Discussion Locked

XP SWAP file on a removable flash drive

0 helpful
7 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I've a mini laptop (Toshiba Libretto U100) with a very low-performance HD (1,8", 4200 rpm) and I'd like to use a SDHC Class6 card like a swap file repository, but XP don't want create it on a removible drive (on Windows 2000, instead, it works very well). How can I force XP to use a removible drive for the swap file (like a local drive)?

My SD card reader isn't an USB device but a mini-pci expansion slot (sdbus.sys).

7 replies

by cmiller5400

If it doesn't want you to do it, then don't. For one that I can think of off the top of my head is the fact that if it was removed during operation, you would crash the workstation and possibly corrupt data.

by c.coletta

I know that I'll have to not remove the SD but infact I intend to use a SD card always IN (the SD slot is PC-internal), like an second hard drive of 4GB. Under "Windows 2000" this usage gave me a great performance improvement during an heavy memory load process.
On my laptop, because of bad performance hard drive, often the swap usage is a very pain.

by cmiller5400

There is nothing like more physical RAM if you can afford to suff it to the max of the laptop or 3GB for an upper barrier for XP32. Those cards are SLOW compared to a HDD. They write by "erasing" whole blocks to "1"'s and then re-writing the "0"'s; this is time consuming. Not to mention that you have a life expectancy on the flash memory of only a hundred thousand writes.

by c.coletta

I know that the better choice should be the RAM, but unfortunately my beautifull mini-laptop support at maximum 1GB.

For the 90% of the my usage 1GB is a good quantity, but sometimes not. In this latter cases the swap is a pain due to the bad 1,8" HD, the use of a good class 6 SD card is better (I can confirm you that because I already use it with Windows 2000, this limit exist from XP on).

by cmiller5400

Next best thing is to swap the HDD in the system for a better one. You can ghost the machine, swap the drive, then ghost it back so you don't loose data. But you may find your answer in the registry... HKLM\System\CurrentControlSet\Control\Session Manager\Memory Management

Key = PagingFiles

by c.coletta

Following a Toshiba indication, the best swap solution is with an HD of 60 GB (unfortunately), but this isn't a real good solution.

I've already tried to use the following regkey:
HKLM\System\CurrentControlSet\Control\Session Manager\Memory Management,Key = PagingFiles
but without success. It seems that Windows XP doesn't want use a removable disk for the swap file.

by mronollo

Sorry there is no way you can convince me that a piece of memory is slower than a HD. If there is a bottleneck it would have to be at the controller level. Technically speaking an SD is most likely slower than onboard HD memory used for caching.

This discussion is closed to new replies.