Discussion Locked

Whats Your Opinion On Song Swapping

0 helpful
61 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

After reading this article>

http://www.zdnet.com/zdnn/stories/news/0,4586,2818064,00.html?chkpt=zdhpnews01

I was upset that RIAA would think that they have the right to perform a DOS on somebodies computer. And not be liable for any damage. Thank god that the piece of legislature they were trying to introduce didn't make it.

Whats your opinion of the whole song swapping thing?

Rad

61 replies

by lordinfidel

While I have ALWAYS been a strong propoment of free information. I also agree that there needs to be rules or guidlines that need to be followed.

First and foremost, I believe that it is up to the creator of the information to deem whether or not it should be free.

If I as an artist make the decision that I do not want to freely distribute my art, then I should have the choice to do so.

The argument can be made that sharing music only hurts the music companies. But that is not and should not be the point.

The point is the freedom and right of choice. If I do not want my songs freely distributable, then I should have the right to protection. If someone chooses to violate my right of non-free distribution, then they should bedealt with legally.

The law is clear, you can not make copies of or distribute any copyrighted material for anything other than personal use. If you take the definition of personal, it means only you. Not your friends, family, acquantinces, etc. Regardless if you are not charging for it.

Would I expect the authorities to come after me for making a copy of a cd and giving it to my wife. No.

But If I take that same CD, post it on the web and allow it to be downloaded to anyone who sochooses without me even knowing. Well then that falls under distribution and is in fact illegal.

I think this is the point that people are missing. Just wanting free music is not valid.

by radiic

I have to agree with what you said about the copyright. I think people have loosly translated what the words "personal use" mean. Now does that mean that people have just started violating the copyright act since the advent of Napster. NO. Remember making cassestes of friends records when you where a kid. People have been violating that law for a long time. So why hasn't the RIAA made such a big fuss before. Does it have to do with the fact that 51% of households now have a pc, and that Millions of people are all of the sudden downloading songs. Maybe, maybe its caught their attention more.

I agree that they have the right to protect their copyright material, but at what cost. Does it give them the right to hire a bunch of hackersto attack these file sharing programs, and kill vaulable bandwidth on the I-net>? The legislation they were trying to push was that they could pursue these file swappers with out any fear of civil liability. IMO I think that would be giving them just a little too much leeway.

by scott.cline

Think of libraries. Where are all the authors' and publishers' complaints about libraries? There are all those books and journals (think files) stored in a central location, where people can come and read or borrow them, or make photocopies, or whatever, and not a nickel changes hands. It's file sharing, plain and simple.
I could go through my entire life without purchasing a single book, magazine, or newspaper in the library, yet read and enjoy the same till I'm blind.
The entire businessmodel of the recording industry is deeply flawed, and the file-sharing of the napster age just served to expose it. After all, the material is really the artists', but the recording industry forces them to sign away their rights. And only a few pennies per recording go to the artists with each sale, with the vast majority of the money going to the labels' coffers.
The fact that they are considering strong-arm tactics like DOS attacks on file-sharing servers only underscores the point about how thuggish and money-hungry they are. Let the artists and the people connect directly, and let music publishers provide the same role book publishers do, providing high-quality media for private and public ownership, without the limitations they currently place on distribution and creativity.
The recording industry isn't concerned with copyright. Just profits... Copyright is a tool they are trying to use to prop up their obsolete business model.
So, hopefully, the outcome of the file-sharing movement will be the toppling of the corrupt and authoritarian recording industry, and maybe a revision of copyright laws that provide for fair use and protection for the artists.

by lordinfidel

Of course not.

Hacking a system of someone suspected of distributing or being part of distibuting is wrong. It just should not even be a option.

Here is the way I look at it. Way back when, People did copy casettes and exchange them with their friends. It was'nt exactly "legal" but it was't a threat or a big infrigment on rights.

Duping tapes and mass producing 100's even 1000's of tapes, that of course crossed the personal use line.

Bring in the net with easy access. Posting acd on the net can potentially attract millions of downloads. Far surpassing tape duping.

Point is. An artist has the right to charge for their work. People should not be allowed to distribute my work without my permission.

When people buy a cd, they are not purchasing the rights to the cd. They are purchasing a limited right to listen to the material in it's original state.

It does not include distribution.

File sharing software is easy to use and seems harmless. In the broader scope it's the same as the old tape dupe studios.

If the file sharing software charges a fee for each song downloaded. Then sends the artist a payment, then I am all for it, 100%.

But anyone who uses the "free" stuff now, has to understand that what they are doing IS illegal. End of story. By choosing to use it, they need to be able to live with the penalities if caught.

The authorities will need to follow the law when prosecuting. They should not have the ability to just shut down a system. Unless they have gone thru the appropiate legal channels.

If you receive a cease and desist order, and refuse to comply. Then yes, they should be able to shut you down.

The law and logic here is pretty easy to understand.

There are ways to come to terms to this dilemma without infringing on everyone's rights. I just think that parties on both sides need to act responsibly..

by epepke

That's why we should forbid any technology that allows millions of people to copy music. We'll start with FM radio. People have been copying from that for years. And what about MTV, VH1, and MTV2? It's a DOUBLE insult! Not only doesn't the record company get paid, but the producer of the video!

I don't want to hear any whining about how you like to listen to radio or watch TV. You're all just a bunch of thieves. And none of this crap about how you went out and bought a CD with a song you heard on the radio. This is America, dammit! If you wanted to hear the song, you should have bought the CD in the first place.

by dr dij

radio and TV stations have monetary arrangements to allow them to broadcast. companies that play elevator music do too. Don't tell me you didn't know this. If you copy from them it's technically illegal but no one will bother you. If you then produce copies and sell them on sleazy cd websites or on the corner you are stealing. people who copied cassettes or tapes in the past may have given them to friend but typically did not sell them. The point is we can't have the profit motive in stealing or we will destroy the small artists & music industry.

As for the teenagers who think it's their god given right to have a total luxury (music) for free, they think it's cool but it's snot.

Why stop at songs? Maybe we should have the right to post anything we can copy such as paintings, software. Do you have anything you created that can be reproduced digitally? I'd be happy to steal it from you and post it on the web.

by nicks

Everybody with access to the net downloads copywrited music, pictures, text information databases there's no rebuttles against that and it's not going to go away. Put a law on it, and soon there will be a way to get around the law. The one thing that has been good about digital music is the ability to back it up.

Every CD I buy I convert to mp3 straight away (160kbps/44khz). At first it was so I could just listen to them on my PC without messing around changing CD's ect. Went on a business trip one weekend and my bag was stolen along with about 45 - 55 Cd's(so I like lots of music). Without having them backed up I would have lost around $1,500 worth of music.

2 dat tapes, and about 5 hours later I had all my music back.

Anyway, at least there some ethical benefits to mp3 audio compression.

by lordinfidel

No should be able to stop you from making backups for your own personal use.

I personally only carry copied cd's in my car. The orginals stay at home. That way if I step on it in the car I don't have to go out and buy another cd.

The difference here is that it is for personal use and I am not distributing the cd's.

The laws are already there. The violations are just so widespread now that it is difficult to prosecute.

In order to prosecute they need evidence. How many geeks do you think actually work for the feds, not as many that are in the private sector. They need us to collect the evidence.

by sledjockey

You have to remember one thing. Most of these laws were created for the arena of business. The actual intent of the laws deal with profits and gains from use of another's work. That is the problem that everyone is running into. For whatever reason, the origin of these type laws have lost their original intent. Drivers licenses, marriage licenses, copyright protection, even federal taxes were all created with some other purpose in mind. Keep things simple people. You are not making a profit. You are not using the material to receive services or tangible wealth. Swapping stuff on the internet between people is just an easy way for me to see if I like something before I spend the money to go and either see it (movies) or buy it (music). This whole copyright fighe has gone WAY overboard and wastes too much time and energy as it is.

by lordinfidel

Taking your point...

If you download 7 songs off of a 7 song cd. And you have a cd burner...

Are you?:

A. Going to burn the 7 songs onto a cd
or
B. Go drive to your record store and buy the CD.

I gurantee you the answer will be A.

It defies all logic to think that you would, after having all of the songs from the cd, to go and buy it.

So if you did not have to purchase the cd you saved yourself x amount of dollars.

Hence you made a profit. Not spending money that you would normally have to spend is profit.

Which by your own admission was the original intent of the law.

So we are in agreement that downloading music off of the net for free without the artists consent and not bying the CD's is illegal and violates the spirit of the law.

by admin

#1 You can't stop it.
#2 No one else can stop it.
#3 This is just another silly attempt to blame the medium. No one learns from betamax, cassetes, cd-r or anything else. Kill the media and you'll only get new more powerful sharing medium.
#4 The internet should become a highly regulated place for the non-technical to pay massive subscription fee's for safe content while the rest of us develop new networks.
#5 If the RIAA denies service on a loose voluntary network, we kill them.

by donald.monteith

Anyone else loving the fact that we can be arrested and sued for DoSing them ( at least that's what the bill would have allowed ) but it's ok in their eyes for them to do it? I'm just waiting for them to get CLEVER. Strongarm tactics WILL NOT work and they need to figure this out. You can't work like the mafia and still be that far in the open. At least the mafia had/has the sense to work underground with this kind of crap.
Oh, and my response to you, admin:

#1 You can't stop it --> Damn skippy.
#2 No one else can stop it. --> Preach it!
#3 This is just another silly attempt to blame the medium. No one learns from betamax, cassetes, cd-r or anything else. Kill the media and you'll only get new more powerful sharing medium. -- See my earlier point.
#4 The internet should become a highly regulated place for the non-technical to pay massive subscription fee's for safe content while the rest of us develop new networks.
--> Gods, please, I anxiously await the day this happens.

#5 If the RIAA denies service on a loose voluntary network, we kill them --> Nah. Just watch and laugh as they shoot themselves in the foot.

by lordinfidel

Some info on them...

First, The books are purchased from an approved source that gives the profits back to the author.

Second, All books in a library are covered by Copyright law.

All because you borrow a book, does not make it yours. You do not have the right to reproduce if borrowed.

Borrowing a book is not the same as downloading music and keeping it. You are obligated to return the book back to it's source.

Let the artists managers fight with their publishers over money. That is not the publics responsibility.

Bypassing the publisher also bypasses the artist. That is a fact.

A publisher uses it's publishing know how, to distribute music that normally would not get distribitued. Whether that is bad or good is adifferent argument.

I look at the net with music in this way. If I was a unknown artist, the perfect way for me to distribute my music and get heard would be to post it for free on the net.

Once I get a following, hopefully a record deal follows, and I can start charging for my music.

Let's face it. The whole starving artist cliche' sucks. No one wants to be one.

Do you work because you don't want to make money? No. I love making cash and I'm not going to give it up. Why should the record companies who support and nuture the artists (loose statement I know, it's a whole other argument) or the artists themselves forfeit their cash.

But the issue here is hacking into peoples systems and using DoS against them. That is just wrong. Unless it is done legally and with notifacation (cease and desist).

A little sensibility goes a long way.

by merlereine

I download hundreds of songs. The argument that the music industry is losing money is ludicrous. If it were not for the songs being free, I would not get them. I would not pay $1 a song for the nearly 1000 songs I have downloaded. Therefore, if they were to stop the sharing of music, I would simply go back to copying the cd to tape. No matter how they try to stop sharing/copying, someone will find a way around it.

by mremixer

I'm guilty, I've pirated stuff before, still do, but I also buy a lot of music, subscribe to a lot of musical services & pay my PPL & PRS licences every year. I'm a mobile DJ & music is my life, I charge for people to listen to the music I play otherwise I'd starve! FREE WORLD never happen in our lifetimes, I don't want it to happen, I like being paid for what I do, it helps me pay other people for what they do, NOTHING IS FREE. Free speech doesn't exist, we are monitored & tracked if we disagree with certain things. To be truly free we would turn to chaos. Imagine working 9 - 5 for your boss for free! I don't think so!

File sharing's all well & good (in whatever form), between friends ONLY! I personally promote a lot of music before It's released because I pirate a copy from a number of sources, but I do get a copy of the albums when they come out! This way I can provide an upto date service for my clients but keep my costs down. I would be paying 1000's a month if I bought all the singles released.

I don't agree with it, its not big & its not clever, but I find it a necessity just to survive. If the prices were more reasonable I would consider buying singles, but at the moment it is more financially viable to get the album. But then of course they release a remix version for the charts, a remix version for the clubs (usually more than 1), this argument will go on & on & on & on & on ................I've had enough bye!

by charles byrne

I agree with your statements, but I'd also like to append if I may. Let me preface this by saying I am NOT a Lawyer. The recording industry is on a fine line. If the recording industry charges the consumer for songs, then the songs aren't forms of free speech and expression. Rather they are a consumable service and also could be interpreted as an advertisement to promote the entire album. The interpretation SHOULD make the songs subject to the same laws that constrain commercial speech andadvertisement. What does this mean? Well it could mean that certain songs could be banned from being played or sold if a community or government decides that the lyrics are improper and it could be supported by the courts (doubt the higher courts would support it).

I think that the prices that are charged are outrageous especially since most of the artists who perform these songs see only a tiny fraction of the profit.

Furthermore, what is to stop someone or some corporation writing an algorithm in some programming language to basically write a song that plays every possible combination of notes at varying tempos and such and then copyright that "song"? I know I'm getting a little paranoid, but lack of sleep and wedding jitters will do that to you.

by lordinfidel

If you have downloaded 1000 songs, then I have news for you.

What you have done is considered illegal. No matter which way you look at it.

Can you say with 100% certanity that if 1 million people download 1000 songs and each song costs $1, that the music industry would not lose money.

Let's look at the equation:
1,000,000 X 1000 x 1 = 1,000,000,000

That is 1 Billion Dollars.

And this is a very liberal estimate. Since I know people who have downloaded thousands of songs.

Nowout of that Billion dollars how much of it was supposed to go to the artists.

Lets say that .10 of each $1 song went to the artist. You just ripped the artist off of 100,000,000. In case you can't count that is 100 million dollars.

Which is I am sure is more than what you will make in a lifetime.

Not hurting anyone... What about the music stores? Transoportation? CD pressing Warehouses? Graphic Artists who design covers?

You obviously do not have any concept of economics.

I apologize for blasting you. But you need to fully understand the repercussions of your actions.

All because it seems harmless does not mean that it is right.

Copying a single tape one time, is very different from downloading thousands of songs. When you get into those amounts it is called "Illegal Distribution". Notice the Keyword Illegal.

Finding a way around it is still, can you say it... Illegal.

by merlereine

If i record 1,000 songs from the radio, which is LEGAL!, how is this any different than downloading a digital version of the song from the internet? You seem to be missing the point. While I agree that your math adds up, it does not add up to a loss to the music industry. I state once again, if the songs were not available on the internet for free, I would not go to the store and purchase 1,000 songs from the store. Thus, whether "napster" exists or not, I would not be purchasing the songs and thus no one is losing any money. Imagine that I am the only one in the world that has the ability to download songs. Imagine that I have never purchased a song in my life but rather just listen to the radio. Where is the loss if I download music? Downloaded music does not correlate to loss of profits. In fact, the record industry has recorded record profits as of late.

by generalist

If all songs are free all the time, then most of the song making population would either starve or have to get 'real' jobs.

The exceptions would be those who are able to market their songs in packages that can't be electronically duplicated.For example, Weird Al Yankovic sells music and puts on good stage shows. I've spent more on the shows and souvenirs than I've spent on his albums. (That's saying something since I have bought most of his stuff.)

by admin

And I, as a musician, should get free housing, medical care, food, and the same for my children. That'll be the day. Too many people in this country are too damn lazy and selfish to work for a common good.

If you think about it, that's sort of the world we can already approximate though.... we just trade commodities through our economic system.

Having said that, I think that usually when I hear complaints about the illegality of sharing songs, it's by people who don't see using inside trading or going a mile or two over the speed limit much of a problem. Often it's picked up by senators who are accepting illegal contributions, greasing the drug wheels of foreign countries for a profit, and banging interns under 18, but hey- it's the music pirates that are menacing our society, right?

I do agree that it is illegal, but that it's kind of silly that it's illegal. Musicians benefit from massive illegal song sharing unless they are the few denizens of the former corporate music world and trying to hang on to the audience they are losing. Look at the rising popularity of The Offspring when they embraced early Napster and the dying audience of Metallica. Basically, if you can intertain a larger audience better than the other guys - you make good money. This is the way it's always been except for the few silly corporate decades in the western world of pop music. In the end, the corporate system is unsustainable anyway and will die a slow, romanesque death, unless helped along to it's logical conclusion.

by lordinfidel

You have basically touched on the basic point.

The artists right to choose.

Metalicca chose not to have it's music available for free.

The offspring did on a Limited Basis (They did not release all of their songs for napster)

But to go in and take that right away from the artist is wrong. No matter which way you look at it.

Hey, don't get me wrong, I am all for free stuff. I'm american for peeks sake.

But I also beleive in the freedom of choice. I do not have the right to take that freedom away from someone.

But the freedom of choice does come with a price. Certain choices come with certain penalites.

If I choose to rip off songs that I have not paid for and the artist has not agreed to allow me to get them for free. Then I should accept the penality if caught.

The same way if I speed. If I get caught I pay a fine. I have to accept it since it was my choice to speed.

It's not the publics place to dictate what/who makes money and who isn't. Their only responsibilty is to buy/or not buy the records. The rest will fall into place.

The artists do need the corporate manpower of the record companies. It is just a part of that life. An unholy alliance/necessary evil if you will.

But there are plenty of artists (like david bowie and trent reznor) who started their own labels. They also charge for their music. Should they be cruxified for doing so or do they have a right to charge for their music.

by admin

Where's the profit motive in the old Napster. Or Gnutella etc? Does this mean it's not stealing because there is no profit?

Sure, some Warez sites might get change for their porn banners, but most of the time they get screwed over and never paid anyway (what did they expect?). Most people on the web aren't profiting from uploading music, at least financially.

I do wish there was a way to duplicate Van Gogh's etc. in 3 dimensions, perfectly textured and colored though, I've always thought prints were pale in comparison with the real pieces.

by epepke

The modest fixed fees that radio stations pay ASCAP and BMI are the real source of profit for the record industry. The rather larger bribes the record industry diverts to DJ's aren't real financial transactions, anyway, because they're sometimes incocaine, and we all know that's white, not green. Besides, it's illegal, so it doesn't exist.

And the hundreds of thousands to millions of dollars that record companies spend per album on producing a music video must be an investment in the hopeof selling single copies in Blockbuster. And the promotional copies of them they give to MTV for free, along with the promotional copies of CD's they give to radio stations for free are really paid for, in virtual money!

Listen, my friend. I'venever swapped an MP3 with anybody. I don't even own a single bootleg album. Frankly, I don't give a wet slap about song swapping.

But I don't believe for a picosecond that song swapping has functioned as anything other than a source of excellent free advertising for the record industry. I've seen it happen in chat rooms. Person A is talking up a band. Person B says "I've never heard of them." Person A sends person B an MP3. The very next day, Person B says that he and/or she went out and bought the CD. That sale, and that profit, was produced by that horrible, immoral act.

Now the record companies are sniffing another trickle of money. They have a right to do it, and the fees that the new Napster is going to charge are quitetrivial. However, this is in addition to the extra revenue that they get simply because people have been exposed to bands that they would not normally, cold, walk into a CD store and buy, hearing unheard.

by guruofdos

I use Audiogalaxy a lot. I used to be a Napster freak. If I want anything 'new' I buy the CD if I really want it.

Most of the stuff I scour the net for is late 70's/early '80s British music. Unless it's been re-released on CD, most of it is only available on vinyl or cassette. I have actually contacted record companies here in the UK or overseas to try and obtain legitimate copies of stuff I like, to be told that it's no longer available or has been deleted. I have even been told to 'record it off the radio or download it from the Internet' by more than one record company executive. Assuming the song I want is no longer available via legitimate channels, this can only mean that the company DON'T want to sell me a copy (and thence earn their royalties) and are HAPPY for me to obtain it by 'grey' means.

By the way, does anyone have the radio version of 'Is she really going out with him?' by Joe Jackson...all I can find on the net is the live accapella version :-)

by treker

If someone breaks into my home, am I allowed to shoot him without any liability for damage? Of course not! RIAA cannot be allowed to take the law into their own hands any more than you or I can. That's what we have police and courts for.

by admin

I remember the Skulls and Crossbones on Bowies albums exclaiming: " Home Recording is Killing the Music Industry" when cassette duping became easy and widespread after which he went on to gain more wealth & popularity than he had ever previously had.
I'm really not sure of Reznor's position, but even the Piracy of Quake disks obviously spread the NIN word. I don't think they should be crucified at all, and should and do profit quite nicely from their work.

I agree that if you break the law, you should understand that you are and accept the consequences. I also believe you can accept a law and yet actively work towards trying to change it.

I was interested in this line: "It's not the publics place to dictate what/who makes money and who isn't. Their only responsibilty is to buy/or not buy the records. The rest will fall into place."

If a product meets my needs, but the company that makes it is immoral in my view, I will buy another product from another company. For instance, I can purchase a detergent tested gruesomely on animals or one that is not. They both meet my needs and I prefer to support the one that does not. This is an important consideration for many people. If I really disapproved strongly of a record company that distributed an artist I liked, I would find another artist to entertain me.

by lordinfidel

If you don't like the record company don't buy the record from it. Buy it from somewhere else.

But don't steal it. Because that does hurt the artist.

You can have the most popular artist out there and their songs can be downloaded for free by the millions. But it does an artist no good.

Why? In order to launch a tour it takes cash. In order to make records it takes cash. In order to host a website it takes cash. In order for the artist to live, it takes cash.

It's an evil cycle. And one that I think most people are missing.

I won't use products that test on animals either. I buy from companies that don't.

In that respect I am invoking change thru my purchase. If the company who tests on animals wants my cash, then they need to change their ways.

Downloading songs though is circumventing the whole purchase cyle altogether and is doing more harm than good. That is why I say "Their only responsibilty is to buy/or not buy the records". You just can't steal the material because you don't want to pay for it. Because, as one person already put it here, even if they sold the songs for $1 they would not buy it.

So in fact the argument here is not how much money it costs. It's whether songs should be free or not and do people have a right to download songs for free at their whim.

The answer is no. They do not have that right.

by kage

"The public doesn't dictate who doesn't make money and who doesn't" au contraire!!!!
The public is the source of the money, therefore they do dictate. But you miss one thing that is clear. These artists are not gonna starve! They have made thier millions already and as a typical being on top of the monetary pyramid, they stick thier noses up high and try and dictate to the public what they can and cannot do. I fully support compliance with the Law and trying to change the ones that are unjust,but come on, if I made a duplicate of a CD that I have and gave it to someone for a present (i.e. b-day) where is the crime and how is it different from song swapping on the internet? Circumstances to said infringement rights are no different. However, it will not stop the artists from making thier millions upon that which they already have.

by lordinfidel

A. you have little or no control over who has acccess to the songs.

B. No money is being sent back to the artist.

C. When more than 2 people swap a song it is considered distribution.

D. Distribution with intent to circumvent payment of thematerial without the Artists consent is illegal.

Now will the feds come after you for making a copy and giving it to someone. no.

But go ahead and make 1000 copies of the same cd and start handing them out. Then the feds will have a reason tolook at you.

Why, because it's illegal distribution.

People, this is not a hard concept. Everyone is just getting pissed because they want stuff for free and are being told it's wrong.

I want stuff for free. I know damn well that if someone gives me a burned CD that it's not right. I will still take it, I'm not an idiot. But If I get busted by the Fed's for having it, well then I have to pay the penalty.

So people need to reach down and grab their balls and own up to their actions.

Who cares how much money they have already made. How would you like it if someone came to you and said, well I think you made enough cash already, you don't deserve any more. Well you would be pissed too.

This is the same thing. And it'swrong.

by scott.cline

The Federal Trade Commission filed a formal complaint against the recording industry for artificial inflation of CD prices, charging that major music companies had illegally enforced minimum pricing for CD and denied competitive discounting by retailers in an effort to keep CD prices high. Critics claim that an average CD price of $16 is much higher than the actual manufacturing costs of a few cents per disc warrants, fueling claims that Napster users are justified in their quest to obtain low or no cost music.

by strahd98

Personally, I don't think there's anything wrong with swapping a song or two. I think CDs are way to expensive to buy, especially if I'm only going to like 1 or 2 songs on the cd. If I like the whole cd, then I'll buy it. Otherwise, I suppose it wouldn't be bad if we could pay like a nominal fee to download a song, provided we pay once and can download it as many times as we need, like if we lose the copy we have.

by cavador

Replying to the story about a piece of failed legislature that the RIAA wanted
to introduce but failed.In theory if it was passed and they hacked into poeples computers,Would that give every body the right to hack into RIAA computers?
This is the most dangerous piece of legislature I have ever heard of.(I study politics for a hobby)This sort of stuff borders on anarchy,and perhaps worse tha a computer virus.
Keith

by kage

It would seem to me that we have swapped songs for years or even decades before the internet. People have made duplicates on thier reel to reel, cassette tapes and gave them to friends, everywhere you look there is resources to get the songs you want for free. One could check out items in the library and copy said songs. Make duplicates at home and give them to friends. Neighbors do the same all the time. To penalize swapping services like Napster, is just plain wrong. Now they will just find people on chat services and transfer files that way. What do they hope to accomplish?

by lordinfidel

Physically Swapping between friends is much different then putting a song on the net.

On the Net, where millions have access to the song free of charge is considered Mass Distribution.

That is the distinction that is being made.

If I make acopy for my friend it is not considered Mass Distrubtion. It is still wrong. But hardly worth a lawsuit.

Napster/Audiogalaxy/Gnutella allows for Mass Distribution. Whether or not the person posting the song realizes it or not. The bottom lineis it violates Copyright Laws by allowing the Mass Distribution without the artists consent.

The lack of Monetary transfer has nothing to do with the violation.

Which goes back to my entire point that has been made time and time again thru this thread and elswhere.

Everyone is pissed because they want the songs for free. They do not want to pay for them. As one person put it, she would not pay for them even if they were $1.

And that my friends is the whole core of this argument.
And the answer is, you do not have the right to steal/swap music that does not belong to you.

If someone gives you a stolen tv and they tell you it's stolen, at the end of the day it's still a stolen tv. And if you get caught with it and it's proven that you knew it was stolen, you will be prosecuted.

Take responsibility for your own actions.

by admin

It may be more like if your friend had "given" you cable or network content commercial free than actually physically the TV. This is interesting, because with my AV computer, I can skip all the the commercial content either in a short time-shift, orby one button pre-recording. Am I stealing the content by advertising avoidance?

I buy CD's because I want the artwork, want to support the artist, and want to rip mp3's for my own use (My AV computer handles thousands of songs in directories with visualizations directly into the stereo in my theatre/listening room) and I want Near CD quality rips, something that for one, still supports the artist (I bought the rights to listen to the songs- not the physical media) and, for two, does not gettraded at this quality level much on the internet anyway.

by blonde.bat

I like the idea of song swapping. I think its great. I realize it hurts the sales of music. But I must say its a great way of getting music.

by phil.hall

I bet the RIAA would be more permissive if people by choice only traded songs that were encoded at, say, 57K as opposed to 128 (or higher.) 57K is more or less radio quality, and they don't really have a problem with people taping their fav tune offof the radio. What they do have a prob with is near perfect digital copies that are floating around (some encoded at over 300K). That causes them to ask if the copy is as good as the original, why use the original when the original costs and the copy is free. I think lower bitrate copies might apease the RIAA and let everyone swap to their heart's content--and if you want a really good version, you have to buy the CD/DVD/whatever the next format becomes.

Now that would only work if everyonefell into line with that thinking, if there was even a handful of people who did not, then the whole scheme collapses.

There is no perfect solution for us all, rather the RIAA want's us to buy their product (can you blame them?), we just don't want to pay $25 for a CD with only one good song on it. Perhaps the RIAA needs to invent a better solution rather than complaining about the existing situation and litigating all willy-nilly.

Personally, I don't swap my songs, the ones I have are mine, I own them. But if I did swap, I think the above idea just might work.

by generalist

A few years ago I seem to recall hearing of a setup where you could create your own CD of favorite songs from a variety of musicians for a nominal fee. That setup appeared to address the 'problem' of encountering a CD with 1 or 2 songs that you like and deciding to download those without paying the musicians.

The biggest problem at the time appeared to be a limited amount of buy in from the musicians. Perhaps this should be looked at again.

by straymoose

Swapping will go on for a long time until someone develops software that will block the transition of copyrighted sound files over the net. There is no point in arguing weather or not it is legal. It will always find a way to move about the net for free.

I myself have not stopped buying CDs and I think I buy as many as I would have even if I didn?t swap. I like to have the artwork and the liner notes. I think swapping encourages buying the original disk. It does for me. Without swapping there are many bands that I like that I never would have heard of because they don't get radio play in my area. Then there are also many, many bands that will never see my money judging from what I have heard from downloading their stuff. Which is also the reason I would not want to pay anything for downloading a song. If it turns out that I don't like it will I get my money back? I don't think so.

If there was a modest yearly fee that would allow me to download as much as I want then I would consider it. But it would have to be about $25 a year max.

Swap till you drop.

by straymoose

One other thing I forgot to mention. The artists should be going after their record companies rather than the listener to get a larger piece of the pie. I don?t recall the exact figures but I believe that all artists get less than a buck for each unit sold. You can?t tell me that it takes an average of $15.50 to press and market a CD. The material alone, paper and plastic can?t cost but 25 cents. The artists should be paid at least $2.00 per unit sold. Then I believe they won?t care if we swap or not because they will be making a lot more money regardless or any ?lost sales? from swapping. I also don?t buy the argument that the record companies will have to raise prices for CDs. If they get some of their salaries in line and reorganize a bit it shouldn?t hurt much at all. I?m all for making a legitimate profit but what the record companies do to artists is out and out rape.

by mjcupp

Downloading music for free, instead of purchasing a CD, is stealing the artist's product. Believe it or not, not all musicians are millionaires. Many of them need the income from CD sales. If the artists can't make money off their CDs, then they will probably stop recording.

by epepke

Don't assume that what's good for the record companies is good for the artists.

Try and remember back before the record companies started getting heavy-handed, say around 1998. There were some companies that started subscription companies for independent and unusual music. Some of them burned CD's for clients at a modest fee, and some just had downloads.

Frankly, I think that the "song-swapping starves the record companies/artists" line is about as bogus as the piracy justification of the XP activation scheme. Record companies, I think, fear the possibility of a new distribution mechanism for artists which bypasses the standard record pipeline, with its well known artist-cheating practices.

If they were smart, they would see the handwriting on the wall and set up their own sites for a reasonable fee. However, people fear change. They just do. Also, the production of physical CD's has certain advantages for a record company. One of the things that record companies do is, if say there is a run of 5000, produce 10000 instead and ship the remaining 5000 out the back door, only crediting royalties on the initial 5000. Frank Zappa had to sue a company for doing this to him. It would be much harder to commit this kind of fraud with a subscription service with centralized record-keeping.

by radiic

You bring up the fact that If you just listened to the radio, that you would never have to pay for music. That if one person wanted too, they would never pay. Hmmmn

by generalist

If you listen to the radio, you are paying for the music second hand. If it is commercial radio, there are these things called advertisements that are used to pay various fees.

If it is public radio, donors pay for it.

by epepke

You aren't paying for the music for most commercial radio; you're paying for the radio broadcast. When I was in Forensics in high school, we used to do a radio show. With very few exceptions, the albums they had were stamped "Promotional Copy--Notfor Sale."

Some of these you will see wind up (this part *is* illegal) in second-hand stores.

by admin

Let's not belittle this act of violence.
Many artists start their own labels or shop around carefully b4 they sign. If they don't, well, it's their fault. No one forces them to sign.

by pmercer

many struggling artists sign with anyone that will give them a contract - and they don't usually have the money to hire an attorney to review the documents.

Unfortunately, the record companies have all of the power in these relationships (at least in the beginning). Jim Croce is a good example of someone that was wrongly treated by a record label . . . he signed because he wanted to share his music (and make a living). In the end it caused him to be unable to even support his family because he was making so little in return. It happens a lot.

Too bad artists don't have a union they can join when they are struggling to make their voice heard, that would help them in contract negotiations with the record companies. After all, youdon't think the record companies would be in business if they weren't making a profit. And, you probably wouldn't have artists that are turning into record companies, if the existing ones treated the artists fairly.

While there is certainly risk in introducing a new artist for the record companies, most of the financial risk for videos and distribution costs fall on the artist. Many of these contracts make them financially responsible for these expenses, and it comes off the top of theircut of the record - which is already small.

by mcarzola

Good luck to those who think they can stop it! They should try to join the cause. As long as there is internet there will be free swapping of a lot of things!

by lordinfidel

I honestly could care less.

My whole beef is when people song swap and then try to hide or dismiss the fact of what they are doing is illegal.

Like I said before, I am all for free information. But I FULLY understand that if I download a songof the net for free and have no intention of paying for it. Then it is stealing and illegal. If caught, I will have to take responsibility for my actions.

That is my beef.

No one wants to take responsibility for the actions. No one really gives a rats ass about the prices, because they would'nt pay for the stuff anyways even if it WAS reasonably priced. People want stuff for free, plain and simple, short and sweet.

So let's stop kidding ourselves and adress the real issue here and own up to your actions.

BTW- the RIAA hacking into peoples systems is wrong and should not be pursued unless it is enforced using the present guidlines used by the federal gov't when conducting an official investigation. And even then the computer systems are monitored and then seized, but not hacked. And it requires a court order issued by a judge who reviews the evidence.

by lordinfidel

So... By your standards you would not buy/listen to any music unless it's free.

So let's say for shits and giggles that you are an artist. And you work at some minimum wage job, no better yet you are unemployed and starving. Yet you found a wayto create this incredible song.

Now your standing on the corner singing your song and someone records it digitally without you knowing.

They then take the recording, without your permission, digitize it and post it on the net. The net goes crazy, a million people download your song for free.

Everyone is enjoying your song.

But you are still poor and starving. Knowing that if you don't make money soon you are going to starve to death, you begin to ask for money for your song.

But no one will pay you, because they can download it for free. There are no record companies to take you on because no one buys records anymore so they have no way to stay afloat.

You can't sell your songs to the radio stations becuase why would they pay for a song that they already have. Even though they are making money from advertisers. It's more profit for them not to pay you.

So if 1 billion dollars is not a loss in profits, then I am doing something wrong and need to have your salary. Apparently you are worth more than bill gates.

BTW- recording songs of the radio and distributing them is not Legal. All radio stations have expressed use liscenses that state the content that they play on the air may not be reproduced in any manner without the expressed written consent of the radio station.

Same with TV. The NFL goes even a step further and puts it in their credits in big letters.

Do you understand now?

No money going into the bank ='s no profits.

by lordinfidel

Just keep in mind the word's "Personal Use".

By ripping songs from a cd that you purchased onto you computer for your own personal use is not stealing.

Now if you posted that ripped song on the net, even though you paid for it, then it is distribution.

And not, skipping commercial content is not stealing. Remember that you probably already pay for cable access. Hence the costs are covered already.

But if your friend gives you cable access then yes it's technically stealing (not like i have never "borrowed" cable access or anything, I am just as guilty, but at least I understood that it was illegal and did not hide that fact or try to cover it up by saying the cable company has enough cash, I don't need to pay them.)

The theme that I keep hearing, not just on this thread but everywhere else is, people just don't want to pay for something that they can get for free. Even if it is their favorite artist, they would much rather download it for free then support the artist.

Granted, there are people like yourself who appear to grasp the concept of the artist needs to make cash. But it just seems like everyone is being greedy with the whole free or nothing deal.

by donald.monteith

"Granted, there are people like yourself who appear to grasp the concept of the artist needs to make cash. But it just seems like everyone is being greedy with the whole free or nothing deal."

Well, I grasp this concept as well and it's where I begin to have an ethical quandary myself. I want to support my favorite artists and I understand that their paycheck comes partially from the sales of the CDs I would be buying. My problem comes when I realize that the bulk of the money on the receipt for any CD I buy goes to record company execs who are right now fighting, not so they can make a living, but so they can keep that fifth BMW and keep those 3 or 4 senators they have on payroll and keep their political power. All the while, they give the artist a pat on the head and a $.30 royalty check. I have a problem supporting greedy bastards like that. If there was a way I could support the artist directly, I wouldn't mind doing that, but I have a real problem buying CDs right now becauseof what I know.

by lordinfidel

That same argument can be applied to just about everyhting we buy.

Cars, Homes, Computers, Electric, Cable, Gas... The list goes on and on.

Nothing is ever proportional when it comes to profits. Do you think the engineering team who worked on any MS project is making the same as Bill Gates. No. Of course not, it would be ludricous to think so.

As I have continued to state, the above argument is just a excuse to hide the fact that people just want stuff for free.

Because if the above were true, there would be a backlash from the artists to their record companies.

They have vehicles to do so like http://www.afm.org, http://www.songwriter.co.uk/
http://www.songwriters.org/
http://www.ascap.com/
Just to name a few.

Artists are not as ignorant as everyone thinks they are. Those who hate the conventional record industry start lables of their own. And those who do start lables of their own, charge the same amount for their cd's as the other record companies. Hmmmmm go figure.

So again, I say to all of you who are hiding behind this fake concept. Admit that all you want is free music, your not willing to pay for it, regardless of the price or who the proceeds go to.

If you are going to donwload music for free. Take responsibility for your actions. Admit that it is stealing, and if you are caught, you will have to pay the penality.

So please people, stop your whining.

I'd dare any of you to write your favorite artist and tell them that youare not going to buy their music unless it's free. (oxymoron I know).

by generalist

I personally don't download music because it is too much like stealing from the artists.

Call it an odd quirk, but I prefer to avoid the hypocracy of downloading one form of copyrighted material and then demanding that anything I copyright be protected by the laws I would be violating.

And when it comes to supporting various artists, I've bought a lot of CDs direct from artists who work through self publishing or small labels. In many instances the artist gets all the money except for production costs. And better still, costs are a lot less.

Don't expect big name musicians though...

by joe

The RIAA may open a bigger can of worms than they may want by these tactics. They may try and hack into the wrong persons computer and life may become unbearable for them online. They are way off base on this one period. You won't nor can you ever get rid of song swapping. The RIAA is looking for a confrontation it will lose. The hackers online are far more prevelant than they can defend themselves from if they want to go toe to toe. Its just a bad idea, whether or not I agree with song swapping on this issue or not,this is just wrong on many different plains ....

by penny_lee_candy

Considering all pro's & con's the more its talked about the stronger each side gets. Until finally a compromize is needed.
We all only have so much time here on earth, so I hope like myself you are listening to your favorite song NO MATTER how you got it. I may burn in for my sins BUT I'll know the words to that new release.
And my feelings are that after paying the high cost of housing,food,transportaion,TAXES, school clothes, Health care, and Personal items. I find little money in my purse to pay for a CD filled with songs, that I have heard on the radio. The cost is too high, They know it, you know it and it won't stop until we are all broke.

by donald.monteith

Don't accuse me of whining because that's not what I'm doing. Nor am I trying to hide behind anything. I was just putting my 2 cents in. I know that when I download a song, I'm technically stealing. And, no... the same concept cannot be applied to all of the examples you listed. Coders for M$, maybe, but I don't tend to buy M$ anyway, so that doesn't matter much to me anyway.
What I'm saying is this:
I disagree w/ the RIAA's tactics, so I don't wish to purchase from them. I will GLADLY PURCHASE ( note that word PURCHASE ) from smaller companies not affiliated with them. I just got tired of putting money in Hillary Rosen's pocket and watching her and her cronies whine about needing more. When CD pricing structure is changed, I'll gladly start purchasing from RIAA companies as well, but for now, the indies have my money.

by admin

a check for 8 bucks or whatever with a nice note explaining your wish to support them and enjoy their current work, which you are enjoying, and let them know you are choosing not to support their record company and why they have lost your album saledue to this. Just don't say the check is specifically for something the recording company owns....

This discussion is closed to new replies.