Discussion Locked

To Cert or To B.S: Which comes first?

0 helpful
14 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Since I have not completed my degree in Computer Information Systems, I was wondering if I should get my certifications first or continue with my B.S.

I can certify myself without class participation saving me some money. However, the Novell, Cisco, and Microsoft Systems Engineer certs are not easy and require hands-on knowledge. I have read here that members are getting notes and other study materials, then creating the lab environment themselves. Do you need a lab for those certs?

I can pay about 5,000 at New Horizons for my MCSA cert which includes Network+. I am currently getting my A+ certification via self-study.

What are the thoughts of the Tech Republic community?

14 replies

by talkingwall

The BS will open doors for you that certifications will not, especially when it comes to government contracts. Depending on the contract, some vendors are obliged to use consultants with a minimum of BS. It doesn't matter how good you are, how many years experience, or how many certifications you have. In many government contracts, if you don't have that BS it's a waste of time to apply.

by burkey

I have, several times, pondered this point as well. I have an Assoc. Degree and debate on the next goal as being a Bachelor's Degree or certifications. Obviously, TalkingWall has a good point in the degree getting one the much needed credibility to "open the door" with opportunities like government contracts.

I have opted, for me, to go with the certifications. One reason being that I have limited time available with a family & more work than I can handle at work and as a freelancer on the side. Certifications seems to be the quickest bang for my time and bucks. I hire people at my job and put more stock in certifications in relevant technologies than theory classes in a classroom. That's just me though.

So, I'll keep an eye on this thread and hope to gain some insight myself from your answers to your question.

by dinotech

...the reason why I like certifications better than the Bachelor's. First, I spent three years at a college that really did nothing for me except give me a fat loan. Sure, some of it was my own doing: I never was good at school, and have a learning disorder which I have treated. So now the question is: do I get myself in more debt, or do I go after certifications like A+, Network+ which I have skills that will help in my study.

Employers want quantity as well as quality and I have proven that I can troubleshoot computers and networks to a certain point. Now my objective is to further that point and work my way into Network Admin or Engineering.

by prefbid ii

The answer depends on what you intend to accomplish. Are you looking to make a quick buck or do you have some long term goal in mind? Do you want to stay in the hardware, network, system administration side or will you want to change to programming at some point? Do you ever want to go into management?

The certs are good for the sys admin, network, and hardware careers. For everything else you need the BS (any discipline, CS is not required).

by xxx_his_royal_badness_xxx

I am using my certificates to continue with my bs.
How ?
I am undergoing a 1 year program which will allow me to get my mcse , network+ , and a+ certs then i am gonna use these credits to apply online to the uni of phoenix to get my bs in IT

Ithought sum certs here and there r good but why not shoot for the bull's eye if I can use the credits to get my bs .

Hope that helped .

by ghstinshll

Dino,

Take the certs yourself, set up a lab in your dorm with that $5k, don't throw it away with New Horizons, and rock out the MCSE on your own! With 5k you can set up your own network segment at school and do all this while in college. The best path for any MIS major is while in college, to complete whatever career path certifications you can while in school. This will show you have the experience in a real scenario to land a job when you start looking. Too many MIS majors come out and can't land good jobs because of a lack of experience, you're smart enough for even thinking abotu this, now go for it!

Due to lack of space in college, I suggest buying a few book-pc profile systems and a KVM switch and one good monitor so that you don't have to have everything strung around your apt or dorm.

Jason Williamson

by tc(uk)

I have MCSE, MCNE and CNE certifications. I also have an MSc and plan to let my certifications lapse when they come up for renewal. Obtaining a good degree either at under graduate (BSc/BA/BS) or post graduate (MSc / MA / MBA) holds far more value than the vendor alternatives. Unfortunately from my experience the vendor certifications have lost creditability within the market place.

by sounds57

In my experince, the only certs that menan anything in today's job market is the MCSE, Novell, Unix, and Cisco certs. You shoud go for your MS or Docorate in IS while sudying on the side for the certs that you want to aquire. I have the A+ cert andall the venders I interveiwed with do not know what this cert even covered, plus about 90% of these venders had never heard about the A+ cert before the interveiw with me.

by manxman

I would recommend finishing your degree first. I didi it the other way around, year full time college apprenticeship in network admin with mcse as qualification at the end, then got my ccna, cna security+ and landed a good job. I am now studying for a BA in IT and European Studies (foreign languages are a BIG plus in Europe in any sector!) and must admit, although still enjoying greatly, it is distance study alongside a full time network admin job (which is very demanding). The certs are all obtainable with home study( 2 pcs and a switch can be picked up real cheap nowadays)and not as demanding as university study. I would therefore recommend finishing your Bachelor and then go for the certs. At the end of the day, a Bachelor without work experience will probably land you a job more quickly than Certs without work experience.

Good luck whichever way you go.

by timwalsh

Need for a lab: The Win2K MCSE is much harder to achieve without hands-on experience than the NT4 MCSE. The question of whether to invest the time and money in putting a lab together depends on whether you just want to pass a test, or do you want to be able to do the job.

If you have already a good start on your degree work, I would continue with the flow and complete it, maybe trying to complete your MCSE a test at a time as time permits. Or maybe dedicate part of one of your summers (ora spring or winter break) to getting a certification. Many of the concepts that you learn in one set of curricula may be relevant to the other.

Both a degree and certifications will be important for a long-term IT career. View the certifications as proof of your technical abilities and view your degree as a necessary stepping stone for future advancement. Which one to get first is merely a function of time available.

by robotech

Didn't graduate because of lack of funds, and still paying off my college loan. Fortunately I have only one semester left to pay off. How am I surviving without a degree? I am an MCP, and I have tons of experience because I always had a network setup in my home practicing stuff. Most people don't care if you have a Degree here in FL. The question is, can you do this? Have you done this before?
At ITT we did Windows NT 4.0 at the time, but our lecturer was smart enough to mix in Windows 2000, which was quite new at the time. We also did VB 6.0, now VB.NET is taking over.
From personal experience, I suggest you save the money for student loans etc, and invest in a good home network.
Try getting the following:
1. A decent Windows 2003 Server
2. A decent LINUX server (this can come later).
3. Windows XP workstation, one each for wife, kid etc.
4. A laptop for yourself.
5. Try getting a used CISCO router from an auction. eBay etc.
6. D-Link Cable/DSL router with VPN.
7. PCMCIA wireless card for your laptop.
8. D-LINK wireless access point.

Get your MCP in XP Pro first and or ?Installing and Configuring a Windows 2003 Server?. Read the book(s) cover to cover and practice the stuff with your hardware. Then go for the CCNA.
After that, complete the other exams for the MCSE or MCSA, but this time don't read the books cover to cover. Do the trial exams on the CD that comes with the book, make a note of what you didn't understand, and then go on your network to practice it. This should reduce the time required to get the MCSE/MCSA.

Before the three years run out, get your CCNP, which will revalidate your CCNA. Keep up to date with emerging technologies, and do the single exam to maintain you CCNP before it lapses. Only get MCSA/MCSE upgrades if the market requires it.
Finally, each time you pass an exam, buy your wife a gift (clothes are a good idea). Spend time with your family and don't worry about degrees. The technology changes too fast, by the time you graduate half of the stuff is almost obsolete. I know tons of people who got BSC's and MSC's years ago, now they can't even open control panel or write a decent program in VB.

by mlayton

...only you can answer some questions about your long-term goals. Keep in mind that while certifications expire, degrees don't. If your long-term goal is upper management, even if it years away, but you have the time to finish your degree now, do it. Going back in 5 or ten years is much more difficult, you won't be at the same place in your life. Many employers look for degrees (any discipline), because they show the ability to follow instructions, reading/writing/presenting skills, ability to commit to a long-term goal, ability to work individually on research, or in a group (that would depend some on the program you are in) and lots of other "soft skills" that don't come assumed with certifications. If you are worried about technology changing, think about finishing with a focus on business, communications, or another widely-applied throughout the business world subject. Keep in mind that understanding of basic business tenets: accounting, finance, project management, hr, even legal will help any IT organization which you join be better able to serve their internal customers when you understand their pain points and can relate. Staying in school may also provide lab environment opportunities, and I have had good experiences with teaming/study groups going for the same certifications within school environments - being able to share resources goes a long way. Of course, if you already have credits and are close to finishing, you can ideally find a job with tuition reimbursement that can assist in finishing for you. Good luck!

by robotech

Do your Network +, it's a lifetime cert. CCNA only lasts three years (it used to be six). It can also go to college credits. Technical colleges tend to respect certs more than traditional Universities, so acquire the necessary certs, utilize your job to go on as necessary seminars and courses as possible. Present these to the University and try exemption exams.
If you writea technical newsletter etc. that can also be a big plus (no pun intended).

by chris.mcguire

The correct answer is whatever makes you the most motivated to achieve your goal. If you have the time to get a degree, than why not? A degree will never hurt you or expire. It will open many doors for you.
Having said that.....if time is an important consideration in your decision than you should definatly work towards your certifications as those can be completed in months not years. Most New Horizions locations have programs that will also provide you with paid internships with employers in your area. Certifications are not easy, neither are degrees.

This discussion is closed to new replies.