America's success a result of Biblical basis of constitution
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
IT Employment
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
"Each of your quotes is from one or another of men, whose knowledge is incomplete and limited."
One could say the same of quotations from the Bible.
by jardinier
Does anyone agree or disagree that America has been a particularly successful nation?
This will help you make a comparison with other countries:
http://www.scaruffi.com/politics/gnp.html
We see that per capita of GNP, only Switzerland is ahead of the USA, with Japan on an equal footing.
The question then is, in relation to the video interview, has the Bible (extracts therefrom) been a factor in America's success?
If the answer is NO, then the interviewee, David Barton, is full of it. If the answer is YES or PERHAPS, then maybe he is worth listening to.
Well at least you are all having a jolly time with this discussion. :)
I do not feel the need to address every individual post that is directed at me, and I especially avoid all the repartee which is not related to the topic.
As you have probably gathered I have, for more than two years now, posted at meetchristians.com
Is it because I am interested in discussing Christianity? No. It is because the posts remain on topic and apart from some pretty heavy flaming, there is NO time spent on personal chit-chat. There is a special forum for this: General, which occasionally discusses a serious topic such as this.
But in Theological where I normally post, the discussions remain on topic.
I therefore consider my time spent more usefully there than getting involved in all the off-topic chit-chat that constitutes the major portion of so many discussions here at techrepublic.
Sorry if I sound supercilious, but that's the way it is for me. I posted solidly to TR for quite a few years. Maybe I just needed a change of pace, or a different flavour. ]:)
Although many of the folk at meetchristians are quite wacky with their religious beliefs, when it comes to American politics they are sharp as a tack.
The off-topic wanderings and personal chit-chat are part of what some of us like about the forums here. A discussion is free to proceed in any direction, and the personal comments help give us some insight to each other's personalities and interests.
Some forums are more accepting of posting potentially controversial content with neither the poster's opinion nor timely replies from him or her. Here it's considered trolling or 'seagull posting'.
I'm not saying either system is better, just different. Some enjoy one style more than the other, some don't care either way.
by jardinier
which gives useful background to the topic under discussion.
http://www.scaruffi.com/politics/american.html
by delbertpgh
What has made America the wide-open success story that it's been for the last 200 years is its complete buy-in on the modern project, i.e. enlightenment values. No matter how earnestly (and often foolishly) Americans do their belief thing, they think religion has no place in economy, and minimal place in government. They trust completely in progress, it seems, sometimes with resignation, but always in the faith that somehow things get better with change.
The American doctrine leads to unrestricted change, driven by business opportunity and all individuals' passion to seek riches and happiness. Americans have always had an uncommon ability to turn their backs on the past. They also trust that the guy who makes money and wins opportunity for himself deserves justice, and that no system of justice is proper if it doesn't allow the natural winners to float to the top. It's rather unusual to find this much generosity to the most fortunate the creed of the common people, but that's how it is in the U.S.A. It prevents religionists from getting much sway in social direction, and prevents government from holding down the achievers. It rejects morality tales made into social policy.
by tig2
How would you know? Are you an American? Do you have a basis for that belief that goes beyond what you have read in popular journalism in Australia or gleaned from unvetted sources on the Internet?
That you are capable of shoveling a brand of manure that people will respond to is unquestioned. Your conclusions are regrettably from the same pile.
says I, sitting back with a pint and an appreciative patter of applause.
:D
Don't forget that I'm English and a Cricket fan so an appreciative clap of the hands is equivalent to one of you Yanks shouting Woo! Woo! at the top of your lungs...
by oz_media
I have always learned that SUCCESS is the prograssive realization of a worthwihle dream.
From what I can see, the American dream is being shattered on a regular basis, especially over the last 5 years or so.
by jardinier
The leadership obviously changes, but the institution continues to grow and strengthen until its survival becomes an end in itself.
The largest body of Christianity, the Roman Catholic Church, would be one obvious example in which the institution outlives any particular leader (Pope) while continuing to grow in power and to hell with the Biblical teachings on which it was initially based.
by boxfiddler Hot topic
from it's inception broke/altered/manipulated Christian Scripture/Christ's Words to suit its own ends.
Nothing much new about that when it comes to religion and scripture, though.
by jardinier
I quite agree Neil -- wild and unsupported generalisations.
By "everywhere" I would say he was referring to Third World countries where you can live on 1 $ a day and there are frequent revolutions.
Because as I am sure you all know I have a personal interest in Third World countries, I did not blink or flinch when he said these things because in a particular context they are true.
Incidentally as I am sure you know, the $US is the universally accepted currency in poorer countries. That is to say that, while they have their indigenous currencies, they think and speak in $US both amongst themselves and to foreigners. America is (for now) the largest economic power in the world and the largest military power. The "American Dream" is what people in poor coutries would hope to aspire to. It is, for better or for worse, viewed as the epitome of material (worldly) success.
I cannot see that highly praising (worshipping) John Locke and using his theories constitutes claiming ownership.
Whether or not Jesus existed has no bearing on the validity, value or otherwise of the teachings attributed to him. Truth is truth, whoever speaks it.
As a matter of fact I am assured by our friend Gret that "everything" (poetic licence) said by Jesus had already been said in the Old Testament (Tanach).
We can only go on what the speaker said and not what we think that he might have meant.
In this case we have two statements. Firstly the comment about "poverty level" which [b]could[/b] be open to some sort of slightly forgiving interpretation and then his very similar comment about "revolution every 22 years on average everywhere except the US" which is SUCH a load of crap and NOT open to anything other than ridicule. Given that the second comment was an outright lie or, at best, consummate ignorance, why should we be generous with the first statement?
With regards to John Locke, we are informed that he "trained for the ministry" and it was hinted or blatantly stated throughout that Locke's ideas came from the Bible. Locke attended Christ Church, Oxford (the top University of the time) and would have had the standard education there which centred around philosophy and classics. Not theology. Locke's training led him to become a Lecturer in Greek at Christ Church and then Lecturer in Rhetoric. I have no problem with them praising John Locke, he was a pretty amazing guy, but they wanted to hijack Locke for their own cause.
The success of the whole piece was predicated on the ignorance and prejudice of their audience. Shame on you for posting it here. Do you think so little of us that you reckon any of us would fall for anything this shallow?
Neil
by jdclyde
[i]""American Dream" is what people in poor coutries would hope to aspire to. It is, for better or for worse, viewed as the epitome of material (worldly) success."[/i]
He is still convinced no one wants to come to the US and everyone hates us.
Some people have rose colored glasses, his are sh|t colored. :D
by oz_media
He is talking of 'poorer countries" and "the American dream".
This does not mean they want to move to America per se, but want to seek the dream of freedom and being able to do what you want to do, which is true in many free and prosperous nations however attributed to being 'The American dream'.
It's a common FACT (meaning the rest of the world knows it and America refuses to see it) that more people seek to move to Australia, Canada and even the UK than America. America's largest immigration rate was betweeon 1815-1875 after the napleonic wars.
Foreign population inflow:
http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/imm_for_pop_inf-immigration-foreign-population-inflow
Germany tops the list, Japan second in fact the USA doesn't come up in many similar categories at all, with the obvious exception of total number of world imigrants as the US is 10X and greater in population and has far more developed land than anyone else, that others and allows a greater number entry each year.
This doesn't mean everyone wants to move to America, in fact I have yet to visit anywhere and hear ANYONE say they'd rather live in the USA, it is usually the asolute opposite. I know plenty of Americans that are begging to get the hell out though.
Of course, you'll believe whatever you choose to believe, your delusions always run rampant here in your constant, insecure defense of all that is American, whether right ro wrong, good or bad.
by jardinier
Which is probably a lot less time than you spend playing word games in this and other discussions.
But maybe the time was more fruitful than you might think.
[b][i]Mark 4:3-8 [/b] Hearken; Behold, there went out a sower to sow:
And it came to pass, as he sowed, some fell by the way side, and the fowls of the air came and devoured it up.
And some fell on stony ground, where it had not much earth; and immediately it sprang up, because it had no depth of earth:
But when the sun was up, it was scorched; and because it had no root, it withered away.
And some fell among thorns, and the thorns grew up, and choked it, and it yielded no fruit.
And other fell on good ground, and did yield fruit that sprang up and increased; and brought forth, some thirty, and some sixty, and some an hundred.[/i]
Who knows if a seed might have fallen on fertile ground in your unbelieving mind? :)
You don't have a clue, do you?
by jardinier
has been found and it is an ongoing process.
It is to make many women happy rather than make one woman unhappy. :)
by delbertpgh
by jdclyde
since nothing makes a woman happier than to see a man miserable? ;\
The proof, just wait until you are content watching your sport of choice, and THAT is when the trash HAS to go out. :D
by boxfiddler Hot topic
you didn't take it out this morning, and the trashman came, and outside bin is full, and the kitchen bin is too. X-(
:D :D :D
by jdclyde
by jdclyde
that the one single cell organism would/could evolve into every animal we see, warm or cold blooded, mammal or otherwise, yet not have ALL still share a basic DNA with only additions for each adaptation?
Talk about life on mars or in space, what again are the odds of all the ransom sequences required to create life?
Now that is faith. :D
I could explain but I'd need your undivided attention for a couple of weeks or so. We'd have to give you a bit of a grounding in biochemistry and then get into genetics.
I'm game...
:)
by jdclyde
sorry, but if there isn't a car chase or two, I would probably fall asleep in class, for now. :D
bad enough I am suppose to be paying attention to a webinar.....
What are the odds that a single undetectable non-corporeal entity would / could create not just that single celled organism but all other organisms, and create them whole and fitted to their ecological niches without the use of that cell as an evolutionary starting point?
Why credit an unprovable creator and unknowable methods, when random creation removes an unnecessary layer from the hypothesis?
Why is the non-creation of this eternal, omnipotent, unproven, entity easier to believe than the random creation of a simple organism?
Faith? I have substantially less than most people.
by jdclyde
could a hundred monkeys really randomly write Shakespeare?
Not seeking to beat you or anyone else up for your choice, just putting out other ideas. Either way, requires a leap of faith, we all have to decide which direction is the best to leap in, for ourselves.
Look out below. :D
I've got him thinking about topless cheerleaders...
:)
by tonythetiger
[i]Why credit an unprovable creator and unknowable methods, when random creation removes an unnecessary layer from the hypothesis?
[/i]
that the layer is unnecessary? Sometimes the "reasons" aren't apparent to an observer. Doesn't mean there aren't any.
Smacks of "If I don't understand it, it must not exist." to me.
by tig2
Of course we are all mad. Mad as hatters. Those of us with any sense know this and are over it.
I'm a Christian. Julian offends me virtually every time he sticks his head into this wonderfully diverse space. Mostly because he has no interest in engaging people in interesting debate, but instead hammers on them with stupidly superficial discussions of nothing much. At least, in my opinion.
I'll try and demonstrate Mendel's pea experiments using cheerleaders instead of peas and topless cheerleaders to demonstrate the recessive genes. Because we have to "mate" the different pea strains to get the experiment to the second generation cross, we'll have plenty of girl-on-girl action to keep you awake.
Neil :)
Oh, the trials that I have endure for the furtherance of the understanding of science.
My real problem with Julian is just how insulting he is and whether that is due to stupidity (my best guess) or malice, I don't truly care.
POST SOMETHING INTELLIGENT. PUT SOME THOUGHT INTO IT.
And, you know, we all might join in happily.
:)
I've changed the subject up aways to topless cheerleaders. Sorry about the sexism but I can't think of any other way that I could hold JD's attention for a genetics class.
But to replicate Mendel's peas, you're going to need someone to pollinate your cheerleaders. I'm more than willing to assist with any demonstrations.
Mmmmh; cheerleaders.
To carry out Mendel's experiment we need two generations. Keeping it legal means at least 32 years over here and varies between 14 years in some Muslim states and a couple of US states up to 36 years so we would have to fake pollinations and growth.
Anyway, who's directing this scientific demonstration? I could find a job for you in, say, wardrobe...
Of course not. That requires the monkeys to produce a specific end product, and it's foolish to expect random chance to have a particular outcome. Chance (and evolution) are processes incapable of producing mandated results. We can make some statistical predictions, but the most basic stats class acknowledges the possibility of the unpredictable.
That's what's wrong with the position some offer, that the Earth must have been created for our type of life because it is such a hospitable environment, that a few miles closer to or farther from the sun and we wouldn't be able to live here. Those people have it backwards; we evolved to fit our environment, and if the Earth was in a slightly different orbit then organic life would have evolved to fit the different conditions.
You're keeping all the good research for yourself.
And what kind of wardrobe do TOPLESS cheerleaders need? Geez, half the job gone, and that's the half with the different logos and emblems. What's the appeal in managing a bunch of pleated skirts?
None of them probably fit me anyway.
by maecuff
And, it would seem, Palmetto.
:D
ALL of the second generation is fully clothed. I'm not just doing this for the t:ts you know, this is PROPER science for JD.
by maecuff
by maecuff
Erotic Fiction..
I have a friend who I had lost contact with over the years. I had always thought of her as the uptight, prudish type.
Anyway, we reconnected recently and I learned that she has 15 erotica books published. I picked one up at the bookstore and couldn't read more than a few pages. Guess it turns out I am the uptight, prudish one. That, or I don't want to know that my friend thinks of, well, things I don't want to think about her thinking about.
That made sense in my head..in case you were wondering.
by jdclyde
by tonythetiger
[i]What's the world coming to?[/i]
an end... if the rest don't capitulate.
by shellbot
doing that..
how genteel :)
by nicknielsen
by shellbot
by tonythetiger
each in our own way seeks it. Over ourselves, or if that fails, over others.
One of my early significant memories was that of the barber forcing my head where he wanted it... Of course I know now that's not what he was doing, but, well, the fact that I find it significant, is itself significant :)
by boxfiddler Hot topic
by boxfiddler Hot topic
by nicknielsen
My sister-in-law visited last summer; she was the announcer/moderator/presenter for a romantic fiction conference. She brought a sample pack of books to us.
One of them was from a series of erotic romance and I read a chapter or two. All I can say is next to this one, Fanny Hill and Tom Jones are Dr Seuss books.
"How did you determine that the layer is unnecessary?"
determine that it is? I used Occam's Razor. Quoting from Wikipedia, "When competing hypotheses are equal in other respects, the principle recommends selection of the hypothesis that introduces the fewest assumptions and postulates the fewest entities while still sufficiently answering the question." Given a choice between an unknown method of creation, or an unknown method wielded by an unknown creator, why suppose an unprovable entity was involved?
(I was surprised to find such a well-worded explanation of a logical principle on Wikipedia. Perhaps there is more there than pop culture references. I may have to reconsider it.)
"Sometimes the "reasons" aren't apparent to an observer."
What is there to observe? Isn't this supposed creator unobservable? To an observer, how does an unapparent, unprovable reason differ from random chance?
Exclamations change. Why did the 'fist bump' replace the 'high five'?
On the other hand, 'Cool!' has been cool for several decades now. 'Wicked' has tried to replace it, but I don't see it happening; too many syllables.
by tonythetiger
[i]determine that it is? I used Occam's Razor.[/i]
Why should you believe it is correct to do so?
Say it snowed at my house last night. Say I then walked around the house three times, on the second and third trip stepping in the tracks I left on the first time around.
Looking at the tracks and using Occam's Razor, one might use the "simplest explanation" that I walked around the house once.
[i]Isn't this supposed creator unobservable?[/i]
I don't know. Are black holes unobservable? Dark matter?
[i]To an observer, how does an unapparent, unprovable reason differ from random chance? [/i]
I suppose the same way one trip around the house in the snow differs from three :)
"Say it snowed at my house last night. Say I then walked around the house three times, on the second and third trip stepping in the tracks I left on the first time around. Looking at the tracks and using Occam's Razor, one might use the "simplest explanation" that I walked around the house once."
Exactly! Lacking any other evidence, I'm concluding you walked around the house once. I have no reason to assume you made multiple trips, and your multiple trips made no apparent difference.
But if I ask you, you can correct my incorrect assumptions. Your walking method can be demonstrated and reliably reproduced. I can observe you and potentially see you doing it again. I can walk around once myself and measure how much the snow packs, and compare it with the more densely packed tracks you made.
Oh, and it's not that it can't exist because I don't understand it. It's that the entire concept is DEFINED around the core premise of being unexplainable, unprovable, requiring unjustified faith in the unprovable.
The effects of black holes have been demonstrated. While they are not observable in the visible spectrum, their effects are observable in other portions of the electromagnetic spectrum. Material can be seen vanishing into them. Last time I checked, 'dark matter' was still a viable but unproven theory, existing only with mathematically demonstrations.
I misread your sentence:
"Oh, and it's not that it can't exist because I don't understand it."
I read "I" instead of the first "it".
I like that better.
Pretty damn close.
:8}
by tonythetiger
[i]But if I ask you, you can correct my incorrect assumptions.[/i]
If I don't, does that make your assumption correct?
[i]Oh, and it's not that it can't exist because I don't understand it. It's that the entire concept is DEFINED around the core premise of being unexplainable, unprovable, requiring unjustified faith in the unprovable.[/i]
I can't speak for all, but I personally don't believe that. I believe that there are things that I don't know... YET!
[i]their effects are observable in other portions of the electromagnetic spectrum.[/i]
Some would say that the entire universe is the "observable effect" of the existence of a creator :)
by tonythetiger
[i]read "I" instead of the first "it".
I like that better. [/i]
Maybe it will give me an alibi someday.
by notsochiguy
Ingenuity.
Sure, everyone knows about big successes, like the nuke and the space program, but I'd say it is the littler things that make the most difference. Take this for example:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eQ79pCJBcJ8
Saves time and is good for a laugh (laughter has been proven to be medically beneficial); what more can you ask of in a product?
;)
EDIT: If you play the clip, you may want to turn the volume down. There isn't anything bad , but the wording is 'interesting'.
by oz_media
By such a statement I can only assume that you elieve AmeriCANS invented the atomic bomb. LOL :D
As shown by your YouTue clip, Americans invent nothing and provide nothing.
America is a global resource for the US dollar, end of.
by notsochiguy
"everyone knows about big successes"
Success does not equal invent, to the best of my knowledge.
MSFT did not invent the graphical OS, but only a fool would suggest they weren't hugely successful (financially) with it.
As for the general assessment of American inventors, it takes more than that bait to get me going.
Nice try, though!
:p
by shellbot
needs a Wunder B0ner..
ROFL.. oh the things i could say.... ]:)
that is awesome!!!!!!
by dhcdbd
I would say that the real reason behind America's success is the fact that after WWII we had the only intact manufacturing base in the world.
Now that the world has caught up to the USA manufacturing base and surpassed it for a number of reasons, such as out sourcing, look at where we are going. Can we say down?
I do not buy the ingenuity excuse. Ingenuity, like creativity, are functions of population [{edit} and manufacturing] base. Many cultures and countries have a greater population base than the USA does and they have learned from this country to incorporate idea's from wherever they come from. China is ahead of the US in genetics, catching up and surpassing in electronics; India and Pakistan have a ways to go to play catch up, but they have not made the financial investment in buying manufacturing infrastructure that China has. Japan is well beyond the US in many areas because they invest in research. The US just does not invest and prefers to sell what they know - laziness and profit mongering.
by oz_media
I am with you for the most part, howver I feel that the US doesn't sell what it knows, it BUYS what others know. All inventions claimed as US inventions seem to be inventions from elsewhere and the US either bought a poorly finded patent or made ever so slight changes to existign inventions so they can patent it as their own.
As for India and Pakistan, they may not be manufacturing giants but the lead the world in biological and related sciences. People travel from around the globe to attend their universities due to the advanced curriculum.
Pakistan is actually a very modern and advanced nation, though I know the news hounds like to portray the dusty, downtrodden parts instead; is it to make us look superior and possibly have some pity no them or is it to display them as outdated and behind the times so we look better?
by nicknielsen
Used primarily to add emphasis or express the superlative. For example: wicked hot, wicked cool, wicked fast.
This usage is popular in the northeast of the United States, primarily northern New England and upstate New York
It's what DHCDBD mentioned in another thread: TTD, or, Test To Destruction.
In order for existential "it" to hold ("it is"), "I" must equally hold. If not -- i.e., you can't manage it -- nothing you or anyone here says about anything holds.
Test that to destruction, folks, all of you, before you go telling me laughingly how anything "is".
If you don't correct my false assumptions, it doesn't make them correct. I must remain cognizant I'm using the assumptions, treat them as working theories or models, and understand I have no proof. This is where many trip up when discussing evolution; it's an unproven theory, but from a scientific viewpoint it can be used as a starting point for further speculation. My assumption may fit the facts as I have them, and I may be able to draw other conclusions from them. If time does not prove my models and working theories wrong, and they work in a predictable, repeatable fashion, then from an application stand point it doesn't matter that my assumption is wrong; it still works as an explanation of how the footprints got there, and can be used to determine how other footprints appear.
I'm assuming you suggest a lack of confirmation, not a false confirmation or outright lying.
I believe there are things I don't know. I don't know how the universe was created. Without knowing a mechanism, I see no reason to search for a hypothetical wielder of it. I KNOW the universe was created by some occurence; it's here. I don't know if it was designed, so looking for a 'who' strikes me as less productive than a 'how'.
"Some would say that the entire universe is the 'observable effect' of the existence of a creator."
And some would not.
Modifying only the noun under discussion:
"Check out my new Alienware system!"
"Aw, man; that's wicked!"
I've also heard it used around here. Maybe there just aren't many wicked things at the grocery? :D
by oz_media
How can anyone possibly hang onto 'concepts' from the bible? Seriously? It's the most contradictory piece of poorly put together scripture known to mankind.
"Love thy neighbor as thyself"
"If thy brother, the son of thy mother, or thy son, or thy daughter, or the wife of thy bosom, or thy friend, which is as thine own soul, entice thee secretly, saying, Let us go and serve other gods, which thou hast not known, thou, nor thy fathers; Namely, of the gods of the people which are round about you ... Thou shalt not consent unto him, nor hearken unto him; neither shall thine eye pity him, neither shalt thou spare, neither shalt thou conceal him: But thou shalt surely kill him; thine hand shall be first upon him to put him to death, and afterwards the hand of all the people. [b]And thou shalt stone him with stones, that he die. -- "[/b]
[i]Be ye not unequally yoked together with unbelievers: [b]for what fellowship hath righteousness with unrighteousness?[/b] and what communion hath light with darkness? And what concord hath Christ with Belial? or what part hath he that believeth with an infidel? ... Wherefore come out from among them, and be ye separate, saith the Lord[/i]
Unequally toked together??
And yet you are amused by those who refer to specific passages of the bible, of course those who favour them.
Do you have anything against those who quote Bugs Bunny and the rest of the Warner Bros. Gang too? That would put me out for sure.
People hold on ot little snippets of teh bible that they feel guide them and simply ignore those that don't, that's why the bible works for some.
An interesting stat raised over the weekend, in Canada, during the 70's more than 70% of Canadians were attending a church (mainly Christian) weekly. Today that number is less than 17%! As MOST now suggest more of a spiritual faith.
In the USA, they still have a grand majority of over 80% that still strongly believe in Christianity today and base their lives on such faith, as well as regular church attendance.
Now look at America's negative impact on teh globe and how they are seen as just 'not with the program', how they still use religious faith to determine right and wrong politically, how the basis of law in teh USA is still to this day built upon religious preferences, and yet how teh entire time they profess to be a multicultural country tha teveryone seeks to move to, ignoring that Canada, the UK and Australia are a greater desired destination for immigrants than the USA.
Why even bother, Julian? You may by typing on a similar keyoard but you sure as hell aren't speaking the same language.
Americans will justify anything they do with anything they want to justify it. In other words, they are just making it all up as they go and have no core reasons to explain any of their actions towards others.
They parrot poorly translated verses from 66 books written and edited over centuries into a single tome of gospel to justify blatant ignorance. Just the concept illustrates that without a need for parroting the verses though.
by shellbot
And there was no pint involved either was there..it was sherry!!!
i am sooooo onto you Neil!!
]:)
by oz_media
Just a little reality thrown into the thread.
Ingenuity? Your reference for the successes of America.
So, with ingenuity being a successful application of ideas, you think that
Hiroshima and Nagasaki was using America's ingenuity? As if it was some form of success?
What's ingenious about dropping a bomb and wiping out over 200,000 people, especially after bombing them unsuccessfully for the 6 months prior? It's like Hitler's battle of Britain, he did the same during the blitz, but then he realized he was beaten and headed for Russia instead.
WOULD he have used a nuke if he had one? Probably, but that doesn't say much to excuse yourselves, does it? When your boming campaign was met with equal resistance to give up, you dropped an Atom bomb developed by a team of scientists from around the world.
That's neither ingenious nor successful.
The space program was successful "ingenuity"?
Russia beat the USA to MOST of the landmark accomplishemnts. First orbit, first human spaceflight, first spacewalk, first automatic landing on another celestial body and even the launch of the first space station. You guys just had to have one becuase Russia had one.
Plenty of US ingenuity and success there.
Perhaps the US leads in most money pi$$ed away on a space program? And I actually supported the space program, despite the shortcomings.
No matter how many Americans feel America runs the world and leads the way, reality is you are the world's infant and everyone seems to know it except Americans, or if you actually do know, you are not admitting to reality.
Ingenuity...success, LOL, you need to buy a new dictionary.
by oz_media
Sorry but I posted directly underneath teh person I was replying to and addressed his comments specifically. As for yoruself, I see no comments in this segue of the thread, thus you just popped your head in to someone else's sideline for the purpose of...what?
Oh right, the purpose of having something to say about someone else's comments, very well done.
by notsochiguy
...yes, Hiroshima was a success.
Would the Allies have forced a Japanese surrender eventually---yes.
Would it have cost many more Allied lives to do so---undoubtedly.
While the loss of life (civilians in particular) is regretful, it was the loss from an enemy nation, and not one of an Allied ones. Given the choice, it's the former every time. There's something to be said about not having a foreign attack on domestic soil for 60 years; and that only the result of people with a twisted view of their own religion.
Not to speak of any of the scientific breakthroughs that were the result of the atomic program, or that the arms race helped accelerate the decline of the Soviet bloc.
As for the space program, given that you're on a technical forum, I'd find the insinuation that it wasn't successful (satellites didn't wish their way into orbit) comical, to say the least.
Finally, in terms of ingenuity:
"skill or cleverness in devising or combining"--from Merriams-Webster's Dictionary. Both the atomic program and the space program more than fit that.
If you want to say that other nations have demonstrated higher levels of creativity, ingenuity and inventiveness, by all means, share your thoughts and any supporting evidence/anecdotes.
If you want to say that the US is currently suffering from a lack of ingenuity, hence a lot of the problems we currently face, I think there may be some valid points to be made.
But to suggest that there has been a historical dearth of ingenuity in the US, that's just plain silly pettiness for the sake of an anti-US rant.
by jamesrl
From a technical perspective the US (with some help from Britain and Canada) did something that no other nation could have done at that time. The German effort failed, despite that country's scientific achievements. Britain could not have afforded that kind of effort. The Soviet Union was not advanced enough scientifically to do it on their own.
As for the use, there is some credible debate as to whether or not the second bomb was necessary. And I grieve for the loss of life, any life in war. But do not for a moment forget that an invasion would have cost BOTH Allied AND Japanese lives in large numbers, and it was looking like any kind of negotiated surrender wouldn't happen because the Japanese government refused to consider reducing the role of the Emperor. The bomb probably saved lives on both sides, in the final analysis.
The space program as well showed ingenuity. The Soviets, who had a lead in space technology and experience in space, could not make it to the moon.
James
by oz_media
"There's something to be said about not having a foreign attack on domestic soil for 60 years;"
Do you ACTUALLY buy that?? What, as a result of Hiroshima? A military nobody will f'with?
Try reality for once, wars are for acquisition, AMERICA HAS NOTHING ANYONE NEEDS BESIDES MONEY!
WHat are you going ot get invaded for oil? Fish? Minerals? Precious stones? Lumber? What? YOu have no resources that pthers demand or need, others supply YOU with what YOU need to exist though. Therefore the only thing any country needs from America is American dollars and greedy fat clowns ready to spend dollars to fill their desires.
You speak of the space program as if it was an example of American ingenuity and success you were sepaking of. I already said I fully support the space program, but if you think it's an American thing you are sadly mistaken. America's space program woul dhave fallen flat on it's arse if it wasn' tfor global contribution and teh ability of American dollars to buy foreign companies.
"Satellites do not wish their way into orbit." Nor does America launch most of them into orbit.
That's why the Canadarm is not the USArm, as is with the Fine Guidance Sensor, James Webb Space Telescope, Tunable Filter Image, the Bodies In Space Environment program and that 33 Canadian engineers played pivotal roles in the technology breakthroughs that made safe manned spaceflight possible.
And that's just one allied nation that was incorporatd by NASA to realize 'America's success'.
One of the most advanced satellites in orbit today was developed for secure allied military communications, Skynet5a is a British satellite launched from French Guiana.
>NASA has spent a total of $450 billion since Apollo 11 (adjusted for inflation to 2003 dollars).
>the sad truth is that the USA has less capability in human spaceflight now than in 1970.
>In 1969, the USA landed on the Moon, but now cannot leave low Earth orbit (LEO).
>NASA claimed that the shuttle would be fifteen times cheaper to fly (per pound of payload) than the Saturn vehicles used in Apollo, but it is actually three times more expensive.
>The average cost of each flight is a staggering $760 million. After a mission, the time required to prepare a shuttle for the next flight was supposed to be less than two weeks, but in practice tens of thousands of technicians spend three to six months rebuilding each "reusable" shuttle after every flight. Worst of all, the shuttle is a needlessly complex, fragile and dangerous vehicle, which has killed fourteen astronauts so far.
>In 1973, the USA had a space station called Skylab, with berths for three astronauts. NASA let it reenter and break up over Western Australia.
>A second Skylab was built, which could have become the Earth terminal of a lunar transportation system.
It is now a tourist attraction at the Air and Space Museum in Washington, and the Saturn V to launch it is nothing more than a monstrous lawn ornament, moldering on its side at Johnson Space Center (JSC).
> Now teh USA is building the International Space Station (ISS), which is still incomplete after twenty years of effort. Its orbital inclination, chosen for political reasons, makes it useless as a base for future missions beyond Earth.
>In the original design, the ISS had a crew of six or seven, but cost overruns have forced deletion of a habitation module and a lifeboat that could return that crew to Earth in emergency. The shrunken station, called "core complete," will accommodate only three astronauts (who will use a Russian Soyuz as a lifeboat). In normal operations, only one of the crew will be American.
Sorry but if NASA were an Auto manufacturer they'd be dead by now, if NASA was a softwarer provider, they'd be chapter11,if NASA was a department store, WalMart would have bought them out already.
It's hard not to look like you are at the top of your game, when there are no other players. Stack NASA up against the rest of the world and they are but another space agency.
The bombs at Hiroshima and Nagasaki were dropped against the advice of the Pacific Theatre General Staff. The Hiroshima bomb was dropped for political reasons to force the capitulation of the Japanese before the Russians could enter the war in that area. The Nagasaki bomb was dropped with the sole purpose of impressing on the Russians that you had more than one bomb.
The sticking point for the Japanese surrender BEFORE the bomb was dropped was the primacy of the Emperor. Even after two atomic weapons were used to flatten two cities, that point was still not conceded by the Japanese and was eventually conceded by the US in their hurry to get the surrender signed.
Politics, not military necessity at all.
The US are still the only nation to use atomic weapons in war.
The Apollo programme is the reason why we aren't in space today. The way that the US achieved Kennedy's goal of putting a man on the Moon in the time-scale that he set was to use brute force: a big rocket to lift a smaller rocket and so on, culminating in the return of the astronauts in a baked bean can.
Had the push to the moon been from Earth orbit - returning to Earth orbit, our species would have truly benefited with microgee industry and, by now, a huge experience of building and living in space.
But you wouldn't have got to the Moon and back in time. Audiences tailed off for the later flights (bar 13, of course) and you abandoned it all.
A political stunt that is the reason why the US will have enormous trouble in putting a man (back) on the Moon within the next five years.
This is not an anti-American post, just my own conclusions drawn from the reading that I have done. Observations which you may feel free to argue against.
Neil :)
The invasion of Iraq was a political stunt. It served no real purpose. Oops! Sorry, that one just slipped in without me noticing...
by dhcdbd
I disagree with your assertions as to the US buying what others know. They steal it, patent it with a few alterations, then tie it up in court for years. When it looks like the patent will be lost or invalidated, they settle quietly out of court.
Nitpick 2:
What slows the growth of India and Pakistan are the prejudices based on the color of the dot they wear on their foreheads. The refusal to work with, and sometimes, speak to someone from a different cast.
Often those dots are based on religious differences and understandings relevant to the culture, which brings this into the correct topic for the thread.
... "ooo, neat! What's that?!"
Okay, sometimes I go "AAAUGH" and run, but I think you can probably guess the sorts of situations that would arise in.
The universe does not tell me where it came from, and I suspect that how I feel (whether in the sense of emotion or inference) is pretty much unconnected to what actually happened. The overall order of things, however you might define that, seems to respond with relative and situational consistency, whether that consistency is the mind-bending madness that is quantum mechanics, the stately elegance of the growth of crystalline structures, or the awe-inspiring complexity of a rotating galaxy.
I figure if someone was pushing the buttons, the human ability to empathize would not be so unreliable, and the universe would come with a clearly-written guide for its tenants (and hopefully contact information for the landlord). Otherwise, I just do what I can (as best I can) and enjoy what time I have.
It's a personally satisfying way to live, and gives me lots of options!
by dhcdbd
"The Soviets, who had a lead in space technology and experience in space, could not make it to the moon."
Did they try?
by jamesrl
But if I believe this link, technical issues weren't their only problem:
http://www.astronautix.com/articles/whynrace.htm
They abandoned the program not long after Apollo 11.
James
by dhcdbd
"IF the leadership had taken seriously Kennedy's challenge in 1961, and given Korolev the go-ahead to build his original N1 according to his original plan, and IF Korolev had the full backing of the Soviet state, then it would have been quite possible to beat the Americans to the moon."
If we believe this quote, then the Soviets DID have the ability to beat the Americans to the moon, but were held back just like the military in Nam.
by jdclyde
http://www.census.gov/population/www/popclockus.html
[i]"One international migrant (net) every............ 36 seconds"[/i]
365 days x 24 hours = 8760 hours
8760 hours x 60 minutes = 525600 minutes
525600 minutes x 60 seconds = 31536000 seconds
31536000 seconds / 1 immigrant per 36 seconds = 876000 immigrants per year.
648,000 was first place on the link you posted. Keep in mind our huge illegal immigrant issue on top of that.
World wide it is known as the American dream, not the British dream or Canadian dream. Why is that?
Now run along little man, your petty jealousy, insecurity and predictability bores me.
by boxfiddler Hot topic
IF the Biblical God is 'real', and the Bible is 'true', then God's promises are 'real' and 'true'. If this is so, then the promise of blessing would manifest to those who keep His Word.
If then, Biblical principle was at work in our founding papers, in the principles of the time, and if it still is, then blessing of this nation is a product of that.
Y'all go everywhere but there.
by dhcdbd
IIF P then Q. (If and only if.)
Then it must follow that the current problems in the country are also "Gods" blessings.
By another rule, I believe Modus Tonens:
IIF not P then Q.
In either case you have a logical fallacy.
We could also use De'Morgan's Transformation to reduce the argument to the inconsequential and false.
Good try Boxie :)
by tig2
by oz_media
Most people speak of America as North america, thus Canada and America. The only time you hear such separation is when someone has ot defend themself as Canadian and not American.
And ocne again, most people understand that a nation with mroe developed cities than any other on Earty will have a greater immigration statistic, this does not in ANY way at all suggest that more people want to live in America than anywhere else.
In fact, American cities come quite low in the list of most desireable places to live, if at all.
So statistically, nobody wants ot live there, but in yoru eyes, everyone wants to live there. You seem to be confusing opportunity and ability with desire.
by oz_media
by jdclyde
just because more people come here (based upon the link) doesn't mean more people want to come here.
[i]"So statistically, nobody wants ot live there, "[/i]
More people moving somewhere does equal more people moving there, INSTEAD of Canada/UK.
Yeah, go with that and cry some more.
I do have some taste. Perhaps a Manzanilla.
:D
Tell you the truth, though, I'm a vintage Port man by choice if I can afford it.
by dhcdbd
However, I pointed out the flaw in the argument. My logic instructor also taught never to use logic in an argument with your wife because the most logical result is a frying pan to the head.
However, most religious and philosophical arguments are based around deductive and syllogistic logic.
;)
by oz_media
You have 10X the population of Canada and MANY more times the number of developed cities. Therefore the are more jobs and US customs is able to allow a greater number to enter the USA than Canada can here, or Australia can.
Most immigrants from the UK choose Canada or Australia, why? Because they think America is better?
It's because of the EASE of movement to Canada or Australia?
So if it is EASIER for MORE people ot go to the USA than Canada, then that's where they will go. It doesn't mean they prefer America, certainly many will compared to living in Kuwait but that does not make the US a preferred destination, it makes the US an easier destination.
Seriously, having met and speaken to people all over the world, most of whom HATE the essence of the USA to the core and what the people stand for, America is seen as a laughing stock. But easy pickins moneywise. Christ, even I almost moved there when I was running businesses there, and you know how much i just love the US. I suppose according to your stats, I would have moved to the US to of preference because I was jealous of Americans. In actual fact it was just because it is so easy to sell complete junk to Americans that buy anything they are told to buy.
The US has been advertising globally, we've seen the ads here to trying to get Canadians to the USA, that they have an extreme need for a skilled labour force. People from Europe are enticed by high paying labour jobs. It has been the same here too, Europeans flock to Canada because of the manual labour jobs, and European craftsmen, engineers etc are in high demand and have little competition from Americans or Canadians when they get there. Good money, easy pickins.
I must ask though, why as a recently unemployed American living in a land of economic turmoil, would you be so proud of skilled workers entering the USA?
Their only interest is US dollars, an easy job market facing an unskilled/inexperienced pool of workers, and they have no interest in US politics or conformity to US customs.
Then again, perhaps that has also been a positive influx that has shown the changing of the guard, there's no WAY someone immigrating from Europe would vote for a tool like Bush and private medical coverage, he's TOO typically American.
I just read a newspiece this morning about how people are choosing France as a preference nwo strictly because of the socially supportive infrastructure, people from England (who are supposed ot hate France, shhhh)move ot England as it has a better social services system, a better place to retire.
"For over a decade, Canada has been ranked number one among 175 countries in the United Nation's Quality of Life survey."
"Where will be the best place to live in 2005? The World in 2005 turned to the Economist Intelligence Unit, which has devised a 2005 ?quality of life? index for 111 countries. Result: Ireland comfortably tops the league. [b]America, though the second-richest country (behind Luxembourg) in GDP per head, slips to 13th in quality of life.[/b] Britain languishes in 29th place.
It has long been accepted that material well-being alone does not adequately measure quality of life. Money matters, of course, but surveys suggest that over the decades big increases in income have translated into only a modest rise in satisfaction. Although rising incomes and expanded individual choice are highly valued, some of the factors associated with modernisation?such as the breakdown of traditional institutions and the erosion of family values?in part offset its posit"LONDON - Ireland is the best country to live in with Switzerland in second spot, according to a sweeping study of 111 nations aimed at comparing happiness around the world.
"The quality of life in Ireland well ahead of the United States, which was ranked 13th, and neighboring Britain, which came in at 29th place."
"WHICH COUNTRIES SET THE BEST EXAMPLES"
http://www.vexen.co.uk/countries/best.html
To be fair you ranked 8th for human development index, didn't hit top 10 for global peace index despite saving the world, didn't rank at all for gender equality, 29th for life expectancy, dropped to 6th (and that was 3yrs ago) for competitive economy, child obesity you just about own that one, 9th for adults at high literacy, didn't rank in top 10 for environmental sustainability or recycled waste (if only they had one for amount of waste you'd top that list for sure), 9th for open access to research, 5th for asylum seeker acceptance rate (again due to sheer size of course), quite low on the scale of amount of aid given to developing countries (of course based on percentage of GDP and not total monetary value), dropped from 1st to 9th for IT Network readiness index, #1 YOU WIN ONE!! for IT piracy levels, 3rd as far as secularism is concerned.
So considering all that, many stats form many places, all compiled on one website, the US offers Child Obesity, secularism and IT piracy.
This speaks volumes if you understood how outsiders see the USA.
With most other countries having more to offer than the USA, to suggest that, due to mere immigration statistics, that the USA is the most desired destination for foreigners is simply stupid.
YOU have everything going against you and not too much going for you, except an EASY workforce to compete with and heaps of jobs for those skilled workers, willing to work harder and with more discipline than Americans, who are known globally to be "lazy, fat and arrogant" (I think those are the three most common adjectives for Americans). As I have always said, I was drawn to the US market because it is easy to beat out lazy, arorgant people for work. It's easy to take an American's money, they feel pride in spending it haphazardly. It's even easier to take an American's job away, as I have done more than once.
If you feel othertwise, why is it that your most successful entrepreneurs seek a labout force far away from America? It's not just money, they also move to Canada to open their operations here where they have a greater pool of immigrant workers with better skillsets.
Of course in your tiny little mind, it must be because everyone thinks America is better, despite global opinion proven over decades in almost every aspect of life.
Sort by Trending