Discussion Locked

Win2k vs Samba in AD as a file server

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I am about to upgrade the existing NT domain to AD mixed mode. I have to make a decision as to what to use for the file server. I've done some testing with Linux and Samba and it semms to work fine. In the past I've had some issues with NTFS permissions compatibility with Linux. What would you choose? What are pros and cons you can think of?

3 replies

by techserf

1. samba seems to run much faster for this. when you map a drive and open it, huge amounts of files display very fast. i find windows lags

2. samba can't (to my knowledge) do secure communications across the network. windows can. go into w2k local security options, see the option, send unencrypted passwords to 'third party' SMB servers. you dont' want that, and i think you are bound to it if you use linux

3. i don't know about permissions, but it's much easier to set them properly onwindows server and you know they're compatible with 2000/xp clients

This discussion is closed to new replies.