Discussion Locked

American Politics -- 3 on 3

0 helpful
32 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Heading into what seems to be the most polarized election in 40 years, I'd like to postulate a new theory of the dynamics of the electorate in recent days.

As a number of writers have noted, ideology became a much stronger component of the political spectrum with the coming of age of the baby boom in the late 1960's. The Democrats' faith in central planning began to fragment in the wake of Vietnam, while the Republicans' social conservatism became a drawback in the attempt to recruit young voters.

The more ideologically-oriented of liberal voters were drawn to a number of movements, usually with a different single issue at the core but united in opposition to what was identified as the military-industrial complex, while disaffected Republicans split between traditionalist single causes (abortion being the most prominent) and a growing Libertarian movement.

Note too, that despite their emergence, the more ideologically-oriented of each side tended to carry a strong prejudice against the opposite core party. Though Greens and Libertarians might be able to engage in intelligent and cordial discourse, it is rare to find a Libertarian who doesn't carry a deep-seated predisposition against the Democrats, and vice-versa.

Now add to this mix the disaffected populist wing of both parties; the most socialistically-oriented of the liberal Democrats, and the populist conservatives who have emerged in the wake of Limbaugh, Savage, Hannity et. al.

With the electorate again polarized, and the better-educated of both sides locked in place by ideological commitments, it could well be that the final outcome may be affected by a last-minute indiscretion by the disaffected wing of either party.

Ladies and gentlemen, please comment.

32 replies

by black panther

How does it work in the USA?

In Australia voting is compulsory. %50 of the people have made up their minds before they get to the polling booth. The others either 'donkey' vote ie the vote is null or make up their minds on the day ( without any knowledge of what has been going on through the media etc ).

Some vote for some obscure party thinking they are not voting for one of the major parties yet the obscure party gives it's preferences to one of the major parties.

Their are some seats which are 'swinging' and may change but the majority of seats have been the same for decades.

Is it any different in the USA - does the campaigning work - do you vote on the person or the policies???

by itgirli

In the area in which I'm currently residing, you don't go to vote unless you have a candidate in mind. We are born or brought up to believe in certain ideas. We then choose the candidate that supports what we believe in those ideas. Most people figure out rather early on what side of the fence they are on. Then you just pick that side's candidate. If anyone doesn't really care all that much about it either way, they are not likely going to go and stand in line so that they can be counted. It all ends up in the electoral college anyway.

by sleepin'dawg

Every now and then a politician with a certain panache will come along and cause people to forget their traditional loyalties but unfortunately not very often. Most tend to vote the way their parents voted and it takes generations to change such ingrained attitudes.

by admin

Oddly, My vote doesn't really count as to who will win the Presidential election due to the Electoral College, although I believe it is very important that I vote because it does have influence.

Voting is not compulsary here and turn-out in my state is high for the U.S.- about 70 %

Here is the totals for all states:

http://www.fec.gov/pages/2000turnout/reg&to00.htm

When I vote for a non-major party, even though their preference has been traditionally Republican, the Republicans will get no credit for that vote. However, they will already have won my state and it is not a "swing" state so voting for them will change nothing and in fact detract from their consideration of implementing change. This is because if you vote for them it affirms their present course of moving towards the other party.

Those that vote for the Democrat, although they do not win, they have influence on the Republican party historically as the Republican party is becoming more like the Democratic party wherever it can to ensure that it maintains its majority in the state. You can definately see this at the primary election level, where the party moves towards it's opponent in an attempt to capture those not secure in a party vote by offering a more similar candidate to the other party rather than a less similar one. Of course, this weakens party ideology over time in a two party system.

By voting non-major party I am attempting to move the major parties towards a return to the roots of American government which has been, and is being sorely weakened and broken down in the two party process in my opinion. Actually, Libertarians have been traditionally more influential to the Republicans, but in this election they are actually drawing traditional Demcrats and the Democratic party is watching too. The Libertarian party is the 3rd largest party in America.

On a more local level I will vote for a person more than a party, but in my State my Presidential vote in the Electoral College has been, for all practical purposes, already decided, so instead I try to have the most influence possible in the Presidential election.

There are those that vote either on the person, the policies or both in combination here.

I hope that makes it more clear, but its not too clear of a system! Unfortunately, many Americans don't even understand or realize there is an Electoral College or what it does!

by black panther

Excuse my ignorance but what is this Electoral College - is it a database of voters similiar to our electoral roll?? or is it some type of Jerimander ( rigging of electoral bounderies to favour a certain party! )

by black panther

It's the same here - we actually have our own Federal election here on October 9th -- Voting is compulsory otherwise you are fined.

Most Voters will vote for the Party they have voted for all of their life and there parents voted for without question.

The 2 major parties are Liberal and Labor ( compared to your Republican's and Democrats (( I think? )

There is a percentage of voters that actually decide on who wins the election the swing voters.

What do we actually know really about these parties anyway - mostly the media runs our countries because they usually are the only way we hear about the parties and they decide what we hear!!

by admin

Here is a good general description of the process from:

http://www.fec.gov/pages/ecworks.htm

How the Electoral College Works
The current workings of the Electoral College are the result of both design and experience. As it now operates:

Each State is allocated a number of Electors equal to the number of its U.S. Senators (always 2) plus the number of its U.S. Representatives (which may change each decade according to the size of each State's population as determined in the Census).
The political parties (or independent candidates) in each State submit to the State's chief election official a list of individuals pledged to their candidate for president and equal in number to the State's electoral vote. Usually, the major political parties select these individuals either in their State party conventions or through appointment by their State party leaders while third parties and independent candidates merely designate theirs.
Members of Congress and employees of the federal government are prohibited from serving as an Elector in order to maintain the balance between the legislative and executive branches of the federal government.
After their caucuses and primaries, the major parties nominate their candidates for president and vice president in their national conventions
traditionally held in the summer preceding the election. (Third parties and independent candidates follow different procedures according to the individual State laws). The names of the duly nominated candidates are then officially submitted to each State's chief election official so that they might appear on the general election ballot.

On the Tuesday following the first Monday of November in years divisible by four, the people in each State cast their ballots for the party slate of Electors representing their choice for president and vice president (although as a matter of practice, general election ballots normally say "Electors for" each set of candidates rather than list the individual Electors on each slate).
Whichever party slate wins the most popular votes in the State becomes that State's Electors-so that, in effect, whichever presidential ticket gets the most popular votes in a State wins all the Electors of that State. [The two exceptions to this are Maine and Nebraska where two Electors are chosen by statewide popular vote and the remainder by the popular vote within each Congressional district].
On the Monday following the second Wednesday of December (as established in federal law) each State's Electors meet in their respective State capitals and cast their electoral votes-one for president and one for vice president.
In order to prevent Electors from voting only for "favorite sons" of their home State, at least one of their votes must be for a person from outside their State (though this is seldom a problem since the parties have consistently nominated presidential and vice presidential candidates from different States).
The electoral votes are then sealed and transmitted from each State to the President of the Senate who, on the following January 6, opens and reads them before both houses of the Congress.
The candidate for president with the most electoral votes, provided that it is an absolute majority (one over half of the total), is declared president. Similarly, the vice presidential candidate with the absolute majority of electoral votes is declared vice president.
In the event no one obtains an absolute majority of electoral votes for president, the U.S. House of Representatives (as the chamber closest to the people) selects the president from among the top three contenders with each State casting only one vote and an absolute majority of the States being required to elect. Similarly, if no one obtains an absolute majority for vice president, then the U.S. Senate makes the selection from among the top two contenders for that office.
At noon on January 20, the duly elected president and vice president are sworn into office.

Occasionally questions arise about what would happen if the pesidential or vice presidential candidate died at some point in this process.

by black panther

How do you know that the Elector you vote for will actually end up voting for the person he/she wants as president ie party.. ie are they in anyway bound..

by olprof67

There are a number of instances in which one or two electors have changed their votes, but this was usually for a candidate within their party, but closer to their personal ideology. The actual electors are always "party regulars" who can be counted on not to defect to the opposition.

One of the more memorable instances was in 1960, when Alabama Democrats ran an "unpledged" slate of electors to vent their opposition to Sen. Kennedy's Catholicism.

by admin

hehe I certainly have thought about these sorts of things. Oddly enough, people from OUTSIDE the U.S. seem to ask about this more frequently, so here is the word from the U.S. Embassy in Mexico:

http://www.usembassy-mexico.gov/ecollege.htm

There is no Constitutional provision or federal law that requires Electors to vote according to the results of the popular vote in their states. Some states (24 plus D.C. at last count) require Electors to cast their votes according to the popular vote. These pledges fall into two categories -- Electors bound by state law and those bound by pledges to political parties.

The Supreme Court has held that the Constitution does not require that Electors be completely free to act as they choose and therefore, political parties may extract pledges from Electors to vote for the parties' nominees. Some state laws provide that so-called "faithless electors" may be subject to fines or may be disqualified for casting an invalid vote and be replaced by a substitute Elector. The Supreme Court has not specifically ruled on the question of whether pledges and penalties for failure to vote as pledged may be enforced under the Constitution. No Elector has ever been prosecuted for failing to vote as pledged.

Today, it is rare for Electors to disregard the popular vote by casting their electoral vote for someone other than their party's candidate. Electors generally hold a leadership position in their party or were chosen to recognize years of loyal service to the party. Throughout our history as a nation, more than 99 percent of Electors have voted as pledged.

by black panther

Why have the 2 votes? ie you vote for the electoral candidate who %99.99 of the time you know which president they will vote for.

Then they have to vote again for the president you already know they will vote for.

Seems a waste of taxpayer's money.

Why not have the 1 vote on the day??

by admin

I think the question is: Why not have a popular vote instead of an Electoral College?

Well, there have more attempts to make amendments to our constitution on this issue than any other, I believe. There are MANY reasons for and against changing it. Different interests would be better off with one or the other, but the real reason to me is that the Electoral College in fact does come straight from our constitution and is difficult to change without broad support. The powers that be are probably better off with it this way, so it will remain a long time.

In some ways, it is also more fair to the Southern States, although this came from a time when they were worried that slavery would be abolished by the Northern States which they felt would be disastrous to their economy.

Most of the uproar about the last election was due to the popular misconception by Americans that their persoanl vote counts directly for who becomes President. Individual votes do not count for Presidential or Vice-Presidential election in the U.S.

Obviously when over half of the states do not require electors to vote for the state's popular vote winner, and the remainder that do require it are threatened because their laws will be overturned at the Supreme Court level as unconstitutional then we could basically have at any time a simple elected coup where a handful of (well 270) people are paid off or otherwise conviced to throw their votes someday. This coupled with a possible National State of Emergency right afterwards makes our process quite dangerous actually. So in light of this why don't we change it?

Well, for one, most people in the U.S. don't understand it. That's why the ones that voted for Gore were so mad. They thought their vote counted in a different way that in their constitution says it does. On the other hand, the majority of people who understand it don't want it to change. It makes it much harder to get a strong third party in the system for one, since the actual electors are from one or the other. At any rate, although I am sure there will be another flood of proposed amendments, it won't be changing anytime soon, so it's up to us U.S. voters to learn how our system works and maximize our votes within the system we have.

by olprof67

As evidenced by the viciousness of the current campaign, the votes of those who live from beer to beer are more easily manipulated than the votes of those who plan from year to year.

Incidentally, Richard Nixon won the 1960 popular vote, so Gore's experience is not unique.

However, had Nixon ascended to the Presidency in pre-Goldwater days, it's unlikely that the events which led to the rise of Ronald Reagan would have transpired.

by black panther

In America what is a percentage estimate of the voters who make up the 'beer to beer' compared to the 'year to year'.

by admin

I'll remember that one- it's a good one :)

I do find it surprising though how many well thought persons will follow every detail of the candidates and are quite up on this level of political knowledge and yet are quite indifferent or have little or no knowledge of the electoral process and how it really affects them. As you said below, one undecided voter makes more difference than 5 party loyalists especially if they happen to live in certain states. Nixons 1960 experience is a classic.

One thing I thought somewhat sad in the last election was how many of those "beer to beer" voters were happy to trade their votes for the possibility of receiving $500 of their own money in what was more a furniture store marketing scheme than politics in my mind. I don't fault the people who did it though, it seemed to work, at least in my area, quite well to garner additional support.

It wouldn't of made a difference, but those on the edge either way definately seemed happy to vote for someone who would send them a check, albeit of their own money.

by onbliss

I know not many people, in the world, really know their country's election process and how the voting goes on.

But should'nt we keep it simple and straightforward for the masses so that, both in theory and practice, the person whom they want to be the President becomes, rather than delegating their choice to the Electoral College and then hoping for the Electors to vote. As someone said it seems not many people understand the Electoral College.

by admin

What if the masses decide they want to elect a President who's campaign pledge is to become a wonderfully helpful Dictator because the masses are weary of the slow change required in the Constitution? Should they be able to vote in a Dictator? Similar things have happened in countries that have a popular vote, and all too often at that.

I would rather they did not have this power- that on a whim or after a bad event they lose their heads and then put up guillotenes so they can watch others literally lose theirs after electing a President who promises to do this for the people to avenge something or other or bring about some temporary fad in social order.

James Madison in Federalist Paper No. 10 makes a pretty clear statement that a Republic is much superior to a pure Democracy: "Measures are too often decided, not according to the rules of justice and the rights of the minor party, but by the superior force of an interested and overbearing majority." We have checks and balances to prevent this in our system like the 3 branches- Judicial, Executive and Legislative. We also have our Constitution and Bill of Rights to stop the masses from tyrannical rule over minorities. Add to checks and balances the Electoral College. It protects us from getting really stupid by popular vote directly after, say, a 911 or something even worse. Of course it also protects us from getting too stupid by basing our votes entirely on the supermarket checkout stands, CBS or Fox news. In the event something goes quite awry, the electoral college protects us, at least for a little while.

:>

by olprof67

I don't doubt that the majority of the voters do go to the polls in the belief that their participation is worthwhile. But most of us who do take an interest in politics tend to favor one party unless a particular candidate, or referendum issue, evokes a very strong image, either positive or negative.

There is however, a modest-sized bloc of voters who remain essentially non-political unless aroused by a particular issue, or who have not made up their minds, but can be relatively easily swayed by an emotional appeal, Hence the current flap over the candidates' service during the Vietnam era.

Remember, from a dynamic point of view, one convert from the other side has more impact than five party loyalists.

Hence, my original point; that a rash or tasteless act by the populist wing of either coalition could have a last-minute impact upon the outcome of the election.

by itgirli

Check out SchoolHouse Rock. The newest special anniversary issue has a brand new song about the electoral college. quite informative really, but I think that of all SchoolHouse Rock.

darn. that's the end.

by admin

I love Schoolhouse Rock!

I swear I learned all basic Grammer Concepts there. :)

by olprof67

To me, it means the crowd at professional wrestling matches and monster-truck rallies.

It means the people whose idea of news is found at supermarket checkout counters.

It means the people who can't tell science fiction from hard science.

It means the people who would eat the seed corn.

A modest-sized portion of the electorate sometimes reverts to extreme short-sight; the fate of school-bond referenda in small blue-collar communites is one of the best examples.

And unfortunately, both major parties have sunken to some new lows in recruiting among this group in recent years.

Personally, this writer believes that the vast majority of those on this fringe of society can be sufficently enlightened. Service in the military or groups such as the Peace Corps would be one route.

So would a requirement of completion of a basic course in citizenship. We require education of drivers and hunters....why not voters?

The thrust of this argument is that people should be taught to enter the voting booth with more concern over what they have to lose than what they might think they have to gain.

by onbliss

can it also mean as people who are easily swayed by emotions, rhetoric, empty promises; and people who are only interested where the next dollar comes from and not what's gonna happen to their retirement....is that kinda deal?

by olprof67

But my original point, and still my main point, is that a late-season incident invloving the "gut reaction" component of either coalition could be the deciding factor in what has become the most vicious campaign in my memory.

As a case in point, it's been argued that in 2002, the Democrats lost the Minnesota seat held by the late Senator Wellstone because the Senator's memorial service (after his sudden death in a plane crash) turned into a somewhat-too-smug glorification of his long allegiance to the DFL (Democratic Farmer-Labor) machine which dominates Minnesota Democratic politics, which in turn provoked a reaction from more independent-minded voters.

by admin

I am beginning to wonder if anyone else watched Schoolhouse Rock, perhaps they should be running it as a public service on the non-cartoon prime-time stations! :)

by montgomery gator

What motivates dead voters? It has been said that dead people in Illinois and Texas made the difference to elect Kennedy instead of Nixon. For some reason, the Democrats have been much better at getting dead people to vote for them (including here in Alabama, particularly in some counties to the west of Montgomery). They have been able to even get people who voted Republican while alive to vote Democrat once they died.

by onbliss

...that the electoral college can not vote on its whims and fancies? They could elect a dictator too, right?

And, don't get me wrong if my questions seem to be polairsed. I understand all systems have their merits and demerits.

Curious George :-)

by admin

There is actually this theory going around right now that a certain Country is buying off the U.S. Electorate to do just that at some point in the future.

An Electoral College President elected broadly aginst the will of the people would probably not stand unless the military was also involved and would not refuse Executive orders at some point. This was probably not as much of a problem to our countries framers, who would not expect an Electoral College Coup in conjunction with the Military as they relied on individual militias joining together.

There are dangers both ways, but the popular vote is less likely to make mistakes on whims and fancies as a benefit of the Electoral College process and the Electorates would face tremendous public uproar if they vote on their personalwhims and fancies. It's a gamble, but less of one when there are checks and balances such as this IMO. I would not really want any one group in possesion of absolute power in our government, and the Executive branch possesses the power to become absolute under certain situations unlike the Judicial or Legislative. I think due diligence and prudence in arranging checks and balances in this is of some benefit. I could go for a different system, but would want more distribution of power- not less.

That's just my opinion though :>

by montgomery gator

I cannot recite the Preamble to the US Constitution without singing it, because of Schoolhouse Rock. Then again, I could not recite it at all if it was not for Schoolhouse Rock.

(I also liked the Interjections Schoolhouse Rock, except I substituted my own interjctions to make it a little more "saltier", so to speak (certain 4 letter words, which were fun for a 8 year old to shout, because they were naughty).

This discussion is closed to new replies.