[b][i]you didn't see federal regulators and prosecutors in banks ordering branch managers to approve loans.[/i]
... you haven't been paying attention to the news.
Under the Clinton administration, federal regulators began using the act to combat ?red-lining,? a practice by which banks loaned money to some communities but not to others, based on economic status. ?No loan is exempt, no bank is immune,? warned then-Attorney General Janet Reno. ?For those who thumb their nose at us, I promise vigorous enforcement.?
The Clinton-Reno threat of ?vigorous enforcement? pushed banks to make the now infamous loans that many blame for the current meltdown, Richman said. ?Banks, in order to not get in trouble with the regulators, had to make loans to people who shouldn?t have been getting mortgage loans.? "
http://www.cnsnews.com/public/Content/Article.aspx?rsrcid=36048
[/b]
ROFLMAO. Dude. Get real. You think their enforcement of pushing banks to lend money to places like families in Compton and other minority neighborhoods over a decade ago caused what the banks did in the past 5 years?
It was the disestablishment of parts of the process and responsible departments by the current presidential administration that allowed banks not only to free-wheel, but to lend money to the nth degree of the edge of what was legal under the regulations.
And in some cases, mortgage lenders even broke the law in falsifying the amount of income put on applications to get them approved. Are you going to blame the government for that too?
[b][i]hmm...everyone gets it...but, only the really poor get absolution from the responsibility.[/i]
Anybody can choose to not spend above poverty level, and thus avoid the "responsibility". Of course, if you do that, your money is going to be in a bank for others to use, so it will help the economy anyway.[/b]
Really?
I dare you to only spend the apportioned amount of your income for that which is poverty level for one year then. I want to see if you can make your house payment, car payment, whatever you have.
It's not a choice. You made the obligation. Prove it to me now that it's your choice whether to spend only poverty level available funds.
Anyone can do it. Right?
[b][i]If you made all tax sales based, there would be a LOT more tax forms. Think about it...
"Please summarize amounts expended for purchases into these categories..."[/i]
What? There would be no such thing!!! When you buy a new item costing $1.00, you will be charged $1.30 at the register. End of story. The only information the government needs is the makeup of your household, in order to prebate the tax on poverty-level spending.[/b]
Maybe in your dreamland it'd work that way. But, let's see. What does your sales tax at a PERCENTAGE do?
Whenever cost of product goes up, so does the expenditure of sales tax by the consumer, thusly putting your American constituent's livelihood at: the mercy of the free market, capitalistic economy.
So when that box of Toasty-Os generic cereal in the cash saver supermarket goes up 20%...the cost of your poor person's cereal goes up 26%.
I guess feeding your family is something that should be based on a corp's need for more cash...rather than what they spend being planned year to year based on pay?
Way to go. You must be a Bush supporter. He just got done doing 3 years of letting the oil companies screw us.
[b][i]whatever agency they create to handle the mass changes to sales tax)[/i]
They will use the same agency, with the same number of employees, that they use now. The only difference is they will be collecting three dimes instead of four (or five or six or whatever) pennies. Do you really think it takes more people to count to 30 than it does to count to 4?[/b]
I know that if you reformed income tax as I have suggested, versus creating a whole new barrage of fights for an added sales tax...you will create a new bureaucracy totally to manage that, while still having to maintain the IRS (or what's left of it) that will handle income taxes through the end of their cycle.
Plus, the IRS would probably take control of the income tax stuff...since...they aren't the Income Tax Collector Service, but the Internal Revenue Service...meaning they'd account for all taxes.
I still say it'd take more processors and auditors to do your sales tax and the reform that would come with it, rather than simplifying income tax code as I have presented.
Maybe I'll find a think tank that will go about comparing needs, etc., required by such changes on both our parts. They might find it interesting enough to do as a project of interest rather than pay-to-research service.
[b][i]Oh btw...exempting people from the first $x,xxx of purchases...doesn't ensure they get "necessities".[/i]
If they don't, they'll soon be dead... unless, of course, you mistrust the government to come to the right value for xx,xxx.[/b]
To be honest, the government can't. Even their estimations of cost-of-living are off. My father working in NJ proved that, as he had to live in squallor conditions because rent on a slum apartment with a public bathroom/showers was almost $1000 a month over 15 years ago.
So no, I don't trust them.
[b][i]As for providing for the needy...
I thought it was their job to get themselves out of the hole?
Work harder, starving single mother of 3 with 2 jobs!!![/i]
I would rather reduce the need than increase support. More money in your pocket equals more buying stuff, which means more people hired to make stuff which means fewer people in need.[/b]
BWAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!
More money in my pocket = more expense under your sales tax.
And, you're essentially just shifting the entry point of where it goes in the government.
[b][i]"even tho the current President of the company does a half decent job, we're gonna hand it off to 50 VPs who we have no idea how well they'll do."[/i]
They did it just fine until 1913! And it's actually state legislatures... Who, by the way, are constitutionally required to balance their state budgets :)[/b]
Actually, not all states are.
[i][u]What is meant by a balanced budget is not as certain as it may seem intuitively. Even the number of states that must balance their budgets can be disputed, depending on the way the requirement is defined. Although the National Conference of State Legislatures (NCSL) traditionally says that 49 states must balance their budgets, it would be more precise to say that 49 states have at least a limited statutory or constitutional requirement of a balanced budget.[/u][/i]
-National Conference of State Legislatures
http://www.ncsl.org/programs/fiscal/balbuda.htm
[b][i]Plus...you just increased bureaucracy...all states have to create their own departments to do what the Feds do now with project funding decisions.[/i]
Uh... the states already have these departments... to decide what to do with all that "federal money" they're getting! All I'm doing is cutting out some of the middlemen![/b]
Er...yeah...and states will STILL have an income tax...cause...guess what!!!
THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT CAN NOT STOP A STATE FROM COLLECTING INCOME TAXES AT THE STATE LEVEL.
You think all states are gonna stop taking income tax because the federal government takes more sales tax.
You are really reaching. States will be greedy til they can't be. Always have been, always will.
Hence, you're gonna grow the bureaucracy and expenditures at the state level, and essentially increase state taxes on everyone.
Nice job, Mr. President.
[b][i]Plus, you just pointed out why your plan will never be put in place.
The federal government can not mandate that a state establish law or agency within their jurisdiction of law and function. States' Rights.[/i]
That's not why... The real reason is that it will take the control away from the lobbyists and politicians and put it directly in the hands of the people, who will be able to really vote... with their wallets![/b]
You think lobbyists don't exist at the state level?
Go to Austin TX and watch the oil lobbyists that are in there every day.
They're also in the state capital in Oklahoma City too. I know. 3 Governors have been personal friends of my parents, and I've been friends with 1 of them myself.
Really. Just because you like a tax doesn't mean it's the best for the system, or it would get implemented how you want.
Have a good weekend. I'm going to get drunk now. Happy New year.