Discussion Locked

Ubuntu Linux - It Just Works... well, except for that.... and that... and..

0 helpful
185 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I mean, it is free, right?

Seriously... I've called Ubuntu on this before around here, and I always get the response,

"Well, you have to..."

Listen... that isn't "It JUST works". That is, "It WILL work, if YOU tweak with it".

XP "Just Works". OS X actually "Just Works".

Ubuntu is Linux, and Linux doesn't "Just Work".

Interestingly enough, again, this is a laptop where Ubuntu isn't Just Working. It is actually a Netbook, a Eee PC 701 - and it is an install that is "customized" for the Eee PC 701. I'll give it some props - it found and configured everything, although I had to mess around with wireless a bit (that didn't JUST work, but the difficulty in making it Just Work was comparable to the kind of difficulty one might encounter with a Win32 install, so we'll call it close enough).

What didn't Just Work was Network Browsing of a Win32 workgroup through the default Gimp Network Browsing app. The error I get and the symptoms I am seeing are well documented - there are various bug tickets opened AND closed with no solution on the Ubuntu bug forums. One of the forum moderators actually reopened a bug report with the comment, "This is a very large obstacle to "Just Working" for many users, and needs to be resolved", but then someone else subsequently closed it again, with no solution. "If we ignore the issue, maybe it will just go away".

Now, using SMBw2k browser (I think that is it), a KDE app, I can make it work suitable for my needs - and so I'm going to leave Ubuntu on this machine. But there are a score of other trivial annoyances as well. The Codecs for Mp4 video are from the "Bad" codec set - and so to watch an iPod movie I have to deal with all kinds of nasty video artifacts.

Best of all, is Ubuntu bloat. I could get a full install with no pre-install modifications of XP onto the SSD at just over 2gb. Ubuntu is pushing 3.4gb for a full install. That leaves me around 600mb free.

If all other things were equal, and Win XP were FREE, it would be a no brainer - there would be NO reason to use Linux. It is more difficult to set up and support, there is more opportunity in my experience, for modifcations and changes to introduce new unwanted behavior into the system.

I'm not sure what changed, but I've been having a much more difficult time getting Adobe Flash to work with Ubuntu lately. This is one of those things that should Just Work. Linux is already at a disadvantage against Win32 for feature rich web browsing. Having Flash be difficult or impossible to install just makes Linux that much less useful to the typical user.

This is the link I used to install:
http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?t=611422

It is amazing that you actually have to do so much post-install cleanup to get it working properly on an Eee PC.

I hear that Ubuntu "Just Works", but I haven't yet had a machine yet where install went without a hitch and everything worked as satisfactory as it would have with an XP install. Not just one machine, but a half a dozen of them, from old Celeron 333mhz to modern core duo desktop machines.

185 replies

by ontheropes

Looks like a pretty decent rant. Nothing more, nothing less. Brought up some good points too, if you ask me.

by santeewelding

In the person of one Tammy, human intervention will prevail.

I read it closely and recognized like issues of my own. I did not notice the "has been reported" until I delved into the responses.

Martin: Was this youthful, ass hole exuberance?

by charliespencer

I don't think it even qualifies as a rant. dcolbert has been around a while and posts on a variety of topics. Just because a post includes a link to an outside site doesn't make it spam. Spam doesn't include a negative review of the product.

The PTBs should let this post remain.

by michael jay

This gentleman;
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5213-6257-0.html?id=2727770&redirectTo=%2f1320-22-20.html

Once posted the following;

Please report the following:
1. Messages about buying products and services that are not relevant to the topic or to IT professionals
2. Nonsensical strings of text "slkdjfksdjf"
3. Messages that are obscene or racially-insensitive or contain links to content that is obscene or racially-insensitive
4. Messages that allow you to access pirated software or other pirated content

Please do NOT report the following:
1. Messages suggesting a product or service that actually meets the needs of the original poster. For example, if someone is asking for the best AV app, it is not spam for someone to post a link to an anti-virus product, even if it is their own product.
2. Messages that you just don't like. We're not going to take sides in arguments, so please don't report something as spam when you just don't agree.

by Member 19291532

He has successfully derailed the original post, which he clearly marked as spam because of an ideological difference, not for any valid reason.

But, that alone probably reinforces his tactics in his own mind. Better to ignore his decision to report my post as spam, and instead focus on what an idiot n00b MS-Fanboy I am. :)

by j-mart

Most of the time would rather go to a bit more effot and install Debian. You can always see how it's going to work for a particular set of hardware or task by seeing how it will work by running live off CD. No one is forcing anyone to use it if they don't like it. You can at any time purchase your OS from Microsoft any time you want.

by jkameleon

... and it just worked. It made a pretty good impression on me. I know a couple of people who use Ubuntu for their small bussinesses (office, backoffice, web page), and they can't praise it enough.

I'm not using it, though, due to lack of fancy development tools like Visual Studio 2005/2008

by .martin.

but I really hate Spam, to any extent.

I'm (sorta) using Ubuntu right now, and sure it is not perfect (I still need to find a display driver so I can use the whole screen).

but if he had not had included the this is were I downloaded it from, and the link, I would have been fine.

by ontheropes

People put download links in discussions, blogs and questions all the time. He's not trying to sell you anything or promote his own website. I've even seen some shameless self promotion that I don't consider spam. Can't point out an example at the moment but maybe you just ought to ease off of that spam button a tad. Just because you don't like something doesn't make it spam.

Of course, feel free to do whatever you want. I'm not the boss of you.

by jaqui

you used Ubuntu.

PCLinuxOS is actually far better at hardware detection and configuration than Ubuntu.
Wireless, it will not configure if there is a wired connection though. going into the DrakX control center and adding the wireless is a click, click, click ... done procedure.
[ windows is harder than PCLinuxOS for this. ]

by Member 19291532

Ok...

In order:

Spam... I didn't realize that was what .martin had done to the post. Probably just as well...

The reason I posted the link was so that the inevitable pro-Linux responders would be able to see my source for the install and be able to comment, well informed, on the reasons for my issues. I'm not interested in having a one sided, fanboy argument AGAINST Linux - if there are legitimate issues (Well, you are using Ubuntu 7, you should really be using 8, which addresses those issues), then I'm open to discussing them. I mean, I'd point it out if we had a Linux discussing which was comparing Ubuntu to Windows ME, after all.

With that said, PCLinuxOS - haven't tried this distro. The *problem* is that Ubuntu has the most industry buzz and market mind-share. Win32 guys who are going to decide to give *nix a try are MOST likely going to go with Ubuntu. And I'm having DISMAL luck on the "It Just Works" philosophy across a variety of machines. I cut my teeth on Debian Sarge and Potato, so I can see the tremendous progress that has been made. But unless a person likes to do a LOT of reading and tinkering, or has a friend who is a Linux guru, the average Win32 convert is going to go screaming back to Win32 in short order after fighting with Ubuntu "Just Working".

For my purposes, I really just want something that is easy to install that I don't have to dink around with a bunch for my Netbook. I was using my Developers license to run a Dev XP on it, under the justification I was using it for developmental work related duties. But I stopped using it for that reason, so using the MSDN license seemed unethical. Linux was the obvious choice (being that the Xandros distro left me flat). Now, I did consider Debian, but obviously the EEE PC with 4gb of SSD presents some special circumstances. Rather than reinvent the wheel for myself (something that might be beyond my *nix skills, in this case, honestly), I figured I'd find something packaged more directly for the situation I face. The linked page I provided seems to fit the bill perfectly.

And honestly, for FREE, I'm going to do my best to make it work for me. But that is exactly the point "making it work for me" is *not* the same as It Just Works. If I had a spare license for XP, it would be a much easier route to just install that, have it really Just Work, and be done with it.

But I'll look into PCLinuxOS. We've discussed this before, and my concern there is that ALL Linux distros are a series of compromise. I played with Xandros - and if I *just* wanted to surf the web and send e-mail (kind of the intended sweet spot of a Netbook), Xandros would probably be fine. But I want to do some media, too... and Xandros starts to fall apart there - in particular it looked like it was going to be a lot of effort to find a codec package and get it installed. On the other hand, I *knew* that the .deb package management of Ubuntu was great... it made it SUPER easy to install the crummy, horrible Codecs that are available in the Ubuntu distro. :)

In much the same way, I wonder what will be the deal-breaker in PCLinuxOS. Difficult Package Management? Spotty hardware support? Lack of high quality codecs? Inability to easily install components to enable a rich web browsing experience? Broken SAMBA/CIFS?

For a Netbook - I'd like to see an OS that does the following:

* Supports wireless with no headaches.
* Supports built in Ethernet
* Recognizes the Audio
* Recognizes and works with Media Readers and USB (and devices).
* Recognizes and supports the video card with full features (desktop eye candy).
* Has a nice e-mail client that works with web based e-mail and Exchange.
* Integrates well with Win32 networks (with an emphasis on Workgroup integration over Domain integration)
* Supports a web client that works with the largest variety of rich-content websites possible.
* Supports the most popular and widely distributed media formats (Mp3, WMA, Mp4) for audio and video with applications that provide the same kind of features and functions that competitive products for other platforms offer.
* Delivers all of this, hassle free, without requiring a high level of expertise or interaction "under the hood" with the OS in order to achieve these goals.

I think this is a reasonable "bare minimum" to expect from an OS that positions itself to compete with either OS X or Win32. And in particular, *especially* one that has picked "It Just Works" as a motto. As far as I can tell, the other Linux distros aren't making this particular claim. They may claim to be superior to either OS X or Win32 for any NUMBER of reasons - but not THIS particular reason.

Again, Ubuntu does a remarkable job and has made significant progress toward achieving the list I outline above. But it isn't there yet, and it misses the mark on some significant points that are likely to be deal breakers for the average Win32 user converting to *nix.

And I know that one of the arguments is that some of these things (SAMBA, Firefox and 3rd party plugins) are outside of the direct control of the Ubuntu (or any other *nix distro) developers direct control. That is one of the unique problems and challenges for *nix. You've got an independent team designing things like Samba, that are critical to the foundation of *nix, and they design it in a generic manner that then gets picked up by any number of different distros and varients. I understand the reason, but that doesn't make it any *better* that it breaks, over and over again.

The thing I get from Linux in general, after years of playing with it, on and off again - is that it is like a tinkerer's OS. The guys working on it tinker, and the guys who use it tinker. I've made the analogy to a mechanic's car before. If you enjoy WORKING on the car as much or more than you enjoy actually DRIVING it, Linux is a great solution. If you just want a daily driver (which is what the MAJORITY of people want), then it isn't so great.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

I'd be interested to hear your thoughts in relation to 'It just works'.

I read with interest your opening post. I've been fiddling with Ubuntu on a desktop for awhile now, and Mint on a laptop. While they haven't been a nightmare, and I'm relatively satisfied with them, they don't 'just work' 'out of the box'.

by tony hopkinson

Tht picked up my wireless no problem. Had to pick the host and do the security, but other than that it was OK.

If did have problems for some reason with the install picking up the existing XP. Wouldn't mount the NTFS device.
Might have been because of other distros I'd tried or Lilo to Grub....

Also having fun with samba to my vista box, which I keep picking at from time to time.

All distros are indeed compromises, Ubuntu is not a compromise I favour. I literally refuse to try it. If I wanted something 'so like windows I wouldn't notice', I'd use windows, saves messing about.

Linux is a tinkerer's OS, Ubuntu is not a tinkerers distro though. I want to tinker, so no Ubuntu.

Your argument founders on one key point, the users Ubuntu aims at do not do installs, no more than they do windows, which can be just as much of a compromise and a pain as Ubuntu, though perhaps in other areas.

After all running a mixed Vista and XP environment is vastly unamusing in places, no reason why throwing any linux distro into the mix is going to make things easier.

by j-mart

The "just works" comes down to wether or not your particular hardware has been intergrated into your particular choice of Linux distro. some manufacture's provide required info, some good driver's, some nothing. If the industry all followed well defined standards it may make intergration of new hardware much simpler

by jaqui

Yup, Ubuntu has the buzz, and I have actually laughed when people ask me to help with Ubuntu systems, put PCLOS livecd in and their "problems" went away.

For my own use, none of the prebuilt distros meets my needs, they are all bloated to heck.

* Supports wireless with no headaches.

a lot of this is there, with those chipsets that don't have bins for the kernel. the ones that do you have to get and install the bins in /lib/firmware.

* Supports built in Ethernet
a gimme, I have yet to find built in wired network card not supported with any distro I've looked at.

* Recognizes the Audio
driver conflict with this one, multiple driver options for sound cards make it hard to support sound properly. Though most distros do default to the best driver for any particular card.

* Recognizes and works with Media Readers and USB (and devices).
work at the very least as mass storage devices

* Recognizes and supports the video card with full features (desktop eye candy).

yup, PCLOS installs the bloatware eye candy stuff by default.

* Has a nice e-mail client that works with web based e-mail and Exchange.

Thunderbird.

* Integrates well with Win32 networks (with an emphasis on Workgroup integration over Domain integration)

trick: install samba server, configured for standalone use and add yourself to samba users. do not have samba server start at boot unless you want to share a folder on the system.

* Supports a web client that works with the largest variety of rich-content websites possible.

the bloated firefox fits that bill.

* Supports the most popular and widely distributed media formats (Mp3, WMA, Mp4) for audio and video with applications that provide the same kind of features and functions that competitive products for other platforms offer.

yup, PCLOS does that.

* Delivers all of this, hassle free, without requiring a high level of expertise or interaction "under the hood" with the OS in order to achieve these goals.

Yeah, Mandriva's DrakX tools give you a windows-like control panel that makes it possible to reach this.

While PCLinusOS is based on Mandriva, they put Synaptic in for the package manager, so it's the more familiar apt-get system .. with rpms. :/

look for the mini me iso for pclos, it's the smallest footprint system, may actually fit on the netbook.

by tig2

Quote from dcolbert:

The *problem* is that Ubuntu has the most industry buzz and market mind-share. Win32 guys who are going to decide to give *nix a try are MOST likely going to go with Ubuntu. And I'm having DISMAL luck on the "It Just Works" philosophy across a variety of machines. I cut my teeth on Debian Sarge and Potato, so I can see the tremendous progress that has been made. But unless a person likes to do a LOT of reading and tinkering, or has a friend who is a Linux guru, the average Win32 convert is going to go screaming back to Win32 in short order after fighting with Ubuntu "Just Working".

End quote.

The statement that I really think is important is about Win32 guys and the tolerance for pain in working with an unfamiliar OS. if there is even a remote dream that Linux will see wider adoption, we have to move to close the rift between the hard core MS users and the hard core Linux users. I know a bunch of support guys that are using both and teaching themselves new stuff. I think that it is important to hear them out when they say that such and such is more support than I care to do or I can't get satisfactory information when I go to the various boards.

Open source proponents need to quit hearing "Long Live Microsoft" every time a support guy with long years supporting an MS network says he is frustrated and struggling with Linux. The fact that he's trying says everything.

The future of computing is likely to be more OS agnostic. I think there is a good chance that we will see more Linux in the corporate environment- cost being a key factor if this recession goes as some think. Better to learn now and be ready for anything.

Edit- extra word

by twindragon99

I started out running the G on Ubuntu but then I installed X on an old IBM think pad for my wife who is practically illiterate when it comes to computers and she loves it, I had no issues with flash and all drivers including the third party no name wireless card was auto installed for me, the only thing i did after the install was to install media codecs as you mentioned as well.

At the end of it all you are right to say that "just works" really doesn't fit as there is still no perfect install, but I still run into XP setups on "supported hardware" that force me to download up to 20 different drivers before I can use it. so XP it seems doesn't "just work" either though I guess Bill never made that claim :)

by Member 19291532

I'd never deny being guilty of having a tendency to rant...

FWIW, I quit smoking every night when I go to bed, and start again every morning when I wake up. I've spent more than half my life as a non-smoker, from this perspective.

by tig2

I claim partial success that way!

Good rant though. You made some good points with good supporting information. I love a good rant!

by Member 19291532

I've been doing some research, and I like the LOOK of PCLinuxOS... but I've got a few concerns.

One, it is based on KDE. My experience, KDE is the far more Win32 like Windows Manager of those that are popular today - and PCLinuxOS leverages that effectively - but, KDE apps are far worse in general than Gimp apps in *stability*. The most recently I've experienced this is with Kubuntu versus Ubuntu. I don't like GIMP as far as asthetics, and I really don't think it is laid out very well, either... but the stability of GIMP apps really trumps KDE's prettier interface. Gimp, under Ubuntu, has improved considerably too. It used to look horrible and be difficult to use. Now it looks passably decent (outside of Ubuntu's crap-brown default color schemes) and is laid out a lot more logically.

The second is that I can only find reviews on the Mini-Me light distro - and having to manually set up networks and apps after a super light base install doesn't sound like what I had in mind. My goal is LESS time spent doing this and more time being productive.

But I just started digging into it. If I do give it a shot, I'll let you know.

by craftamics

dcolber:

Ubuntu uses the Gnome desktop manager. Gimp [or GIMP, as it is usually listed] is the Gnu Image Manipulation Program, meant to be the Open Source answer to Adobe Photoshop.

So, I think you meant to be comparing KDE to Gnome, not Gimp.

by Member 19291532

And someone else caught me IRL doing that today and corrected me.

I did, indeed mean Gnome, and not GIMP.

I think it is because I keep seeing GIMP getting so much press as a viable Photoshop alternative lately that I got Gimp stuck in my head.

by neon samurai

I prefer to stick with 2008.1 for now rather than the newer 2009.0 though. Will PCLinuxOS not allow you to do a minimal install and add GNOME (GNOME and GIMP are the apps, GTK is what they are based on)? I've not looked at PCLinuxOS myself yet either so I don't know how flexable it is. I know I can do a Mandriva custom install in a half hour including 20 minutes form DVD to first boot and ten more minutes letting urpmi install all the extras and updates after a minimal install. That's just from using for so long that it's dead simple to work with for me now perhaps though.

Anyhow, if you do grab a few different liveCD or the Mandriva eeePC install let us know how it goes.

by Member 19291532

Is that I'm inclined to believe that they're likely to only enhance my frustration. I'm a Debian guy, so Ubuntu should be a fairly comfortable extension of that. When I get into another Distro, I can get by, but it usually means even MORE research, reference, and "under the hood" tinkering.

So, in that sense - my goal was to have a smooth install that didn't require a lot of fine tuning. An "It Just Works" install.

And that is my biggest COMPLAINT. Is that I've yet to have an "It Just Works" install of Linux, period.

Once I popped the hood and got the tool-belt out, I now have Ubuntu humming along pretty nice on the eee PC (short of a few minor complaints, e.g., WPA2). Actually, Ubuntu is operating better on the eee PC than any other previous install I've attempted (Well, it might run pretty good on my Lenovo T61, but it dual boots and is my work PC, so I use it mostly in Win32 and I'm not sure if there are a lot of annoyances on the Ubuntu side).

And, true to the words of the Ubuntu acolytes, I've learned a lot more about Ubuntu in this process - my guess is that I'll be better able to quickly fix issues I encounter on future Ubuntu installs based on the key learning here.

But I said this elsewhere...

Ubuntu "It Just Works" Fail. :)

The thing is, going to another distro that I've never dealt with before, I can't imagine it would "Just Work" better, and I think it would be more difficult for me to find, figure out and implement the fixes on a distro I am unfamiliar with.

by Member 19291532

"All distros are indeed compromises, Ubuntu is not a compromise I favour. I literally refuse to try it. If I wanted something 'so like windows I wouldn't notice', I'd use windows, saves messing about."

Well, then this conversation probably doesn't have any value for you - because I'm approaching this from the perspective of people who are interested in a very Win32 like environment without the Win32 licensing or cost issues. No disrespect intended. Your conclusion is probably right, though. If you want a Win32 environment, Linux probably isn't the right choice. It has already been done, it is called Windows. :)

"Linux is a tinkerer's OS, Ubuntu is not a tinkerers distro though. I want to tinker, so no Ubuntu."

Funny, because when I was into Debian, it was *the* tinkerer's distro. I can't imagine that Ubuntu isn't. I mean, back in the day I used to have to always go into the Xfree.conf file and edit the PS3 mouse switch and the supported video resolutions and monitor type, had to install and configure TrueType fonts (or FreeType or...) recompile the kernal for your PCI wireless, audio, and countless other small things... Being that Ubuntu is Debian under the hood, I can't see how it COULDN'T support this kind of tinkering under the hood if you were so inclined.

"Your argument founders on one key point, the users Ubuntu aims at do not do installs, no more than they do windows, which can be just as much of a compromise and a pain as Ubuntu, though perhaps in other areas."

Not sure I understand this. Could you elaborate? They do not do installs? The OS, or Apps? I've got a feeling that you have a particular concept of what "doing an install" is that doesn't mesh with the commonly accepted vision of "doing an install" in the industry.

I also don't feel that Win32 makes me accept compromises (other than PAYING for something that I would rather be free, and paying MORE for it than I think it should actually cost). As far as delivering what I want to do and doing it reliably and well, Win32 excels.

"After all running a mixed Vista and XP environment is vastly unamusing in places, no reason why throwing any linux distro into the mix is going to make things easier."

Back around Potato and Sarge, Samba connectivity was excellent with a Win32 environment. Then XP, especially Home, and W2k AD really broke the NT4 LanMan model - and you're right, it broke it between NT4 and XP/W2k machines as much as with *nix machines running SAMBA. Since then, it has been on again/off again for reliability and ease of configuration, but worse for Linux and FreeBSD than for anything else, including, for example, OS X.

I don't have these SAMBA/CIFS integration issues with OS X. Why?

by tony hopkinson

market, well in my opinion anyway. The people it's designed for are looking for someone like me or thee to have set it up for them.

How can windows not be a compromise?. Even if they designed and set it up for you, they can't have done it for me as well can they?

My samba issues have all been with Vista, XP it works fine......

Who broke what is an open question to me. I've been in the keep up with MS's changes game software wise for a long time, and it's a right PIA.

But again, if you were 'selling' a distro to take the place of windows in a basic home user setting, why would samba be a concern?

Can't even be that important for me, seeing as I haven't bothered to get it working yet.

Perhaps you are still judging Ubuntu against a more (or perhaps less :p ) specialised need for that which it was designed.

If you went into a retail outfit (given you could find one), and bought one already set up your impression of it's effectiveness in that market might change. Pre-installed from retailers is a huge advantage for MS.

I don't think people like us are a good test for this sort of thing, you need to buy compliant hardware for the distro, set up and then give it to Aunty Em, see what she makes of it.

by Member 19291532

Regarding compromise, it is in the nature of the compromise. I suppose that the compromise in Win32 is that it is not highly customizable at the Kernel level. Again, I'll use the daily-driver grocery getter. The thing is, that compromise, the Grocery Getter, is "no effective compromise" for the vast majority of the people who want a car. In the same way, Win32 Grocery Getter design is "no compromise" for the vast majority of people who want an OS. It does all the basics that they want on a very competent level with very little hassle. Trojans and Malware aside. (Given that trojans and malware are probably the most common disruption of satisfaction with Win32).

Well, who broke what isn't really that important. Ultimately, Linux interfacing with Win32 networks on Win32's terms is what is important. If Microsoft "breaks" it (which they do), but your Win32 machines and OS X machines still all talk to each other, but Linux won't talk anymore, Linux *looks* responsible.

Look at SAMBA speed right now, on FreeBSD 6.x in particular, I don't know about FreeBSD 7, but also to a lesser extent with Linux. This is absolutely a SAMBA issue - because Win32 to Win32 is relatively fine Win32 to OS X and back is relatively fine (with OS X being SUPER efficient), but just about anything to Linux or FreeBSD via SAMBA/CIFS having a horrible hit. A quick search of the online forums or google will illustrate this. Ultimately, it doesn't matter who has broken what, the fact that Linux and SAMBA have trouble playing well with Win32 only hurts Linux. (Issues become very noticable on gb networks and Intel Pro Set NICs seem to go a long way to compensating for the issue).

Most homes have a workgroup network set up sharing a common broadband connection, these days. And most home users have shared printers and shared storage on the network. Most networks you're going to encounter are going to be Win32 based. So SAMBA should absolutely be a concern for a "Win alternative contender".

I'm judging Ubuntu as a contender for Easy to Install and Use Desktop OS alternative for home and small office. It seems to me that this is what it is marketed towards. Maybe I'm wrong.

Xandros and the other Netbook OSes are designed to be these OEM pre-installed solutions. They're not working (See my other thread, 5 reasons why Linux is failing - re: 4:1 return ratios for Linux based netbooks versus WinXP netbooks). Linux has huge inherent disadvantages as a desktop alternative aimed at consumers.

While Win32 certainly has a HCL that Microsoft Support will use against you if you have problems, the truth is that the majority of NON HCL hardware works fine with Win32. With Ubuntu, when they say "this is non compliant and may not work, or won't work well, or won't have certain features", they *mean* it... and a LOT of *common* hardware is non Ubuntu HCL. It isn't as bad as trying to build a custom PC to be a Hackintosh, but it is still pretty severe.

Either way, Aunty Em has been getting OEM installed Linux Desktop OS netbooks, and she has been returning 4 of them for every 1 XP netbook that gets returned. So, I feel like we already have the numbers. As a matter of fact, the unsuitability of Xandros is what drove me to install Ubuntu on this Eee PC in the first place.

I mean, just an alternative perspective on the points you bring up. This is certainly a "two-sided coin" kind of discussion.

by the_fixer

I am a Windows admin and I have used Windows almost exclusively in a business environment and I had always had the believe that *nix desktops would not catch on. I had played around with multiple distributions but I cannot say that I have ever really achieved any real level of comfort. Well, like most every other business, we are feeling the pinch of the economic downturn and my department has begun to look for alternatives to save some money. We have already implemented a VM solution on the server side. I have read some reviews on this site regarding the Ubuntu distro and I decided to give it a try. I have to say that I have been impressed. Now granted, I am running this on older hardware (Dell D505 laptop) but I had no issues with hardware detection and configuration even with the network browser and wireless. It was easy to configure and setup even for a self admitted Linux novice like me.

I will give the PCLinuxOS a try as well as per Jaqui's recommendation.

We have begun to look at a possible desktop replacement for our programmers and providing them with a virtual Windows desktop so that they can continue to use .NET for their programming.

I hope to have a pilot program in place by the second quarter of 2009.

by jaqui

is criminal you know. :p

actually, openSuse and Mandriva both include Mono, the open source version of .net.

you can write your bloatware even in Linux with Mono.
[ just don't expect me to use it, the .net framework is grounds to ignore any app. ]

by Member 19291532

I explored this as well, and found too many issues where Ubuntu was a non-starter.

It was close, far better than it has been in the past - but there were JUST enough deal-breakers that popped up that we killed the project early.

I'd love to have the OPTION of an open license alternative that met all my corporate needs. But it isn't there, yet.

by linuxcanuck1

I have installed Ubuntu many times on desktops and my eeePC. Every version of Ubuntu from 7.04 to 8.10 has installed flawlessly. On my eeePC 900 the wireless just works. So does the camera.

In Ubuntu, I have never had to hunt for a driver. When I install Ubuntu, I am done in 20 minutes. When I install XP, it takes an hour and then I have to spend hours shovelling in CDs and driver disks.

Do people have problems with Ubuntu or any other distribution? Sure. They do in XP and Vista, too. As for the Mac, it is a closed system. Proprietary everything. When you control all of the variables, then it would be surprising if things did not work.

It is a continuum. On one end you have free (as in liberty) software and open architecture and on the other extreme you have DRM and closed everything (Apple). Microsoft is somewhere in between, but things work better only because of their cozy relationship with OEMs. It all depends on what you want in an operating system.

In my experience, Ubuntu is no better and no worse than most up-to-date operating systems. If you are trying to get old equipment to work then you will have problems in any OS. You need the original disks in Windows or you have to hunt for drivers and good luck if it is hard to find. Linux may or not support it if it is old. The Mac OS certainly won't install on anything but Apple equipment (legally anyway) in the first place so it is therefore likely that peripherals will work if it came with an Apple computer. If it is really new then you will need the latest driver disk for Vista or you may be out of luck. In Linux you may have to wait till the next kernel is released. C'est la vie.

BTW, have you heard of the class action lawsuit against Microsoft for its Vista capable programme?

You are comparing apples to oranges.

by Member 19291532

I admit the "Apple Advantage" elsewhere in this thread.

The EEE PC 701 isn't exactly ancient. Do your F keys work - disabling WiFi? Did you always have the MadWIFI drivers or did you use the ndiswrapper for the WiFi at some point? These little issues, that I *know* about them and *have* to know about them to get things working as they should, are a bother - a bother that you don't have to concern yourself with in Win32.

I think this is where there is a disconnect though - your perspective is probably based in (possibly large) part on ideology and philosophy. Mine isn't. Mine is based on efficiency and peak effectiveness. When people start talking about "Free as in Liberty" software, there is an implied set of ideals, of morals and ethics that defines all the other choices that an individual makes from that core belief system.

Most people don't give an eff about that. They just want their powerpoint slides to work.

Now, the way I see it, The Win32 people never made this a war over "who is best and who will steal market share from who". That all came from the Linux side of the argument. Win32 was never concerned about stealing market share from Linux, making inroads into Linux dominated segments of the industry. You've never seen an article, "Will Win32 upset the Linux dominance of the Desktop" or "When do you plan on migrating from Linux to Win32".

So if I'm comparing apples to oranges, I'm only following a well established tradition started by Linux advocates.

Which I've mentioned before - the Linux advocates seem perfectly content to argue how Linux is superior to Win32, from the earliest days...

But when you start making comparissons back that find Linux unfavorably positioned, they OFTEN trot out this "You can't compare them, they're different".

Well... which is it? I'm puzzled. Can you compare them, or can't you? If you can't, I expect the Linux community to immediately STOP comparing itself to Win32. Apples and Oranges, after all.

:D

by neon samurai

It's kind of hard not be get defensive with Balmer denouncing FOSS as a cancer or the enevitable fanboys that break in to Linux discussions to proclaim how wonderful there personal choice is. Same goes the other way too, Windows discussions enevitably get crashed by zealotry that only want to hear themselves repeat there prefered choice over and over. Lest we forget Cult of Mac.. they turn up too.

The X vs Y has been going on forever though. Before Microsoft was a twinkle in the Gates dormroom, it was CP/M vs something else. vi vs Emacs. Windows vs Apple.. there is always something.

by jiminpa

I tried Ubuntu once, I found that as long as you just want to load it up and use it as is it works ok. Any customization I attempted was an exercise in extreme frustration.

Red Hat is a little less user friendly to the non-techie user but it works so much better.

by tig2

There are people watching this thread. I may call you an "idiot n00b MS-Fanboy." I have known you for awhile and you still refuse to toss your MS systems for the one true platform- CP/M! But I consider your other qualities and love you for them. I feel I can allow you to have an opinion... even if JD thinks it's wrong.
:D

Seriously- people will drive past the spam marker and into the discussion. It's a good one in light of the growing popularity of the ASUS box. To be honest, I had been thinking about getting one but that bug report thing you mentioned is giving me a rationale to reconsider.

by dumphrey

test models I have seen seemed very poorly built. Is this due to them being floor models with no guts? I guess I could start a new thread on this.

by Member 19291532

Especially at the Win32 server level, the HCL starts to get more important...

But the breadth of support for non HCL hardware in Win32 environments is something that Linux just seems hard pressed to compete with, in my experience. The closest that gap ever got was when Vista was first released and had poor hardware support, and even then, I bet Vista hardware support was still broader than the "best" Linux distros.

If the industry all followed well defined standards, we would all own Macs. It is how well you handle non-standards. :)

At least... well...

OS X has a built in advantage (outside of the Hackintosh world. Oddly enough, though, you start using OS X like "any old OS" and it starts having more problems than EITHER Linux or Win32) in that the hardware and OS integration is tight and controlled with an iron fist.

Linux tries to compete on an open architecture platform - and Win32 just has a giant lead there, and years of experience dealing with the difficulities introduced by such a model.

Again, it may not be the FAULT of Linux, but it is what Linux has to compete with and against, in either case.

by neon samurai

"the breadth of support for non HCL hardware in Win32 environments is something that Linux just seems hard pressed to compete with"

This is a measure of how much hardware works with the OS not how well the newest hardware works with the OS though. In terms of how much hardware each supports, Windows pales in comparison. A quick look at the supported hardware in the kernel can confirm that for you.

Each platform does somethings better than the other. Windows gets the newest hardware by virtue of the vendor providing drivers for it themselves. Linux gets the longer list of hardware though. How many processor architectures does Windows (kernel plus drivers) run on vs Linux (kernel alone)? Will the NT kernel still boot on a 286, it's not hard to setup a Linux kernel and minimal user space on hardware that old.

How is Vista doing for supporting older hardware? What was the last bit of hardware that Linux dropped support for? It's just not as simple as all that to measure really.

by Member 19291532

Man, when we start talking, "I can run the latest Linux on a PC 5150 or a NEC V10" (go ahead, google it or head over to Wikipedia and search... :) )

Or that Linux supports ST, Mac 68k, Sparc and Amiga... (do they still, probably some variant does)...

I mean... I'm all yawns. This isn't *relevant*, especially in the terms of this discussion. I start thinking about under-employed, highly intelligent, dumpster diving and Goodwill prowling uber-nerds with a Sailor Moon fetish whenever the conversation goes this way.

I mean, I can ALWAYS pull out DOS 5 and Win 3.11 for a 286 if we really want to go 20 years back in the development cycle. And you're certainly not going to be running Ubuntu or Kubuntu with Compiz on the 286. You're probably not even going to be running XWindows with a uber lite windows manager. You're going to be running a CLI and maybe Lynx. This retort is a non-starter, Neon.

I mean, just talking along these lines made me have a memory of riding my BMW down to Shakey's Pizza to play Zaxxon in the arcade. Seriously - a *vivid* memory. How relevant IS that? (Wow... that was some sort of Freudian slip. I meant "riding my BMX down to Shakey's". Talk about being subconciously honest with yourself).

For all intents and purposes, if we crawl all the way back to NT4, a 386 will run it, and that is as effective as installing a latest/greatest Linux on a 386. A 386 is about the farthest back I would consider a PC "modern" (assuming a 32 bit machine, at that... no 386SX). I mean, I've got a nice Windows smart phone, but even your basic FREE phone from Verizon has more computational power than a 386.

Sorry to rant on this, but this one is just a fallacy - especially in the context of "Linux winning a bigger share of the Desktop OS market by being more friendly, i.e., It Just Works".

by Member 19291532

Exactly.

Seriously. My entire point. You nailed it.

"RTFM Noob" doesn't cut it. Listen to them and close the gap and make it better. The Linux community *has*, in all honesty, but you've got a ways to go still.

But yeah, that is absolutely my point here.

I want to use Linux, I keep trying to use Linux, and I make an extra effort that most of my peers would NEVER try - and *I* end up frustrated and often go with Win32 instead.

If that doesn't change, *nix is always going to be a fringe player.

Which may be fine, actually. But, I'd certainly like to see it go the other way, and actually make a significant impact on the market.

by tig2

You made a point in another post that spoke to why. Companies need to save money. Near as I can tell, nothing is off the table, every possibility will be considered. If the company is paying a yearly fee to MS for the OS and they can deploy a solution enterprise wide or even mostly enterprise wide that costs less, they will look at that really hard.

This is a place where the Open Source folks need to wake up a bit. Yes, there is a corporate Red Hat out there that is significantly less to license. The license, I believe, pays for support.

The hinge point will always be Total Cost of Ownership. If I have to hire additional support staff because calls take so much longer to resolve that my end user's productivity is harmed, then I have to consider how expensive "free" is.

Closing the gap is really the issue.

Good on you for being proactive with Linux. I think it will pay off for you.

by andrewchristiandc

You definitely have a point about Ubuntu. Sometimes it requires quite a lot of configuration to get features to work and I agree with what you're saying, in principle.

But in practice try building a custom server out of an XP installation and then try building one out of an ubuntu installation.

Then tell me which one just works?

by ---tk---

I'm not really going to argue with any of them, they are legit reasons... But I am a Ubuntu and PCLOS fan, I find that tweaking it just right is all part of the fun... I get bored with installing, and everything works off the bat... I enjoy a good challenge, lol but that might be why I am going gray at such an early age. Every now and then linux makes me want to rip my hair out, and scream.... but I find that its worth it in the long run...

by the scummy one

made me want to rip my hair out and scream.

My XP hdd started making noise, so I piced up a new drive. Started cloning it (few problems with earlier versions of ghost).

2 hours later I went by to check status, and found that it had 9 hours remaining :0
after the nin hours it hung on 1 sec remaining -- all friggin night. tonight I am going to use a live distro and dd it so that I can use my friggin system some time this week.
funny thing -- after trying to ghost it, the hdd seems to have stopped making noise, and seems to be fine. however, I think I have lost all the confidence in ghost now -- and am moving it all over to linux. Symantec products just keep getting worse and worse in my opinion (well, same with Roxio, becoming too much a hassle to bother with)

by ---tk---

One second remaining... thats a total kick in the junk! I still use Ghost 8, it has yet to fail me. knock on wood... lol over the weekend I used it 5 times on my system. I really would have been angry if that happened!

by neon samurai

It's been on my todo list to look at for a while but I finally had a valid need to do so. It's a rather nice tool to keep around; the disk is already in my bag beside system recovery and various other liveCDs.

by charliespencer

in both cases the hard drive failed soon after. I attributed the slow speed more to the impending drive failure than to Ghost. As you noted, the drive was making noises before you started.

by Member 19291532

I recently used Ghost 4 Linux to make an image of the eee PC. During my distro tests, I accidently fubared Grub at one point, and was able to easily reinstall using the G4L image I had made.

My results weren't so good with an XP image I made using G4L for my Lenovo. Ended up having to restore that image using the bundled XP 1-Touch restore.

G4L has a funky interface with confusing and inconsistent terminology, and it doesn't seem to make a single raw image... it breaks the image up into chunks and it seems like it is a file image of the complete drive contents (so you need to partition and format your destination appropriately prior to a restore). But, for an open source alternative, it is worth a look.

by the scummy one

the base OS and built in apps worked fine, but other apps didnt?
Ok, the wireless wasnt as easy as it could have been (my PCLOS box worked fine with wireless on several HP notebooks).

The point about the networking is valid though. Many people trying to move from Windows would have a small home network already. I think the installation should ask if the system will connect to a Windows network, and then go from there. However, in my experiences, Linux does 'just work' until you need to config something or add cr@p from another source (3rd party) -- then it is touch and go (like Win).
Flash was a pain to get setup on my last XP box, it worked fine for a while then suddenly I had to upgrade. After the upgrade I couldnt get it working at all in either FF or IE. Had similar exp. in Vista as well.

So, from your rantings, I would have to say that 3rd party apps dont 'just work' as easily as Windows. And I would have to agree. There are some things that I gave up on trying to do.
However, is it worth $400 + to more easily deal with your mp4's?

by the scummy one

it keeps Windows running instead of rebooting it to gain exclusive access. this morning about 22 hours into the clone, it was working on the mft entries.

The last ver. I used was '03 -- it rebooted the system to clone the drives, and could be run from cd. in Ghost 10, it will not clone the drives from cd boot, it will nly get to backup points (non boot drive). WTF is that? I can access the second or non boot drives in a number of ways with or without the OS to gather data.

Nope, I lost all respect for Symantec

by ---tk---

http://www.runtime.org/driveimage-xml.htm

I have had a few friends say it works really good, and I have scene a few people on here talk about it... plus its free :)....

I gave up on Symantec back in 2003... I purchased their "Package (AV/firewall)" bla bla bla. lol the second day I tried to uninstall it, and it wouldn't... I tried all their "fixes" that didn't work, researched the hell out of it... I ended up blowing it all away... I was totally heated about it...

by the scummy one

from Linux. The best points about it as well, it is a bit by bit clone, therefore it can cross partitions to clone the entire drive, not just a partition. However, it can be used to copy by partition as well.

About the only things I use from Symantec (except at work) anymore was the ghost (used for backup of my data drive) and Partition Magic (havent needed it in a while at home).

by dumphrey

only because at the time it came with a ghost 2003 cd as well... my previous cd had a scrath in it that made it unreliable. I tried ghost 10 for about 2 days before realizing it was just a dressed up version of NTbackup (with bare metal restore admittedly).

by the scummy one

and I always got errors since I installed it that there was not enough resources to complete the api.
Even after telling it to remove old files (keep 4 versions) and having it on a 250GB HDD to backup 50 GB. I just dealt with the error, it seemed to backup. However this was the first restore attempt, and I was hardly impressed. I first tried booting to the restore disk, after a 5 min. load time, no operational mouse, I found that there was no option to clone a disk, only recover data FROM one of the backup points.
I thought, WTF is this and pulled out the book only to find out it was true.
nothing about the SW was thrilling at all, just an expensive POS of a utility that once was good.

by jlabadessa

I have been running VMware Server on my laptop for a while to play with various OS. I decided to download a free & current version of SUSE and installed into VMware. Install was smooth & SUSE works well for basic web browsing, email & daily applications. However, when I started to get into other applications, my frustrations began. I found some steps to install PPTP VPN service & attempted to get this to work, but after spending hours trying to sort this out I gave up...for now. I have setup hundreds of VPN connections on Windows computers & this has always been a very easy task.

The fact that SUSE is a very slick operating system & FREE makes it very attractive. But my question is WHY do you have to go through so many HOOPS to install software or other services?? Seems like VPN client should be part of base install along with a multitude of tech applications. Why is Linux lacking a common installer so we can download & install apps??

I admit that I am a Linux newbie & am learning more as I play with it. I have always envisioned replacing all Windows computers in one of my smaller customer environments with a FREE version of SUSE or other Linux OS. My fear is that users are not ready and learning curve is too great.

As Linux evolves & becomes MUCH more intuitive, I can see the day where I can setup a complete Linux client/server environment. Microsoft licensing costs are out of control...I just hope the Linux community continues to work towards an OS that rivals Windows.

Just my 2 cents.

by jdclyde

it is SuSE linux, not linux SuSE.... :D

As for learning curve, did you have a learning curve to start with Windows? Have you subjected yourself to the learning curve of Vista and the latest/blotiest version of Office? ;\

Cheers.

jd

by charliespencer

I'm responding to bump this up. I'm sure someone will respond with a description of the software installer for Suse. (Sorry, jd, but it isn't an acronym and I refuse to capitalize letters after the first one; see also: Powerpoint) Until then, you may want to Google the terms 'yast' and 'Zenworks'. While Zenworks is Suse-specific, yast is an application management tool common to many Linux distributions.

by neon samurai

Within Xwindows, you'll find the package manager under the draketools "configure my computer". Add the repositories if they are not there already with the [add] button.

Alternatively, from the command line, "urpmq partial-name" gives you a search for a string. (eg. urpmq firefox returns all package names including the text "firefox")

Debian has it's own repositories and used the deb package manager. I believe the GUI package manager is Synaptec.

The GUI package managers are actually easier to use than Windows Update. Basically, Windows Update with a full library to download from.

Did you try using the Suse GUI package manager?

by neon samurai

It works towards it's project goals and is evolving quickly but there are other distributions that have been at it longer and do a better job of it. Ubuntu is just another example of the power of marketing.

by dumphrey

while not perfect, at least people may try it, and maybe try another distro until they find their favorite. But most dedicated win users will probably not want to make the switch if they have to learn/re-learn too much.

I think Linux needs to do a lot of work on standardizing on a package type and management system other then compile from code if it really wants to saturate the win32 market. As well as standardizing where files are located (example apache root dir across all distros).
But, overall, as smooth as Linux has become, it has a long way to go to reach the plug and play of win. (There are exceptions to all rules, so no flames here plz). Worth considering, is the learning curve on Linux can also lead to a more informed and educated computer user, and hopefully, a safer user on the internet, no matter what platform they use, through a general computing skill bleed-over and security awareness. (major improvements in SELinux usability would be a huge plus as well...)

by neon samurai

Connonical has also done a lot so far outside of advertising like the media codec deal.

But saturating the win32 market is not the goal of all platforms based on Linux either. The distributions that do persue that goal will keep evolving while other distributions will fit there own goals and user needs.

by neon samurai

I liked DD back when using it to create boot disks but the simplicity of dropping a CD to an ISO file with it really sold me. Fantastic tool. I'm tempted to look for a win32 compile of it.

by dumphrey

How do you find its copy speeds? Its been a while since I tried a new version, the one I have is over a year old now I think.

by neon samurai

I'm doing drive image to ssh mount so that slows the speed down. If I do a machine drive upgrade in the near future, I may be able to test the drive to drive speed.

by dumphrey

part of the speed issue I was having was sending the image across a usb connection. But, slow or not, it did the job when several other products crapped out (including my venerable ghost 2003). It was able to do a bit lvl copy of a 2.5 ide disk with many bad sectors and noticeable, audible clicking (another reason for slow speed). I really didn't have lots of time to keep trying stuff out. After transferring the image to a new HD, I needed to do a repair install of the OS, and 90% of the data was recoverable and usable. If I had started with it, I probably would have been able to save all the data.

I have run a disk to disk copy on a single machine, and while slower then ghost, it was acceptable. But ghost skips copying blank space, and im pretty sure clonezilla copies the blank space too.

by the scummy one

I wonder now, if that can be used to create an image file from a full HDD?
how would the extraction work from dd?

by the scummy one

however, after cancelling the operation the system was fine. The noise was there until I removed the cover to verify which drive it was. After another reboot, the noise stopped.
Never BSOD'd or anything, used it for a while last nigh, verifying directories and everything.

I think it had to do with trying to clone the boot (Win) drive with Win still running.

oh, and the long time that it was planning to take is likely due to the HDD size (250GB partition). I would think that an average of 10GB/hr it would take more than the original 9 hours to complete (noted completion time by ghost). Right now it is going on 7 hours, but dd does not give a progress bar. I will check it tomorrow sometime.

by neon samurai

That's my guess anyhow. I needed to iso a distro install cd and was completely stunned at the simplicity after years of needing some third party app under Windows.

I now ISO flashdrives that are showing signs of dying. I can then dig through the ISO with recovery tools or a loopback mount.

I don't see why you couldn't dd a hard drive over to a .img or .iso

by Member 19291532

After a complete reinstall of Ubuntu, I still had trouble with the WiFi as described in the document I originally linked to.

So I searched, and found:

http://madwifi-project.org/wiki/UserDocs/FirstTimeHowTo

(I link, by the way, out of courtesy, to anyone here reading who may have similar problems, or to anyone who found this thread seeking answers for similar problems).

And now I have working MadWiFi (non ndiswrapper) wireless drivers set up and working on my EeePC.

And this, ladies and gentlemen, is NOT the hallmark of an OS that "Just Works" - especially not one that aspires to "replace Win32" on the home user/office user desktop.

If I'm downloading .gz-ed tarballs, unextracting them, running make, makeinstall and doing mod probes from the terminal to get my wireless working - there is a problem. I spent several days troubleshooting and resolving this issue. Normal, non-technically inclined users are not going to put up with this. They're used to installing a driver disk, installing their device, and GENERALLY having it work.

Oh... and I spoke to soon, I actually had the wired ethernet still connected when I claimed victory and thought I had a connection via wireless. After a failed reboot that required a fsck to correct, I'm back up and in and wireless is working.

Linux, it isn't a desktop OS... it is the world's ultimate puzzle game.

by jaqui

and both Mandriva and PCLinuxOS include madwifi by default if there is an Atheros chipset wireless card on the system.

:p

go figger, the much touted distro fails where the often maligned ones succeed. ;)

by neon samurai

It may be more accurate to specify the distribution you are working with rather than the blanket term "Linux" meaning more than the kernel itself. Ubuntu may have given you grief where other distributions give you perfect support. Maybe the Mandriva for eeePC would have been worth trying?

by Member 19291532

By the end of it, I was convinced that the best route is to simply go Xandros, which is a Debian variant with an EeePC friendly KDE interface, and do the "Enable Advanced Desktop" hack.

You're right, my complaint here *is* Ubuntu. And the marketing *is* the problem. The "It Just Works" mantra is misleading - especially for a distro that aims to be a desktop OS alternative for Win32 users. But the fact that I give Linux a blanket condemnation for Ubuntu's failures should be an indication. Almost anyone else who goes Ubuntu and discovers the same issues is likely to do the same.

And we've had this discussion before. While I may be willing to go through several distros (after all, I've got a Lenovo S10 IdeaPad, a HP DV8005 17" notebook, and a couple of desktops, all running XP or Vista) the Eee PC is just to tinker with at this point), to find one that is well suited to my network and to the machine I need it for, I think the majority of people out there would rather go to Best Buy, plunk down a couple hundred dollars for an OS, and be done with it. Many of them have no choice - they just don't have the expertise to do otherwise.

And that is the Linux gap - as a community, all that "choice" is a liability. It is the difference between the way Japanese car packages are modeled and American car packages are modeled. Compare a Nissan Titan to a Ford F150 some time. Nissan has 3 trim levels, and I think 3 packages. Ford has about 6 trim levels, and literally hundreds of different packages and thousands of options.

Sounds great, right? But Nissan isn't begging Tokyo for a bailout.

Linux needs to bring it together and get all their features in one distro. I don't know if the "chaos structure" of the Linux community can ever support that, though.

FWIW, I'm having trouble with the wireless again. It looks like it is a WPA/WPA2 issue. Connecting to my network at home which has a WEP hex key, it works fine. The interface for Network Settings doesn't give enough details compared to a Win32 interface. I see I'm "associated" - but I'm not getting any real feedback on signal strength, on if I am being assigned an IP address, if the WPA authentication is being accepted. I know I can open up a terminal session and drill down to find that info... but, isn't NOT having to do that the point?

The more I play with Ubuntu, the more I am convinced that they are setting the "Linux on the desktop" cause BACK, not forward.

They really should change the motto to "It ALMOST just works".

by the scummy one

it wasnt the disk :)
dd worked flawlessly, it finished up sometime between last night at 5:pm and this morning at 8AM.
So, if it finished right before I got in this morning, it only took 22 hours.
Personally, I think it finished much sooner than that, likely it was done within a couple of hours of leaving last night.

XP and Vista can read the drive fine, now I just got to put it in my system and boot tonight.
If I am on TR tonight, then it worked :)
of course, I have no doubts about that anyway -- things just seem to work when using linux :^0

by j-mart

I keep a collection of "Live CD's" If I have some old hardware lying about that I have a use for, it's simple enough to try a few to find the best start point before putting in time to set up a system. Ubuntu is not my favorite but sometimes easiest solution for task in hand, sometimes not, sometimes its PCLinuxos, sometimes something else.

by Member 19291532

But I find that you know, I can get the iDeneb hackintosh live CD to run on almost anything, but I can't get the install to actually WORK. :)

I'd love to be running OS X on the eee PC, and evidently lots of folks are - but it sounds like more work than any Linux variant. So Ubuntu it was...

Although granted, I don't think in the LiveCD paradigm as it is, in my experience, a relatively recent *nix development (and Win32 and OS X development, too, really). I mean, the saturation of live CD OSes that do an install is really a pretty recent thing. It wouldn't hurt to make a collection of Live CDs and try what you advise, anyhow.

by Member 19291532

They've still got their hand out and they're a multi-billion dollar global corporation.

Although if you can paint Ford's situation as rosy, you're clearly a "The Glass if Half Full" kind of guy, and that might explain having faith in the Linux desktop, as well...

:D

by the scummy one

you may have interpreted it that way.

This was an announcement by Ford themselves. They said that at the moment they are not hurting, however if sales do not pick up, they will be hurting by mid 09.

They also stated that they never asked for a bailout, however they would except a loan from the bailout package IF the government wanted to loan the money, to be used to re-tool some plants.

yes, they got their hand out IF the government offers, otherwise, they do not seem to be worried yet.

and yes, I have faith in the Linux desktop (except KDE4 -- it s*cks) :)

by Member 19291532

Ok - so...

It took a lot more "under the hood" work than I thought I was willing to do...

But I've actually got wireless working EXCEPT for WPA... mostly. It seems to lose connection and require a reboot from time to time, nothing else will get the connection back...

But... for the FIRST time, I've gotten the Compiz cube up and running like it looks in all those pretty screen shots, as well as enabling all the other Compiz functions...

And... Ubuntu supports higher resolution on an external monitor than the Win XP Eee PC (or even Intel) video drivers will do. I don't know or understand why, But it seemed like it was a 1240x1024 screen I was seeing on the external LCD. It was way bigger than the 800x420 or whatever the LCD does. On XP, the 7" resolution is what you get on an external monitor. 1 point for Ubuntu.

Unfortunately, the F keys don't work (for turning off wireless, switching to external monitor, etc). I see that there are hacks and tweaks to make this work, but I'm kind of done, at least for now.

Ultimately, it is an Ubuntu Fail - as far as Ubuntu is marketed....

But I'll give it an Ubuntu Pass, in as much as it seems I'll be able to use it effectively for the things I want to do.

For free, I guess I can live with that.

I *certainly* wouldn't want to support Ubuntu as a business desktop alternative for my 100+ users.

by neon samurai

Suse and Red Hat would be the obvious picks since you can also get SLA from Novel, Red Hat and various hardware vendors like HP. Debian could be a good choice though you don't have the SLA to fall back on. Mandriva also supports it's distributions through SLA. I'd have to be made happy in a few meetings with Connonical before I'd consider *buntu for an office wide workstation though.

by neon samurai

I've been tempted a few times to get an eee just to play with the different eee specific distributions becoming available. At the time, budget went to my N810 and I've not found justificaiton beyond hobby curiousity for the eee. If Xandors works best for you with least amount of adjustment though then that's the way to go.

The confusion of "Linux" being a blanket name for any and all distros that happen to choose that kernel is one reason I've taken to specifying the distribution name I'm talking about. Ubuntu is very different from PCLinuxOS, Mandriva or even Debian thow it is closest to the last. But yeah, the marketing is very much the problem; for and against too. Ubuntu would not be my first choice of a distribution though it's become the one most start with these days. It's unfortunate that the failings of one distribution become attributed to any distribution though. In the same way, a failing in Windows does not usualy account for 98, NT or XP though Vista's branding seporates it from the rest of the family (I'm still hearing "windows 2007" from my users at work when meaning the new office but what can you do).

Like any OS, if it is preinstalled, it's probalby going to work just fine since the vendor has already provided the hardware support not included in the kernel. Some distros are more flexible than others though. On my N810, it has a very specialized distribution with flexability limited in some ways (still blows PalmOS or winCE out of the water for my needs though). I could also get Debian on too it or Android if so inclined.

Yes, since the specific machine your looking at is the Eee, you have a shorter list to choose from and unfortunately, I don't belive there is a liveCD method of testing either. Booo.

"I think the majority of people out there would rather go to Best Buy, plunk down a couple hundred dollars"

Very true, not everyone is a computer type. This is where preinstalled selections becomes more important along with sales staff that actually try to fit the device to the person and manage expectations not inflate commissions or sales counts. Consumers getting home with mislead expectations does not help anyone.

The real difference is that it's not hundreds of packages to choose from. The selection can be narrowed down very quickly with ten or less questions. You see a dealer and ask questions about the car your interested in, why do people blindly throw money at a computer without any questions?

The other thing is that the various OS based around the Linux kernel are for a veriety of different uses. The distributions developed for use in science labs could be used for a desktop but are not ideally suited outside of the intended use. Multimedia focussed distributions are the same way. SystemRescue is a very small distro with a specific use as is Backtrack. If we go back to the well over used auto analogy; I don't buy a VW Bug to pull my camping trailer any more than I'd buy an F150 for driving the local quarter mile on Sundays. On the other side of the fense, Windows tries to do everything good'ish but nothing exceedingly well except generate profit margins; that's it's primary intended goal. If I need a lean and solid server, I'm not going to choose Windows where it is still the prefered choice for a gaming rig.

I feel your wireless pain. Mandriva picks up my NIC and attaches to WPA2 in under five mouse clicks. I get signal strength, IP issued and the rest of the info. I can drop to cli with ifconfig/iwconfig too in the same way that I often drop to cli for ipconfig on windows machines.

With Backtrack, I can attach to WPA but no wpa2_supplicant is included yet. It's not a bleeding edge distro updated weekly either though. Debian Stable is the same way, not ideal for the latest hostile hardware like wifi. Better support from the hardware vendors like broadcom would be very welcome as the software would quickly make it usable for us end users. Between Mandriva on desktops and Debian on my servers, I've not had reason to look at other distros outside of curiousity in VMs though either.

Preinstalled, it should work fine but like Windows, a self install is going to cause you extra steps. Have you been into the Ubuntu forums or posted bug reports for hte issues your having?

by neon samurai

I started with Red Hat and went to Mandrake -> Mandriva so urpmi is very familiar. While I often take a look at various new distrubtion liveCD, digging into Debian like I do with Mandriva has been a recent thing for me. The conversion has not been hard so far though. the biggest stumble for me was installing KDE then figuring out that I had apt-get in xorg behind it. I have a few other things I'm learning to do the Debian way but it's not been a show stopper.

Granted, learning a different distro can be adding to your frustration but between Mandriva's approach to user friendly and the eeePC specific version, it's the one I'd recommend.

If your rig is working and you can get through the install steps in under an hour though, your already all set.

by Member 19291532

Is connected via the WPA connection to my public wireless network at the office. No updates applied, no driver changes, nothing has changed. I spent all last week troubleshooting this darned thing and got nowhere - and today it just starts working.

And I am hesitant to turn it off, because next time, I don't have faith that it will work again.

Wireless is still pretty crude on Ubuntu. They've got a way to go. I'm not looking a gift horse in the mouth. I'm glad it is connected now. And I am actually connected on the eee PC right now. But I really wish I had faith it would be consistent.

by Member 19291532

And installing various places on the eee PC 701. SD Ram, SSD drive, via USB pendrive and external CD...

Tried Xubuntu, EEE-Ubuntu and Ubuntu-Eee.

Xubuntu worked the best of the three, but was still pretty crippled on install. I can't remember which one, eee-ubuntu or ubuntu-eee, had built in support for the F-keys via the Xandros drives (with on screen display when toggled), but the wireless didn't work. Finally, I stumbled onto a script from a guy in the UK... riceeey tweak should do it if you google it. I was able to install a full ubuntu 8.10 to the SD ram (bypassing the SSD drive altogether). Wireless worked fine after his script, it resizes windows and fonts intelligently for the eee PC screen, and the Fkeys work. So far, it has been the nicest install of Ubuntu I've achieved. It is too bad it took me so long to hunt it down. That is part of the problem with *nix - so many people repeating the same effort with various degrees of success, and no real central place that is authoritative to say, "This is the way to go". But anyhow, if you're looking for an alternative OS for the Eee PC 701, this looks like the best bet at the moment. I still haven't tried setting up Flash. I saw a "Installing Flash with Ubuntu 8.10" walkthrough somewhere, discussing the challenges right now - and I'm going to find that and do it their way before just trying to install the Adobe package *or* the official repository supporte flash (both of which seem broken right now in Ubuntu). anybody who is using an Eee PC and has any questions can feel free to contact me. I'll try to help any way I can.

by neon samurai

Still don't have the budge for a hobby box right now since it went to the N810 at the time. Getting my own to take home and make all hacky is very tempting though.

by jlabadessa

DColbert, thanks for posting your experiences with various distros...it has helped me to stay away from a few.

I have been playing with SUSE Linux within VMWare & the only thing that I continue to fight with is VPN connections. I have a need to establish VPN to various locations for support purposes & have NOT found an easy solution for SUSE.

I have followed steps to rpm VPN client packages, but no luck in connecting. I don't think packages are installing correctly but also not sure how to tell.

As you know, this setup takes about 30 seconds with any Windows version after say...WIN95!!

These days, I would rather put my keys in the car & go!

by Member 19291532

I'll admit, I never got all the way to checking into any non-Debian/Ubuntu based distros, although I planned on it. I burnt all my time trying the various Deb-distros and working through hardware challenges.

The real shame is that the Eee-PC specific Ubuntu distros all had significant problems. If any should be expected to "Just Work", it should have been those. Ultimately, I ended up with 8.10 with a nice script to clean things up and unlock "broken" functions.

But on 7.0.4 and 8.10, I can get either of them humming in under an hour on an EeePC now (and get them humming on a Lenovo S10 in even less time. Ubuntu 8.10 really JUST works on this particular machine).

8.10, also resolves some of the outstanding operational issues... e.g., the codecs for MP4 video don't have the weird green artifacts, from what I've seen so far.

So ultimately, Ubuntu will be a very useful and practical OS for me on my netbooks, and I'll probably just stick with it. The problem is that it DID take me a long time to get to that point - and THAT is going to prevent Ubuntu from achieving a goal of being a desktop OS alternative for the MASSES. That is my real point of debate here. I've come to the conclusion, Linux is not, and probably will not be a desktop OS alternative for the mass audience, and it probably shouldn't be. It serves the role it serves well enough, and there is a lot of compromise involved in it becoming "that other thing". In that sense, I think I can be a content Linux user without feeling a need to witness or promote Linux, especially to those who probably shouldn't be using it. If anything, selling someone on Linux who SHOULDN'T be using it is only going to hurt the reputation of Linux.

With the Lenovo becoming my workhorse netbook, the Eee PC will become my testing PC for playing with interesting distros or other "lab" type environments. To that end, I'll probably blow off the Ubuntu on it now and play around with some of the other OSes in the future. I'd like to play around with Xandros with advanced desktop on, and with PCLinuxOS for Eee PC - and maybe some others. I'd really like to spend the time to get a working Hackintosh running on it at some time - just for the "Mac Air for under $300" value. :)

by dumphrey

And you are right about each OS needing to play to its strength and evolve in their own direction (SPARC, PPC, Alpha, what have you). But some saturation is needed to get Linux into the mainstream of acceptance. Like it or not, the win32 desktop (it SHOULD be win64 by now, ) is the dominate force. I would like to go to a computer shop and be asked "Win, Lin, or Mac on that sir?"
Overall, having more users aware of viable alternatives is not really a bad thing. As long as those users are not being sold a Win Clone... but are aware that its a different OS and what that entails.

by Member 19291532

I traded for my Eee PC 701, just to see if I would like a netbook. I was headed to Spain, had a short time frame after I made the decision, and didn't want to jump in at the $400 range for something I wasn't sure I would like - but I didn't want to lug my 17" HP Multimedia notebook all over Europe.

I traded an old Dual Xeon 400 Netfinity 5000 server with a 70GB raid 5, an Ipaq, and a cheap Aiptek SD digicam for it. So I got rid of a bunch of clutter and got a nice small testbed machine in the trade.

But with the 701 coming down so far in NEW retail price, I'd suspect you could get a used one for around $100-150 if you shop carefully and look for someone with reasonable expectations.

What I *hate* right now is that people buy something for $250, the retail price drops to $199 during the 6 months to a year that they use it, and they go to sell it and think $175 is a fair price. For $25 more, I'll just buy new... Fair retail for a used eeePC701 with no significant upgrades (512MB ram, one battery, case, 4gb SDD) should be $100.

by Member 19291532

I think the problem that I sumbled onto while I was trying different distros is the lack of centralized organization in the *nix/tux community.

By that I mean, Microsoft has a strong organizational structure, so does Apple, saying, "THIS is the direction we are headed in", and that is more or less reflected throughout these organizations. The strength in this is that everyone is working toward a common direction and goal.

The Linux community is anarchy. A good project may wither on the vine simply because the guy heading it had a kid or is going through a divorce. Another project in competition may not be as good, but may become dominant just because it has more support behind it, for whatever random reason. Finding a trustworthy opinion on which way to go is also a crapshoot - You may get horrible advice from a well-meaning idiot who SOUNDS credible, or you may just not google across the GREAT advice and assistance from a true guru.

THAT model will never work for a general consumption OS. It may have a lot of subtle advantages - but being easily applicable to a general audience of home/small office desktop users isn't one of them. And if I were a vendor or builder, the support headaches associated with that would ALWAYS make me shy away from offering Linux. I might offer BARE systems that you can install whatever you WANT (unsupported), on - but even then, from a small retail perspective, there are a ton of headaches with that. e.g., "My Wireless doesn't work, and I want a hardware warranty repair on my machine" - turns out that you end up having a tech spend hours to determine that the consumer's version of Linux doesn't support the wireless chipset he bought. Who is responsible for that? What does it matter if at the end you have a dissatisfied customer bad-mouthing your sales and service because they picked the wrong machine and put the wrong OS on it?

by Member 19291532

Actually, an EEE specific Xubuntu, I believe. And it did install well, but no wireless. The PC701 wireless seems to be one of the more challenging wireless NICs for Ubuntu (although Wireless in general seems to be a bit of a challenge for Ubuntu across the board - much like ATI chipset GPUs are a monkey-wrench for Ubuntu).

I'm not a fan of the Xfce Windows Manager. Actually, it LOOKED pretty nice on the eee PC as a Win32 look alike interface.

There was some major "dealbreaker" for me beyond the wireless and the Xfce interface, though - I just can't remember what it was.

I installed 5 or 6 different distros about a dozen times total in the last 5 days during Christmas vacation. So I can't remember all the details of those candidates that didn't make the grade. :)

by Member 19291532

But...

I did assign one of my desktop support engineers to look into Ubuntu awhile back as an alternative OS. I don't want to give out any proprietary information - but we use a VPN client from a company who has a logo closely associated with a famous bridge... :)

Anyhow, that company has a linux VPN client available I believe. Either that or there is a built in package in Ubuntu. He and I installed and played around with that, as well as with the Citrix client for Linux through VPN, and had pretty good results. He spent more time on this than I did, I just remember getting the package installed, configuring the VPN client, and being able to connect and "do (most of) those VPN things" I might want to do.

What are the specifics of the VPN you are trying to set up? If I can't help you, I bet there are a bunch of people here who can.