Discussion Locked

Where to get unbiased outside counsel?

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I am responsible for our current production computing machines, and it has become apparent that we will need to change system platforms and partake a massive application development effort to change our primary application to another application environment. A HUGE undertaking.
To date, I know of no consulting firm that is unbiased. (I consider Gartner group extremely biased - a valuable asset, but extremely biased)
Have any of you found any vendors that are in general unbiased, that haveexperience with multiple operating systems, including OpenVMS and manufacturing production environments?

Thanks so much !!

Rick

5 replies

by timwalsh

You may be asking for the impossible. The problem is that unless you have as much knowledge as the vendor as to the pros and cons of the available solutions (in which case you don't need a consultant), you have know way of judging that vendor's bias.
I think it is only human nature that a vendor will try to push a solution that either centers on that vendor's core strengths or gives them the biggest profit margin.
One approach you might want to try (if your budget allows) is to hire one vendor to determine the best solution, with the clear understanding that they will not be providing or implementing that solution. Then find a seperate vendor that specializes in that particular solution to implement it. This will at least remove thebias based on profit. You still won't be able to judge any bias based on core strengths (A vendor may offer solutions in multiple environments yet have broader knowledge and experience in one area than in others.).
Another approach (if you have time) might be to research other companies in your business field to see what types of similar solutions they have implemented (and how well those solutions have worked).
Of course, any answers you get here are likely to include some bias from the person offering the answer.
I'm not after your points, just wanted to pass on my perspective on what you are attempting to do (and possibly help some).
Good Luck!

by jereg

I have to agree with Tim. Everyone has some kind of bias. I know that I do. Any recommendtions you get will be based on knowledge and ignorance. A consultant has knowledge of a product or service and will recommend that because they may be ignorant of anything better. Or greed, because their firm gets a cut of some company's product. Your best bet maybe to find someone (seemingly indepent)and interview them. Find out what they know and like. And why. I was lucky enough to have dinner one time with some of the editors from Network Computing magazine, and I think they're fairly unbiased. But we all have our preferences. Your best bet may be to put out an RFP and try to get several proposals and see which one makes the most sense.
Good Luck!

This discussion is closed to new replies.