Discussion Locked

America's success a result of Biblical basis of constitution

0 helpful
388 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post

388 replies

by oz_media

At first yoru posts amused me, then they just plain drove me nuts, now they are purposely offensive withotu even regarding teh material yuo are referring to. Just personal character shots.

At one time, I thought you were above that, only to be proven wrong of course.

Insert pithy rebuttal from confucious here:

by jamesrl

You are living in Vancouver, and you missed Cedar planked salmon?

For those of you who aren't familiar, you take cedar planks, soak them in water, season them, and put them on the BBQ.

Once the plank is smoking, you put the salmon skin side down on the plank. Other seasonings on top of the fish as you like.

Just make sure the cedar isn't treated with anything.....

James

by dhcdbd

You do not follow the gist of what was being said. So allow me to make it simple for you on a discussion that was closed.

Go to a Catechism school for two years. Study comparative religion. Study logic, not the star trek definition your post indicates. Decide that Christianity has holes. Join the Argentium Astrium and attend the College of Thelema. Withdraw from the AA after reaching the point of Adeptus Minor. Decide that all organized religion is full of non-sense and open yourself to other realities. Become involved with shamans from many different cultures but focusing primarily on the American Indians and the Meso American variety. Now throw in Schrodinger's cat.

You will have reached the point that I am at.

Since you are an expert, you know from your studies of physics, math, and a certain cat that there are many realities and that these realities are currently being examined by science.

Now I say, as a direct attack on you that you have no concept of what I am talking about. You have no concept of what you are talking about even though you think you do. As a simple example, a cursory read of relativity will show that the perception from being inside a moving train versus the perception observing it from the outside are different. Now read and understand Kant and Descartes. Because the perception is different, you have a different reality. Now go back to relativity, examine the discussion about two space ships traveling at the speed of light passing one another in opposite directions. Again different realities. To be blunt, you don't even have to read about relativity, Basic calculus combined with the special theory of relativity will provide a numeric representation of what I just said.

Now dude, throw in Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle which briefly states: "for any moving particle its position n its momentum cannot be determined at a same time. mathematically." Rephrasing the Uncertainty Principle in the accepted definitions, the more certain you are of a particles momentum, the less certain you are of its position. I hate to break it to you, [B]You are a moving particle in this vast universe[/B]

In summary, you are all wet and out of your element.

If you wish to challenge, start a new sub thread, I'll be happy to embarrass you.

There are plenty of holes in my beliefs, but far fewer than there are in many other religions.

by oz_media

EIther free when camping, or at exorbitant prices in Whistler.

The problem with BC salmon is that it is just too common here. Whenever I am entertaining guests from out of town it's ALWAYS Salmon for dinner, zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz.

Yes I love Salmon, a friend is a commercial fisherman, I think I tol dyou before how he gives me a flash frozen fish or two from the boat and I have to thaw the middle and either fold it or cut it in half to get it in the freezer.

Not all salmon is good on a cedar plank though, most of the stuff we get here is too big and is better as salmon steaks. Though restaurants make a bundle selling all breeds of Salmon on a plank to tourists who don't know how some tastes better prepared other ways. Salmon on a plank at Araxi (anyone watching the latest Hell's Kitchen knows that's where the winning chef gets to take over) is usually over $40.00 (I I have to drive over thousands of them with my dirtbike when the rivers are dry and they are flip flopping all over the logging roads).

I have reservations at Araxi for next Saturday, going up for a few days at the condo for the Kokanee Crankworx festival, babes galore!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I always make agreat collage wallpaper of all the girls there each year. Back to Araxi, I just have a real issue paying that much for local food. the veggies from pemberton and Liloette are awesome, ut fish and clams harvested down the road for that much money is purely tourist fare. I go for the lamb!

What's really funny is that some stores sell the cedar planks, with some poor quality indian design burned into them for $20 a board, and peopel BUY them! Cedar in BC, and people PAY for it! LOL.

I could split off 30 for you in about 10 minutes for free, sans native impression.

So for us it's mroe of a camping thing, grab a salmon from the river(literally, you can gaff them just like a bear)and cut the closet log, split off a few boards and chuck it on the fire. Nothign like that real bonfire taste to finish it off!

Coho makes great steaks, Pink is a good plank salmon, Sockeye is great grilled whole but cleaned with butter and lemon.

by dhcdbd

Down Fido (me), Down Devil (you).

No, that fracas was because the neighbor kept throwing trash in my yard over both his front and back fence.

by jdclyde

no crying.
no hiding.
no asking anyone to address you on my behalf.

As you have seen, I have stood toe to toe, and walked away untouched.

Surely you haven't forgotten this is just an internet posting board, and nothing the faceless Oz posts could hurt me, let alone cause physical harm.

This has gone on long enough, you can jump up and down and tell everyone you won, as I am bored with you and your rants. I will even allow you to have the last post.

by charliespencer

We used to pull rainbows and browns out of a couple of lakes in SW Utah for breakfast.

Anyone frying salmon or trout should be battered and dropped in their own oil.

by oz_media

That cheap store bought halibut or cod garbage or a cheap woman is about all I will batter.

I don't really believe in deep frying too many foods, I prefer the taste of the food instead. The closer to it's original form the better. (never deep fried a woman though, but then again I prefer the taste of the woman instead).

by maecuff

You know what I love?

That I can be gone for months. Be ballsy enough to show up and scold you and JD after being absent for so long. And then STILL get an apology.

It's so good to be me. :)

I'll check that link out later. They recently put a web filter on at work and youtube is blocked.

by jardinier

of posts made to meetchristians by certain people. :)

Later perhaps I will post a couple of examples of people who ALWAYS end their sarcastic or offensive comments with a "blessing."

by notsochiguy

Actually, this leads into another primary reason I would list.

Manufacturing, in of itself, I wouldn't list as a cause; but more so an effect (a crucial one, though). The causes I'd attribute it to are ingenuity (Ford & the assembly line, for instance) and geography (speaks to why the manufacturing base was intact).

Being bordered by two oceans and two allies has helped the US tremendously; if for no other reason that it would have required a tremendous amount of effort (prior to the advent of ICBMs and Internet-facing infrastructure) to put a 'dent' into the American interior. It still helps not having to devote substantial military (read: financial) resources to patrol the entirety of our Northern border. As for the Southern border..... ;)

As for how the US is looking going forward, I would admit to having concerns. You're right that the rest of the world is catching up/surpassing the US in a whole slew of areas. By itself, that wouldn't alarm me as much; as the world grows smaller, someone's success in Japan or in England (or elsewhere) will probably benefit us all in some way. However, what bothers me is what you mentioned about the seeming lack of investment in furthering research and idea generation. A level of co-dependence is one thing, but to become wholly reliant on others....that's a dangerous slope; and one I'd prefer not to see the US attempt to climb.

by dogbadger

I will not lose sleep about anything posted here. I am actually an Australian Citizen living in the USA. Been here for 30 or so years, so I am pretty familiar with this immigration stuff. I have relatives that come to the USA from UK/Holland/Australia all the time. Funny thing is most of them want to go to Walmart more than anywhere else.... Anyway, just to completely honest, I am a non-apologetic Christian Aussie living in the blessed USA, no other place I would rather be, even with the current political climate... Nowhere in the world do you have the Freedoms that we have here, which can be good and bad ofcourse and some of that really leads to/from what the original question/post was here, before we got all this sniffling I hate the USA crap. A question though for all of you non biblical believing people out there. What/where do you get your values from, you know what leads you when you decide what is right/wrong?

by jamesrl

See parable of the good Samaratan.

You don't have to believe in the Bible/Koran/etc. to have a rational belief system or moral code. Look at all of the major religions that have a variation of the golden rule (do unto others...) and tell me that the rule doesn't preceed many of those religions.

There are many who profess a religion who do evil things that are seemingly against the religions principles, and many people who are aetheists and agnostics who do many good deeds.

James

by Member 25348569

Well, the unfortunate truth (for someone asking such a loaded question as the one that you just asked) is that neither religions nor gods are necessary for personal or societal morality, ethics or values. They can - and do - exist in a secular environment perfectly satisfactorily.

I'm a godless atheists who leads a perfectly moral life. I haven't worshipped Satan for absolutely AGES.

To briefly answer your question; what we use is reason. We think clearly and coherently about our moral choices and do what we think is right. Add in our own personal concepts of justice, mercy and honesty. Maybe a good slug of empathy and you have a recipe for a pretty good moral sense.

I could go on but I have to tell you that I find your question more than a little insulting. You seem to be saying that morality is something that can be separated from society and the person. I find the idea that morality exists exclusively in terms of god and religion more than a little elitist especially when those who pose the question usually want to narrow (emphasis "narrow") it down to THEIR god and THEIR religion.

Neil :)

Feel free to come back. But be aware that I bite.

Edit: Santee. Sorry, but I used "reason" which, I guess, is almost as bad as "rational". Not that I have a problem with either. :)

by oz_media

I'll refrain from the lengthy explanation of what I don't like about America these days, however I am not Anti-American (as anyone with anything negative to say about America is tagged) I am anti-ignorant-American attitude, but so's the rest of the world, I'm far from being alone and in fact I find myself defending America against other poeple's flames quite often.

You need to give this forum time, people try to play games here like they are on a bad episode of Big Brother. You'll see many sides of many people, which change according to topic. People are famous fo rquoting people out of context in order to change direction fo their comments and make it appear that they have said something other than what they actually said. In other words, you need to have your wits about you.

That aside, with respect to your new hero JDClyde, he's admittedly playing a child's game. A few months back he professed that he will post such utter lies and senseless garbage after every post I make, simply to pi$$ me off. He has admitted he will offer nothing of value and will simply post garbage to ruin threads I post to, he's pretty grown up that way. He used to offer some rather intelligent commentary at one time, notice how he pounced on teh opportunity to introduce himself and flame me in a heartbeat. His true colours are clear to see, by all but JD of course.

To bring you up to speed on the resource issue, the discussion was about how the world wouldn't survive without America, to which I commented that America would also perish without the world. The only interest of allies is the American dollar, the only interest from America towards allies is getting what they need from them.

You rely on the world for your day to day lifestyle, the world relies on America for dollars, that's the only comment made so please don't drag it too far out of proprtion and into a pi$$ing contest of who gave what to whom.

The charitable facts are also warped if you want to investigate, it should be raised as a separarate thread, we've been down that road many times here already. Look at per capita support (REAL figures) and the USA is not on top by any means. And when they are shown based on GDP, you must also consider that Federal tax laws-notably low income tax, plus breaks for donations are often cited for American's generosity. As is religion, which drives one-third of U.S. charitable giving.

As for soldiers, we all lost soldiers in wars over the years, whether rightfully or wrong, war is a chosen way of life for the US government anyway, if you grow up in America, expect it. America has been supported as much as America has been needed in that respect, I just don't buy the typical American brainwashed history that they are saving the world. If anything America often places allies and their own soldiers in great danger, when not needed.

[i]"Nowhere in the world do you have the Freedoms that we have here"[/i]

Please explain what FREEDOMS you have in the USA that I do not have in Canada.
Here are the top listed nations for freedom that are all seen on the EXACT same level with respect to political rights and civil liberties:
?Andorra
?Australia
?Austria
?Bahamas
?Barbados
?Belgium
?Canada
?Cape Verde
?Chile
?Costa Rica
?Cyprus
?Czech Republic
?Denmark
?Dominica
?Estonia
?Finland
?France
?Germany
?Hungary
?Iceland
?Ireland
?Italy
?Kiribati
?Latvia
?Liechtenstein
?Lithuania
?Luxembourg
?Malta
?Marshall Islands
?Micronesia
?Nauru
?Netherlands
?New Zealand
?Norway
?Palau
?Poland
?Portugal
?St. Kitts and Nevis
?St. Lucia
?San Marino
?Slovakia
?Slovenia
?Spain
?Sweden
?Switzerland
?Tuvalu
?United Kingdom
?United States
?Uruguay
(Source http://www.infoplease.com/ipa/A0930918.html)

Sure nobody is as free as America, even though others do get the whole picture and not just a government controlled view of world events.

America has no more freedom than MANY other nations, you certainly don't have freedom of press that some nations have. American media and news broadcasting has greater restrictions than many otehr natons, leaving Americans with only part of the whole picture. I am not suggesting Canada gets the whole deal, but we do get news stories/video and interviews that are later shown on US networks all clipped up and edited. I always suggest openign yourselves up to many different views form different nations in order ot get teh bigger picture, which I find many Americans simply dismiss as foreign and inapplicable as it wasn't aired on CNN.

So, that's just media, the news you are shown is heabilty controlle dand paid for by politicial supporters with an agenda (we've been there too, how the SBG team are controlling and recreating news to show only one side of reality to Americans.

Today, in a word focused more toward foreign affairs and the global economy, to only see part of the picture leaves Americans making decisions and supporting actions with only part of the real story to go on.

Freedom of pressindex, a few years old but teh America's PDF shows the USA as ranking 22nd for news withign the nation and 108th! for freedom of press in Iraq. Sounds like the old freedoms dreams are not so accurate afterall. Unless you consider having a repressed and controlled press to be freedom.

[b]FREEDOM OF PRESS[/b] (tantamount in a citizen's ability to understand and develop world views based on facts instead of political BS)
Reporters without borders, press freedom index:
http://arabia.reporters-sans-frontieres.org/article.php3?id_article=11715

[i]"What/where do you get your values from, you know what leads you when you decide what is right/wrong? "[/i]

Myself. Sorry but I have been exposed to and accept scientific facts, not biblical scripture written over thousands of years and in many dialects and translated into 60+ books that are supposed to be the facts of how to live my life.

Many people simply don't need religion to find human values, most are common courtesy. Society, based on biblical beliefs, has engrained what they feel are values and acceptable behaviours. If there was no religion, our accpteance of what is right and wrong would be different, but that does not mean it would be better or worse as it would be seen as completely normal, acceptable bahaviour.

Don't kill, don't lie, cheat or steal? First of all these 'rules' have all be broken by religious supporters and even religious leaders. Faith has nothign to do with it.

We don't need to believe in a God in order to not kill, lie, cheat and steal from one another.

Religion is FAITH, BELIEF, and that's it, there's no proof of any religious 'belief' otherwise there would be a single religion in the world. There is belief, there is hope, there is faith but none of those feelings are a result of fact or scientific proof.

You are free to have your faith and beliefs and I will not question your choice to find the good things or shape your life that way, THAT'S FREEDOM!

However, you have questioned how people that don't share your faith also can possibly have understanding of right and wrong, good or bad, is that not questioning another's faith ?

Having lived in the UK and Canada, I have grown up with a life enriched with science, as a result MOST Canadians, over 70% now, don't subscribe to Christianity as they once did, before modern scientific exposure helped them understand evolution and the formation of life. That same exposur eot scientific fact i snot offered on major US networks, it is not a mandatory subject taught in every school for the whole 12 years. People in the USA have less exposure to science on a broad scale, it requries personal time and study which is easily dismissed by a politically focused media.

In contrast, 80% of America still subscribes to Christianity and attends regular weekly services and is one of few remaining countries on the planet to do so as others have greater exposure to alternative, scientific facts.

by dhcdbd

What moral values. The value of the moral depends on the paradox you currently live in.

If you live in war, then it is perfectly acceptable and expected to kill on sight. In civilian life that is unacceptable. Yet it is not unacceptable to kill under the right circumstances.

In business it is perfectly acceptable to "Do unto others before they do unto you - Anton Sazander LaVey, The Santanic Bible." In non business civilian life this is less acceptable. It would be more normal to "Do unto others as you would have them do unto you." How many follow this though?

Man is the determiner of what is right or wrong, what is moral or immoral and those determinations depend on time, situation, and events. These events are not determined by the Bible, the Talmud, the Quran, the Bahgvad Gita, the Havimal, nor any other religious writing.

Politically, the determination of right or wrong, morality and immorality is out of your hands. The critters that we elect determine that for us and, unfortunately, those morals and values are often determined by who has the biggest pocketbook.

Culturally the determination of what is right or wrong is made by a population consensus that is understood, but often not spoken.

by notsochiguy

You're pretty good at playing devil's advocate without resorting to off-base attacks.

I can appreciate that!

:)

by charliespencer

The light bulb.
The phonograph.
The process of vulcanization of rubber
A laboratory for the evolution of the democratic process.
The cotton gin.
ARPANet, the basis for the Internet.
'Star Trek'
Marketing techinques.
Chicken McNuggets.

by oz_media

Raise hell that you can't enjoy your work day and relax properly without watching stinky monkey at least once a day. That'll get them into action.

As for your extended absence, it was noted and I hope you brought a note.

As for being able to garner apology, any woman with the big cast iron clangers you have, gets my respect.

And truly, Maecuff, who the hell wouldn't respect you anyway?

by santeewelding

Except, where do get "rational" from?

The kind that bootstraps and pronounces its own being as rational?

It is a word found throughout these threads; one that each beats another with over the head.

by deadly ernest

attitude and reply. It's been almost a week now and still no response to my last email.

But you have to love their inability to read emails as each was just an addition to the previous one. I wonder if the responses came from different people or the same person as they didn't give individual names - probably not sure enough of themselves to allow themselves to be personally identified.

I know wonder if I'd seen the whole video file how much of it I would've been able to point out as historical distortion. On the web site they mention one historical 'fact' and it's so wrong it's almost as bad as saying the South won the War Between the States.

by santeewelding

To put in your dentures.

Until then, you forbear on how you come by your facile notion of, "reason".

by Member 25348569

Oh I know it's not that simple. That was the answer that the question "A question though for all of you non biblical believing people out there. What/where do you get your values from, you know what leads you when you decide what is right/wrong?" deserves. Well, we THINK about it! Because we have no-one to lead us by the nose.

Perhaps we should go with David Hume who really pissed off the English Clergy a while back. He said (among other things) that reason is an advisor and not the decision-maker in matters of morality. Hume said that moral principles are based in their usefulness. He stated that morality was not God?s will but he also didn't believe that moral certainties could be derived scientifically. Hume's theory was that moral rules appeal to us when they promote our interests and those of our fellow human beings with whom we sympathise. We are biologically predisposed to whatever helps society, since we live in a community and stand to benefit from reciprocity

No reason why I should believe that but I've always kind of liked it. Still ain't go no god in it, though.

Neil :)

Hey guys. I answer different people in different ways. Gimme a CHANCE!

by charliespencer

When a US Southerner includes the phrase "God bless him" in a sentence, it doesn't indicate concern for spiritual well-being. It's more along the lines of, "If you can't say something nice..."

"Cousin Billy is up for parole again, God bless him."

Aunt Polly, God bless her, she's had three accidents in her own driveway."

by santeewelding

Gathering and growing into such a ball of "fact" that you no longer have access to your point of nucleation.

by charliespencer

All of them contain some good philosophical and ethical principles that can be applied without the religious wrapping.

Me? I don't believe in an afterlife of any kind. I think each and every life gets one shot and one only at this plane of existence, and that this is the only one there is. Each of us has just this one precious opportunity, and to deprive another of his or her chance at happiness is wrong. Live and let live.

by jdclyde

"common sense". Gawd I hate when people state that as if there actually were such a thing.

by oz_media

I have stated and linked to facts that I have found on mroe than one website, with multiple sources around the world reporting the same 'facts', your only real opportunity to debate them accurately is to step up to the plate, put your money where your mouth is and offer proof that these facts are not real and that YOUR facts are.

Speaking in one of your many cryptic tongues does nto make you intelligent, as you just shoot the messenger without proving the message wrong.

This site was once a website where thoughtful discussions ALL required proof of comments. YOu couldn't post OPINION wihtout sayign it was opinion and you couldn't post FACTS withotu proof of your sources.

Of course the easy way out at that time was to simply discount the source and some were quite sketchy.

However you and very few others seem to feel that simply flaming the person posting and discounting their comments, while offering no alternative views, facts or proof to show otherwise, is actually clever.

That's no different than someone just saying, "B.S., you are American" to everything you say, whether supported or not.

When you grow up and learn to actually debate and not just flame like a child, you'll be heard; until then, stomp your feet and paddy all you like, prove me wrong if you don't like or believe what I have to say. But don't just stand there shaking your head like a dummy if you can't 'prove' otherwise.

what' sit gonna be? Will yuo stand up and prove yourself? Will you provide more mouthfuls of garbage that relate to nothing and do nothing to support an alternate opinion.

I highly bloody doubt it, you have never shown such mental capacity here.

by charliespencer

I'm not Dogbadger and can't read his mind, but I saw the question as an innocent inquiry devoid of judgmental baggage. Just me.

by charliespencer

What did Dogbadger say that makes you think jd is his 'new hero'?

"Nowhere in the world do you have the Freedoms that we have here"

Gods of us all, the remark was clearly an idle exuberance, in the same category as "No where in the world do you have the pizza we have in Chicago!" Not everything is a personal challenge.

"However, you have questioned how people that don't share your faith also can possibly have understanding of right and wrong, good or bad, is that not questioning another's faith ?"

Like I told neil, I think you're finding offense where none was intended. He all he did was ask how we reached our values. He said nothing to imply we were incapable of understanding the concepts without using a spiritual framework. If he doesn't ask, how is he going to find out?

by maecuff

That would be disturbing for both of them.

Not to mention the sleepless nights I would suffer.

by santeewelding

Where was "nucleation" in all that?

You know: that origin which subtends and characterizes your entirety; the one I persistently question, and not only in your case.

Hint: same origin subtending and characterizing "reason" and "rationality", mentioned to others here. Goes, too, for your "fact...proof...real" and, particularly your, "alternate opinion".

I can't get past that last one.

Our nucleation can have no alternate. That, sir, wipes out, "opinion". It is non sequitur.

Wipes out DHCDBD and his situational stuff, too.

Footnote: Which is what Neil amounts to.

by Member 25348569

They are all so loaded with stuff that ISN'T good for you that it's not really very productive to try and find the stuff that is.

Once you have decided which book, that is...

Much better to get a slim volume on applied ethics and proceed from there.

:)

by Member 25348569

But that particular question is SUCH a loaded one that there isn't any really good way to ask it. I've been asked it a few times on TR and rarely - if ever - with the questioners real desire for an answer.

If I'm honest then there ISN'T a full answer other than on a personal basis. We are fundamentally familial and then tribal beings and most of our morality comes from there and we add a few of our own bits on. Most of the Holy Books Golden Rules come from our preliterate days - without any input required from a supreme being - and the rot sets in when the Keepers Of The Holy Book write their own prejudices into it.

:)

And people get burned alive...

by Member 25348569

[i]The fool hath said in his heart, There is no God. They are corrupt, they have done abominable works, there is none that doeth good. [/i]

Hmmm. There's quite a lot I could say in answer to that.

by maecuff

I think that mae be accurate. Depends on how you define corrupt.

And, I believe I've been abominable from time to time. Never had any complaints, though.

by Member 25348569

[i]They are all gone aside, they are all together become filthy: there is none that doeth good, no, not one. [/i]

Well, I guess we DO have the best parties!

:^0

by oz_media

He was directly referencing my earlier posts and JD was simply gobbling it up and patting him on the back. Obviously this new poster doe not know JD or that he has said that he will purposely post garbage to follow each and everyone of my posts, which he has proven time and time again now.

As for the questioning of where no religious people find morals without faith, it is teh same agi old question Christians have asked to try and explain that morals are based on religion. I simply explained taht you don't need Christian faith to have such morals.

Your understanding of my comments has become very defensive and predictive, as has JD but he's just a tool, admittedly playing games with no intent or ability of intelligent conversation or reasoned debate at all.

You create an impression of what I am saying, without me having said it. It results in predetermined conclusions that are incorrect. My reason for morals was questioned, I replied to it and thus questioned the posters reason for morals purely based on faith.

Slow down, relax, it's not a war of words as JD wants to make it.

by oz_media

I disagree entirely. Prove your point for once in your lifetime.

I make comments formed from personal experience, media portayal, available scientific facts, and use such information to arrive at an final opinion.

I then state that opinion, offer additional comments found elsewhere, with links to teh sources of the information, and add scientific fact where available.

Sure beats wankign away and offering drivel withotu substance, no matter hwo yo try to word it, yuo have failed ot prove any of my assertions otherwise and will continue to warble away withotu substance as you have proven that is all you do here.

No facts, no worthy comments, no derivative opinions, no discussions, no reasoned debates, no supported arguments, just drivel.

You are one step away from sliding into JD's simple mentality of having nothing of value to offer to anyone in his life.

by oz_media

While I do agree with your commentary on where values differ and are applicable, I differ in origin.

Yes politics is the origin of what is legally acceptable however moral values, I feel, are the left over dregs of religion that was, and in some cases still is, a basis for government.

With the one time massive following of Christianity in Canada, society was 'commanded' by a set of religious values. As more and more people adopted more scientific understandings of man's origin, from developing into single cell organisms to the evolution of multicell organisms, such religious 'rules' became less and less important to people. Certainly a lot of moral values were retained as acceptable to modern society but it also created teh PC wars.

I have said a thousand times, Canada had their PC wars in teh 90's and it has settled down already into generally acceptable behaviour, the USA has only started addressing such issues in recent years this teh whole politically correct bandwagon many are on today. However development into a more comprehensive understanding of right and wrong, will never be achieved whil religion dominates Americans society and citates teh laws of right and wrong. Of course that also includes decidions at a political level, as while they profess to be open to religion, it is also the basis of personal decisions.

I think a whole new world will be opened up to America by Obama. I certainly don't agree with or trust all he does, nor would I ANY politician (especially our own)but I think his focus towards science, the Earth,protection and awareness towards natural resources vs the exploitation of such, seeking facts that may conflict with religion and our evolution as a society will certainly supercede Bush's hanging onto outdated dogma in order to make governing decisions.

Want a good explanation of evolution,

6 parts, from a BBC documentary by one of the most interesting hosts around.

Charles Darwin and The Tree of life:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zZv1Z4X0sgw

I also saw a doc a while back abou tteh big bang that actually explains where such elementary gases were created and existed to form the initial forms of life that eventually evolved into cell based organisms, which this touches on but only breifly due to time.

by dhcdbd

about this issue because you will turn it into a Canada Vs. US issue.

Your understanding of moral and values is incorrect because that argument extends back to caveman days. What is good for my tribe is good for my tribe and not yours. This is also the root of prejudice which you show plenty. This I believe is related to survival of the tribe and the fittest, though I have no proof of the assertion.

And yes, santee, I saw your post above. I would like to hear your comments on it.

by oz_media

I already explained how/why I saw it differently in the US and Canada, that does not mean it is a competition of Canada versus anyone though, or a debate about who has superior moral standards or anything.

However, the way it is addressed or applied in each nation is obvious and undeniably different.

I'll set that down as I have no interest in debating Canadian vs US morals and standards as there is no possible way one can be considered superior to the other. (you shouldn't jump to such conclusions)

As for the basis of moral behaviour, of COURSE it dates back to day one. However todays moral values were mainly a derivative of Christian values, which is obvious considering both of our nations were formed with Christian values.

My point is that countries will eventually question such values and reconsider such morals as that Christian foundation falls apart. I believe this is where the politically correct theme came from, it is not based on religious foundation but simply what people feel is acceptable in modern society.

The bible segregated people based on their chosen faith, whereas today such a thought processs is deemed archaic and repressive, as were other religious concepts towards humanity. Ex. We don't stone people into compliance these days whereas that was once a lesson in morality.

Politicians today can only impart such values upon society if the people accept them, at least it works that way here for the most part.

With Canada's centre focused government (we call it a right wing but it is almost centre/left by US standards), our politicians are very in tune with Canadian opinion, knowing that if they are not suiting citizen's needs, our system is set up that they are quickly ousted if they are not preferred over the minority seat holders that are eagerly chomping at the bit to take over.

In short, they suck up to the public that voted for them and are to careful not to push it or they quickly lose their lead.

by oz_media

Now read it in a Hindu voice/accent and it sounds like some terrorist prayer.

"Grace and peace be multiplied unto you through the knowledge of God and our Lord Jesus Christ (2 Peter 1:2)"

It's like saying "you suck rocks, no offense."

by dhcdbd

"With the one time massive following of Christianity in Canada"

"I have said a thousand times, Canada had their PC wars in teh 90's and it has settled down already into generally acceptable behaviour, the USA has only started addressing such issues in recent years this teh whole politically correct bandwagon many are on today"

"However development into a more comprehensive understanding of right and wrong, will never be achieved whil religion dominates Americans society..."

"I already explained how/why I saw it differently in the US and Canada..."

"With Canada's centre focused government (we call it a right wing but it is almost centre/left by US standards..."

[B]NOW, AS I HAVE SAID, I DO NOT WISH TO DISCUSS THE ISSUE WITH YOU!!![/B]

by dogbadger

Usually when someone gets offended it was because something was offensive (obviously) even though it was not intended to be.... It was really a basic question, not meant to be offensive. I wonder if I would of left out the Christian part if you would of been so offended? Anyway, Okay so what I see here that or read rather is that some/most of the posts cannot point to a specific thing. I read we use reason, what we think, it seems you guys are saying, and let me know if I am wrong.. morality is relative.... such a cliche I know.. but that is what I am reading. Would it be true that I can believe what I want because of the way I feel? Think about it......if you want to say, You can believe what you feel as long as you don't infringe on others rights... Because, my next question would be where do you get that it is right or wrong to infringe on others rights? Or better yet, where am I given these so called rights?

Another question.. why can I only reply to some posts and not all? I almost... ALMOST had to reply to another rant by OZ....

by charliespencer

There's a maximum of seven levels of response, not counting the original post. It's not possible to reply to a seventh-level post, so we keep appending replies to the sixth-level. To avoid confusion, it's best to include the name of the person you're responding to in the post title.

by dogbadger

other countries do not have. Guns. Now lets not get into all the stuff about guns.. but since I am not a U.S. Citizen, I dont own any guns here, but my wife and Kids do :-). She has a few rifles, an AK-47, great gun to shoot, very loud though. Some others that need not be mentioned.

I will give you that there are other countries that might have some of the same freedoms we have, at least until very lately, what the U.S. has that most do not have is all the opportunites, where can so many people come to a country and do so well? Back to one of the original posts... why have/are so many people immigrating to the U.S. (please don't do the percapita stuff again, read my previous post)

So what if all the rest of the world wants from us is $$$ what's your point. We see how the rest of the world is affected when the U.S. experiences a rough economy... but we don't see that when other countries economy is in the tank.... hmmmm.....

Side note.... Leaving out the VP. Gore remark....LOL... where was the internet invented?

Soldier thing... I thank the U.S. for what its soldiers have done... or my father who was in Holland during WWII might be speaking german, and my mother who was a Aussie might of spoken Jappanese. There are so MANY other countries who OWE the US Soldier alot... no arguments there....

Charity work... You ask the peopel that have recieved our charity if they care that the BILLIONS upon BILLIONS of $ came from 10 people or 150,000,000 people. It is still BILLIONS of dollars. Billions more than any other country has given.

If you do not hate the US, like you say you don't, why don't you focus all of your energy on trying to bring to light the real injustices that are happening in other places of the world for instance, IRAN/N. Korea/Venezula the list is long........

by oz_media

As you are pretty new to TR I have to have some patience with your questions despite the fact that they are simply patriotic rhetoric that has been torn down a thousand times here already.

Guns: Canada has more legal guns per capita than the USA. More Canadians own guns (by percentage) than Americans of course with only 10% of you population, in sheer numbers you have mroe guns, however that doesn't illustrate greater freedom in any way shape or form. First greater freedom myth, debunked.

"where can so many people come to a country and do so well?"
Australia, Canada, Germany, Austria, France and so on. Second greater freedom myth debunked. IN sheer numbers you have more room, more cities, but yuo also have mroe people competeing for teh same job. Here, for example, you can find a job in aheartbeat, you are usually lucky to get the rest of the week off before starting your next job. SO the oppotunity is greater here, as it is easier to find employment and there is far less competition for the job, affording more people opportunities. Sure 1,000 people enterign the US is a greater number than 100 people entering Canada, ut proportionately the percentage of new people entering the nation and seeking opportunity is the same. Now if you consider that 75 of those people entering Canada will have jobs in days, the number of people entering America and finding work right away will be similar. When comparing nations, 'PER CAPITA' is the only accurate way of comparison. Now compare the nuber of deaths by handgun in your country compared to others. You would probably look alot better comparing on a per capita basis.

Which other economies tanking are you referring to?
The effects the US dollar has on other nations is not quite as dire as you feel it is. The only reason there is any ecominoc effect is that teh US dollar is teh international currency for oil, and that constitures many trillions of dollars. You just have to HOPE that the world doesn't start trading in a stronger currency. Some nations already trade with Suadi's using teh EURO "Eurodollars" as opposed to the "US petrodollar" if that trend was to continue and grow into other nations, the US would enter instant recession as you have never experienced before. You wouldn't be able to drive down the street. Many TRILLIONs of Suadi Dollars are invested in MOST of Florida's resorts and oceanfronts for example, once that money is retracted for greater investment elsewhere, the US instantly plummets trillions into greater debt.

The internet was invented a s aresult of technology invented worldwide. I can't believe that every new guy on these forums raises the same old questions that have been hashed out for years here now, but that's not really your fault, you only get so much information given to you, living in the US, without exploring for facts yourself.

I too respect soldiers, from the US, Australia, UK and all other parts of the allied world. This does not in ANY way make teh US superior. Remember, Hitler had failed at conquering the whole of Europe, he turned tail from his attempts at taking Britain and headed off to Russia before the D-Day invasion ever took place. The German air campaign was thwarted, the German sea compaign was thwarted, he had ground troops left and a few fireworks to shoot across the channel in demonstration. His armies had shown great dissention im teh ranks, his commanders were second guessing and eventually refusing to follow Hitler's lead, he was beaten, had gone mad due to developing syphillis and was on his way down, before teh D-Day landings. Nobody was really saved from speaking German as is so commonly thought. This doesn't detract from teh efforts of allied soldiers though.
If you really want ot dig into it, don't be too upset when you find out that the US landings on D-Day were a near failure and that other nations were there first and made it farther towards their ojectives, without Canada's glider landings during teh late night and early mornings, German troops woul dhave made it into the beaches and it may not have been anywhere near as effective. John Wayne movies kinda screwed up the reality of the landings themselves. Remember teh first attempt at landing in France was a complete allied massacre, but again that is history that took place long before D-Day (D-Day of course being nearly 5 years AFTER war broke out in Europe).

As for charity, you are correct more money is more money, but that doesn't illustrate Americans generosity towards charity. Proportionately, the PEOPLE in America are NOT as charitable as they think they are. When soemone with less gives up a greater amount of his/her income, that is being more charitable than someone with more offering less.

for example, by your standards, 100 people each donating 1% of their income is superior to 10 people offering 15% of thheir income. Sure your final numer may be higher, but that does not make the people who donated more chaitable.

Per capita stats are a VERY accurate comparison in such cases.

by oz_media

If you feel that my comments are an attack on America then ANY comparison you make between America and ANY other nation for ANY other reason is simply putting down the other nation and claiming America as superior. That is, of course, complete horseshlt.

I actially AGREESD with your comments! You suggested moral behaviour is a result of a society's acceptable behaviour.

I echoed that point by showing how as Canadians started to leave religion behind Canada went through the whole PC thing a decade ago, and now is less focused on toeing the PC line and more focused on just gettign on with things.

America, still having approx 80% of citizens still following religion is tied up with being politically correct and beign a lot mroe stringent on what is acceptable and what isn't.

I didn't say one was better than the other, but that you can see how the level of morally acceptable behaviour has changed in one country as a result of less religion and yet is still quite prominent in another which hhas strong religious values.

teh same can be said between England and Canada. England is now far roe multicultural and has a lower percentage of Chsritian follower than it once did, politically correct in the UK is very different than in Canada too.

That doesn't mean that Canada sucks and I think the UK is better, as your standards define.

Man, talk about wearing your pride on your sleeve! I wasn't attacking the US, it's not anti-US sentiment, there was nothing said to be derogatory to the US at all, you are just too defensive an dream it all up.

by tonythetiger

[i]I'm assuming you suggest a lack of confirmation, not a false confirmation or outright lying.[/i]

[i]I believe there are things I don't know. I don't know how the universe was created. Without knowing a mechanism, I see no reason to search for a hypothetical wielder of it. I KNOW the universe was created by some occurence; it's here. I don't know if it was designed, so looking for a 'who' strikes me as less productive than a 'how'.[/i]

If your goal is "knowing the facts", I would agree. Spirituality has little to do with "facts", in the scientific sense.

by Member 25348569

I accept that you didn't [b]deliberately[/b] set out to imply that that without the inspiration of morality from a divine origin we couldn't be moral. But that's how that question always comes over - that we atheists are immoral, lacking guidance. Godless! I can fake "nice". Just ask anyone round here.

Really, you do need to think a little outside of your comfortable box. How can I say that? If you take the Bible, for example, in the old testament slavery was codified as part of the law (Deuteronomy 15 and some other places that I can't remember). That is one of the many reasons that it took society a couple of thousand years to outlaw the practice of slavery.

Examine all religions' stipulations on the behaviour and deportment of women and measure that against what our moral senses tells is so obviously correct today and ask "Where do you get your values?". Does your religion truly treat women as equals? My Godless morality insists that you should.

Just asking...

by maecuff

Umm..yeah. You're really not GREAT at faking nice.

It just doesn't come off right. You're better being your normal curmudgeonly self. It's so much more attractive.

by dhcdbd

Do you think you can insert an ignore user feature that would prevent a users posts from appearing on another users browser?

by santeewelding

Helped by my baseline appreciation of what you accomplish here, despite your ox-like, blundering manner.

by dhcdbd

the device in his Poetics, where he argued that the resolution of a plot must arise internally, following from previous action of the play:

In the characters too, exactly as in the structure of the incidents, ought always to seek what is either necessary or probable, so that it is either necessary or probable that a person of such-and-such a sort say or do things of the same sort, and it is either necessary or probable that this happen after that one.

by maecuff

I can't help you.

I am a mere member..not a PTB.

I can make a suggestion, though. Don't get your panties twisted up by anything posted here. You'll end up having a stroke or some sort of stress related illness if you get knotted up by this type of social interaction. How do you deal with real life if THIS needs to monitored for you?

by oz_media

That you have no ability to comrpehend something or someone without applying some form of reference to categorize it?

Is individual opinion and thought process that unique amongst your collective?

If someone doesn't agree with and side with you, they are then against you.

If someone doesn't pat you on the back for your every move, they are supporting your demise.

If someone doesn't find your every comment to be accurate and true, they are attacking you.

Man I feel sorry for all the victims that US system has created.

Maybe they should have a fundaraiser for you lot or something, the poor innocent victims who simply want to fight their wars in peace and not be held accountable for ther actions and baseless opinions of others.

by jdclyde

After all, if you can ignore some of the more childish and/or abusive stuff thrown around by some, think how easy it will be back in the meat world where the annoying are at least pretending to be civil while they annoy you. :D

by maecuff

Nah. Not me.

okay. maybe a little. not much though. Not enough that most people would even notice. I'm actually very sweet.

(that made me vomit a little bit)

by dhcdbd

In the meat world my responses are a little more .... uhm, direct. But you are absolutely correct that it is good practice.

Funny thing, had an illegal alien family next door that had been throwing trash in my yard, allowing their children to pee in my yard, attempting to break in until I showed them videos. Warned them twice that problems would ensue if they did not stop. Funny thing, I.C.E. arrested them this morning.

Of course, I.C.E. did not like it when I told them they had to get off my property.

by oz_media

Taken from your own words, is that you have "failed to meet his (my) force and passion."

You have carried on and on with your own baseless flames and when I point out that you openly stated your only intent is to post rubbish and flames afetr each of my posts, you just ramble on about your other problems, admitting by default that I was indeed correct; not that you could argue it anyway, you posted as much on TR in B&W for all to read.

Now, all of a sudden, you are the adult in the room, offering clever advice about just ignoring people's posts if you don't like them. A complete and utter hypocrite to the 'nth degree.

Heed your own words, practice what you preach, beyond that you are just a two-faced liar.

This discussion is closed to new replies.