Which Desktop Vendor Offers the Best Support?
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Hardware
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by spookster
by unixmandt
by dhreceni
You must be using Dimension machines NOT Optiplexes or Precision Workstations. I am in Canada and we are a Dell shop. We get Complete care warranty on these machines and if a user drops it and breaks it, it is fixed on site NO QUESTIONS ASKED! Oh and did I mention the default warranty is 3 years on site, not a measly 1 year depot with IBM. Add a three year on site with IBM and you add at least another $300-$400 to the cost of the machine.
I also had a wonderfull experience with IBM where I waited longer on the phone then they spent troubleshooting with me before they said "reload the OS". I am pretty stubborn and fixed it without the reload (of course without IBM's help).
When I call for support with Dell it takes me longer to type in the service tag then it does for them to answer the phone. Precision workstations are ISV certified and the Optiplexes are extensivly tested to perform in a business envirionment. We were and IBM shop but we only have one machine left. I am EXTRMELY happy with Dell and their support, qulity and price.
by jbaker
by oz_media
Forgive my ignorance but that is a new term for me when it comes to PC's. I see two possible things it MAY mean, but correct me if I am wrong.
BLoodless: MAY refer to not being proprietary. When it comes to standards, you WANT 'bloodless' proprietary in replacement hardware, especially if it is under warranty, it is tested and designed to work efficiently, OTHER OEM's actually DO optimize the proprietary hardware they use by customizing the BIOS to ensure maximum performance between hardware.
If you meant BLOODLESS as in easy to install. YOU obviously haven't worked with IBM or Compaq over the last few years. They BOTH offer completely toolless chassis and parts (drives) don't even get screwed into the frames, it clips in and out in seconds. The entire drive varriage just swings awat from teh PC (or lifts up and out) you slip the new hardware in and you're done in FAR less than 5 minutes.
Now you DID mention that you need the Dell onsite warranty. This is included in professional workstations, 3 or 5 years onsite next day service. But the phone support from the others makes the phone support form DEL a laughing stock. YEs I have worked on MANY DELL's, I sigh everytime someone calls me with a Dell because I KNOW what I have to face to get the right parts sent out.
Hopefully that explains my stand and why I considered Dell a farce. They are okay for Joe Home user but are simply a CHEAP solution when it come to a professional workstation.
by rss
You have not mentioned operating sysytems. Any way , if you plan to use dual boot sytems, I would recommend custom build system from a reliable local expert vendor. For windows you won't have any problems. For Linux you have to catch some local Linux expert. But the trouble is worth the pain. For big Vendors machines you might have to pay less in the beginning, but you would be locked down to them only for any part that stops working. It is all rosy picture till warranty period exists. Afterwards you will be at the God,s mercy. In addition you will loose all the flexibity you get from custom built systems. For 20 or odd machines it would certainly be possible to get a very high and reliable support from the people building machines made to order. You should go for all the genuine original retail boxed pack parts. It pays in the long run.It appears you have some inhouse technical expertise. But most important is is the software support. That is the part which is most expensive. But you could also get hold of local software experts. This will save you all the trouble, plus you won't have to bogged down to get parts from any one vendor. Please also don't get motherboards with in built sound, Display, Modem etc. always get a high quality mother board from ASUS.(i have their board since 2000 without problem). Choose your Memory,etc carefully. IN conclusion go in foa custom made PC with enogh space for future upgradation.That way your machines will not become obsolete within near future. So the extra price is worth the trouble. In addiyion for 20 machines you could bargain.
Please send a reply to this post. My e-mail is rss@powersurfer.net
with regards
rss
by oz_media
BIOS, Sound Card, Graphics card, Power Management, Intel SpeedStep, etc.
DO these companies provide asingle page for all of these updates where they have been tested against each other? OR does the user need to download drivers from 5-10 different sites and hope they work together without conflict?
What happens when the Graphics chipset provider merges and ceases support?
What happens when the BIOS on the mobo is found to hang with a specific piece of hardware or manufacturers driver is installed?
These are REAL problems that I have experienced with "custom boxes" better known as the WHITE BOX BLUES.
by oz_media
Hmmm, such as "IBM has great systems for the banking and stock market industries"
IBM's are not designed for banking and stock industries. IN fact their M-series Intellistantion lineup is 'specifically' designed for graphic design, CAD drafting and 3D modelling. They are tested and optimized for specific AUTOCAD and Graphic design software and even specific VERSIONS of software. (versions supported/designed for are listed by model on the IBM site).
I suppose saying they are best for banking and stock industries would definitely constritute a "half baked opinion then" or at least a rash or unqualified one.
Compaq's have an entire line of professional desktops (EN, EXD, and EPRO)designed specifically for Office and general desktop multitasking positions.
Again, "half baked" and unqualified.
Dell, they are cheap, end of story.
ANYONE who has ever tried to make a case for Dell can only say, 'They are chepaer' which nobody can contest.
As for operating costs, YES IT costs need to be monitored, this includes far more than an initial investment though and carries through to support, uptime, hardware reliability (no dead drives) etc.
Both Compaq AND IBM have proprietary hardware monitoring, testing and maintenance software installed in the BIOS. IF the hardware is GOING to die in the next wihle you WILL be warned on boot. And yes I have saved mroe than one hard drive form failure this way. The BIOS gives me a code, the computer is still fine, boots and works like new. You call IBM OR Compaq give them the code and someone is at your door the next day to install a new HD and copy the image over BEFORE it dies. Data loss is another expensive cost for an IT department.
There's more to saving money than buying the cheapest.
by nagelpg
I work with Dell, HP and IBM.
HP have an exelent website for desktop support so telephone support is cut down - their telephone support is exellent as well. Their desktops tend to require more attention than DELL & IBM.
IBM - website for support only covers basics - telephone support is good. Replacements may take time depending on where you are located.
Dell - Stick to Optiplex and you do not have to call their maccabre telephone support - once you speak to the right guy he will be able to help you and solve the issues at hand - but the waiting is going to killing you.
Dell have exellent replacement turn around times on components - they will do cross shipping.
Dell's support website is exellent as well.
We are not even looking at the prices from other desktop suppliers anymore - Dell have the work horses (Optiplex & Precesion) stay away from Dimension in a network environment though.
by networkguy55
by oz_media
ANY IBM deksotp I have bought offers a 3 OR 5 year ONSITE warranty with the purchase. Your commments are EXTREMELY wrong in that respect, andfor someone who is a competetive dealer you should know better.
My LAPTOP was a carry in 2 year warranty, which YES I did upgrade at the time of purchase to 4 years onsite.
But the desktops (professional desktops) ALL come with either a 3 or more comonly 5 year ONSITE warranty, you are wrong in that respect.
As a competitor, you should review their website and check them out once in a while to stay on top.
The FIRST Compaaq I ever bought came with a 5 year onsite and others also come with 3 or 5 year ONSITE service.
As for speed in connecting with support, BOTH IBM and Copmpaq give you a separate number to call for business support as opposed to retail boxes they make (which is what YOU are being confused with), they answer VERY quickly, smile and send out a tch then ask if there's anything else thay can do for you.
SO lets face it and be realistic when making false claims. When I spoke of DELL, I wouldn't have been referring to Dimensions, I would never buy, reccommend or service a Dimension. Again, you made a false assumtpion.
So all you have done in your post is say that Dell offers what others don't, which they don't, others offer the exact same and even better (5 year) service on professional workstations. They answer right away and send out a tech in 24 hours no questions asked.
Try again.
by oz_media
In my experience both IBM and Compaq will spend time onsite making sure your PC is running properly. If they swap a NIC, they connect it, if they swap a wifi card, thy connect itm if they swap a Graphics Card they will run their own proprietary system tests on it as they need a clear code from the test for their work order. If they swap a system board they update and reprogram the BIOS with teh serials etc. But they sure as hell don't charge me for it.
I DO expect them to do this for free, and they do.
by oz_media
I don't think we are talking apples and apples here. YOu have described residential service offerings, or those you get when you go to BEST BUY and buy your company's workstations off the shelf.
We are discussing professional workstations, you don't find them at Best Buy or any retail outlet for that matter.
Elevator music? Online web support? Don't know anything? You are definitely NOT talking about a professional workstation with onsite support.
by oz_media
Shows people happy with DELL's out of the box, but what should be noted is that they received one of the lowest ratings for phone hold time and phone support.
I also don't think this pertains to professional workstations either, they are comparing to E-Machines, Independant sellers, and Gateway's. This is for residential, shelf systems, not the same thing.
Not relevant to the topic here.
by oz_media
E-Machines....good one!
THey are referrign to residential crappo boxes. E-Machines are the low cost, off the shel answer for someone looking for NO standardization.
Not exactly the topic being discussed here.
DO you get 3 years onsite service with you e-Machine too?
Those are just grannies at home saying they are happy with how they managed to get help with their online Yahoo bingo, when webshots crashed the fellow on the phone was helpful and VERY knowledgeable when he had me reboot to fix the issue.
by rgcastillo
by dr dij
clearcube is computing of the future. it a modularized thin (thick?) client.
alot of big companies are testing or deploying them.
uses blades on back end
perfect as if a blade goes out the client simply connects to another one. there's alot less hardware to break at the client desk. just a monitor/kb/mouse I/F with ethernet port.
When they get cheap enuf I'll use them at home.
since at any given time only 2/3 of corporate PCs are actually being used, you could buy just 2/3 of blades and have hot spares. you might be able to share the blade PCs like citrix does.
by oz_media
Buy 15 Dells, open them up and you will see every part you can think of from every corner of the world.
How does this help with site images or standards?
Awesome product, well, to each his own I suppose. Have you USED other machines in a professional encironment?
Largest market share? For what, home users, desktop workstations, servers, blade servers, web application servers?
But of a proud statement and an inconsistent one too if you ask me, bu you didn't so I'll let you enjoy it.
Secondly, who would use market share as a focal point when considering company purchases especially when comparing to IBM or Compaq/HP, are you suggesting they MAY not last?
by warwizard
Jetula,
Your opening the case will NOT void the warranty, you can install third party hardware and still not void the warranty unless it is obvious that the 3rd party hardware caused the damage, and I do not mean a bent pin, more like installing an incompatible memory in backwards and shorting out the system board kind of damage.
As far as I know there has not been a "warranty voided if sticker is removed" lable on any Dell system. I cannot say the same for Compaq (now HP). It's a function of the way Dell looks at tech support, you can put anything you want into a Dell, if there are problems, pull it out to eliminate it as the cause of the problems. Check the online forums to see if others have a fix for the H/W you're installing.
While Compaq (HP) offered limited versions with tightly controlled BIOS and hardware. If their models did not offer what you needed, you were out of luck.
by cp7212
Read on for problems with Dell and then pass it on to management....
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=170117&start=0
by oz_media
You aren't talking apples and apples. You HAVEN'T bought any IBM or HP professional workstations obviously.
Reading Railroad???? Next day onsite service is more like it (3 or 5 year included in initial purchase price for ALL professional desktops and workstations).
Factory warranties? So you SEND them away and get a new one? How much downtime do YOU allow in your company?
As for warranty being voided, again complete hogwash. Any of thee companies will support any hardware you install. If you have a system failure, they WILL remove any added hardware before restoring your system as that is the ONLY way to ensure it is THEIR issue or not, just like any other PC manufacturer in the world.
Any compatible system is easier to repair? This is proof you are not talking with experience.
If you use ANY tools, even a Phillips screwdriver to remove the case or harddrives, it is NOT easier to repair than an IBM Compaq/HP. They can be completely rebuilt without a SINGLE tool and it is generally performed the next day, onsite by their own tech under their warranty.
As for that's all you get, have you ever considered hardware standards? Imaging multiple boxes? Where do you get all the updates for your white boxes? Who tested the MOBO Bios with the Graphic scard and optimized the drivers?
Sorry to sound rude but so many people are making false assumtptions here based on incomplete information or just providing plain misinsformation that it is very misleading to the original poster.
Your comments are NOT true of the other manufacturers, there's HUGE of difference between OEM and aftermarket clones. You BS about sending parts off on the Reading Railrod in one paragraph and THEN say that all the parts in a white box have manu warranties (1 year to mail in the HD, instead of 3 or 5 onsite warranty is just great!)in your example YOU are talking about sending parts off on the Reading Railroad but ignoring the fact that all the others EXTEND that hardware warranty and do it on site in 24-48 hours no questions asked.
If you want to rant and rave about white boxes, do so. When someone is looking for facts about OEM business machines, there's no reason for you to offer such BS though, it hardly helps anyone.
by dryflies
by dafe2
White box & build your own have no place in Businesses.
HP, IBM, Dell & Compaq, even at their worst, outperform white box vendors
by dafe2
I use one myself & have deployed about 600 of them.
I've had 62 of the drive issues you talk about....all resolved PROMPTLY & without grief.
We're not talking about problems. We're talking about how they were dealt with.
by dafe2
Most of those machines turn to A1 sauce in business.
Most of the dealers turn to Bankrupcy court with a year.....if they bother to do the honorable thing to begin with.
by dafe2
by scott
by bhunsinger
by bizman
RE: >> Anyone who has worked in this industry for more than the past 12 months knows that Dell corporate support is far superior to anything IPM, Compaq/HP or any others trying to compete.
I haven't said much in these forums, but I just couldn't let that comment go by. I have been in the industry for over 20 years. I started out as a field service tech, and have touched just about every brand to call itself a PC over the years. For the past Eight years I have been supporting a 2000 workstation network that buys about 400 new workstations every year. Four or Five years ago I would have said Dell is the best hands down. Over the past 5 years, their quality has drastically decreased, as well as their level of service.
RE: >> As a "professional" you have to be careful about giving "opinions" to others without having experience on more than one level.
I agree, so let me tell you where I am coming from . I have worked for dealers as well as service organizations. Now I work for an in house support department. I have been a tech, and a service manager at many levels. Right now it is very discouraging, because Dell quality, and support, has decreased quite a bit in the past few years, and no one has stepped up, at least not on a very large scale, to fill this void.
IBM is a non factor, since they have sold their desktop division to a Chinese company, I would reserve judgement until I see how that turns out. That really only leaves Dell or Compaq / HP as the major players in the desktop market.
Over the years HP and Compaq have had their share of great machines, as well as dogs. I have many good experiences to share about Compaq and HP service, but that is all before they merged. Both companies quality has been somewhat inconsistant.
Depending how large your budget is, and if you can afford to do it, you need to buy from both. Any good business person has more than one source. Buying a little from both keeps them both honest. Plus if you can do your own comparisons in your world, that's the best test.
While I give a slight edge right now to Dell, what worries me about them is they keep trying to low ball every price, they sell only on price. Quality and service has been declining, and if they sell on price alone, I can't see how it will improve any time soon.
by oisleach9
I am a small VAR that put in 35 desktop systems into a company that consists of 55 people. After doing the homework and pricing I was a fool and bid this job fixed cost. Dell sent me the systems and 4 DID NOT BOOT UP. 6 system were missing software. I called Tech Support and Had to speakk to some people who did NOT SPEAK ENGLISH, and would not direct me to the next level or to someone who did speak english.
I COULD NOT SEND THEM BACK.
I spent the weekend reformating and re-installing from Scratch the 4 that would not boot and bought out of my OWN POCKET the software that was missing.
In the end I WILL NEVER EVER BUY OR RECOMMEND DELL !!!!!!!
by lbog
by aaardal
I think you hit all the major points.
We're majority a HP shop here and HP support has been pretty painless. No real hassles. They send parts right away. I also would recommend using a 3rd party vendor like CDW or Zones.
by tbha
by oz_media
I haven't seen too many people say that the Thinkpads are not by far the best machines on the market. They are stronger than most machines, the service and support (with an onsite upgrade) is top notch, IBM is the ONLY notebook vendor I have EVER seen that replaces an LCD with the lowest number or burned pixes (about half of what others require).
I even had the IBM tech turn up and say that IBM would complain if less than 6 were burned (most are 12 to 18 or GROUPS of pixels) so he took it to the shop and burned out a few more before sending it back.
They replace ANY thinkpad parts in a heartbeat and without ANY questions, even moreso than the dekstops. THey even gave me a notbook upgrade at no cost because I "didn't like the way mine preformed". THey offered to fix it onsite, which I didn't want because it was new, so they replaced it with th enest model up instead.
THey take their Thinkpads VERY seriously, mine is a PIII, 1.13 Ghz with 640MB RAM, it walks ALL Over my friend's HP P4 3.2 gig with 512MB RAM.
It walkes all over my PBX support tech's, Tosh Satellite with a P4 and 2.6 Ghz with 640MB ram.
It is easy to update, in fact you CAN have it update from IBM diorectly on a schedule, howver I prefer to choose updates myself, though the same ones it would have done itself.
THen there's the BIG BLUE BUTTON! SOlve ANY internal hardware or even most software problems by pushing a button by th evolume controls! NICE.
On drawback to Thinkpads, they have crappy speakers, not made for Audio work, but th eHP with teh Harman Kardon speakers is bulky, heavy as hell and nowhere near as durable, not to mention mine being 3 years older STILL outperforms the new HP notebook/desktop replacements.
I can't believe how fast the notebook support at IBM is, they replace ANYTHING immediately, no wuestions, no bills etc.
I even managed to get an EXTRA HD in a box in case mine dies because they weren't SURE one day. I asked about a shpping bill to return it and they said to keep it in case I need it one day.
I liked my Toshiba, but it was nowhere near as durable. THe IBM system board sits in a titanium cage, has security chip on board too. Is USELESS if stolen etc. By far my fondest PC investment.
I have to agree with you on Thinkpads - both build quality and support.
My company uses thinkpads and they get a real beating as we work with telcos in SE Asia and it is normal for us to work in extreme conditions of heat, humidity and dust with power surges to boot. It's also normal to spend hours in a jeep boucing along to the next client site while working on them at the same time.
Out of all the laptops being used they were the least likely to breakdown under the conditions we used them. (Unlike the users who sometimes suffered quite badly from all the conditions listed above)
The IBM international warranty is superb and the service is quick and professional. My experience with using it in Australia - was I phoned in the morning - they sent a courier out who picked it up 2 hours later that day. My machine was returned with a new system board without any questions.
I'm very impressed with the way they do things.
by chromacat
I don't know why, but I almost aways find the use of that word to be hilarious - probably because it's unexpected. Most people would use choke or strangle, but you do work at a library, so...
Anyway, thanks for the laugh.
On the laptops, do you have Latitudes or Inspirons?
I have only purchased Latitudes with the Gold technical support (which I heard was great) but then when a key went missing of a user's laptop, I got a bent replacement keyboard as a user serviceable part. Seriously, I had to bend it back to get it installed. The thing that gets me upset the most: The box it shipped in was packed with pillowy, styrofoamy goodness and was not damaged at all -- This means the part was bent either when it was picked or packed. Great quality control!!
by kathy.porch
And the survey says!!!!
Go with Dell...
IBM has a serious problem with scheduling and billing. HP has serious communication problems with India. Dell outsources tech support to India but repair/replace come right out of the good ole' USA...Texas!
I support Dell's both at work and home and have never had a problem with tech support. In fact, sersver support is exceptional (becuase they pulled that division back to the states) and I highly recommend purchasing PC's from them However, if you are in the market for heavy duty use printers, don't bother even considering Dell. Their printer support bites.
Take care.
by oz_media
IBM has a serious problem with scheduling and billing? What billing? 24/48 hours onsite, pretty easy schedule if oyou ask me. But BILLING? What BILLS do YOU pay for IBM's?
What's with US made computers being considered better? When have you EVER made something better?
No offense, Canada is no invention tweaker either.
But IBM support is STILL US based so language isn't an issue. TEchs are sent form Local depots the very next day and without a BILL?
I still don't see what BILLING you arereferring to? You mean after the 5 year warranty you have to pay for parts? 5 years and it's time to buy something new.
I STILL support a few DELL's gruidgingly, I HATE their tech suipport they are clueless. I hate the mailing out of parts that takes time. I HATE the fact that all teh parts are different each time you buy them, STANDARDS!!! I can see it for the average home user, but definietly not for business unles syou have on eof those cheapassed bosss that buys on price.
WHY is Dell so popular? Price, end of story.
by oz_media
Did you not notice that you completely contradicted yourself? TWICE? The second by making a noted unqualified opinion?
In one comment you said that anyone who has worked in IT for more than 12 months...
Well that includes most of the TR peers here I would say, therefore all of the opinions shown whether you and I agree or not, CAN be relevant, though many are offered from a single experience with just one of the products.
Your qaulifying statements are irrelevant, nobody cares how many PC's or how long you've been in the business, the most recent experience is obviously the most needed, companies and products change, as you yourself have explained.
But to your contradictions,
[i]Dell corporate support is far superior to anything IBM, Compaq/HP or any others trying to compete.[/i]
Is IBM now NEW to the game and trying to COMPETE for the PC industry?
Followed immediately by:
[i]"Four or Five years ago I would have said Dell is the best hands down. Over the past 5 years, their quality has drastically decreased, as well as their level of service."[/i]
So what is it, the best or the worst? I would read that as a pretty inconlusive opinion.
[i]"IBM is a non factor, since they have sold their desktop division to a Chinese company, I would reserve judgement until I see how that turns out."[/i]
Immediately followed by;
[i] That really only leaves Dell or Compaq / HP as the major players in the desktop market.[/i]
I thought you said you said would reserve judgement on IBM. How are they not a player now? Because the desktops division is not American? Those boxes are built all over the world with parts from every corner you can name. Why would havign Chinese ownership change the US based service departments? THEY still exist as do local support techs because they are outsourced to local reputable repair depots.
Where will I get 5 years of onsite support at no additional cost? All of the above? Who has more standards compliant hardware? IBM first, Compaq/HP sometimes, Dell...sure whatever. You get what you pay for, in business and in real life. You buy cheap, you GET cheap. You pay more, you GET more.
I haven't noticed ANY change in IBM's service or support staff in MANY years now, it has always been absolutely top notch, fast and effective, ONSITE service.
by oz_media
That argument is 100% based on IF's and speculation and certainly can't be a negative issue to be considered.
If IBM was supported in the US and techs were sent out from IBM authorized repair shops and NOW they are supported in the US and techs are sent out from IBM authorized repair shops, why would it matter if they are built in China?
What is wrong with a product designed in China? Other than the fact that quality assurance inrceases and price drops? THey have ALWAYS been made all over the place, why do people seem to think that because they were BASED in the US that it was better? I thought they were great when they were made in the US but I don't live there, why should I care if they are built under more stringent guidelines and sold for less?
Everyone has bitched and complained about IBM costs for years, so they make a sensibvle move that will effectively help reduce the costs while offering even tighter quality assuranec in manufacturing, but people STILL bitch because it isn't red white and Big blue anymore. Get over it, the world's a big place, you have never built a decent compact car either but nobody cares about those being made better in Japan, Germany, Brazil etc.
by bhunsinger
THe question about the sale of IBM to China raises just that , a question of what will be happening with their support 2 years from now. Have the prices gone down yet? No. Will the people making the decisionsdecide to take support East? Maybe. While rational people can come to a different understanding of the importance of this fact in their decision making, it does have to BE a factor. Just as much a factor as the DETERIATION of Dell customer support over the last few years. Not Gold business support maybe, but where will the bean counters start slicing next? Will the 'sucessful' managers from consumer support get promoted to Corporate Support? Will HP and Compaq find happiness after spurning Fiona? Stay tuned to 'As the Disk Turns"
And could we remember that each of were asked to share our experience and concerns about these vendors. My experience may be different from yours, but it is still what happened to me. Could we respect that.
by oz_media
We were asked to share our experience with these vendors. YOu said it yourself right there. So Predicting a failed support network for IBM is not an experience IS it?
Whyt haven't prices dropped? WEll I would say that first of all, desktops still roll out from North America and they are also selling back stock. THIS doesn't have a lower manufacturing cost.
WILL support suffer, nobody can say at this point so it is ocmplete heresay and unqualified opinion at this time.
As for the current support, IBM has locations all over the US that have a good reputation for support knowledge, haven't heard of too many layoffs in that department yet. So one can ASSUME that nothing has realy changed yet. As for support in the future WHO CARES? Seriously, it doesn't matter if they have crappy phone support from China or Zimbabwe for that matter, all they do is collect customer info and send out a tech anyway. It's not like they actuially even TRY to resolve issues on the phone.
Mr. Chan or MR. Wong, makes no difference when the only locally authorized support tech is Mr. Roberts from ABC company and is a friend who knows me and my system well. Are ythey perhaps gona start sending parts out form China now and we won't be able to read the instructions? Will Eddy Woo be flying out with a new keyboard for me?
I don't NEED support to speak good English, I can email them a trouble ticket and they will have a tech out ASAP. If you think their response time will suffer, think again. Bug Blue is STILL an American company, will they allow a Chinese division to run them into the ground? I would doubt it.
by kfonda
The question should be - Which vendor requires less support? The answer to that is easy - it's IBM. I've been doing this since 1983 and IBM has always been the most expensive and the most reliable.
Kevin Fonda
Manasquan, NJ
by sfc byte
by cybdiver1
Tech support is mostly only as good as your support staff. I hope I can explain this correctly.
If your staff does not trouble shoot the problem and calls up tech support and just says "We have an error message" then yes tech support will stink.
Lots of Tech support have no idea what your machine even looks like, they are looking at the same support pages on the web that you are.
Dell has a battery of Diags you should run before picking up the phone. Use their open manage product and you will have a diagnostic code before you even call. It will save you hours of time on the phone.
Be patient, don't yell at the tech they have a script to follow. Just like you they have a job to do. Learn how your tech support service works, learn the system.
If you do not get what you want ask for 2nd level support.
by cwestgor
I have worked with all three systems. The compaq/HP systems used to be very proprietary in their drivers and hardware, this made support very difficult. Fortunately, I have not had to deal with these for a long time.
I have worked with Dell for about 5 years now, and would highly recommend them. Of the 250 Optiplex systems we purchased, I have had only 1 fail from the start, and a total of 10 hard drives go bad. Support was always responsive and quick to send out a replacement part. The on-site support was actually farmed out through IBM in the Chicagoland area, and they were quick to respond as well.
I have recently changed jobs to a company which uses IBM. Their systems are 2 and 3 years old. They have replaced more than 40 hard drives in these systems in the last year alone. However, a few of the systems are out of warrantee, and they replaced the hard drive or motherboard anyway. IBM?s customer care is investigating the serial numbers of the systems we purchased, and may send replacement hard drives before they fail. This was still a lot of work for the technicians.
I experienced far less problems with the Dells, and they ran flawlessly with our applications. Drivers were easy to access, if needed, and you can track the systems on their web site. Their web support has been the best I have ever used!!! You enter the system number and you know exactly what drivers and software downloads are needed. They have wake-on-lan capabilities, as well as built in PXE (network) boot options. These make them great for deploying and maintenance.
Thanks!
Chris
by oz_media
Have you not realized that IBM offers excellent Web support for driver updates too?
IBM's site will auto detect your machine info and give you a list of the latest updates in seconds.
The online support is similar, it detects the serial and fills out the entire form except comments for you to submit to them, if you choose not to phone.
WOL and Network Boot capability is standard on most desktops these days.
But I find IBM's website support better than HP/Compaq too. Compaq's used to have awesome online support, until they mererged with the poorly designed HP website. Now your better off calling the 800# instead.
by fgarvin
The Dell Optiplex is a really solid system. But the GX280 has a LOT of problems. The Heatsink can cause the Proc fan to run extremely fast and sound like a jet taxiing for takeoff. Easy fix, just something to be aware of.
The Latitude D800 has issues with it's docking station. USB Throughput is terrible. I find it a real problem when you can't hook up a PDA to the docking station and be able to synch it. I wish they would re-hire some of those engineers they let go (Unless they are the ones who designed it in the first place).
by data_monkey
I worked in feedback for a company that analyzed data from support cases for HP/Compaq, Dell and Gateway. All I can say is, all the support is relatively equal. Poor by my standards (I've lived in a corporate support environment for the last seven years) but a standard for the industry. No matter who you choose, you'll be on the phone for hours, asked to call back or told you'll be contacted. ;) You'll be asked to format and reimage your harddrive to resolve simple issues, etc.
A while back, I heard that Dell was bringing some of their support back to the states from overseas but I haven't seen it for myself.
As far as I can tell from the majority of case notes, the turn-over rate for call-centers in India is a lot higher than it was in the states (which is high regardless), the amount of case notes I saw where a tech wasn't able to recognize common trends in support calls was a bit unnerving. It's my opinion that Dell has come the farthest with case note documentation and adapting to resolve new issues. I'm not saying that they will be able to resolve your issues the way you want them to but at least they're better informed about the issue when you call back (which you will) than the others.
I know this isn't an easy decision and all the posts here probably make it harder to decide but I think as far as the industry goes, cost and functionality, not support should be your major concern. Support from the OEMs is almost equally poor.
by dr dij
look up a part dell sells like a hard drive on shopping.com
they regulary have lowest ratings 2 1/2 stars of any vendor, (despite lowest prices).
you can read hundreds of peoples experiences with them. some good, mostly good only if they didn't need tech support. bad includes:
lies about availability and ship date
changes to terms (0% financing not available)
changes to price
doa
phone support hell (fairly recurring theme)
unable to cancel orders after telling them to after ship dates missed
cruddy parts
unable to return items
Have fun reading!
Most of the manufactors are using out sourcing for their tech support, and they harlly understand ENGLISH. Which as you know is an important task in 9-5 settings. Even Dell went outsourcing and most of microsoft's support services are now shot to H---!
Hope this helps!
Tdhclueless50@hotmail.com
by apotheon
by dafe2
Unless you have an ISO stamp & sound manufacturing processes forget it. So what if you use an intel product?
For every 9 or 10 machines you fix...........there are probably a hundred of those 'put together' crap boxes out there dying off.
'Quality Components' are one thing, and even then these guys, more often than not, buy the quality control rejects when 'building' these Frankenputers. How these components work together is whats important.
You'd be hard pressed to come up with the MTBF stats that a Brand name manufacturer CONSISTENTLY demontrates by using sound manufacturing processes & quality control.
by dafe2
Only if you use sound and CONSISTENT manufacturing processes(and) strict ISO standards.
ISO standards is not usually found in the "shops" or more often the basements that build the 'Frankenputers.'
THe only consitent thing about a Frankenputer is it's faillure rates. LOL
by apotheon
For a knowledgeable professional, I find that it's usually a good idea to build one's own computer when only one computer is needed for a particular task, for purposes of cost, reliability, predictability, and performance. When you need a number of standardized systems, however, it's better to go through a vendor that knows its business and has standardization process built into manufacturing/assembly procedures so that you'll get consistent quality and capability with platform pre-testing to suit your needs.
That having been said, I recommend high-quality organizations other than the Big Names in PCs. Don't get a Dell, an HP, a Compaq, a Gateway, or other Big Name contract: get your contract with someone that survives on quality and professional reputation rather than marketing and public perception. Of those asked about, I would tend to prefer IBM systems (particularly for servers or laptops), but I'd be more inclined to go with a quality vendor whose name is a complete mystery to the average soccer mom.
I've dealt with Nobilis/Equus with one of my current employers, and they've not done me wrong, as an example. Shop around for your own needs, and don't buy into marketing hype when choosing a brand name. It's about the quality of product and service, not the mystique attached to a name.
by dafe2
Agreed......
My primary box is a Laptop, however, I'll usually buy a barebone workstation from a reputable reliable source & build up from there.
Most recently this has been HP. I mostly concern myself with value for money.
Your last line says it best:
"It's about the quality of product and service, not the mystique attached to a name."
EXCEPT when it comes to certain cars. LOL
by wrifraf
I work for a large company that was using Dell and because of a number of excuses when requesting warranty work, we move to IBM ThinkCentre A50. These machines are very stable. We've been running them for a number of months now and out of 973 PC's only 6 have had to be called in for warranty.
IBM has a warranty that is structed for self-maintainers and for those companies that need assistance from IBM. We used both. When out Tech Support orders the part and does the work ourselves, we file an e-claim that reimbuses the company for the work done. The only down fall is I had to spend money getting my Tech's A+ Certified and to take the IBM test. This is required to be considered a self-maintainer, otherwise you should not have any problems.
by mbelmore
As the IT Administrator of 350+ PC's. I too have recently been through the mill of Vendors.
Just for you information we previously used Dell until their change of Spec's (almost weekly) meant system 'ghosting' was out of the question and as for performance? Well fair at best. Pricing is comparable but Dell has lost focus on its Business customers these past few in favour of continued Market share.
IBM I agree are pricey. But the newer range of system including the small-factor M-series are well worth a look. My last discussion with an IBM allowed us the base prices of <$800 per unit and $199 for a 15in Monitor/ $279 for a 17in Monitor. So al little higher than the competition but IBM has a better product these days.
Gateway - still a way behind the rest. Performance from their desktops is dull and the pricing includes many non-standard features (but optional-cost add on's).
Compaq - of all the manufacturer machines I have purchased (approx. 50-80 PC's) I have never experienced a problem with any of them.
The DX2000 (soon to be phased out) has plenty of speed and the standard unit perform well.
A base unit upgraded to 512Mb (to handle XP's baggage) run's us around $690. So with an LCD and Office the price is $1300-1400.
3yr warranty and next day repair. Very impressed.
Quick note - if you looking at standardizing with a single vendor don't forget to ask about 'special pricing'. HP/Compaq is keen to get back PC market share in both Business and Home sectors. So far they offer impressive discount problems if you stay with the same product.
by daveaaaaaa24
The support can't be satisfactory if the system is a bummer. Make sure the quotes you're getting are for business grade systems. They should have a 3-year
on-site next-business day warranty.
Like the HP (Compaq) business models I sell, the components are better very reliable.
Apart from the warranty, you are the support because the actual tech on the phone will vary widely in competence.
When I sell these systems, as a local reseller, I
make sure they call me, and I deal with tech and then we it right virtually all the time.
Dave Smiley
by gene.parks
I read your request and you have purchased from Dell in the past but you have never purchased optiplex. We deploy these machines all the time. We pull them out of the box, blow our image on them and put them in service. I have not called Dell support for any issues on over 600 machines in 4 years. Hate dealing with support anyway.
I have used support from IBM, and Compaq/HP. They are all about the same in my opinion.
I would suggest going with a mochine built for the job that you do not need to call support.
Gene
by rb_snow
Hello,
Without knowing any particulars about your involvement, if you have a mixed brand shop, it really doesn't matter who you use. If you are uncomfortable with one vendor then do not use that vendor. If you need extra support for the hardware, it would probably be less expensive to hire an additional tech. With the extra help, you have a stronger position.
If you were buying a thousand new units the question asked would be important. Only 20 units should be a minor decision. If your plate is so full that the question is strangling you, the additional help is needed to insure company satisfaction. If you are replacing 20 units, it shouold not matter at all who you use. It all depends on who the skills of the tech.
by gabriella
by bleedingedge
My 2 cents from 20 years supporting PCs.
1. HP/Compaq is the best if you know what you're doing (a tech yourself) and you have a difficult problem.
2. IBM support has always been responsive. Even when they have farmed out the equipment and support to other companies.
3. Dell support is great if you are a rookie. If you have any more than a month's worth of computer experience you will be smarter than the brain dead chimps they hire for their support.
Desktops; I buy Dell. Laptops; I buy IBM. If I ever want a machine that works, I'll probably buy a MAC. Until then, I'll enjoy the challenge of making these guys behave.
by computab
by oz_media
First of all, nobody is going to give you a reference to someone they HAVEN'T helped or that has complained about them. A company having three or four happy clients is hardly a measure of success.
Anyone can provide two or three written testimonials and asking a company to offer a phone reference is completely silly. If I had a supplier give MY number out to people asking for a reference, I am gonna get pretty damn tired of a weekly call from some insecure buyer.
My work requires constant use of testimonials and but people asking for phone references can get stuffed. Sure I have happy clients, but that's because I don't give their number out to every yahoo who second guesses me.
I would just ask THEM about what types of installs or landmark jobs they have landed.
If they have done the local school board, police department, local training academy's etc. THen you can pretty much trust that they are capable of supporting a few systems as those contracts are generally under a tight tender especially when it comes to non-OEM stuff.
But whenever I see people checking out a company, even checking out a potential employee, and wanting references, I just roll my eyes. I don't want your business if that's how you evaluate a potential employee/purchase.
Any company can provide you with a few good references regardless, who cares if three of fifteen hundred clients are happy?
by msprn3
When I purchased my HP online a couple of years ago, I attempted to call HP tech support. I got somebody with an Indian (as in Bombay, India) accent who could not understand my requests about having the hard drive fragmaented (he kept asking me how it had gotten broken). The information must not have been in his troubleshooting application. By talking to him briefly, I got the impression that he had no technical knowlege of anything to do with computers other than how to use applications.
I was not favorably impressed.
by cg it
Why buy the damn stuff when Dell, Gateway, HP, IBM, Compaq, and all the rest have terrible phone support, terrible techs and if hardware goes down, you have to rely upon them to get new stuff and all they do is go back to the mfg anyways.
We build them ourselves and use the MFGs warranty. we buy our O/S with volume licensing. Give us stuff to do and we know the machines cuz we built em, instead of having to fart around with something someone else built and given the tech support the big 3 has, who knows what kind of guys built em.
by dafe2
And what kind of guys build them?
The answer to question #1 is for the quality, warranty & consistent usage of parts. If I buy 1, 20 or 500 systems...they all use the SAME components, with the possible exeption of a diferent ROM rev.
The answer to question #2 is (usually) robotics not 'some guy'.
Who, today, would put together machines in business is beyond me.....but I guess there's one in every crowd.
Farting arround building boxes in business usually translates to screwing over your data aquisition.
***I customize or build some systems for my own personal uses.....but it's MY data to lose.***
by hal 9000
One of the Big Companies getting a hardware problem back and the first thing that they do is wipe the HDD and reload it with the original install to see if it still doesn't work.
Sorry I've seen this with something as simple as the wrong screen display settings and no matter just how much I begged to know the default settings they just had to have it back and destroy everything on the drive so they could reset the defaults by reinstalling the system.
Of course the lack of help desk guy was insistent that what the unit was running was acceptable even if you couldn't read anything written on the screen. But a transport charge either way and repacking the 2 week old machine and the 2 weeks down time plus the loss of all the stored data was an acceptable turn around period and repair when all that was really required was a display resolution change.
Col
by leighgresham
I have been an avid Mac operator for 20 yrs. I learned by mistake
that Apple has a support network that would be hard to top. The
secret is to take out an Applecare policy mine for single
workstation was about $250. They have answered every
question I've ever had. Also if a part breaks down they replace it
free. I just got a new hard drive with installation. It cost me
nothing. I've gone 5 yrs. now on this single investment. Pleasant,
knowledgeable staff. Leighla
by jtakiwi
by eric
by tx-netware
by hal 9000
Tell you that the shiny side is supposed to go down?
I got that one once and tried to crawl down the phone line and have a quite little talk to the particular person. It would have involved ripping their arms off and beating them to death with the soggy ends. :)
I just love the way you are treated as they are the first point that you ever consider contacting when you have a problem rather than you have to be dragged kicking and screaming for protection before even considering ringing them up as it is just way to painful an experience that you don't willingly want to go through again.
Col ]:)
by newitguy
I used to think Dell's support was below standard but I believe that have really picked it up a notch.
Not too long ago I had a request for a dell power supply and the person on the other line couldn't understand power supply. They kept saying battery. Anyway, it took over an hour to order 1 power supply. But recently the upgrade to their web site and the fact that they moved some if not all of their IT support back to the US is welcoming.
I am now in the Education sector and a my support is good. I'm not sure if the Education sector has anything to do with it though. But I would say Dell would be a good choice. I am not too sure of the other ones.
by livinghell
by andeanderson
Last year we switched to Dell for our Server and work stations and the tech support was great.
A few months ago Dell changed their Tech Support function to out-sourced companies, I think they are in India, and the tech support became one of "If it's not on my troubleshooting chart I can't help you.
Here is the last response I received from Dell's Gold Support Team: "This issue goes beyond the intended level of support that Dell Computer
Corporation typically can offer." They wanted us to start paying them for the Support we had already paid for when we bought the systems. And that was for brand new Dimension 4700 Desktops. So, we sent them back to Dell.
Even Toshiba Support has gone downhill in the last couple of months.
We are seriously looking at just building our own White Boxes from now on. That way we could at least get tech support from the component manufacturers.
by mslevette
by pierre!
Been a MPC shop since 1998, 100% MPC for the past year. It has made life sooooo much easier!
Last year the longest it took me to get a tech on the phone was 5:39 (Five Minutes, Thirty Nine Seconds!) The average hold time was One Minute.
Once on the phone with the tech, I did not have to ask him what he had just said. I easily understand those Techs in Nampa Idaho USA. That has great value for me and the staff!!!
Micron - The Secret Weapon...
L8ter!
by ka4nmx
We switched to Gateway.
I get 3yr warranty on site with Gateway. Responce time is noramlly 1-5 days for replacment parts. I have received parts the next day and at times no longer than 5 days.
I work for a county school system and support 2,200 desktops. We don't have a credit card big enough for Dell to talk to us when we need support. IBM is not longer in the desktop business. And I would never buy a HP computer, cpnn (Compac with new name (and just as slow as the original Compac's computers)).
Hope this helps.
by timbeech
by theroyala9
Are there any bulk rate dealers for mobos and
such? I build my own too. i get killed on the
retail packaging, s&h retail pricing end. I
priced out a simalar set up for ~380 wo/ display
and os and what not. oems pay about half after
it gets there. with individualized pieces one
ballooned markup blows the whole budget. i get a
hardware manufacture warrentty if i like. they
charge for bad returns.
for twenty units, if theyre on the same foor you
could knock off twelve of those cdroms, make half
dvd+-rw's and double up 6 of them and shave off a
couple $.
there are few dell computers I've met that aren't
slick machines. not too many experimentals, no
junk. i have a slot 1 550 optiplex. this is an
ok box. the graphics are weak and its slow. the
box can drop all the cards, processor and ram in
under a minute, which is something to concider.
With hp you could get anything. I wish they still
had those steal cases. not much room but so
solid. someone mentioned compaq -- what planet
are you from?
ibm is like dell, keeps their value, no funny
stuff. They dont sell store models and so CS is
on the professional level. they are more
prepared to give higher order assistance for
small customers.
support is a site, docs and in this case
downloads too. dell has gotten sloppy with spec
sheets and such once or twice.
This may be a bit too late to help the OP, but the title of my reply comes from today's headline...
Dell will hire another 2,000 people for its India offices, the company has reported, bringing its total number of Indian employees up to 10,000 by the year's end.
http://story.news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&cid=75&e=1&u=/nf/20050429/tc_nf/33846
by dotcommie
I guess that 2004 is a long time ago, now... I don't think eMachines really can be competitive in a business arena because of the cost for replacement parts (double or more than similar parts). Their systems use more proprietary parts, which makes the replacement of an entire machine more likely than maintaining it to current standards.
I think that everyone will have differing opinions on systems because the vendors are all very comparable. It's almost as bad as watching politics, nowadays. (Definition) Politics - from Greek Poly (meaning 'many') and tics (meaning 'blood-sucking creatures').
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending