Discussion Locked

Vista...a victim of Mac Propaganda

0 helpful
19 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I?ve encountered many IT professionals who espouse the usual and safe ?windows vista sucks? line but when challenged to be specific about the objection, they regurgitate end user experiences that I find lacking in substance. In my almost 20 years of working in IT I?ve never seen such a pile on mentality resulting from what I see to be a brilliant Mac propaganda effort. Don?t get me wrong, I have no love affair for MS these days and find myself using Linux more and more but to say Vista is not a good product just seems disingenuous. I?ve been using vista since the Beta, rolled it out to 60 plus users without a single lock-up or blue screen, was XP or 2000 without blue screens? Be honest. Most problems I encounter are the result of software venders that have not even elevated their product to Windows 2000 logo certification much less giving us something to work with on an increased security platform like Vista. Printer driver problems were the only legitimate challenge for Vista but most of those were the junk personal printers that have long been the source of garbage software.

For years we found ways of dealing with poorly written software requiring elevated rights, ini files in the windows directory, profile ignorant etc. on the XP platform and now we have to find ways to make older junk software work with a platform that everyone wanted, ? a more secure operating system?. But we could always take the easy way and just get a Mac, after all that leopard has no bad spot?right?

19 replies

by tony hopkinson

No we didn't. MS provided them. Backwards compatibility was their mantra, (and market wise a great strength)

Software vendors are business's, do you really think they are going to spend a great deal of resource preparing for a possible change in windows? Who was going to pay for that? What wouldn't get done while they were doing it?

I use Vista at home and at work and I like it, however I am aware of it's downsides. You appear to be saying because you didn't have any, there are none, which for someone who claims 20 years in IT, is fatuous at best.

by outofcontrol

I respect your differing view on this point but that is no reason to question my credentials. 87-93 installing and supporting Small business accounting systems, 93-98 Internal IT staff for 1000 node Law firm supporting DOS, WP5.1 platform on Novell 3.11 migrating to Windows 98 with Novell 4.x, 98 to present, MCSE consulting firm specializing in Law firms.

Many programs were developed before spyware was as big a menace as it is today and because of this elevated privileges were assumed then, in fact it?s quite common to be directed by application support to give a user administrator rights to run their program. Giving an end user full local admin rights is just asking for a compromised computer. A responsible Network administrator does not take the easy way out, they pin-hole security areas to allow these programs to run. That is what I was referring to when stating we found ways to make them work. Backward compatibility has almost nothing to do with it, its security, spyware, viruses etc. that necessitate a stronger operating system and that means software venders need to keep pace.
I understand that Software Vendors are businesses and that it is costly to re-code for a new operating system however most are not even in compliance with Windows 2000 Logo certification, saving quite a bit over the years I think. I notice many software versions are subsequent to the release of Vista rather than version updates, infusing more revenue. Misleading information like windows compatible is common where logo certified is in rare.

by tony hopkinson

Definitley an alternate reality though.

Spyware was developed, after MS opened up the entire OS to a browser.

Windows still has no privilege separation, UAC in Vista is simply a more restrictive permissions overlay emplaced by MS to force custoners to pay ISVs for compliant software, so MS coulod have a hope of moving on and starting to compete with vastly superior architectures

by charliespencer

Copy and paste that first paragraph to your TR User Profile in the History section. That way others can check your background before responding to your posts, and you won't have to periodically repeat the information.

Microsoft should deny 'Vista compatible' certification to any application that requires Admin privileges to run, even if it's required for only the first run. It should also deny it to any app that doesn't require Admin privs to install.

by tony hopkinson

Can't see single one that indicates you know anything about software design, in theory or practice.

Your posts tend to confirm this impression.

The task of keeping code upto date with windows version could indeed be beneficial in the long run. The bean counters though don't think long term so unless an OS release breaks the application, they will put off the work until it does.....

So you won't pay for it, they won't pay for it, it don't get done. It really is that simple.

Nothing to do with lazyiness, incompetence, politics, lifestyle, propaganda....

Simply business as usual.

by jmgarvin

A) Software companies need to make money and will not invest in the kludges and workarounds that MS provides unless there is ROI attached.

B) For all MS OS's (including XP and Vista), MS has made it quite difficult to code securely or smartly. They've ensured developers use poor coding practices in the way they refuse to change or update their OOOLLLLDDD security model.

So:
"I?ve been using vista since the Beta, rolled it out to 60 plus users without a single lock-up or blue screen, was XP or 2000 without blue screens? Be honest."

This is a pretty damn sad metric. The fact that you have to COUNT ON blue screens shows just how far we've NOT come.

"Most problems I encounter are the result of software venders that have not even elevated their product to Windows 2000 logo certification much less giving us something to work with on an increased security platform like Vista."

Because:
A) There is no ROI in it
B) Vista has a stupid security model
C) Vista is STILL a moving target (read SP1)
D) Software companies that are MS Gold partners are still not Vista certified because MS has made it damn near impossible.

by the scummy one

3 needed to be rebuilt within 3 days, 1 (one of mine) decided it could not boot anymore and had to be rebuilt, and 1 had to be rebuilt before I finished building it.

I would say that you were lucky as I am at 50% rebuild within 3 days.
however, the 5 that did not rebuild have had few problems I will admit.

by jdclyde

My gaming system at home would be hard pressed to be a word processor with Vista.

clearly there is something going on with MS that they would make this unworkable on older systems. Kickback from Dell, dude?

by jck

I have a dual-core 64-bit Dell laptop with 2 GB.

Vista still runs slow on it.

In fact, their last set "recommended" updates?

It hosed something with Windows Firewall. And even though I have Windows Firewall disabled (because I use a better product), it takes about 2-3 minutes to load now at boot, tying up all sorts of hard drive access in the process.

Ack...Linux needs have native Windows games support so I can just quit paying MS...dammit.

by jdclyde

:D

Time to Downdate back to XP and watch that puppy fly!

Why do people ACCEPT that crap?

We have seen the previews from YEARS ago on how Vista/Longhorn was suppose to be. It was designed ON the older equipment to run, so why at it's release did it turn into such a bloated pig?

Thanks, but no thanks.

by charliespencer

If Vista is a 'victim' of propaganda, it's not from Apple.

One source is Windows XP users who attempted to upgrade to Vista without doing the required background testing. There's a great free tool on MS web site that will check your hardware and software for compatibility. If you buy Vista without running the compatibility tool first, I consider that your problem. It's no different from buying a new engine for your car without first checking to see if it will fit. These unhappy upgraders are the source of a lot of fussing.

Second, propaganda came from Microsoft. Their various "Vista Compatible" and "Designed for Vista" designations confused consumers about the minimum hardware requirements to EFFECTIVELY run the operating systems. Their documented collusion with hardware vendors resulted Vista being pre-installed on hardware it had no business (literally) being on.

There are other problems besides the propaganda issues that have caused Vista problems. First are the hardware requirements that many regard as unnecessarily high. Second is the lack of a "killer app" requiring Vista as it's OS. Third was an initial lack of hardware drivers, but that should have been expected by anyone with experience of previous intial releases of Windows versions. Fourth is an incompatibility with existing business applications.

Mac sales are driven by those who use applications that require a Mac, those who purchase other Apple products (iPods, etc.), and those who like to be different and 'cool'. These people weren't going to buy a Windows system in the first place. Some recent Mac buyers are disgruntled Vista users, but most of them are opting for Linux or remaining on XP instead.

Many users who purchased Vista pre-installed on adequate hardware are quite happy, especially those with compatible existing software. Typical human behavior is to complain when unhappy but normally to remain silent when things work properly.

by jck

Under Vista SP1 with the latest updates applied, I have these issues that I do not have on XP Pro x64:

Slower boot time
Slower GUI performance (even with transparency turned off in Vista)
VS2008 locking up (and having to Ctrl-Alt-Del it) or erroring out
Slower wireless network recognition and connection establishment

I don't know about security issues and all with Vista. I've not studied that.

However, I just know that Vista is not a great performer speed wise. It is bloatware, to say the least. If you don't believe me, just look at Task Manager in Vista vs XP Pro. Compare the number of service processes and system applications that run.

Maybe if they get Vista more efficient and stable, I'll be happier with it.

by jck

that's what's causing my Media Player to be so slow...it's doing checks or something.

I swear...it just kills me.

by jck

Like I have mentioned before, I bought the thing from Dell.

a) It's a 64-bit laptop, but Dell would only offer me the 32-bit OS with no chance to update later. Why the 32-bit OS? And I quote the Dell representative I spoke with:

"We don't 64-bit drivers yet for Vista."

b) When I bought it, Dell had switch over to "Vista only" on their PCs. Of course in June 2007, they went back to offering XP on "certain models". My laptop was one of those. Would they give me XP? No.

Given, this was over a year ago. But, at least they should have let me "sign-up" for a free update to 64-bit Vista later or let me have XP Pro 64.

Next time, I'll demand Kubuntu. lol ;)

by jck

just as soon as you white folks send me my reparation check! :p lol

Actually found a Toshiba I like, but the video card isn't upgradable :(

by cognos

I'm thinking not so much. MS has bungled a lot of things prior to the advent of Vista. So maybe Vista is suffering from MS's bad rep.

Apple has taken much longer to develop OS X that MS has Vista. They are smaller and have less money I'm sure, so that's probably one reason. The other is likely that Apple controls the hardware underneath the OS, so they have to accommodate a much smaller range of contingencies in terms of hardware. They can also ensure (to a degree) the performance of the hardware. MS kinda has to deal with everything under the sun, which makes it tough -- to their credit.

Apple also has well-defined standards and strong documentation for developers, and a very powerful framework for application development. This has been around since OS X was first released, I believe. The .NET platform *finally* provides the same, and I am glad to see it finally maturing. (I'm not forgetting COM or Win32, but let's face it, they were tedious and difficult, much as was programming in OS 9, the predecessor to OS X.)

OS X is built on top of a kernel that's much older than the NT kernel. It's been around longer and is more mature. On top of that, Apple seems to take much longer to test and develop its OS's than MS. (That's my perception -- I'm writing this response because I'm procrastinating on a large coding project...if anyone has hard numbers, by all means...)

I think this all boils down to a personal choice. For people like me, who code in several languages and have to manage everything from networks to development efforts to desktop support, I find the Mac more flexible. Certainly easier to use, what with spaces and the like.

I'd much rather manage Macs than PC's -- but that has more to do with OS X' UNIX heritage than it does with the brand itself.

This discussion is closed to new replies.