9 replies
by bfilmfan
The easy rule of thumb is:
If all of your applications can use DNS to resolve a name to an IP address, you do not need WINS.
You should be very careful as some older custom applications may well be making calls to netbios share names and most likely will not support a LDAP query call to AD or DNS resolution to access a network share.
by jbaker
NetBIOS uses WINS to resolve NetBIOS-to-IP names. This is especially important in a DHCP environment. Also, WINS traffic is unicast instead of being broadcast, so it can (theoretically) reduce the network overhead as a result of name resolution.
Basically, if you are not using NetBIOS, or Exchange (Exchange uses WINS as well). Test it. Remove it from a machine, test that everyhting still works, if so, go forward with the removal.
by mhengkhi
if you have pc clients still running Win98/95 or lower, it is dependent on WINS. the name resolution within a network for these OS version depends on WINS because they use NETBIOS protocol to connect to other workstation. 98/95 are not capable of full DNS name resolution within the network that's why it uses NETBIOS instead. some applications also uses WINS instead of DNS as per experience. some sql connection/query relies on WINS to resolve server upon their database connection. it is important that you also check with the developers of these applications existing in your company if it uses WINS or DNS resolution for data connectivity.
you can perhaps isolate (as previously recommended) that you setup a pc not using WINS to simulate running all the applications in your organization (e.g. email and other apps) to see if you will have issues. make sure you test on all client platforms.
you can also sniff (or thru netstat) while testing apps on that test machine/pc if you will notice any WINS traffic request.
hope this helps.
by ron
by dchristy
We discussed eliminating WINS also and found that Exchange 2000 and 2003 still have a dependency on WINS. Below are a couple of links about it. You can also just do a google search with "WINS exchange 2003" (without quoutes)
http://support.microsoft.com/Default.aspx?id=837391
And on the TechRepublic site:
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5138-10586-5649096.html
Hope this helps
by skooboy
by hsingh
one of the reasons for needing WINS, is for Windows 95 computers to connect to you 2000 exchange server/servers.
If you only used it for that reason, then you can remove.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending IT Employment posts
Sort by Trending