Discussion Locked

Will replacing Win98 with Win2K help?

0 helpful
50 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hello everybody
I really need urgent help on this one. My client has 5 PC networked through a SoHo Basic 10 BaseT hub, with Cat5 cable (about 5m each length). They are using Win98 on all machines, including the 'server' (a PIII 700MHz 128Mb RAM 10 Gig HDD with more than 7 Gig free). They are mainly using Pastel Ver 6 and Excel 2000.

The problem is that when more than one client tries to access the shared Pastel or Excel files on the server the process slows down terribly. When all four areconnected, it becomes real hell.

I had suggested that we replace the Win98 on the 'server' with Win NT 4 or Win2K Server (especially Win2K, since it recognises Fat32). Will this help? I would like to hear your advice before I proceed. Please help.

Simbarashe

50 replies

by apache5056

Back up the server 110% and give it a shot. I am no expert by any means (and will never claim to be) but I'd recommend 2000Advanced Server. And with 2K/A.S., your license should cover 5 users. I'd also use client license instead of the server license (unless the company is planning an upgrade in the future).

No pain, no gain. Having the backup can always put it back to the way it was. Sounds as if a late night is on the horizon...;0)

Why would they have 98 running on a sever anyhow? The security has got to be next to nothing.

by lordinfidel

He does not need advanced server in this scenario.

Advanced server's main purpose in life is in the use of clustering. It is the same platform as 2k Server. (Side note, all versions of 2k, including pro, are built on the same set of instrucions, that is they are the same os, just with more features enabled. This is similar to the linux concept where it is just one OS but with different features enabled)

In this scenario he just would want 2k server.

Now for more clarification, Fine they are using a PIII 700 system. But is it a server class system?
Speed alone does not make a server. Or is it some system that they bought at compusa that has a crappy subsystem.

In this instance I would definetly get rid of 98. It has no business acting as a file server.

I would also upgrade to 2k. It does not have to be server, it can be 2k pro. (see my next post though on upgrades and the faux use of the word)

Next I would beef up the memory. 128 megs is nothing for a file server. Remember how OS's work. they work in memory, not off of the hdd.
A min of 512 megs would suffice for a file server.
(This is dependant on the size of the netwk)

2K pro by default allows a max of 10 connections to it. If you do not forsee yourself going over 10 connections 2k pro is fine.

However, you will not be able to use domain security, you will be limited to workgroup security. (see my next post on security)

by admin

While I agree that for his purposes he should probably bite it and go 2k server, and that I agree that RAM makes the most difference (obviously all 512 mb sticks are not at all created equal either- use server class memory!) and that he will probably need new hardware, still, his original question was asking if 2k would make his network faster if put on his 98 box.

Wouldn't the answer to this be "No"? 98 may have all the security problems etc. but as far as sheer speed of the OS and a willingness to run on any (including crappy) equipment, it seems like it would outperform 2kserver here. I wonder if he has done any troubleshooting on his network personally to see if it's the OS anyway, because all things being equal including the box that probably came with 98 installed I would guess that he would go slower by just installing 2k. If it would even run or install at all. :>

by lordinfidel

The use of the word upgrade always throw's people.

Most people think that you can just put in the cd and upgrade the system while retaining your old settings. While this is true, that there are upgrade paths from certain OS's. It is not the best path to take.

When ever you attempt to upgrade, things might not go as planned. All because an OS worked on one system, the new OS might not.

Also you need to understand what is going on behind the scenes. It is upgrading or attempting to upgrade, millions of lines of code. A mistake can and will happen. You may not be able to see it, but it can cause weird unexplainable problems.

The best course of action when upgrading, is to back up your files to cd/alternate disk. Make sure you have all of your programs. If your systems hardware is older then 2 years, flash the bios with the latest version.

Then blow away the old OS, including all partitions, reformat (with 2k always use NTFS, no matter what, i'm not a big fan of dual-booting, live in one world and deal with it or get another machine). Using NTFS allows you to have file level security, an unlimited amount of files (NTFS is not limited by the size of a FAT).

Misconception with newbies, 98/95 clients can access files on a 2K/NT4 server/System that uses NTFS. The OS hosting the files, hands the files back to the client in a format that it can understand.

Personal tip, for prodcution type servers, I always prefer to format the root drive (c) as a 4 gig partition. This stems back from my NT4 days, but I ported it over with security in mind. Limiting the root drive to 4 gigs makes me pay more attention to increased files sizes which means somethings wrong. Some of my counterparts have debated thiswith me, and while I do see their point in not limiting the root drive to 4 gigs, the flip side is that you should not be installing 4 gigs worth of programs on a server anyways.

by lordinfidel

While one would think that if you upgrade to 2K you are automatically more secure. Well yes and no... It depends.

Flaky, yes I know, but here is why.

It will depend on how it is installed. If you install it on top of a FAT32 partition, you will not get any security that is built in.

In fact, AD will only install if NTFS is the file system. It will not install on FAT32 partitions.

Domain or not to domain. What is a domain?

A domain is essentially a group of computers that has a leader. That leader is responsible for the security (user name and passwords) of the rest of the systems. By using a domain model, 1 user name and password will grant you access to any domain members systems.

Now, this is different from a workgroup model. A wrkgrp does not have a central authority figure. Each system is responsible for it's own security.

So if you have a user called mytoe on system 1 and a user on system 2 called mytoe with a different password assinged to it. Mytoefrom system 1 can not access files on system 2.

Workgroups require that you set up users on every system. That is if you have 5 users and 5 systems and each system shares files to the other 4. Every system has to have a u/p for each person. Ifone person changes their password, it would need to be changed on every system.

by lordinfidel

Next liscensing.....

One Newbie was correct, use CAL's not server liscense. However, he failed to mention what that means. A cal (Client Access Liscens) allows users to gain access to a server. If you have 10 Machines on the network but only 5users, you only need 5 Cals. Now there are 2 versions of server when you buy it, one that comes with 5 cals, the other does not. If it does not come with cals you will need to buy them thru your vendor.

2Kpro does not take cals. It is not a server. But it will allow for 10 connections. But you can not make a domain using 2k Pro.

Installing 2K server makes not a domain.
You would need to install AD after the installation of server. This is different then NT4 where you specify it's domsin membership during the installation.

I hope this helps clear things up for you.

Before attemting any of this, especially if you have no idea of what you are doing. Get a test system and try it out first.

While one newbie is not an expert, I am. Plan and test everything before you deploy it. If you have to install AD 300 times before you get it right then do it.

If you definitely plan on going to 2K but are still unsure how to do it, it may serve to bring in outside help.

by rrgilmore_2001

for starters you can not go back to per server licence agreement, once you are per seat.
2.if you go by server you only need to pay for one server. by client you need to pay per seat and this is only feesable if you have mutiple servers.
3. advanced server would be a waist of money. you have no need or call for advanced server. you are not running more than 2 processiors are you? no win 98 support up 2 2 processiors.
4 last and not least running windows 98 for a server you have to pay no licence fees.

R Gilmore A+, MCP for windows 2000 professional, MCP for windows 2000 server. MICROSOFT 2408514

by lordinfidel

Since you took the time to post, I will take the time to reply. (wish you would of read the rest of the thread first though)

1. You are correct, when you choose a license scheme, if you go to seat you can't reverse it and go to cal's.

2. Seats are more expensive then cal's. I always reccomend cal's because that allows for adding additional servers to the netwk. Also most OEM server packs come with 5 cals.

3. Yes, advanced server is not needed but not for the reasons you specified.Nt4 wkstn/srvr/ent servr, 2k pro, srvr, adv srvr and datacenter can all run on 2 processors. I have never tried 98 on a dual procc, maybe someone else can shed some light on that one.

As I stated in my other post, adv srvr is used for clusteringpurposes. Not just processors. pro can support 2 proc, Srvr can take up to 4 processors, Adv server can do up to 8. Data center, well let's just say that most of us won't see it on a daily basis, and if you do, can I come work for you.

4. Win98 is not suited as a server product of any sort.

Certs- It's poor taste to list your certs and ID in a thread. But since you brought it up, I trump your MCP and A+ with the MCP+I MCSE (NT4 and 2K) RHCE CCNA (but who's counting)

by wraithy

Since you only have 5 PCs and you dont need all the advanced services that W2K has, I advise you upgrade to the Windows 2000 Standard Server. By installing it with all the defaults and creating a domain with the wizard, you will be good to go. Dont let AD scare you. It can be a bear in large enterprises, but, for you, it should be a breeze as you arent using it for anything but user authentication. Treat the W2K server as you would a Windows NT4 server and youw will be just fine. Most of the info that LordInfidel gave is correct, it does not have to be that hard.

Always back up your data prior to any installs and DO format the drives using NTFS and install the server clean. If you have no experience with the server architcture and admin, read up on it or ask for professional help.

by sklaszky

Most of the advice given here is excellent for enterprises. But if your client is a small business on limited budget with little computing expertise and fewer than 10 workstations, why not install a Snap Server or similar Network Attached Storage (NAS) device? You can get 160GB with RAID for about $1500, or smaller ones for less. These are designed to do only one thing really well -- serve files. They work strictly as file storage devices (no console), but most NAS servers do have login authentication services without all the headaches and expense of admistrating a more complex Network OS. Then set your Win98 workstations up to use Peer-to-Peer with NetBEUI for File & Print Sharing and TCP/IP for those PC's with internet connections or some other compelling reason to use TCP/IP. This setup works really well and is VERY easy to administer on small networks.

by bootstrap

Talk about bad advice - you are getting plenty.

1) you do NOT need win2K - it is nice, but with 5 hosts on the network, it is hardly worth the money. Go get a USED NT4 SErver with 5 CALS and save about $1500.

2) You do NOT need security - orif you do, you certainly didn't say anything about it. You might review your security issues - if any.

3) Win98 is slower than dirt as an OS and does NOT have an fault tolerance. Something you are in dire need - fault tolerance.

4) Access speed. Looking at the wrong animal(s). Your bottlenecks are in THIS order:

a: 10Bt ethernet. PLEASE replace NIC's with fast ethernet immediatly for a fraction of the cost of anything else - along with the hub/switch. Them, make sure you are getting fast Ethernet speed.

b: Disk Subsystem. PLEASE get a SCSI hardware RAID in place. With the modest storage requirements, I would suggest a 2-disk mirror arrangement for both cost, simplicity, and speed. It will run in ANY operating system.

Finally, after addressing your real bottlenecks, look at spending money on the Operating system - but any MS server OS will not address the speed/security issues you have.

I guess I also want to say .... before you go off on the wrong tangent again, DEFINE the PROBLEM - the first order of any troubleshooting/fix.

by lordinfidel

First, I made clear mention of server system hardware.

Plus, the old adage of the fewer number of users don't do a domain is BS. Everyone needs security. From the single user on the net to the corp enterprise. Lack of security just makes my job easier breaking into your system.

Also, a five user network is not going to be passing 10 megabits of data across the network.

Going with a 100mb switch in this scenario is overkill.
While nice and cool (I personally use nothing but switches) is still overkill for a five user netwk unless there is some need for it.

Yes, there is a need for fault tolerance... Hence which is why I said make sure they format with NTFS..... Data storage is a whole other concept.

Of course there is a possibilty that there their netwk cards are hosed, but if *everyone* is experiencing the same sluggishness, then it is probably not it.

Fine, I will give you with going with NT4 srvr over 2K. But on the other hand, NT4 will not be supported for one, 2) you can not buy cal's for it, 3)Licenses in the eys of M$ are non-transferrable which means they will have to find a shrinkwrapped NT4 box with the 5 cals sticker.

Buying a server that does not come with the license pack is technically not-legal.
(BTW 2k srvr with 5 cals is 850 [695 for OS, 28 per cal thru open license, check with your vendor], not sure where you got 1500 from)

While there has been lot's of advice on this thread, most of it has been correct, inlcuding some of yours. So don't go blasting unless something is blatanly wrong.

And if it is wrong, respond direclty to the poster instead of making a general comment.

by bootstrap

and I have not trouble finding plenty of NT4 used for $100 or so ... and with 5 CALS with it ............ all nice and legal, thank you.

So, I'll give you that wrong was the wrong adjective.

As for supported ....... I suspect you'll find plenty of folks who can run NT4 - especially if you install it as a MEMBER SERVER.

Notice I am staying away from the security issue - who knows what evil lurks .......

by ghstinshll

Ok, that guy was way off, and shouldn't be consulting in anyone's office. We're talking best scenario. 2K is it.

The snap server is a good idea, but not what I'm used to. They're not replacing hardware, so don't think about SCSI, or new server. At most, think about an IDE RAID card, and 2 drives set up in a mirror, plus a tape drive to back it up. At most.

My company hasn't given me the $ to replace my 10MB LAN and switch for my 80+ users... No need for NICs.

As for NT? Only if you know it, should you purchase CALs from ebay (for cheap) and use them on your LAN. Do it right with 2k so you can call MS and get help if needed.

Take the advice of Infidel, he knows what he's doing. We all know who to trust when proof-reading everyone else's posts for your protection.

by draco vulgaris

I was waiting for someone mention the disks! Disks that are of the same vintage as W98 are hardly state-of-the-art. Without RAID and even, sometimes, with RAID a disk can handle only one I/O request at a time. A top-of-the-line hardware RAID controller may allow N simultaneous reads from an N member mirror set!

I'd say that RAID is a must for performance and reliability/availability. Mirroring is the most expensive but may provide the best performance as long as the controller supports multiple read requests and the accesses are mostly read. RAID 5 may a better bet with a mix of read/write requests.

Network advice is right on but a switch may be a better choice than a hub.

And truer words were never spoken than "define the problem". You can waste endless time and money trying to solve the wrong problem.

If you use NT4, be sure to install the latest service pack; there have been at least six and there were sound reasons for all of them! Ditto for W2K but that's only up to SP3 which I have not yet installed due to reported problems with it.

by lordinfidel

There are probably a million problems going on with this netwk as with all netwks that are set up in this manner.

First and foremost though, they need to get into some sort of organized structure.

Once they can get that part up and running then they can get to the other upgrades.

One of my original points was the type of hardware being used. While I did not elaborate, I thought I was clear that if it was not a server class system and It was just some crappy office depot special, then they won't get the performance that they are looking for.

A workstation class system will fair much better for small netwks price wise then a full blown server class system. It all depends on what the server is going to be doing.

For a small netwk (5 users), the throughput for an IDE drive will be able to handle the small amount of requests going to it. The OS will be the bottleneck at that point. If the OS can'd handle the threads/requests and manange them, then the rest is moot.

I'm all for redundancy (you should see my exchange servers, they are built to the max reccomendations including dual controllers, but that is a whole other subject).

Sometimes you need to take what you have and make it work.

Everyone can tout off, buy a raid card; but if they have a crappy pci bus then it's not going to do them much good. Then you have to look at the PowerSupply. Is it a 250w? You will need at least a 350 to power all of those scsi drives.

Like I say all of the time, when you design these things out, you have to think it all the way thru.

But as I said before, sometimes you just have to work with what you got.

by c.barnhorst

I agree that upgrading to 10/100 NIC's as a first step is good. You can do so cheaply and why wouldn't you want to anyway? After you upgrade to whatever Win2k you pick, what are the client side issues? I am interested in whether or not Win98 needs to be optimized differently if the server changes. I suspect so, but would like to hear a comment or two.

by lordinfidel

Ya know... Funny you mention it.

I was debugging a issue with a program being really slow on a system.

I was told by the vendor (and what I also thought) that it was the interaction with another programs use of the btrieve engine that was causing the issue.

After a reinstall of the updated versions of the programs, a packet sniffer anylasis and a reinstall of the OS. It was still slow.

It turned out that the netwk card was going bad. As soon as I replaced it, all was well again. And it did not show up in any of the diag tests. No dropped packets, nothing. It was just having issues passing traffic up.

In any case, I did make mention about the hardware they were running on. 2K does though manage memory better then 98. But like I said before, if they are running this on some crappy hardware, then they will not see performance.

by apache5056

Didn't think about the hardware end to much. Must have been using my head for the hat thing...

I look to over-build things and my suggestion of Advanced Server maybe over-kill but I am the type that looks to the future needs and not the present needs...

signed,
should have read between the lines and thought about it first ..... :0)

by lordinfidel

Advanced server would not address their future needs.

Like I was saying in one of my posts. Adv Srvr was designed for a different purpose then server.

They(M$) basically mirrored the NT4 model with it's servers. So wkstn=pro srvr=srvr and enterpise server=adv srvr.

Ent Srvr/Adv Srvr are primarily used for clustering technology. Regular srvr won't do clustering. So you have to spend the additional cash and get Adv Srvr. When your designing a netwk you will know whether or not you need adv server. If you can not think of any reason to get adv srvr then just get srvr.

It's just knowing the difference between the OS's.

My server ration is 20 regular servers for every advanced server that I have deployed. And the AdvancedServers that are deployed are for sql clusters. You would not want to spend the amount of cash for adv srvr just to have it be a file srvr.

by djent

If you intend no more the ten concurrent logins NT4 or W2K workstation will work just fine. If you have crappy bargain hardware it wont work faster but will be more stable. Some of your problems may be the result of file locking on single user applications.

by lordinfidel

Part of the problem with NT4 licenses is that you can't get them anymore, at least not thru open license.

You would literally have to find a sealed OEM box with the cals.

Licenses are not technically transferrable. Except for in the case if you buy a OEM machine such as a dell and it has the license sticker on that machine, then that license stays with that machine.

But let's say they went with NT4 and then they needed more cals. Well they can't get them thru open license and the only way to buy legal license packs is thru a approved MS reseller. And they no longer can sell NT4 cals.

The only real loophole to the transfer of cals is if you buy a company that already has licenses in open license. Because they are assets of the company you just bought.

But that same company can not sell off their cals to another person.

Also, on a point of clarity, you can't install NT4 as a member server unless a domain exists. It will need to be either a standalone server or a PDC.

As far as secuity, it's not something I stay away since my job is enforcing security and conducting penetration tests. So I am a stickler about it and bring it up whenever I am given the chance.

Designing networks is more then just installing an OS. It takes a lot of planning and know how. The systems that are always being taken over are created by people who don't know what they are doing.

Case in point, If anyone had followed best practices for installing IIS, Nimda would not have propagated the way it did. But there are thousands of "admins" out there installing products that they have no idea how to secure.

Security is everyones responsibilty who decides to put a machine on the net.

by apache5056

Keep it simple stupid.... When I read Infidel's post after mine, I thought what a j**k. But, reading and re-reading the additional posts by him, I too would take his advice. I would even consider asking him for permission for additional contact information if he would allow.

The dude is on the up-and-up in my book..

by lordinfidel

I know that sometimes I come across as an *sshole. I'm not always correct though and do not mind being corrected when it is warranted.

No one is perfect. I just try to share my knowledge and experience.

I do it not for recognition or anything like that. I have found over the years that by helping others figure out their problems it gives you more avenues to figure out problems that you might face. Sometimes a problem that I am working on here that I am stalled on might get a push fromsome tid bit of information I pick up on newsgroups and forums.

In any event, thanks for the consideration.... I can be contacted thru the contact info in the republic. I beleive if you click on my name it will bring you to my profile, there should be a contact link right next to my name. It is in the top portion and is small from what I remember.

I usually like to keep info here so that others can read it and take advantage of it.

Sometimes it's hard for me to have off-line discussions because of the requirements of my job. I still have e-mail from a month ago that I need to reply to.

by ghstinshll

Techrepublic's forums are as much of a learning tool for daily life as the articles themselves are. It's great.

It's like they say, teachers learn as they teach... and it keeps going on in here too.

by maxwell edison

Here’s my take:

Yes, upgrade to Windows 2000. It would indeed improve your performance.

Windows 2000 Professional for your clients.

Windows 2000 Server for your file server.

I concur with LordInfidel. He gave some great advice. And, from what I’ve seen from his previous posts, he knows his stuff. There’s no need for me to say the same thing.

I would, however, add one thing:

The Server hardware is fine, but I would bump up the RAM (in the server). The price of RAM is VERY cheap and would be worth the upgrade. I would get ECC (either "error correction [or correcting] code" or "error checking and correcting") RAM for the server. I’ve found that crucial.com has a great product at a great price. I’d guess that you could get 1.0 – 1.5 GB (giga-bytes) for around $300.

Good luck.

by lordinfidel

I usually get my ram from MicroWarehouse (www.warehouse.com) or MemoryMan (www.memman.com).

Right now I'm getting 256 of pc133 ecc for about $25 thru Mwhse. (But I go thru my rep so I get the good discounts, my rep is great if anyone needs an account mgr there)

So if you are looking to upgrade your memory, now is the time to do it before prices go back up again.

by admin

www.mwave.com

I was almost going to reply again but didn't have time way above.... RAM is another issue in itself. A stick of 266mHz pc2100 will run circles around the 133 pc133 as far as I can tell by running it, so the 512mb in my w2k servers is a little decieving. It's not just the amount anymore. We went with dual processors too. It's another relatively cheap performance shot as long as you're doing it.

by rrgilmore_2001

you want to know the truth, here it is your users need to pull the data to there workstation and not work on the server.
1 upgrade your windows 98 server to windows 2000 server stay with the per server licence.
2 install 2-3 more hard drives and configure them as a raid drive. this will provide faster access to stored data and provide fault talerance. I would install 3 more and use the 10 gig as a systems partition or volume.
3. GET RID OF THE HUB 10 base t is old they are probley complaining of internet speeds. a linsys router and netgear 10-100 will help
4. you will have to increase you RAM find out the max the board supports. more than liklie it will be 2 slots one gig of RAM. put 1 gig into the box.
This is cheap 90.00 at tiger direct .com but 2 512 chips.

here is your bottom line you need more ram 90.00 software 600.00 this is a high price. this minimum. I would recumend that you spen another 200 for the linsys router and netgear hub. think about 3 hd the same size as raid 240.00

you will need to write a scipt for mutiple users on a single user application. You can find this info on line at microsoft.com or in one of the cycbex book 70-210 or 70-215
Good luck to you.
Rgilmore A+,MCP pro and server

by rrgilmore_2001

you want to know the truth, here it is your users need to pull the data to there workstation and not work on the server.
1 upgrade your windows 98 server to windows 2000 server stay with the per server licence.
2 install 2-3 more hard drives and configure them as a raid drive. this will provide faster access to stored data and provide fault talerance. I would install 3 more and use the 10 gig as a systems partition or volume.
3. GET RID OF THE HUB 10 base t is old they are probley complaining of internet speeds. a linsys router and netgear 10-100 will help
4. you will have to increase you RAM find out the max the board supports. more than liklie it will be 2 slots one gig of RAM. put 1 gig into the box.
This is cheap 90.00 at tiger direct .com but 2 512 chips.

here is your bottom line you need more ram 90.00 software 600.00 this is a high price. this minimum. I would recumend that you spen another 200 for the linsys router and netgear hub. think about 3 hd the same size as raid 240.00

you will need to write a scipt for mutiple users on a single user application. You can find this info on line at microsoft.com or in one of the cycbex book 70-210 or 70-215
Good luck to you.
Rgilmore A+,MCP pro and server

by ajmmon

Hi I think you should try first to change the hub to an small soho switch 10/100, then change the network cards to 10/100 and switch them to 100 mbits/sec full duplex, if i does not get better, then change to win2k pro in any machine adding firts another 128 mb ram to each of them.

With this I think you will have about 50 to 100% better performance

by mrafrohead

I hope i'm not getting ahead of myself here, as I haven't read everything written yet... I'm making it through the list, but...

I would think that win2k/pro/srvr/asrvr would run slower on the pc than win98 - but wouldn't it handle the networkingaspects better??? So if they were using it as a server and pulling files from the machine, I would think that they would get much better performance using the 2k line versus the 9x os...

Granted actual apps on the server may run at a slower rate, the clients would get better transfers, etc from the server???

I'm curious here and I'm seeing a great spot to learn.

I use machines 9x and 2k that are networked and I personally think the 2k boxes handle network type stuff MUCH better than win9x does... But then again, this is my opinion here:)

by admin

I'm pretty sure it's not shared by everyone else, but hopefully you'll get a bunch of opinions while forming your own :)

Win98se is faster as an OS in my experience especially in a default install and this shows up more on older hardware. (u gotta tweak 2k to go fast- especially with games in my experience). I have also used 98 as a yes,server at work. We do social work and sometimes we just don't have a lot of money and only old donated equipment to use. We ran our HR database on itfor some time (PeopleTrack) and we ran a lot of 5-6 ws workgroups. We also used both NT and 98se and as far as speed on hp 233's, win98se did the best for us. They did occasionally Blue screen or otherwise fail more than the NT boxes and were religiously rebooted nightly (required!). 2k came along and it's memory management superiority is obvious and upgraded my opinion to "it depends" as far as which is fastest. As you said it depends on the applications.

Having said all that, I would still run 2k and recommend it over NT (NT has no life cycle any longer, why buy something that's gone in year or less... Plus, sometime I'm gonna post a few select lines that are repeated many times each day in my server logs from all you guys running un-patched NT! {not directed at anyone specifically, sorry!}) and I would especially recommend it over 98se, but that was not the question.... the question was "will it run faster just upgrading the OS" and I personally don't think he'll gain much speed especially in the small network he's running. So, basically I wasn't recommending anyone run 98se in a network unless they absolutely have to. I was recommending that this was probably not his speed problem and that he should look elsewhere.

Personally, I still game on 98se. At work I stick with NT (getting less of this :), 2k and Linux. So, again, this basically just backs up what you said above.

by tbragsda

As I described in my "Another Friday rant" https://www.techrepublic.com/forumdiscuss/thread_detail.jhtml?thread_id=107125 it looks like this question has taken up a number of peoples time and effort. Problem is, I think it may be for nothing, as thequestioner has not posted anything back.

If he is out there "listening" then he should post back, let everyone know what he is doing, or just a bit of thanks. Good advise has been given. If he cant give a little thanks, then... well....

by mrafrohead

So, I read everything and have a couple of questions...

I know, they are off topic, but this thread is getting high traffic and it's partially about what the question is...

You talk about server class products... What exactly do you mean?

If I were to go and build myself a server, personally, I WOULD NOT go with any prefab crap that Compaq or dell would try to sell you. I would build it from scratch. As I believe that you know what you are getting as you are the one that is buildingit.

Are you talking about making sure you have high quality hardware and not just the cheap stuff. And it has the extra features like self diagnostics and all that jazz???

I figure if you aren't building a HUGE setup it's alright to stay awayfrom 64bit hardware at this time, since it's not exactly cost effective.

Also, for a small network with five users, wouldn't it be safe to upgrade to a Linksys 10-100 Switch for about a hundred and fifty bucks and not use a Cisco or other???

At home i run two different servers. They run off of computers that i have built. They are definately NOT something I would employ in a business environment as they are missing a few features that I think a business would need, but I have them running on a linksys router/switch setup and I have no problems whatsoever and they get EXTREMELY high traffic.

As a matter of fact, my setup runs better and more smoothly than the setup here at work with all of the expensive crap.

So - basically, I'm trying to turn my ignorance here into knowledge. If anyone has the time, please give me your input. I would appreciate it!!!

Mrafrohead

by admin

I get:

1. a view of what my peers would do in this situation, which to me is valuable.

2. a sense of community. I know we talked about this before, but this discussion specifically seems kind of like the computer equivalent of hunters around acampfire and I like that :)

3. entertainment. there are some pretty entertaining characters in this thread :> and I enjoy reading it.

so to me it's not a complete waste of time, although some of these are. Sometimes if I'm down at the computershop we talk an extra five minutes about all the different ways and approaces we would take to solving a problem that one of us has usually solved already but it's fun to hear about how incredibly difficult it was to troubleshoot, or how silly the problem was or how some key piece was overlooked -but we've all done that. It's kinda the stories that hunters tell. One guy comes to the fire, says he spotted the herd of elk at some ridge and then leaves. The other hunters left are still going to talk into the night about which way they headed, rather he really saw them or not and where they think they are now. That's kind of how I see the value of this. People should be more courteous and come back and check etc. but if they don't all is not lost. We still benefit in my view. Now then though.... about those rascals that come and post their test questions! AyEEEEEE! :)

by tbragsda

It is for some good. People learned and shared. I dont like to be the angry one all the time. Realy, I'm very positive.

by admin

1 SEAGATE 20GB/40GB HORNET40 EIDE INT TRAVAN W/SERVER SW

1 TYAN S2466N TIGER MPX AMD 760MPX CHIPSET DUAL SOCKET A ATX FORM FACTOR 1xAGP/2xPCI(64BIT)/4xPCI(32BIT)/4xDDR W/ LAN Detail Specs (CPU TYPE:AMD ATHLON MP, XP)

1 ATI XPERT 2000 PRO 16MB AGP 128BIT DVD VIDEO PLAYBACK

4 Microsoft 5-client License for Windows 2000 SERVER

1 LITE ON 16X-DVD/48X-CDROM INTERNAL EIDE #LTD-163

1 SONY 1.44MB FLOPPY DRIVE

2 AMD ATHLON MP 2000+ 1.67GHZ (AMP2000BOX) RETAIL BOX W/COOLING FAN (3YR WARRANTY)

1 Microsoft Windows 2000 Server w/5 user licenses

4 KINGWIN KF-201DF LCD MOBILE RACK 5.25" EIDE ULTRA ATA100/133 ALUMINUM ALLOY INTERNAL REMOVABLE DRIVE KIT

4 WD 100GB 1000JB EIDE ULTRA-ATA/100 7200RPM SE W/8MB BUFFER

3SEAGATE ACCESSORIES 20GB/40GB TRAVAN 40 DATA CARTRIDGE 3-PK

1 18" IDE 2-CONNECTORS ROUND CABLE FOR FLOPPY DRIVE

1 ADAPTEC 1200A 2-CHANNEL ATA/100/66 PCI ATA RAID KIT

1 SUPERMICRO SC760P4 (CSE-044) FULL SERVER TOWER W/300W (PENTIUM 4 READY) ATX POWER SUPPLY

4 512MB PC2100 266MHZ NON-ECC CAS2.5 DDR DIMM

3 18" IDE 3-CONNECTORS ROUND CABLE FOR ULTRA ATA66/100/133 HARD DRIVE

This particular install will have another identical server on the network. It will run several commercial small billing databases, run our accounting program and serve 24 workstations. The servers will be in two seperate buildings that are currently connected so if one burns, the other stays up, mirrored drives, tape back-ups and all. It's a little bigger than 5 ws, but still a small little network at one of our locations. This is my sort of solution, but I would also be interested in what my peers here think for the small network server, will it be adequate? Thanks! :>

by admin

I've had really good luck with LinkSys and will continue to use it for my business.

:)

by lordinfidel

There are essentially 3 different classes of computers.

Desktop
Workstation
Server

While each of these classes has their own sub classses, this is the 3 main ones.

Now to focus on a Server Class system. You mentioned Compaq and Dell. While their desktop systems might not be the best, their server systems are pretty good.

A server class system has a lot of design put into it. Not just in the look and the case, but in the hardware subsystem. Most importantly the Motherboard. If you look inside a actual real server class system, and look at the motherboard, you will see a striking difference, night and day, when put against a desktop system.

You can buy server type motherboards and build them yourself. There will be a price difference.

In essence, the OS makes not a server alone.

Also Server Class systems are almost always scsi based systems, always take ecc memory, most of the time are dual procc capabale (I do not consider anything running a celeron a server, don't care who makes it). Most have dual power supplies (hopefully redundant/hot swappable).

While I have never been a fan of compaq desktops, their server line kicks ass. As so does dell's server and workstation line.

The best exch server I ever built was on a Proliant ML570. This is a huge bad boy of a server with 12 drive bays with 2 controllers. Perfect for setting up exch with the way it was meant to be set up. It also weighs 200lbs, has 3 redundant 350w power supplies and sounds like a jet when it starts up; but it rocks.

by admin

Ok... I know you're a hard ass and I respect that, but don't you think that there are also 3 classes of business: Large, Medium and Small roughly? While in a perfect world (or even a future non-perfect one) we may all have to use server class equipment (wouldn't it be nice if we were forced to budget like that to operate a business?) when most businesses start they are small and barely cobbling together a little 2-3 box peer to peer with little or no money. As they move through the wonderful journey of IT they get to where you are (hopefully), but along the way they are going to chose what works and even a dual processor celeron box, if constructed with some forethought, would probably suffice now and into the near future for a 5 station workgroup with w2k on the server as a step up from what the guy has now, wouldn't you think?

:)

by lordinfidel

They have a decision to make, how valuable is their data and what does it mean to them.

Then we need to decide what their spending limit realistically is. Not what they want it to be, but what they can spend.

Yes, I may be a hard ass, but I also have a unique understanding of the many things that can and will go wrong. Especially if I am consulting for someone, the last thing I want to do is have to continue to correct issues and not get paid for them. I would much rather collect my monthly service fee and not have to do anything.

I have a client now that is a small business (which I disagree with the 3 classes of business' model, I think it should be based on cash flow and #of systems, and not soley on employees)

Anyways, they only have a couple of people. Originally I was going to build them a server on top of a workstation class system. But that changed once we found out that a enterprise app that they want to run needs terminal services and the app is processor heavy. Then I opted for a server class system to support that. They were not happpy that they had to fork out 3500 for a new server, but again, how valuable is your data?

As far as celerons, I really dislike celerons. They are still flaky as hell, and I just don't feel that they have a place in a server or workstation system. Athlons and PIII's are relatively inexpensive.

Why put a chevvette engine in when just for a couple of bucks more you can have a mustang?

by draco vulgaris

Small, medium, or large business is not the key here! What really matters is what server down time is going to cost you. In the case under discussion, failure of the server is going to put five people out of work. Even the poor performance of theexisting server is probably making those five people less productive than they could be.

I'd say that the potential cost justifies the expenditure of $2 or $3K on an industrial strength piece of hardware. Servers, as well as businesses, come in small, medium or large; you'd spend far more on a server meant to support 50 users.

by admin

ok... I get you now. Originally I thought you may have been saying that every business needs a Proliant or better. I was wrong and thank you for helping me see that. I'm not a fan of celerons either (since the 300A) :)

by mrafrohead

Here's an idear...

Maybe just build a new server. And the costs that you save in that, you can buy your new os to run on the server. That would possibly equal out to a prefab machine's cost... Just make sure that you're using quality hardware that has all of those handy dandy self diagnostic features built into it and you'd probably be doing real well:)

Mrafrohead

by lordinfidel

I am a hardcore mustang man.

I'm on my second one now. (Gave up my 98 for a 2002) Black Rouch Stage3 GT, extremely fast.

The only thing I have against mustangs is that they allowed them to be made in automatic. Totally pointless and allows idiots to own them.

by philippehall

Hi

Adding more Ram will help a lot. Try this before making your client spend a lot of money to buy Win2k Server.

This discussion is closed to new replies.