I think you are both kind of correct. There is a dirctory on the hard drive used for Outlook attachments. You can see what directory is being used (and even change it) by looking at the registry key:
[HKEY_CURRENT_USER\Software\Microsoft\Office\[version]\Outlook\Security]
and looking at the value for OutlookSecureTempFolder.
However, I believe that this folder only contains files of the attachments that you actually open. This would explain why all of the attachments are not in the folder (you have not actually opened all of them yet). If you simply save the attachment withtout "opening" it (like by double-clicking on it to start the application it is registered to) then a copy will not be sent to the storage folder.
Cheers,
RW