First XP is step backwards from 2k. I do not have high hopes for Vista, but then I do not plan to run Vista unless I absolutly *need* to. I am still running 2k on my personal windows box (even though it shipped with XP). The first two years of XP problems have probably jaded me.
One thing that should change over the coming years is the price difference for "server" and "home" editions. Exactly what is the difference?
As a local consultant I use my laptop in a variety of roles every day. If a firewall dies, I reconfigure my laptop to be a NATing router, complete with DHCP, DNS, and proxy services. I can reconfigure my laptop on the fly, without rebooting, to be a file server, web or email server, basically whatever tasks need to be completed. In this way I can reduce down time for my clients while I fix their systems. This laptop also makes for a smoking workstation.
Needless to say I do not run windows, as the different roles I described can not be met by a single MS product. Reconfiguring their products usually involves a reboot, which is more annoying when you are not used to it.
The point is that the difference between "server" and "workstation" or "home" editions is arbitrary, and thus nonexistant on many platforms (BSD and Linux come to mind). Even product versions are largely irrelevant. I do not need to install a fresh copy of an OS when it is relaesed. I have several severs that have been in service for many years, migrating to new hardware as needs dictate. This is not data migration, I move the hard drives or copy the drives bit for bit to the new hardware. The OS upgrades itself piece by piece, obliterating the need for data migration to a new or updated platform, even across "major" product version numbers. Again, you can't do this with *any* MS product. For me it is a matter of choosing the best tools, and MS does not currently come close for me.
We should not forget that computers and cars are tools to help us get work done. Why let a vendor dictate the role of a computer and thus what work you can or can not get done? Why should I be tied to their roadmap? Why should I be tied to the illusion
The answer is that you don't have to be. The best tool for recovering windows machines is a live linux CD (http://www.sysresccd.org/), so that is what I carry with me.
In the end, the discussion of Vista does not matter. Since windows XP (home or pro) does not meet my needs, I suspect Vista will not either. If it suited my needs I would switch. That should be the focus, the needs of the user or organization. For many, they have no choice in the platform, so they will be moving to Vista and will simply have to cope with whatever Vista turns out to be.