Discussion Locked

What is it that I saw? IS it true?

0 helpful
20 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Is there any possibility to drive a car with water Like being claimed here? http://bit.ly/8uOh1i

20 replies

by deadly ernest

the best way to use water for energy is to use a power cell and break the water up to hydrogen and oxygen and use them to create electricity, the way NASA has been doing in space vehicles for decades. There are some cars out there that do this already.

As a normal rule water will NOT work ion a petrol or diesel engine as it isn't volatile enough. however, if they have a method to break the oxygen and hydrogen out, and add that to the petrol as gases, then you could see a better performance. BUT, I don't see that happening without you having to install a specially designed motor to handle it as it's a lot like the way racers use nitrous oxide to give their cars a boost - it works, but the car has to be specially set up for it and not every engine can handle it.

I've seen these ads around for about twenty years, and if they really did work that well, many of the government agencies would be using them, yet none are, nor are any of the green movement people - and all that makes me want to have a huge block of sale handy when I ready such ads.

by Member 25348569

And the basic petrol/diesel engine doesn't have to be particularly modified. The key is the fact that the propagation speed for the hydrogen/petrol mix is higher than that for petrol alone so that the ignition point can be advanced for the engine to closer to Top Dead Centre and there is less wasted energy on pushing the piston up against the igniting fuel. The fuel burns quicker, the engine is cooler and more efficient. It also extends the catalytic convertors life.

I looked into something similar a while ago and if I hadn't had a car with injectors - much more expensive to tune - I might have given it a try as it wasn't particularly expensive for the unit and we do have petrol at ridiculous prices.

Even a 5% saving and it would have paid for itself in no time.

Neil :)

The main problem for me would have been in resetting the Engine Management Unit computer as it would have had no idea what was going on.

by jamesrl

whether the energy used by the engine to create the hydrogen is less than the "extra" energy the vehicle can use by burning the created hydrogen.

James

by hal 9000

Will determine what is going on by analyzing the exhaust gasses and modify the amount of Fuel that is injected.

The higher the Oxygen or Hydrogen content in the Inlet Manifold the less Fuel will be required as the Oxygen supports combustion much better than what we know as Air.

Personally here I think most of the improvement comes from adding Oxygen the the inlet Manifold rather than any marked improvement from adding Hydrogen as a Additional fuel.

The down side with stuff like this is that it drastically increases the potential for Fire under the Bonnet and if it was to work as advertised you would need a considerably larger supply of Water to break down with the Electrolysis method being used here. Also if you used plain Tap Water the additional Minerals/Trace Elements and so on in it would build up on the Plates rendering them far less efficient than they where when new. So you would need to use Demineralized Water which is a lot more expensive than Petrol at the moment. Or incorporate some way to effectively clean the plates. ;)

You could get a Performance Increase by just using Water Injection into any conventional Engine without any additional Danger being created under the bonnet.

The Aero Industry has used Water Injection for years now in Aircraft Engines without a issue. The only possible problem with adding water injection to cars is that with the additional need for another liquid container in the car the problems associated with Surge will be increased so the Water Tanks will need to be heavily baffled which will make then rather expensive. ;)

Col

by boxfiddler Hot topic

there's only so much potable water on this planet. We humans can go without food longer than we can go without water.

Fueling my vehicle with that which is primary necessity to my life is pretty damned stupid if you ask me.

etu

by hal 9000

The byproduct of combustion is water. :p

So you are not actually using any water as it is reclaimable after it is burnt.

Not even the Stanley Steamers had a efficient way of recovering used water that allowed them a decent range so they where effectively of no use for anything longer than a City/Town Commute.

Col

by jamesrl

They built one from the manual, set up a test rig and saw no improvement in fuel economy at all.

James

by tig2

Covered a car in clay that they then dimpled like a golf ball. That DID improve fuel economy.

I love Mythbusters!

by nexs

Seems a bit dodgy to me... Reminds me of those ads that say "Give me all your bank credentials and we'll deposit $10,000 into your account each month!"

Though, the technology does exist, but I could imagine it being frightfully expensive...

by .martin.

one of those stupid products they advertise on cable TV (you PAY for cable TV, yet the adds are longer and MORE ANNOYING! WHY?).

I, honestly, would not trust it.

by Member 25348569

The key - as I said above - is the fact that you can advance the ignition timing because of the flame propagation speed of air and hydrogen being so much greater than igniting air and gas or diesel. You waste less energy forcing the pistons up and over the top of the stroke against the combusting fuel. A couple of degrees will do it.

It's not really about the fuel but about efficiency. Well-designed petrol (gas) engines generally run at about 20-25% and up to 30% if very well tuned, diesel as high as 45%. There is plenty of room for savings in there.

Neil :)

by jamesrl

To create the hydrogen and how much gasoline/diesel fuel it costs to create it.

Would the additional load be more than running the AC on high? In my minivan, thats worth 2-3 MPG, or about 10%. Would I have to get a heavy duty alternator?

There are many questions to be answered.

James

by jamesrl

If I overinflate the tires (from the factory 35 to 40 PSI) slightly I get better mileage and better handling.

James

by Member 25348569

what I want is what I can get from good driving and good tyre pressure PLUS what I could get from an engine that's as efficient as it could be.

:)

by hal 9000

Infernal Combustions Engines are a lot of things but Efficient isn't one of them.

Col ;)

This discussion is closed to new replies.