Alright, well what about Fort Hood?
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
IT Employment
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by jiminpa
You already know the answers to the questions you ask. Your just trying to stir up a debate so you can try to "educate" us on the ills of American society. IMO you went too far this time.
Disgraceful.
:(
by poppatab
Hello,
I have not read all the posts here, but I do know about the military a bit. First, a civilian police officer shot and wounded the alleged killer. How she got there? She was directing traffic on post. What's that you say? A civilian police officer was directing traffic? Yep, she is a hero now! She was civilian police officer working for DoD at Ft. Hood. What can happen and does happen is the city, county, or state can take jurisdiction giving if a civilian was harmed. Most of the time civil courts have first shot at military if said person committed the crime off post. Then, action can be taken by the military once the civilian courts are done with him. The last military person actually put to death in the US was in 1961, most executions are remanded to a federal prison rather than having it done in the USDB. (United States Disciplinary Barracks) The USDB on Ft. Leavenworth is not the only USDB which are distributed though-out the US. In an article found on CNN, the last man sentenced to death in the military is still awaiting appeal; although President Bush did authorize the death penalty. See here: http://www.cnn.com/2008/CRIME/12/03/military.execution/index.html Usually in matters of this much importance, the case is tried by the most punitive power holder. I believe the Military can take jurisdiction, but I seriously doubt they can get a death penalty approved by our current president. In all this hub-bub; I have not actually seen who is actually going to take jurisdiction of the currently comatose alleged murderer. I would think this one will not be a courts-martial type of trial. Mind you all, I am not and expert; simply a military policeman back in the day. My belief here is we had a mental patient treating mental patients who did not want to go to war. He just screwed up and didn't get killed enough by the police woman. We can always rely upon his medical condition to serve justice.
by oz_media
It has nothing at all to do with American society at all. They were very fair questions referring to law that would be asked whether it was in Canada, the US, UK or any other democratic nation.
Give your ***kin head a shake and grow up already. You're not even being overly defensive, it is paranoia.
Leaping.
Yours is a mixture of the very good, and the not so good. This one is somewhere in between.
You're doing all right picking up the pieces.
by jiminpa
Shows your ignorance.
Don't play dumb. You knew the answer to the question before you even asked. Coming from anyone else you may call me overly defensive and paranoid but from you? Nah. Anyone who reads anything political in nature posted by you, knows where you stand.
JJ, sits quietly and waits for more less than witty 4 letter words from "The Great Oz"
by oz_media
Some little whiner, that thinks he's being clever, steps into a thread and starts making false accusations of the objective of the thread and my alternate agenda and I am going to defend my objective.
If that cretin then continues to lie and state he knows things, while proving he is absurdly ignorant to the whole subject, and I don't just lay down...well, sorry, I'm not French.
I've shown no disresepct to the US or US military, I've shown not disrespect to the soldiers and their families who were effected by the incident, JJ has done that by completely ignoring teh suject matter.
Don't even start with the "YOU GUYS" stuff, it's not 'YOU GUYS' it's ONE guy, and he knows he's being a complete tosser but thought he had a point and couldn't substatiate his false claims so he is being a child about it instead. If I was American, his stand would be the extreme opposite and, from his comments, that's very clear for all to see.
I know you want to play the middleman and not accuse either of wrongdoing in an effort to settle an issue, like that most annoying "let's just agree to disagree bullshit that people spew these days" but I have done nothing wrong and have no reason to let someoen else start flaming my intentions and character when he has no ground to stand on at all.
You might tell your children to just walk away when someone walks up and blindsides them with a sucker punch, but I always taught mine to turn around and kick the living snot out of the guy instead.
by oz_media
There's always one track minds resulting in racism.
They see one radical action as tied to anyone of a particular skin tone or "foreign land" to be feared.
by oz_media
I seem to have spelled it martial in most posts, save one.
Didn't mean to upset or annoy you.
by boxfiddler Hot topic
by oz_media
Will he receive the same scrutiny and sentence, as a member of the US military, as he would if he were civilian?
Will they twist the truth to allow themselves to save face?
They may use him to set an example, as has been shown many times by various nation's military, or they could mask the truth to make his crime seem like a mantal breakdown in order to retain their security credibility, which I am also sure has been done many times worldwide.
If they say he was a nutbag, a one off wiredo, then they also could accept an insanity plea. He'd he'd almost certainly face execution as a citizen for doing that in a mall or something, insanity plea or not.
There's already been a statement wondering how Islamic terrorits managed to infiltrate the US military. It fuels bigotry and hatred by those who think you need to stay in Iraq, essentially making a case for them.
Of course I know he was an American and was admitted to the US army as anyone else would be but he's already being pegged by some nutters as a radical islamist. Therefore making such racists feel that even American Islamists can't be trusted and furthering attacks on Islamist Americans.
by nicknielsen
In my experience, the military legal system is much better at that than is the civilian system.
And in the case of those already making the "radical Islamist" claim, intellectual honesty has no place in their world-view.
by jdclyde
by oz_media
by oz_media
by oz_media
There you have it, 5 letters and yet it is still bang on.
If this was regarding an issue in the Canadian or UK military I would have still posted it. So how does your stupid, mindless analogy fit? It doesn't.
It is also not a political issue, has nothing to do with politics.
It is a legal issue and I discuss many legal issues here, without bias, so grow up already.
You THINK you have an objective or ulterior motive figured out but you are clearly wrong, as others seem to agree. In fact you are the only one who feels otherwise, even Maxwell didn't see any alternate motive to my comment and he's the first one to read undertones (he's actually quite good at it sometimes, obviously unlike yourself), you are simply incorrect in your brash assumption.
Read through the thread and show me where I have taken an offensive stand on the US.
Show me where I have attacked someone's post or discounted the ability or credibility of the US.
You can't.
Now either follow the post and offer some
relevant comments, or bugger off and find somewhere else to whine where you may actually have a point.
You haven't added anything worthwhile to the thread at all, except the mindless snivelling of a child.
by jiminpa
did I strike a nerve?
You call me a child and tell me to grow up but of the 2 of us I believe you are the only one who has resorted to playground name calling.
"Now either follow the post and offer some
relevant comments, or bugger off and find somewhere else to whine where you may actually have a point"
It seems to me no one ever has a point except those that may agree with you and those who do not are met with fierce backlash and name calling.
by oz_media
Seriously, it's like trying to debate a subject with a 5 year old who can't focus on the topic at hand.
It's not a matter of agreeing or disagreeing with me.
You came here and started in on ridiculous accusations and didn't offer a SINGLE WORD, not ONE LETER, that referred to the topic, you're only intent was to call me out on starting the post to begin with. I mad eno accusations and there were no opinions for you to agree or disagree with, as you so suggest, illustrating your absolute failure to comprehend the subject matter.
I don't care if you agree with me or not, actually I haven't even said anything that seeks agreement, it's just gathering other opinions and discussing the matter with people who know how to carry out a conversation.
I don't even think you've read the OP, based on your complete lack of understanding of the whole thread.
Don't try to say that you were disagreeing and I didn't like it, you made no comment at all about the post.
Like I said, get a life, grow up or go back to your room and play while the adults have a conversation.
In short, contribute or leave.
by oz_media
Lieberman has commented that trial could be held in a military trial behind closed doors in order to mask the truth. However he wants none of that and feels it should rightly be tried in a more open forum.
[i]"A confession would put an end to the controversy developing in the US, as conservatives, independents and some military rank and file accuse the Obama administration and its supporters of equivocating on the Islamist factor of the Fort Hood crime in a way that could encourage radical Muslim Americans in and outside the army to emulate Maj. Hasan's act.
In anticipation of efforts to suppress the findings of the official investigations by a news blackout or other means and conduct the trial or court martial behind closed doors, Lieberman has acted to make sure the entire episode and its ramifications see the light of day in an open congressional inquiry. Hence also his demand for an independent probe to be launched by the Department of Defense."[/i]
by jamesrl
While I agree its a good idea if it isn't closed, its a little early to anticipate which way the wind is blowing.
Seeing how its a capital crime, and civilians were involved (the police who shot him would be witnesses), there would be very strong pressure to make it public/open.
I think sometimes Joe, as an independant, has to jump on issues early to keep his name out there.
James
by oz_media
But in teh same case if it is considered by one, it is considered by others. If it is aired by one with a pulic voice, public will parrot.
It's that old pulling at a lose thread thing, next thing you know you are cold and your sewater is a tangled ball of wool at your feet.
by av .
It shouldn't be private so that we all know the truth. Is this a new kind of terrorist attack? US version of a suicide bomber? Serviceman that snapped?
I'm not surprised Lieberman is speaking out on this incident given his pro-Israel stance. Aside from that, I agree the motive for something this egregious should be unmasked so we all know the truth.
AV
by jamesrl
I disagree with your idea that "agree to disagree" is bullshit. Perhaps it isn't applicable in this particular case, but where two people will never agree on something, what is the point in back and forth forever?
Neither you or Jimmy are going to "win" this argument, because neither of you will change your minds. So whats the point?
This isn't fighting in the street, its a forum for discussion. He didn't sucker punch you, he responded. He may have over-reacted, but you've done the same to others. You've said what you have to say, so has he, so why waste energy picking it apart?
In fact your fighting over it only takes focus away from your original question, and I think that was Palmy's point.
James
by oz_media
my point is, if there is disagreement between adults, AGREEMENT can be reached. Even agreeing to disagree is agreement.
It's just a hip and trendy way of backing out of a debate when you have either nothing more to support your claims, are unable to admit you were wrong or simply feel otherwise.
Okay so you disagree, but why? That is what debate is, otherwise its just laying down and giving up as if your thoughts and comments are not worthy of defense. I am very firm in my convictions, yeah really I am, I am nto abotu to put my convictions on hold just ecause someoen said, well I don't want ot argeu about it, I think you're wrong but can't prove it.
In this particular case, Jimmy is clearly very wrong. I haven't made a single comment to disqualify or discredit the US in any way shape or form. That's no different than me complaining that you said I was fat, ifi you haven't said I was fat then how can we never agree on it? It's a fact, and I asked him to show me where I hade mude such accusations against the USA.
His only reply is that I always do it, which is also false.
I do bash US policy and the ignorant (from any nation) quite often but not always and not in this post as he so states I have.
But why would I accept that he will never agree when he has simply made what was plainly a false accusation toward my comments and has nothing to back it up?
Can you see where I have bashed America? Can you see a hidden agenda? Please post it.
Just way to spineless for me.
Do this guy's opinions, either of me or of the subject, matter to me?
Do other members of the forum recognize my name as one who consistently posts worthwhile material?
Is the other guy doing such a poor job of presenting his position that nobody I respect will take him seriously?
by oz_media
If you are going to accuse someone of something they clearly did not do, then you should expect to be called on it and support your false claims.
If you are unable to support those false claims, then those claims are pure rubbish and should be revoked.
In this case, there was no proof provided when asked, just further insults. There was no support, just more insults and therefore I will not lay down. I don't care if others belive me or him or whomever, it's not about others it's about he and I. If he wants to call me a liar, he an expect to prove it or revoke his comments and f-off.
Do this guys opinion either of me or the suject matter to me?
His opinion? Not in the least. The subject matter? No.
Falsely accusing me of something that is unsubstantiated on a public forum.No
Directly posting a personal attack to me? Yes. Defend it or revoke it as unsupported BS.
Do others recognize my name as one who consistently posts worthwhile material? I don't really know nor really care, I think it works both ways. I get positive peer mail from people who are afraid to speak out on TR, I get bashes from those who aren't afraid to speak out, that's why I've hung around so long, it can be fun to debate.
Is the other guy doing such a poor job of presenting his position that nobody I respect will take him seriously?
Who knows? Other poeple's opinions are not my concern unless they are forming an opinion on what I have said and calling me out on my comments. Then it is a personal debate, or in this case, personal attack based on false pretenses.
Life doesn't all fit into a tiny box, some things have to be viewed on a case by case basis.
by jiminpa
You have oft time lamented your disdain for this country within this forum. The same cannot be said of me.
As for the others, if my comments here have in any way caused you to believe that I do not care what happened well then I do apologize. Apparently however there are those who feel I am not worthy of respect. For that reason feel free to comment but I will bow out of this "discussion".
by jamesrl
Have I ever thought Oz has crossed the line into America bashing on these forums. Absolutely.
Did his first post which started this thread bash Americans or the US military? I've re-read it half a dozen times and I see that Oz took great pains to avoid any implication of criticism of the US or the US military.
Did Jimmy Jam disrespect other than Oz anyone by arguing with Oz? No.
Can we all just move along?
James
by oz_media
Disrespect is exactly what you showed in your rapid dismissal of the content due to your falsely preconceived beliefs of the intent. I don't care if you disrespect me but to dismiss the subject matter without consideration is disrespectful to the subject being discused.
READ the post next time, and THEN tell me it's bashing America, otherwise STFU and good riddance.
by jiminpa
I read the whole post. Word for word... Now who is making assumptions D1ck.
Wait let me retort for you. Blah blah blah expletive said he wasn't gonna post blah blah blah more witty expletives. You are nothing else but predictable.
by oz_media
I found an article on the weekend, should have bookmarked it because I couldn't find it today, that interviewed people with all different views.
One was a redkneck who pretty much said kill as brown people, they don't belong in our nation. Others were from Muslims who have already been getting harassed in public. The military has been telling officers to keep an eye out for racism in teh army as it is actually quite rampant, they even called Hasan a camel jockey, though he didn't seem to take it as a joke. They have already said it will e covered up behind closed doors, others have said it will prove there is infiltration in the US Army...speculation is like a virus.
It's not just Lieberman, it's all over the place and everyoen has a different viewpoint. Even Obama, who was first chastized for speaking too soon against a friend who was arrested at his college home, is NOW being chastized for NOT speaking on this issue right away. People are actually saying he is laying down and forgetting about it because he supports the Muslim terrorists.
by tig2
As of the news this morning, there is an indication that the shooter had made contact with, or attempted to make contact with people known to be linked to Al Quida. I have no idea if that has been confirmed or not.
Still, my take on this from the beginning is simple. What the man did is an act of terrorism (in my opinion). Now get on with determining whatever else needs to be known.
Oddly, I can't even say that I care if PTSD was an element or not. There are a lot of people living with stress beyond most people's ability to imagine. They aren't shooting up rooms full of people. There are a lot of people faced with situations that appear to be wholly unresolvable. They manage without bloodshed. This was the cowardly act of someone not fit to wear the uniform or rank given him. To quote someone dear to me, "Shoot him where he stands, leave him for the crows. There are people out there more deserving of our time and attention."
by oz_media
Now I know where you got the four letter word comment from.
If you read the whole post and still think it was leading into anti-US sentiment, then you have comprehension issues far beyond the scope that anyone here can help with.
Give it up, you were wrong, you were proven wrong. Despite mutiple efforts to allow you to show where you got your assumption from, you have failed to come up with any proof for anyone. Others have also been around here and know me far better than yourself, after reading the post they too have confirmed there is no such leading commentary in it.
You are simply wrong and your comment cannot be justified.
"For that reason feel free to comment but I will bow out of this "discussion"."
The phrase 'bow out of this "discussion"' is usually interpreted as meaning you aren't coming back to that particular topic. Observe; I'll demonstrate.
by jamesrl
Whether or not it was terrorism doesn't change the outcome for the victims.
Terrorism is an attempt to influence behaviour through fear. Whether that was his intent, or whether the impending deployment caused him to snap, the number of dead and wounded remain the same.
It really shouldn't impact sentancing either, not when we look at something on this scale.
It isn't unlike the same discussion around Timothy McVeigh many years back. The fact that Hasan was wearing a uniform to me doesn't change much, perhaps only the venue of the trial, not the outcome. Like any organization of people, the military is bound to get a share of good people, and bad ones. We'd all like to hope the selection process would weed them out and that military discipline would keep the bad ones who sneak through in line, but no system created by man is perfect.
James
by jiminpa
I wanted to publicly apologize to OZ for my earlier posts in this thread. I read and reread and there is no reason for me to have posted what I did. I allowed previous perception and discussions to taint my judgment of this one.
FWIW Oz, I apologize
by jamesrl
It shows maturity and wisdom to be able to revisit your actions and reflect on them.
For what its worth, I figured that you were probably having a bad day/week, and I also know that Oz can take care of himself and has skin like iron.
James
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending