you still can't grasp the concept of a baited, closed ended question (so common in polls, in fact the exact reason why most polls are deemed garbage) you still haven't addressed the fact that you have instantly dismissed pretty much any poll posted by anyone on TR as evidence of fact.

You throw them out and ignore them as the trash they are, but when when has a really veiled, baited question that results in supporting your own argument, all of a sudden it's gospel.

Get real, Max, I am not that stupid and yu assume, rely on the hopes that other readers are too.

Perhaps you can find many others who are dumb enough to buy into it with you too, but I am not one of them. it's completele garbage and you know it very well, you would NEVER accept someone posting such crap as fact, but you'll buy it when it favours you.

And you wonder why I call you a hypocrite?

You stand on one side and scream blue murder, until it is in your favour then you cross the tracks and scream in the other direction to suit your current agenda.

Not very clever and I think ANYONE here can see that too.

by oz_media

I have noticed some real inconsistencies in people's views. People seem to simply hang on to what supports their own personal beliefs/conclusions and show no consistency of opinion.

There are concerns about quetsionable science, bad science, junk science, theory based on loose facts etc.

But this is completely inconsistent with the mindset many readers here normally share towards issues. I find most people here will base their conclusions on loose opinions, not facts at all, and they will stand by heresay and conclusion as if it is fact. When challenging a view point they support, all of a sudden loose opinions, heresay and conclusions are the law and answer all the world's known problems.

When America got false information on oil rich, Iraqi intentions to develop nucear arms, it was well known BEFORE the scary report that they had not sought out "yellow cake".
However that was not broadcast, instead it was confirmed that they HAD tried to buy yellow cake and were working on nuclear arms development, which could be used to attack allied nations, more specifically the USA. Now, most countries denied such claims and said that the information was unreliable, obtained through questionable means, from an informer with ulterior motives.

But for the sake of erring on the side of caution, trillions have been spent and thousands of Americans have lost their lives for a senseless and unjust cause, bordering on illegal invasion of another nation by allies.

When it comes to war, you believe anything regardless of fact or questionable intentions.

When it coems to energy conservation, which means you may have to walk a few extra blocks, drive a smaller car, turn the heat down and shut the lights off or make any personal sacrifice, science is questioned until absolutely 100% confirmed, as it would impose on people's freedoms and liberties to have any government control over something that just may not be.

If only you could stand back and have a hear yourselves once in a while, you'd probably laugh as hard as most others do when listening to you.

by tonythetiger

[i]If we all reduced our emissions by 1 tonne each year (it really is effortless to reduce your overall emissions and does not impose in any way)[/i]

Many people are already being as efficient as they can. So when the government comes along and says "you must reduce emissions by xx% or be penalized", the people who already reduced or never wasted in the first place can't cut any further and get stuck with the lion's share of the penalties.

It's the same old story... punish those who are being responsible...

[i]I wish we could just thin out of society and cull the herd a bit, no more ignorant, idiots allowed. [/i]

We don't have to thin them out... we can just remove the protections that keep them from thinning themselves out.

by oz_media

"punish those who are being responsible..."

That's only because so many choose not to be responsible and NEED the government to force them into action.

If everyone did their share, no need for action.

I'm not suggesting all Canadians are good at conserving energy or reducing personal emissions, but most are aware that they should and slowly follow suit as they are surrounded by more and more people who do.

They imposed a carbon tax here, but nobody pays attention to it or revolts against government actions by purposely ignoring personal responsibility, as if to spite them.
Like cutting off your nose to spite your face.

We just ignore the government and continue doing our own thing anyway. I KNOW, being forced to by paying taxes AND taking personal responsiblity, whatever next?

Why not just waste as much as possible because the government is FORCING us to pay for wasted emissions?
Because the government doesn't matter to anyone, they are crooked and corrupt and we can't rely on them for anything anyway, so nobody cares.

That doesn't mean we can't work as a nation of people to make it better for ourselves.

That's interesting actually, now that I see it, while Americans claim their independence is due to them being a nation of people, not of government (and seeing Canada as completely under the government thumb) it's actually the absolute opposite.

Americans live breathe and bleed politics, politics is all consuming and always in the forefront of people's minds and actions.

In Canada political discussion clears a room, seriously, we tested and laughed at that one during a recent Secrutiy Assn meeting. We were all to sit an unmarked tables, just finding people we wanted to hang with and meet/network with for a few hours over a nice dinner.

We had three people at our table set for 8, as people walked up to ask if they could share a table, my customer and I started talking openly about Obama, Free Tade etc. whatever political BS we could be 'obviously' discussing. People would walk up, hear a couple of political namess or terms and quickly b-line for another table.

The three of us ate alone while talking about camping instead.

It was just screwing around but it did prove a point, nobody gives a toss about Canadian politics enough to talk about it over dinner.
We certainly don't bleed politics here.

To conclude, sorry for length, it is an indicator that we are REALLY the ones who are free of government, live our lives for the benefit of ourselves and our neigbours and enjoy our own freedoms from government more than our southern neighbours who constantly have to remind themselves and all others around them that they are living in freedom.

Perhaps we'll send the Canadian tank and boat down there one day to topple your dictatorship of a government and instill freedom and democracy once again.

But then again that would take our political involvement, don't mind if we do that after camping do you? ;)

by larryd4

"George Carlin's "The Planet Is Fine"

We're so self-important. So self-important. Everybody's going to save something now. "Save the trees, save the bees, save the whales, save those snails." And the greatest arrogance of all: save the planet. What? Are these fucking people kidding me? Save the planet, we don't even know how to take care of ourselves yet. We haven't learned how to care for one another, we're gonna save the fucking planet?

I'm getting tired of that shit. Tired of that shit. I'm tired of fucking Earth Day, I'm tired of these self-righteous environmentalists, these white, bourgeois liberals who think the only thing wrong with this country is there aren't enough bicycle paths. People trying to make the world safe for their Volvos. Besides, environmentalists don't give a shit about the planet. They don't care about the planet. Not in the abstract they don't. Not in the abstract they don't. You know what they're interested in? A clean place to live. Their own habitat. They're worried that some day in the future, they might be personally inconvenienced. Narrow, unenlightened self-interest doesn't impress me.

Besides, there is nothing wrong with the planet. Nothing wrong with the planet. The planet is fine. The PEOPLE are fucked. Difference. Difference. The planet is fine. Compared to the people, the planet is doing great. Been here four and a half billion years. Did you ever think about the arithmetic? The planet has been here four and a half billion years. We've been here, what, a hundred thousand? Maybe two hundred thousand? And we've only been engaged in heavy industry for a little over two hundred years. Two hundred years versus four and a half billion. And we have the CONCEIT to think that somehow we're a threat? That somehow we're gonna put in jeopardy this beautiful little blue-green ball that's just a-floatin' around the sun?

The planet has been through a lot worse than us. Been through all kinds of things worse than us. Been through earthquakes, volcanoes, plate tectonics, continental drift, solar flares, sun spots, magnetic storms, the magnetic reversal of the poles...hundreds of thousands of years of bombardment by comets and asteroids and meteors, worlwide floods, tidal waves, worldwide fires, erosion, cosmic rays, recurring ice ages...And we think some plastic bags, and some aluminum cans are going to make a difference? The planet...the planet...the planet isn't going anywhere. WE ARE!

We're going away. Pack your shit, folks. We're going away. And we won't leave much of a trace, either. Thank God for that. Maybe a little styrofoam. Maybe. A little styrofoam. The planet'll be here and we'll be long gone. Just another failed mutation. Just another closed-end biological mistake. An evolutionary cul-de-sac. The planet'll shake us off like a bad case of fleas. A surface nuisance.

You wanna know how the planet's doing? Ask those people at Pompeii, who are frozen into position from volcanic ash, how the planet's doing. You wanna know if the planet's all right, ask those people in Mexico City or Armenia or a hundred other places buried under thousands of tons of earthquake rubble, if they feel like a threat to the planet this week. Or how about those people in Kilowaia, Hawaii, who built their homes right next to an active volcano, and then wonder why they have lava in the living room.

The planet will be here for a long, long, LONG time after we're gone, and it will heal itself, it will cleanse itself, 'cause that's what it does. It's a self-correcting system. The air and the water will recover, the earth will be renewed, and if it's true that plastic is not degradable, well, the planet will simply incorporate plastic into a new pardigm: the earth plus plastic. The earth doesn't share our prejudice towards plastic. Plastic came out of the earth. The earth probably sees plastic as just another one of its children. Could be the only reason the earth allowed us to be spawned from it in the first place. It wanted plastic for itself. Didn't know how to make it. Needed us. Could be the answer to our age-old egocentric philosophical question, "Why are we here?" Plastic...asshole.

So, the plastic is here, our job is done, we can be phased out now. And I think that's begun. Don't you think that's already started? I think, to be fair, the planet sees us as a mild threat. Something to be dealt with. And the planet can defend itself in an organized, collective way, the way a beehive or an ant colony can. A collective defense mechanism. The planet will think of something. What would you do if you were the planet? How would you defend yourself against this troublesome, pesky species? Let's see... Viruses. Viruses might be good. They seem vulnerable to viruses. And, uh...viruses are tricky, always mutating and forming new strains whenever a vaccine is developed. Perhaps, this first virus could be one that compromises the immune system of these creatures. Perhaps a human immunodeficiency virus, making them vulnerable to all sorts of other diseases and infections that might come along. And maybe it could be spread sexually, making them a little reluctant to engage in the act of reproduction.

Well, that's a poetic note. And it's a start. And I can dream, can't I? See I don't worry about the little things: bees, trees, whales, snails. I think we're part of a greater wisdom than we will ever understand. A higher order. Call it what you want. Know what I call it? The Big Electron. The Big Electron...whoooa. Whoooa. Whoooa. It doesn't punish, it doesn't reward, it doesn't judge at all. It just is. And so are we. For a little while."
--------------------------------

I just had to post this...

"Be excellent to each other!" Rufus

by oz_media

LOVED Carlin, I have pretty much all his material on DVD now, just way too real for most people.

However, just as I like "Penn & Teller's Bullsh1t" too, a great series, they are often focused solely on what they can say to stir teh masses. Varlin was a shock comedian, I loved his material but it is designed to create shock value, controversy and rumour, that's what sell good comedy.

IN Carlin's veiw, and i must agree, there's no way we can destroy the planet, but tha's not what being environmentally concious is all about.

It's about whether or not WE can continue to exist as the planet changes; not that we are going to throw the ball of axis and cause it to perish.

But thanks all the same, that was nice to read through and remember again.

Though I preferred him as the train conductor in the kid's TV Series Thomas the Tank Engine, as opposed to Rufus.

by larryd4

I'm sorta like Carlin in the thought process of the planet will be fine.

Personally, I do recycle, beleave in saving forest space and know we need alternatives, but on the other hand, I'm also not going to start driving hybrid cars and try to force people to stop doing what they want to do. But when they do have an affordable electric car with the same features and abilities of current cars, I'm all their!

As time goes on things will change, they always do. And their will be new better ways to save energy.

We are our own conscious and their will be abusers, saviors, and nay sayers but it all comes down to what each new generation does.

by tonythetiger

I've thought it myself. Every time a hurricane or a flood or a wildfire takes out someone's house... "A message has been sent... [b]The earth doesn't give a $hit what your deed says, it doesn't WANT you there![/b]" and then the idiots rebuild in the exact same spot, then cry and moan when it happens again...

This is the kind of stupidity we need to stop subsidizing. Maybe they'll come up with a test to detect these kinds of people in childhood, so they can be neutered before they breed.

by jdclyde

As it seems we have a huge voting block that thinks that by getting BO elected, they have hit the gravy train.

Personal responsibility? everyone knows it is the fault of "the rich".

And this is like the proabortion/antiabortion camps. They DO know how the "give an inch" rule works against them, thanks to "Precedence" being the law of the land instead of actual constitutional law.

There is not a common sense approach being offered. It is a wild-eyed "New York will be under 100 feet of water and we will all drown!" bs being fed to our kids.

A firm STFU is the only reply you can give unreasonable people that have had their little minds made up for them a long time ago in favor of the myth of man-made global warming.

Someone offers a solution to cutting emissions, I am all ears. Someone just says something stupid like "SUV's are bad" or "don't drive".... well.....

by oz_media

"New York will be under 100 feet of water and we will all drown!"

I read that on another forum last night, I couldnt' believe what i wa sreading, "What a clueless idiot!' is all I could think, I didn't even bother replying as it was just insane.

I can't believe there are people on Earth that actually believe such crap. I've heard some real left wing rants from BC, believe me its always about forests and fish around here, but I have yet to hear something as completely screwed up as that. HOW? Where are these people from? What lack of education leads to believing such contrived bull anyway?

I'm not saying Canadians are smarter than you, we only have 10% of your population so the real nutjobs are fewer or more easily dismissed as one offs.

SUV's are bad, don't drive. Well I drive an SUV too, i also tow a trailer and drag my dirt bikes into teh hills to bomb around and burn up teh gas in teh woods for aweekend. that is quality of life though, which I am not abotu to be forced into sacrificing either. However the little things, recycling, better windows, lights, heat etc. can all help reduce our carbon footprint a great deal. I don't agree with our governmentimplementing a carbon tax, that's BS, but its also the government and nobody cares what they do here anyway. We still just soldier on and do our own thing as if they don't exist. It's not sticking your head in the sand, people are aware but simply not concerned enough to let it ruin their quality of life either.

Cheers, JD.
That's my point, if we just watch ourselves we are on teh right path.

by jdclyde

with ground water contamination.

And yes, many of the extremists in the US would gleefully make it ILLEGAL or put a punitive tax out there to punish people like you that burn gas in the woods for entertainment.

underwater, I take it you never watched Mr. Gores slide show? Although he said 20 feet, I have heard the 100 feet more than once.

Need some chlorine in the gene pool.

by oz_media

Exactly my view too. People here find me very abrasive, but it's usually because I call a spade a spade and don't mince words and opinions, much as Carlin or anyone else who learns to speak their mind will offer.

My typing skills are hideous, I am the last person to correct typing mistakes or point them out to others, but I figured I'd nitpick a tiny bit on yoru post.

When using THEIR it only really applies when you are speaking of someone's posessions. Their house, their way of thinking, etc. Their is a pronoun, they or their.

When speakign of a place, there is the correct word. I'll be there on time.

"I'm all there"

"And there will be new, better ways to save energy etc."
Again, sorry to nitpick, my typing is horrific, I can spell but not type.

But I do agre ewith you, I don't drive a hybrid either, there's no cost effective way to do so yet. It takes a lot of saved gas and emissions, over a standard automobile, to save $15K over 5 years.

But I do recycle, pretty much everyone does these days here, I am very concious of recycling fliuds when I am workign on cars etc. I keep the heat down and teh lights off when not used, I don't burn the dichwasher each night (once a week suits me), laundry is always a full load and I air dry what I can etc.

Now if EVERYONE does these simple things, instead of whining about political posturing from either side, we are at least being more responsible of what we spew into our atmosphere and even reduce the level of ground level pollutants (such as CO) that make us sick and can even kill us.

That's all I've been sayign all along, we don't have to change the way we live, we just have to THINK abotu it and be mroe responsible. From just these most basic 'adjustments' in our lives, it is estimated that each person can reduce greenhouse emissions by up to one tonne a year.

That means 33 million tonnes saved in Canada alone, add the US to that and you have another 330 million, to make over 350 MILLION TONNES of air pollution reduced each and every year, THAT'S a whole lot. Can you imagine that worldwdie? BILLIONS of tonnes each year, and that's just what we are reducing it by, ,kinda gives you a picture of how much we actually still emit if we can reduce it by that much with so little effort.

Been a good chat, thanks for that.

by larryd4

My grammer on TR is horrible and though some may look at it and frown, I tend to look at it like this.

I love TR, its a great resource and a great place to discuss topics and solve problems. But 90% of the time I am posting off the cuff and though I wish I could have the time to proof my work its just not possible. I am in one of those jobs currently where, not to sound pompous, but I am the last line of support and I cover a wide range of systems. So my day is hectic, to say the least, and all the proof reading I do goes to office work rather then posts.

But I'm gonna try! Maybe I can request a secretary to proof all my TR posts! :)

Fun topic none the less.

by oz_media

I wasn't going to say anything, I started typing and deleted it, and typed it again and left it. It doesn't matter AT ALL to me personally, not one tiny iota, I couldn't care less if you spelled 'their' with Z.

Between peers we often prompt each otehr to littl ethings like that, sometimes it is unknown or just the way someone has spelled it for years and never been corrected. It was purely an FYI and perhaps something you were unaware of and perhaps I could help sort it out for you.

I agree with the need for a proof reader.

I can go through a post four times and find new typos each time, I just can't type worth a crap. I play keyboards too and my techer woul dcringe at my unorthodox fingering skills (on the keyboard). But unlike typing, I always managed to hit the right keys.
The funniest part is that I get paid to write a lot of copy.

I put together marketing campaigns and ads, write press kits for bands, write IPO's for mining and exploration firms etc. But I do have three editors that go over my work and proof it for print first.

Unfortunately I haven't the resources to have them proof my posts either and most of the time, couldn't care less or simply do not respect the person I am debating with enough to correct it myself (no offense if I leave typos in here now).

Anyway, it was a gesture of good will, not a lesson, hope you don't take it the wrong way.

have a good one,
OM

by tonythetiger

[i]hat's only because so many choose not to be responsible and NEED the government to force them into action.

If everyone did their share, no need for action.
[/i]

Little Johnny got caught chewing gum in class so EVERYONE has to stay in during recess...

Keep on kicking a good dog, and eventually he'll turn around and bite you...

by oz_media

Encourage mreo people to chew gun in class, encourage people to act responsibly, it doesn' trequrie a government to force action, if people took personal responsibility fo rtheir actions, yhere would be no need.

If you want to stand alone and be different, do it in someone else's face.

In the exact same sense that non-smokers complain that laws need to be lassed to protect their freedoms from these horrific smokers, they are in turn stepping one someone else's freedom to smoke. Which is where our rights are limited. We have rights as long as they don't step on someone else's rights.

However I don't see that applying to being personally responsible for our carbon footprints.

In this case you don't have a right to waste the planet's resources or harm wildlife, or place others in danger. however I do have a right to encourage people to act more personally responsibly. I don't have a right to force it upon them, but there's no harm in encouraging resourcefulness.

I accept people tellign me how smoking will kill me, it gets a bit old but watever, nobody is forcing it on me. I even accept that smoking in small, public spaces such as restaurants is wrong. It's not like everyone finishes eating at teh same time and teh smokers light up, in a restaurant people are smoking WHILE others are eating, I respect people more than to subject them to my habits. but it doesn't need to be, or SHOULDN'T need ot be law, however enough people have no courtesy to others so a law is passed.

On the flipside, this has now been taken too far (give an inch...). In Seattle they are looking at banning smoking in public apartment! Non smokers are complainign that they have a right to clean air.
I say great, move into a non smoking building, they descriminate over me living there but that's okay, you can live there, just don't discriminate against me living in a smoking building.

It's like smoking in bars, waitresses started to complain that it is an unhealthy workplace. Well its a strip bar, my dear, did you not think of smoking and sexual advances from drunk men when you applied?
In that scenario they have a choice, though tehy swear they are subjected to it without choice as if they were sentenced to work there.

As for recycling and being responsible with use of our resources, it is a different scnario. Nobody is actually put out by reducing their resource waste. In fact people will SAVE money by reducing waste, so it actually benefits all participants.

Should it be forced upon people? no.
But until teh message is straight and clear, peopl ewill refuse to follow along based on false pretenses, such as we are not going ot kill teh planet, or New York will no be under 10' of water in 12 years, or we aren't going to fry to a crisp.

People need to learn and be taught form an early age to take on personal responsiblity, from there the government is leaned on less often to solve such matters, activists will be appeased as everyone just does what they can/should to live a cleaner life etc.

When the message is vague or contested, peple don't act. Our politicians and this big GW debate is the catalyst for a never ending debate and no sign of action taken on by people.

When the message is clear, simple, concise and unimposing, people follow suit.

by delbertpgh

Scientific congresses of the best repute are usually sponsored by a scholarly organization, or in some cases by a governmental body.

This one is a little as if the Baptists had held a council to discuss evolution, or the National Abortion Rights Action League had convened its own College of Cardinals to review the opionions of the Pope. It carries a whiff of prejudice, if you've got the nose for it.

by jdclyde

Although only one was funded by Soros, both are out there.

So, if we look at the source, based upon your post, we don't NEED to worry about refuting what is said, we just ignore it.

So, until you hear it on NPR, it matter who it is giving the scientists a voice in the world that "scholarly organizations" and much of the "government bodies" ignore?

Again, proving that it is not the science driving the myth of man-made global warming, or someone would have the integrity to look at the evidence and prove it wrong.

by delbertpgh

Media Matters and the ACLU are not scholarly organizations, nor are they governmental. It doesn't matter if they have scholars on staff (the ACLU has got some hot law professors working for it); that doesn't make them scholarly. Governmental organizations seated in the east wing of the White house don't count, either. Bodies like the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, or the National Institutes of Health, can count as worthy and impartial hosts of a scientific conference.

When scientists are called in to help a political organization make a point, or to help a company make money, it's not a scientific conference. It doesn't mean it's completely unworthy of attention, but it's a partisan forum.

Non-partisanship, or impartiality, in science doesn't mean that everybody with a logical idea should get equal time at a microphone. The state of the art leads the profession to regard some positions as more proven and worthy of study than others. What's out of favor gets neglected. How else can you pursue can you pursue the advance of knowledge, other than to behave thus? Scientist X, finding himself out of favor, has to either get in the boat with the rest of the profession, or stick it out in his lab, generating new research and publicizing it, until he establishes a new mainstream of thought. Unfortunately, the lonely seeker of elusive truth will find himself fighting for attention with all the crackpots who got jobs at universities, but are likewise rejected by their colleagues.

by oz_media

I did see Gores kaibosh of a GW scare presentation. It's people like that who cause these issues to be never ending debates to begin with. If the message was clear, simple and concise, people wouldn't argue the point.

Its easy to say "FU, I don't believe New York will be underwater so therefore the whole GW and personal responsiblity thing is all crap."

If it was focused on reality, small changes and not government imposed ones, just small efforts that see us all on the same page, we are ahead of the game already.

For instance, I don't think there are too mahy peers here opposed to recycling, within reason. I don't think there are too many peers here who would disagree that driving to the corner store is a waste, and while it is convenient when we are lazy, it's not a huge imposition to take on, again as a personal responsiblity.

That's why I comment about David Suzuki so much, he's REAL, and not just full of scare tactics and trying to impose regulations on us, just asking for everyone to do a little that adds up to a lot.

by larryd4

I noticed it all the time especially after the fact. :)

I wish I had the time, but as mandatory furloughs start and lay offs loom. I should be thankful I have this much work. Hopefully it will keep me off the chopping block.

by oz_media

[b]If asked to take a political poll do you lie?[/b]
"I've been asked to take no fewer than a half-dozen political polls over the past two weeks. Without exception, I've lied on all questions. [b][i]I hate polls.[/b][/i] I especially hate polls that are made up to make news. [i][b]I do everything I can do discredit them.[/i][/b]" -Maxwell Edison
11/02.08
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=277757

[b]Down with Polls[/b]
"Cheers to you." - Maxwell Edison 11/02/08
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=277757&messageID=2630079

[b]Why do I hate polls?[/b]
Because all too often, [b][i]polls ask leading questions, and are really intended to sway opinion[/b][/i], not report on public opinion; or polls are made-up to MAKE news, instead of being reported AS news (ABC News poll, conducted by ABC, and reported by ABC to fill time on their news shows); or polls are used to influence voter turnout, giving a false impression of true voter support; etc. - Maxwell Edison 11/03/08
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=277757&messageID=2630580

[b]Another reason I hate polls[/b]
It's simply a waste of time to conduct them; it's a waste of time to participate in them; and [b][i]it's a waste of time to listen to them.[/i][/b] - Maxwell Edison 11/03/08
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=277757&messageID=2630620

[b]You've commented several times on. . . . . [/b]
....scientific and unbiased polls, and that seems to be your focus. My focus, on the other hand, is all the rest of them. [b][i]Are you suggesting there are no junk polls? From my perspective, that defines the majority of them. [/b][/i]- Maxwell Edison 02/03/08
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=277757&messageID=2630807

[b]Just like the New York Times or CBS News[/b]
They'll make them up. - Maxwell Edison 05/16/06
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=194802&messageID=2011270

[b][i]"From my perspective, that defines the majority of them." [/b][/i]

Of course, the polls that favour your opinion are those very few exceptions to your rules.

by maxwell edison

One: Like I've said many times, you [i]make sport[/i] of challenging me and my messages. (I care not, however, because when it comes to being [i]informed[/i], you don't hold a candle to me.)

Two: You have WAY too much time on your hands.

Okay, a third: You have a habit of taking intent WAY out of context to support number one - almost to the point of being funny, or sad, depending on how one looks at it.

Okay, Oz, rant on.

by tonythetiger

[i]It's like smoking in bars, waitresses started to complain that it is an unhealthy workplace. Well its a strip bar, my dear, did you not think of smoking and sexual advances from drunk men when you applied?[/i]

I agree. I personally think it should be up to the owner of the property. If I, as a non-owner, don't like it, I don't have to enter... I am extremely sensitive to all things hickory-smoked... I even have to go inside when the neighbors are grilling and the breeze blows the wrong way... It doesn't give me the right to walk into a rib joint and demand they stop smoking their meat! I don't need, or want the world to cater to me... I have quite enough sense to avoid things that I know are going to be unpleasant.

by tonythetiger

[i]Keep politics out of the issue?[/i]

Without politics,there wouldn't BE an issue. If it were just about the science, some geeks might say something like, "Hey, look. The world's going to end... cool! Let's publish this in our scientific journal and go figure out something else."

by oz_media

[i]One: Like I've said many times, you make sport of challenging me and my messages. (I care not, however, because when it comes to being informed, you don't hold a candle to me.)[/i]

ONE: For someone who claims I am arrogant, you really drill that point home well here. :D

[i]"informed" of what[/i] outdated US history? Yup got me there. a Life learning the ins and outs of the US budget? Got me there too.
As far as being informed on thsi topic, it was you who was unaware of the effects of CO (carbon monoxide), when I was talking about the poisons in our carbon fuel emissions. You asserted that I was wrong about Co2 (Carbon dioxide) and that it was essential to life on the planet. After I offerd a Wiki link and personal explanation of CO and carboxyhemogloben, you did your homework and conceded the point. Is your memory failing you a bit these days? In all fairness, it was at least a year ago, I think.
With respect to carbon fuel emissions, you seem to forget that I have been taught, tested and certified as a specialist in air care, emissions control and alternate fuels.

But to suggest you are all wise and "informed" is simply a laughing matter.

TWO: It was just a simple TR search for 'Polls', as I know we've had a few discussions on polls before and you are adamant about how useless an unrealistic they are, how manipulated the resulta are etc. I don't disagree in that respect either.

It was just a typical burn. You stepped right into it and used two polls in one thread to try and support your assertions.

THREE: WAY out of context? You posted two polls. With the first, you argued its accuracy and validity. Nothing WAY out of context here at all, just a little display of your true feelings when others post POLLS to support their assertions.

Face it, if you had come up with the same towards me, which you do pretty much any chance you get, you'd have been laughing pretty good too.

It appears that you just can't take a fair comeback and laugh it off when its thrown at you without getting pissy about it. Face it, it was just a burn and a pretty funny one at that; again it was only 5 minutes to C&P from TR search results, not really an effort because you have stood beside that opinion many times before and most people here have read it, and agreed with you on your views there too.

by maxwell edison

[i]you just can't take a fair comeback and laugh it off when its thrown at you ......[/i]

Uh, that's all I did, dude.

[i].....without getting pissy about it....[/i]

You're the one who appears to be doing that. Chill, why don't you.

by jck

On one hand:

[i]He (Klaus) is also an outspoken critic of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, and says the panel is one-sided and has a political agenda.[/i]

Hates that the IPCC is one-sided.

yet:
[i]Opening the conference is Vaclav Klaus, president of the Czech Republic and the European Union.[/i]

[i]
The A-list of manmade climate-change skeptics is meeting in New York City for the 2009 International Conference on Climate Change.[/i]

He will be the opening speaker for...a one-sided conference...as a one-sided mindset type person.

Pot calls kettle black. More news at 11. :^0

by maxwell edison

A couple of points:

First of all, by the Heartland's own admission, it's an organization dedicated to free market solutions to public issues. Sure it has conservative and libertarian roots - those are the free market advocates. The liberal leaning organizations, on the other hand, rarely admit their own bias or publicly acknowledge their desire for infringement on free market solutions in favor of government mandated solutions.

And secondly, here's something you must not have known. The Heartland Institute's International Conference on Climate Change HAS INDEED invited public debate. Al Gore was invited - and was even offered a $200,000 honorarium - but he refused. James Hansen was invited to debate, and he too refused.

When was the last time you heard of a public debate between two climate scientists (in Hansen's case) or advocates (in Gore's case) with opposing views? Hell, I'd pay to see James Hansen publicly debate Roy Spencer, but Hansen won't do it.

The MMGW/CC people WILL NOT engage in public debate with their counterparts who disagree. The MMGW/CC advocates like to suggest [i]the debate is over[/i], but it's really no more than a public ploy to mask their unwillingness for real public debate.

by jck

not the organization.

Did you not read it? Are you trying to make an argument with me for no reason? Please go back.

I specifically state [b]he[/b] as the point of irony, not they in any way to the organization other than being the organization at which he will speak.

My assessment of Klaus is spot-on, relevant to the information you provided. He chides one organization whose opinion he does not like for being one-sided, then attends the conference of another "one-sided" group because they fall in line with what he wants.

He complains about "one-sided" organizations, yet he will foster their perpetuation by going to one as opening speaker because it fits his belief system.

If you're going to say an organization who is one-sided is wrong in climate/global warming, then don't water on the other side of the fence.

Again, Pot calls kettle black.

Look for the sequel: "Do as I say, not as I do" on newsstands soon.

by maxwell edison

You said, [i]"My assessment of Klaus is spot-on, relevant to the information you provided. He chides one organization whose opinion he does not like for being one-sided, then attends the conference of another "one-sided" group because they fall in line with what he wants.

He complains about "one-sided" organizations, yet he will foster their perpetuation by going to one as opening speaker because it fits his belief system.

If you're going to say an organization who is one-sided is wrong in climate/global warming, then don't water on the other side of the fence."[/i]

Okay, fine and dandy. Therefore what?

Yours is a typical ploy. If one can't debate the issue or message, one attacks and discredits the person (or institution).

What else is new?

How about a Klaus - Gore debate?

by jck

Tony is right! That's asking Gore to be a hypocrite too.

He better start rowing!!! :^0

by jck

Did I attack him? Have I said he was wrong? Called him a name? Insinuated anything about [b]YOU[/b]?

And yes, you can use all the vagaries you want ("If one..." for example when actually not having the balls to refer to me directly). I understood your post. It's not that hard.

I could debate the issue, but it would go nowhere since you won't listen and evaluate anything other than what you want to hear. You've been that way the 3 years I've been here, and you'll never change. Yours is the only way, and to move you to a different POV probably would take a Krakatoa size event.

I pointed out what is obvious: the man holds a double-standard.

It's okay for him to perpetuate and be in collusion with a "one-sided" organization in regards to environmental beliefs that he agrees with, but the opposing side he is all against being in existence.

I never discredited him. I just called him for the hypocrite he is.

He discredits himself by contradicting his ethos with his own actions.

To me, someone like that is the Mr. Mackey of environmental issues.

"Now kids...one-sided environmental oorganizations are bad...mmmmkay???" :^0

So, call it a ploy or roose or shenanigans.

But, I'm still right about Klaus: he's a "do as I say, not as I do" type of guy.

At least Gore tried to conserve as much energy as he could on that big estate of his.

I wonder if ole Klaus bought a Hummer to drive to work at the EU. :^0

by maxwell edison

Therefore what?

By the way, you said, [i]And yes, you can use all the vagaries you want ("If one..." for example when actually not having the balls to refer to me directly). I understood your post. It's not that hard. [/i]

Actually it wasn't directed at you - at least not you alone or even in a disparaging manner. And I actually cut and pasted it from another message left for someone else:

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=303792&messageID=3032270

The gist of my discussion was this: No, the debate IS NOT over. I said what I did to you because you didn't even address the intent of my message. What's your point? You want to slam Klaus? Fine, consider him slammed. But [i]therefore what[/i] as it pertains to the intent of my message?

P.S. You said, [i]"Yours is the only way, and to move you to a different POV probably would take a Krakatoa size event."[/i]

Well, right back at you, my friend. Why don't you change your point of view? I believe MMGW/CC is a bunch of crap. Why should I change my POV if I'm not convinced otherwise?

by oz_media

I was just rereading my own post to catch up with the thread and noticed teh typos in that last one.

Looks like it was typed by a octopalegic octopus with Parkinson's disease. :D

Great work, perhaps I'll include it in my next resume.

by delbertpgh

Politicians will always be interested in the outcomes of science and medicine, especially if they suggest changes in policy may be recommended, and especially if the recommendations have major economic impact. For example, I remember how many complaints about junk science and shoddy research accompanied the early discoveries linking cancer and smoking. Politicians from tobacco-growing states, and politicians whose re-election campaigns were being stuffed with tobacco cash, made sure the public did not get unduly alarmed about risks that could be construed as unproven. (The warning read, "The surgeon general has determined that smoking may be hazardous to your health." Not "...has determined smoking may cause heart disease and cancer.") My father-in-law happily smoked for the next forty years, confident in his own way that nothing could be proved. In a way he was right; he got good and old, and it's doubtful that the heart failure that ended him was smoking-related.

You can probably tell I'm drawing parallels here.

by Member 25348569

However, I'm immediately less than favourably impressed by the introduction made by the editor, Dr. Singer. I haven't even started on the article yet.

"Our imperfect understanding of the causes and consequences of climate change means the science is far from settled." Maybe so. I'll get back to that when I've read the article.

"This, in turn, means proposed efforts to mitigate climate change by reducing greenhouse gas emissions are premature and misguided." Certainly not premature. If anthropogenic climate change is real, it's probably too late. Misguided? I can't see that any attempt to limit the deliberate waste inherent in the current Western "civilisation" can be described as "misguided".

"Any attempt to influence global temperatures by reducing such emissions would be both futile and expensive." Now, we are getting somewhere. If the science is "far from settled", then to dismiss attempts to modify global climate as "futile" is arrogance similar to the worst of the "other side".

So far, so bad...

More later :)

by jck

[i]Actually it wasn't directed at you - at least not you alone or even in a disparaging manner. And I actually cut and pasted it from another message left for someone else:[/i]

In a message to me...about the content i posted...you started talking about someone else? Right. Even you are not that senile.

[i]The gist of my discussion was this: No, the debate IS NOT over. I said what I did to you because you didn't even address the intent of my message.[/i]

WOW!!!! YOU FINALLY GOT THAT!!! GOOD BOY!!! *pat on head*

My intention was never to contradict your statement that the debate is not over...because DEBATE IS NEVER OVER...HUMANS WILL ALWAYS DISAGREE...STATE THE OBVIOUS.

Did I want to slam Klaus? No.

If I had wanted to do that, I would have found out some tidbit of information that is unsavory and calls into question his humanity, not just moral fibre on one topic.

[i]Well, right back at you, my friend. Why don't you change your point of view? I believe MMGW/CC is a bunch of crap. Why should I change my POV if I'm not convinced otherwise?[/i]

Because when I have provided you with content and fact, you either blow it off as non-fact because you can't believe it, or you stop discussing it...then come back months later as though I never showed you information and maintain your stance.

Anyways.

Klaus said it was wrong to have a one-sided environmental group, yet he supports one.

"1: a feigning to be what one is not or to believe what one does not "

That is hypocrisy...from the Merriam-Webster dictionary.

Do as I say...not as I do...out in the EU presidency NOW. :^0

by road-dog

Even though I believe that MMGW is a load, I'm not against common sense good stewardship of my little piece of the earth.

I believe in mass transit when and for whom it makes sense. Quite frankly, it doesn't suit my work situation but it can be a cost effective solution for others. I have serious heartburn with municipalities running them at a loss and asking non-users to pick up the tab. If a city cannot run a bus line efficiently, they should open the service up for bid rather than doing it in typical government fashion.

I do sort out paper and plastic on trash day. Even though it doesn't balance out economically versus new right now, I believe that things that can be reused should be. I just don't believe that government needs to mandate it. At some point someone will come out with a cheap and easily recyclable plastic. It won't be a government.

I too loathe the people who think that a little boonie bashing on the week-end should be banned because the environment might be damaged.

I think that companies that make toxic waste while conducting business should be considering prudent waste disposal as part of CODB. Those who cut corners harm the quality of life for their neighbors and compete unfairly in the economy.

I guess what I'm saying is that the private sector is the solution to all our ills, not government.

Private sector:
Build a better mousetrap and the world will make a path to your door.

Government:
Create taxes that will cripple business while not solving the mouse problem. When the problem is not solved, blame business and raise taxes again.

by jdclyde

then who's fault is it that the convention is "one sided"? The people that show, or the unethical people that refuse to show?

by tonythetiger

He's a 24/7 hypocrite. He generates more greenhouse gases in a few month than I have in my entire (51.5 year) life! He and his family uses 40-50 times more natural resources than the average American family. And that's BEFORE counting his trans-world jaunts to spread his hype!

It's very clear what's really going on. Many of those in power (money) believe they should be in control of everything... especially if it might be running low, in which case they think they should have exclusive use of it. The Democratic process is an affront to what they believe should be the natural order of things.

That's all it is.... Really.... [b]Look at what they do[/b], not what they say, and you'll see....

by Member 25348569

Bring a bottle and please make your own way to Croydon.

8 for 8:30 and feel free to bring Max. I do owe him a steak supper after all...

:)

I invited the Queen to last years bash but the unethical old biddy didn't come.

by delbertpgh

I Googled it, and the scientific papers I found did no more than remind me that my basic college chemistry was 40 years ago, and that I flunked out of differential equations shortly thereafter.

What doth it portend, o wise one?