Discussion Locked

What is better? Single Sided vs. Double Sided DIMM?

0 helpful
14 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hi out there,

I am into fixing an old PC to give it to a friend (Fujitsu-Siemens, PIII, ATX, D1107)and I am about to buy a 256MB-(168pin,PC133, CL3).
Could anyone pls tell me what is better a single sided DIMM or a double sided?

Thanks

Callie

14 replies

by dryflies

DIMM is Dual inl;ine memory module with the dual meaning both sides of the DIMM have chips. I know, some of them only have chips on one side but that is because higher densities are making that viable. there is really no difference, get either.

by dryflies

DIMM is Dual inl;ine memory module with the dual meaning both sides of the DIMM have chips. I know, some of them only have chips on one side but that is because higher densities are making that viable. there is really no difference, get either.

by wmr029

From personal experinece, as long as the module is of the right type physical other characteristics (such as wether chips are on one side ot on both sides) will only be a factor in actually fitting the module into the computer. I have had cases where a DIMM with chips on both sides was too thick to sit properly in to the case.

by softcorp.us

Hello Callie,

As the others have said here, there is nothing inherently better about chips being on one side vs. both sides.

That said, not all DIMMs that appear to have the same specs are alike. Many PCs using PC133 RAM cannot use DIMMs that are made using "high density" chips. For those PCs, the DIMMs must be made using "lower density" chips. And, in order to get the large DIMM sizes that people want these days (256MB in one DIMM was huge when your PC was made), there must be so many "low density" chips that they must be physically arranged on both sides of the DIMM in order to physically fit.

Recommendation: Go to crucial.com and buy your memory there. They have a nice system that determines the correct memory for your PC. And, they guarantee compatibility.

Disclosure: I have no relationship with Crucial :-).

-----Steve Jackson

CEO/CSA
Software Corporation (Softcorp)
http://www.softcorp.us/probono
Advanced pro bono tools and utilities free for personal use

by willcomp

Most PIII mobos require low density RAM. Some will work only with single density and some accept double density. There are no single density 256MB modules that I know of (would take 32 chips). A double density 256MB module will have 16 chips and be double sided.

Single sided 256MB modules are quad (high) density.

What is you chipset? If it is Intel 440BX, 810 or 815, then low density is only option.

Advice to use Crucial's selector is sound.

You may be able to find used memory at a considerable savings. I'm seeing quite a bit of PC100 and PC133 RAM on the used market. Most is either single or double density.

Dalton

by thechas

Callie,

I am going to disagree with the previous answers.

For your specific situation, I would buy DIMMs with the RAM chips on both sides.
It's not a question of "better", but which style is more apt to be compatible with your hardware.

The older the motherboard, the more finicky it is about just which DIMMs will work with it.

I keep a 128M double sided DIMM on hand for sanity checks on older PCs. I have yet to find a motherboard that it would not work in. Except for some old Pentium boards that had 64MB limits on the DIMM capacity.

The SDRAM DIMM specification has evolved over time.

When the quad density DIMMs first came out a few years ago, they did not work in anything but the newest motherboards.

As to the definition of the dual in DIMM meaning that there are chips on both sides: WRONG!!!
The dual in DIMM refers to the socket having dual rows of in-line pins.

I have a number of old 30 and 72 pin SIMM (Single In-line Memory Modules that have chips on both sides.
However, the SIMM socket has just one row of mating pins.

I do agree with going with name brand memory from Crucial, Kingston or PNY.
So long as the system or motherboard is in their database, you are guaranteed that the memory you buy will work with your hardware.

Chas

by thechas

I disagree with answers 1, 2 and 3.

Answers 4 and 5 are just as sound as my response.

There is often a delay between when a post is made, and when it appears to other peers.

Bottom line:
Play it safe.
Either get the double sided DIMM, or go through one of the major RAM suppliers.

Chas

This discussion is closed to new replies.