Of course not.
Hacking a system of someone suspected of distributing or being part of distibuting is wrong. It just should not even be a option.
Here is the way I look at it. Way back when, People did copy casettes and exchange them with their friends. It was'nt exactly "legal" but it was't a threat or a big infrigment on rights.
Duping tapes and mass producing 100's even 1000's of tapes, that of course crossed the personal use line.
Bring in the net with easy access. Posting acd on the net can potentially attract millions of downloads. Far surpassing tape duping.
Point is. An artist has the right to charge for their work. People should not be allowed to distribute my work without my permission.
When people buy a cd, they are not purchasing the rights to the cd. They are purchasing a limited right to listen to the material in it's original state.
It does not include distribution.
File sharing software is easy to use and seems harmless. In the broader scope it's the same as the old tape dupe studios.
If the file sharing software charges a fee for each song downloaded. Then sends the artist a payment, then I am all for it, 100%.
But anyone who uses the "free" stuff now, has to understand that what they are doing IS illegal. End of story. By choosing to use it, they need to be able to live with the penalities if caught.
The authorities will need to follow the law when prosecuting. They should not have the ability to just shut down a system. Unless they have gone thru the appropiate legal channels.
If you receive a cease and desist order, and refuse to comply. Then yes, they should be able to shut you down.
The law and logic here is pretty easy to understand.
There are ways to come to terms to this dilemma without infringing on everyone's rights. I just think that parties on both sides need to act responsibly..