Discussion Locked

Thousands of failing schools face major overhaul

0 helpful
26 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

http://www.cnn.com/2007/EDUCATION/06/20/failing.schools.ap/index.html

Now, if you were to talk to my better half who is a Teacher. She would say that 'no child left behind' is a joke. I know that she is a good teacher, just because I can see the excitement in her face everyday when she comes home and tells me about her day. But, she feels that 'no child left behind' is a waste for a number of reasons:
1). More time is spent testing then teaching.
2). Children with learning disabilities are being lumped in with everyone else, thus pushing down the scores.
3). States are able to have their own standards they need to meet, which you know will be geared to make the state look good.
*** She has more arguments, but I can't remember them all.

Ok, I just covered my a$$ with providing her side to this. My thoughts, I think it's about time. They teach based upon what is going to be tested so that they look good. Well, I've heard her talk about the tests that are given(reading, math, history, ...). I haven't heard anything yet that I consider trivial or shouldn't be in the test. You drive it into a person enough times, they will remember. If for no other reason then to shut you up. This is good.

The article talks about schools being restructured because scores have not improved. This includes moving of personnel and firing principles. Good, these people quite obviously did not take the time to research out all the different ways others have found to improve the child's education. Laura is always talking about learning various new ways to get the points across. Hell, she loves having substitute teachers for the simple reason that she sees other ways of presenting the material. How many teachers of 25 years do you think feel the same way? Which is why their schools are failing. They need to be replaced.

Do I think 'no child left behind' is perfect. Hell no, it's a government program. But, do I think it is finally shaking the tree of the lazy a$$ educators that just pass the children along. yes I do, and that's a good thing.

Dan

26 replies

by jmgarvin

No Child Left Behind is a total waste of time. Teachers will have to spend the bulk of their time teaching for the test, which is unfair to the student.

Sure, I can teach any student how to test well, but that doesn't mean they are critical thinkers, nor does it mean they are able to adapt their knowledge to various situations. This is a HUGE problem.

I had students walk into my COLLEGE classroom and not know what exponents were. I've had students not know what a paragraph was. I've had students look at me like I was from Mars we I explained they needed a better algorithm. I've had students stop my lecture to ask me to define SIMPLE VOCABULARY.

Right now our schools are failing. Why? They don't teach the Three R's. We need to go back to basics and build from there.

by danlm

I see both yours and Laura's side to where you both feel that the students are not being taught, but are being prepared for a test. And I can't argue that in any way.

But, I also see teacher's that have been there 30 years that feel it's either my way or no way when it comes to teaching. That are unwilling to learn new methods of teaching the 3 r's. They don't care that they don't capture the imagination of the children with their lessons. Truthfully, I don't think they care that children are not learning. Where I see the 'No Child Left Behind' working is, it's moving this group of good for nothing educators out of the system.

Trust me when I say this. I lose this argument with Laura every time we talk about it. But then, I give in because I know she loves her job. And to be honest, I know she sees what does and what doesn't work.

Dan

by locrian_lyric

This person shouldn't have been allowed to teach fish to swim.

When I was going through the school, this teacher was the worst of the worst. But, alas... tenure being what it is.

Among the lesser crimes this fool comitted was refusing to allow a child who was going through chemotherapy to have a pass to the bathroom so she could throw-up in private.

The girl got her revenge though, she vomited right on bulldog's desk.

Naturally, the NJEA fought tooth and nail to force the school to retain bulldog.

Eventually, they moved bulldog to a position where no student contact was required.

by danlm

I've discussed them with my girlfriend. You need a firm knowledge in the subject to pass.

As a follow up to this, Laura told me about a student that had a severe learning disability. This student had parents that worked with both the school and the student to insure he was properly educated. Because of this child's learning disability, the testing process allowed him as much time as he wanted to use in taking the test. Where student's that have not been identified with learning disabilities are under a time limit per subject test. Ie: 2 hours for the english test. They start giving the federal test in 10th grade like I previously mentioned so that the students have 3 years to pass all subjects. What is failed one year can be taken again in the next. This student with the learning disability took a very long time in taking his tests, but he passed every subject in the 10th grade. The very first time he took the test he passed everything. He did not take a different test then any other student either. This shows if a parent is involved and stays on top of both the student and the school that there is no reason for a student to not be properly educated. Needless to say, his mother was a very proud parent. Actually, she was in tears.

I've also been told about the opposite of this story. Parents that complain the material is too hard for their baby. Who do the work for their baby.

The blame should be spread equally between the school system and the parents when it comes to a child not being properly educated.

Dan

by tony hopkinson

Ask them to work out 397 * 8, they reach for the calculator, where as someone who understood would take 24 of 3200, course nowadays they'd reach for teh calculator to work that out as well.

by dr dij

doesn't that mean that they give passing grades to everyone so they're not 'left behind' regardless of whether they can function in the real world when they grow up?

by danlm

Huge piece in the Cleveland paper about kids that have completed all their grades. But could not pass the manditory test required to get their diploma.

And the kicker is, the kid's start taking the test in 10th grade. So, if they pass a specific subject. Then all they have to worry about the next year is the subjects they didn't pass in the previous years test.

Look, I am not trying to promote this. Well, I guess I am from the position that it is getting rid of the teachers that just don't care about the children being prepared for life.

Dan

by dr dij

because the unions have tenure.

that's the problem with a public school system.

I'm a strong believer in vouchers. The schools that did the best job would tend to get the students.

Problem is these dumb little kids are dumb because of a self reinforcing cycle - schools are not interesting to them; they do not keep them in line enuf to learn; being public schools they allow outrageous behavior in classes either because they are afraid to discipline them, or don't care.

When I was in Dallas as a kid at a private school, the math teacher would put bobby pins in boy's hair if it fell down over their eyebrows. Good incentive to be able to see. I think they stopped hitting kids tho.

by inkling

Public schools cost per student is ~$9000.

Charter schools cost per student is ~$6000.

More states need to make it easier to create charter schools.

The federal government needs to stand up to the teachers union and it's lobbyists.

More money needs to be spent on the educators. Less money on stupid federally/state mandated testing programs which are worthless.

Students of charter schools are 12% more likely to become proficient in English and 13% more likely to become proficient in Math.

Public schools are a failure.

I will not be sending my kids to public schools.

by tony hopkinson

last ten years.
The kids get taught to pass the tests.
What constitutes a pass has been changed, to get more passes.

They still come out of there with less skills and knowledge than I did , when 'it was all wrong'

More opportunities to learn to think are what is required. The test mentality simply promotes learning things parrot fashion. The latter is not a problem for basic facts, but using the facts can't be taught like that.

You want children good at basic arithmetic, get them to score a dart game, that's a real test.

by danlm

And I'll follow this up when Laura gets here tonight.

I was told that European schools provide a general education up to the 10th grade I believe. And at that stage, they funnel the children into concentrated class's on the subjects where the children have strong skills. Ie: If a child has strong skills in math they are then funneled into class's that concentrate on this during the high school years. Higher level math skills that can be used in engineering, science, what ever. The child is actually taking what would be considered college level class's here in America during their years in high school.

Is this correct? And if it is not, I do apologize for being misinformed.

Dan

by tony hopkinson

But basically at 13 you get to pick which optional subjects you wish to take exams in and get a graded qualification, two years of that then you take exams and leave at 16.

Then you have the chance to do A levels, that's 'specialist' subjects. That usually is two years. Then if you get decent grades, or have a sum of money you go and do a degree at university.

I did Physics, biology, and Chemistry at 14 to 16. My son did combined science. Hardest question he got was identifying the labels (harmful, irritant etc) on chemicals. I was doing organic chemistry, could name every major part of the human body and what it was for, and knew how to apply coefficients to calculate heat dissapation in a simple electronic circuit.

Don't even start me up about maths....

by wayne m.

No Child Left Behind is merely another example of people relying on measurement rather than action. What are the steps put into place should a student, a school, a school district, etc. fail a test? Where are the recommendations to help improve instruction?

Rather than providing a solution to teaching difficulties, No Child Left Behind simply punts on what to do. Replacing principals and teachers, transferring students, etc., do nothing to improve teaching - they merely move the problem around. What is needed is a concentrated study into what to teach and how to teach it to a variety of learning styles. Students should move on only as they master a subject; no one should move on with a 60% or 75% mastery of a subject just because of a date on a calendar - we need pass/incomplete grading.

Without changed processes of teaching, expecting changed results is pointless. Mass testing tells nothing about the work of the individual teachers and principals; it only reflects the reality of the current system of education.

P.S. I heartily agree with the typo in the original article, the reactions do reflect "firing principles."

by danlm

Teacher's that could care less if they keep a students attention. That do not want to learn new ways of teaching. These teacher's are easily identified in the test scores. Each school gets a breakdown on how the student's do by grade, subject matter, gender, and race. It shows up pretty strong when you have a school doing great in every subject except for one. And that's all it takes for a school to have a failing grade. One subject with a low score. Trust me when I say this... Principles and school districts, at least here in Cleveland, put these specific subject's/grades/schools under a microscope to see how to better these scores. If it means booting a teacher to home room duty, I am quite sure they will. If it means moving a principle/teacher from a school that is doing well to one that isn't. They do this also. They take the teacher's that have shown the ability help the children learn the subject matter and place them where they are needed most. And as the die hard idiots retire or move on, they fill those positions with younger blood. You also know that teachers are required to update their own education over time or else their license to teach is not renewed. Another way of removing the non motivated.

Dan

I need to start doing these post's in word first so that I can see everything instead of this little freaken box which I continuously scroll up and down.

by wayne m.

Often the easiest rationalization when faced with a problem one does not understand is to blame the individuals involved. The reality is that in most situations, the individuals are doing the best that they can, but are in an environment where the results are largely outside of their control.

First, realize that eyeballing data is not sufficient, true statistical analysis is required. It is impossible to select one number out of a set and be able to instinctively know that the result was due to poor teaching. There are a large number of variables involved and I doubt that any teacher has started the year saying "I know how to teach better, I just don't feel like doing it."

Who decided the curriculum? Who decided the class length? Who defined the teaching methods? Who researched effective teaching methods? Who decided the class size? What are the variables that influence learning? What is the expected variance among pupils? There are simply far too many variables involved to point fingers at a teacher, a principal, a school, a school system as the culprit. It is easy to pass a law or set an arbitrary numeric target ? it is far more difficult to actually research and implement an effective improvement.

P.S. See ?Out of the Crisis? by Dr. W. E. Deming for a far better discussion of these issues than I can provide.

by danlm

That was how I understood it. But for me sitting afar, I was unsure of how well it worked.

I get the impression that it was better when you was growing up. And I'm not trying to say your old.

;o)

Thank you.

Dan

by tony hopkinson

I'd had more opportunity to learn math at 11 than my daughter did at sixteen.

We both went to the same schools, says it all really.

by inkling

I take no credit for the following logic. Someone that has given it much more thought than myself said this:

If you send your child to a Catholic School, you would (rightfully so) expect that Catholicism would be taught as the religion of choice. If you sent your child to a Jewish school, your child will be taught to worship the tenets of Judaism, etc., etc.

If you send your child to a government run school ("public schools" in the U.S. are, truthfully, "government schools"), you should expect that they will be taught to obey and worship government.

I'll leave you with a quote from a very prominent government educator:

"When schoolchildren start paying union dues," he said, "that's when I'll start representing the interests of schoolchildren."

The late Albert Shanker, former president of the powerful American Federation of Teachers said that.

Ladies and gentlemen, that is, sadly representative of teachers and their unions in the government schools in the United States of America.

It isn't testing that is wrong with American schools.

It is the people running those schools...the United States government.

One last tidbit of information that should horrify you:

Harcourt Brace, a major publisher of schoolbooks, published a social studies "activity book" that had a page addressing the Bill or Rights. Let's take the second amendment as an example...

The second amendment explains the right to bear arms thusly: "The right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed."

Harcourt Brace's "activity book" changes the second amendment to say: "The Second Amendment says that states may enlist citizens for a trained militia [army] and provide and train them with weapons."

That is a MAJOR perversion of the Bill of Rights.

The states, nor the federal government have the legal ability to "grant" or deny the right to bear arms. The Bill of Rights (specifically the Second Amendment) GUARANTEES this right to "the people".

This is only ONE example of the treachery that is our government school system.

If I have to live out of my Jeep, my children will be attending private schools.

No child left behind is a failure. Government schools are a failure.

The only way to correct our schools is to completely privatize it or to move to a voucher system which encourages competition and to severely limit the power of the teachers unions.

by danlm

Just a clarification there. Your example of the bill of rights and the social studies book would be found in both public and private schools.

Not all schools buy from the same publisher's also. Again, further clarification.

Damn publisher should be shot though.

Dan

by midnightstorm

Here in SA things are a little different. For the past few weeks the teachers have been on strike. Pupils could not write some of their exams and tests simply as there were no teachers to watch over them. Why are the teachers on strike... Because the South African government wouldn't give them a 12% increase on their salaries. We dont have enought teachers to take classes (the average pupils in one class is 40 pupils to one teacher) and then the children are so misbehaved that the teachers are leaving and being replaced in certain places by people that can't even read or write.

If you dont want your teachers, ship them over here! We could use all the help we can get!

by danlm

We don't want the teachers that are there just to retire.

No child in any nation should have the misfortune of being educated by someone that is only there to collect a pay check. Education is like health care, you should only be in either profession because you want to improve someones life.\

I also understand teacher's position on strikes though. The quality of the work can/does shape the world as we know it. They should be properly compensated for that.

dan

by locrian_lyric

I have dysgraphia, which is not uncommon for people with AS.

I can not write more than a few sentences before my hand freezes on the page. I had to develop a near photographic memory to survive school.

Even people with severe LDs can make it if they try, and if the parents are involved.

I, like you, am of two minds on this one...

I do think that the schools are failing to teach our children. The fact that I had to teach a new graduate how to write a for-next loop demonstrates that. Oh, and his English skills were apalling as well. What made that bit worse was he was born and raised here!

by danlm

To say there are not teachers that do not want to learn new ways is not being realistic. I am not saying that teachers/school district's are the complete problem. But they are definatly a part of it.

Examples of school districts/principles not doing their job. Not because they don't care, but they have never taken the initiative to improve their educational assets.
1). Educational websites continuously publish different teaching methods and highlight what has and has not worked. Principles/teachers do not reference this material until they are in deep water because of the test scores. The principles did not require strict lesson plans. The teacher's did not take the time to see what was there to assist them. This information was provided to this school district as it is to all school districts. Either by handouts, emails, or other publications. Ohio, small town. Real life example.

2). There already has been an example of a teacher 'bulldog' at the top of the thread where this teacher should have never been in his position. These examples are in every school district.

3). There are both young and old teachers that feel that once they have earned their degree and reached a certain level of experience. They should not have to change. In their mind, what they are doing is right. Evan though their method no longer works. The book 'Who moved the cheese' best explains these types of teachers. Just like in any profession where there are people unwilling to change.

Example of where teacher's have no control over the issue. They have a class of 30 students, mainstream classroom. In this class you have a mix of students. Students with learning disabilities, students that have both physical and learning disabilities, students that are able to grasp all lessons, and students that things are not moving fast enough. Because of the disruptions caused by this mix of student's within one classroom, proper time is not spent with any category of student so that they are taught properly. Student's with learning disabilities should be taught differently and at a different pace then the rest of the students. They should learn the same material, but it needs to be taught differently. Students that are more faced paced should be placed in class's that will challenge them. But all of these student's are within one environment and learning together, with them all losing in their education.

No, I do not think all teachers need to be replaced. Yes, I do think that there are individuals that do not belong in the education system. The job is too important for them to be in a job they really don't care about. No, I do not think that the shuffling of personnel for troubled schools is the complete answer. Yes, I do think it is something that should be tried though. As in any profession, you place your best suited assets in the area's that work the best for the overall situation. Some principles are not inspirational enough with their personnel to go the extra mile. Some teacher's just work better in different environments. It's human nature.

Dan

Chuckle, and I just got my faced ripped off for this post from my better half. lol, so no matter how bad you may disagree with my post if is not even close to what I just had to hear.

Her final comment on this was. If parents are not involved, then their children will not want to learn. The students that have issues(learning, otherwise) who have involved parents. Almost always achieve or excel in their lessons.

by wayne m.

The quality approach I subscribe to defines two classes of issues that cause problems: systemic causes and assignable causes. Assignable causes have a direct cause and effect relationship while systemic causes are broad and not empirically identifiable. Fixing assignable causes, however, rarely affects the median result nor range of variation in the system. At best, the "bulldog teacher" would be an example of an assignable cause and my expectation would be that replacement of the teacher would not have noticeable affect on the test scores at a school, in a school system, nor the nation as a whole.

As long as we rely on a system of individual choice to select teaching mechanisms, we must accept that teachers will, individually, choose to do what is right "... in their own mind(s)."

A further outcome of this line of thinking is that random changes in response to individual measurements will make the situation worse than if no changes are made.

Though egregious examples of poor teachers and principals may be found, addressing them will likely have no affect on the education system as a whole.

This discussion is closed to new replies.