Discussion Locked

Alright, well what about Fort Hood?

0 helpful
140 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I figured I'd let it sit a bit and see if anyone else mentioned it, because if I do it is Anti-American slander, but perhaps nobody is aware or interested?

Fort Hood, arguably the largest military base on Earth, has been subject to a mass killing of 11 with 31 more injured, one gunman dead and 2 others suspect.

This is a horrific incident and not unique to the US or US military tensions. I don't think it's an example of the US military, a detriment to their training or mental capacity, it is just a few of many tens of thousands of trained personnel, who simply seemed to snap.

My heart goes out to the families who were already wary of their sons and daughters fighting a war and being in grave danger, only to find out that their own brothers on their own soil had ended their lives. Nothing could seem more tragic or senseless to their parents, who will never accept of be appeased by any explanations or answers they receive.

My reason for posting is twofold, one is to offer my deepest sympathies to anyone on the base, the parents and relatives of the soldiers who fight for their nation; though such small words would never have any bearing on this tragedy.

Secondly punishment: Now as one gunman is dead, his punishments need not be discussed. apparently there are two others who were also involved though, and are in custody.

Questions: IF and that's a VERY big if, these two men are also found guilty of murder, shooting fellow US soldiers on their own base, how will/should it be handled?

Considering that this is Texas:

If they are guilty of murder, of a fellow soldier or any civilian too I suppose, will/should they be incarcerated by the army? Will/should they spend life imprisoned?

Will they be sentenced to death, as any other person found guilty of mass shooting would be?

or do you think that because they are soldiers, and because they are subject to additional stresses most citizens are not, will/should they be excused to a certain degree, have reduced sentences, spend life in jail, be put into psychiatric care etc?

At this point it is pure speculation, they are not pr oven guilty of a crime and should not be treated as such.

however this is a 'what if' situation.

What if they are guilty?
What WILL happen, what SHOULD happen?

Once again, I am very sorry to hear of this incident, in the US or anywhere else for that matter.

I make no implications of inadequacy on the part of the US military, I blame no training or soldiers, just the men who decided to execute their brothers in arms.

However will a patriotic, military overtone overlook or excuse the real, criminal actions of this man(these men)?

140 replies

by maxwell edison

is purely a military matter. A military Court Martial will probably result in the first military execution in ?? years - if there was more than one gunman involved. (One was killed, two others apprehended, but how many gunmen remains unclear, at least from what I've heard.)

Speculation will run amok for quite a while concerning the motives of the gunmen.

[i]"A law enforcement official identified the shooting suspect as Army Maj. Malik Nadal Hasan. The official said Hasan, believed to be in his late 30s, was killed after opening fire at the base. The official spoke on condition of anonymity because he was not authorized to discuss the case publicly.

A defense official, also speaking on condition of anonymity, said Hasan was a mental health professional - an Army psychologist or psychiatrist. Officials say it was not clear what Hasan's religion was, but investigators are trying to determine if Hasan was his birth name or if he may have changed his name and converted to Islam at some point."[/i]

My heart goes out to the families of those killed and wounded.

Edit:

The question, did he snap or was he a terrorist plant, is one that is on the minds of many - including me. (The gunman wasn't a combat soldier, so why would he snap? But then again, I'm sure he treated scores of them, hearing stories, etc.) I'm sure the answer will be pursued with all diligence, but I can only hope politics doesn't keep it a secret.

by oz_media

As far as the punishment via court marshall, you think he [i]would[/i] be executed if found guilty?

I'd like to think so, too regardless of his modus operandi, psychological state of being, I think he should be treated as any other murderer in Texas, another one to be executed.

To be clear, you know very well that I don't condone the death sentence unless we can be 100% certain, not just beyond a reasonable doubt, of such a crime worthy of execution. as we often make mistakes with such sentencing, I don't see it as reasonable action.

However, in this case, there is absolutely NO question with respect to the man man who was killed, the others in custody will also be found out with absolute certainty due to the number of witnesses as well as the obvious number of security cameras on and around the base.

One situation where I hope justice will be served swiftly and with full effect.

NOTE: I too read the speculation regarding his background, religion etc. However I refrained from mentioning it as, at this time, it simply creates prejudice.

by maxwell edison

Texas has nothing to do with it. Military installations within a state are like foreign embassies within another country.

Military justice will apply, not that of the state of Texas.

by maxwell edison

..... I oppose the death penalty (whether it be state, federal, or otherwise). But it's not a [i]hot button[/i] issue with me.

by av .

My heart goes out to all of the victims of this senseless tragedy as well.

Hasan, the gunman, did not want to be deployed to Iraq, according to this article.

http://www.cnn.com/2009/US/11/05/texas.fort.hood.shootings/index.html

This matter will likely be dealt with by the military, but I can't help but think about the motive. Is it a military doctor that snapped or a premeditated terrorist attack?

AV

Neither outcome is good.

by oz_media

I don't want to subject myself to media bias, as nobody has any answers yet, it is all pure speculation.

However, I was more interested in how it would be handled. Will it be seen as someone losing control and acting out in insanity? Or will it be tried as any other murder in Texas?

Because he is in the military, will they cover it up to hide the possibility of one of their own being driven off the edge?

However if the speculation of his origin and terrorist motives ARE proven true, I'm sure it will be a military and media field day, while Bush say's "see what I mean?"

Will we actually know whether it is terrorism or not or will they just peg him as one even if they find out otherwise. Simply to appease the public of their ruling?

From what I understand, a Court Marshall is not a public hearing and therefore such actual details do no have to be publicly disclosed and are easily covered up if need be. Is that correct?

by maxwell edison

....it's me. That's why I advocate LESS government (in general) over more. But they'll be no cover-up, per se, regardless of the gunman's motives. This is simply too big to try to cover-up.

I will say this, however. Pick a political side - any side - and they will try to use it to advance their own political agenda.

Even YOU speculated on what GWB will say - it was because this or that happens. Bush is not the president any more. Get over it. I'd bet a dollar to dirt that he'll have nothing to say except words of sympathy for the families.

You just HAD to bring Bush into this, didn't you? However, it reflects more on you than it does on him.

by av .

The military will handle this legally, but the issue of whether Hasan lost control or it was a collaborated act of terrorism will be front and center.

There is no way you can hide this tragedy. Still, I don't see any Texas-style justice being doled out.

We don't know enough yet, but we will.

AV

by santeewelding

As Max says, this is purely federal. Texas judiciary has nothing to do with it.

I, for one, am anxious to hear how the "other two" are determined to have been "involved".

One, I can half-understand. Three: that is another whole new ball game.

As to your death-penalty thing, I, too, like Max, have exigent thoughts about it.

by maxwell edison

I'm not quite sure how to take it. And I'm not quite sure if you intended to insult or not. I can only assume you did.

Let me put it this way. If I were in a position to EVER vote against the death penalty, I would do so. But I'm not the type to [i]protest[/i] against it, so to speak. They're pulling the trigger, not me.

If you want to characterize and judge me for failing to actively protest against and prevent every moral injustice in the world (moral - as I see it), then please apply the same measure to yourself.

Addendum: Screw you, might apply here.

by tonythetiger

Everybody dies... sooner or later...

Oh, you mean 'death penalty'...

It is, in my opinion, a suitable sentence for many heinous crimes... My problem is not with the sentence, but with the non-zero probability of a faulty conviction that may garner that sentence...

by boxfiddler Hot topic

when people don't quite understand what you just said, they automatically assume insult. That never ceases to amaze me.

"I don't get it. Therefore it has to be an insult."

by maxwell edison

[i]If death is not a "hot-button" issue, you have no soul, Max.[/i]

If (whatever), you have no soul, boxy.

Assume whatever you want.

P.S. You're not exactly one with an unbiased opinion, boxy. Your cyber-infatuation is obvious.

by oz_media

You are completely missing my focus.

Anyone else, a normal citizen tried under Texas state law would e executed.

If others are found guilty of the same crime ut are in the military, will they offer reduced sentence and make them seem less involved just to save face? The problem is, from what In understand, a court marshall is privately held behind closed military doors and is not for pblic knowledge, they tell you whata they want you to know and that's it.

So how will you "hear" with certainty the truth and not some spin, either way for military and political benefit? Trust in the media and the military?

by santeewelding

"Pentagon Papers"?

There is no way in hell they can hide any of this.

Besides, military trials can be, and occasionally are, publicly reported.

by nicknielsen

to other members of the military and to members of the press who ask to attend. I expect this one to be no different.

I attended a couple in my career; they were educational experiences. But many scheduled courts martial never actually convene; if the defendant pleas guilty, he will usually face only a military judge for sentencing.

by santeewelding

You [i] are [/i] pulling the trigger. Unless, you opt out of what I know to be us.

Insult: fluck you. That last is an insult. Do, please, discriminate when I address you directly. Do not waste my attention with herrings.

by maxwell edison

..... that you look for reasons to lob insults and judgments at me. You've done it again - and I'm sure you're happy with yourself. But your opinion of me does not define me.

Have a nice day.

Addendum: I will never again read or reply to any of your messages.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

about being anti-death penalty, implies that death is a hot-button issue for you. Therefore, how is it you take his statement as an insult?

The implications I see, drawn from both your statements, are that you have soul, Max.

etu

by maxwell edison

...... but his words speak for themself.

They were rude, wrong, off-base, and uncalled for.

If you want to defend him, knock yourself out.

But I'm through with the pompous jerk.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

is not pompous about you, or me, or any number of others out here?

It's not about defending him, he's more capable than I of that. It's about stepping outside ourselves to try to understand worldviews with which we have no experience.

Infatuation? Really. Now that there's funny.

etu

by oz_media

Come on Max, you've said and taken far worse.

I think he's a knob too, most of the time a complete prick in fact, but then again so am I, and so are you and so is.... get it?

If you can't accept that people will disagree with you and use such comments which can hardly be seen as 'rude or offensive' then you need to lighten up a bit.

We don't live in Mayberry this isn't a rated gg website, we have PG13 conversations here. You spew out insults and flames all the time, perhaps you choose words that are lss commonly used as insults today, but the intent is identical and the result is the same.

I'm not sticking up for him in any way, I'm just saying that you are no better than anyone else here when it comes to heated arguments and getting into personal attacks.
YOu assumed I was havign pot shots at Bush and trie dot imply my reasons were predictable and not worth people's consideration, however that is entirely false, not my intent at all and thus is offensive. So what, I expect that from you.

Your calling me disingenious is no different to me than saying "f-you, I don't believe you, you're an idiot"!

by oz_media

I offered a post regarding military personnel being attacked by what seemed to be one of their own gone bad. It's a horrific incident that merits further discussion.

I thought someone like you would afford it more credibility than to call it crap.

See what I mean? anything no matter how innocently put forth CAn be taken offensive, if you really want it to be.

You did actually offer some good and constructive comments though, until....well, someone stuck their oar on the wrong side of the boat and it started turning in circles.

by nicknielsen

There is no excuse for the actions of any perpetrator of such an act. There might be reasons, but there are no excuses. I am crying tonight with the families as a military brother of those killed.

As for how it will be handled, it is a [u]military[/u] matter. The killings were committed by [u]military[/u] personnel on active duty on a [u]military[/u] installation. There is no civilian jurisdiction involved.

The case will be handled according to the Uniform Code of Military Justice (10 USC 47 - http://www4.law.cornell.edu/uscode/10/stApIIch47.html)

There are steps that must be followed (SubChapter VI) before a court martial can be convened. The death penalty is a possibility (http://www4.law.cornell.edu/uscode/10/usc_sec_10_00000918----000-.html), as is an insanity defense (http://www4.law.cornell.edu/uscode/10/usc_sec_10_00000850---a000-.html).

Anything further at this point is pure speculation.

My feelings on the death penalty? Heinlein pretty much speaks for me at the hanging in [i]Starship Troopers[/i]. Killing the perpetrator will not undo the crime, but will prevent him from doing it again.

by santeewelding

Gotcha.

Lose the shilt about Starship Troopers, or, whomever.

You are whom I wish to know about this. No one else. No other reasoning.

Stand right out there with your own.

by oz_media

I nve implid there is,m or at least i certainly didn't mean to.

My point was just that anyone tried under texas state law for killing like that would be executed, no questions.

Because this is a military installation, and one of their own, what repercussions would execution have? Will he face the same demise as any other citizen comitting that crime in that state, regardless of his home state?

by nicknielsen

If tried, convicted, and sentenced to death in court martial, he will face the same demise as any other member of the military sentenced to death. Military executions are conducted at the U.S. Military Disciplinary Barracks at Fort Leavenworth, Kansas. If sentenced to death, he will be remanded to Leavenworth to wait out the appeal process. After all appeals are exhausted, he would be taken to the execution chamber in the cellar, strapped to the gurney, and given a lethal injection. This procedure is followed for all [u]military[/u] death sentences and executions; the military will not even note his current legal residence, other than as the place to send his personal effects after it's all over.

As for the alleged perpetrator (and he is still only "alleged", not yet having been convicted) being military, the majority of his victims were also military. I think it will be slightly more difficult (but not impossible) for the members of a court martial to isolate themselves from the consequences of his actions.

by oz_media

It's called finishing work for the day and going to the track for dinner and a few drinks.

I also start work on PST so I'm not up in the wee hours posting on TR.

by charliespencer

Updates this morning say there was a single gunman, and he is still alive and in custody. Since he is a soldier and the shootings occurred on a military post, he will be tried in a military court under the provisions of the Uniform Code of Military Justice, which covers the crime of murder and includes a death penalty for same. Laws and penalties of the state where the installation is located do not apply.

This may not be the best reference, but it was one of the first I found and is essentially correct.

http://usmilitary.about.com/library/milinfo/mcm/bl118.htm

by tig2

Hasan is currently alive and paralyzed. As far as I know, you are absolutely correct- he will be tried under the UCMJ. Assuming he lives, of course.

A gentle reminder to remember the families of the 13 killed, the injured, and the families of all in your thoughts and prayers.

by oz_media

First of all, I am truly sorry that you lost a brother in arms in such a sensless way. Being killed in the line of duty is one thing, being killed by friendly fire is another ut being killed by a nutter on your own base is inexcusable and tragic.

I read over my initial post and STILL can't see why people don't get the comment about how he will be tried.

Of COURSE he will be tried on a base under court martial.

My point is, these murders/executions were carried out in the state of Texas. IF and that's IF meaning a hypothetical example to be considered, he was NOT in the military, he would be executed, whereas in many other states he may not.

HOWEVER, as he IS (meaning it is a fact) on a military base and this incident WILL be tried under court marshall and behind closed doors, will he still face the same level of punishment that anyone else comitting teh same crime in the same state be subjected to. OR will he be let off easier and it will e played out as insanity, some kinds of mentality only soldiers would understand that is excusable and given time in jail instead?

Either way, it is a closed trial, we only know what they tell us happened behind those millitary doors. If there are any security concerns, even false or unwarranted concerns, they could tell the media and public whatever they wanted to.

by charliespencer

"HOWEVER, as he IS ... on a military base and this incident WILL be tried under court marshall and behind closed doors, will he still face the same level of punishment that anyone else comitting teh same crime in the same state OR will he be let off easier and it will e played out as insanity, some kinds of mentality only soldiers would understand that is excusable and given time in jail instead?"

First, just because there's a court-martial doesn't mean it's going to be behind closed doors.

Second, there may not be a court-martial. None of us here has seen all the evidence. The military police and JAGs haven't interviewed the man yet. He may really have mental problems. In that case, he would no more stand trial under the UCMJ than a civilian incapable of participating in his own defense in a civilian court. Or he may be capable of understanding his actions and participating in his defense. Or he may receive non-judicial punishment; unlikely, but theoretically possible.

Third, this isn't an 'either / or' question. You list two options - punishment comparable to other Texas crimes OR let off easy by the military system. Your first option is inapplicable. We could replace Texas with California or Florida and it would make no difference. His punishment will be comparable to similar crimes in th same JURISDICTION: the U.S. military. Your second option ignores the possibility a military court will not treat him any easier than a civilian one would for the same crime. Since he would be tried for crimes against fellow soldiers, a military court is not likely to treat him favorably, particularly if he did so to avoid deployment. That's cowardice, a 'crime' some regard as comparable to murder.

Fourth, you repeatedly make the assumption that, if found guilty, a Texas court would sentence him to death.

by ic-it

It all depends on the agreements setup between the Army and the State, etc.

Some bases allow any crime that is also punishable by local jurisdiction to be tried in local courts.
A very few insist on military right of jurisdiction.
Any matter that is only punishable by the military would of course default to the military.

To qualify this: I did 24 years of active duty as a Security Specialist and First Sergeant (very involved in disciplinary actions).

by charliespencer

what do you think are the chances this will enter the civilian system? We don't know the breakdown of the victims yet; if one of them is a civilian, do you think that would make any difference?

by jamesrl

I've never served because of a physical issue, tried to, but was rejected. But I have relatives on both sides of my family who have served, so I have a little insight into the mindset.

A solider is subject to military courts and military law if they commit an act while serving. The location doesn't really matter, the law is the same for those stateside or serving in a war zone.

Military justice standards tend to be harsher than civilian. Thats because of the importance and implications of discipline in the military. You don't want someone you can't trust with a gun, or access to weapons. You need someone who will obey lawful orders.

The military often looks to set an example, not excuse, cover up or in any way explain away bad behvaiour. Take the case of the Canadian soldier who fatally shot his best friend in Afghanistan. They were playing "quickdraw" when things went terribly wrong. He clearly had no intent to injure, and had also clearly paid a high price psychologically for the incident. In civilian life he might have any lesser charges about careless use of a firearm dropped. In the Canadian military they threw the book at him. They needed to show soliders they have a zero tolerence for mishandling weapons.

No doubt the shooter in the US will have the book thrown at him. There is already speculation that he may have wanted to be killed after inflicting punishment on the military. But even if that proves to be the case, the military courts seem less suspectable to be influence by mitigating circumstances and for good reason.

I'm not in principle in favour of the death penalty. I think someone with criminal intent rarely thinks through those consequences so its not a detterent. But like Max, I'm not going to shed a tear for this guy.

James

by oz_media

Firstly I KNOW he will be tried as a soldier under military court marshall. I don't expect not have implied he would or should be tried as a citizen.

Traditionally the military makes examples of people, as you noted with Cpl. Wilcox.

However it took two yeas for, what we are told is, the truth of that incident to come out in trial. It was a sketchy and vague testimony at that. Even the soldier 'recalling' a condemning conversation he had with Wilcox admitted he had a ad memory, couldn't remeber what month it was in, didn't know whethr they were drunk or not, 3 -7 drinks, didn't rememer WHERE it had occurred but had clear recollection of the conversation he had with Wilcox. That's just too vague and sketchy.

[i]"Keigan also said he didn't reveal the conversation he had with Wilcox to his superiors until a few weeks ago, when he was asked to come forward by the prosecution team.

But Keigan later testified that even though he couldn't recall specific details surrounding the conversation, the circumstances of the shooting were clear.

"A friend of mine was killed," he said. "I consider that important." [/i]

In that case there was not a few thousand witnesses, as I am sure there is in this case. There were most definitley security cameras too, which should show at least some of the incident clearly.

But who's to say that they WILL throw th eook at him? What if it shows a security flaw, and they have to make him look like a soldier gone bad? What if he actually WAS a terrorist and had infiltrated army security? What if he wasn't and they want to pretend he was to further justify their cause?

It's a political nightmare our there right now, they tell citizens what they want citizens to kbow, and that's it.

It is very likely that he will receive hard punishment/execution, and they will uncover facts. It is just as possibele that they could make up whatever story suits their agenda though, and we'd be no wiser.

by ---tk---

I go about 50/50 on the death penalty. However in this case, I hope they do not give him the death penalty. Why?

As a tax payer: I would gladly pay to see this guy locked up in solitary confinement for the rest of his life, with no windows and just a clock. But make sure that clock makes a nice loud tick. If he is given the death penalty, he got the easy way out.

by seanferd

I suppose he could claim insanity after a few years (or days) of that.

This is actually why I don't understand usage of the death penalty sometimes. If the intent is to punish, punishment ends with death. Of course, some may have their urge to revenge satisfied more that way than to see the offender locked up in solitary for life.

by oz_media

My comparison was that a normally Texas law would execute someone for the same crime.

Based on that, will the accused get it easier as he is in the military and tried under military law?

It's highly likely in another state, the accused would get off on an insanity plea, have a life sentence (or several consecutive terms) etc.

by charliespencer

"...will the accused get it easier as he is in the military and tried under military law?"

Negative. If anything, his sentence will be harsher. Remember, his victims were military.

The state is irrelevant; this is completely a matter for military law.

by oz_media

[i]"It all depends on the agreements setup between the Army and the State, etc.

Some bases allow any crime that is also punishable by local jurisdiction to be tried in local courts.
A very few insist on military right of jurisdiction.
Any matter that is only punishable by the military would of course default to the military.
"[/i]

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=320458&messageID=3196010

You see I THOUGHT he would automatically be tried by the military too, however upon asking I found out that's not necessarily true though.

The only reason I initially asked about the state was to consider if he would get the same punishment any other citizen comitting such a crime in Texas would face.

It's not irrelevant at all, in fact it is entirely relevant because that was the reason for the OP.

by oz_media

Except the media will seek him out as he was teh one who started the war that this man is supposed to be in fear of facing.

I agree Bush will probaly offer condolences, even I don't think he's that big of a dick. Obama will do the same and say how the military willl see to it that he's brought to justice yada yada.

BUT, if this turns out to be terrorism, or even if they find out he's Muslim, it just goes to fuel tha hatred for muslims further, the distrust of Muslims in American society and thus makes Bush's warnings of their motives are brought to light again, of course falsely. These guys aren't lining up in droves to take out the US, this is clearly an isolated incident, unless heaven forbid it occurs every day now.

by oz_media

If he's NOT a terrorist, they can peg him as one to excuse a choice of actions or further fuel the need for soldiers in Iraq.

If he IS a terrorist, they could peg it as an isolated incident to cover up the embasrassment of having him within their ranks.

In other words, they don't HAVE to air what they really find out, they may they may not but either way how do we know what really goes on if tried behidn closed doors.

by charliespencer

He is an officer who has been in for several years. As to cover-ups, the victims' families and the rest of the military want to know what happened. The Pentagon will want to know what happened in order to prevent it from happening again. The best way to do that will be to disseminate the findings to commanders at the lowest possible levels.

Sadly, there's nothing isolated about this; only the number of victims makes it unique. Soldiers have shot and killed each other in and out of war zones before. Sometimes post-traumatic stress disorder is involved; sometimes it isn't.

by oz_media

He did not want to go to Iraq due to his background, apparently, nobody knows what the real story is.

The media ran with the possibility of terrorism, as his last name indicates he's not a corn fed american boy. It simply opens up too much ignirant speculation, NO facts at all, and you will be left trust whatever they tell you is the real story.

Of course the military and government does not have the ability to twist it into something it isn't.
They can't pull the wool over citizens eyes that way, it's always above board.
They can't just say it may be linked to terrorism and could be a security theat in order to keep it from public eyes indefinitely.

by maxwell edison

He may or may not have been motivated by the stereotypical Islamic flavor of terrorism - the jury is still out in that regard - but he's a terrorist, no doubt about it.

by santeewelding

He could not hope to wipe out the entire U.S. armed forces -- but he could leverage his one act into fear and confusion among the entire, which is terrorism, if not treason.

by oz_media

But something that should to be considered in thie case.

Will he get off easier because he's in the military?

by tig2

But may get a different sentence due to his paralysis as a result of the rapid response by a civilian on base who was directing traffic.

My sense is that justice will be as swift as it can be. The identity of the shooter, along with his intent, is not in question.

by oz_media

But not the reasons for his actions, which are used to determine causation and the resulting penalty for his actions.

Causation is where prosecution and defense battle, not so much the actions or results of the actions.

by dmambo

I've been reading your posts for a long time, and generally disagree with you and I basically think Ayn Rand had her head up her arse. BUT, I think your arguments are well presented and unusually consistent compared to others'. AND you usually attack the arguments, not the arguers. SO, I do believe you have a soul ;)

Not that you need any peer support, but there it is.

Signed,
The King of Capitalized Conjunctions.

(Kind of an inappropriate thread to get off on this tangent, ain't it?)

by oz_media

not unless you have very thin skin.

When I chat with friends and we have disagreements it's not offensive to say, "you're just being a dickhhead" or "are you an idiot?" things like that are simply accepted as emotion and passionate speech between friends and not deemed "insults'.

but this thread is not the right place for such debate, it detracts from the horrific incdent thta occurred and makes it into a personal pissing contest of who said what, as if that holds greater importance.

by maxwell edison

.... I have pretty thick skin; nothing anyone says to me or about me in these threads defines who I am. However, at times, I will admit, my patience does wear a bit thin.

by dmambo

This Army psychiatrist, an officer born in the US, did his undergrad at Virginia Tech, the same institution where the gunman went crazy 2 1/2 years ago. I would imagine that a collective shudder is going through that institution today.

by charliespencer

as I understand this last exchange, is your question, "Can he be tried in a Texas court?" Your original question comes across as if you're asking, "Will it make any difference that the crime occurred on a military base that happens to be located in Texas?"

by oz_media

IF he is tried by the military, will they seek to cover up parts of his crimes for security credibility or will they charge and sentence him as any other court would, in this case as it is in Texas, I used a comparison to Texas state's normal resolution, execution.

The comparison is completely logical.

Would HE get the same treament anyone else in Texas would? Whether tried by the military or not or will it e preferential treatment as a fellow soldier, or will they make an example of him, or will they cover up truth to protect security and save face?

There are many ways it could go, depending on the best interests of the military.

by ic-it

be treated as any citizen of Texas, he would be treated as any military member.

The military, in general, holds their members to a high standard of behavior (perhaps more so when it involves the media or civilians).
Having said that, they rarely would cover up anything UNLESS it could be (strongly) argued that it would be a comprimise of National Security.

by charliespencer

He was born in New Jersey. While there isn't much corn raised there, he is a US citizen by birth, if that's what you mean by 'corn fed american boy'.

by jamesrl

Since the offenses took place by army personnel on an army base, that would mean it would have to be extraordinary circumstances to transfer to civilian courts. If there were only civilian victims and it was off base, it might happen.

I've seen instances where Marine guards in Ottawa have gone bad, in public places with civilians and there was some pressure between the government and the US Embassy to have the guard stand trial locally. In both instances, the Marines chose to patriate (bring back to the US) and hold court martial there.

I don't think having some civilians killed would change the jurisdiction, and any civilians killed were likely contractors for the army anyway, giving more credence to court martial.

James

by ic-it

When on foreign soil it would depend on the SOFA (Status of Forces Agreement). Similiar to States, Counties, Towns agreements with local bases, but on a National level.

There may be external pressures in this case, but the ultimate legal document is the current arrangement in place between the Army and Texas jurisdiction powers.
It could be Concurrent jurisdiction, then they (the lawyers and prosecutors, military and civilian) would be negotiating to try the trail where each feels it would be most advantages to whom they represent.

It would even be possible to try him both ways as long is it doesn't cross the line into a double jepardy situation.

by charliespencer

My opinion is the results will be the same in either a military or civilian court, with the procedures being the only difference. Same evidence, same publicity, same disclosure, same outcome. Either way, assuming he stands trial, right now I think he's looking at guilty and a death penalty.

None of us have all the facts, and I probably never will.

by charliespencer

Like you, I (and I suspect most of us) made the same assumption. All of my previous responses have been based on that assumption.

Now, ASSUMING the case is handed over to the civilian courts, AND he's found competent to stand trial, AND convicted and not found insane, there's still no guarantee he'll be sentenced to death. However, a civilian trial eliminates the unlikely possibilities of closed doors or receiving softer treatment by other soldiers because he's one of them.

by ic-it

On this fact ---but may decline a court-martial and receive non-judicial punishment. Unlikely, but theoretically possible.

You can not decline a Court Martial; you have no choice.
You may decline an Article 15 and then the Commander may continue action with a Court Martial.

by charliespencer

I haven't dealt with these matters in several years, and fortunately had few when it counted. I've edited my post to correct the error:

"Or he may receive non-judicial punishment; unlikely, but theoretically possible."

by oz_media

He can also be tried in a civillian court under Texas law and from what one peer says that is quite likely.

I have also stated several times that those were the assumed resolutions, only to have others confirm it WOULD be a military trial for sure, as you did yourself too, then they too were proven wrong.

That's the basis and effectiveness of such discussion.

by oz_media

Exactly the sort of reply I was looking for.

Many seem to think he's be treated more severely by the military, which is true in many cases and the impression they give off to me too, especially when public and they need to set examples. However it can go either way, I think (as you've noted also), depending on what's best for their own political and security interests.

I was interested if people thought it usually goes one way or another, however it seems most feel it would be a military issue and that they wouldn't deceive public, or wouldn't be able to in this case anyway.

by charliespencer

Texas was the state with the most military enlistments on this unfortunately undated chart:

http://www.statemaster.com/graph/mil_tot_mil_rec_arm_nav_air_for-recruits-army-navy-air-force

The accompanying linked chart has it seventh per capita. Numerous military bases are a significant portion of the Texas economy, one reason why it's also a popular state for military retirees.

My point in these stats is that Texas has strong ties to the military (as does the southeastern US in general). Any hypothetical civilian trial would have a sizable percentage of people with military ties in the juror pool. It's debatable whether a defense attorney would view that as a good thing or a bad one, but there would likely be too many to exclude them all if desired.

by oz_media

It was others that brought the issue to light for me, then I started to see teh media BS about it. Again as it was all new it was also all speculation, as is anything at tthis time really. But he apprently had issues with going to Iraq, whether that was a result of religion or not i do not know (which may not be impacted at all by his nationality or country of residence).

I hadn't even considered it myself, until it was brought up, to which I have consistently stated that it is premature mud slinging by the media not to be really considered until proven.

I think it's safe to assume he's not a blonde haired redkneck though, which puts an instant target on his back for many.

by charliespencer

"But he apprently had issues with going to Iraq, whether that was a result of religion or not i do not know..."

I heard a radio report this morning that he is a psychiatrist. Among his patients were soldiers with PTSD. Possibly this played a part in his choice of actions.

Everything is speculation at this point. The news channels have to fill those 24 hours somehow.

by charliespencer

In the civilian world, bigamy isn't a crime. Neither is "Conduct Unbecoming", or failure to obey a legal order, or too many others to list.

by oz_media

Early reports said he was a psychologist, which hardly excuses him for anything not that his profession WOULD excuse him anyway.

by oz_media

As expected, they are already trying to place importance on his race and lo and behold a former Army Lieutenant, bigot, running for congress is chomping at the terrorist infiltration bit already (we really don't need to guess for which party now do we? And Max complained that I brought Bush into it, foresight is important):

[i]"Andrew Grant-Thomas, deputy director of the Kirwan Institute for the Study of Race and Ethnicity at Ohio State University, said [b]reporting about the incident had unduly emphasized Hasan's ethnicity and religion.[/b]

He also said some politicians were using the incident to fan fears about Islamic extremism, citing a statement by [b]retired Army Lieutenant Colonel Allen West, who is running for Congress in Florida, that urged the Pentagon to do a better job to prevent Muslim extremists from "infiltrating" its ranks.[/b][/i]

by charliespencer

"As expected, they are already trying to place importance on his race and lo and behold a former Army Lieutenant, ... citing a statement by retired Army Lieutenant Colonel Allen West, "

Who are 'they'? People of many races are Muslims; Islam isn't confined to any one race or country. There's a huge difference between a Lieutenant and a Lieutenant Colonel.

by maxwell edison

..... [i]crap[/i] was not your discussion, but rather the tangent that I got dragged into. (And you'll notice by the time-stamp on the post, that I was through with [i]that crap[/i].) [i]Crap[/i] tangents - I should have known better.

by seanferd

Not that I think it likely, for many reasons, but I won't soon forget the complete BS surrounding the USS Iowa.

by santeewelding

Learned as a novice, the plural being, "courts-martial", like, "teaspoons-full".

Geese.

At least, get the goddamned nomenclature right before we ride off waving into the sunrise.

Yahoo!

Yeh.

by charliespencer

Quoting from the ever-doubtful Wikipedia,

"Terrorism is the systematic use of terror especially as a means of coercion. ... Common definitions of terrorism refer only to those violent acts which are intended to create fear (terror), are perpetrated for an ideological goal (as opposed to a lone attack), and deliberately target or disregard the safety of non-combatants."

I don't think there was any ideological goal behind his actions, or even a point of political protest. My opinion is it was a failed suicide attempt.

by charliespencer

At a minimum, the post paper will cover it. Depending on his mental state, military psychiatrists (ironically) may produce material for both military and civilian professional publications.