Discussion Locked

Which Windows to use?

0 helpful
17 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I will be porting a system I developed under Solaris to a Windows Platform in the next few months. About 2/3 of the system will be rewritten in Java and the rest will remain C++.

Which Windows operating system should I use?

As I understand it, currently there is NT 4.0, ME, 2000 and XP (soon). What are the differences between them?

17 replies

by guruofdos

You missed a few!! Windows 3.0, Windows 3.1, Windows for Workgroups 3.11, which are all 16 bit versions and still in use in around 15% of the world PC community. Then ya have the 9x series windows, Windows 95, Windows 98 etc....this is the 32bit 'home user' version of windows but with many 16 bit parts. 9x is necessary for games as many features required for gaming are simply not supported under 'NT' Windows. NT3.51 was the forerunner to NT4.0 and is the 16 bit version of NT. NT4 is true 32 bit, but has been patched so many times it's ridiculous...and little or no built-in support for USB, AGP, DVD or many of the newer features. 2000 is effectively NT5.0 and is essentially NT4 with the Windows 98 goodies.

ME is if you like, Windows 983rd edition...or what would have been Windows 2000 if Microsoft opted to go their original route of one OS, dual options.

XP is another attempt by MS to cause even more confusion.

Best stick with 98SE for personal use, and Win2k for commercialuse.

by marcial.rodriguez

I think everyone had some good things to say. I would surely move away from 9x and forget about NT 4 and ME. I like the fact that Win2K is built on a stable NT technology with a lot of user friendly capabilities (like finding drivers). I would even consider waiting awhile until XP is stable enough; from what I've seen/heard, it's going to be a great step-up in windows technology.

by lordinfidel

Use win2k pro. It is the most stable out of all of them.

If you have the option, Stay clear away from 98/98se/ME/XP. If you are going to do a NT based system, go with 2K

2K is the best OS to date that M$ has developed. It beats NT4 hands down when it comes to reliabilty and flexibility.

XP I just don't trust. It has not proven itself, plus it's liscensing model sucks.

ME, just don't do it. It is a souped of version of 98 that can't network itself to save it's life. Horrible OS; I wouldn't even use the cd as a drink coaster.

(don't forget to format your drive with NTFS and do not upgrade!, fresh install)

by khahina

I'm agree. Win2kpro
if you want perenize your product.

Xp is newest but not enough stable, based on lot of W2Kpro , and no matters to talk about licensing politics .

W98/SE/ME would be dead in none so long time

by shah_sar

There are wide range of os offered by micrsft
They all vary with your req.If you have less
use of network then win98se is the best option.Bec it is old and much more stable then other new desktop os offered by micsft.
And if you want high end winthen go for nt
bec it has less bugs then 2000 and more easy.No one know much about 2000 so u will find a bit tough to work on it and there will
be less tech supp.

by shuja52

The best bet today is WIN2K, it is actually upgrade of WINNT. WIN XP is ultimate OS, using features of both WINNT and WINMe/WIN98 series. For your purpose IWN 2K is the best.

by lordinfidel

I would not trust xp. Especially if it uses anything based on 98/95.

The whole purpose of OS evolution is to move to more reliable platforms. Not go backwards.

by satnel

XP is fine. It is not based on anything in 9X. It simply has some "features" from 9x. TO make it as simple as possible, XP has a new NT kernel under the hood making it the most stable Windows I have ever used, but it has all of the multimedia andhome features most home users crave that are NOT in or NOT fully supported in 2K or NT4.
I've been using XP since Beta2 and I have to say Microsoft busted their butt on this one. They did a greta job on it. XP has never crashed on me ONCE, and that was while using Beta2(2462), RC1(2505), and presently RC2(2525). Rock solid, and the extra features unique to XP are great. When you use it, then go back to 2K or a 9x, you miss it. Really.
Personally, XP still isn't good enough for me sinceI primarily play games. It's great for everything else, and lots have had no problems playing games in XP. However, I think I'll stay with my very stable Win95B for my games, and continue to go back and forth between XP and Linux for everything else I do.

by lordinfidel

I would not trust xp. Especially if it uses anything based on 98/95.

The whole purpose of OS evolution is to move to more reliable platforms. Not go backwards.

by lyncham

I'm surprised at how many responses you got to such an open-ended question. While I am certain that most of the responses were from people who have much better experience than I do as a techie, my first response to your question would be another question; what will you application do and what kind of application is it? Other than that, I would want to develop a system that fits the Windows platform that the majority of my target market is using, and then write my code to that platform. In speaking with most excellent programmers, I've found that the best ones all try to write the program so that it controls for most of the functions necessary within itself with minimal intrustions by outside platforms. Having said this, Java is one of those programs that will allow for this. So, as long as your code is truly excellent, any problems will usually be within the "host" platform. Those can then be adjusted for later.

by rcsoar4fun

I am curious, why the switch from Solaris? If it had short comings for you it would be good to know before recomending an OS. That having been said Win 2K is really the only MS OS that is good for commercial use. 98se has security issues typical of the Fat32 OS that cannot be overcome. NT 4.0 lacks many nice modern features. Its support life from Microsoft is coming to an end. Win2K is fairly stable and will be supported for some time to come. XP may be an alternative IF you can wait a year or so for most of the bugs to be worked out. The transistion from 2k to XP should be fairly simple if you decide to take that route later on.

by mazeing

Unfortunately, that is a political decision. The system I'm building is for the military and they've decided that Unix is too difficult (I guess), so we must change to a PC platform (because everybody knows how to use it).

And, besides, 100 million lemmings can't be wrong :)

by mazeing

I was surprised as well. I was expecting more answers along the lines of yours asking for more details.

As it turns out, I'm finding that I might not have a decision in the matter. The customer for this system has a specified operating system that they supply that is a modification of the original.

My main concern was to be able to avoid pitfalls of your last statement, that was the problems of the host platform. I was trying to avoid those as much as possible by picking the best Windows platform, since that's where I've been told to go.

As a Unix programmer for the past 10 years, I've don't trust much of what Microsoft puts out.

by windwalker7

M$ has intorduced a bug that will make it a cinch for any hacker to create denial-of-service (DOS) problems through XP. M$ has been notified and has refused to fix the bug. For full details of the analysis, the currently existing hacks, and M$ replies, see Steve Gibson's website, at: http://grc.com/dos/intro.htm
I wouldn't touch XP if you paid me, unless the box was never connect to the Internet.

by admin

A whole lot of other people, not necessarily XP users, will have increased dDos poblems in direct proportion to increasing XP use.....

This discussion is closed to new replies.