Discussion Locked

What is happening to TechRepublic?

0 helpful
42 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

You know, there was a time that I would come to TR because I would look to my peers to help resolve IT issues or to discuss professional subjects in a mature and conversational way. So what has happened and why do I feel so obscenely let down by TR?

Here is a clue. It is a question on the forums now: "Group Policy - How to configure". A question from an "IT Consultant" in India. Or maybe a question like "How do I program in C++", this time from Pakistan. Perhaps something like "How to configure a Cisco router" from an African state.

I use to try and offer assistance to these people but I started getting bombarded by emails from these people/criminal organisations and two phishing emails and three pharming emails got to my inbox from these TR members.

My question is: Has TR become a platform from which to launch attacks, maybe even using social engineering in the form of the forums to met their ends? I have the feeling that it has. I also believe that TR is not fulfilling a committment to weed out these miscreants. Does that sound harsh?

I try and protect my computer at home as well as I can and never open dodgy attachments etc; but when I see something from a TR member sending me a personal message, it makes my skin crawl now. I can guess 9 out of ten times what the content will be.

Does anyone else feel as I do and does anyone feel that TR, a once fantastic site for techy people the world over, could do more to return the site to its former glory days?

42 replies

by kevaburg

I have answered a couple of really dumb questions with what I hoped were helpful and polite answers. Before I knew it I had three emils from that person in my Junk mail. All were exactly the same, simply sent three times.

It is beginning to annoy me.....

by ansugisalas

Would it be possible to give the recipient of a peermail the option of replying with a non-identifying blanket reply of "please post your question on the forums, I will respond there", or something to that effect, that doesn't expose the members mail?

by ansugisalas

I'm glad you posted your concerns, it made me think about things. Like, I decided to change my username from the default, because, while it doesn't show the whole thing, it's still one step closer to compromising my mail account.

by cg it

goes with ethics.

Other than that, only you can decide what you want to do on Techrepublic.

by charliespencer

I don't open any correspondence from a TR member I don't recognize. It gets Alt-Delete'd without a second thought. With rare exceptions, I restrict my assistance to posting on this site.

I don't open e-mail that started as a discussion. In addition to the security issues, it strikes me as rude to take the conversation off-line. It deprives future readers of possible solutions.

Questions like the ones you cite have been posted here for years. If anything, I think the 'How do I hack a password' ones are at a low ebb right now.

'Glory Days' are always 'former'. You never hear anyone describe anything as being currently in its 'glory days' (except derivatives managers).

by santeewelding

You are happening. I am happening. The others are happening each in their way.

In other words, and for my part, nothing is happening [i]to[/i] me. I'm doing it.

So are you.

So why are you laying it on TechRepublic?

by kevaburg

I think someting could be done to stop these spammers from ruining the purpose, or at least trying to ruin, that TR exists.

They should be able to filter these spammers and exclude them from the forums for example.

I used the term "what is happening to TR" simply to demonstrate that I feel that a change is occuring to the site that shouldnt be happening and it is stopping some people from answering posts they may otherwise be able to help with.

by nicknielsen

As long as the site is open to the public, there will be spammers. You've got a better chance of removing stupid drivers from the highways than you do of eliminating spammers on TR.

Spam has been a problem on TR almost since day one. I can't find it now, but I remember a long discussion from several years ago in which the regulars discussed several proposals for reducing the site spam. I believe the result of that discussion was the "Mark as spam" link.

The same steps that will reduce spamming will also reduce general access to the site. As others have pointed out, that would not be good financially, and I don't think it would be good for the site in general. Best thing to do is just roll your eyes, mark the post as spam, and move on.

by ron k.

I think that once all is said and done and the final analysis is resolved you'll be at the heart of every problem. You and your cockroaches.

by kevaburg

The only problem is that the questions (at least in the title) are begining to sound intelligent.

At least until you get to the body text.....

by ron k.

Don't reply.
There are only 12 or so people here that can send me an email anytime and they don't need to use peermail.
If you want to answer questions go to the questions forum.
You don't OWE an unsolicited TR peermail a reply. If they keep it up use their email address to sign them up for a free laptop or something.

by cg it

At one time I thought about answering them with smarmy answers but then I'm waisting time.

Not going to waste time on time wasters.

by neon samurai

If they are sending to you through the TR private messaging then they should be limited to the basic email it sends. Maybe they are including links in the message box that get sent on. Have you reported specific users to TR?

Another option may be spoofed sources. I'm not sure how they would get your email originally but after that they could simply be mucking with the email header to appear as if it's from TR.

(now to go see what other's speculate)

by kevaburg

but then I haven't delved too deeply to look. I will do though because it certainly sounds reasonable....

by neon samurai

I've become familiar with digging into email headers due to work needs. You can see some interesting things; it'll show the sending domain and related IP. I've actually seen the "domain" shown as my mail server's IP though they could not forge the related IP listed beside it.

In Outlook: open email, View -> Options, Internet Headers. Copy All, paste to .txt and have a good read.

I'm not sure how TR's outbound filter is so the possibility of them simply pasting code into the message body field exists.

by michael jay

over time. If you are getting peer mail from someone you don't know or trust, just delete or post it for a few laughs.

TR is still a great place and like any great place some riffraff will sneak in and post BS, but don't let it get you down, it is just the nature of the beast.

by av .

Answer them on TR instead. Then they don't have your email address and they can't spam you. You have to be particular as to who you respond to if you receive a peermail.

I always thought it would be nice if peermail responses didn't include your real email address, or maybe it could be a choice whether you want to or not, but I don't know if TR could do that.

TR is still a fantastic place and we're making "glory days" all the time.

AV

by charliespencer

is that it can be difficult to the discussion that prompted their message. I dislike starting a new one just to tell some twit where to get off.

by av .

Its better than never answering the peermail and its anonymous.

AV

by Tammy.Cavadias

If you feel someone is abusing the peermail system by using it as a means to harass/offend or in any other means that would violate our TOS, you can report them peermails to myself by forwarding me a copy with the full headers to tammy.cavadias AT cbs DOT com

-Tammy

by .martin.

have got a thank you (or maybe a few?), and one abusive peermail, but no spam.

the site seems to be going that way, we seem to be getting more spam than we used to, so this might be the next step.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

awhile back, then leaving a post stating how long the thread took to load. I got several smartass responses telling me to butt out of 'their' threads. :^0

by nicknielsen

One, reply to the peermail via post on TR.

Two, if you must reply by email, use a throwaway email address.

by kevaburg

Actually if I wasn't so lazy I would have done that first off! But it is an interesting subject for those on the receiving end of stuff they don't want so could this maybe be written up as an article?

by neon samurai

Sounds like a Michael or Chad request to me though it may fit into Michael's current trend better unless it relates to Chad's last spam filter article.

by charliespencer

While the majority of poorly worded, uninformed questions appear to originate on the Indian subcontinental area, we've had twits from all over the world.

We suffered an attack of potty-mouthed Irish kids around Christmas '07 or '08. They disappeared when school started back up.

There was an invasion of rude 'anonymous' idjits during Jason Hiner's 'President of the Internet' discussion, and a wave of them combating with Scientology defenders before that. Unruly posters from both groups originated in many countries. None of them were TR 'regulars' per se; they spotted a couple of 'hot button' phrases they apparently search for constantly and came like flies to fresh cowpats.

We've had obvious homework questions from most English speaking countries.

For a while we had a rash of "I bought / was given / borrowed (read: stole) a computer and 'forgot' the Admin password" nonsense from right here in the Good Ol'.

by hal 9000

I'll answer your unanswerable question Tomorrow.

You'll have to wait till tomorrow comes though. ;)

Col 0:-)

by neon samurai

It may have already been mentioned but a method for replying through TR would be ideal as it removes the external email from either end. Something like Facebook's internal messaging may be overkill but a link in the email that says "click here to send a reply through peermail" or some such would work.

This discussion is closed to new replies.