Question Locked

What PSU would you pick?

0 helpful
21 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

How good it is to find TR! Having never gone further than installing a DVDRW drive some years ago I recently tried to do the same in my 3 yr old machine but instead the whole system just died. After reading so many similar stories and replies I summoned up the courage and took everything out of the case and then used a PSU from an old machine to ascertain that it was the PSU that had stopped working. I have reinstalled most items and it still fires up on the old PSU but I need to buy a new one, around 400W should be fine.
Are there any brands to look out for or to avoid and, apart from getting the right connections any other considerations.
One other question, if you don't mind. The power/reset button switches the computer on but does not switch it off as it did before, no matter how long I hold it in. Is there something I may have altered inadvertently.
Thanks for any comments that you may have.

21 replies

by rob miners

Check your Motherboard manual for the pinouts for the Reset and Power switches. To test a switch swap it to the power connector on the Motherboard.

I always use Antec Power Supplies as they are in my opinion the best on the market.

Have a look at these to give you a guide. I would be looking at 550-650 Watts.

http://www.antec.com/Believe_it/product.php?Series=MjQ=

by b.confell

Thank you for your prompt reply, sorry to be slow in responding.
Re: the switch, I have tried it on both the power and reset pins and it only switches on, not off, on both. That must mean that the switch itself works though, I believe?
Thanks once again

by rob miners

if I put something together for a client I want them to get the longest use out of the System that I can possibly provide. With a relativly expensive Motherboard I look at the PSU as an investment that will protect and prolong the life of the Motherboard. So far it's worked for me.

by thechas

As far as power supplies, I agree that Antec is one of the top vendors.

I would not be afraid to use Thermaltake, hec, or PowerMax brand power supplies.

It is actually getting hard to find aftermarket supplies as small as 400 Watts. Do not be afraid to buy a 500 watt supply.

As to not shutting down properly, if the front panel switches are connected properly, the problem is with one of 2 things.

Either the shut down circuit in the power supply has failed.

Or, the power control circuit on the motherboard has failed.

A new power supply will fix the former. A new motherboard would be required to fix the later.

Chas

by b.confell

Thank you for taking the time to reply.
And though I may not be enthusiastic about the possible need to replace mobo as well, it's better to know in advance.
Thank you again

by oh smeg

Only Power Supplies worth putting into a case as far as I'm concerned.

Col

by vendril

I am currently using a Thermaltake PSU and have not been dissapointed.

by oh smeg

one of the big ones is that the Wholesalers that I deal with don't sell these which is sort of important but the really big one is that I have seen the results of a High Voltage Line coming into contact with the Mains Power Lines when a Tree fell onto them in a severe storm.

The PS in question sent about 18 inches to 2 feet of Flame out of the Fan Opening setting fire to the curtain behind the computer which was a bit spectacular but considering that there was now 33,000 Volts Involved the computers reaction was fairly minor compared to every other electrical device in the neighborhood did a similar thing before expiring and heading to [b]Silicon Heaven[/b] the Electric Stoves where quite Spectacular I should day.

Anyway the Computer in question was good and properly dead when it was inspected and the Insurance Company insisted that I try a new PS in the thing to see what if anything happened. I didn't expect anything at all to happen except maybe the destruction of a otherwise perfectly good PS. But I was wrong the Antec Earthworks PS that was in that unit sacrificed itself and saved the computer it was still working faultlessly 3 years latter when it was decommissioned.

That was the only device in the entire Neighborhood that survived the "Electrical Event" and by all rights it shouldn't have. The only reason that the insurance company was so insistent that I try this was because of the cost of recovering the Data off a dead HDD. It was a company Server and after that the Company itself and the Insurance Companies involved in covering for this type of event only specified Antec Power Supplies as their Approved PS.

Not something that I would recommend to do to see what happens but it was interesting none the less as it shouldn't have worked again. Prior to that I got a computer in from Townsville where the Electrical Contractors when replacing a Transformer from the Overland Transmission Grid into the Domestic Grid incorrectly connected it back-wards so instead of stepping down it was stepping up to something like 111KV that also was apparently the only survivor from that Incident.

Personally I don't need any better test to see what will protect my systems and in the event of a PS they should self destruct and prevent high voltages inside the case. With the Cheap PS's I have seen cases of Mains Power getting to the M'Board and Drives when one failed in a server and sent Mains Power out over the Network Lines destroying everything connected to the Network. That server was then less than 10 days old and was a very expensive repair.

Col

by balge

hi
please be aware, brand names are not the only way to specify equipment - just saying 'so and so is the best' is meaningless - most manufacturers provide a range of different equipment at different price points, you need to decide how much to spend and on what -e.g. do you want a particularly quiet PSU, or are you stone deaf? affects your costing, no?
Do you need PCI-e power connectors, etc. etc.
Also specifying by just one value e.g. '400W'
is not really helpful, like buying a car by its colour...
check this out -
http://www.firingsquad.com/guides/power_supply/

ref your last, not sure what you mean, is this the first PSU or the second one? If your switch does not turn off PC presumably either the switch is duff/sticking or you may have altered power management settings in OS or BIOS? Do you get a message saying 'safe to turn off now'?
cheers

by b.confell

Thanks for replying and I recognise what you say is valid. However, I have read though the suggested link and am afraid it's a bit beyond me. My simple strategy was to go on the conservative side: 400W is higher than the 350W that was originally fitted by Evesham and a reputable,(but not necessarily "the best",)PSU manufacturer should ensure that I don't end up with something that looks right but doesn't perform adequately. Actually, since my original post I have been on the Corsair website and they offer a good PSU selector guide for noddys like me. Suggestions for my setup range from 400W to 520W.
Re: not switching off. This has only developed since I have used the old PSU to ascertain that there is life in the system yet. As it is only a 90W PSU I have only connected it to show that the fans come on and the HDD begins to spin. I'll have to wait until I get the new PSU and then can report further.
Thanks for your help, and thanks to everybody that contributes this great site.

by kingbackwards

2 feet of flames out the back?

That sounds more like a cooling issue to me. Maybe you should have gotten a bigger fan for the case. Antec makes so nice fans also.

by oh smeg

You would have seen that the unit was feed 33,000 Volts not the 240 that it was designed for due to a incident with a power supply failure.

Personally the 2 feet of flame that was shot out the back was more likely due to the air flow that was created by the Antec Fan being directed that way. But on the other hand insignificant things like Electric Stove Hot plates exploded and had bits embedded int he ceiling. Those Glass Cook Tops do leave something to be desired when things like that happen. :D

The TV's involved also set small fires. :^0

Col

by kingbackwards

I was trying to make a joke.
Flames = heat. Fans = cooling.

Sadly I guess my humor was lost.

by skdtech

But I do see the point you are making in favor of Antec and will definitely consider them in the future. The real question I would be asking in these stories though is that considering these were servers, presumably critical to operations, what were your surge suppressors and UPSes doing while all of this was taking place? It is my understanding that any UPS worth its salt is supposed to protect from overvoltage situations as well as loss of power.

by oh smeg

The other one was a domestic system in a domestic setting that got hit during a thunderstorm.

However the Server which set Mains Voltage inside the Case was on a APC UPS and that was destroyed when the Monitoring Cable passed Mains Voltage to the UPS over the Monitoring Lead.

Even still with these extreme events happening I never really trust any Surge Protector to actually do as it is claimed to.

I have Surge Protectors on the Mains here that supposedly stop a Lighting Strike at 100 Meters. But that by no means, means I want to test that claim. When there are Thunder Storms here I unplug everything it's just safer and easier that way. ;)

When you look at a lighting strike there is a Raise to over 400,000 Volts in under a Nanosecond and most of the better surge Suppression Systems take 1.5 Nanoseconds to trigger so for at least 0.5 of a Nanosecond full voltage is going through and this destroys things. ;)

Even with the Tree Falling onto the overhead lines the rise time is instant then it drops off and starts to raise again till the Electricity Companies over-voltage protection kicks in. Here that means it trips tries to reset 3 times and then waits 15 minutes and tries to reset again. If it is still in a Over voltage/Fault situation the circuits then stay off and they require a person to reset them.

That is a lot of chances for damage to occur.

Normal run of the mill surges will be stopped by most surge protectors event he ones that take 4 Nanoseconds to trigger as these have slow rise times but the extreme events are a different story.

Col

by b.confell

Thanks for your reply. I guess Antec would be pleased to have confirmation of how rugged their devices are.

by willcomp

Antec and ThermalTake are both good. TheChas mentioned hec which are fine except their cheaper Orion line.

Arguably, the top PSUs are PC Power & Cooling but they are a bit pricey for an older PC. Enermax and Seasonic are also top quality PSUs and pricey as well.

This is an excellent replacement and is reasonably priced:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817153023

I can't let all the praising Antec pass without comment. A cap in an Antec True Power PSU failed and took out the motherboard along with the PSU in one of my custom built systems. I wound up eating the motherboard replacement cost and wasn't too happy with Antec at that point. Still use them since Sonata III cases are such good buys.

by oh smeg

After all the Antec Fan did blow out the flame while it was still working. :D

Col 0:-)

by b.confell

Thanks to all who replied. In the end I bought a Corsair HX 450W, that seemed a good price on Amazon and persuaded by one person's review (elsewhere) that it "exudes quality". I received it yesterday and absolutely confirm that review, and it's guaranteed for 7 years!. I installed it and all seems to be well bar some issues with the BIOS but I am going to post a seperate question for that. I tried again fitting the pre-used DVD-RW drive that had led to failure of the old PSU. This time the Corsair just did it's thing and refused to power up, so assume there is a short there, but as soon as I removed the drive it was OK again. The switch issue has resolved itself.
Thanks for all your help.

This discussion is closed to new replies.