29 replies
by notsochiguy
...you just found the newest bookmark for defense attorneys across the country!
;)
by geek3001
It could ground certain types of DNA evidence while creating a whole new underground industry.
Imagine buying 'decoy' DNA based evidence on the Internet and making sure that it gets left behind at the scene of a crime. If done correctly, you would hide the real evidence in a massive 'haystack' of fake evidence.
And for a few dollars more, the 'decoy' evidence could be used to finger people who might be better suspects. (The DA, your local politician, the head of the local gang...)
by notsochiguy
I was actually thinking about that, too.
If this is as simple as the author implies, I could see mobile labs going around the country, setting up shop for a few days in some parking lot or rest area, and then going on to the next town.
Meet the snake oil salesmen of the 21st century!
by boxfiddler Hot topic
by ksoniat
by the maverick phantom wanderer (formerly macoza, nodice, kp, etc.)
...many cases that were decided mainly through DNA evidence should be looked at again.
*Paranoia mode on*
I'm taking extra precautions in order to prevent anyone from getting a sample of my DNA. (No one's framing me, EVER.)
*Paranoia mode off*
Tserugenen Macoza
by tonythetiger
How do you know they don't already HAVE a sample... just waiting for the right time to use it? :)
Do you collect your hair clippings after getting a hair cut?
by av .
If they wanted a pure DNA sample, they could take it from you when you're born, without your consent and anybody knowing. They might already be doing that and who knows for how long. :O
Theres no end to the number of ways they can get your DNA. Now I'll have to start using my own carefully guarded cup to drink from wherever I go. :^0
AV
by the maverick phantom wanderer (formerly macoza, nodice, kp, etc.)
I always collect my own hair clippings.
Also, the paranoia mode was obviously a joke.
by netman1958
by av .
Criminals always seem to find a way to beat the system. I think fabricated DNA has to be detectable though. If Nucleix can provide a valid test, that would be one for the good guys.
AV
by gsg
1) it's got to be enormously expensive
2) I'm sure the local yokel who's planning to kill his wife/girlfriend is going to know this is possible, and actually call someone up and ask them to fabricate DNA (sarcasm)
3) DNA alone is not enough (usually) to convict. You still have to have other evidence to support the case.
Yes, eventually the price will come down, and I'm sure that defense attorneys will use this and someone will get off somewhere, but unless its an actual DNA scientist, who had the ability/technology to manufacture the DNA, well I seriously doubt that would be plausible. AFter all in the U.S the person is innocent until proven guilty beyond a REASONABLE doubt. I'd say this comes under the heading of Unreasonable doubt.
by oh smeg
Would lack the Ability or Technology to Fabricate Evidence to get a conviction would they?
Just like Organized Crime lacks the ability to boil down Flu Tablets to make speed. :D
Seems that is is just a improvement on the [b]Good Old Verbal[/b] of old if you ask me. ;)
But you are right those who commit crimes in the [b]Heat of the Moment[/b] are very unlikely to even consider Fabricating Evidence as they have never done this in the past and are unlikely to consider doing it in the future as once they start planning something it is no longer in [b]The Heat of the Moment[/b] it becomes a Conspiracy. :0
For instance the person accused of causing Grievous Bodily Harm to another and the only evidence that placed him at the Scene of the crime was the victims blood over his clothing. Of course it's perfectly normal for the Victims Blood to contain DNA from more than one person as they had to have a Blood Transfusion while they where undergoing Emergence treatment to stop them dieing. The blood found over the Accused Clothes was the same as was found in the victim after the Transfusion so the Accused must have snuk into the Hospital and beat him up all over again right? Of course the fact that he was in Custody at the time didn't really mean anything other than he's also an Expert Escape Artist. After all what other possibility is there to explain this evidence? :^0
Col 0:-)
by oh smeg
All new Born's have their Umbilical Blood stored for future unknown use.
But the reality is that they don't even need that just a very small sample of the Placenta would be sufficient to construct a DNA Data Base of all new Born's and hence that individual for their life and paternity Testing for any offspring.
The bits left over for normal life make a perfect Sample Gathering place to start looking for the required Samples for Big Brother to build a similar Data Base if they wanted to. ;)
The more complicated that Technology gets the easier it is to fake things. :D
Col 0:-)
by av .
I don't know how long storing umbilical cord blood has been an option in the US.
My concern is that you could unknowingly become part of a DNA database just because you were born. Isn't your placenta your property? Shouldn't it be private and not government property?
AV
by hal 9000
Under Law the Mother is normally the owner of the New Born. ;)
As for as far as placenta's are concerned they may belong to the Mother even though they have the genetic code of the baby but most hospitals insist that anything that they remove becomes their propriety to do with as they please.
I think that is their way out of that and there is technically nothing at all stopping them starting a DNA Data Base of children born in their faculties. They could even perform Genetic Testing on the Placenta charge the Mother as she is their patient for the tests with the covering idea that they are making sure that the new born is healthy and doesn't have any abnormalities which require some form of treatment. Parents will accept that happily, but then there is nothing stopping them sharing that information with who ever pays for it or they chose to either by Law or their own Personal Preference.
I believe that DNA profiling is done with every Genetic Test of this type of Material and it's the DNA profile that the Genetic Test Results are tied to.
Nice though isn't it? :D
Col
fake evidence has been supplied in crimes before now. All that's new is they can now build it, instead of steal it, if they know your code. The planting of finger prints, hair samples, and other forms of identification has been going on in some criminal matters since the first crime was ever committed, as new ways of ID come along some one plants that to blame another. There have already been rapes when the rapist planted semen from someone they hated to implicate them in the crime.
So my answer to this is
whoopy do.
Dr. Frumkin is a founder of Nucleix, a company based in Tel Aviv that has developed a test to distinguish real DNA samples from fake ones that it hopes to sell to forensics laboratories.
by jck
If I have a widget to sell you that I want you to buy, I can tell you that a problem is there and rampant and gonna get you too.
Ever thought of what it takes to engineer the number of DNA samples in a drop of blood for a crime scene?
Taking G, C, T and A from a double helix and recombining it to design isn't simple as doing Rubix's Cube.
It's cool they've developed it, but I don't think Mark Furman hired genetic engineers to fabricate OJ's DNA.
by tonythetiger
[i]If I have a widget to sell you that I want you to buy, I can tell you that a problem is there and rampant and gonna get you too.[/i]
some people don't seem to notice the same tactic used by the government :)
by jck
by locolobo
If I want to implicate you in a crime, then it would be far easier to obtain your DNA (hair, skin, etc) and plant it at the crime scene.
To me, this article does open up the question of HOW did the DNA get to the crime scene in the first place? This is something that should be considered in any criminal investigation for any evidence.
by boxfiddler Hot topic
by tonythetiger
by jck
Not many thought I was any good because I came from rural America.
Of course, I was one of the top local computer nerds as a kid that other kids' parents called to help them with computers. :^0
I got to Florida and did the black box work, I did things and improved processes that most other corp jobs would have given me "quality improvement" or "performance" bonuses for.
Instead, I watched management get big bonuses and take trips while guys at my level were all whacking away at blown timelines to get things in on schedule due to...poor management.
That's why I don't go into mainstream work with a corp anymore. If I really put out 100% effort again 5 days a week and got no rewards for being top performer again like in the past, I'd just give up and go work in sanitation or something.
Being all that you can be anymore is not worth the effort. Efforts more often than not lead nowhere.
by seanferd
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending Web Development posts
Sort by Trending