Discussion Locked

Why we need to cut more trees and replant to save the environment

0 helpful
243 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is an excellent article from the co-founder of Greenpeace Patrick Moore.

http://www.canada.com/vancouversun/news/editorial/story.html?id=67623834-a1af-42e4-91cb-28492a462651

To summarize, he says the anti-forestry rhetoric like Leonardo DiCaprio's latest climate-change rant, The 11th Hour is harming the environment.

Moore gives a convincing argument why cutting old trees and replacing them with young trees removes a lot more carbon from the atmosphere. He also argues that it's even more important to remove those that are dying or are already dead because it reduces forest fires which put out massive amounts of carbon. On the other hand a piece of furniture from hundreds of years ago hasn't released any carbon.

Here's a quote:
"To address climate change, we must use more wood, not less. Using wood sends a signal to the marketplace to grow more trees and to produce more wood. That means we can then use less concrete, steel and plastic -- heavy carbon emitters through their production. Trees are the only abundant, biodegradable and renewable global resource."

243 replies

by dr dij

this destroys streams, increases runnoff, etc.

And cutting trees near developments increases landslides.

While wood products are a good carbon sink, the tree farms do suck up less carbon than old growth forests (but way more than parking lots :)

by georgeou

You don't do clearcutting on steep hill sides and near streams and no one suggested that we do so. You do that on flat lands and you replant in controlled sections of clearcutting and you'll have a new forest there within 10 years pulling out more carbon from the atmosphere.

What you do is remove the dead trees which the eco fanatics won't let us do which is causing massive fires. Then their "let burn" policy massacred the forest when active forest management should have eased us in to a natural fuel state before we revert to a natural "let burn" policy.

Patrick Moore makes a great point about forestry and why it's important to use wood and Hollywood and the eco fanatics just don't get it.

by cactus pete

Old trees have their place in the ecosystem, as much as saplings. Even more so, in some regards.

Old trees are homes for many animals. Dead trees are homes and eventually food for many things, as well.

The only problem with the fires is that people live near the path of the fire. Stop building mansions there are no one cares, right?

The solution is massive cutting and replanting, and it's not forcing people to go without. It's in the middle. Finding the balance between short term human needs and long term world needs is the grail for which we should be looking.

by drowningnotwaving

Keeping old growth forests, saving the habitats, protecting thousand-year-old trees just because they are thousand-year-old trees, etc etc etc - Good.

Growing new forests, planting billions of trees, using them wisely etc etc etc - Very Good.

You don't have to destroy the old forests in order to grow new forests.

edited to make some kind of sense. I think.

by w2ktechman

But it is not entirely accurate. Steel, Concrete, and Plastic have their places as well. That piece of furniture can catch on fire, while the steel and concrete can still be very strong and durable in a fire. Plastics can be molded to do more things with less wear and longer reliability.
It may be better to try to reduce emissions from these other items rather than finding the most cost effective way (current ways) to do this.
Concrete would be the easiest among these to do. The main polluter is crishing the rock into the concrete powder. The rock crushers are powered by fossil fuels.
Steel needs to be heated thousands of degrees during its process, so it would be harder to find alternatives to the process.
However, I do not know much about plastics, and the creation. But I would bet it is more akin to steel, depending on the strength and type of plastics (but probably not the same amount of intense heat)

by Member 25348569

One of the constituents is crushed limestone - Calcium Carbonate - which, when it is heated as part of the cement making process, releases huge quantities of fossil CO2. That is in addition to what the heating produces.

by tony hopkinson

Cutting down trees has never been the problem, cutting down forests has.

We should do a lot more with trees in urban areas, it's alright saying the land the tree takes up is valuable living space, but the difference a little copse or even a row of evergreens down a street makes is huge.

Turns an area from a drab, grey piece of concrete into a living area.

by jdclyde

If we can't see them from our cubicles ( no, actually I have an office ) what does it matter?

Soon it will be winter here in Michigan, which means it will be dark when I go into work, and even darker when I come out at night. :(

I HATE "daylight savings time". X-(

by tony hopkinson

you mights see a tree!

If all else fails mount the streetlight in it, living lampost.

You should have a plant in your cubicle anyway to bouncing ideas off it's leaves.
Liable to get a better answer off it than your manager anyway.

by Member 25348569

Trees can be very useful at night as roosts for birds so that they can crap on my car. But I don't begrudge the little feathered bastards if it saves the planet.

by tony hopkinson

our ancestors were quite happy living in them.

:D

Course I was thinking of dwarf conifers, prunus alba, creeping juniper verges instead of grass.

by Member 25348569

The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change say tree-planting will, at best, simply buy the world a little time but may make things worse.

You, the US, are the biggest emitter of greenhouse gases, and you would love to believe that you can plant your way out of doing anything to curb that output by creating new forests to soak up your CO2 but the IPCC says these planned forests, "carbon sinks", will soon become saturated with carbon and start returning most of it to the atmosphere. This may well have the effect of accelerating global warming, not slowing it down.

The statement from the IPCC is "New forests are temporary reservoirs that can buy valuable time to reduce industrial emissions, not permanent offsets to these emissions."

Annual CO2 emissions from human activity add just over six billion tonnes of carbon to the atmosphere, of which about a third is absorbed by the world's forests and so the simple idea that more trees would simply mean more carbon absorption gave rise to the happy idea that there was leeway to carry on polluting.

The problem is that although trees absorb CO2 during photosynthesis, they also release it back into the air when plant matter breaks down the sugars they have made by respiration (trees need energy, you know). Respiration increases in response to temperature rises, which are triggered by the rising levels of CO2 and, if (when) that happens, the effect will be to turn the forests from sinks to sources of carbon.

This has only been realised recently because, although CO2 take-up is instantaneous, the warming that triggers respiration has a built-in delay of about 50 years due to the oceans' thermal inertia.

So planting more trees could soon prove a quick way of speeding up climate change, not of moderating it.

Neil :)

by jdclyde

We just continue to cut the trees down before they are 50 years old!

I would think the idea of this is suppose to be in conjunction with reducing emissions elsewhere, not instead of.

As there will be no single solution, shouldn't we look at knocking out as many smaller issues, when and where we can?

The argument that I hear all the time of "that won't solve the issue" is overused. Just like drilling in the ANWAR won't replace the US need for Middle East oil, it will REDUCE it. All steps in the right direction.

by Member 25348569

The research suggests that it may make things worse if the temperature rises. The very worst case could be for the US and others to plant forests and use this as an excuse to not do anything else - which seems to be what people would like. On our little island, we don't have that option anyway.

The problem is not that fifty year old trees become carbon sources rather than sinks but that in fifty years time the climate may have changed to make the forests ALL nett sources.

Even if that's not the case, it's not just a matter of cutting the trees down before they are fifty years old, because what do you do with the wood? Unless you plant some GE'd ultra-fast-growing stuff, you don't have a lot that's usable and even the GE'd trees would produce softwood which all decays back to CO2 anyway. If you plant slow-growing trees that provide useful hardwood, you don't get a lot in fifty years. Unless you plant [b]proper[/b] trees - i.e. a real mix with lots of undergrowth - you f*ck up the biodiversity.

Doomed! We're all doomed!

Neil :D

I did tell myself that I wouldn't get into a TRGW discussion again but I couldn't let myself be lectured ON CLIMATE CHANGE by dear old George. M$, yes...

by inkling

As to how you could possibly bring your anti-US rhetoric into this discussion...

You do realize that the author of the article George is referring to is...Canadian...right?

I mean, sweet friggn monkey nuts Neil, the IPCC?! You trust the UN to get something right, seriously?

Of course, with your anti-American views you probably view the UN as a very constructive, very efficient, very benevolent...blah, blah, blah...organization.

I know you will deny the anti-US sentiments Neil. I've called you on it in the past and, after accepting your protestations, backed down. I'm sorry, if you can somehow make THIS article about the horrors of the US, you can no longer deny that your prejudices against the United States are quite substantial.

Anyway, JD more or less made the point I was going to make. I just wanted give you a poke.

To be clear...I don't mind that you are anti-US (and from past discussions I dislike much of what you do about us). I would just like to see you justify bringing it into this particular discussion.

by Member 25348569

Well, rarely, but I don't have the monstrous anti-UN bias that I've seen on this site and in the US. You all HATE them, don't you? What I reckon is that if we don't attach some credence to what the IPCC say, there is no point in any of this discussion! All that George posted is a waste of time unless the IPCC is right. If CO2 doesn't do anything, wtf are we arguing about?

Do I trust the US to do what's right for the interests of other? Well, there you go, that's the 64,000 dollar question. There are two areas where I disapprove VERY much what the US does and which I comment on TR - Iraq (and the War on Terror) and Climate Change. As for the rest - well I'll see you in Florida in October (weeks 2 and 3 and hopefully the hurricanes will be absent). That's how anti-US I am.

The reason that my post comes over as anti-US (it is, in this case) is that the idea of planting forests whilst avoiding other action is a mainstay of US policy on climate change AND the US is and has been and will be a very large contributor of greenhouse emissions. Canada, per capita, does match you but they have a much lower capita and they've got more forests than you could shake a stick at already.

China looks set fair to become the real culprit but I don't see what I can do about China.

Neil :D

by tony hopkinson

Did you hear Chaney's reaction after Tokyo?

You 'uropeens' can be as green as you like we will keep making a profit.

At the moment to be vaguely green is to be anti-american.

by Member 25348569

So, what brings you back here?

Never mind, I don't really care. Back under your rock before your skin dries out and starts to crack.

:D

p.s. Any chance that you could try posting for quality and not quantity?

by tig2

He IS nice.

I think that the thing that keeps you two at each other's throats is that you don't get Neil's approach and take it as hostile. He may be sarcastic, even ironic, but rarely hostile. I've seen him go for the jugular when warranted but never as a steady diet.

I understand that his nuances may very well appear differently to you. But be aware, if he ever decided that you needed to leave, you would be VERY certain that the door was open.

What I hear Neil saying is that the so-called "Carbon Sink" plan doesn't stand up to hard scrutiny. What I hear you saying is that managed forests are better both functionally (the fire issue) and ecologically (replacing dead trees with living ones. I agree with both of those points.

In Washington State where Weyrhauser is a major employer, there are managed tree farms- planted to replace trees harvested for paper. If you drove the highway between Bremerton and Port Angeles, you will see several. They are marked with the planting date and the intended harvest date. The parts of the tree that can't be used by Weyrhauser go to a company that produces OSB- Oriented Strand Board- a legitimate building material.

Personally, I would like to see more of that- a company that regrows the supply it requires and passes the parts unusable to a company that not only can use them, but can use them in a product that has an audience.

Chill here. Neil is not out to attack you. If you give him reason, he will respond in any number of ways- witty, sarcastic, ironic, sardonic, and in all ways, classically Neil.

by locrian_lyric

If You say your car is worth 30,000 dollars and I say it is worth nothing, the truth is not 15,000.

It may well be worth 30,000 if it's a brand new higher-end car, it may well be worth nothing if it's been totalled.

The fact that a middle exists does not mean that it is a true value.

by locrian_lyric

some of the environmental policies, such as ludicrous attempts to keep areas "pristine" have led to the massive fires over the last few years.

If you want a REAL education, ask a few firefighters how they feel about the regulations regarding what equipment they can bring in to FIGHT the fires.

When the founder of an organization such as Greenpeace says "hold on, waitaminute", It's a good indication that some of the greenies have gone goonie.

Now, obviously, I am not for turning the world into one giant city either, but we can manage our use of resources in a way that can limit damage or even diminish it.

The simple fact is that had managed logging been allowed in those forests, we wouldn't have the rampant destruction of so many acres over the past decade.

by georgeou

Well, I just thought the co-founder of Greenpeace makes a great point and it's worth sharing. You made some good points in your other posts too.

by locrian_lyric

He is an environmentalist of the first order, in that he cares about the **results**.

There are some splinter green groups out there who call themselves "hard greens" and "Crunchy Cons".

They are purely results oriented and like the founder of greenpeace are not afraid to discuss the best way of achieving their ends and don't play the "us vs them" games that others do.

It is not being anti-environment to reject the **methods** proposed by the certain groups, though certain groups think so.

by tig2

Was to get people talking. That right there is a good thing.

Whether the co-founder of Greenpeace is the best citation or not is truly immaterial. There have been excellent points raised here.

The best outcome has been that people are actively and productively stating their opinions and asking questions. Great!

I'm originally from Southern California, home of the Santa Ana winds that are on their own, very destructive. Unfortunately, it seems like a yearly thing that parts of California simply burn down. That was always heartbreaking to see. It seemed like every year someone I knew was being evacuated. If managing that acreage is the right answer, I am for it 100%. Even if we only THINK it will help. The payback is in avoiding losing the lives that are lost both in the path of the fire and in fighting it.

by Member 25348569

Leaving aside the dispute about Moore's status as "co-founder" or "early member", he is not a member now and most of what he says is now hotly disputed by his erstwhile colleagues in that organisation.

He may well appear to have some superficially "good points" but not all stand up to real scrutiny once you step past the headline-grabbing lobbyist...

by locrian_lyric

And we are allowed to respond, that's what makes it a wonderful world.

It is not what you said to george, but the tone and the swipes involved. I've not known him to be rude to you, or anything less than courteous. You could reciprocate.

Fine, you have a background in biology. We could all probably learn a great deal from you, but when you make comments like "stick to microsoft" and such, you undermine the value of your own knowledge as it's not likely to be listened to.

I started out quite interested in what you had to say when I first started reading your posts, but now I am not inclined to give them too deep a read because you wrap so many insults around them.

It's like preparing a fine gormet meal, then serving it on used plates on a filthy table.

You're an intelligent man Neil, you don't need to berate people to make your points.

by Member 25348569

or, if he did I never read it, he to me. I never post on George's Microsoft threads as my knowledge is not sufficient and he, barring a few exceptions, has not really chosen to step outside of his field of expertise.

In this case, I believe he so stepped outside and I chose to disagree. More significantly, he started the thread and I considered - as I always do - that there was a greater onus upon him to be both accurate and authoritative.

In my opinion, he deserved what was a minor ticking off and I consider it no less than the truth until he demonstrates differently. The post body content contained no insults to George but did contain an anti-American paragraph which I believe that I explained (at least to my satisfaction) in response to Inkling's criticism.

Neil :)

Edited to stress "In my opinion"

by locrian_lyric

Anyone who disagrees with you seems to 'deserve' what ever level of abuse you level towards them.

You are quick to be offended, but seem to believe that others 'deserved' what you give to them. You don't know whether George took it as 'minor' or not. Your intent may well have been a minor tweaking but that may not have been the case.

Given your past crusades on how deeply you've been offended, a bit of empathy towards George might be prudent.

by oz_media

Greenpeace....whatever.

In Vancouver, about 30 years ago, Crown Forest Products offered to clear dead/dying trees from our world famous, Stanley Park. The idea was that it would decrease the risk of forest fire while allowing new growth to live uninhibited by the massive old trees throughout the park.

Last year we had a tremendous wind storm that leveled over 1000 of these majestic beauties and changed the Stanley Park landscape forever. Even today, driving around the park you see great open areas that were once heavily forrested.

IF Crown Forest had been allowed to clean up debris over the last 30 years, it is said that fewer tree would have suffered...but we can't tryst a forestry company to stick to original promises, Stanley Park could have massive clear cut patches already.

As for tree planting, since VERY FEW of replanted trees even get a start, yet alone make it to 3-year growth, they never seem to equal what was removed.

We see so much logging and replanting here it isn't funny, in fact tree planting is one of the top summer jobs for students qnd people collecting welfare or EI, (no claims just quiet cash) to take on.

But I have seen all stages of this regrowth and it doesn't even come remotely close to what was originally removed. Once clear cut, it will stay that way. They now have an easy outlet for trees, nobody is trying to protect regrowth, just old forests, so that nice new concept of replanting is just replenishing a clear cut to be clear cut again in fewer years.

I have seen instances where such 'Controlled forestry" would have saved a lot of land (Google BC Forest fires, Barriere).

Then again, the burn is natural replenishment of the land, not even remotely close to the damage of a clear cut.
You may see greenhouse gases, the world itself sees new life.

Let's not try to tamper with or control mother nature.

by naughtymonkey

you didn't have some dumb prick throwing a cigarette out the window while going down the interstate. Or some dumb pyromaniac with a cigarette lighter and gasoline. It is a lot easier to start a fire than it used to be. I would like to see any of the dumba$$es that start most of these fires do it with 2 sticks.

Sorry Loc, I had to say that.

by maecuff

It's that they persist in being so damn chirpy in the morning. Can't they just shut the f*ck up until I'm ready to wake up?

by w2ktechman

Hmmm, maybe we can have some footage from this. Please setup the web cam. I gotta see the little birdies getting 'missed' by the shovel, and flying around you... :^0

by maecuff

It does crack my husband up to hear me yell at the birds. He thinks it sounds nice. He's convinced that other people LIKE the sound of birds in the morning. I think he's loopy.

by Member 25348569

When all things seem new born
A bird perched on my window sill
To greet the nascent dawn
It sang to me so sweetly
As I lay there in my bed
I crossed over to the window
And crushed its f*cking head.

by tig2

Very harsh. Wouldn't a bit of masking tape over the beak worked as well?

by maecuff

That is the nicest poem that anyone ever wrote for me!

Now..I must go and move.

Why do men get so worked up over moving? If my husband doesn't get in a better mood, I'm crushing his f*cking head.

by georgeou

Dead trees spawn infestations that kill other trees and build the kind of fuel levels that can devastate most of Yellow Stone with some long-term damage. The number of dead trees in our forests are alarming.

by georgeou

1000 years ago, Man didn't spend 100+ years building up fuel. Now that we've built up the fuel that can basically nuke a forest, "let burn" is just crazy. We need to thin out the fuel to natural levels before we go to a "let burn" policy.

by georgeou

Yes and your postion is that we don't need more energy, we've gone over this many times before. Sorry, that's just not acceptable.

by cactus pete

But if we need more energy, isn't it still best to figure out how to provide it more efficiently from the sources we already have?

The best solution isn't to use up all the fuel that can't be replaced. The best solution is to use the scarce fuels sparingly and efficiently while developing other sources.

That path solves the most problems.

by locrian_lyric

We can't simply turn off the spigots, well we could, and many of our problems would go away because the resulting wars that would break out would make WWII look like a schoolyard spat in comparison.

We are nowhere NEAR running out of petrolium, just exceding the demand of easily accessable petrolium.

The best solution is the shotgun approach. Stop looking for magic bullets and just deploy the shotgun, and see what hits the target.

Ethanol from corn is fine on a small scale, but if we try to run the country on it, we'll not be able to grow enough food to feed ourselves any longer with the existing farmland devoted solely to produce energy from corn (WHICH by the way has a negative energy yeild when you factor in the necessity of petrochemical fertilizers, fuel to run the harvesting tractors and trucks. Space to store it for primary and secondary fermentation, the waste from the process, and the fuel required to distill the fermented corn to ethanol)

by tony hopkinson

And I certainly didn't know that.

That was truly pathetic George.

That's actually worse than
"Tony wants the third world to starve."

by Member 25348569

Or, at least, he doesn't care if Bangladesh does. Oh, and Florida, London, New York and most of the World's other coastal cities.

"global warming and the melting of glaciers is not necessarily a negative event because it creates more arable land".

by georgeou

You just proved my point. The population is growing (mostly due to immigration) in this country and we do need more energy. Our society needs energy to run and while we should do everything we can to conserve, we have to be realistic that we do need more energy.

Unlike Al Gore I'm not a hypocrite on energy. My electric bill averages $60/month while Al Gore spends $2500/month on electricity in his mansion. I talk about energy conservation as much as possible in my blogs and I walk the walk. People can make all the accusations they like about me but I know I live a very responsible life environmentally. But what I won?t do is sit on an ivory tower and say that people can?t have more energy to live their lives (though I?d like to slash Al Gore?s power consumption ten fold).

by w2ktechman

I think most of us can care less about the UN, and/or laugh about some of the things that they do. I dont think that us Americans actually HATE the UN.
Heck, I am sure that if there are many Americans that dont know where the USA is on a map, they probably dont know that a UN exists, or what it does. With this in mind, how can we all hate it???

by inkling

...you love us and are just disappointed in some of our poor choices? Parental feelings maybe?

As I said, I dislike much of what you do about my country. Probably a heck of a lot more...

My point was...this article (which George referred to) was written by a Canadian and has NOTHING to do with the U.S...

Ok, it has a little to do with the U.S. But if ANYTHING, it's that the Hollywood is going overboard with the "bein' green" bit...and this from a Canadian.

This man, a co-founder of Greenpeace, is simply trying to say that the vilification of using trees for energy, lumber, etc...is not entirely just. Especially the Hollywood version of it.

Again, I just don't see how you draw the the United States' environmental policies into a fairly specific topic.

by cactus pete

Dr. Moore referred to North America as much as he could, and went on to name the USA and Canada (with New Zealand and Sweden, as well).

by inkling

That still doesn't explain how the door was opened to the United States' policies.

Did I miss where an American of any importance (or one at all) supported Dr. Moore's ideas?

by cactus pete

"According to the United Nations, our forests have expanded nearly 100 million acres over the past decade."

I'd like to see the publication from the UN that proclaims this. I've seen the satellite images of "then and now" areas like Seattle and Atlanta, and can't imagine that we are at a net gain.

I also see the far suburban landscape changing from forests and farms into houses. In the past decade, wood to build the frames for these houses and the new furniture to put in them (and downtown condos) must have increased demand considerably. Incidentally, I believe we then noticed logging issues from Brazil as a result.

The bottom line is that the logging industry doesn't care about sustainable harvesting as much as it does about turning the quickest (cheapest) buck.

by georgeou

"The bottom line is that the logging industry doesn't care about sustainable harvesting as much as it does about turning the quickest (cheapest) buck."

The private logging industry is extremely responsible with the lands they own because trees are renewable. The private logging industry replants everything they take. You're seem so misinformed on this issue that you can't even take something Patrick Moore says seriously.

by jdclyde

They pay to take the trees.

They are suppose to bury the branches that they cut off, but generally they just leave them all over the place.

They take a nice section of woods, clear cut it, and leave the crap. A few years later jack pines or poplars will spring up in the clear cut area, (not the same quality of tree that they took out) but because of all the waste left behind, you can't walk through it for about 20 to 30 years.

I have seen it, several times. All within an hour ride from my house.

Go out and look for yourself at some logged areas and see if you believe the logging company cares. Look at a place JUST cut, and also look at a place that had been cut five years earlier.

by jamesrl

My reading of Neil's reply to the OP was that the title might have been a mild put down, the rest of the posting was an attempt at a fact based reasoned discourse.

I have known Neil through his posts at least for a few years, and I would hardly think of him as quick to be offended.

I don't by the way agree with Neil's stand. George saw something interesting and posted. He never claimed to be a scientist. I think the article itself is good - stimulates debate.

I've disagreed with Neil many times, without ever having dived into ad hominem attacks by either of us.

George is a big boy, and well able to defend himself and his position. I've seen him truly insulted by a racist jerk, and not lower himself. If George has an issue with Neil, he can email him.

James

by inkling

I question the ethics of a co-founder of Greenpeace all of a sudden speaking out against environmentalism the amount that he has.

Honestly, what's his argument here anyway? That Hollywood is too "dramatic" in it's renditions of environmental issues?

Well....no sh*t.

I don't mind George, or anyone else, starting a thread about AGW, politics, religion...with or without credentials.

I do think that using this particular article to support your (as in George) argument was a bad choice though.

EDIT: Clarity.

by locrian_lyric

And he's not speaking out against environmentalism, just the branch of it that has gone off the deep end.

by jamesrl

He has had a very public break away from his friends at Greenpeace. He has started a consulting company that makes a profit advising companies on how to get green and promote themselves as such.

He has made public and published statements attacking Greenpeaces' stand on nuclear power. He was once against it, but now sees that nuclear power will lower green house gas emissions.

He is, I think, being a practical environmentalist, versus the hardcore, no compromises Greenpeace types.

From where I sit, we need more of him and fewer Greenpeace. Because Greenpeace protesters tend to alienate those they attack. He is looking for practical doable answers.

James

by inkling

"All of a sudden" was a poor choice of words.

You have, however, brought about the point of why I don't necessarily trust the man. He's just trying to stay in the spotlight so that his company will make more money.

I actually agree with some of his views (I've read quite a lot of his criticism of the "Church of the Goreacle" nuts), but anyone that is profiting from it the way he is has an agenda all their own.

Just having an agenda itself isn't bad, as long as you know what that agenda is...but with such a radical shift in his attitude...my cynicism won't let me to believe he simply became wiser with age.

by locrian_lyric

And he knows that.

I'll say this again and again.

Disagreement with a proposed solution is in no way disregarding the problem.

by Member 25348569

But anyway, I find corn kernels dipped in quick-setting acrylic resin to be quite satisfactory.

Chirpy chirpy cheep chp p ...

by Member 25348569

referenced quite widely in US government strategy on reduction of emissions. Though, to be honest, there's precious little US overall government strategy on emissions reductions, most of what there is centring around reduction of "unfriendly" sources for your energy imports.

To be honest, I didn't pick up on the fact that Moore is a Canadian and even didn't notice the "Vancouver" Sun until I went back and looked after posting. I just assumed too much from the way Moore was going after di Caprio that it was all a US spat. We're further away over here and the distinctions get blurred.

Anyway, shoot first, ask questions afterwards has always been my way...

by tig2

You aren't supposed to engage in the willful destruction of innocent little birdies... or feathered sh*t houses if you prefer.

The place I work has beautifully managed grounds with trees and a small park in the middle of a created lake- the property extends about a mile and a half and is simply beautiful. I have learned that putting out seed for the birds can guarantee that the next time I come out of a meeting ready to choke the crap out of someone, I can just go outside and watch the chickadees and nuthatches make fools of themselves over the seeds. Very soothing.

The downside is that there is a large section that is all glass in about the middle of the building. Today a little bird was sitting on the patio trying to recover it's wits after flying into the glass. He perked up after awhile and flew away but he was certainly dizzy for a bit!

by tig2

I read your post as you intended it... I think.

What I heard is that one man's opinion without sufficient scientific evidence should not be considered to be a final solution.

I also heard you say that while you respect George's knowledge of Microsoft, you don't believe that it translates to something completely out of his field and that his greater effort should be in the world that he is so qualified in.

I get your point and agree. If I have a question on Linux, I ask Apotheon or Jack. If I have a Unix question, I go to Apotheon first. If I am baffled with a script, I would come to you. If I am baffled by cancer, I come to you. If I have a Microsoft question, I would ask George or W2KT.

We all have our unique strengths and weaknesses. It is up to each of us to recognise and value them.

by Member 25348569

Thank you, you put it very well. Must be the socks...

It is also my personal feeling that a thread-starter has a particular duty to start it right and keep it going and I will usually - and did this time - reply differently and more critically to the first, key post.

Neil :D

That's it! I'm done explaining my conduct! En garde, mon braves! (Cracks knuckles, reaches for the quill pen...)

by georgeou

Even father Gaia theory endorses nuclear power because he knows it's the only abundant and clean energy source. But Tony there doesn't believe we need abundant energy and that we should be ashamed of wanting energy.

by locrian_lyric

are all fine and good approached in a SANE manner.

The ONLY major nuclear disaster to ever take life was Chernoble, and from what I've heard, there was more going on than just power at that site.

We need oil, coal, wood, fuel cells, solar cells, wind, hydro, geothermal, nuclear, and even kinetic power sources as a scatter-shot approach, just to name a FEW.

The idea that there is a single silver bullet that can solve all of our problems is ludicrous.

Excluding anything at this time is dangerous, and any solution will breed new problems.

by Member 25348569

I was lucky enough to take in the Sequoia National Park in my travels last year. Those forests were carefully managed and any and all fires stamped out immediately and the forest began to die. Those forests [b]need[/b] to burn or the seeds will not germinate to provide the trees for the next generations.

So, what Moore would have us do is raze the Seqoias (the wood is fit only for pencils) and replace them with...what?

It ain't always so simple

:D

by georgeou

The eco extremists won't let you remove the dead and dying trees which breeds even more infestation and more dead trees. It's a vicious circle that ends in scorched earth that far exceeds what nature intended for natural fires. We got this way with 100 years of interference from man to stop all fires and the only way to get out is active forest management to bring us back to equilibrium. We do that by taking out the dead trees and clearing out the fuel on the ground with controlled burns during off-fire season.

by georgeou

Greenpeace of old is the one that did all the good during the 70s. The Greenpeace of new are the extremists and the lawyers. The Sierra Clubs of new are the ones that sue to stop the Army Corps of Engineers from shoring up the levees in New Orleans which caused Katrina.
http://www.americanthinker.com/2005/09/the_new_york_times_contradicts.html

Patrick Moore is one of the good environmentalists out there and your cheap attacks at him tell me that you already had your mind made up.

by Member 25348569

are not the same as environmentalists in Europe. [b]Everything[/b] in the US - and environmentalism is no exception - is more politicised and hugely more hooked into your legal system. That's something that affects your culture in so many ways and is something that you will have to work out for yourselves.

I'm seeing and commentating from a different perspective and that doesn't make me wrong when I compare what Patrick Moore is saying and what [b]our[/b] climate scientists and environmentalists are saying and what they are saying about Patrick Moore. They - and I - agree with some of what he says and disagree with other statements.

Widen your horizons, George. He's far too simplistic about "planting trees to save the planet". It's a lot more complicated and all I'm saying is that if he chooses to portray himself as "co-founder of Greenpeace" and you choose to label him as "one of the good environmentalists", it really isn't too much for me to ask for him to give the full picture and [b]get it right[/b].

In this case, he hasn't.

You tell me that my mind is already made up. I could equally accuse you of the same.

by tony hopkinson

could be reduced to we don't need more energy...

If you wear blinkers and squint a lot.

You want to go for round two George be my guest, try to come up with some cogent responses this time though eh.

The strawmen got boring and this sort of misrepresention is making me yawn as well.

Why do we need more energy George ?

by tony hopkinson

for GM
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=206234&messageID=2141080

My apologies , (that's what you do when you are wrong by the way!)

I can't imagine saying nuclear (fission) was clean, not ever.

Seeing as not being clean is my problem with it.

In personal opinion we should be looking at the cost of a continual growth in energy demand.
We should be be looking at why we want it, continually attempting to meet the demand, while basing our economies on increasing this demand is stupid isn't it?

No matter what solution we come up, no matter how green it might be, it will never be met. Which is in fact the whole point demand = money.

You aren't looking from the point of sustainable supply, but sustainable demand.

by tony hopkinson

If they want it, it will be supplied, that's the ecomomy isn't it?

All a green should be saying is we should look at the real costs of contining to base our economies on increasing the demand so we can make a profit meeting it.

It's an infinite model in a finite world.
In those terms renewable energy isn't a solution either.

by Member 25348569

A couple of feet will do for Bangladesh and for London unless we do something starting now. However you miss the point again and take the simple way out by invoking Al Gore. And your buddy, Lyric, accuses ME of ad hominem...

For this one time only, I'll tell you: Al Gore means NOTHING to me. He's one of [b]your[/b] citizens who scarcely comes into my Climate Radar and then I see him as a simple nutjob balance to Dick Cheney, whose eloquence was so nicely demonstrated by TonyH! Gore is a DISASTER for any sensible environmentalists. But so is Cheney.

It's not only the sea-level rise that does it, it's the storm surges on top of the sea level rise. And if there are stronger storms as a result of warmer seas - see, now?

Hurricanes need a minimum temperature of 26C to form and grow. If the area of water with that Summer and Fall temperature increases northwards, hurricanes could continue along the Gulf Stream more so than at present. Given that hurricanes might last longer at high wind-speeds with the increased energy from the warmer oceans, how well would New York survive the storm surge from a category four hurricane (that's up to eight metres, well over that twenty foot range) on top of a couple of feet mean sea-level rise at high tide? Luckily, current climate conditions impose an area of high wind shear between the hurricane-forming area and New York and that tends to kill hurricanes but if we continue to f*ck up the climate, that might change.

Let's just try and keep stuff from changing too fast! Is that too much to ask?

by Member 25348569

And you will, of course, tell me what your government is doing to coerce - no, you don't do that, do you - or guide or even sufficiently inform its citizens so that they might do just that.

As for Al Gore, I refer you to the post that I made some moments ago.

:)