Discussion Locked

Why do they call them 3.5 inch drives?

0 helpful
48 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I think that back when floppy discs were the main way to store and move files on all computers, the 5.25 size and then the 3.5 size, everyone started calling the drive for the latter a 3.5 inch drive. Now they use the term for everything, i.e. 3.5" HDD, and card reader for 3.5" bay, or USB hub-fits in 3.5" bay etc. Has anybody but me ever bothered to check the drive or drive bay size? If you do you'll find that they're 4" wide. All so-called 3.5" drives are. I think it's too late to change now but why did it start in the first place. I gave my reason which is the only one I can think of. Anybody else have any ideas or responses to this?

48 replies

by charliespencer

While the floppy disk itself is 3.5" wide, -very- early drives for it were the same size as drives for 5.25" floppies, and both size drives mounted in the same 5.25" bay.

4" drives for 3.5" floppies appeared very quickly, but case manufacturers were slow to build machines with two sizes of drive bays. Instead, there were adapters used to mount a 4" drive in a 5.25" bay - carriages, rails, etc.

Eventually manufacturers began building systems with two sized of bays 5.25 and 4".

The drive is called a 3.5" drive not because of the physical size of the drive itself, but because of the size floppy disks it uses. The resulting bay is also referred to the same way because until recently all you could mount in one was a 3.5" drive.

Oh, and "diesel cars" aren't made of diesel; they're called that because of the fuel they use. Also, "dairy cows" aren't made of milk. I could go on about parking in driveway and driving on a parkway, but that's been done to death (literally).

by kirk227

Most of what you say I agree with, but have you bothered to measure your 5.25" bay? It's just under 6 inches. Just thought I should clarify.

by charliespencer

The 5.25" bay got it's name the same way. 5.25" drives were called that not because of their physical width, but because they used 5.25" floppy disks. 5.25" bays held 5.25" drives; they aren't 5.25" wide.

Same deal with 8" floppy drives; they used 8" disks, they weren't 8" wide.

In our next class guest instructor w2ktechman will discuss 1200 baud modems, and why they didn't actually transmit 1200 bytes per second.

by dr. tarr

I get almost all of my hardwood rough sawn and it is at least 2"x4", occasionally a little larger.

by kirk227

I understand it came from the size of the disks. I was just responding to Palmetto's post. By the way, if we applied that logic everywhere a steering wheel would still be called the reins and a space helmet would be an aviator's cap. Those are the kind of analogies used earlier.

by charliespencer

"...a steering wheel would still be called the reins and a space helmet would be an aviator's cap."

Inputing a telephone number is still called "dialing", although phones haven't had dials in decades. Televisions don't either, but advertisers still tell you to, "Don't touch that dial!"

You've left the realm of logic and entered the vague world of etymology.

by seanferd

Properly, it is a 3.5" disk drive. It is a machine which drives a 3.5" disk. This is logically correct, shortened names notwithstanding.

<3.5" disk>
not
<3.5">

by the 'g-man.'

The question was:

Why do they call them 3.5 inch drives?

The answer I provided is correct.

Why on earch would you apply that naming convention everywhere anyway?

It is a naming convention for hard drives based on the disk platter size, so what?

You comments made no sense and reek of somebody looking to start arguments despite getting the correct answer.

Why are you called Kirk227?
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.

Based on that then I'm using Keyboard476462469454
Mouse46734958639869865
Screen34578547873678735

Sad.

by kirk227

Just to really mess up your argument I checked the size of a 3.5" platter and guess what? It's 3.75 inches. Try again. I appreciated your answer by the way. I just thought your analogies stunk. That's why I replied in kind.

by oh smeg

Every HDD that I have ever trashed has 3.5 Inch Platters in it.

They are 3.5 inch in Diameter not any other size but then again I only use Seagate, Samsung, Fujitsu and Hitachi Drives none of the others.

As I remove the platters and destroy them it's easy to compare the size as they are all in a bundle before going into the furnace.

Col

by kirk227

I remeasured to make sure. It's definitely 3.75. I guess to be totally accurate it was more like 3.72. As you know, Maxtor is now owned by Seagate but this was made long before that. I'd rip open another one if I had another dead one, but this is all I've got.

by oh smeg

Than the Media that they contain. So a 3.5 Inch drive takes 3.5 Inch Media and when it comes to HDD the Platters are 3,5 Inch in Diameter. Just as a 2.5 Inch Drive has 2.5 Inch Platters. If you actually measure a 3.5 Inch HDD it's not 3.5 inches wide either.

4 Inches for a 3.5 Inch Drive Bay is a standard measurement that indicates the size of the Media used to store Data on, not the size of a Drive the drives have to be larger to fit the media in. :)

However my favorite is with Metric Conversions in every Metric Country it's not uncommon to say use a XX mm Socket here. They then go on to say a XX mm Socket with a 1/2 inch drive. I could never quite workout how the French/Germans for argument sake can talk in Metric for the Socket Sizes but in Imperial for the Drive Sizes for the Sockets. The standard Drive sizes for all Sockets are 1/4, 3/8, 1/2, 3/4 and 1 Inch.

Then depending on the actual measurement standard used sometimes the Size can refer to the size of the Head across the Flats or the size of the threaded area in it's Diameter. Wire and Metal Gages are similar they make sense till you think about things. :D

Col

by nicknielsen

One would think that as the wire diameter got smaller or the sheet metal thinner, the numbers would be lower. NOT!

by hal 9000

That both Wire and Metal Gages are different as one gets smaller the numbers get bigger and just as you have wrapped your head around that you hit the other one as the numbers get smaller the thickness gets bigger. :D

Or have I messed that up again? :(

Col ]:)

by bizzo

Because they fit into a bay designed/sized for a 3.5" floppy drive.
Similarly, internal CD/DVD drives fit into a bay designed for a 5.25" floppy drive.

The measurements are for the size of the floppy disk that fits into the drive that the bay can hold.

I suppose it's just old terminology that hasn't changed, and does it really need to?

by hal 9000

So that the average person can be as confused as Hell.

After all what's the point of keeping a Standard that everyone understands when they don't understand the Bloody Computer anyway? :D

[b]Confuse the Hell[/b] out of them I say and keep them confused it's easier that way. :^0

That isn't a 5.25 Inch Slot it's a DVD Slot and that isn't a 3.5 Inch bay it's a 500 GIG Bay. Sort of difficult when the more commonly used HDD are bigger than 500 GIG though. :p

Col ]:)

by w2ktechman

notebook drives go by drive size (1.8"/2.5", etc.) however desktop drives dont ?:|
Now please let me know how to confuse the HAL a bit more now :^0

by kirk227

I'm sorry if it seemed I was trying to start an argument. I just had a recent event that brought it to my attention. I would agree with the platter size idea except for one thing. If you go by the platter size on a HDD then why don't you use the same criteria on the original 3.5" floppy disk. I haven't pulled one apart to measure but obviously the platter in it can't be 3.5", thus, it was named after the shell size, not it's contents. My original opinion as I stated is that the industry just continued to use the terms 3.5" bay and 5.25" bay because it would have been confusing to change the terminology. Everyone was already familiar with the two size standards so they stuck. I think I proved that it is not based on the size of the platter, but others disagree. I only brought it up because I wanted other opinions which I got. Why is that a problem for you? As to your other question. It refers to the length of a part of my anatomy. I'll let you guess where the decimal point goes. Then again, it might be metric. I hope you aren't po'd at me. I respect and enjoy your opinions as well as those of other contributors to this site. That's why I asked the question. Not to argue, just to start a discussion. If I offended you, I apologize.

by the 'g-man.'

Removable disks are measured by the physical size if the enclosure that would house them when accessed. This is to indicate the size needed to house the access device.

Fixed Hard Disks by platter size inside them.

Glad we cleared that up.

by hal 9000

Something like Moly Di Sulfate would be my first choice. It's super slippery, Nonconductive and doesn't rub off.

If you apply enough you may even get one of those old open real Tape Drives from the Old Mainframes to fit in a PC Case as well. :0

Col

by seanferd

But they are considerably larger before they dry. This has reminded me of very old 2x4s I've run across (90+ years old) which were a bit larger than the modern variety, and a heck of a lot harder. Both properties probably have something to do with the density of very old-growth lumber. :)

by nicknielsen

You may be right about the higher density of old-growth lumber, but there weren't as many finishing steps back then either; the lumber was cut to dimension, air-dried, and used. Today, the lumber is cut to dimension, kiln-dried, then finished (surface planed, edges rounded, etc.) to the standard dimensions.

by hal 9000

I seem to remember that the NB Drive in my hand at the moment has a 2.5 inch platter in it. It's an old 2.5 inch 80 GIG NB Drive that died a while ago after the Guarantee had run out so I took a look see.

Not sure about the 1.8 inch drives as I haven't had one fail yet. :p

Col ]:)

by oh smeg

Do you want me to look?

At the Semi Trailer that I have just Transported to 300 feet above The Scummy Ones place of residence perhaps? :^0

Col

by oh smeg

I change TR Accounts log in with a different User Name & Password and nothing happens. :(

Third Time I have tried to change User Accounts and it's not working.

Col

This discussion is closed to new replies.