Question Locked

What are your experiences with limiting concurrent user logins?

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

What are your experiences with limiting concurrent user logins from anywhere in the domain? Netware has a feature which allows administrators to set users or groups to limit concurrent login sessions. Microsoft's AD does not have this feature built-in.
I have explored 3 MS AD solutions and I am wondering if anyone has any experiences they'd like to share about these only solutions that exist:
a) Free TechNet LimitLogin utility (new does not require client)
http://www.microsoft.com/technet/technetmag/issues/2005/05/UtilitySpotlight/
b) Free TechNet CConect.exe (older requires client)
http://support.microsoft.com/kb/237282/en-us

c) Limit Logins 2.0 by Sonarware (requires client)
http://sonarware.com/index.php?limitlogins

We must limit concurrent logins and it would be great if someone that has experience with this could share it!

5 replies

by chrisb2003

We attempted to find similar applications. I tried using the free limitlogin utility from technet, but could not get it working correctly. (maybe because i have a small brain :))

So I tried limit logins from sonarware. I have not purchased it yet, but have been using their 30 day trial. After installing, I had a little bit of a hard time knowing what to do, but after printing out their instructions, I was able to install it correctly.

We have about 200 machines consisting of mostly windows xp computers in a single domain environment. It seems to work well at doing its job.

One thing i especially like is seeing which computer the user is on. One handy little tool it has is the remote execution. I have used it a few times to run remote defrags on all user's computers. Within about 40 seconds, I had all 200 computers defraging!

My users started calling me at first with questions on why they can't login to some computers, but after a little explaining the phone calls disappeared, and they were able to figure out how to clear their own connections by logging out of their computer first, before logging into another computer. Also, we tell our users that they need to shutdown their computer at night to save power. I'd be surprised if half of them listened. I set the limit logins utility to shutdown the computer everyday at 7pm, just incase they forget. Works like a charm.

All in all, I'd recommend this solution.

by wsimbanegavi

The only frustration with this tool is that you can't delegate clearing mutliple logins to any other users except Domain admins. I would like Helpdesk stff to be able to perform such tasks without getting excessive permissions. Any suggestions on other tools?

by famigorena

A couple of remarks to begin with:

- LimitLogin is not compatible with Windows Server 2008 and Windows Server 2008 R2 and is incredibly cumbersome to deploy and administer.

- Cconnect offered limited and poor functionality and is really complex to implement. It even introduces new breaches: with very limited skills, it is possible to carry out several successful attacks. These attacks let an unskilled user log in despite CConnect measures, gain sensitive information, and finally run a Denial of Service attack (!!!).

If you're serious about limiting concurrent logins to your Windows network, you should give a look to UserLock (fully compatible with Windows Server 2008, including R2, and Windows 7), that allows IT security teams to:
- prevent or limit simultaneous logon (same ID, same password), per user, user group or Organizational Unit
- record all session logging and locking events in an ODBC database (Access, SQL Server, Oracle, MySQL,???) for future reference
- monitor user sessions in realtime (who is connected, from which workstation(s), for how long???)
- remotely lock, logoff and reset all interactive sessions
- define working hours and/or maximum session time for protected users and disconnect users with prior warning outside of the defined timeframe(s) and/or when time is up
- restrict user group???s network access per workstation or IP range
- notify all users prior to gaining access to a system with a tailor-made warning message (legal disclaimer, etc.)
- ???

Detailed info and fully-functional trial:
http://www.UserLock.com

This discussion is closed to new replies.