Discussion Locked

TR - password requests - do we flame OR take the blame?

0 helpful
135 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I for one, as a relative newcomer, am surprised that a forum such as this can have so much disagreement over a single subject.

By far, the single most frequently requested information, is for the bypass of either BIOS or Administrator passwords. These requests are to varying degrees either blatantly illegal or flowery woeful cries for help.

Nevertheless they all require one or more of us to risk everything to answer the posted question.

Instead of ripping each other apart for being sarcastic, or not being understanding enough, or not being nice to the li'l ol' lady - we either agree to agree or agree to differ.

I for one will continue to view these particular requests with the eye of one who has personally lost over ?4,000 in stolen laptops over a one-year-period, including having to become a litigator in order to get a hotel owner into the British Court System to sue for having no insurance cover. My demeanour in this instance is clearly tarnished but it brings an unsavoury taste to my mouth when I read these woefully ill-written tales of hardship.

It is time to stand up and be counted. No secret ballot for this topic. How do you stand?

135 replies

by locrian_lyric

As one who has had to clean up systems after script kiddies have hacked into them, I will not give ANY advice with regards to hacking passwords UNLESS:

I know the person and know they won't do damage.

OR

The person has been a member for a considerable amount of time. Sorry kiddies, no one-day passes to learn how to crack.

AND...

any and all information I disclose will be through private email and not on a board where any idiot with half a brain and a desire to cause mischief can get at it.

SERIOUSLY folks!

If someone came in here and posted...

"Hi, I need instructions on how to build an explosive device, I have a tree stump on my property that I wish to remove"...

Would you give them instructions, or would you think that such information just might not be a good idea to post publicly?

by shellbot

I do have a tree stump I'd like to remove from my ex's property. How about posting those instructions.. it may be a delicate operation as his car is right next to it..but i'll be careful, i promise ]:)

by deadly ernest

Drill a hole through the middle of the stump; get a long high strength wire rope; feed rope through hole; attach different ends of rope to the tow points under the back of ex's vehicle. Next time he drives out, his car will pull the stump out of the ground for you. If it's not powerful enough, then the tow truck that he calls to tow his car away will surely do the job.

by locrian_lyric

Under certain conditions, It's been known to have explosive properties. It is also known as "the universal solvent", and I can assure you that there would be no legal ramifications for using it to remove a stump.

by deadly ernest

contact your local pyrotechnician to do this for you, as they'll have the licence needed to buy the explosive materials.

by locrian_lyric

I am assuming that many of us here have a working knowledge of basic chemistry.

Forgive me if I sound condescending, it is not intentional.

If someone came on a site and asked how to build a bomb, (including asking about chemical formulae) I wouldn't give them advice, as I am sure, nobody else would.

When anyone answers those hack questions, they are essentially doing the same thing.

by sleepin'dawg

the necessary materials under your kitchen sink or in your garage. If not, a quick trip to the nursery for some high nitrate fertilizer or to the pharmacy and you should be able to take out half your neighbourhood in one go.

I've actually used fertilizer to remove stumps but for a real bang and you really want to have fun, try mixing it with furnace oil. That's the terrorists favourite homebrew for explosives. Mind you, if you aren't careful and don't know what you are doing, they'll be picking up bits and pieces of you all over the place. Sad to say, anyone with a few highschool chemistry courses under their belts could be capable of doing this. The instructions are available over the net. BTW you can create quite a blast in your toilet by pouring in bleach and certain toilet cleaners. If that doesn't get your ass blown away the fume are highly toxic and could asphyxiate or poison you.

Cheers and sleep well tonite. B-) ;) :^0

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by shellbot

No way am i helping someone crack into a PC.
Big problem over here with laptop thefts..no way am i going to be party to that.

At the end of the day, if you've a genuine need for it, take it somewhere for some support.

by raymond danner

Seriously, have had occasion one time to need to break an XP admin password. The client had purchased the machine used, and the previous owner had been dimwitted enough not to give him the password to the only account on the box. Thus, I broke out the proper software (AFTER the client left the box with me) and (after the software did its thing) passworded the thing the way he needed it.

by deadly ernest

the seller should have provided the software discs as well, thus the password isn't needed - just format C: and a clean install of the software. And if the software discs aren't supplied, the software should be removed as it's now pirate.

Since it's new to the new owner, he shouldn't have any concerns re any old data from the previous owner.

by deadly ernest

First, let me say I see a big difference between the need for a BIOS password reset and an Administrator password work around.

BIOS
I've frequently come across the need to reset BIOS passwords because someone bought a second hand PC and the BIOS has a password on it, you need to get around this to install new hardware; or it was put on by the etch at the place of purchase and they don't know it. In most cases this is simply done by resetting the BIOS - just about every motherboard manufacturer will tell you how to do this if you ask them. It's also in the manual which can be obtained from their web sites. I always recommend people go to the web site for the relevant motherboard manufacturer as there's over 80 different ways of doing this that I've come across.

This only affects the ability to adjust the BIOS. A frequent problem for people with legitimate requests in this area.

ADMINISTRATOR PASSWORDS
I NEVER give advice on how do get around administrator passwords as I've never come across a legitimate reason for this where the password isn't known. If the person is the legitimate owner, they know it - if it's not working then a clean install is needed. If they've forgotten it and can prove to me they own the system and the data (they better have a valid receipt with the bloody serial number on it, for starters) - then there's things I can do to rescue most of their data. In every case, I'll go on to format the drive and reinstall the operating system, adding a new administrator account and password for myself. next time they mess up, I get in using that account.

Every work situation I've been in, the IT section has set each machine up with a special administrator password that's known to all who have a need to get in at that level. If a user needs administrator capability, they set up a user account with administrator privileges and let them set their own password for it.

In essence, I see anyone asking for an Administrator password work around as either a crook trying to crack into a stolen computer; or an employee trying to get access to a section of the computer denied to them; or a silly fool whose messed up their system big time and didn't set up a back door access, in which case, they're only going to mess it up further - they should take it to a true professional and have them fix it properly by saving the data and doing a clean install.

by Former member

I have helped many families over the years who: 1) bought a computer frm someone, who set an admin password and didn't chage it or share it. 2) Had a kid who while messing around set a password they didn't remember the next day. 3) Had a parent who while messing around set a password and forgot it.

by jamesrl

You know the families.

We don't know these people asking for the same assistance, most of them create a membership and ask the question on the same day. That looks pretty suspicious.

James

by pser

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=101&threadID=227277&messageID=2263466

This is an example of someone who may or may have not been a real person with a real problem, granted a "User problem", but a problem none the less. Yes, there are those that are so blatantly obvious as to NOT be worthy of an response at all. However, to make the claim that everyone who has ever come to me at work or in my personal life or even on TR, with the "I forgot my PW" line is deserving of nothing but contempt and humiliation because they MUST be up to "no good" ... is just ridicules!

Like I said there are the obvious "trolls" ... solution ... IGNORE. Those not so "obvious" deserve no less than the benefit of the doubt of an honest person with an honest problem. Being the "professionals" so many claim to be ... we should be able to determine the validity and intentions of the poster with some simple questions and or statements. You can do this in a manner that is non offensive ... more of a query, if you will. (See NN and Col's responses in the link) From there help may or may not be able to be given to help resolve this persons issue without ever giving out any information as to "how to crack a pw" (which I do NOT condone under any circumstances ... period).

If any or all of you feel the need to open up a six pack of flame brew on any and everybody who has the word 'Password' in their post ... then by all means, have at it. Maybe you're just saying what you'd like to be able to say to your own customers but can't, maybe it makes you feel superior, maybe your just venting frustrations, maybe its therapeutic, who knows. What I do know ... there are plenty of things, people, perspectives both political and personal, as well as all kinds of subject matter here at TR for people to use as their "outlet" for "flaming". Most of the time flames are an accepted/expected part of any "Discussion". Flaming a "Question" ... bad form. IMHO.

by nentech

of the computer should know all the user names and passwords

I always tell them what names or passwords I have left on the machine

I always show them how to change both

But that?s just my opinion

by deadly ernest

but I make sure they know it's there as a backdoor to get in and fix things AFTER they've manage to cause problems with their main access and request they don't change it, unless they're happy to have to totally rebuild the system again. Most don't, they know I can't access their system unless I'm in their house, so it's not a worry. And if the change password and can't give it to me - then the cost escalates very quickly.

by captbilly1eye

The tact I will take from now on will be different.

Until now, I responded to TR visitor requests for password help and BIOS resets based on their supplied information. Giving special consideration to those that stated it is their system or a similar seemingly legit request.
I had decided they could be supplied links to information or links to retail products for assistance.
The premise being - how they ultimately use the product is up to them. If they misrepresented their intent to obtain information and advise and then use that for ill gains, then they are the ones who are liable.
I saw this as different then actually providing them with the steps or walking them through the actual process of clearing or changing passwords.

However, I now believe [b]that thinking follows a line of indifference rather than one of professional discretion and concern.[/b]

I heard what you and others have said and I too will stay on the side of prudence, ignoring such requests in the future.

But forgive me the occasional head-shaking comment on the blatant ones. ...or using the spam button. ;)

by shellbot

to our side..it didn't take long, it never does..eventually the smart ones see it our way.

Don't ask who "we" are..I can't tell you..

by jdclyde

Bios, if they are to stupid and/or lazy to contact the manufacturer, they do not DESERVE the answer, even if it is their legal system.

Admin password request, are almost never valid.

Mind you, I am bummed that I wasn't able to do a password reset on an NT4 system I got as a hand-me-down because my utility would not boot the raid5. Sure, it is going to be wiped and reloaded with linux, but I like to get into the system and look at the devices and make a list FIRST, just in case plug and pray doesn't recognize something correctly. If I really decide I want in, I would peer Col or someone, not put it out here for every stupid kid to see.

I am finishing up a degree, and it amazes me just how many stupid kids there are out there. Stupid and lazy. If you can't even check google first, you do not deserve anything but scorn and ridicule. B-) No spoon feeding here.

by bogdan.botezatu

As a newbie here, I don't quite know all the features implemented in this software, so I'd ask someone more experienced to wake the sleeping polls. My question is: "Do we keep on providing support for issues on the edge of hacking, or not?". If the majority decides "no", we should delete the flaming posts and wash our hands off. In fact, Google is full of hacking and cracking crap; let's keep a healthy community here at TR.

by deadly ernest

In most jurisdictions, you do need a licence once you make up a mix that has significant explosive potential. However, I'm aware there's a number of household and farm products you can buy without an explosives licence that can be used to cook up chemical bombs.

And anyone who isn't a reasonably good chemist and wants to do that - I suggest you get some good medical and funeral insurance first. I've seen what can happen if you make a little mistake doing that.

Years ago, I used to help family blowing up rabbit burrows on their farm with fertiliser bombs. We'd mix the material and use half plugs of gelignite and detonator cord to set them off. But we did it under the supervision of a licenced pyrotechnician - we wanted to get involved making big bangs, but weren't stupid.

by locrian_lyric

What I'm trying to say is that if someone has sinister motives, such legalities won't impede him...

Gee, I was going to do something malicious with this bomb, but I don't have a licence, oh darn...

Still, I won't give them the recipes.

by deadly ernest

need a licence if you're actually legit - many people think because you bought the components without a licence, you don't need one when you mix them - that's wrong in most areas.

We all know people committing crimes aren't going to worry about that.

On a related aspect - I know someone who's very experienced with home made chemical bombs (paid for by the government - he has to defuse the buggers) who looked up a few of the ones that are posted on the Internet. He showed me two and laughed. They gave explicit instructions on how to make very strong home made chemical bombs from everyday ingredients; and if you followed the instructions faithfully (as they tell you to do) you'll get blown up by it about two thirds of the way through making your bomb. he wondered if someone posted those instructions as a way of cleansing the gene pool of idiot bombers.

by shellbot

my experience here at TR for the past couple of years has been that no hack requests were answered with anything other than contempt..
a few of the newbies have posted some hack solutions recently, but they disappeared pretty quick..

(yee gods its been that long already...where has all that time gone??)

by tig2

Then slap Palmetto. For some odd reason he likes that.

The people that answer password hack questions with anything other than sarcasm do not show me anything but a glimpse of their own idiocy. A professional will not choose to risk their career like that. People talk and all that.

by w2ktechman

I sometimes choose to let them know about tools such as ERD Commander, which are expensive and will usually throw them off a bit. I do not bring up free hack tools though.
ERD is now owned by MS, and it hacks their product, so this is the tool that I may recommend. If MS sells it to them it is on them, not me.
Aside from that, yes, I agree.

by charliespencer

I've got to upgrade this helmet to Kevlar.

I should ignore them. I'm able to ignore some of them. But some of the stories are so obviously bogus and insulting to my intelligence that they encourage me to indulge my smart-@ss streak. Who do they think they're fooling? Other are just so blatantly malicious they invite me to unload the day's frustrations.

Nuke 'em. Nuke 'em 'til they glow, then you can shoot 'em in the dark. I'm sorry, but use of the words "hack", "crack" or "administrator password" wave a red flag in front of this fat bull's eyes. So does a request for this information with a date that matches the "Member since" date, especially when combined with a web-based mail address posted in the clear but a conflicting refusal to accept peer messages. As I recently replied to one of these requests, "Would you join a hunting club and immediately ask about the best shotgun to use on bald eagles?"

by hal 9000

And wanted directions on how to bypass a Password that the person who they loaned the NB to had added. I said something about returning it to a service center and that he had to realize that a person placed this there and to ask them for the password. I tried to make out that it wasn't the computers fault but his as he didn't want to pay for the recovery but expected to get this for free and thought that it was his right.

While I didn't directly Flame him he took it that way and seemed to get very upset claiming that I was bad for TR and was driving people away in droves.

Now that I think about it every answer that he supplied made me more and more suspicious he had apparently taken the unit to a shop and didn't want to pay the money and had a evil girlfriend or something. [i]Steffi must have hit him really hard and taken him down and he was still suffering.[/i] :^0

Anyway from my prospective were I'm held legally libel for helping thief's I see [b]Big Red Flags Waved[/b] whenever the words NB, Student, Crack, Hack, I don't Want to Pay to have this fixed are used and avoid answering questions.

Now all I need is to find that Thread after a really bad day for some Therapy. :D

Col

by steffi28

Why did it have to be me who hit him!

And I didnt like the way you said red flags wave when you hear the word student! You know I still have a year left at uni :(

by locrian_lyric

I started precisely one arguement, unintentionally and have apologized for it.

The principles in the arguement have let it drop. Please do the same.

Thank you.

by locrian_lyric

If you, or some of the other regulars I TRUST asked me, I'd send you an email telling you how to do it or where to go to get the tools to do it.

Some newbie with a born-on date of today, NEVER.

by mjd420nova

I've held off on weighing on this and can't any longer. I have cracked many passwords and disabled units by pulling the batteries and such to get beyond forgotten passwords or unavailable users. Some units are left when an employee quits and this is the most common. Mind you this is all on site and under contract. Over a forum or discussion site, I just refrain, especially when I see a members joined date of the same day. Too many laptops are getting ripped off and this would be an easy way for a thief to get into anothers unit. I don't jump or run, just bypass the request. There are so many others who would begin the routine of flaming and taunts but I try to stay above that. There is no hard and fast rule. Many long time members of TR are above these approaches and will not offer to help, as it should be. More members of long standing know how this is done and are not being selfish just protective of others property. The same would apply to knowing how to use a jimbar to unlock a car door without a key. None are the same from model to model and it takes intimate knowledge to get past the pitfalls and achieve success. Passing that knowledge on is one thing and could be interpreted as illegal. We all must live with these decisions, right or wrong.

by Former member

I think yours is a good approach.
When I was a wee lad, like most little boys, I was curious about things that went boom. I actually had a teacher that gave me a rudimentary education in explosive devices, along with a substantial education in responsible use of that knowledge. He could have not said anyhting, and that probably would have been an acceptable approach as well, though it wouldn't have satisfied my curiosity. He could have derided me and treated me like a delinquent as well... Pretty sure that would have just made me angry, and more determined to get info. I grew up in an area that attracted quite a few loonies of the kkk-and-derivatives persuasion. I'm sure they would have been more than happy to educate me - sans the responsible use part...
Treat a person like a criminal, and they just might become one.

by jamesrl

Your teacher knew you - knew your charecter.

Do you think you could have walked onto an army base, or into the chem lab in a university and asked them to teach you about blowing stuff up? Why not?

James

by Former member

stops you to ask a question do you immediately taze them, just in case they are a mugger?

by locrian_lyric

says "Tell me how to pick a lock, I need to get into my car"

I would hardly teach him, nor would I help him pick a lock.

by Former member

You would politely decline, rather than kicking them in the dangly bits?
that's fair...

by locrian_lyric

but I would nonetheless decline.

To further the analogy...

I'm in a neighborhood where there have been a rash of car thefts. The prefered method is to pick the locks...

there is trust, and there is being naive.

by mdphoenix

No way. They can go find it elsewhere. There's the underground of the Internet. They can find everything they need there. They can spend the money on legitimate software if they want to hack someone's computer. I won't help. Period.

by w2ktechman

if the stump is large, and he speeds off, it might just wreck his car...

Wait, I do not think that Shell would mind soo much.

by w2ktechman

Although I have started a 2 parter response. The first post is to address the proper way to deal with it (call support, take it to a shop, etc.). The second post is marked to read the first post, and if they still want to hack away, then continue.
The hack basically tells them (in a nice way) how to destroy their keyboard, monitor, HDD, and then electrocute themselves.
yes therapeutic....

by jdclyde

when they use words like "hack" and "crack", it shows their intent.

If someone is looking to "recover", and is more than a fly-by-night member, they would probably get their answer in a peer message.

When it is a bios password, and they [b]refuse[/b] to contact the vendor/manufacturer, it points to it being a stolen system, and again, worthy of only contempt, scorn and flames.

by pser

I am right there with you about the "hack" and "crack" key words.

"If someone is looking to "recover", and is more than a fly-by-night member, they would probably get their answer in a peer message."

First, let's hope if they're more than a fly by night member ... they would not NEED a solution to such a problem. But say they did, how long do you have to be a member before they are out of "FBN" status? Who approves such status?

As far as refusing to contact the vendor/manufacturer. That would seem to imply ulterior motives. Otherwise they would do whatever they could to "recover". So, again, right there with you.

However, in this case, the OP did NOT use the words Hack, Crack, or even Recover. Hmmm, maybe words a USER would not think to use?? Maybe?

I dunno, being SO willing and quick to be the "virtual" judge, jury, and executioner of someone asking a "Question" on a Forum ... in the "Question" area ... is just not my bag.

Chew 'em up and spit 'em out boys and girls! After all, they deserve it for being SOOOOO STUPID, don't they?

by jdclyde

The last one I saw specifically was asking to hack admin password.

How long? Just like in the meat world, people have to EARN trust. If they have not EARNED that trust, they do not deserve it. Would you lend your car to someone you just me?

There is also the old smell test. If it doesn't smell right, you refuse to answer. If it smells bad, you need to take out the trash.

Another little test is to see how they respond to the first few posts, provided they respond at all. If they start throwing around insults, again, it puts them in doubt. When you walk in with your hat in your hand asking someone else to give you something for free, they need to learn to be respectful, just like anywhere else in the world.

Being on the net does not excuse bad behavior.

I firmly disagree that we should flame someone based on limited english.

by deadly ernest

the vendor / manufacturer. Here's a few obvious ones.

1. They don't have the information on their website and they don't answer any tech questions unless you pay them.

2. No answer on the web site, and the only contact info is to call them - and they're on another continent - expensive man, expensive.

3. They don't have a web site and you can't find any contact details for them. usually because they went out of business. OK, this is more like they refuse to be contacted, than refusing to contact them.

by pser

I stand corrected on this point, and a big DUH on my part ... I've dealt with all three of your scenarios!

Yet more examples of "why" someone not "Technical" would come to a Tech. site for Q&A without knowing the "Proper" techie speak to keep them from being toasted.

Stupid Bastards, they should have known better than that ...

Thank you sir!

by charliespencer

Can these be achieved at standard temperature and pressure? I realize it's a highly dangerous chemical, but the industry has apparently kept is quiet about the explosive hazards.

by hal 9000

At that point it becomes dangerous. But the same is true for anything I've seen the results of one Blonde and a bag of flour over a Gas Stove.

She Instantly Remodeled the new kitchen that she had just had installed. [i][b]Note[/b] to Shelly here keep Steffi out of your Kitchen if you want it to remain sort of like it used to be.[/i] :^0

Col

by steffi28

I can cook, kinda, almost, ok not really but still...

unfair!! :(

Especially as I've only set the kitchen on fire 3 times! :p

by Member 25348569

One of the most entertaining science lessons that we ever had was a visiting lecturer who was an expert on explosions.

One of the things that he did was to seal a small, ~5ml, glass vial of dihydrogen monoxide and suspend it in a candle flame. Ten minutes after the start of the lecture, the explosion woke EVERYBODY up and five of my classmates had to go out and change their underwear...

So, at standard temperature and pressure, no. But you CAN make it explode.

Be aware that the explosion at Karakatoa was mostly caused by the rapid vapourisation of Dihydrogen monoxide.

You have been warned!

Neil :D

by charliespencer

The dihydrogen monoxide didn't explode. It changed states of mass, increased in pressure, and the vial couldn't take the stress. You could say it erupted, like Krakatoa, but it didn't explode. No chemical changes occurred, and the dihydrogen monoxide remained as deadly after the "explosion" as before.

by locrian_lyric

They placed a small amount of pure DHMO in a microwave for several minutes, then introduced a non-reactive forign body.

DHMO was so unstable at this point that it did in fact explode.

by Former member

Day 2 of class.
And my point: helping responsibly OR quietly not helping are both reasonable strategies. 'Flaming' or treating like a criminal - not so much.

by w2ktechman

The first part is valid responses, like sending it to a tech, purchasing ERD commander, calling the company, etc.

Then at the bottom, I put, if you just want to hack/crack the PW, read my next post.

The next post says to read the first before continuing, and if they are certain that they just want to hack/crack then continue. Then it goes into getting a second HDD and destroying it, destroying their keyboard, poking a hole in their monitor, wiping their HDD, and finally electrocuting themselves.

by mjwx

The people who generally post here asking on how to crack passwords know a little about the subject but not enough to teach themselves. So for this reason I'm biased, that people asking for passwords are just script kiddies or other such degenerates who want this information for malicious purposes.

I'm not unsympathetic to the plight of someone who has legitimately lost a password. In that event I tell them to seek a professional data recovery service who can get their password for a fee. This has the side effect of helping them to remember their password because it costs them money to recover it.

This being said, I am not normally involved in such discussions (I have been involved in a few) and find that weather or not to answer these "requests" to be question of ethics. on an open forum, anyone could read this information and use it for illegitimate purposes. As for the flaming, most of the requests are written in poor English and utilize language that indicates they have a malicious intent (using "crack" as opposed to recover etc), I think we should not spare these people.

by jdclyde

and one I follow in most cases when it comes to end users.

The easier it is to resolve an issue from a user doing a process wrong, the less likely they will learn the correct way to do it. Who cares if the techs have to go through hoops to fix it? "I got my crap done and have moved on with my life!" You will see this from the users that do the same mistake on a regular basis because it isn't their problem.

If it is a hassle, they WILL learn the simple process, because it will benefit THEM. The more "punishment" or negative effects of doing something incorrect, the less likely they will do that same thing again.

On a side job, it cost the user $80 because he didn't know his password for his email, and he was unable to follow the tech support from his IP provider. I wrote it down, and he WILL have that on hand the next time he needs it. A dumb reason to fork out almost $100.

by deadly ernest

at least two meals - ring up for delivery pizza and ring up for delivery chinese take away; some areas have more options due to more delivery services.

by hal 9000

Never open a packet of this while there is a naked flame in the kitchen under any circumstances. :^0 :D :^0

Shelly you'll have to be very careful and refuse to allow Steffi into your Kitchen if you ever arrange a visit. Similarly you'll have to avoid hers. :D

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

Neils description is mild compared to what water can do in a similar situation. This is what makes Nuclear Facilities so dangerous the fact that the fuel can melt down proceed through the concrete floor and keeps going down till it hits the ground water and then [b]All Hell Breaks Loose.[/b]

But back when I was at High School I used to spend way too much time in the Chem Lab and make my own explosives. Some were incredibly dangerous but still easy to make. What can I say I like big bangs and when Guy Fawkes night was removed from the calender here I had to make my own Play Toys! :D

Col

by pser

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=101&threadID=227277&messageID=2263466

Of this "Question" which spurred 'Old M' into starting this thread. This is where it all started. Then the next day (or maybe the same) an obvious attempt to get "cracking pw" knowledge, inspired 'bogdan' to post this link as a response because he assumed we ALL gave out this kind of info. to whomever asked. (BTW: bogdan, you were "wrong")

Your 4th paragraph hit this nail on the head.

Last line ... I am glad you do not "flame" based on limited English. Did I imply that you did? I don't think I did but If so, that was not my intent and I apologize. I could not agree more with you here as well...

by nicknielsen

I don't usually flame this kind of request, but do let the requester know that he/she/it will not receive much assistance from this site.

I have to be in the mood to flame; usually I'll have had a d'ay! at work and will need to vent. (Note that "d'ay!" is usually pronounced the way HE would pronounce it: http://tinyurl.com/3a4uxr)

The wording also makes a difference. The "I loosed my password help me crack!" request is much more likely to get flames from me than the "Here's the situation, can anybody help?" request.

by nentech

occurred in the flame
This flame tranfered energy to the glass and its contents
explode or erupt may depend in the direction
not the cause
dihydogen monoxide can be dangerous at low temperature
I would not like to be surrounded by it when its very cold :(
I also try to avoid contact with the crystal stage as well B-)

by absolutely

The best general process I know to decide actions while uncertain is to consider the worst case scenario, for each type of possible error.

In this case, if I hit "Report as spam" on a question that is legitimate, the person who asked can still appeal to the Management, who I have seen to be pretty agreeable about what is "spam" so far.

If I don't hit "Report as spam" on a question that is not legitimate, I effectively encourage more BS on a site that has been enjoyable to me, thus encouraging its demise.

by nentech

Thankyou for that

But it would be best to ask a question first
And see what answer you get

Some people may have the wrong idea about something
That does not mean they have nothing of value to offer

We all must make our own decision about each reply or post

Again Thankyou for your input

by older mycroft

My original stance was set out in plain terms at the first post.

I have read with interest, the multitude of responses and have taken on-board some ideas that I had not, previously given, any degree of thought to.

I find myself viewing the situation from an ever-so-slightly different viewpoint now.

My initial response will now be more inquisitorial, but my Railgun will still be to hand, for the flaming response as and when it befits the situation.

Thank you all.

by charliespencer

The flame underwent a chemical change. The dihydrogen monoxide neither underwent a chemical change nor exploded.

I seen examples of road and pavement damage caused by naturally occurring dihydrogen monoxide transitioning from a liquid to crystalline form.

by jdclyde

PSer, sorry I didn't clarify. The part about limited English, while in post that does reply to you, was not directed to you, but a side note.

In the most recent "help me hack" earlier this week, someone (don't remember who, doesn't matter) was going off on how they deserved to be flamed because of their use of the English language.

I said something then, but added it in my last post because I was listing reasons to or not to flame/help. So it fit my list, but should have clarified that it wasn't directed at you.

My error. Sorry about that.

[i]
oh, I agree with me too..... ;\

by deadly ernest

sarcastic comes from sarcasm, correct -

sar is the short form of search and rescue -

chasm is a large tear like hole in the ground -

tic is a very small insect -

so sarcastic should be a very small insect the search and rescue people throw into a large hole in the ground to search for people down in it. is that right shell?

NB: I noticed TR have stopped us playing that little trick to add a level - I got a lovely little message, see below, when I tried this just now.

"You cannot reply to this message.

Go back to message."

by pser

I am not worthy ... I am merely a novice compared to most of you guys and gals. No offense meant, I hear you're a lovely person ... with a BIG shovel. So, again, no offense meant! :)

by pser

Old M! Good on ya and this was a very fruitful thread.

Glad you'll be keeping your phaser on 'stun' until a 'kill' setting is necessary/required.

Take care!

by pser

Shovel ... virus ... it's so hard to remember which female members to fear and for which reasons.

But like I said ... they are ALL lovely people!

Is there a "suck up" emoticon? I have a feeling I am going to need it! :)

by nentech

The disks are important but they are not licences
Just to let you know
What you may already know

by nentech

I had just come from the discussion about Muslims and was in safe mode

?Again Thankyou for your input?

Was not the best way to thank him

I would like to see one or two people take point when it comes to passwords

Let them ask the questions

Then wait some time to see what the replies are like

The questions about passwords are not discussions

The replies should be confined to questions
Then suggestions

Until we know better
Then look out

by tig2

The password "questions" that the OP files as a discussion?

Burned once is too many times. I don't want to be forced to turn off peer mail. So I take the "no" road. And until someone can validate another approach, I will stick to that.

How do I know that the querent is not someone trying to hack to the private information on my servers?

by nentech

That make the difference

Good starts are

1. Why don?t you know the password?
2. How would you feel if I helped someone steal your information?
3. How do I know if you own the computer it could be stolen I need proof
4. Do you know that what you ask may be illegal?
5. I need proof that you have the right to access the computer

Just some
Lay it on heavy
Legal stuff is good

If they still don?t get it
Ask them if they would be willing to give their name and home address
So you can ask the police to check that they are not breaking the law
Tell them not to post it but to contact you by peer mail
Remind them about identity theft

This will scare off the nasties

Edited to add this

One thing that may work is the suggestion
You can contact Microsoft for help

by w2ktechman

I would make some nasty comments, but I am not in the mood for it right now...
In any event, yes, they are lovely -- and with big hooters...
:)

by tig2

Most of us disregard the "suck up" emoticon. JD uses it WAY too frequently!

On a more serious note-

I got my hat handed me when I suggested to a "one day wonder" that he take his issue to the manufacturer and then tried to explain that no one on this site would help him crack a password. I had already had the experience where I responded the exact same way to a poster (whose peer mail was disabled) and was treated to a 2 week spamming of my email demanding that I help him and threatening me with violence if I did not.

The thread went over 300 posts- people threatening to leave TR because of me, my tone wasn't correct, people read into my post what they wanted. Supporters tried to stem the tide, but in the end, even Jay (Trivia Geek, now Jay Garmon) took sides against me in his blog. Yes, Jay. I read it. I may have saved it, I would have to look. But I can recite it.

I still insist on telling people to contact the manufacturer. I won't do pass recovery for someone I don't know. I DO now suggest that they Google for assistance.

Flames? You and I know that when the subject matter is heated, the exchange may be as well. We are adults and we get past those moments. Would I gratuitously flame one? I may have done when I had more time on my hands. These days I am so busy that I can't expend the brain power.

We get all kinds here. We hope to keep the ones that have a real interest. But the cell phone spammers and script kiddies need to understand the nature of this particular beast.

Just remember to slap Palmetto. He like that for some odd reason.