Question Locked

Which consistent laptop is worth the money?

0 helpful
23 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

There's been blogs about which vendors make the best and worst laptops... and sometimes they're the same.
Which leads to this question: Which specific laptops have worked well for you? Especially the high-end kinds that are likely to be relatively consistent in makeup globally (and not, say, thrown together with random-brand parts, varying by the build-month). I figure that cheap machines are often crap, so let's focus on the specific models that have worked well. Especially with the not overheating, and having parts with good drivers.

Every truthful answer will get a thumb (eventually); I have a truthometer online. :p
I'll then do a weighted assessment of all answers for future reference.

EDIT:Scrapped the high-end from the title, can be any kind, as long as they can be trusted to be consistent within a series, at least for a while (as in 6 months).

23 replies

by darryl~

the "T" series & have had good luck with them.

We seldom have any hardware issues & all the custom software we have at the Municipality seems to run on it fine.

Docking stations & other add-ons are easily obtained & service is also easily available if needed.

Here's a link to the one's we use.

http://shop.lenovo.com/SEUILibrary/controller/e/webca/LenovoPortal/en_CA/catalog.workflow:category.details?current-catalog-id=12F0696583E04D86B9B79B0FEC01C087?t-category-id=289EA260AEE544F183059D38630597D5

by boxfiddler Hot topic

HP and Acer with great luck. After some experience with each, I went HP for my third lappie. The first HP (Pavilion - circa 2000) is still around and performing wonderfully as a Linux test machine, sans wireless (which I don't care about anyway). I could put Win2k back on it with no probs.

My current HP was special ordered so that I could get a 17", glare proof screen and Vista Business. It was costly, but has been performing as my primary computer for well over a year now. I'd easily buy another.

(I needed Vista Business as I was scheduled to start teaching it... :( )

I'll come back later with recent make and model number...

Most recent purchase is a SD-MS/Pro-MMC-XD.
Intel Core2 Duo T9300 @2.5GHz with 4G RAM. Windows 'sees' only 3071 MB of it.

etu

by oh smeg

You should have gone with a 64 Bit OS instead of the 32 Bit one you are using. That would cure your current problem. ;)

Col

by oh smeg

And Clevo is hands down the best. only real problem is that Dell is buying their complete production these days to sell as their High End Alienware systems.

Cost lots of money but they are very good and super reliable.

MSI had some good units back before they got strange about warranty claims as well as Benq who do make a lot of the other makers components. Today I'm using Gigabyte NB's which have so far proved to be very good.

Though while the hardware needs to be good a lot depends on the person using the NB and how they treat them. ;)

Col

by ansugisalas

How'd you know what I do to my machines... damn, that camera has remote access, right?
:(

by oh smeg

It's the Security Utility to find a Lost Stolen NB that allows me to remote into the Web Cam and see where the NB is being used and by who. :D

But the reality is that I have some users who are Earth Movers and they are anything by gentle with their NB's. I had one guy who got more than a bit peeved off with the way that something worked park a big excavator on it.

Certainly didn't fix the NB but it made him feel good. :^0

Col

by nexs

The ol' Thinkpads have only had 'user errors', the HP Laptops don't die as often as the Small Form factor Power supplies (but seem to work fairly smoothly), Acers have never been very reliable (but that was a few years ago...), and I've not yet had any trouble with my Dell, and i've had it for 12 months.
I think it's a little unfair to judge my Toshiba (R.I.P.) as it had Vista installed on it, and that's just not a fair test! But it finally died after 3 years.
I hope I can resurrect it long enough to get some data off it ;)

by ansugisalas

Thinkpads I recognize as a series.
But what kind of Dell was it?
And what Toshiba?

Of course, the older series' aren't so relevant to me, in considering a new buy.

by robo_dev

I've owned dozens of HP/Compaq laptops, a couple of Thinkpads, and now two Dell Inspiron Minis.

Never had any real bad issues that were the fault of the laptop...hard drives do not last forever in any laptop.

My Dell Mini9 is about a year old and works great.

I just bought a Dell Mini 10. Cost $220 USD delivered from the Dell Outlet Store (open box).

These are Netbooks, so they are light, yet not super-fast. Running Ubuntu Netbook Remix on the Mini9 and plain old XP on the Mini10.

by nexs

Was the Acer P.O.S.
Toshy was in satellite A200 series.

At that point, the Thinkpads were the T43's being upgraded (I think).

The dell is a latitude D620.

by ansugisalas

- didn't fix the NB...
Right, I'm marking that Helpful - I mean, if that's not good to know, what is?!
That'd be an expensive test to run, you know?

by .martin.

my latest HP (dm3-1011tu), so far it has been good, apart from the normal windows issues.

before that that, I had some really good experiences with a Toshiba A350, then an A30 before it.

only laptop I have had troubles with, are a couple of Dells, which I had problems with overheating.

by oh smeg

under them like the one here

http://www.antec.com/Believe_it/product.php?id=NzI=

These plug into a USB Port and provide power for 2 fans under the NB.

This sucks air between the NB and Cooling Pad to cut back on heat. But in reality this doesn't matter anywhere near as much as the Cool Pad draws air through it faster than the Fan sucking air into the NB so any Air Borne Dust and Crud gets sucked into the Cooling Pad and doesn't end up in the NB's Internal Cooling Ducts and Heat Sinks.

From my experience it's the crud sucked into NB that does the most damage after rough handling by the users. ;)

Col

by .martin.

Inspiron 15's, from the start of 2009.

if they were left on (connected to AC power, not no programs open) I would frequently find them with black screen (like the safe mode selection screen) informing me the laptop had overheated, and had been shutdown to protect it.

by lavrenty1

I've had two Compaqs over the years. Both have served me well and have no hesitation about updating to a third at some point.

by ansugisalas

Salesman:"Yes, we scale down the machines to increase portability... Now you just have to place one of these Huge Iron Lungs(tm) at each usage site, so you can use the sized down machines there!"

Me:"Oh, that's nifty!"

Seriously though, I guess this is the kind of modulization that adds ruggedness to a system. So I guess I have to look into that too.

by santeewelding

It's looking like a binary abacus and you getting real good with machine language.

by suzannebraun

I still have one of the "old" 2005 HP/Compaq tablet computers with the stylus. Still works great!! I also bought two other HP laptops and only had a problem with a hard drive once. Replaced the hard drive for about $35.00. I will always go with an HP.

This discussion is closed to new replies.