Discussion Locked

What qualifications are a useful measure of competence

0 helpful
186 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
The industry is awash now with qualifications costing a fortune to gain - many in boot-camp guaranteed pass training centres. Meanwhile there are thousands of qualified and very experienced people overlooked because they have all the practical skills and experience without the paperwork to "prove" it. What do you think counts most? Practical and proven skills or in-depth knowledge? What qualifications do you find give the best measure of a persons abilities?

186 replies

by jimhm

The training whether it is self taught or class room - then the Experience to apply that training. The paper you are going to get - thousands that have the paper and don't know how to even wipe their butt with it...

The days of past - Paper CNE's - ECNE's - Then it hit the Microsoft world - Paper - had the Cert - but couldn't do a thing with it. "We didn't learn that in class!"

Experience most of the time out wieghts the training - and all the time outweights any paper.

by stevegantt

Neither experience or training will do you any good unless the person can get along with other people. You managers out there need to take a course in behavioral assessment like the C.A.R.E or D.I.S.C behavioral profile. With a little practice you will be able to spot an asset from a "dud". I think the criteia is
1) Behavior
2) Experience
3) Maturity
4) Dependability
5) Formal Training

Behavior is often overlooked, but it is the most essential component when building a team. People have to the able to work together as a team. Training can be done later, experience comes in time along with maturity, but you will find it very difficult to change behavior.

by lfhowell1

...the challenge is that IT managers and recruiters tend to be more comfortable with ultimately focusing the "technical" competencies--whatever that means. Unfortunately, behavioral skills, which includes the ability to get along with diverse people with diverse interests and politics and the ability to inspire people is essential. For example, when you take a look at job descriptions posted and then interview, most of us notice a disturbing trend--the technical skills tend to trump the behavioral criteria. And unfortunately, that is why a large majority of these hires "don't work out" and yet the criteria and the emphasis on what is learned tends not to change. So, the solution is to focus on different criteria up-front in the recruiting process combined with the ability to "apply" technical skills in real-life settings using scenarios to evaluate how someone can respond. The criteria outlined above is absolutely correct. Cheers!

by dogdaze

I see this trend everywhere now. Completely charming people come in the door, well versed in interview techniques (there must be a cert somewhere for that too), and nobody seems to notice much less care that the applicant is really just a bag of wind- all talk, no action.
You end up having to hire, and then fire a really pleasant but ultimately incompetant person, and you become the bad guy.

Apparently the days of I.T, people being brilliant but quirky are over. In all areas of employment we now tend to prefer milktoast personalities with skills to match. "Oh, he couldn't fix it but he was so pleasant!"

Its all about spin anymore isn't it. I look for 'dirt under the fingernails', personally. I'm not impressed with those ten dollar words memorized in boot camp. I'll hire the intuitive tech who can fix it even when he doesn't know what its called.

-D

by dmwoodcock

What mold do you use for behavior. When you are hiring someone to build servers or program routers/switches or program code, you really don't have alot of time to socialize. Let me guess, you are not an IT person, but someone that would like people to walk around all day smiling while the servers go unbuilt and your stock takes a nose dive. When will the MBA's of the world realize that IT people are a different breed and we spend more time working and less time talking about it.

by revblugenes

After managing PC repair, I have had to train four A+ certified people how to build a PC from scratch. And I am not certified at all. Two tech's had no certification and could do it all. I am sure certification has it's place, but experience really counts.

by richfairfull

Good morning.

The original question was how to separate the wheat from the chaff.

Have a conversation with the recruit. Begin with the first job on their resume and work your way forward.

Ask about the wrok they performed then drill into the details of the work. You will quickly be able to make a judgement about the depth of their knowledge. For example if someone lists on their resume MSSQL admin ask if they have installed it, how they installed it, and what they installed it on. While talking about the MSSQL host ask about CPU, disk subsystem, RAM requirements, etc. From their you can branch off into the subject of RAID, etc. I like to try to keep it light, like a conversation about baseball or cars.

-Rich

by luis_a_delgado

I have found that experience teaches how to and training teaches the why. I've been unable to train for 4 years running around converting our shop to cisco, migrating to windows and migrating our email to exchange, and putting new branches online. I have the hands on knowledge, but only an MCP and CNA. Still I can troubleshoot my way around almost any problem. I know of people with many certs that can't even troubleshoot their way out of a room.

by jeff

I have simular cert's (No Degree) and have spent the time instead teaching accredited IT courses, engineering wide-scale global deployment processes and solutions, creating standards, providing engineering feedback and solutioning to MS and our clients and creating solutions for real-world issues not addressed with existing technologies...

Certifications/Degrees would be redundant in the face of experience and accomplishments.

Not that they don't mean anything though. In view of the fact that for myself, I was fortunate (? ;-)) enough to get into the field when it was still in it's infancy (outside of Mainframe systems) and was able to grow with the technology, new people don't have that opportunity, so taking the courses and certifications is the only realistic way of getting their feet in the door
and beginning a career in the field. The trick comes down to being able to seperate those that 'know it all' from those that are willing to learn and listen from those with the experience.

by lutterwortht

Experience is key without a doubt. I've been in I.T. for 10 years but experience stretches to 18 years. I have no "techie" qualifications and time and time again have been amazed at how little consultants (with loads of qualifications) know! I've often dug such people out of holes when they've been paid 3 times my salary! Look for experience and achievement not bits of paper. ARH

by wiggy1948

If experience is the key than why can't I get a job. I have over 23 years of experience at the Kennedy Space Center working as a Technical support analyst for four different contractors. I don't have a BS degree or any certs. I was laid off almost 2 years ago and despite posting my resume with numerous online sites and applying to hundreds of positions I still have not even been called for an interview. It appears that they all want both a degree and certs.

by steve v

I have 6 years EXP in the field now. I started as a PC tech and now I run a helpdesk. I only have 2 certs NT4 and Win2kPRO. I have learned that I have been able to get jobs not based on my certs but on my EXP. Companies want to know what you have worked with and how you have handled certain issues and situations. A lot of past interviews I have seen a greater deal of scenario based questions. "How would you handle A if B happened". If you have worked with the product before in the past you should be able to answer the question. Trying to seperate the wheat from the chaff can be troublesome if you do not know which kind of wheat you are looking for. I feel that the best thing to go for is EXP. If I had to choose from a young college grad with a BS in Comp Sci, and 1 or 2 certs W/no EXP. Versus a 21-22 yr old kid with 5-6 years hands on EXP and no formal education; I would take the the latter. The college grad might be smart and have the ability to learn, but then you have to take the time out of your day to teach this will result in loss of productivity. It is better to have someone that can hit the ground running.

by jamesrl

It struck me as I was conducting interviews for a techie recently that there were a lot of people with a lot of impressive certs who couldn't do the job. All a cert tells you is that someone can study and take a test well. Thats not an indication of well someone can apply the knowledege. Give me someone who has a good approach to troubleshooting and I won't worry about his/her cert being up to date. If I had two candidates who I thought were both reasonably competant, I would not use a cert to break a tie - I would look at soft skills.

We have all seen people in jobs they weren't meant for - people on the help desk with good knowledge but bad attitudes and communications skills, desktop techs who I wouldn't let open the case of my computer, people who can't break down a problem. I have to figure some of these people got their through certs.

James

by stress junkie

Ever since I started to prepare for this work in college
I've noticed that there are some people that just don't
get it. They just don't understand how the computer
works. You can walk these people step by step through
troubleshooting and fixing the problem in front of them
but they can't apply what you show to them when they
confront their next problem. They apparently don't
comprehend how all the parts form a system. It's as
if a car mechanic didn't understand that a car's engine
only runs if the fuel reaches the engine and is dispersed
evenly to all of the cylinders and has to be ingited by
the spark plugs, and it all has to work at exactly the right
time in the right amounts. All of the parts have to work
together for the system to operate properly. Some people
just don't or can't understand that principle.

by ole88

I've seen exactly what you describe both in college and at work. I was the one in class that ended up assisting the instructor in helping others grasp what they were seeing. A few would get it and then be able to apply it, but many others couldn't tell a SIMM/DIMM from their aunt Fannie's bobbie pin. It's the ones I run into at work that bother me, no matter how many times I show them something the lightbulb never gets any brighter. We have one guy on our team that came from a non-IT background and has passed many MCSE cert tests and is still trying to figure things out. He has implemented a few things we have no use for just to prove he learned it in cert class.

If you want to hire competent professionals, look for the ones that have an IT/IS degree and 3 or more successful years of experience in the industry.

by lwilliam

I have always said it takes a certain "orientation" toward the world of computers to be successful and truely enjoy the field. The ability to troubleshoot and understand the whole data/pc/network/infrastructure process is an intangible that people either have or they don't.

by csobott

First measure the person.
Second measure the experience
Third measure the education
Fourth measure the willingness to verify all the above

by i call it as i see it !

It is indeed a crazy world we have come to live in. I worked in IT for many a year from the early 90's on and was able to do so without one certification. Over the past two years things have changed quite a bit. While a lot of jobs have been lost due to econonmics, corporate america has become obsessed with certifications.
There was a time I could send out one resume and get 20 calls, now I send out twenty resumes and get no calls. The art of hiring by corporate america has been left to so called technical recruiters and computer wannabees who at best can't spell computer. We are however left at their mercy to be chosen or not for whatever positions are out there. In the event your are selected to be "presented" to a client you still have to get past the hiring paranoia. In that I mean you sre generally are being interviewed by someone who is in fear of losing their job to the person they might hire. So does the best man win. NO. I know even as a consultant I was asked to do interviews for prospectice hirees. Most employees are not capable of conducting an fruitful and unbiased interview and most are simply untrained in the art of the interview.

by jamesrl

As a former techie who is a manager of techies, I am not at all paranoid about hiring someone who might be able to replace me. Any manager who does have at least one person in their group who could step up to the plate if needed is not doing their job. You can't get promoted if there is no one who can replace you.

My company does do a lot of training in the interview process. We do have good interviewing techniques.

But the interview isn't usually about technical skills - that should be evident on the resume. The interview is to uncover soft skills - how well do you work with others, what are your work habits, how do you handle conflict. I've seen some technical geniuses hired at other companies who were fired for being abusive towards their peers - you would like to think you might uncover some of that kind of attitude before you hire.

I too struggled after being laid off in 2002. I applied for the few managerial jobs out there - didn't get many calls. I applied for technical jobs, but because I had been a manager for a while, they felt I wasn't up to date technically. I finally got a contract doing business process analysis. That got me through until my current job opened up.

If you aren't getting hits from your resume, change your resume. Look at the examples at www.aneliteresume.com - I did a workshop with this guy and my hit rate improved a great deal.

When I was working with a major corp, my job was outsourced and I was promoted. Then they experienced issues with the quality of the new hires the outsourcing company brought on board. To improve this, I sat in on interviews for all of the new hires for this group for the region. Having done the job, I had a good perspective. 9 times out of 10, they were focussed on the wrong things - like certs, and not on the right things like time management, follow through and customer service.

James

by nosreppih

Could not agree more. I learnt two importantr things from my management courses here in the UK.

The first is that good management is delegation - never be afraid of hiring someone who knows more than you, your job is to build a team not be the team, your job is not to know but to know who in your team knows.

Second thing is that Delegation is not the abrigation of duty - delegate but you must manage that delegation.

This means you employ people 'with dirt under their finger nails' not that just the theory.

by jimhm

I've seen that - I Call it level setting..

Where a 3/4 knowledgable manager will look to hire a 2/3/4 knwledgable worker (so that the manager isn't shown up)...

Where a 8/9 knowledgable manager will look to hire a 8/9/10 knowledgable worker - to do the work.

This has traspired because management - hire the lower paid technical people... I am in the position right now - the boss that hired me was a 9/10 - I am 8/9 - the new manager is a 3/4 - and has me hidden - so I don't show them up in meetings...

I am just waiting - directors and managers come and go like yesterdays news...

But it's not being paranoia - its the truth - seen it and lived it..

by pgm554

Certifications are like using shine on the bumper of a car to measure how well it works in an accident.

Little, if any, correlation.

I knew that taking the SAT's would come in handy one day.

by jamesrl

I've worked in some pretty high tech companies; software, telecom and nuclear, and all of them acknowledge that managers are supposed to manage - they aren't expected to be as technically competant as their staff. The reality is that there was a time when I was as techie as my staff but without neglecting my management duties, I couldn't possibly keep up - one of the reasons I am here in TechRepublic is to keep up to date.

Are you sure the reason you are not invited to meetings is that you show up the manager? Or is it your opinions are not always phrased in the most polite way. I have had similar situations where a senior techie is seen and not heard because they tend to be disruptive. A good manager will coach someone in that sitaution - a bad maanger will just not invite them.

James

by steven.c.kienle

A lot of posts here have discussed both technical and behavior aspects. I just want to emphasize the personal part again.

There are no projects which are completed by only one person. So I approach the hiring practice by using technical and experience aspects to help weed out the obviously wrong candidates. And I don't use certifications for this. Experience in my business area is also a very strong plus.

Once I have the shorter list, my interviews mix proving technical ability and "project ability." By this I don't mean project management, but:

Will the person's personality fit well into your existing team? The best technical knowledge does you no good if no one can work with them.

How flexible are they? The best technical architect will not work if they cannot accept constructive comments.

How well do they communicate? The best technical people are ineffective if they cannot explain themselves.

One way I've used to help identify some of these traits is asking the following question at the interview: Think back to the worse project you've worked on; explain what went wrong and how you might have been able to prevent it? The answer to this often helps me understand if this is a person who can help solve the business need rather than someone who can just produce really good code which will never be used.

by black panther

A degree is just a background or base knowledge. The sooner management realise that it is not the be all end all the better.

It is a shame that most Govt jobs have mandatory qualifications such as a degree.. sometimes the degree has no relation to the actual job.

Give others a chance.... experience in IT, such as life is far more valuable than a degree.

People who work they way up, have the correct attitude and are willing to learn are a far more postive asset that a person coming out of UNI with a degree, a bad attitude thinking their sh.t don't stink.

***no degree***

by theundertaker

I also do not have a degree, and I find it interesting that "work experience can be substituted for degree". The silliest one I recall is 2 years hands on experience for one year of degree. So... given guidance, a person with 8 years of hands on, real world, firefighting experience is qualified to attain an entry level position beside a 4 year degree'd man. whee...
I am amazed at the IROC's I used to interview that NEVER loaded the operating system much less could answer even basic questions on troubleshooting, but responded with foolish drivel about college.
Now before the flame wars start, I give total respect to anyone that completed a degree (I admit to given more creedence to those degrees that are more technical like engineering, but that is just me). All I am saying is give us 15-years-of-experience types consideration along with those that attended college. That is all...

by mkeilen

Technical skills are so vastly abundant today that they are viewed by management simply as commodity and a cost of business. Information workers are the "factory rats" of the modern age. I have worked in IT for 12 years and have a bachelor's degree in business as well as various IT certifications. Since the boom days of IT have ended, I have noticed a dramatic improvement in the interpersonal and cognitive qualities of IT workers - not from a technical perspective but from a business perspective. The desired IT staff members today are those with excellent communication skills, the ability to manage projects, and the savy to navigate the often complex politics of the corporate world. My view is that anyone complaining about certs and degree requirements is just not getting it. It's not about the knowledge gained from those things per se that matter. Rather it is that they demonstrate an ability to follow through with something to completion, to think in a logical and rational manner, and a desire to do more than play video games in their spare time. It is interesting that those who voice disdain for degrees are invariably the ones whose postings are the most littered with poor grammar and misspelled words. Folks, the days of the hip IT dude who knows it all and arrogantly sits around judging those who really make the business successful are gone - thankfully. U.S. corporations need business minded people with tecnical aptitude to fill their IT strategy positions. Asia is filled with highly qualified technical drones to do the grunt work.

by stubby

It is a shame that you blindly judge all of us who don't have degrees. In fact you called those of us without degrees, arrogant and illiterate.

It is your arrogance that shines through in your posting and whilst some of what you say is true, it is lost amidst the obvious distaste you have for those you consider to be "lower down the educational ladder".

For my part I don't have a degree due to circumstances (yes I'll tell if you want to know but for the thread it isn't important) - I would have loved to have one and to have sat around on my arse for an extra 5 years or so from my O's to achieve this elite status you drivel about. I would have loved to get a higher salary just because I stayed at school and can pass exams.

Instead I worked damn hard for a pathetic wage and have achieved what you probably fell into "just because you have a degree" but not, real world experience.

Please, don't judge me or any other non-degreed folks based on what you think is right.

Where does a degree give you the real world experience that is so necessary?

Where does it give you the inter-personal skills that are so necessary - it may do this, but it is not a mandatory part of a degree as you can be a recluse or party animal and still get a degree.

Where does it give you project management skills?

How does it teach you about complex office-politics? etc ....

I'd wager that the only place you learn most of these skills is in the hard fought front of the office itself.

OK - that's me vented.

FYI, I am literate; extremely well read; can speak Latin (yes still); can run multi-million pound projects and ones that paid nothing but gave a huge local benefit; manage people and still get on with them. I have no degree, 4 O's and umpteen certs BUT above all I value my experience and that of others (call it real world knowledge if you like) above and beyond anything.

by gsquared

(Ironic that a post that contains within it a complaint about grammar and spelling has typos, punctuation errors and a complete lack of that basic concept known as the paragraph.)

Saying that a person with a degree automatically can be assumed to have the persistence and strength of character to pick a goal, stick to it and carry through on it is only partially true.

I've met many a college graduate who had a degree simply because parents and/or the state were picking up all/most of the tab, and four years to a BS was easier than 4 years in the job market.

Sure, there are universities that turn out competent or even brilliant graduates. If you can afford to hire such, by all means do so. (Most have very high expectations on starting salary.)

At the same time, a vast number of people with degrees are just barely good enough at work to be able to remember to ask if the customer wants fries. (A degree in philosopy, while potentially very personally rewarding, isn't an indicator of competence of any sort.)

Interpersonal skills may matter comparably to technical skills if we're talking about a help desk person. If we're talking about a network admin, I'd much rather have an experienced but surly high-school dropout who can keep the network up 99.9% of the time than a highly personable Ph.D. who can only keep the network up 99% of the time. (99.9% = 8.5 hours of unplanned downtime per year; 99% = 85 hours [3.7 days].) For a customer contact position, I'd never even consider the surly guy, no matter how much technical expertise he had.

In conclusion, I'd say the qualifications depend on the job. Blanket statements about degrees, certs and experience that don't take into account all of the skills needed for the job at hand are nearly useless.

by jkstill

It's 'savvy', not 'savy'. ;)

Your argument that those possessing a degree have proven the ability to see something through to completion is somewhat muted by many degree holders.

When it comes to a surprise to you that your co-worker has a BS in CompSci you have to ask yourself "What was he doing all that time in school"?

When a graduate student has to get an undergrad to help create a Makefile, it gives one pause, doesn't it.

This seems to be more prevalant with technical degrees than other, giving rise to the notion that some folks are looking for the sheepskin that is worth the most in the open market.

Aside from medical and law degrees of course, they just require too much time and effort. Too long to market you know.

by dirtylaundry

run-on sentences "It's not about the knowledge gained from those things per se that matter. Rather it is that they demonstrate an ability to follow through with something to completion, to think in a logical and rational manner, and a desire to do more than play video games in their spare time."
misspellings : savy )it's savvy), "business minded people with tecnical aptitude" (oops a typo)
misuse of word: " Since the boom days of IT" it's boon not boom

and by the way, I am not degreed. I build stable, working computers, and have been in the "business" for 12 years - not one corporate company would hire me based on the fact that I do not have any degrees, and I am constantly playing "catch-up" with those that are papered and then receive further on-the-job training and schooling. I have also worked in the corporate world in various departments such as mailroom, order processing, proofreader, and accounts receivable for 9 years. I cannot afford college and am 35 yrs old. What I know has been self-taught. I do lack knowledge and experience in Networking and that may be my biggest drawback, but nothing that couldn't be remedied with support and subsidizig from a worthy employer that is not caught up in degrees. I have not been that lucky.

by steve v

for the reasons of this posting. A degree is not related to making a good decision to hire someone. What matters most when trying to bring someone in for a position is their prior knowedge related to the role the will be filling. If a comapny needs a SQL person they will not hire a someone that has only cisco EXP. If a company needs a helpdesk tech to support 6 different apps then they will look for someone that has prior EXP with those 6 different apps. If a person has a degree, all that tells me is that you went to school for 4 or 5 years. It doesnt tell me that if a office user has a corrupt PST file I can tell you to go run scanpst on that and you will know what I am talking about.
When I started in the IT industry I had no prior work experience in the corporate world. I had to learn all those "complex politics of the corporate world" by myself. Want to know what i used to accomplish that? Common sense.
I went to work and I treated people the way I wanted to be treated. With respect and professionalism. It didnt take sitting in a classroom and hearing some dude lecture me on interpersonal skills to do this.
Also the ability to think in a logical and rational manner also falls under the common sense area. When you work with networking and PCs you will learn that everything works in steps. You can't do B without doing A first. If it takes a person 4-5 years to learn this concept, then by all means stay in college and get as many degrees as your logical and rational heart desires.

A degree would be necessary if you have a desire to move towards the corporate management side of things. But if you have a desire to remain in the trenches where the actual work is done. Then it can be overlooked.

by garion11

I absolutely agree that practical proven skills and experience is LOT more important than any piece of paper out there. But the HR people that hire these techs don't know any better. They want to see the paper first. An MCSE is like a college degree for these HR people before you even walk in the door. In some cases a college degree is more important (of which I partially agree) than an MCSE of which I am finding out (I went back to college).

So if you have the experience and skill set, get that certification. It won't hurt and it shows your knowledge on paper.

by rr-travis

Degree vs Cert will this ever get laid to rest?

We've all seen the college grad who couldnt troubleshoot IP to save his life. And we've all seen the paper cert without the conceptual overview. Even more unfortunate we've all seen the guy with years of experience who coulnt match wits with the previous two.

To get in the door you need all of the above or to know somebody.

Most of the degree holders I work with (CIS) dont have a clue. But thats because their trained as programmers and many of the skills they offer to the position dont apply to managing the network.

by dharker

As said in the replies we have all seen the guys who have excellent theory and no practical... and vice versa. I agree you should go out there and get the paper if you want to have the best chance. With the certification process getting more complex and costly though what qualifications do people have high regard for in for example the networking/computer support arena? Is MCSE the Holy Grail? Or is something like Network + more practical and trustworthy? What about the MCSA and MCP qualifications?

by jfister_state of nh

Practical experience is paramount, while certs are just icing on the cake. You should make sure the interview process asks questions based on history of experience. This approach will decrease the chance you will get "snowed" by the jargon or personality.

by youngri

There used to be a saying that those who could
were CNE qualified, those that might were MSCE
qualified.

One of the most important qualities in a
candidate now is their ability to approach an
issue with a business focus. The days of techies
that sit on information, who don't share or
provide documentation are long over.

A prime candidate is one who has worked within
several different industries with a variety of
software platforms. They have usually had to
work on interoperability between these disparate
systems and as such can think outside the square.

Microsoft qualifications can not possibly tell
the whole story, and people who have only
specialised in them are generally limited in
focus and vision.

You need to look for people who if a workstation
appears to be non responsive are more likely to
check that the cleaner hasn't unplugged it rather
than attempting to reach for the re-imaging disk.

Just my two bobs worth.

Richard.

by ole88

I would say that the certifications, experience and background you need to look for depend on your architecture and the job openings. If you are hiring a network engineer and you run Cisco equipment, you don't want to hire someoneone to manage that gear that has an MCSE - it won't apply - get at least a CCNA. Microsoft's certs that cover networking are flawed from the Cisco or Nortel standpoint - they only apply to Windows based systems. Look at how long they have been working in IT. The biggest problem I see with degrees is that hiring managers will bring graduates of their alma matter on board before they bring someone with experience. Also, if you are hiring for entry level, go for the good candidate that just graduated and/or just got their cert - you can mold them.

by rob.lay

I'm not gonna start preaching, I'm not in a position to do so. I'm 22 and been working in computers for 3 years, so I have some experience, I know how to go about troubleshooting, have some practical skills. BUT - I learnt alot of what I know from other people who you can't be sure are doing it right, and also does experience always guarantee an understanding?? I don't think it does, I had to go and study for the CCNA before I understood how networks worked properly (in the basic sense of course) and I now realise that what I learnt didn't really ive me an indepth knowledge. I'm now studying for the MCSE and have found that some of what I have learnt from other people isn't right. When I come to look for a new job I hope that people will look at both my experience (what little there is) and then say "ok, well its good that he has the certs to back up his experience"

by dshaw1

It depends on the job context. In my very specialised IT area, several years of front-line experience is necessary before you can be productive. So, in hiring, I look for those scars. I don't care how you won them.

In other areas, paper credentials are more important. Overall, I always look for people with a problem-solving mentality and a business orientation. Both of these are rare.

by makariusdc

I agree in both cases, howerver given the candidate has some of the experience, has the paper credentials, technical, and business skills, what about self motiviation and desire to learn. These are often forgotten so I always look for these before the others, along with the problem solving, and business skills which contribute the over all health of the organization.

by dannomanno1

I am an individual with a varied employment background in the computer sciences and information technologies. As we all would like to be "seen" as being someone with something to offer, the proof, as they say is "in the pudding".
I have come to realize that integration of a new best practice called "interactive interviewing" pays everything forward.
Having been an applicant at one point in time for a lead network manager position at a local bank, I found myself face to face with true experience; the network itself, and the man in charge of it all. When posed with each illustration and issue, I was offered the opportunity to demonstrate real time within a virtual configuration that was setup. Afterwards, I was hired within three business days once my references were verified. Guess what? I had no certifications, but I had references. So as my contribution to this thread, I say without intent to impress, but to suggest that anyone applying for a position should ask for an opportunity to demonstrate their skills, and that anyone hiring should request the same of the applicant. Have references ready!

Danno

by seasonedsysdba

It all comes down to the skills of your interview team and how clearly you define what the person will be doing after they are hired. There's no easy way around doing the homework and working the interview. (No - Your not getting out of it.)
Interview questions (phone screen and face-to-face)need to ask questions the elicit what the person HAS done in a particular situation and not what they WOULD do. "Can you give me an example of a difficult you handled well?" "Can you give me an example of when you didn't?" How they person handles these types of questions is much more telling about a person that "I would handle it this way...". Just cut off those "I would" answers, they just waste interview time. Now get to work...

by morter

I developed a series of test questions that IT managers can use to assess job candidates or current staff. The testing goal for current staff is to identify weakness that will be corrected by additional/targeted training. Focused training based on employee needs is a better use of IT training dollars than sending someone to a week long certifcation class. Learn what you need!

by jeff

I've been in the IT field for a long time (about 15 years), before there were normally even dedicated positions for Desktop support, and one of the things I find disappointment in is the 'Paper Techs' that get ground out of 'Boot Camps' and college with no clue on how to apply their knowledge to the real world. This can normally only be gained by experience.

Things to look for:

* Progressive job history - has the person advanced within his field and responsibilities at previous employers?
* Personability - is the person able to work with other team members and/or the clients?
* Practical job knowledge - Given a sample real-world problem (from something experienced at your location previously, suitable for the position being filled) have them work out the resolution logically and see how they would solve it

by rosaticrew

I am also of the ilk of expereince without the multitude of certs. I tend to take the courses for whatever it is I am in need of. Courses with certs as has been said can be passed without ever stepping into a real life experience.

Most companies and HR people tend to favor the paper before the experience or worst yet will hire the paper lion who has had a multitude of perm positions but is out for that next pay increase that they wouldn't have gotten staying put.

by michaelpo

Anyone who has posted a job, knows that you get resumes from everyone. You must have something to decide who you are going to interview. Some people use education, some certs and some both. I use both based on past hiring where I have had good and bad from both sides.

To find the best candidate I have a Sr tech do the technical part of the interview. We script the questions for 4 or 5 technologies that are most important to us. If they can answer the first level question they have some general knowledge. If they get that, we ask a deeper question and if they get that, we ask one that only an expert can answer. We grade the candidates on this scale. I focus on soft skills. We have had great success with this method.

by dguyer

Michael,
Your reply and approach is the most rounded I have seen in this entire thread. I basically use the same approach. You have to screen or filter based on degrees/certs/experience, then test that technical knowledge in the interview. But the bottom line is finding the person with the right personality and attitude. My motto is find the person that is passionate but grounded. Behavior is the most difficult to mold. Someone with ambition and desire, but has humility can be taught just about anything.

by mikencove

Certifications that are not backed up by experience are worthless. "Boot camp" certification are mostly worthless under any circumstances. Experience counts the most in my opinion. Certifications are a good way to "round out" a skill set, but prove nothing otherwise.

by rob.lay

I agree totally, I'm in the process of doing that myself. I think the certs are important to reinforce experience, certainly I didn't understand networks properly until I'd done a cert to back up my experience. We employed a guy who had loads of experience and some good references - within a couple of weeks our network had fallen over cos this guy didn't know how to do stuff right, the likes of the MCSE don't necessarily teach the most efficient way of doing things but if you use best practices then they shouldn't cause such serious problems.

by patric.worth

This is a hard subject to measure. FOr I have seen people that had the "certs" but could not figure out how to open a computer much less know what they are looking at. then I have seen people that did not have the "certs" but could trouble shoot and repair a system with just a piece of wire and gum but could not talk to the end usres (you know the ones we are supporting). The only way to know if someone is right for the job is to:
1. talk to them about the resume and experiences.
2. try them out and see if they can walk the walk and talk the talk. For all the schooling means nothing if they do not know which end of the screw driver to use.
3. while giving them a try out talk to your other staff and the endusers for they will get a better view than just yours.

by morter

reviewnet.net, an online technical testing service for HR, offers technical testing for job applicants.

by vlambek

Perfect answer!

The problem is that it's difficult for a manager to execute your plan.

He cannot ask the 20 persons who applied for the job, to each come in for one or two days to see them walk and talk.

You need a shortlist, and a manager base his shortlist on stuff he can see on paper. This is much easier (and less dangerous) than trying out 20 people.

by raycaldwell73

I totally understand where you are coming with this. There are alot of companies that want to see that "paper" and can care less about your expereince which is very dumb and poor hiring choices on their part. I'd rather hire someone who has been in the field that someone who just has a certification and have little or no real world expereince.
I know alot of people that have tons of experience and can run circles around alot of people with certifications (including myself), but companies are blinded by this trend to have "credentials/papers".
If there is a real life situation where a server goes down and the downtime is suppose to be minimal, what is that person with the "book-smarts" going to do? Refer back to Ch.6?!?!?! I don't think so......companies need to wisen up and stop overlooking those who have paid their dues in this field and stop caring about this "certification" crap, because when it all boils down to it, who is gonna fix the situation in a timely manner, or may recongnize the problem because they have been thru this before?

by jamesrl

And I doubt I am the only one.

Most managers didn't graduate university and go directly into management.

I have managed many technical resources, some with and some without certifications. Some I encourage to get certifications, because it may broaden their horizons. Others, who already have been there and done that, I don't bother pushing to get certified. As Dr. Phil would say, the best predictor of someone's future behaviour is their past behaviour - if they are already technically excellent, whats the point in proving they can take a test.

James

by csobott

The best drivers are experienced ones. Plenty people drive without ever taking an exam. But guess what- the cop that stops you wants to see the license. You need a license to get the experience. Would you hire a doctor to do a transplant that never went to med school and only got his knowledge in a battlefield? Hire the person who has gotten the training for the job at hand. Your job as an interviewer is to find out if he has the relavent experience.

by jeff

I agree!

Something also to consider, and I see this often myself, is when there's a serious problem, time/money is at stake, who would you prefer to put on seeing that it get's resolved soonest? The experienced person that has been there, done that - or the newbie that only knows the possible causes in theory?

In the real world, both of these people might be teamed up (staffing permitting) so that

a.) The new person might gain some additional experience
b.) the new person might have some unique insights and/or idea's gained from recent studies
c.) Team building

What I'm trying to illistrate is that Certifications and Experience should be weighed (I give more credit to experience with a progressive work history myself) with interpersonal/teamworking skills for the overall benefit of the group and company.

by stubby

I've been around PC's in the UK since they were introduced - back in the early to mid 80's. Then if anyone said they had experience they were either lying or from the manufacturer :-)

My point is that no-one had experience or certs of any sort so other decisions had to be made on how to hire. Soft skills, willingness to learn maybe, whatever. On the whole management got it right because they had nothing to fear about a clever techie.

In the intervening 20 years I have noticed an alarming trend to favour degrees and certs and now see it from the hiring side. For myself, I'm not anti-degree or certs (I have a few of the later) but they are the last thing I consider in who I hire. As others have already said, I go with the ability to work in a team, with the public, a willingness to have-a-go and others before I get to considering their "qualifications".

I've seen countless people with no degrees, no certs but that can out tech me any day. Then there are those with quals up to their eyeballs that are better than me - but I've equally seen the reverse and in far greater numbers.

Just my 2p.

by randalbin

As far as technical competence goes there is no substitute for real world experience. A degree is an indicator that the person is reasonably intelligent and trainable. A certification is an indication that the person can learn and understand technical information, but it does not prove that they can apply said information. A few other people have suggested carrying on a conversation with the applicant that contains a number of technical subjects and see how they respond.

This being said, I would always hire someone with a good attitude and good communication skills and invest in their technical training (assuming they are trainable - see above) rather than hire a genius who ticks off every user that they come into contact with.

by patg1

Regardless of experience or class time, the candidate needs to respond appropriately to a situations or scenarios. I asked a DBA what the first things he would do if he was hired into a new shop where he was now in charge DB maintenance. One of the key responses I was looking for was " ask where are the back ups and when was the database last backed up". (DBAs are only as good as their abiltiy to recover the DB) Also, always ask questions where you know the expected answer. You may get a different response, but that may also help find a technical gem.

by rob.lay

I'm at the start of my IT career, I have a couple of certs and about 3 years experience so I'm not goning to claim to know alot, I don't. What I have noticed is that if you look at job adverts they list cert requirements, I'm not naive enough to think that an MCSE and a CCNA will get me the earth, but at my stage their very important for opening the door and getting me as far as the interview, once there then I wouldn't personally expect to be offered the job on the basis of the certs but without them I wouldn't even have got to the interview. I also think that when we're talking about smaller amounts of experience like my 3 years (rather than the old hands with 10years +) that certs play an important role in demostrating an understanding and an ability to learn. Just my 2p worth.

by dketter

The definition of competence is "The quality of being competent or capable of performing an allotted function." A synonym is "know-how." An indisputable axiom is you can't have know-how if you don't have solid education/training. However, that is merely the beginning. One must have the aptitude to learn, adapt, and survive. This can not be taught. The employer must first define what they need. If it is a repetitive task, a solid education is more important. If you need a problem solver or leader/manager, the criteria are totally different. I have worked as an HR Manager, Process Engineer, Chemist, Microbiologist, and IT Project Manager. I have worked with many PhDs with trememdous amounts of knowledge but a total inability to focus and solve problems. Working in IT requires a unique set of skills since you must work with the entire range of business needs. You must know how to interact with customers as a salesman would and solve their problems, not yours. Team leadership and ability to see the forest (not the trees)is a must. A smart man learns from his mistakes; a wise man learns from the mistakes of others. These are aptitudes and behavioral abilities that are not taught - they are developed.

If you need a leader, they must be a risk taker. Find out whether the interviewee has gone beyond the "job description" and has a fire in his/her gut to make a difference; not just fight fires.

In summary; in-depth knowledge is just the foundation which must be fleshed out with the skills above that can only be developed in the fire of the furnace. If one has never experienced a failure, they have never extended themselves beyond the mudande.

by a-vet

The main question is what do you want and need?
Do you need little or no experience, so much experience; what quals do they need for this position, etc, etc....

In my case, I have over 25 years in electronics and computers with only a degree. There are people out there with certs and no experience so then the original question raises its ugly head again.

Try this out.

1. Whats the job?
2. What do you need in this position? (What level of experience and training)
3. What are you welling to pay? (Wise man sez; you pay peanuts you get monkey)
4. Don't always judge a book by its cover (Look at the resume' and then really look at the person. Ask yourself if this person can work with the team, be part of the team and support the team? If no; then they go.
5. I've known techs that were pure geeks that were colored blind, slured, were dyslexic and bad spellers such as myself who could break it down to the simple steps, repair it and teach the clients with utter simplicity. I guess I'm saying go with your gut. And may you find the tech of your dreams.

A-Vet

by gsquared

Neither matters more than the other.

The question is more complex than that.

Part of what you have to ask is:

a) Are technical skills the only thing that matter for this position;
b) Are technical skills the most important aspect of the position in question but other skills (interpersonal/ business/ presentation/ writing/ etc.) have some bearing;
c) Are technical skills and other skills equally important in the specific case at hand;
d) Are technical skills less important than other skills;
e) Are technical skills a nice thing to have but not a necessity for the position;
f) Are technical skills irrelevant to the position in question?

Decide which of the above applies. If technical skills matter, then you need to determine which technical skills (web design, database design, network admin, etc.). Then come up some realistic scenarios that those skills apply to and ask applicants what they would do about those scenarios.

For example, if you're looking for someone who can help administer a workflow application based on MS Office and Exchange Server with an MS SQL server in the back, you might ask "How would you connect a thousand desktop and laptop computers, half local, half remote, to an SQL database on a server here, if you had to deploy an Access project to them?" Ask each candidate for the job the same thing. Don't listen for technojargon, listen for answers that make sense. Note if the person asks questions to clarify the situation so a better answer can be given (e.g.: "Any of the clients on non-MS operating systems?" would be relevant to the question above).

Make sure to come up with at least a few scenarios, so you can make sure you haven't hit "the one question they can/can't answer".

Oh, and make sure the question isn't something that was on the certification exam they took last week. :)

If a candidate has all the requisite skills, technical and otherwise (as per the first part above) and can coherently answer most/all of your scenarios, does it really matter WHERE they got the skills? Training or experience or both? Not to me. Probably not to you.

by pbt

Here's what I do in short:

Interview stage.
Test 'em hard myself for tech skill. Talk through the soft skills and prior experience to flush out inconsistencies while they're still in shock post test.

CV filtering.
Treat certs as an indication of either candidate's desired direction or previous employer's immediate needs. Key is experience backed up with an appropriate degree.

Getting CVs.
Cast the net wide with the recruitment firms giving them only the most rudimentary requirements for 'must have' and 'nice to have'. Few recruiters can do more than match keywords: know that and use it.
---------------------
I'll ignore soft skills and attitude not because they're not important but because they're off topic.

There are several filtering levels a candidate has to pass through. The final one with me has always been a thorough test of the skills I'm in the market to hire, so I set my own standard based on what I need and don't care which cert they show up with.

Getting the tests right costs but so does making a bad hire or significant re-training. Don't test basics extensively, test hard and nasty. A complete guru should have to sweat blood to get 100% in the time allowed so the bar can be set where you need it. The test result will tell you a lot about the candidate beyond just the tech answers too.

I use their prior experience as a guide to what they can actually do on their first day. Any training not backed up with hands on use is of dubious worth IMHO.

Degrees are highly variable and hard to judge but still worthwhile IMHO. A degree should get across the theory that is honed by application. Knowing the funamentals of an OS or what makes software good can be applied in more contexts than a cert in a given language. Comes down to the difference between knowing what you're doing and understanding what you're doing.

by sbigelow

The technical qualifications look good on paper, but... I'm much more interested in what a person has done with their skills, rather than what they're certified in.

All the training and certifications in the world are useless if folks haven't actually used that training to deliver 'work product' that benefited their customers (internal or external).

It takes a little more digging through the resumes and questioning at the interviews, but I focus on the accomplishments more than the training, especially when I'm looking for mid-range or senior-level contributors.

by ken cooper

The answer to your question must revolve around what you are looking for. I am a concultant advsiing companies on their IT use in the UK, and while I have degrees in IT, the most useful qualifcation is TMB accreditation, as this shows i am impartial as well as able to provide quality advice, and the accreditation depends on CPD for it's maintenace.
If you are lookign for employees, then is it a technical job, or a non technical one. For a technical job, the paper should be an indication of their skill level, and you can judge their abilities through providing them with tests when you look to interview, as well as asking for details of the type of work involved in their training. And don't forget that he length of time since gaining the qualification is alos important. The IT scene moves so q If a non technical based job, then I agree with other repsonders that the soft skills become more important, and those can't be shown by having a qualification, only by judgement of their ability to relate to people and problems.

by ken cooper

The answer to your question must revolve around what you are looking for. I am a consultant advising companies on their IT use in the UK, and while I have degrees in IT, the most useful qualifcation is TMB accreditation, as this shows I am impartial as well as able to provide quality advice, and the accreditation depends on CPD for it's maintenace.
If you are looking for employees, then is it a technical job, or a non technical one?
For a technical job, the paper qualification should be an indication of their skill level, and you can judge their abilities through providing them with tests when you look to interview, as well as asking for details of the type of work involved in their training. And don't forget that the length of time since gaining the qualification is also important. The IT scene moves so quickly that without intervening training or CPD, the knowledge could well be out of date.
If a non technical based job, then I agree with other repsonders that the soft skills become more important, and those can't be shown by having a qualification, only by judgement of their ability to relate to people and problems.

by britontn

I am very much for Tech exprience and knowledge.
Get in a crisis and you will see that papers don't pay. Why is that all hackers and geeks have no respectable qualifications. I'd say a passion and drive to do or get something done counts most.
Most of these paper-holders don't know much about tech. If someone can do it then hire them. My own experience is about me. I went to college and got all the papers I could need, but when I got on the job, I wasn't much different from a novice. Now I know more than college could ever teach.
Its not about the papers, its about the ability.

by aldanatech

Ideally, a professional should have both because one compliments the other. Now if I were to choose I would say practical and proven skills. In-depth knowledge show that you are qualified to do the job, but skills show you successfully completed the job. Of course this brings the issue on how to prove it. Well, for that I would recommend you keep a journal of every major project you work on for your prospect employers and compliment it with some good reference letters from your previous employers. Now if you don't have that much hands-on experience then maybe should try to get some training so you can something to get you started.

by rob.lay

I'm in full favour of both certs and experience, I have 3 years in IT (Not much I know) and a couple of certs. Here is the problem that I would face without the certs, people ask for references, I have worked for the same company for the last 3 years in IT, before that I was at school. Now its not good practice for employers to approach the current employer of an applicant for a reference is it. That would lead to all sorts of agro. So in my case certs are a valuable backing for my experience, other wise I wouldn't get many interviews.

by lthoms

Nothing replaces raw talent and experience in the workplace, especially if the individual works with knowledgeable people. Dedication to your profession and a willingness to keep on learning new things is far more of value than "certificates".
lt.

by mitchlr

In a candidate I want to see that the raw material is there in terms of core competencies. These are not specific technical skills, but communications abilities, systematic thinking, and a general knowledge of how things work. My criteria are as follows:

1. How does the candidate speak? Is there evidence of the ability compose a cogent English sentence? Is the resume well crafted and systematic? Does the candidate use a rich vocabulary? I know that managers may think that not all techies are English majors, but these things are important indicators that the raw material is there.

2. How does the candidate perform under pressure? Can he/she keep cool even when pressed? I pose some difficult scenario questions and role play with the candidate, acting the part of a pushy, ticked-off executive. I don't like to actually be that way, but this is a real situation the candidate may have to face, and I want to see if the temperamental raw material is there as well.

3. Is there any indication of systematic, orderly thought? Or does the candidate use a shotgun approach -- throw possible solutions at the problem until one sticks. I seek the former -- an effort to understand the problem or challenge thoroughly before running off and coding up a solution that may or may not actually address the need.

A candidate has to get this far in the vetting process before we get down to the specific technical skills.

-- Dex

by david_filwood

The Challenge today in Hiring Top Talent for Technical Support/Help Desk Operations is Twofold.

1st ? How Do You Find a Sufficient Quantity of Quality Applicants for your Technical Support/Help Desk Positions?

2nd ? How Do You Weed Out the Job Candidates Who Will Burn Out Fast Because They Aren't Suited For The Work, and Identify the People With the Skills, Motivation, and Work Ethic to be Your Top Technical Support/Help Desk Agents?

Many North American Labor Markets have reached the Saturation Point for Call Center Agent Applicants in the Local Labor Pool (including Candidates for Technical Support/Help Desk Positions).

In fact, 64% of all North American Call Centers now find it a ?Major Struggle? or ?Somewhat of a Challenge? to Find Quality Applicants for Call Center Agent Positions. And 37% of Call Center Employers are now Reporting ?Severe? Competition for Call Center Agents by Other Employers.

Then there is the Issue of Agent Turnover.

While Almost Everyone can Use a Telephone, Not Everyone is Cut Out to Work Successfully as a Technical Support/Help Desk Agent.

In 2003, the Average Annual Turnover Rate of Full-Time Agents in the Technical Support (Software) Segment of the Call Center Industry was 20%, and for Full-Time Agents in the Technical Support (Hardware) Segment it was 28%. The Turnover Rate for Part-Time Agents was Much Worse (84% - with 15 Month Avg. Job Tenure).

In 2003, the Average Cost to Recruit/Hire/Train a New Technical Support (Software) Agent was US$4,900., and for a New Technical Support (Hardware) Agent it was US$10,140.

Most importantly, 80% of all Technical Support/Help Desk Agent Turnover is ?Dysfunctional Turnover?:

Quick Quit / Fast Fire - (Under 6 Month Tenure for New Hires. A Constant Cycle of Recruit/Hire/Train for the same Position).

Bad Hires - (Low Productivity, Poor Performance, Poor Customer Satisfaction Ratings and a Negative Impact on Operator Team Morale. Bad Hires also have a Level of Absenteeism 4x Higher than Average).

Hiring the Wrong Technical Support/Help Desk Agent is Clearly a Significant Drain on your Budget, Bottom Line, Customer Satisfaction, and on your Agent Team Morale.

Call Center Agent Pre-Employment Testing Software is Easy to Deploy, Very Cost-Effective and Highly Predictive of an Individual's Suitability for a particular Call Center Agent Position.

There are Versions of Call Center Agent Pre-Employment Testing Software available to Test for:

Tier 1 Technical Support
Central Station Monitoring Operator
InBound Customer Service
Inside Sales Agent
OutBound Telephone Sales
Telephone Collections
Telephone Answering Service Operator
Reservations/Guest Service Agent
Government Information & Referral Operator

Call Center Agent Pre-Employment Testing Software also meets and exceeds all Employment Standards Requirements as a Hiring Tool.

Call Center Agent Pre-Employment Testing Software allows you to Recruit & Select New Technical Support/Help Desk Agents who fit your Employment Needs Better and Stay On The Job Longer - leading to a Technical Support/Help Desk Agent Workgroup that has More Experience and is More Productive. Your Technical Support/Help Desk Agent Productivity Will Go Up ? along with your Customer Satisfaction Ratings - and Your Turnover Costs Will Go Down.

I would be Happy to Prove to you ? in Advance and at No Charge ? that Call Center Agent Pre-Employment Testing Software Will Work for Arctic your Technical Support/Help Desk Operation as well.

Click Here to Find Out More:

http://www.telesoftsystems.ca/64201.html

Or, send me a Reply eMail at info@telesoftsystems.ca and I will be Happy to Give My Presentation on ?How To Cost-Effectively Recruit & Hire Top Talent For Your Call Center? to you and your Hiring Team. I?ll need 30 Minutes of your Time. You will need Telephone Access while being in front of a Computer with Internet Access.

I Look Forward to Hearing from you.

Regards.

David Filwood
Principal
TeleSoft Systems
604-986-4116
david_filwood@telesoftsystems.ca
www.telesoftsystems.ca

by dmwoodcock

In most cases Level 1 support are "script readers" and new to the IT field. Unless they like to be underpaid and have no ambitions of moving up the corporate ladder I do not blame any of them for not staying more than a couple of years. The ones with ambition get the buzz words down and move on. Thanks Corporate America for outsourcing the first level of the training pipeline.

by kwright

Well I had an interview once over the phone I had all the experience but had no paper and this is the advice he gave me. "Impressive as your skills are let me give you some advice. Employers look at education first then certifications and then experience." I asked why? He told me this "If a person goes to school for his chosen career he is commited. Then he backs that schooling up with certifications that says he knows the material. And finally can he back up his certifications with real world experience". I was on the Microsoft Windows 2000 setup team when it launched and it was stunning for me to sit next to a Full MCSE and I had no formal training and this guy couldn't even change the resolution on he screen. PAPER MCSE SUCK AND DONT MEAN A THING. You have to be commited and excited about the work you do.

by blarman

Probably the most difficult thing is the interview process when hiring for IT. Human Resources just isn't cut out for the job. There's got to be an "expert" doing the practical skills assessment by asking some scenario-based questions. Only someone who has the experience on a particular task is suited to evaluate the responses from potential candidates. That's about the only way short of having all candidates take another exam at your doorstep to sorting out between the very valuable experienced candidates (with or without certs) and the paper cert.

by jason_mawhinney

My experience has been that a developer that has many years in the trenches is more valuable than a developer with a certification that was gained in a boot camp. A few years ago we brought in a Java ?developer? who had a good looking certification ? he answered 85% of the questions correctly on his ?certification? exam. However, when the rubber met the road he fell apart. We ended up terminating his contract early and had to rewrite most of his code.

I have nothing against certifications (I am a JCJP with 15+ years in the industry) ? they are most valuable when they are backed up with many seasoned years of experience.

by kaceyr

I've been reading the posts for this discussion group and I've come to the conclusion that you folks should definately get into a debate with all the folks who have posted on the various "Hire someone with a degree" discussion groups.

I'm one of those people who started when our industry was in it's infancy. I was authoring programs back in the days of punch tape and punch cards in languages like assembler (pre-BAL), Fortran, and COBOL (no, it isn't a dead language, you've been lied to). I work on everything from mainframes to micros, shifting from language to language and OS to OS as necessary, even making the different systems play nice together.

One of you mentioned that you like to do a review, via the resume, of all of the applicants work experience. That would be 13 pages for me (so far). My work experience and ability to learn and adapt is my certification. I have no degree and no certifications. I have no intention of going back to school for a degree (at least in CompSci), and even less intention of ever getting any of the "coveted" MS certifications.

I'm arrogant, strong willed, smart (I told you I was arrogant), a very fast learner, and most importantly, I know what I'm doing. You want a secure web application to work with a mix of SQL Server and IMS data from your 40 year old system? Not a problem, and I know a couple of dozen others who could do the job, too.

I am a computer programmer. That's not a title, it's a statement. If you want to assign some kind of title to me, go for it. I really don't care about titles. I can create the systems from scratch, and fix or add to the ones that you already have. I'm not the cheapest on the block and I have been known to argue my point (sometimes I win, sometimes I lose; either way more than one point of view is heard).

I've been told by many of my clients that I tend to energize the people around me to want to learn. This helps me train the folks who will be maintaining what I write. That's right, M-A-I-N-T-A-I-N-I-N-G. It's not a bad word, and all software gets maintained or replaced. I also produce *gasp* documentation.

HOLY S**T! I used both the "M" word and the "D" word in the same paragraph!!!!!

Surprise, programmers really do know that software needs to be documented.

The point of my ranting is that anyone who can study can get a certification, anyone who has the time and money can get a degree, and absolutely anyone can hire someone to write a resume that makes them look good. In our industry, like politics, the lines have become fuzzy. Here's your choices:

1) Place all value on the paper. No paper, no job.

2) Place all value on the work experience.

3) Talk to the applicant. Don't evaluate them based on some stupid list of questions provided by HR, actually talk to them and get a feel for whether or not you think they're blowing smoke.

It's been my experience that the people who take option #3 tend to locate the best people for the job and the best fit for their work environment. I'm not saying it's always easy or 100% certain, but you may find that you're a better judge of character than you think.

KC

- Sometimes 10 cents worth of advice isn't worth a dime.

by help

I agree with "Do you want fries with that?". It depends on the job as to what qualifications are most important. My partner works half time in maintenance, half in computer dept. and can't pass tests & doesn't have a degree. He doesn't like to read particularly, and abhors multitasking. But throw him a tricky software problem (one that I couldn't figure out) and he'll stick with it & solve it whether it takes him 5 minutes or 10 hours in 1 day. I'm lucky to have him on my team.

by daveslash

In my experience, I've not been impressed with certifications. When interviewing candidates for technical jobs, I always try to compose my own small "technical test" for them to show their stuff.

The key to making the test is to make it easy enough that a "truly qualified" candidate will find it trivial, but a "paper-only" candidate will probably be stumped. Interviews are often stressful, and asking anything REALLY hard can alienate even a "truly qualified" candidate.

For instance, in interviewing for a database administrator / database developer, I ask the candidate to write:

1) a simple SQL select statement to join two tables (for which I provide the structure)

2) the same SQL, but substitue a LEFT OUTER JOIN (and tell me why the results will be different)

For any REAL database developer, these would be trivial queries, but they COMPLETELY stump the "fakers".

For some reason, many managers are afraid to actually test the technical abilities of a candidate, but I think it's the only way to REALLY know. (and even then, you can't be absolutely sure)

by jeff

Same idea here. For positions with deployment, I ask them to describe SYSPREP. For positions with desktop support, I ask them about GPEDIT, how they would troubleshoot an application failure, etc. for desktop systems engineering, I ask about scripting, Windows Installer, etc... focusing on the the aspect of the position they're interviewing for. I do occasionally like to hear "I don't know, but here is where I can find the answer..." when I ask the rougher questions.

by bmorter

I developed a series of test questions that IT managers can use to assess job candidates or current staff. The testing goal for current staff is to identify weakness that will be corrected by additional/targeted training. Focused training based on employee needs is a better use of IT training dollars than sending someone to a week long certifcation class. Learn what you need!

by ctos

My criteria (even for a contact) that is kept: Focussed, Able to solve and fix problems of any varied combination and Personality if possible. If they can solve a problem quickly and thoroughly and do it RIGHT the first time, they are treasured by me and I make SURE they are told how important they are to me (my business).

by jbmv

I agree with dogdaze.

I have been in networking for 5 years now. I do not have any certification and technical terms are hard to remember but I am competent in my job. (MY boss thinks so anyway.) I find hands on training is better for me than any courses. I also read any manuals I can find.

Knowledge and expierence are important as well as the ability to work with others. A good work ethic also helps.

by srivera

I supervise 10-12 IT Help Desk students. Whether on paper or job experienced, basic necessary skills for the job must be evaluated for competency. This can be done through the type of questions or abilities measured on tests that are formulated prior to an interview. And/Or,verify details of that knowledge in the interview. Assessing what skills or ability depend upon your business needs. Evaluate for what you need or can train. I've hired people with minimal technical knowledge to do the job, but have a motivation to learn, capable of learning what is needed, and have the desire to do the type of work. I've also hired people for purely technical experience, but lacking in other areas which may or may not be trainable or changed. Qualifications for the best measure would depend upon the job to fill. A degree or certificate is not a requirement for my candidates. Maybe you mean what skills are the best measure of a persons ability? Testing for the basics of what is needed to do the job is the first best measure. Interview and subjective judging of a person's ability is always a gray area. Do your best!

by bkendall

Many of the IT services that used to be parsed among motivated and competent government employees is now being jealously guarded by IRM managers for reasons of security and frequently outsourced to private contractors. I believe in "giving to Ceasar what is Ceasars" and IT services could very well be an "inherently Private" activity, but I believe the operational stability of our IT systems has suffered greatly as a result. Many of these contract personnel seem to be getting entry level pay and "learning as they go" using a lot of trial and error methods that are not adequate and are significantly impacting the ability of the workforce to complete work that requires specialized software.

Most of them are fairly adequate at installing and maintaining what can be termed as common "Office Automation" software like Word processing, spreadsheet, Internet Browsers, etc. But when it comes to specialized software like CAD, GPS or GIS packages they tend to try and install them in the same ways they install the office automation products and the software doesn't work properly afterwards, even though they are provided with thorough documentation on installation procedures.

My point is that you should consider skills that the person posesses to go beyond just learning the basics and routine procedures and give them the ability to be creative, innovative, and flexible enough to address subtle or unusual technical problems. I believe that these skills are mostly innate and give the individual the ability to actually understand what they are doing and how things work rather than simply following "cook-book" instructions and being completely lost when things don't go right. This is especially important when the initial functions of a software appear to work correctly but more sophisticated user functions do not. The IT person who doesn't really understand the technology will often insist that everything is fine simply because the initial functions work and they are unable to take it to the next level of troubleshooting and correction.

by ibm5081

HR qualifications (e.g. filtering resumes in HR):
Since the folks in HR don't do the technical work, filter the resumes based on some minimal levels of certification OR experience, unless you are filling an entry-level position.

Interviewing qualifications (e.g. ranking resumes as likely interviewees):
Look for resumes which concisely state a sufficiently broad work experience. A balance between too much detail (potentially inflated) and too little (many possible causes).
What you are looking for is evidence of the "voice of experience" which communicates without bragging.

Interviewing methods: definitely start with a phone interview to allow the candidate to ask questions as well as explain their resume and fill in any gaps.

by andglycol

What good is it if you have your papers and no experience to back it up. It takes time and a lot of hard work to become a good IT person who can fix, and build PC and understand whats going on when something breaks or goes wrong. Hats off to all those IT people who have worked without certification and can still manage to get the job done and done correctly.

by csobott

Fine, then get some schooling - either in a Community College, University at night or on weekends or even online. Those who are too lazy to devote the time deserve what they get. Education pays, lack of it does not. It has been that way since the begining and only since the downturn in IT has it hit home. IT is not the way to circumvent the lack of a degree that it once was. Now you have to do it the old fashioned way - earn it.

by jsdutcher69

As a network administrator I have NO time to be a social bug because of all the routers, servers and most of all, pathetic end users that i'm trying to fix. In all honesty, I was hired to keep the company safe, up and running not to be the socail butterfly. I would take anyone who knows their work anyday over the political, social butt kisser

by pmoleski

Qualifications are like an insurance policy. While certifications demonstrate an ability to learn, there is nonthing that comes close to demonstrated ability on the job that is verfied by qualified peers.

The ability to get the job done provides value to any company, certifications by them selves do not.

by ray8alot

Personally I am cert free. I find that when the bad stuff hits the fan I can fix it, because all the time I have spent on boards, in books, and my share of mistakes. :)

There is a but, and to me it is the worst kind. HR depts seem to hire vs IT depts. Means have certs or miss lots of good opportunities.

So my return question is 'counts' to whom? HR dept., IT dept., or someone who knows someone who knows someone?

by trevor.sears

When I post job positions, I include a statement to let the applicants know that there will be a written screen prior to any interview.
I have formulated various questions ranging from general management and industry level questions to very complex technical questions concerning specific technologies or equipment.
In my experience, people who really want the job, and have the skills, don't mind the test.
There are numerous resources to help with engineering the test questions properly.
I use only short answer. This gives me some insight into the applicant's written communication skills and thought process.
Grading the test should be subjective only. Most people cannot walk in off the street and answer technical questions with 100% accuracy. However, it is easy to tell who knows what they are talking about and who doesn't.
Good luck.

by sonivivek

We also need to know who is accessing the talent here. If we have kids accessing somebody's talent then its the best way to send the wrong signals and taint the image of your company.

by vltiii

I think it depends on the position being filled. If the position calls for hands on experience that is what should be demonstrated. If the position is more supervisory/managerial then proven knowledge may be all that's necessary even though practical experience is a plus. I also think that hiring managers who lack the technical experiece should have someone from the technical staff sit in on interviews when making hiring decisions.

by jdsnetbiz

I think that the subject matter experts should designate a small portion of their network for testing candidates in the skill set's desired for the position. If the candidate cannot make it through that process, then there's no need to waste man hours and company time as relates to the interviewing process. This is a be about it industry, plagued by many talk about it persons, and I beleive that this process will save individual Corp. money and time, no tto mention the integrity of the industry as a whole.

Example: I've concluded the resume review process and moved to interviewing the cream of the crop for Desktop Support Position. I'll meet and greet as I escort the candidate to my stand alone PC Testing Area. A document at the workstation ask's him to reboot into Safe Mode, Uninstall MS Office Suite and boot back up normally, reinstall reboot only 2 progams (MS Word & Power Point)from the Suite via the installation disk which sit's next to the Keyboard, and to give the Account Admin Rights specifically for those 2 programs, given a local Admin. password of course, and explain that he explain to me what he's doing and why (because I'm the acting not so savvy user and I'm nosey or concerned). That's (dependent on the speed of the system)not much work at all and takes not much time at all, but will give you enough to make an informed decision as to wether the interview need go any further.

What do you think (Everyone)?

by gordonuk

Most would agree that experience counts for a lot more than qualifications, but if you work in a large company you may never see those experienced people.

HR departments can get so many applications for a post that they throw out applications simply for not having a qualification.

I've seen it happen....

by james31

I live in the UK and find that having few qualifications inhibits my chances of employment within the IT industry because they value pieces of paper over experience not gained working for someone else. So I like others are persuing certification. I believe that both experience and qualification are the key. Why not have a qualification that demonstrates ability. Maybe employers could have a policy of employing qualified certified employees and those who do not have qualifications to work together. the problem for employers seems to be finding the answer to the age old question. how can I be sure this person has the relavent experience and is it checkable. what is required is a way of introducing new people into the industry to enable new ideas to be propagated without throwing away the people who have slogged and fought their way through to gain certification. In Short Practical and proven skills should be a requirement whilst in depth Knowledge of the subject aids in using those skills to greater effect.

by steve v

the reason why companies prefer to hire those with certs and degrees is to justify their spending. The decision to hire is made by a manger. The person who is a manger is usually someone that went to college and attained some degree to become that manager. When a company hires IT people they pay them pretty well; hopefully. Companies feel that if I am going to pay you a good sum of money, you should be just as educated as me. In other words why should i pay someone who has less formal training then me, the same salary or almost equal to the same salary of a person that went to 4-5 years of school? They fell that if it took them 4-5 years to get to the position and pay rate they are at then it should take the same time for you.

What they don't understand is that you cant get a desgree in networking. Tell me if their are any 4 year colleges out there; not technical schools. That will give you a degree in PC repair. Or a degree in network admin, or engineering?
I would venture in saying that none exist.