Discussion Locked

Use of infos found on the Intranet

0 helpful
12 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I'm unsatisfied about the salary, especially after seeing a documnet listing the salaries of other employees....but....i could see it only because i am the network admin!!!!
How can i use those figures in a discussion about my salary??

12 replies

by gadgetgirl

- unless you can think of a justifiable reason for being able to access and read them in the first place!

The only way you can make a pay comparison is to quote the figures for compatible jobs, whether internal or external to your particular organisation. Or, if you can find a decent recruitment site which users a "salary checker" use that, and use the print out as evidence of your low pay rate.

GG

by wayne m.

My advice is to immediately delete any copies of the salary document and edit your post to remove any references to reading it.

Using that document will not help you negotiate a better salary and will more likely lead you to being terminated. You have been given a position of trust as a network administrator and by accessing data not related to your job, you have violated that trust.

Talk to your boss about your job performance, ask for ways to improve, and ask for increased responsibility. Leave it to your management to provide an acceptable salary and benefits. If they can not or will not, then look for new employment, but do not snoop into information that you should not access.

by aazpf1

Thanks for your advices.
actually it was not snooping but a desktop i had to fix and user left the file (with an obvuious name) on the desktop...hard to resist!!!
anyway thank you for the advices which will follow even though reading the file made me feel upset

by charliespencer

As soon as you bring those numbers up, you've endangered your job. Part of working in IT is not just knowing when to keep your mouth shut, it's knowing not to go where you shouldn't be. Get some professional ethics.

by stress junkie

You explained that you happened to see this information in this post:

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-11181-0.html?forumID=6&threadID=183694&messageID=1874081

You gave the post the name "no snoop but poor user attention". Are you kidding? The user may have expected you to act ethically. You say that the file name made it hard to resist looking at it. If that's the extent of your self restraint and ethics then you should't be allowed to work in any job that requires confidentiality.

When I had a military clearance you needed more than just the clearance to see confidential information. You also needed to have a reason to know the information. That meant that you couldn't just say "I have a clearance so I want to know this or that". Other people were supposed to ask you why you needed to know the information. BUT, there is also the expectation that you will not ask about things that you don't have a reason to know. This expectation of self restraint is, I think, also a part of any business environment. Just because you have read access to a file doesn't mean that you should look at the contents of that file.

If I had a way to contact your employer I would let them know all about this. You are too immature and immoral to hold any position of trust.

by tigersharkjs

I am not trying to lecture but it is unethical to use that kind of information for your own personals gains. It could really do damage to your position in the company if they knew you knew that kind of sensitive data and try to use it to your own advantage. I am in the same position and I have a lot of access to very sensitive information but you may want to consider updating your resume if you are not happy with that company.

by dc guy

It's impossible to resist absolutely every temptation that comes along in life. I'm sure we've all done something that is just a little bit over the line.

The user could have left that document up on his screen and you couldn't help but see it. Stuff like that happens every day.

But this is where DISCRETION comes in. If you had inadvertently seen somebody's bank statement or love letter or doctor's bill while you were administering their computer, would you run right out and tell somebody? Would you volunteer the information if it seemed germaine to a conversation with your boss? (Let's assume for the sake of argument that personal use of the computers is permitted so the employee was not violating any rules.)

I hope the answer to that question is NO.

Well then the answer to this question is the same.

You are in a position of trust. That means you never tell ANYBODY what you see. Not under any circumstances. Period!

But you ESPECIALLY don't exploit that information for personal gain. That is absolutely unethical!!!

I'll have to agree with the consensus here that your sense of ethics needs a little improvement. But I'll give you the benefit of the doubt. You're young (I assume), and like most folks who choose careers in IT, your "people skills" are a little weak. And to your credit, you didn't just run off and tell the boss, you asked us for help.

So... assimilate the information you've acquired today and go back there and become a more discrete employee. Your boss will be able to sense that and maybe he'll give you a raise next year because you'll deserve it then.

The reason you shouldn't tell your boss about this is NOT that it won't help your career and might actually damage it. The reason is that it is WRONG! Once you understand that, you're on the right track.

by platformrogue

When I used to do Sexual Harrassment policy training we used a concept called one moment of stupidity.

A "One moment of stupidity" is the following: You tell a dirty joke to someone who finds them offensive, most of the time if you sincerly appologize to that person and never do it again, everyone will move on.
Now somethings are too far gone for the one moment of stupidity to cover and I always covered that in the class.

In terms of IT ethics in your current job, I think if you're lucky this can be your One moment of stupidity.

If you don't talk about the incident, do your best to forget the details you saw and do not use any of the data you saw this MIGHT go away.

I say might because even if you do the above this might come back at you. The file could have been a plant to see if you'd open it. Even if it wasn't a plant, the user might notice the file in their recent documents area, even though the user doesn't remember opening the file.

As network admins we're exposed to all sorts of info but we rarely know all the details behind that data. Your looking at information and using it out of context is dangerous. The document you looked might not have been the actual salaries but instead could have been:

* an old proposed budget
* a "what-if we had done this" scenario
* a planted fake doc to see if you take the bait
* a document with errors
* a document that counted additional factors into the salaries such as health care costs.

Please take whats been said here and in other posts and consider it.

by tonythetiger

is that some people worry more about what they haven't got than what they have.

Unless you're talking about government employees, what someone else makes is none of your business. It is unethical for you to possess the information, and it would be unethical to try to reap any benefit from the possession of this information.

Forget you know it! If you want to negotiate a salary increase, do so based on what you can do for your company, not what someone else is making.

by aazpf1

Well, i guess yur replies are intended to make me understand that is REALLY REALLY wrong: ok, i got it.
Look that i haven't searched the intranet for it, it was just on a desktop! Ok wrong, i know, but, wit woas just like calling to be opened!
And also, i haven't mentioned anything to anybody i would never do that. I was just looking for an advice!
How can you keep working happily when you (now ) know somebody who works the half of you gets payed more?

by charliespencer

"How can you keep working happily when you (now ) know somebody who works the half of you gets payed more?"

Why bother? Get the old resume together and burn a few vacation days on interviews.

by aazpf1

that's what i 'm doing Palmetto...
I got the point of the discussion.
At the ned, yes i saw what i shouldn't have to but nobody knows and will ever know it.
I keep it for me as of course i know it is a private document...as i always did

This discussion is closed to new replies.