Discussion Locked

Users complaining of SPAM

0 helpful
21 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hi ~ I administer/supervise a network for a public school district. I have tried to explain to users ('til I'm blue in the face) that SPAM happens. Aside from warning them about distibuting their e-mail address etc., etc., they continue to be inundated with SPAM and PHISH attacks (like myself!). What are some responses that have been used with computer/e-mail users (without being too harsh) to get people off of one's back!?

Thanks
Tim

21 replies

by gralfus

We just started using a McAfee anti-spam system, and it seems to be working well. Occasionally traps good messages, and a couple of icky ones still make it through, but they can be added for future blocking.

by old guy

or at least some time of stand alone Spam Firewall. You really need a separate firewall along with the Barracuda if you can swing it.

This is an email I sent out to my users that seemed to help and you are definitely welcome to use it, or any part of you would like to.

To all:

As you know, we have a Spam filter on the network that will block a lot of spam and objectionable email from getting delivered to you, the user. In order for this to work there has to be certain key words entered into the Body filtering list, or into the Subject filtering list. Unfortunately, there is no way to keep all such emails from getting in. If you have the filtering too constrictive it will block a large number of legitimate emails from getting in also, which could adversely affect our business. I have added certain keywords as we go to block. There have been some words, such as, cialis that I?ve had to take out of the block section because it was blocking any emails that contained the word specialist. As you know, we have specialists here on staff so those emails can not be blocked.

I certainly understand the detestable and repulsive effect opening some of these can be. Unfortunately, the Barracuda can not catch all objectionable emails from getting in. There are two things that you, as an email user can do when you receive an email like these. One let me know about it and I will try to find some keywords in the particular email to add to the Block list. Two you can delete the emails either before opening it, if you realize it?s spam or objectionable, or delete it after you open it and realize the same.

Just please be aware that if we could stop all the bad emails from getting to you we would. However, that is not possible so keep in mind there will be times when you may stumble into an email that will be repulsive to you. In that case, just delete it, and for those who pray, pray for the one who sent it.

Also, keep in mind that if someone you have emailed, or are expecting an email from, tell you they received a notice from [our company] that their email was blocked but shouldn?t be, please let me know and I can go into the Barracuda and have it delivered. There is also an option to allow specific email addresses that have been blocked to be allowed regardless of the content.

If you have any questions about this please let me know.

Thanks,

(Your Name here)

by old guy

Also, it is your responsibility to continue to train your users how to avoid Phishing and viruses. I realize it gets exasperating sometimes but this is what we are being paid to do and we need to patient with our users. Just like fighting Spam and viruses is a never-ending battle, thanks to the self-centered, malicious, idiots that keep writing the virsuses, so is teaching our users.

by cactus pete

Teaching the users to not give out their addresses, and not allowing the addresses to be published ANYWHERE on the net (good luck there) will keep down the spam. But once it's out, it's out.

So we use an appliance from Tumbleweed to filter spam. In addition to using sbl, it uses ai to determine if the message is spam. The users can make their own settings, and they get reports once or twice a day, as appropriate.

by sterling "chip" camden

We subscribe to postini:
http://www.postini.com/

Have been very happy with it. The default settings work pretty well out of the box, and users can tweak those as well as specify senders or domains to accept or block. They catch most of the stuff before it even gets to our firewall.

by bschaettle

Our site has about 800 email users, and SPAM was just about overwhelming us. Since we started using Postini, SPAM has dropped to near nothing.

by Member 30634329

We've used Postini for the last couple of years and have been very impressed. It catches 90% of the SPAM before it hits our email systems. And the best part is with our lean staff there is no hardware to manage and configuration is easy.

by lhatcher

We have been using Postini for about a year. In the beginning it was great, caught everything, but now we are noticing more spam coming through, but still worth the money.

by av .

If they get spam, don't open it - delete it. Spam is a part of life, so they need to become savvy about handling it. Send them an email with an article about the percentage of email that is spam in any company and they will realize that whatever they get pales in comparison.

I use GFI Mail Essentials and Mail Security for spam. It has many options and Bayesian filtering that works well. Generally, people may get 3 or 4 pieces of spam each. It works great for a small site, but if you have more than 50 people its too much upkeep.

We're looking to outsource spam management and considering Postini.

by dfirefire

Most of the solutions given here are targeted for corporate networks. For home users and people who like cheap (free) but effective solutions I recommend Spambayes for Outlook users, or Mozilla Thunderbird for the rest. Just type the names in your search engine for download locations...

by matthew yurksaitis

Tim,

In considering the question you posed, I have a few questions which came to mind prior to recommending a response to your user audience.

1. Is there a Acceptable Use policy in place for email in your school district, as well as an acceptable use policy for use of the schools network?

2. If there is acceptable use policies in place have the users acknowledged reading them?

3. Is there any Anitvirus, Pop-up blocker, Spyware and SPAM control software deployed on the districts network? or are there such filters in place on the core net devices such as routers & switches etc..?

I ask all these questions prior to suggesting a response, because the appropriate response is dependent on the answers. If none of these are in place then the net is wide open to these vulnerabilities and the user audience in large is not educated on this. In this case the response would be one of educating the entire user base, advising them of acceptable use and that an acceptable use policy is forthcoming, and that security is everyones job and that you need thier help in protecting the schools network.

If the policies and protective software are in place then the response would be more one of violation of acceptable use policies and placing the network at risk, and that such activity is monitored, tracked and violators may be subject to disciplinary action.

Either way I believe that telling users to "get off ones" back would do more to inflame the user base and not alleviate your fustration or additional work.

Just some thoughts which I hope help you in your efforts. Let me know how decided to respond to your users.

by elinder

Two-pronged approach to alleviating spam consists of not inviting into the workplace in the first place (enforcement of an acceptable use policy) coupled with technical solutions. You're the first of several replies to even mention this...

by tobe-soft

Period. That's it. Nothing more to say. Just blame the users for going to sites they shouldn't have on the company (or state's) time and you'll see a lot of the compliants start to disappear.

by dfirefire

It's a bit short-sighted to solely blame the users. The Web is full of traps and pitfalls, and not only do those things reside on x-rated sites and such. If spiders are allowed to index page content, so can anyone. How hard is it to program a crawler to search for e-mail-adresses? How easely can some databases be cracked to reveal adresses? It has become a business, so you can be sure that people are investigating methods to acquire e-mail-adresses in various ways, without the knowledge or suspicion of the everyday users...
Sure, anyone who has friends sending their and others' e-mail-adresses in the 'TO:' section in order to spread jokes and such can be pretty sure they'll get offers for viagra over time. Always insist that they either delete you from the jokelist or use the 'BCC:' section (not completely waterproof though).
A good Web Developer nowadays will hide e-mail-adresses on his sites, using a button or hiding part of the adress (like TR does). Always notify the webmaster should this not be the case.
So don't blame everything on the user!

by tobe-soft

I kind of did that reply tongue in cheek. I know a network administrator who would do something like that to get people off his back. It?s not at all ethical, but its works. He did nothing but sit on his ass while the network assistant did all the work. I?ve never been anyone that the T1 connection got blamed for so much. And any problems he couldn?t blame on the T1 connection, he would throw money at it by bringing in outside help. He?s an expert at directing blame and dodging responsibility, yet with all of this, he still has a job.

I guess I should have included these points in my last post.

by tatsnice

Although this does not eliminate all spam, changing the email address in the browser to a nonexist such as not@home.com stops collection of email for distribution or advertising if the user clicks on a download link that leads to an ftp site, or http download site which requires an email to access.

Most sites are only looking for a name@domain.com or something similar, doesnt care if its actually real.

Another real effective way to control spam, is to eliminate or restrict access to the internet outside of the domain to a few select ppl who really require it.

I know of a few networks where internet access has been restricted and virus's, bandwidth problems, spam has dropped by 50% over a year period.
Spam filters have dropped the rest of the attacks down to almost nil.

Good security management, social engineering, go a long way.

by pscheuer

We use Lightspeed from www.lightspeedsystems.com

It does a great job of blocking spam.
We tried Barracuda but weren't happy with it.

There are many, many features in Lightspeed. One of the nicest features is that the user receives an email message showing any email that was blocked and gives them the opportunity to still receive that mail.

Paul

This discussion is closed to new replies.