Discussion Locked

Arguments on Certification

0 helpful
29 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I am a compaq ASE and Novell CNE and this arugment is something which is not new.

From the Blue Chip point of view they need income. However as a CNE I refuse to enter the MCSE arena.

Basically I consider one whom has a a CNE/MCSE does not need to fulfil a parallel cerification as the skills gained within one is repeated. Furthermore I am consider doing an MCP because they are more certiable then MCSE's.

Why?

Because for one, they don't expire. I value a person with many diffenentMCP's higher then an MCSE. In the Novell Arena I am a CNE in Netware 3, and 5 but I do not have any Groupwise. So by doing a CNA in Groupwise 5.5 not only expands my portfollio but it never expires and I update WHEN I WANT and NOT WHEN NOVELL SAYS!

I see the same in MS products. If you are an MCP with say 10 differnt products. Why doesn't that make you a more equitable product then someone with a standard MCSE.

Experence is another product which is higher then certification. I do nothave enough expirence to say I am expirence although I been in the IT industry on and off since 1996 and as a hobbyist since 1990, when I moved away from the BBC Micro Arena.

If you de-certify so what. Microsoft will only change their way when the certification paths are abandoned.

Get all the MCP's, CNA's etc you need and cover the topic you feel are releavant to you. Not what is suitable for Microsoft. That way you study what you want, when you want and a CV with all these differnt modules looks far more appearling then a straigh CNE/MCSE.

Finally remember treat MCP's as modular and combine with expirence will never become out of date.

29 replies

by semcclure98

I think that managers don't understand the certification they have just heard that an employee should have the MCSE.

by shanghai sam

That's probably true in a lot of cases. I doubt a lot of the managers really know the difference between an MCSE that takes 1 test to upgrade or someone who does the full certification and becomes an MCSE with 7 W2K MCPs. Or is there really a difference?

I'm at the opposite end of most of these discussions. A lot of folks say they have the certifications and can't get employed in the IT field without experience. I have years of experience with the same company providing NT end-user/server support and never bothered with the certs. I never needed them.

With the environment at work becoming more volatile, I decided to jump on the Microsoft bandwagon and get the nice little letters behind my name. Where I work, those little letters really do mean something. I believe a lot of the folks doing the hiring at work don't fully understand what all the letters really mean, but you're correct, someone, somewhere decided that the MCP, MCSE certs mean something and it does make a difference in hiring decisions.

As for me, in a few months I'll have a lot of pretty little Microsoft letters behind my name.

Does it mean I know anything more than I do now? - No

Does it make a difference to some of the people making hiring decisions? - In some cases, Yes.

by heartyguffaw

That's probably true in a lot of cases. I doubt a lot of the managers really know the difference between an MCSE that takes 1 test to upgrade or someone who does the full certification and becomes an MCSE with 7 W2K MCPs. Or is there really a difference?

I'm at the opposite end of most of these discussions. A lot of folks say they have the certifications and can't get employed in the IT field without experience. I have years of experience with the same company providing NT end-user/server support and never bothered with the certs. I never needed them.

With the environment at work becoming more volatile, I decided to jump on the Microsoft bandwagon and get the nice little letters behind my name. Where I work, those little letters really do mean something. I believe a lot of the folks doing the hiring at work don't fully understand what all the letters really mean, but you're correct, someone, somewhere decided that the MCP, MCSE certs mean something and it does make a difference in hiring decisions.

As for me, in a few months I'll have a lot of pretty little Microsoft letters behind my name.

Does it mean I know anything more than I do now? - No

Does it make a difference to some of the people making hiring decisions? - In some cases, Yes.

by zlatin zlatev

Well I've found my present job not having any certifications. I have some experiance but it was not enough. What was more important, after making a test and demo project, according to my boss, I have abillity to learn so she hired me.

Now I'm MCP(exam#70-029 Implementing... SQLServer7) and soon will need to upgrade it to #70-229 (Implementing... SqlServer2000)
I'm planning to became an MCDBA and MCSD.

That certifications, according to me, will improve that I have the knowledge and the abillities to work with Databases and to develop applications.

Moreover there are some Microsoft partner programms that will offer a lot of advantages for our firm.

Regards,
Zlatin Zlatev
Software Engineer - JEI Bulgaria,
student (BA in banking) - UE Varna (BG)
3rd. yr/4

by zlatin zlatev

Well I've found my present job not having any certifications. I have some experiance but it was not enough. What was more important, after making a test and demo project, according to my boss, I have abillity to learn so she hired me.

Now I'm MCP(exam#70-029 Implementing... SQLServer7) and soon will need to upgrade it to #70-229 (Implementing... SqlServer2000)
I'm planning to became an MCDBA and MCSD.

That certifications, according to me, will prove that I have the knowledge and the abillities to work with Databases and to develop applications.

Moreover there are some Microsoft partner programms that will offer a lot of advantages for our firm.

Regards,
Zlatin Zlatev
Software Engineer - JEI Bulgaria,
student (BA in banking) - UE Varna (BG)
3rd. yr/4

by urshvd

I agree whole heartedly with you Robert, however, I have a question to ask you and maybe you or anyone else reading this can come up with a suggestion or answer.

I was toatlly taken with becoming an MCSE and with all the hype and promises of a better future once attaining certification, I gave up my career and studied for an MCSE certification. I obtained certification in 1999 and am still looking for someone who will employ me. Don't get me wrong, I am not looking for a high paying job atthe outset and I want an entry level poition, but not one person will employ an MCSE with no experience.
After spending so much money and the time and dedication it took from me to complete my MCSE, is it worth upgrading to win2k given my problem of finding employment?
I would appreciate any feed back from you and anyone else, your comments and or suggestions. Ursula

by robertcohen

It is difficult to say. Basically this is where the coin begins to spin. Is it heads or tails.

If it is a matter of one exam/two exams, then go for it, as you have worked so hard to get where you are.

I am also out of work, but it has mademe think to take a contract even if it is call loggin' to show you are employ-able.

All you need to do is to then is switch jobs when the opportunity comes, unless you are happy.

Another thing is to consider is to ask yourself what line of support you want to work in. Is IT the answer or maybe another profession. The thing is you have IT skills and you can work anywhere not just in IT. To have some-one of your calibra you can manage a team, and make good friends spending all day fixing other people problems, another way via the back door.

by shanghai sam

A certification of any kind doesn't grant anyone a job unless the potential employer wants to take a chance ot them.

I've been in computers for over 14 years and get calls for employment all the time.

I keep track of the job market and put outa feeler resume every once in awhile to see if my resume gets the attention it should.

Three years ago a youd man came to see me for a job. He had just got a degree in computer science with just a little experience working with computers. Duringthe conversation he demonstrated that he knowledgable enough to perform hands on desktop support. We put him to work doing desktop support. The task grew to where he had 7 personnel under him. The organization did not want to take a chance on losing him so they created a government position permanetly for him.

Bottom line, he had a well written resume and was well groomed.

by adisha

Have you thought about a career in teaching/instructing? You could work freelance or even hone your skills to provide specialised software support.

There is a great demand for this at the moment . . .

Let me know what you think

IT GURU

by robertcohen

Sounds great, and yes I have thought about it. But the problem is that I like working on a challenging role. Support and Server Building/Back Office various from day to day.

Training on the other hand is convayor belt work. Don't get me wrong. I could probely get ?50 a hour but the novity will wear off. Again it is not for everyone. Some will love it. If I am going to train in anything I will not bother with modern IT. It better to teach the basics. Again I do not have the paitence. A Trainer is a person whom can deal with dicktwits. I on the otherhand would be telling jokes to everyone.

by pink.e

I can understand your dilemma, I am on the flip slide. I have been in computers since 1977. I have seen alot, have a vast variety of experience in networking, support and troubleshooting networks and desktops. Came from the DOS days, great with Windows and Office Suites, but I do not have any certifications. Oh, I tried about 3-4 classes for MSCE when it was booming, but that was so intense, I couldn't cut it. I applaud everyone who did it. My hat is off to you, that is an accomplishment! It is hard for me to get any higher in the technical field because I don't have what it takes to get the certifications. Yet I have stayed in classes to earn a degree and some certificates but I don't think that is as impressive as MSCE. ObviouslyI am older and yes a woman and that is a bad combination trust me. I always sold myself short just to get in a company, then once in I was able to move up. Good luck to you.

by romulus

I think people place too much value on a certification. I've seen lots of MCSEs panic when the server crashes. There's nothing in a brain dump that can help you then. Experience is always more valuable. The only thing is how do you parlay your experience and personality into a fulfilling position. My best mentors had no certs, just lots of experience with multiple operatings systems. I know CCNAs who haven't been in the same room with a router, much less configured one. My main argument against certification for certification's sake is that I don't want to be married to a vendor or a platform. The key to "job security" is a varied skill set, not some dumb certification that's going to expire anyway.

by larry23

One clarification...
MCP's do expire. Once a test is retired you have 1 year to upgrade your certification.

by robertcohen

Thanks, that One thing I did not know. I was informed that an MCP is a static certitication like a CNA or driving licence.

by pallan

Novell retired the IntranetWare CNA last year, and NetWare 3 some time before that (along with the respective CNEs).

by robertcohen

I still have my CNA in Netware 3 from 1995.
I just checked my demographics and it is still confirmed valid.

by pallan

Novell announced the retirement of CNA/CNE 4 last summer and was quite thorough in mailing upgrade notifications. They even found me after two moves.

It's nice of Novell to track your cert history like that, but it *is* retired.

by colorse

Should one give-up??

Let us look at the government as an example, After mandating vital security measures be tested and implemented for its own computer and network systems, We see on the news how little or nothing has been done by its own agencies now under hacker attack from around the world. If the government had said from the beginning if you don't comply by a deadline, you will give up your job title and once forfeited have to re-certify, they would have had a much higher percentage of completion.
To some there is never enough time and always another upgrade or patch around the bend to deal with, While others like already Win2K MCSE Certified, ask were the next challenge lies. (8 months before the deadline).
This brings me to my next thought, MCP certification levels and alternate job paths. MCP?s were designed to help create jobs and fill trained support rolls for the MCSE.
MCP?s provide an opportunity for more clear and productive objectives for today?s MCSE.

Is Microsoft over burdening the consumer in there cutting edge quest to control the future of the OS marketplace, applications and the Internet, or is it just trying to regain the glory days of Win95, it?s only true victory to date, by offering improvements as the become available?
All the new technology and services we are being forced to learn and implement, is to ?keep information safe?, protect copywrite web content, increase speed, and improve multimedia, while conducting real time business aroundworld under controllable circumstances.
So is it MCSE or MCP?s and wait?
Well of course you be the judge.
Thanks, John?

by jlipton

Robert-
I wonder if the MCP's & MCSE's are a Microsoft marketing tool... I know that at IBM, training is mandatory. I go on an average of 5 (or so) classes a year, paid by IBM to learn and certify in their products, then pass the knowlege to my Clients. I doubt any of the certifications would be of any benefit outside an IMB shop (except for Tivoli). Problem is, trying to get *into* IBM in the first place, without doing "contract" work, is next to impossible. Once you're in, you never leave. (shades of Hotel California, huh?)

by robertcohen

Mr Lipton

Thanks for you very valuable comments. I personally would love to work for the BIG BLUE. I wonder if you company would be intrested in approching me.

I tried once to get a job at IBM in 1993 at both Basingstoke and Southampton as part of employement year within my degree with no sucess. If some-one whom the BIG BLUE called me tommorrow either in the US or UK and put the ball in my call, I will jump with joy!

by semcclure98

When I was at ITT some of my best teachers told jokes and war stories all day.

What about teaching onsite as a consultant ?

by robertcohen

Sounds Ideal, do you know anyone whom is after a teacher with a good sence of humor?

I am in London, but could work anywhere, especially the US!

by adisha

I always remember this quote when delivering any IT Instruction to students:

"I hear, and I forget. I see, and I remember. I do, and I understand."
-old Chinese proverb

Teaching is very reqarding as long as you make your students actively involved in your lessons - doing things.

by eric

I think your right Mr. Cohen, In your 2nd to the last statement, I'll heed your advice.

by dkohut

I have a MCSE and MCDBA. I got my MCP a couple of years ago. At that time a MCP meant something. Even when I got my MCSE it was worth more. I think all of the boot camps have brought the meaning of the cert down. I have been in a hiring role. I must admit I was much more interested in those who went for the MCP and waited for a company to pick up the bill for the rest. Typically these people researched and studied for the test on their own. Not to mention were a little more finicially savey. If I found someone who didn't know about braindumps...I was even more impressed. I really don't like the idea of the all inclusive MCSE packages. I don't have any plans of keeping the MCSE status.

by chrislau

I have been doing Routing and Switching for three years and now I am planning to get my CCNA this year. What do you think about Cisco Certification? My boss has been talking to me for many times that, 'if you are good, then, you just no need to be certified'.

by robertcohen

I don't know. You boss is right, but again it can be for one self satisfaction.

As it happen's to day I was in the bookshop looking a CCNA guides and found diffucuty choosing a really good book to learn from. I want CISCO to grow on me so I want to take an exam and course which is not so mind blowin' making me wanting to come back for more! Although I am an IT PRO, I always like my books in layman terms because the OSI layer for example differs from manufacture to manufacture. Also it give me a chance to polish up without all the gibberish that one comes across.

GO for the exam, if your boss leaves tommorrow and you are handed your P45 (UK), Pink Slip (US), can you get back in to the same line of work. Grab the Cert as Insurance. As for me I am stuck on what to do in order to start a CCNA.

Finally CISCO is not like Microsoft, it is Hardware orientated so you will not need to sit exams every so offen as far as I can gather, does every-one agree. Love to hear from those whom have completed both the CISCO 1.0 and CISCO 2.0 Certification paths.

Rob

by shanghai sam

Hi Robert, I took the CCNA 2.0 and the CCNP exams and found them very tough but not insurmountable. You are right about recertification, every three years with CCNA and CCNP and every 2 years on CCIE. I am not a spring chicken myself (49) so certifications are a way to insure I keep up on the growing technology so I can be competitive with the young guns. I have 10 years experience in the networking career field and my computer experience dates back to 1974. There are too many young people out there who think that getting certifications will get them that great job and make them lots of money. That's not always true. I had six years working with Cisco routers and switches before I took the CCNA and CCNP exams. Does that mean that mycertification means more because I have the experience to back it up. It should!! Passing the CCNA exam with a score of 1000 or even 950 does not make you a guru unless you can back it up with experience. I know a guy in the Air Force who took the CCNA 1.0 exam and passed with a 961, never laid hands on a router. Would you rather hire a smart test taker with little experience or a person who passed the test (CCNA 2.0 with a 914 with six years of hands on router knowledge in a real world environment. Robert, the best book, in my opinion, is the Cybex, Todd Lammle CCNA Exam Guide. I failed the CCNA 2.0 the first time because of a question that was not in the Cisco Press book. I don't think the answer to certify or not to certify willbe found on this discussion board or any discussion board simply because there is nothing written that dictates that requirement. Employers are simply looking for people who can keep their respective company operating and not losing money, cert or no cert. Smaller companies with less capital may not be able to afford the professional with certifications, so they don't require them. Larger companies can afford to be picky.

by tburt1530

As an IT instructor, with more than 7 years of contract/consulting work, and no certifications...I have to say that if you are spending the money on getting your MCSE in any other way than self study, you are throwing your money away. There are manyother things in the IT field that have a much greater return on a similar, or dramatically lower, investment in time and money. Not saying it's not a good certification to have, but I have paid MCSE's $12.00/hr. to subcontract for me, and that is the most they had been paid/hour to date, due top little hands on experience

This discussion is closed to new replies.