Discussion Locked

Worm of the Week Nominees!

0 helpful
49 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Are you tired of people who ask questions and never rate the answers?

They ran off with your great solution and fixed the issue and never acknowledged you?

Well here is your chance to recoup some points and name the WORM OF THE WEEK! You can check to see if someone has appeared on the WORM OF THE WEEK question before wasting your time giving them a thoughtful answer.

Let the party commence!

49 replies

by jdclyde

sahilshaa@
sahilshaa@
sahilshaa@
sahilshaa@

I HAVE to put this in, as the Worm that started this all.

This leach on the A$$ of TQ&A has asked 30 questions of fellow TR'ers, but hasn't had the decency to rate a single response out of all 30 questions.

This leach has also never offered to provide an answer to anyone else.

Wish there was a way to have somoene banished from this realm.

(just decline, last thing I am worried about is points)

by jdclyde

Number of answers given: 22
Number of answers accepted: 5 (22%)
Number of answers rejected: 2 (9%)
Number of answers not rated: 15 (68%)

Number of questions: 1
Questions with no responses: 0
Questions closed for rating inactivity: 0

Most amusing. While I remembered why I dropped out of the Q&A shortly after joining TR, to see the most of you have more unrated than I have even replied to. I don't feel nearly as abused as I did when I started off on my temper tantrum about the worms. (well, maybe just a little still)

The nice thing is my accepted average is higher than many here. na na naa naaaaa naa!

by jdclyde

Wow IP, looks like you found a real vampire. ask_anurag@ has asked 140 questions? And just looking at the last handful all are answered with none accepted.

I love BFilms advice to him.

by gary_w

There are too many to list!

However, there are times when I can help someone and they are really appreciative which makes up for all the others.

I don't care about the points anyway, I'm just trying to give back. I'm from the old school that remembers the internet before the general public found out about it. In the old days, it was all about helping each other out on the usenet newsgroups. I have received plenty of help so in that spirit I try to help someone out too. It's a shame that some folks have not been raised to even return a simple thank you when someone goes out of their way to lend some knowledge and assistance.

Gary

by bfilmfan

Oh man that brings back memories of trading recollections of Hammer Horror movies on The Right Place running on Wildfire BBS software! I miss Relay International Message Exchange, but the net is better!

by willcomp

In defense of the leech, sahilshaa@ has rated a goodly percentage of answers, provided some feedback, and closed a number of his questions (I checked).

Although he is purely a questioner and may lack some tact, he's not as bad as purported.

Don't get me wrong, I very much sympathize with the frustrated TQ&A answerers. After all I are one. We just need to make sure of our targets.

Dalton

by jdclyde

The worst thing is if people stop answering questions, then a lot of us will lose out.

I like to read what problems people are having. sure, I only may know the answer to one out of five but I answer the ones I can and learn from the ones I can't. I would much rather learn from someone else's mistakes than my own.

Maybe I came down hard, maybe I didnt'. (male menapause? getting beotchy in my old age I guess)

And while TR was gimping on me bad yesterday, I didn't see any that sahilshaa had done more than note that it was answered and ran away. I will go back because (believe it or not) even I could make a mistake (or so I am told).

by willcomp

Read the post regarding Experts Exchange. I also participate on EE infrequently. On the whole, I prefer TR, especially the Discussions. TQ&A is also more "professional" (for want of a better description) than is EE, but EE does force questioners to respond. It works there because EE is a fee service.

EE has some very knowledgable responders. Also have a lot of wannabes with junk answers that create lots of unneeded e-mail to other responders.

By the way, my acceptance rate on EE is >70% (28 for 38) versus about 24% on TR with >50% unrated. So opinion of EE is definitely not sour grapes.

by willcomp

Since some are throwing numbers around, here are mine. Suspect there are several even worse.

As a side thought, has anyone seen any activity from ReWrite lately? Maybe he just burned out from the frustration.

Number of answers given: 768
Number of answers accepted: 182 (23%)
Number of answers rejected: 174 (22%)
Number of answers not rated: 412 (53%)

Dalton

by bfilmfan

I think it is time to go to Bilouxi and get us some dance time with some honkey tonk queens!

by oz_media

I found a leech, may we burn him?

This BFilm guy, does nothing but help people out and answer questions. NEVER asks anyone for help and is always a one sided participant. Too much give and no get!

OR is it supposed to be the OTHER way around we are looking for? :D

OzMedia, now this one's dumb as a stump. Asks the dumbest questions, rejects all the answers and THEN STILL gives awy points!

Just recently he posted about a Thunderbird mail issue with a disappearing mailbox. No matter what people tried, he just thanked them very much for their help but then rejected the answer anyway!

Some of these people just need to be kicked out, we don't need it here.

by razz2

Almost lost my drink when I saw BFilmFan had asked a question. I feel better now.

I have used this place to ask questions when I can't figure it out. Before that I have tried on my own to learn about the problem and better myself. When I am stumped I ask the people here like BFilmFan and SGT_Shultz, and Oz etc that, well, are darn good. Sometimes the answers they give amaze me.

Of all the answers I have given (225), 136 or 60% have not been rated. That is sad. I have had questions where no answer fits my need. I would have loved to award someone but the fact is that just like I had no answer, no one did. If I don't answer the question in a way that helps then reject my answer, (I have been rejected by better looking people anyway) but at least rate it and PLEASE give feedback as to why so I might try again.

There is no one person I would vote for, but all those that don't try on their own. Sometimes, if I don't know the answer, I look it up to help someone. Why didn't they use google?

So, the Worms of the Week are the people that want us to do their school work or jobs for them without pay.

razz

by razz2

I had to jump into this again, I must be nuts. Here are my stats:

Number of answers given: 226
Number of answers accepted: 35 (15%)
Number of answers rejected: 54 (23%)
Number of answers not rated: 137 (60%)

I do not answer for points but for the practice. If I can help save
someone the headache I already went through, why not. If I ever
need help then I would ask too. EE is fine and I use that too but I
like the interface here better. It would be great if TR had
moderators trying to cause more answers to be rated, but this is
really a barter system. I answer what little I know and ask for
what I need to know. That said, Points do matter. I still like the
feeling when I answer a question worth 250, 500, or 1000 points
I got it right. They are a sign of thanks. I just wish people gave
some feedback on wrong or right answers.

As to those commenting on the broken english...

I am dis-appointed. I too hate when I call a company and get
someone I can't understand, or that can't understand me, but
write your question in the best english you can and as long as I
understand your point I will give it a shot. More power to you for
trying to learn our language when we didn't try yours.

and for the TQ&A or Discussion group thing...

Any non-point giving discussion goes in discussions, and
anything where you want to give points has to go here. They
could always allow points to be given in the discussion area but
since that is not the case then BFilmFan can post here and offer
the points. Then he can not give them, Then we start a
discussion in the Q&A about BFilmFan and award points. And so
on...

Ha! Have a great day all of you,

razz

by bfilmfan

I am just lil ol me that has been around a long time as a consultant. And I don't care what Oz says about that Bike Week partying. I was not on top of the speaker saying, "Grrr baby. I am a hair animal!"

by house

Well, I'm not very active in the Q&A. About two months ago, I started answering questions, but soon realized that, while I was so sure of my response, the people on the other end did not agree.

I tend not to write lengthy 'hand holding' responses either, whereas veterans like BFilmFan, will write a descriptive tut.

This one was pretty funny...
http://tinyurl.com/54qwg
...it led me to beleive that not everyone knows about the way the the TR TQ&A works.

Then again, there are those who just do not care, as noted in BFilmFan's recent answer to one of these notorious offenders. The biggest problem that I have now is not knowing whether or not the solution is a vaild one (did the answer help). ;)

by house

Number of answers given: 108
Number of answers accepted: 13 (12%)
Number of answers rejected: 17 (15%)
Number of answers not rated: 78 (72%)

Yuk... I think that I know my stuff for the most part. These stats are brutal.

Who's talking about 'EE'? That's taboo - heh. I saw another response in regards to flagging a leach. I remember this one a few months ago - maybe it is a good idea after all. Maybe if the reputation meter is implemented (if this is still on the table), we will be able to quickly bypass abusers.

On misposting from discussions to TQ&A... It's your prerogative... you will get more qualtiy answers in the Q&A area, and a bit of negative feedback in the open discussions - [i]this is a historical issue[/i].

ee... tsk, tsk

by house

Good idea Jaqui - I'd love the opportunity to browse my 'personal' archives (for lack of a better term).

...without having to resort to a search engine with keywords.

by house

I don't think any of us really care about points at all. It is the communication factor is what bothers me the most.

by house

Speaking of bad English... whoops. How about an "edit comment" feature. I believe Oz has mentioned this before after telling me about his poor fingering skills (his words; not mine). ;)

by bfilmfan

When I get frustrated with the leeches, I just pretend they are some of those dirty stinking barbarians and unleash my legions on them in Rome: Total War. Nothing like a good rout in Gaul to make ya feel better.

by cp7212

I'd like to nominate the people that think they own the site. Since I have been on recently, I've been corrected on paragraph breaks, location of questions, and whether I was a man or a woman.

I'm sure this is going to be stepping on toes, but I say get a life. I see this a lot. Thankfully, I have decent grammar and can spell, or I'm sure that would've been another slap on the hand. Why don't the members just realize that this isn't English class or TR 101?

I was real surprised not to see a post here that goes like, "This belongs in a discussion group." Yeesh, who cares?

To the heart of the Q, I have went from 30% rated to 18%. We should all compare percentages at the end of each month and issue a no-prize for the lowest percentage.

by cp7212

Number of answers given: 76
Number of answers accepted: 14 (18%)
Number of answers rejected: 15 (19%)
Number of answers not rated: 47 (61%)

Yeah, looking at the hard data now, I'm almost inclined to think, "Why bother?" My worst stat is "answers accepted". Geez, that's harsh....

by bfilmfan

Thank god for Word's spell-checker function. I use that to type my response and then post into answer's usually.

by ippirate

I agree.

I don't get to often answer many questions. I generally don't get the opportunity as BFilm, SgtSchultz and a couple others seem to have an automated sentient responder linked directly to TR and generally have presented prior to my arrival for the day. However, I do enjoy reading responses and I think more importantly, checking what I would have said against my peer groups responses. In the position I am in (small, family owned business, very anti-tech) affirmation is good.

Anyway, to answer the question. I would nominate at the current time anyone who types in broken English for the most part. From what I have observed many of them are our outsourcing buddies way out east and there are literally hoards of questions asked, answered and ignored in their regard.

Honestly, I wish that TR would generate a way to for me, as an answerer to tag a questioner as a leach in order to eject them from our happy abode.

One last thing;
This belongs in a Discussion group and.....

"To the heart of the Q, I have went from 30% rated to 18%-----"
cp7212, correct grammar would have been to use the word gone in the place of went.

wink, wink, nudge, nudge. I couldn't resist

Thanks all,

J

by ippirate

To clarify something on the broken English issue. I am not attempting to insinuate someone's ignorance or intellect because of their ability to speek English. I am however pointing out that, as I percieve it anyway, there are a great many questions posted by those speaking said broken English who are severe offenders. I will point to my nomination for Leach of the Week with the following individual

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5216-6257-0.html?id=3205344

This person's more direct information:

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5213-6257-0.html?id=3205344&redirectTo=%2f1320-22-20.html

All those questions asked, no points that I can see and looky, looky.... a big fat 0 for interaction on the level of answering questions or interacting with peers.

So? Can we pour salt on it now?

by ippirate

You know, maybe (I SAID MAYBE SO PIPE DOWN) I came off a little harsh (I SAID A LITTLE).

No, broken English is not a indicator of poor ethics.

No, it is not an indicator of an evil person.

No, I can't say that every human being that posts in such is a leach.

Do I notice an increase of mining in correlation with the first. Yes, but that is my perception and that is exactly what was asked for, perceptions, better, opinions.

If I've offended your sensibilities by my references, if they are non-indicative of yourself, I apologize, I wasn't attempting to target anyone who learns English as a second language blindly. Reading my statement I can understand how it has come off like that to some.

I apologize.

by bfilmfan

I got my Zippo! Where's Barbara Leigh with her BIC when ya need her? (Extra points for everyone who knows who she is!)

by pgm554

I have pretty much quit answering questions on this site, because of the many unrated posts of the lazy people who ask ,but do not acknowledge.

EE(Experts Exchange)is a site that is a whole lot more strict on people actually rating your answers with feedback.

Nothing is very challenging here anymore.
EE has a bit more variety and decent questions.

by pgm554

Number of answers given: 169
Number of answers accepted: 41 (24%)
Number of answers rejected: 38 (22%)
Number of answers not rated: 90 (53%)

by bfilmfan

EE has always taken a tough line on it, but they are a charge service and no one wants to pay for bad advice.

by jaqui

Number of answers given: 230
Number of answers accepted: 43 (18%)
Number of answers rejected: 39 (16%)
Number of answers not rated: 148 (64%)

and you can only see the last few questions you posted an answer to??
so there are 100+ questions I would have to search the Q&A for to find my answers.

by jaqui

Blackcurrant,
I know what you mean, I have almost 10,000 points, yet have no real use for them.
it's not about collecting points, it's about helping people. getting feedback is important, as then you know if you actually helped or not.
the points are the easiest means of guaging that..they went up an answer was accepted. ;)

House,
I've been agitating for something better in the activity section of profile for a bit now.

by bfilmfan

Well you could impress those wild Ontario women dancing on speakers at the casino with them....

On second thought, maybe that wouldn't work...

by blackcurrant

Number of answers given: 435
Number of answers accepted: 142 (32%)
Number of answers rejected: 108 (24%)
Number of answers not rated: 185 (42%)

Well, while I can't nominate a Worm of the Week, I do agree with a lot of the above. I would appreciate knowing if my answer did any good, pointed someone in the right direction, or was entirely innapropriate.

Such information would not only help me, it would also help others evaluate responses when searching TR Q&A for answers. And it's FREE. I think TR is a great resource, and it's a shame to see the generosity of its participants/contributors go unrewarded. Quite a few of the solutions I have suggested were only arrived at after a lot of trial and error, frustration, snarling coaxing, pleading and time (or just plain luck)!

Also, at the end of the day, points don't really matter (though they are appreciated! ;)), but it's a good feeling knowing you helped someone solve a problem.

Blimey, some people don't have any manners when looking a gift horse in the mouth...

by bfilmfan

If they don't respond my thought is that the advice worked. But their boss's know that knowledge didn't come out of their heads, so he is probably sniffing their Internet Usage logs even now...

by deepsand

Aside from the fact that many of these toads never even acknowledge the responses that they get, a goody portion of them don't even allow for peer-to-peer messaging as well.

When I 1st came on board, I briefly visited Q&A, but quickly gave up out of frustration. My recent forays there have been no more satisfactory.

I am considering first attempting a peer-to-peer contact before offering any constructive reply. If such contact is blocked, I might then considered responding with a not so gentle opinion of the poster.

by bfilmfan

Perhaps a Top 10 List of Interesting things to do with a TR Question Toad?

Look for that one today....

by wlbowers

My soapbox has to do with the questions that are answered in more than one thread and the person rejects them all. Or dismisses what myself and others know is sound advice.

How about the home work kids. They can't even reword the question. Good Grief! haven't they heard of Google.

My Stats
Answers Given 1242
Answers Accepted 295 23%
Answers Rejected 145 11%
Answers Not Rated 802 64%

Yea I know. But thats what the stats page says.

As long as I know I am helping I will continue to give answers.

Lee

by wlbowers

I haven't posted any questions. Usually when I get stuck it's at a customers site that is growling over my shoulder asking "When can I $*%!.

I usually have to figure it out, then laugh about it later.

by bfilmfan

Thou Shalt Google! Thou Shalt Learn The OSI Model! Thou Shalt Not Fail To Rate Peer Questions!

I like it!

by sgt_shultz

bfilm, please don't leave the forum until i get enuf of a clue about my dns namespace and ad domain to ask semi coherent questions. i am fumbling with security boundaries as my beacon...
you are helping me so much.
i see myself in everybody. i can't knock anybody. how can the world go 'round run by us mega assholes. i just shake my head...let he/she without an asshole be the first one to be mean to somebody...(who me, mean? me?)
how long was i here guys before i snapped to close all my questions? pretty long time. plus i do not revisit questions much so if you all have been tactfully (right?) suggesting that i close questons, i have been rudely out of communication...plus have slipped up several times and not awarded points like they should have been. bad bad sgt.
i am doing scores of things during day, stolen moments for TR. get bored easy (smile). i do not give it my full brain as you have seen (smile). (if it paid, i would)...people who post don't always give it their full brain either. their excuse is probably the dread sick feeling of 'wonder if i can fix it this time'? i can relate.
when they blow right past my answer which we all agree probably is the answer and they have blind eye to it, i feel more like normal. because i do that someimes (plenty) too. when they reject ALL our right answers, well then i feel like i belong...
i can't tell you how valuable everybody's questions and answers have been to me. everything goes into the hopper. the poorest worded unanswered question will help me. the most off-handed comment by bfilm turns on the lightbulb...
thanks to you all i have a clue sometimes. rock on.
and for my 2 cents:
please don't be prejudiced against folks not from usa. it is small world and we don't deserve the biggest chunk of it even though our tv says we do.
however, those students who want to get homework answered without trying to understand it any are fair game for us to have plenty of fun with, do you agree?

This discussion is closed to new replies.