Discussion Locked

The State of Affairs in Iraq

0 helpful
26 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is a statement from a buddy who is still in Iraq. If he is reading this post let me say that I saw the photo of him and another co-conspirator (who will remain unnamed) going after more helipad lights. I worry about you guys! Don't loose your head over a couple of lights.
"Randy commented that he and Dave heard a report on how Iraqi bankers are being terrorized, etc.

The other day, while having my haircut, the barber confided he is scared to death of the Mahdi militia and he doesn't think much of PM Maliki, "Maliki, you know, you know, Maliki, he Iran [points finger to head], he Iran." He then elaborated, "Maliki 'Ali Baba', you know; you know Ali Baba? Maliki Ali Baba, Ali Baba" - which I took as a reference to Ali Baba and the Forty Thieves (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ali_Baba).

The flip side of this is Kurdistan. So, even if Iraq flies apart at the seams, Kurdistan can survive on its own. Kurdistan is safe, developing with two new international airports, and resource rich with newly discovered untapped oil fields. (www.theotheriraq.com)

There are four or five banks with heavy foreign investments (see attached), and they are expanding - primarily into Kurdistan."

So my friend and I have discussed this before but I wanted to put it to a larger audience - What are your thoughts on the future for Iraq?

Scenario #1 Democrats gain huge leads in mid-term elections and force the administration to begin troop withdrawals from Iraq.
In this scenario the external forces that have put so much pressure in Iraq will become invigorated and will turn their aggressions on the current Iraqi government. Civil war will ensure with the Kurds confining themselves to Kurdistan to the north and doing what it can to close its southern borders. The Shiite south will align itself with Iran. While I do not see the Arab Shiites joining nationally with the Persian Shiites I do see a strong theocratic bond that will then turn its resources against other western interests in the area (primarily Israel). The Sunni minority will suffer the most while being relegated to the eastern dessert the people will be impoverished and will either flee to Syria, or will continue to wage an increasingly feeble civil aggression against the Kurds to the north and the Shiites to the south.

Scenario #2 The Republicans maintain control of house and the senate and the efforts in Iraq get ramped up.
The difficulty in Iraq is that while the Coalition forces know what should happen to stabilize the country the political leaders of the new Iraqi government are not willing to become so draconian and do what needs to be done. Muqtada Al Sadr is a prime example of this. He should have been arrested along time ago and his Madi Army should have been forcibly disbanded. The Iraqi government and it's military has been given increasingly more responsibility for it's own security over the past year. During this time foreign fighters have flooded into the country from Syria and Iran and while opposed to one another have both attacked Iraqi government forces (army and police) and the coalition forces.

Bottom line is: If we cut and run now Iraq WILL descend into civil war which will destabilize the region for years to come. If we stay we must convince the Iraqi government to do what is necessary to win the war and repel the foreign terrorists that have infiltrated Iraq.

26 replies

by Member 25348569

is, I fear, potentially a ticking time-bomb. At the moment, they're quite happy to have escaped the control and emnity of Saddam Hussein and are enjoying their new-found autonomy and the wealth coming from the US.

Kurdistan as a cultural, racial and geographic entity, however, spreads across a significant part of Turkey and portions of Iran and Syria. Nationalism - with or without religion thrown in - is a strong force and is something that the Iraqi Kurds are revelling in since Desert Storm. When they decide that they want an autonomous "Greater Kurdistan", more sh@t will hit more fans! Turkey may well be in the EU by then!

OK, now for the tricky one!

As for Iraq as a whole, the only rational argument for continuing as we are is that things will be worse if we leave. I would like to point out that when the US were forced out of Vietnam we were assured of a bloodbath and the fall of the "South East Asian Dominoes". Neither happened and the US remained a world power. We've already covered the lie that if you did not drop the bomb on Hiroshima, you would have to invade Japan and huge casualties would follow. We all know now and knew then that this was not true.

Let's be frank about it [b]no one knows what will happen if we and the United States withdraw[/b]. We have little choice even if we step back from the political rhetoric: there will be increasing chaos if we stay, we do not know what will follow if we leave.

We should get out as soon as possible. The UN - hated though they are by the US - should arrange for an international group of peacekeepers and negotiators from the Arab countries to bring together Shiites, Sunnis and Kurds, and work out a solution that suits the Iraqis and not the US. The UN should arrange for shipments of food and medicine, from the United States, the UK and other countries, as well as engineers to help rebuild the country [b]with no strings attached[/b].

I have to stress that the UK and the United States, having destroyed Iraq through two invasions and ten years of sanctions, should play no role in the future of the country other than to supply money. The United States should withdraw from Iraq and the international community, particularly the Arab world, should try to reconstruct a nation. That gives the Iraqi people a chance.

Neil :D

sorry to disagree with you but then, I always was a pessimist and I do hope that I'm wrong.

by tony hopkinson

Iraq will break up eventually, only someone like madman hussein could keep a country like this together.

Whether the breakup will be less violent or more with continued intervention is something we'll never know.

by deepsand

This was a point I raised elsewhere prior to the invasion, as the over-arching reason for arguing against invading, as well as here after such, but now as the root cause of the current morass.

For taking such a stance, I was held up to ridicule and scorn by many here; still, I held my ground. I now say to all who villified me, (edited out of a respect for civility.)

GWB either failed to understand, or chose to ignore, the fact that, like not a few other countries, Irag was and is [b]not[/b] a nation, but rather a loose and contrived confederation of parties in conflict, bound together by the force of a sufficiently powerful and ruthless ruler. Remove said force and all hell breaks loose.

Humpty Dumpty has fallen, and all the King's Horses and all the King's Men can do nothing to put him together again.

by protiusx

You may be spot on regarding the Kurdistan question but I must disagree with some of the points you've made.
A blood bath did occur in the vacuum that was Vietnam and hundreds of thousands of people were murdered and imprisoned for their complicity with the South Vietnamese government and the US. I know this as I have a friend who was born in South Vietnam in 1968, and remembers his father being drug from the house in 1976 never to return again. It was a crime for his or his family to enquire where the Vietnamese government took their father. They learned later that he had been taken to a re-education camp and then executed. The other lesson we can learn from Vietnam comes from the testimony of North Vietnamese Army officers who stated that the war was all but over after Nixon bombed the North but they were encouraged to persevere when the listened to American radio and read American news reports about the unrest in the US. They knew if they could hold out the American's would loose heart and go home. That is precisely what happened. We left our friends and allies to their fates.
So, I disagree and say that we should stay in Iraq and ramp up our attacks on the insurgency until such time as they are dead or loose their resolve.
The other point that I have to disagree with you on is the destruction caused by the "US and UK" forces. Firstly, let me point out that while certainly in the majority the coalition forces consist of more than our two nations. I have pictures to prove this. I worked with Lithuanians, Latvians, Italians, Poles, Georgians, El Salvadorians, Japanese and even Mongolians. The thing I disagree on is the level of destruction allegedly caused by the Multi-National Forces in Iraq. The amount of money being spent on constructing schools, hospitals, housing, roads, and water treatment facilities and so on is staggering. No one knows about this because it is not news worthy but I can assure you it is happening. These services are being done without Iraqi compensation at any level.
The only destruction that is occurring of Iraqi property is by the constant bombings and explosions perpetrated by the foreign terrorists who are hell bent on fomenting a civil war.
There is no vested interest in Iran or the other surrounding nations to have a stable democracy in Iraq and that is why the foreign element has infiltrated into Iraq and is bent on destabilization.

by Member 25348569

I guess I have a different perspective on Vietnam as - thank God - my country was well out of that one and I was a teenager with little interest. I had become a little more interested in wider world affairs during the very last stages.

I do believe that the lessons of Vietnam which cost your nation so dear are being ignored. The US withdrawal from Vietnam was done on the basis that the local south Vietnamese forces would "fill the gap", your troops now, like then, are under enormous pressure, support for the war at home is decreasing. I'm expecting - I hope I'm wrong - something akin to My Lai.

As to what happened after the war. Well, simply to say that had you not got involved in the first place in what was really a proxy war agains Russia, events would have progressed differently.

The historical parallels are too close for comfort.

As for Iraq, given that the majority of the foreign insurgents are there to stir the crap up and foment civil war in Iraq for your benefit, I leave you to extrapolate a solution.

As for your comment "no vested interest in Iran or the other surrounding nations to have a stable democracy in Iraq". Well of COURSE NOT. But then anyone will an ounce of political savvy KNEW that. But your President has to do something to keep his bogus "War on Terror" going so he destabilises the region as much as he possibly can. Hello? How sensible is that!

Neil :D

p.s. Israel's up to her old tricks, I see. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle_east/6112386.stm

by nicknielsen

[i]There is no vested interest in Iran or the other surrounding nations to have a stable democracy in Iraq and that is why the foreign element has infiltrated into Iraq and is bent on destabilization.[/i]

Of course not. The last thing Syria, Saudi Arabia, Jordan, Kuwait, or Iran want in the region is another Western-style democracy; one is too many. Anybody with half a lick of political sense has known this for decades.

The only thing the Saudis want less is a Shiite-dominated state, democratic or otherwise, on their northern border. Why do you think they tolerated Saddam for so long?

by onbliss

For any kind of violence committed by foreign forces to be sustainable, there needs to be domestic support.
Say if we think the violence is caused only by foreigners, then we would find three categories of Iraqis, those:
1)Supporting the violence
2)Opposing the violence
3)Indifferent to the violence

Even if the people in categories (2) and (3) were to be in the majority, there should be sizable (1) category people for the violence to last this long. Without the common people's support violence would fizzle out faster. Jammu & Kashmir, Srilanka, Afghanistan, Palestine, French Resistance helping Allied soldiers, Lebanon etc. are just few examples where the "foreign hand" could not have accomplished much without local sympathy and support.

It might not be possible to know the numbers of infiltrators and domestic supporters, but it would be naive if we believe that it is just the infiltrators that are causing all the trouble.

by delbertpgh

After the U.S. left Viet Nam, there was plenty of murder, some in South Viet Nam, much more in Cambodia. Two or three million Cambodians died, killed by the Khmer Rouge and the Vietnamese, who later invaded to get the country quiet.

What did not happen was that Thailand or the Philippines or Maylaya fell to communism. Our prestige was not shattered; we did not lose the cold war. America came out okay, having left a war it should not have gotten into, and where it could not achieve victory.

Victory in Viet Nam was not a matter of defeating the North's army. Victory was establishing a good-guy government in the South, which would unify the people, keep the communists from operating and recruiting new soldiers, and allow us to leave. There was no chance of the good-guy government appearing in Viet Nam to save us from our problems, any more than there is in Iraq. That's why it was smart to leave Viet Nam. That's why it was so dumb to repeat virtually the same mistakes in Iraq.

(Protius is right, of course, that almost all the destruction caused in Iraq from 2003 to today was by the insurgents. Most of them are Iraqi, though, not foreigners. And regardless of who is blowing up the country, Arab pretzel logic blames the U.S. as the root cause.)

by tony hopkinson

where does it say the UK will ?

The poodle won't be in charge then, but any ah difficulties experienced after an early withdrawal will be a lasting political legacy, just like those from staying.

The only possible win now is democracy in iraq, or more correctly kurdistan and the rest or even three countries.

Self determination is after all self determination, anybody thought of asking the current inhabitants of iraq what they want, instead of trying to impose what we want.

by Member 25348569

Tony, Tony, Tony...

Whan have we ever done that? When have the US ever done that?

We know best! What they want a two-party democracy with an executive president, free markets and open foreign investment. Oh, and the right to bear arms. (oops!)

All this despite the fact that Iraq has never been anything close to a democracy and has an extremely fervent nationalistic streak and a hatred of outside ownership of Iraqi industry and resources since before the Shah.

But you know all of that, don't you? Are we the only ones who do?

Neil :D

by deepsand

we don't get to call the shots, only to try to deal with the consequences.

The Nixon/Ford boys are once more in control,
Dylan's [i]Masters of War[/i] and Farina's [i]Bold Marauder[/i] and [i]Children of Darkness[/i] are again timely, and it's [i]deja vu[/i] all over again.

by delbertpgh

The Iraqis were calling the looters who sacked the country in the month after Saddam was overthrown "Ali Baba", after Ali Baba and the Forty Thieves. This barber probably is trying to say he thinks Maliki is another common bandit, looting Iraq.

Some Iraqi barbers have been given threatening messages to stop giving western haircuts and cutting off beards, because clean-shaven men with fashion haircuts are anti-Islamic. Some barbers have even been killed.

by delbertpgh

We entered the war for reasons that aren't very clear. I don't think that GWB was dumb enought to believe that a half-@ssed atomic weapons program was enough of an immediate danger to go to war, but he was sure foolish enough to think that changing a government and building a national spirit in Iraq would be easy, and without problems.

We've got problems now. Given that we overthrew Saddam, we can be blamed for them. Iraq is more dangerous to Iraqis than it was under the murderer Saddam. It's more dangerous to us, too. There were no terrorists there to bring our War on Terror to, but there sure are now. When (not "if"; but "when") Iraq breaks up in a civil war, it will spread terror around the region, and maybe spawn wars in the Middle East.

You might think that having screwed it up so bad, and created an international disaster that will get worse if we leave, we should stay and fix it. Well, there's big problems with that.

While we're trying to repair Iraq, revolutionaries are trying to spoil everything we do. If we train more policemen, they kill policemen. If we build schools, they burn schools. If we fix sewers and power stations, they blow them up. We are seen as the inspiration for this violence, and we are blamed for it. The government of Iraq won't make the hard political decisions as long as it can lean on us. Things will just get no better, or worse, so long as we are a factor. For all the force we can bring to bear, and all the good it can accomplish, the crooks and warlords and religious crackpots have a greater capacity to destroy. Meanwhile, Iran gains influence in the region, we lose our moral advantage, and the terrorists around the world gain prestige and new recruits.

The longer we stay, the more our power erodes. This war consumes our resources, and gets us nothing. There's no reasonable expectation that a nice bunch of guys will step up and unify the country and let us leave a prosperous and peaceful state behind.

There are real risks in walking away. We've got to keep some involvement in the region, to do what we can to reassure surrounding governments, and contain Iranian power. It will be tricky. It will require smart thinking, timing, diplomacy, and force. It will need to be handled a lot better than the Iraq debacle.

(I borrowed some of this from a letter in the Wall Street Journal editorials on Friday.)

by deepsand

He knowingly failed to heed the advise of his father and others who had an experienced grasp of geo-politics in general, and Middle Eastern affairs in particular, that was far superior to his, mounted his horse and galloped off hell-bent for leather like a crazed cowboy.

The world is now paying, and will continue to pay, for his arrogance; or, perhaps hubris would be a more appropriate depiction.

Pride goeth before the fall.

by tony hopkinson

The more intelligent you are, the dumber your mistakes look. :D

Maybe in private the guy's kicking himself saying, should have listened to pop and begging forgiveness before his god for his pride.

It would be political suicide for him to admit it though.

Hubris would be my pick as well.

by tony hopkinson

You only have to look at the break up of the USSR and the balkan states for a bit of a clue.

States jammed together from disparate ethnic and religious leanings where one particular section of the population has exercised extreme control to keep their pre-eminence always go bang.

Anyone who pulls their head out of the sand for a furtive look round should be able to see this.

by deepsand

how is it that those of us standing on the deck can see the mast of an approaching vessel on the horizon, while those up in the crows nest give no warning of such? And, if they do, their cries are ignored by the captain?

by deepsand

In my youth, I was known by my high school classmates as a "know it all." Said reputation had a basis both in fact and the constant praise of my teachers, with the result that I came dangerously close to believing it to be true. It was my tenure at the US Naval Academy which put the lie to such. There I quickly learned that, rather than quessing, and, when caught in such, having to recite the ritualistic and tediously long response to an upper-classeman's query "Why did you guess, Mister?", it was best, in the face of even the smallest doubt as to the accuracy of my proposed answer, to respond with "I'll find out, Sir."

Following that epiphany, I forced myself to make a deliberate and concious effort to speak less, and listen more; and, when speaking, to more often ask questions rather than making statements, and to limit statements to those which I could substantiate. Eventually, I acquired a reputation for always being right, when in fact I was simply taking great care not to be wrong.

The point of all this? Most people would rather hear an "I don't know" than a guess that turns out to be wrong. Had GWB early on admitted his mistakes, he would have stood a reasonably good chance of avoiding the train wreck that has befallen him and his administration. Now, at best, he might merely be held up to public ridicule and scorn; at worst, he'd so badly alienate Republican voters that enough would sit out the elections at least though the 2008 Prsidential race, thereby relegating the Republican Party to the status of has-beens.

by tomart

Let's not forget that in a free society like ours, it's supposed to be OK to DISAGREE, you moron. Our founding fathers set up branches of government to check too much power getting in the wrong hands, like W.
Someone mentioned above that for W to admit to any mistake is political suicide? No, I think political irrelevance is holding onto a political stance that has been shown to be WRONG. The voters just told W that he was WRONG; if we can all see it, then just admit the OBVIOUS and move on!
The majority of Americans have learned to ignore his (and Rove's) stupid stubborn lies, and until W admits that he made a MISTAKE, and shown some sign that he's learned from it, we're not listening to a word he says!
He has managed to make the most powerful man in the world, irrelevant, by ignoring reality.
And I'm sick of people like you supporting his stupid, costly and wrong-headed policies. Will any of you make a simple admission that he was WRONG to invade Iraq? History will be appalled at the egregious lies that got us in there, the stupendous amounts of OUR TAX DOLLARS squandered over there, the excessive loss of life, which WE HAVE CAUSED.
The Neocons thought they could take over the OIL for cheap - what's a few thousand lives to them? Don't continue to defend this evil, costly, failed, state-sponsored THEFT. There were no WMDs, have you heard? And if ANY of Bush's high-falutin' intentions of saving Iraqis from Saddam's torture chambers had even a shred of honesty, then why are WE torturing people now? and why not invade Darfur to prevent ongoing genocide? Because THERE'S NO OIL THERE.
Lieberman's PR piece is well-written propaganda. As an American, I have NEVER agreed to have my tax dollars disappear into the Iraqi sinkhole (while Halliburton and others make millions.)
You disgust me, you name-calling dimwit.

by maxwell edison

(A cut-and-pasted article from the Wall Street Journal)

Our Troops Must Stay

America can't abandon 27 million Iraqis to 10,000 terrorists.

BY JOE LIEBERMAN
Tuesday, November 29, 2005 12:01 a.m. EST

I have just returned from my fourth trip to Iraq in the past 17 months and can report real progress there. More work needs to be done, of course, but the Iraqi people are in reach of a watershed transformation from the
primitive, killing tyranny of Saddam to modern, self-governing, self-securing nationhood--unless the great American military that has given them and us this unexpected opportunity is prematurely withdrawn.

Progress is visible and practical. In the Kurdish North, there is continuing security and growing prosperity. The primarily Shiite South remains largely free of terrorism, receives much more electric power and other public services than it did under Saddam, and is experiencing greater economic activity. The Sunni triangle, geographically defined by Baghdad to the east, Tikrit to the north and Ramadi to the west, is where most of the terrorist enemy attacks occur. And yet here, too, there is progress.

There are many more cars on the streets, satellite television dishes on the roofs, and literally millions more cell phones in Iraqi hands than before. All of that says the Iraqi economy is growing. And Sunni candidates are actively campaigning for seats in the National Assembly. People are working their way toward a functioning society and economy in the midst of a very brutal, inhumane, sustained terrorist war against the civilian population and the Iraqi and American military there to protect it.

It is a war between 27 million and 10,000; 27 million Iraqis who want to live lives of freedom, opportunity and prosperity and roughly 10,000 terrorists who are either Saddam revanchists, Iraqi Islamic extremists or al Qaeda foreign fighters who know their wretched causes will be set back if Iraq becomes free and modern. The terrorists are intent on stopping this by instigating a civil war to produce the chaos that will allow Iraq to replace Afghanistan as the base for their fanatical war-making. We are fighting on the side of the 27 million because the outcome of this war is critically
important to the security and freedom of America. If the terrorists win, they will be emboldened to strike us directly again and to further undermine the growing stability and progress in the Middle East, which has long been a major American national and economic security priority.

Before going to Iraq last week, I visited Israel and the Palestinian Authority. Israel has been the only genuine democracy in the region, but it is now getting some welcome company from the Iraqis and Palestinians who are in the midst of robust national legislative election campaigns, the Lebanese who have risen up in proud self-determination after the Hariri assassination to eject their Syrian occupiers (the Syrian- and Iranian-backed Hezbollah militias should be next), and the Kuwaitis, Egyptians and Saudis who have taken steps to open up their governments more broadly to their people. In my meeting with the thoughtful prime minister of Iraq, Ibrahim al-Jaafari, he declared with justifiable pride that his country now has the most open, democratic political system in the Arab world. He is right. In the face of terrorist threats and escalating violence, eight million Iraqis voted for their interim national government in January, almost 10 million participated in the referendum on their new constitution in October, and even more than that are expected to vote in the elections for a full-term government on Dec. 15. Every time the 27 million Iraqis have been given the chance since Saddam was overthrown, they have voted for self-government and hope over the violence and hatred the 10,000 terrorists offer them. Most encouraging has been the behavior of the Sunni community, which, when disappointed by the proposed constitution, registered to vote and went to the polls instead of taking up arms and going to the streets. Last week, I was thrilled to see a vigorous political campaign, and a large number of independent television stations and newspapers covering it.

None of these remarkable changes would have happened without the coalition forces led by the U.S. And, I am convinced, almost all of the progress in Iraq and throughout the Middle East will be lost if those forces are withdrawn faster than the Iraqi military is capable of securing the country.

The leaders of Iraq's duly elected government understand this, and they asked me for reassurance about America's commitment. The question is whether the American people and enough of their representatives in Congress from both parties understand this. I am disappointed by Democrats who are more focused on how President Bush took America into the war in Iraq almost three years ago, and by Republicans who are more worried about whether the war will bring them down in next November's elections, than they are concerned about how we continue the progress in Iraq in the months and years ahead.

Here is an ironic finding I brought back from Iraq. While U.S. public opinion polls show serious declines in support for the war and increasing pessimism about how it will end, polls conducted by Iraqis for Iraqi universities show increasing optimism. Two-thirds say they are better off than they ere under Saddam, and a resounding 82% are confident their lives in Iraq will be better a year from now than they are today. What a colossal mistake it would be for America's bipartisan political leadership to choose this moment in history to lose its will and, in the famous phrase, to seize defeat from the jaws of the coming victory.

The leaders of America's military and diplomatic forces in Iraq, Gen. George Casey and Ambassador Zal Khalilzad, have a clear and compelling vision of our mission there. It is to create the environment in which Iraqi democracy, security and prosperity can take hold and the Iraqis themselves can defend their political progress against those 10,000 terrorists who would take it from them.

Does America have a good plan for doing this, a strategy for victory in Iraq? Yes we do. And it is important to make it clear to the American people that the plan has not remained stubbornly still but has changed over the years. Mistakes, some of them big, were made after Saddam was removed, and no one who supports the war should hesitate to admit that; but we have learned from those mistakes and, in characteristic American fashion, from what has worked and not worked on the ground. The administration's recent
use of the banner "clear, hold and build" accurately describes the strategy as I saw it being implemented last week. We are now embedding a core of coalition forces in every Iraqi fighting unit, which makes each unit more effective and acts as a multiplier of our forces. Progress in "clearing" and "holding" is being made. The Sixth Infantry Division of the Iraqi Security Forces now controls and polices more than one-third of Baghdad on its own. Coalition and Iraqi forces have together cleared the previously terrorist-controlled cities of Fallujah, Mosul and Tal Afar, and most of the border with Syria. Those areas are now being "held" secure by the Iraqi military themselves. Iraqi and coalition forces are jointly carrying out a mission to clear Ramadi, now the most dangerous city in Al-Anbar province at the west end of the Sunni Triangle.

Nationwide, American military leaders estimate that about one-third of the approximately 100,000 members of the Iraqi military are able to "lead the fight" themselves with logistical support from the U.S., and that that number should double by next year. If that happens, American military forces could begin a drawdown in numbers proportional to the increasing self-sufficiency of the Iraqi forces in 2006. If all goes well, I believe we can have a much smaller American military presence there by the end of 2006 or in 2007, but it is also likely that our presence will need to be significant in Iraq or nearby for years to come.

The economic reconstruction of Iraq has gone slower than it should have, and too much money has been wasted or stolen. Ambassador Khalilzad is now implementing reform that has worked in Afghanistan--Provincial Reconstruction Teams, composed of American economic and political experts, working in partnership in each of Iraq's 18 provinces with its elected leadership, civil service and the private sector. That is the "build" part of the "clear, hold and build" strategy, and so is the work American and international teams are doing to professionalize national and provincial governmental agencies in Iraq.

These are new ideas that are working and changing the reality on the ground, which is undoubtedly why the Iraqi people are optimistic about their future--and why the American people should be, too.

I cannot say enough about the U.S. Army and Marines who are carrying most of the fight for us in Iraq. They are courageous, smart, effective, innovative, very honorable and very proud. After a Thanksgiving meal with a great group of Marines at Camp Fallujah in western Iraq, I asked their commander whether the morale of his troops had been hurt by the growing public dissent in America over the war in Iraq. His answer was insightful, instructive and inspirational: "I would guess that if the opposition and division at home go
on a lot longer and get a lot deeper it might have some effect, but, Senator, my Marines are motivated by their devotion to each other and the cause, not by political debates."
Thank you, General. That is a powerful, needed message for the rest of America and its political leadership at this critical moment in our nation's history. Semper Fi.

http://www.opinionjournal.com/editorial/feature.html?id=110007611

Thank you, Senator Lieberman, for reminding us of all the good things we are doing in Iraq.

And a personal note to Senator Lieberman: I've often said that I would never vote for a Democrat. But in your case, if I was ever faced with such a choice, I might make an exception. You are indeed a man who puts principle before politics. You have my utmost respect.

And where was this message in the recent election coverage?

by jamesrl

In the years prior to the second gulf war, the Kurdish area of Iraq was becoming more and more independant. For all intents and purposes there was a functioning Kurdish government and economy.

Saddam could not send his army in. The nofly agreements meant he could not send in his helicopters, which he needed to protect his army.

If you cross into Kurdish territory on the main roads from Turkey, you were met by Kurds, not Iraqi soldiers.

Saddam quietly ceded control of the area to the Kurds. He did send in his secret police to spy and assasinate but couldn't do much more.

My point is that, given the Kurds developed that much autonomy, it would be hard for them to accept much less under a new Iraqi constituion.

And perhaps given the desire to unite the kurds in Iran and Turkey with those in Iraq, it might be better to cut them loose, than have them drag Iraq into a war with its neighbours.

I don't compare the situation with Vietnam, its more like the former Yugoslavia. While Tito was no Saddam, he did keep different "countries" together under one state, and when he died, the breakup of Yugoslavia was almost inevitable. It was of course bitter and painful.

The Sunni/Shiite civil war has already started, it is just fairly low intensity now.

I don't have any answers. Clearly it would be good if the Iraqi police and army could bring order themselves. But that doesn't seem to be happening after years of effort and training.

It would be difficult to keep the foreigners out in any event.

James

by deepsand

If such cost is acceptable to him, he deems the cost to others to be irrelevant and immaterial.

And, in his eyes, if another does not agree, the fault is theirs'.

This discussion is closed to new replies.