Experience is great and is usually preferred over certifications since it deals more with the real world. It usually tells what you can actually do.
Certifications are an indiction of what you are knowledgeable about and to a lesser degree what you can be expected to do without a lot of extra training.
Certifications should be selected to match your career goals. By looking at where you wat to be, you can determine what certs to go after.
Generically, the industry is hitting big on network security, wireless, and small office and home (SOHO) networks. I would check out the Security+, Server+, Linux+, and HTI+ certs. Since you already have 4 years experience, Network+ will probably not help you much.
If you are looking for a move into the WAN area, the CCNA would be a great place to start. If you like security try the CISSP cert after the Security+ exam.
Most of the employers that I have talked with insist that a college degree is weighted more heavily that certifications. They say that experience first, education next, and certifications third.
An AAS degree from a technical college in an IT related field would be my suggestion along with the pursuit of certificationss. The more qualifiers you have the better chances you have at landing your "ideal" job.